Free Essay

Gender Selection

In:

Submitted By karbear
Words 1117
Pages 5
Running head: GENDER SELECTION

Is Gender Selection of a Fetus Ethical?
Emily Myer
Grand Canyon University
NRS 437V
08.21.2010

Gender Selection

It is a commonly known fact that countries such as China and India prize their male children far above their females. Investigations have also shown that many parents in these countries have been illegally aborting these less desirable female children as a means of gender selection. As a result, it is estimated that there will be nearly 60 million more men of marriageable age in China than women by the year 2050. (The Economist, 2011) A recent technological development published in the Journal of the American Medical Association report that, “a new maternal blood test can determine a fetus’ sex as early as seven weeks into a pregnancy” (Ravitsky, 2011). Is it possible that this technology, in and of itself, can pose an ethical threat to humanity? Some are already saying that it does. One such critic is Vardit Ravitsky, an assistant professor in the bioethics program at the University of Montreal. She is also the editor of “The Penn Center Guide to Bioethics”. In her opinion piece published on CNN’s website, she asserts that this new technology is safer, less invasive, and more accurate than the options that are currently available to the public, making it much easier to use for non-medical purposes such as gender selection (Ravitsky, 2011). For the purpose of this assignment, the ethical implications of gender selection through the use of gender prediction tests during pregnancy will be discussed. My personal view concerning this topic is derived from a moral particularist as well as a deontological perspective. I was raised a Christian and believe strongly in these values. I am also a staunch proponent for women’s rights as well as a huge advocate for maintaining our autonomy in society, however I also believe that a human is a human from the moment of conception and do not support murder of any kind. My view is that we do not attain humanness during some magical moment or when scientists and politicians consider one “viable”. While I admit that I lean more toward a rule-utilitarianist approach, I also sympathize with those who support abortion when a mother’s life is at risk. On this issue, I would take more of an act-utilitarianist stance because, although it remains in conflict with my original view that the child is still alive and very much a human being, there is now a chance that two lives will be lost if the pregnancy is not terminated. Inconvenience and gender preference are simply not justifiable reasons for abortion no matter what country one lives in. With that said, some argue that parents may fear that their child is at risk for a sex-linked condition. My original position still stands, however, that regardless of the findings abortion is not justified. I’d like to reiterate the fact that we are discussing the issue of gender selection through the use of gender prediction tests during pregnancy, not in vitro implantation of a known male or female embryo. This is a whole separate ethical issue altogether. Gender “selection” during pregnancy directly implies that the parents intend to abort the child if it is not the desired sex. I’d now like to explore the various strategies that may be employed with regard to this topic. The FDA has not yet approved this particular test for routine use by physicians, but if it were, how should it be regulated? Should it be regulated at all? Does patient autonomy take precedent over the fact that this test may be used for the purpose of sex selection and non-medical outcomes? (Ravitsky, 2011) It seems that regulation of such tests would be difficult, as patients would not necessarily choose to divulge the motive behind receiving the test. The bottom line in this case is that abortion itself is legal in the U.S. and women need not state a specific reason for having the procedure. There are clinics all over the world that provide gender selection services and I would advocate for prohibiting the use of these tests for that specific purpose. In China and India these practices have been in place for over a decade and we are now seeing the social impact that it is having, as the gender ratios are so grossly skewed. Granted, social mores provide the impetus for their behavior, however the ethical impact is the same all over the world. If this technology were to be approved for routine use, laws could be put in place that could help prevent physicians from using the service for the purpose of gender selection. For example, once a woman receives the test and discovers the sex of the baby, this could be filed in an official database. If that same woman were to request an abortion after receiving the test without a medical reason, a red flag would then go up. If this woman were to develop a pattern of this behavior and request another abortion after a similar test result, a waiting period and counseling would be mandated. Many would argue that this is a violation of a woman’s right to privacy, however I would advocate for this particular strategy. Another strategy might involve allowing women to practice gender selection in order to protect freedom of choice, privacy and patient autonomy. This could, however, lead to serious social and ethical consequences similar to those seen in China. Many conservatives in the 1970’s were concerned that Roe vs. Wade would take society down an ethical slippery slope. No one at that time could have foreseen where technology would eventually take this issue. Where will the line be drawn? When is the use of this right going to cross the line? What will stop science, or society for that matter, from using genetic testing to select certain genetic preferences such as blonde hair or blue eyes? This sounds eerily familiar. Eugenics was a heated issue in the 1940’s and we fought hard against such “genetic cleansing”, but could we be heading in that direction now?
References
Burkhardt, M., & Nathaniel, A. (2008). Ethics & Issues in Contemporary Nursing (3rd ed.). Clifton Park, NY: Delmar Cengage Leaning.
The Economist. (2011). The decline of Asian marriage: Asia's lonely hearts. The Economist, July, 2011, 1. Retrieved August 16, 2011, from The Economist Web site: www.economist.com
Ravitsky, V. (2011). Is Gender Selection of a Fetus Ethical? . (Original work published 2011) Retrieved August 16, 2011, from CNN.com Web site: www.cnn.com/ 2011/ OPINION/ 08/ 15/ ravitsky.gender.selection/ index.html?hpt=he_c2

