Free Essay

Billy Elliot

In:

Submitted By aantsss
Words 1480
Pages 6
“Understanding nourishes belonging ...a lack of understanding prevents it. “
Demonstrate how your prescribed text and ONE other related text of your own choosing represent this interpretation of belonging.
Belonging is a multi-facetated concept that encompasses both beneficial and detrimental aspects, as it can either provide feelings of sense of security and companionship, or have the exact opposite effect and produce feelings of animosity, disaffection and estrangement. The texts ‘The Joy Luck club’ and ‘Devil wears Prada’ are both exemplary texts in depicting the interpretation of understanding and a lack of understanding which acts as a catalyst to belong. ‘The Joy Luck Club’ tells the story of four Chinese immigrants and their Americanised daughters who tell the stories of their mothers through four parables. ‘The Devil Wears Prada’ tells the story of a young woman, Andy, who in her newly gained job as a co-assistant in the chaotic unfamiliar world of high-end fashion, portrays the concept that understanding can nourish belonging or a lack of understanding can hinder belonging, thus portraying an absence of belonging.
Belonging to a culture brings stability at a place. This aspect is widely expressed through the text ‘The Joy Luck Club’ with Jing-Mei as the focus. After the death of her mother, Jing-Mei is forced to carry on the role as the ‘fourth corner’ in the parable ‘Joy Luck Club.’ Through her barriers of lack of understanding and knowledge of her Chinese culture, it is evident from the outset that she doesn’t belong to the Joy Luck Club, and thus feeling a sense of isolation and displacement. This is evident through the quote, “Nobody says to me ‘come sit here, this is where your mother used to sit’” (pg 32). Throughout the chapter, Jing-Mei suffers silently as she receives criticisms for dropping out of school. The mood in this chapter is quite nostalgic, due to the use of flashbacks. As Jing-Mei has flashbacks of her mother’s reason for establishing the Joy Luck Club, the tone was bright and full of hope and dreams that Suyan Woo had for her daughter. The chapter is constructed with a number of different flashbacks. This allows Tan to show how the past impinges with the present and how ones heritage flows through one-self’s life. However, Jing-Mei feels more connected to her mother by establishing more connection to her Chinese culture through broadening an understanding and adapting traditions by conforming. She gains determination by fulfilling her mother’s wish, which was meeting her long lost sisters in China that her mother left behind when she migrated to America. This concept is also evident when Jing-Mei begins to realise the best qualities of herself, her mother and her culture when she is given the Jade pendant. Her self-worth is enhanced, and thus feels more stable and synchronised in the Joy Luck club. This is evident through the quote, “And, I think my mother was right, I am becoming Chinese” (pg 267). Through a connection to her culture, it creates a distinctive bond with her and the Joy Luck club, thus feeling a song sense of connection to a place by nourishing an understanding on the culture. Even though Jing-Mei suffered a loss of her mother, she still gained two siblings and realise the importance of her mother’s teachings, and thus, connect to the Joy Luck club by developing feelings of satisfaction and contentment.
Belonging can be derived from belonging to a culture by feeling stability at a place, which is demonstrated in the text ‘The Devil Wears Prada.’ At the beginning of the text, the protagonist Andy, is introduced to the upper-end fashion couture, a chaotic and stressful workplace environment and the cynical and demanding magazine editor, Miranda Priestly. Through these barriers, it is evident from the outset she doesn’t belong through her lack of knowledge on the fashion elite. Multiple sequences are used to clearly illustrate the stressful and chaotic world that Andy is introduced to. It also exemplifies the idea that she clearly isn’t comfortable with the transition in the metamorphosis of the fashion world. The juxtaposition of Andy’s appearance to the appearance of the fashion environment also assists and shapes the audiences understanding that she clearly doesn’t belong, which further symbolises the barriers of belonging. This is further evident in the quote, “You’re right, I don’t fit in here, I’m not skinny or glamorous, and I don’t know a lot about fashion.” Through this, it is evident that she feels displaced and a sense of disarray. However, Andy conforms to the workplace by altering her appearance and broadening her knowledge on the fashion industry and influential icons. This is evident when Andy is complimented by her co-assistant – “you look chic.” This brings about feelings of achievement, and officially symbolises the successful transition into the fashion elite ‘world’ by belonging to all aspects of the workplace.