nder

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Gender Selection

...Human Gender Selecting Jessica McIntosh Medical Office Management Dr. Bridget Kelly Bryant & Stratton ABSTRACT This paper aims to provide a concise review of the ethical issues that are commonly raised in the debate between non-medical sex selection and natural selection. Background information on sex selection technologies is provided, as is a description of the process regarding the medical procedure. Arguments for and against gender selection will be explained and compared and conclusions will be drawn. Included will be the pros and cons of gender selection. Finally, the views of people I know as well as my own. Aside from cases in which it is used to prevent an inherited disease more likely to strike one gender than the other, should parents be permitted to use technology that selects the gender of their children? One of the first pieces of information that parents receive about a newborn baby is its gender. The widespread use of ultrasound technology during pregnancy even allows many parents to find out whether their baby is male or female before it is born. In recent years, technology has enabled parents to go one step further. They can now, with a good chance of success, take steps to select the gender of their children. While gender selection is legal in the U.S., it has generated some controversy among the medical advisory groups that tackle questions of bioethics. For instance, although the sperm-separation method is widely endorsed for families...

Words: 1806 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Gender Selection and Ethical Marketing

...Running Head: Gender selection and ethical marketing Gender Selection and Ethical Marketing Unit 4 Assignment MT330 International Marketing Kaplan University Christina Olson October 16, 2011 Soft glow of the skin, feelings of butterflies in the stomach, and countless days of pampering and love; this is what pregnancy should be like. Expecting mothers should be joyous about the wonderful life that they are caring. Medical technology advancement has made the ability of planning for new born babies easier by the use of ultrasound machines. Currently ultrasound machines are produced by many different companies, one of them being General Electric. Ultrasound machines were first used to test the distance between two areas. During the 1950s these machines were used by doctors to identify masses in the human body such as tumors (Barfee.net, 2011). General Electric designs their ultrasound machines with the women’s body in mind, to be with her every step of the way from pre to post pregnancy (GE, 2011). This company is taking strides to ensure that all women are being looked after with the best technological advancements possible (GE, 2011). They have developed portable ultrasound systems which help to provide medical capabilities to all those in need at any location imaginable. In China the easy accessibility of GE’s ultra sound machines has become more of a negative effect than a positive one. Since the pass of China’s One-Child Policy, many women wanted only...

Words: 641 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ant 101 Week 3 Assignments

...1) Select one aspect of your own culture from the list provided for Part I. Be sure to review the relevant sections of the textbook for each topic. Once you've made your selection, please delete all other options. Race Education Communication Gender Childrearing Courtship and Marriage Rites of passage Religion Politics Economics 2) Select a source to use for Part I of the paper. You will be using your textbook and the article by Miner for this section as well, but for this assignment, include the source you found on your own. Review the tutorial on Evaluating sources and enter the reference in the space below. Reference entry in APA format: 3) Select one article from the list for Part II. Once you've made your selection, please delete all other options. Atran, S. (2003). Genesis of suicide terrorism. Science, 299(5612), 1534-1539. Retrieved from the EBSCOhost database. Becker. A. E. (2004). Television, disordered eating, and young women in Fiji: Negotiating body image and identity during rapid social change. Culture, Medicine & Psychiatry, 28(4), 533-559. Retrieved from the EBSCOhost database. Grey, S. (2008). Historical roots, contemporary relevance: Explaining the persistence of polygyny in Sub- Saharan Africa. Undercurrent Journal, 5(3), 6-19. Retrieved from the EBSCOhost database. Hoodfar, H. (1993). The veil in their minds and on our heads: The persistence of colonial images of Muslim women. Resources for Feminist Researchers...