Belonging is also derived from comfortability within oneself. This concept is effectively demonstrated in the ‘Joy Luck Club’ and the character of Lindo Jong as she expresses the most anxiety over her cultural identity. She has always believed in her ability to shift between her two faces – one was used to comply with the traditions and culture, and the other was used to represent her true self. Both faces were exchangeable, but not compatible. Lindo’s inability to reconcile her Chinese heritage with her American surroundings acts as a barrier for Lindo’s true identity to be established, which is expressed through the parable ‘The Red Candle.’ From a young age, Lindo was arranged to marry a man she didn’t know. The Red Candle symbolises Chinese culture and traditions. If it blew out, the marriage wouldn’t end happily. This is demonstrated through the quote, “it meant that I couldn’t divorce, or even re-marry, even if Tyan-yu died” (pg 59). Lindo was able to extricate herself from an unhappy marriage, and the tyranny and oppression of her mother-in-law without dishonouring the promise to her family, thus increasing her self-esteem. Tan’s use of first person allows the audience to experience the challenges and experiences of Lindo. Further, it allows the audience to connect to the persona on a personal level, and can understand Lindo’s feelings of confusion and isolation. A cyclical structure is used, representing the mothers and daughters stories and how they diverge in their paths, but all come back to a single point of unconditional love and understanding. Moreover, it suggests that the stories occurred in the past, will recur in future generations. Lindo’s ability to shift between two faces is expressed through the quotes, “I smile, I use my American face.” (pg 255) and “I smile. Only this time I use my Chinese face” (pg 256). After developing a greater connection to her daughter, Waverly, Lindo realises that her ability to shift between her true self and her public self, may not always be used and wonders if her public self is not, infact, her true self. Lindo gains a greater understanding of herself through the greater knowledge of herself and her capabilities, thus feeling a sense of security.
‘The Devil Wears Prada’ is also an effective text in effectively portraying the concept of comfortability with oneself. After Andy is confronted with the reality that she is becoming more like her cynical boss Miranda, she realises that she doesn’t want to belong to her unorthodox and shallow nature due to its emotionless concept. Andy also realises that her world, with the inclusion of her friends and devoted partner Nate, conflicts with the nature of her workplace, and cannot be compatible. This is due to the fact that she has sacrificed her friends to belong in the workplace. This is evident when Nate tells Andy, “I liked the old you.” Andy feels derived from her true-self and isolated from her loved ones. After Miranda tells Andy “I see a great deal of myself in you,” Andy replies “what if I don’t want to live the way you live.” This exemplification brings about Andy’s self-realisation and her greater understanding of her capabilities and herself. The use of wide shots and long shots symbolise the ‘bigger picture’ of Andy walking away from Miranda’s world. It also symbolises the fact that Andy’s understanding has acted as a catalyst for her withdrawal from Miranda’s world, and thus, being able to nourish belonging. Additionally, joyful music is used to enhance this concept further, generating a content mood in the final scenes of the film. Andy therefore generates feelings of satisfaction and contentment with being her ‘true self.’
In conclusion, it cannot be doubted that both texts are exemplary in portraying an absence of connection through a lack of understanding, and understanding that nourishes belonging. It is through cinematic techniques, that this aspect can be effectively depicted to the responders.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Billy Elliot

...moving into the world. However, with self-determination and the support of others it can potentially lead to a positive outcome. Stephan Daldrys film Billy Elliot (2000) explores these notions and highlights the importance of rising above circumstances and embracing the support of others by enduring such experiences in order to succeed in the transition of moving into the world. The film reveals how individual determination and strength is often required to transition from one world to another, also exploring the idea of how transitioning into another world can be daunting and unexpected for the individual whom is making the change and that everyone's world is different and needs to be accepted. Firstly the film explores the notion of how individual determination and strength is often required to transition from one world to another, this idea is reflected throughout the 'private lessons and rising tensions' scene. In this particular scene billy and his ballet teacher Mrs Wilkinson are both equally committed, consistent and also remain perseverant regardless of the circumstances in which they find themselves. We see that Billy embraces the support of others and in turn, is on the road to potential success. As billy enters the hall, a high angle shot of him is used representing his powerless emotion. The shot reveals vulnerable billy, as he has not yet embraced the support he has been given. Also soft, mysterious music begins to play in the background, as the lights dim. This signifies...

Words: 1288 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Billy Elliot

...movie. Stereotypes play a significant role in this movie as they represent the main obstacles that keep Billy from achieving his dreams. Billy has to overcome the fact that his family, and even Billy himself at the beginning of the film believes that only “puffs” or homosexual men would want to do Ballet. Similarly, he has to fight the stereotype that “real” men play football, or box, or wrestle. In what way do the male characters in the film influence Billy or function as a role model? Male characters play an important role in Billy’s life as they both help him and keep him from accomplishing his dreams. Billy’s dad for instance, at the beginning of the film is a distant father who is set against Billy learning how to dance. However by the end of the film this changes as his dad begins to fulfill his duty as father and raises enough money for Billy to audition for the royal ballet. Meanwhile Tony influences Billy by showing him the dangers of following in his family’s footsteps by going to work in the mines, and by pushing him to dance as a means of self expression when they get in to conflict. Comment on many critics’ description of Billy Elliot as a “feel-good movie” To label Billy Elliot as “feel-good” movie is to ignore the political, social, cultural and historical context of the film, thereby missing a significant portion of the film. Billy Elliot is a British film as the accents, the scenery, and the dialogue all attest to, and is therefore influenced...

Words: 400 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Billy Elliot

...(Introduction you must introduce Billy Elliot (2002) directed by Stephen Daldry) Paragraph One: The context of Billy’s World * Depicts the obstacles of transgressing cultural and economic boundaries * Set against Britain’s bitter 1984 coal miner’s strike – frames of posters encouraging workers to keep to the strike are juxtaposed with lines of police officers holding up shields * Explores the effects of economic struggle on the community and individual * The recurring image of an armed police presence represents the social conformity that blocks Billy’s transition * Family’s economic struggle due to the strike – emotional scene of Jackie cutting up his wife’s piano for firewood at Christmas * Juxtaposition of Billy’s impoverished working class neighbourhood of crammed red brick townhouses with Debbie’s more affluent suburb with well-trimmed gardens and open spaces – the steep, cobblestoned backstreets reflect the confined uniformity of Billy’s existence * Billy’s aspiration of becoming a ballet dancer is contextualised within an environment of limited opportunities – the mis-en-scene of billy preparing breakfast shows a cramped kitchen with clothes hung on a makeshift clothesline. Yet Billy glides around to “Cosmic Dancer”, oblivious to the mess and disorder * Yorkshire slang and working class dialect is used in the film to add credibility to the story * Slow motion images of jostling torsos and beating shields during the miner’s confrontations with...

Words: 689 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Billy Elliot

...Billy Elliot Analysis template |Description of scene: Opening scene: Mood, direction of plot and characterisation is established. | |Scene numbers: One, two, three | |Link to Into the World focus: Billy’s natural world is established | |Action |Film techniques used |Meaning conveyed | |Billy puts record onto record player. He |Extreme close up. There is no sound. |There is a sense of anticipation. The | |begins playing the song. |Costume: Billy is dressed simply, |audience is waiting for something to happen| |( to 1 min; 14 secs) |predominately in a bright yellow singlet. |and wondering what it will be. | | |The singlet symbolises both childhood | | | |(children wear singlets) and his working | | | |class background (‘working class’ men | | | |stereotypically wear singlets). It is also | ...