Words: 359 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Decisions of Uncertainity

...Decisions of Uncertainty Introduction The Decision What is the probability of hiring a qualified employee upon selecting one from 52 applicants 26 are male and 26 are female? Probability Concepts The probability of the event –hiring a qualified male employee—is the proportion of times the company would expect to obtain a qualified male employee over the long run if the HR managers selected applicants many times. I will refer to each repetition of the situation – in this case the selection of a qualified male future employee—as a sampling experiment. The probability of the event is the proportion of times we would expect the event to occur in an infinitely long series of identical sampling experiments. The Outcome In this case, the probability of selecting a qualified male employee is 0 .50 or 50%. I arrived at this conclusion by using the knowledge that there are 52 applicants who areapplying for the open position, 26 are female and 26 are male. If the company assume that each of the 52 possibilities is equally likely, it is reasonable to expect that the company would select a male applicant that is qualified for the open position 0.50 of the time of a period of time ( 26/52 = ½ = 0.50 ). This illustrates the basic rule for obtaining probabilities in situations in which each of the possible outcomes is equally likely, the probability of the occurrence of an event is equal to the proportion of the possible outcomes characterized by the event. In the case of...

Words: 341 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Delegate Replication Rights to Non-Admins

...Task 1 of 2 Create a Universal Group called Replication Management Admins in an OU you’ve chosen to hold groups for delegated access or other security related task. Open ADSI Edit and connect to the Configuration Naming Context as seen in the image below. Once you've selected Configuration in "Select a well known Naming Context", click OK Expand the Configuration Naming context and right click the Naming Context node below it. See the picture below for the arrow indicating where you should right-click. Next Click Properties Click the Security Tab Click the Advanced button Click Add Enter the name of the Universal Group you created in Step 1 and click OK In the Permission Entry for Configuration box scroll to the bottom and tic the Allow box for the Replication Synchronization permission. Ensure that "This object and all child objects" is selected for the Apply to and click OK Click Apply, then OK, and then click OK once more and you should be back to ADSI Edit with no open dialog boxes. Task 2 of 2 After you’ve completed steps 1-10 in Task 1 you'll need to view all the replicated partitions and do the same process for each partition. Click on CN=Partitions under CN=Configuration, DC= to view the partitions in the Configuration naming context. On each partition right click each object and select New Connection to Naming Context. Note: You don't have to do this for...

Words: 354 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Information System Briefing

...risks due to potential loss of funding” (Wager, Lee, & Glaser, 2009, para. 9). Implementing a new software system will benefit the Mobile Mammography Van greatly. This paper is intended to identify the process for selecting and acquiring an information system, explain how the organizations goals drive the selection process, and identify the roles each organization’s stakeholders play in the selection process. Selecting and Acquiring an Information System When an organization is selecting and acquiring a new information system there is a great deal of planning and steps they must take to implement the system properly. The first step is to establish a project steering committee. “This committee’s primary function is to plan, organize, coordinate, and manage all aspects of the acquisition process” (Wager, et. al., 2009, pg. 150). After the committee has been formed the project goals should be outlines along with the scope of the project and committee. Many questions will need to be discussed during this step. For example, the committee will need to determine the methods, processes, communication techniques, resources, and type of system that will be used through the selection and acquisition process. Once project goals and the scope of the project are defined the next step is to screen the marketplace and review vendor profiles. “Concurrently with the...

Words: 985 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Skyline

...Name :Muhammad Musab Hussain ID:7601 Subject :MGM411 Human resource a,Analyze the job selected position and wirte their job description and job specification? Ans, description * Sales of companies goods and services * Building relationship with customers * Responsible for repeat sales of existing customers * Approaching customer with the aim of making new business deals * Presenting the product or service in a professional or structured way * Researching the market * Checking the inventory for products * Responding to incoming emails and phone calls * Attending team meeting and providing valuable feedback Specification * Strong sales skills * Communication skills * Bachelor’s degree * Master’s degree * Ability to multitask * Delivering revenue or exceeding target * 3 years minimum experience in sales * Organizational and time management skills * Negotiating and closing sales B,what method will you adopt for appointing a person on the selected position? Ans, 1. Top management approval 2. Advertisement development 3. Post advertisement on the news paper 4. Call the people for interviews 5. Conducts interviews 6. Select the people which best match the requirement 7. Further skim them 8. Conduct another interview 9. Upon approval select the final people for hiring 10. Conduct the physical examination 11. Hire people that pass the final test. c,how...