Words: 735 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Billy Elliot - Film Review

...Billy Elliot - Film Review Running time: 111 minutes Starring: Jamie Bell, Julie Walters, Gary Lewis, Jamie Draven, Stuart Wells, Jean Hollywood ✶✶✶✶✶✶✶✶ Rating 8 out of 10 Billy Elliot is a coming-of-age drama about a young son of a poor coal miner, who dreams of being a ballet dancer. Billy Elliot (Jamie Bell), main character, is an shy 11-year old boy who is living with his proud miner father (Gary Lewis) and older brother Tony (Jamie Draven) during the political and social unrest of the 1984 miner’s strike in Durham, North East England. It’s a hard time, - the men of the house is spending their days on the picket lines clashing with the police, while Billy is exploring new sides of himself and taking care of his increasingly senile grandmother (Jean Heywood). Though his dad, and brother nagging him into taking boxing classes, he manages to fall in love with the art of dancing. While his fancy footwork can’t being pointed fingers at, he simply can’t take a punch. One day at the gym, Billy notices a ballet class, which it taught by hard-bitten Mrs. Wilkinson (Julie Walters), and ends up joining the class after being dared by Mrs. Wilkinson’ young daughter. When Billy’s father learns about his son has being forsaken boxing gloves for ballet shoes, he is distraught, and bans him from taking classes. Despite his father banning him from taking classes, he can’t put his passion on hold. After accepting his son’ passion for dancing, he sets about raising money to send his...

Words: 482 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Billy Elliot

...relationship in the visual text Billy Elliot, is that between Billy and his father Jackie. Their relationship is a complete exemplification to the idea of gender role stereotypes. With Jackie being a typical hard man who sees no prospect outside of the mining industry, and Billy, who possesses a great deal of talent toward the deeply taboo art of ballet, the conflict of gender role expectations is amplified. Because of Jackie and Billy's relationship, the viewer can therefore understand the fact that Billy faces a major challenge, as far as gender roles are concerned, if he chooses to pursue a life of Ballet. Jackie gives powerful illustration to the stereotypical psyche of male roles in society. His identity as a miner of North England during the miners' strike and ex-champion boxer already reverberates the fact that he holds very traditionalistic male values. He literally cannot perceive life outside of the mining industry "Why would I want to go to London? There are no mines in London" In effect, when Jackie sees his son Billy in dancing school behind his back for the first time, there is major repercussion, "You, out, now!" He then drags Billy back home and informs him that "Lads do football... or boxing... or wrestling, Not friggin' ballet", expressing his views of gender role. Billy then questions him "I don't see what's wrong with it", to which Jackie replies "You know quite nicely what's wrong with it" Jackie expects his son Billy to realize the fact that ballet...

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Billy Elliot

...of the film Billy Elliot (2000). After a brief discussion of the portrayal of the male ballet dancer in the dancing scene since the 1990s and the inherent voyeuristic inclinations of contemporary audiences, the analysis will focus on five aspects of male presence in Billy Elliot the Musical (2005). The dynamics of working-class masculinity will be contextualised within the framework of the family, the older female, the community, the self and the act of dancing itself. These aspects will be referenced using reviews of the musical version of the work and articles written on the film of Billy Elliot. However, have today‟s audiences conditioned their gendered gaze to allow for the male ballet dancer to dominate the contemporary stage? Or do we still control our social perceptions and cultural associations with out-of-date images of the past? Have popular perceptions about the male ballet dancer changed? Is there a birth of a new male dancer phenomenon? However, have today‟s audiences conditioned their gendered gaze to allow for the male ballet dancer to dominate the contemporary stage? Or do we still control our social perceptions and cultural associations with out-of-date images of the past? Have popular perceptions about the male ballet dancer changed? Is there a birth of a new male dancer phenomenon?Even if nineteenth-century ballet became „so concerned with the display of female bodies that male characters became almost an impossibility. The film Billy elliot changing the...

Words: 745 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Period of Unrest

...Ronnie Palachuk In the movie Billy Elliot, directed by Stephen Daldry, choosing what direction to go in life is never easy, the struggles you face and sacrifices being made you can overcome and succeed over everything else. With the miners’ strike and Billy switching from what his father wants and what he wants, creates turmoil not only for himself but his family as well…in the end creates a world that gives him clarity and definition. The plot focuses on Billy, the younger son of a mining family in which the mother has recently died, and Billy’s macho father and older activist brother take part in the miners struggle. Billy does not identify with the masculine world-view of his father and brother, and instead of boxing he secretly joins the ballet class. The notion of belonging to a group that shares the same values is repeated throughout the film, which portrayed class, gender and sexual orientation issues. Billy’s gender role shift journey starts as he is first exposed of a ballet class while he participated in boxing class at the gym. A new world opens up for Billy, it marks a world of self-identity. When Bill’s father find out that he’s dancing and not boxing, his father makes it clear he’s not happy and wants Billy to quit ballet dancing. But Billy defied his father and started taking private lessons with Miss Wilkinson. Billy’s gender issues are being questioned but over comes the odds and the stereotype of what society thinks. Billy finds Michael dressing in woman’s...

Words: 943 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Billey Eliot

...Dear Bob. Long time no see! Thank you so much for the letter, I was really happy when I received it! A lot of things have happened since you moved out of Durham. You know my father was all into boxing and he hoped that I will become at great boxer one day! But I didn’t want to box and I really didn’t have any talent for it! I had my thoughts in a completely different place. I loved music and of course I had that from my mother’s side! A little part of the boxing gym was used by a ballet class, and here I had my chance to learn ballet. So I was learning ballet secretly without my father knowing it! But pretty soon he found out! He wasn’t happy, but what could I do? This was my passion. My father was striking, and all the other miners were doing the same. They didn’t want to work anymore down in the black, and cold mines, they wanted more pay for the hard work they did! My brother Tony was doing some bad things when he saw my father sitting in the bus with the other striking miners! And I actually missed a very important audition for the Royal Ballet School because of Tony’s act! So my ballet teacher took all the way home to my house just to tell my father about the bad influence he got on me and my ballet, and she persuaded my father to go to the next audition in the Royal apartments. Two months later I got a letter back from them, where they told me that they wanted me on the Royal Ballet School. So I moved to London when I was only 11 years old! Fourteen years later...

Words: 482 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Interview

...Biosafety, Compliance and You! A seminar by David Cavallaro, Institutional Biosafety Officer at UConn Friday, September 13, 2013 12:20pm – 1pm Storrs Campus, George White 209 Rainbow Cinema: F**k the Disabled Saturday, September 14, 2013, 2pm - 4pm Rainbow Center @ UConn, Student Union 403 Admission Fee: Free and open to all Female Orgasm Dorian Solot and Marshall Miller are renowned sex educators who have put together a hilarious, yet incredibly informative, sex education seminar. Thursday, September 17, 2013 7pm – 8pm Student Union Theater Admission Fee: Free Fall 2013 AACC Annual Welcome Back Soul Food Dinner Friday, September 20, 2013, 7pm - 10pm Student Union , Ballroom Admission: Free Rainbow Cinema: Billy Elliot Saturday, September 21, 2013, 2pm - 4pm Rainbow Center @ UConn, Student Union 403 Admission Fee: Free and open to all Chorus Concert...

Words: 356 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Billy Elliot

...Introduction A. In general, the food related products will include: Beef, Chicken, Turkey, Potatoes, Fish, Processed Foods, Stoves, Vegetables, various machinery, and cash registers, order monitors, ovens, wireless systems for ordering services. Products will be explained in more detail further on. B. What will the product or service be called? The named Baked Hut shows our customers the kind of products we export because, usually fast food eaters are accustomed to oiled foods, so as an alternative for oil, most products will indeed be baked to lessen the amount of calories. It will also affect how we advertise it because it is a short, catchy, and non-difficult name that no one will have problems pronouncing or reading. Baked Hut will export food related products that will differ from a typical fast food restaurant in various ways. In current typical North American fast food markets, restaurants such as McDonald’s, Burger King, and KFC provide customers with food containing high amounts of calories, saturated and trans fats, sodium salt and processed sweeteners that increase your risk for chronic diseases. Baked Hut will alter this issue by providing the same idea of fast food, but instead encountering the health risks associated with regular fast food and providing customers with healthier food. The idea is for customers to gain the same pleasure of eating “fast food”, but without being conscious of how it is affecting their health. Generally, we’re looking at North American...

Words: 6060 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Billy Elliot - Film Review

...Film review of 'Billy Elliot' Short summary: In the film ‘Billy Elliot’, 11 year old boy Billy is bought up into an economically repressed mining town. In a small cramped house, in northern England, he lives with his father, his brother and his grandmother. Like most men in the town his father and brother works in the local mine. But due to cutbacks from the government they are on a strike. Billy goes to boxing in his spare time, to make his father proud. But he soon discovers his interest in dancing, and not just any dancing, but ballet. For a long time he hides this from his father, and when he is at ballet dancing he tells his pap that he is at boxing practice. But after a while his father discovers Billy's secret and is furious. His father doesn't want his son to dance, "cause boys don't dance, they wrestle!". But as time progresses his father comes to terms with Billy's wish to become a ballet dancer. And it turns out that Billy is also very good at it, and is recommended to go to the Royal Ballet School in London. But his family can't afford to send him to the school. Ultimately his father breaks the picket line, to get money for Billy. But Billy's older brother sees their father break the line, and runs over to stop him. They decide that they have to make the money in a different way. Again time passes and they get the money. After a hard tryout in a school where Billy feels like a total mismatch, he is accepted and gets to live his dream. Setting and Characterization: ...

Words: 626 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Billy Elliot Research Paper

...talk with us, we always did something special. One night when I was five, we went to go see The Lion King on the West End. Despite not remembering the show, I do remember being amazed by the vibrant colors, roaring music, and jaw-dropping costumes. The moment it was over, I wanted nothing more than to watch it on repeat for the rest of my life. Going to the West End became a memorable tradition for me and my mother. We went to both Mary Poppins and The Sound of Music in the year that followed. The first show I remember was Billy Elliot, which...

Words: 1851 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Going Home

...couple of names: Billy Woodward and William Jacob Woodward. Those two names symbolize the two sides he has as a ‘white’ aboriginal. When he is the ‘son of his parents’ and when he talks to other aboriginals, he’s called Billy. When he’s among white people, being a regular teenager in Britain, he goes by the name William Jacob. At 18 years of age, he gets picked up by a big football team and moves away from home. Besides football, he also likes painting pictures and is very good at it. He tries to live like a white man, even though he is black, repressing his past. From time to time he stumbles into some aboriginal family of his, and is being very ashamed of them. He thinks that they are all drunken and disgusting individuals. Even though he looks at his people with revulsion, he wants to go home and visit his family for his twenty-first birthday. He expects them to celebrate him, though he hasn’t been home for three years. He didn’t even come home when his father died in an accident. Billys’ family lives far away from the city in an old aboriginal-camp. When the day arrives, he drives out to the old camp in his new fancy car. He had sold some pictures to afford this car. He picks up Darcy, an aboriginal-man, on the way out there, whom he spent the rest of the trip with. When finally he arrives at his family’s’ camp, not all of them are happy to see him. Carlton and Rennie, his brother and cousin, greet him very politely and are happy to see him. Rennie gives Billy a nice gold watch...

Words: 939 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

My Life

...Major Works Data Sheet Page 3 Characters Name Role in the story Significance Adjectives Billy Pilgrim Bernard V. O’Hare Mary O’Hare Gerhard Muller Kurt Vonnegut Edgar Derby Billy’s Mother Valencia Pilgrim Barbara Pilgrim Robert Pilgrim Montana Wildhack Roland Weary Tralfamadorians Hobo Paul Lazzaro Englishmen Kilgore Trout Wild Bob Elliot Rosewater Howard W. Campbell, Jr. Werner Gluck Bertram Rumford Lily Rumford Billy’s Father Main Character Protagonist Friend of Vonnegut’s from the War. Wife of Bernard Taxi Driver for Vonnegut and O’Hare Author and takes part in WWII scenes. A middle aged school teacher in WWII Billy Visits her in Nursing Home Billy’s wife Billy’s Daughter, newly-wed Billy’s Son, Green Beret Bill’s mate in Tralfamador’s zoo Fellow soldier, helps Billy in WWII A group of Aliens that take Billy captive The man on the train that talks to Billy Soldier, vows to kill Billy Help out Billy in WWII Science fiction writer, Billy’s favorite author Man who dies on Train in Germany Fellow resident in Mental ward with Billy An American turned Nazi German guard at Slaughterhouse Roommate of Billy in Hospital Wife of Bertram Throws Billy into Pool, dies in hunting Accident We see his life and the horrible and odd things he has had to experience throughout it. ...

Words: 564 - Pages: 3