Words: 355 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Html Css 6th Edition Chapter 6 Video Quiz Questions

...type attribute, browsers assume you are creating a(n): a. file input box b. text input box ***** c. hidden input box d. image input box 3. What is required in the syntax when you need to refer to the control element? a. checkbox b. form label c. id attribute ******** d. name asterisk 4. The asterisk in Name* tells users that Name is a(n): a. id attribute b. required field ******* c. form label d. inline element 5. You create a selection list using the: a. id attribute b. name attribute c. option element d. selection element ******* 6. Which term defines the number of options that the selection list displays at one time? a. element b. control c. value **** d. field 7. Consider your audience and its initial reaction to a selection list when setting the: a. size attribute ****** b. list control c. style coding d. type option 8. The name attribute provides the name of the: a. field value b. selection list c. style sheet d. data field ***** 9. To create an option button, use the input element with the type attribute set to a value of: a. file b. image c. radio ******* d. text 10. When you use the same name for two or more option buttons, browsers treat them as a group, so selecting one option button automatically: a. highlights all the others b. selects all of the others c. deletes all the others d. deselects all of the others ***** ...

Words: 449 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Human Resource Management

...Chapter -6 Employee Testing And Selection The importance of Selecting the Right Employee: If the Right Employee is not selected then there will be some problem like fall of organization,low performance,cost of recriting and hiring .there may 3problem feced by the employer if he Select wrong person  Organizational performance  Cost of Recruiting and hiring  Legal Obligation and Liability Organizational Performance: Employee performance affects organizational performance.Organizational performance including stragic planner operation,finance.legal and organizational development will fall if the employer select the wrong candidate Perfromance differ for different employee The Costof Recruitong and hiring:The cost of simlpy finding the right person recruiting cost.if wrong person hired the the organization have to take another Interview ,advertige so that will increase the cost of the organization Legal Obligation and Liability:The candidate who apply for the job may be he/she be a bad person .He may have Criminal activities.so these Candidate can do Crime in the organization or harm the organization   Avoiding Negliting hiring claims: • Carefully Scrutinze information on employment applications.the information about candidate provided on the application should be read very carefully • Get Written Authorization...

Words: 296 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Lab Report

...1 )   Create a new query in Query Design, including the Employee Info and Sales by Employee tables. Add the First Name and Last Name fields from the Employee Info table, and the Quarter and Actual Sales fields from the Sales by Employee table (in that order). Run the query.   Ribbon 1. | Click the CREATE tab. | 2. | On the CREATE tab, in the Queries group, click Query Design. | 3. | In the Show Table dialog box, with the Employee Info table selected, click Add. | 4. | Click the Sales by Employee table and then click Add. | 5. | Click Close in the Show Table dialog box. | 6. | In the query design window, in the Employee Info table, double-click the First Name field. | 7. | In the query design window, in the Employee Info table, double-click the Last Name field. | 8. | In the query design window, in the Sales by Employee table, double-click the Quarter field. | 9. | In the query design window, in the Sales by Employee table, double-click the Actual Sales field. | 10. | On the DESIGN tab, in the Results group, click Run. | |   Keyboard 1. | Press ALT (or F10, or F6 two times), C, and then QD. | 2. | In the Show Table dialog box, with Employee Info selected press ALT+A (or ENTER or TAB to select the Add button, and then press ENTER (or A or SPACEBAR)). | 3. | Press S (or use ARROW keys) to select the Sales by Employee table, and then press ALT+A (or ENTER or TAB to select the Add button, and then press ENTER (or A or SPACEBAR))...

Words: 10463 - Pages: 42

Premium Essay

Consumer Studies

...MDSE 3750 Consumer Studies Semester Project Objectives: * To provide students with the opportunity to apply course concepts and ideas to a specific brand/product * Develop your team building, * Refine time management skills, * Apply written and oral communication skills. Procedures: Groups and Brand Selection 1. Groups of three people will be formed. You will have a window of opportunity to select your own group; students not selecting a group will be placed in one. * Sign-up Deadline: Midnight, September 24 * All student not in a group by the time Dr. Kinley logs on September 25 will be placed into a group. 2. You will be asked to select a brand (of product or store) to focus on for the semester. 3. Once groups are formed, students will submit their “top 3” list in the Bb Discussion Board, which will open on September 25. Dr. Kinley will make the final selections for each group. Your Top 3 should be in order of preference. **** NOTE: This discussion board will be in the “Discussion” menu-item on the left-menu of Bb. DO NOT POST YOUR PREFRENCES IN YOUR GROUP DISCUSSION BOARD. Project: After the brand/product is selected, your group will focus on that specific product and relate it to all concepts we discuss in class. Your team will keep a running wiki of how each chapter’s materials relate to the product (starting with Text Chapter 3). In some chapters, there will be more to discuss than others. Your...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Guy Gh Gykgig Bdrtwv Gu

...Self-Guided Career Exploration Personality Assessment Instructions The process of selecting an academic major and deciding upon a future occupation is ongoing and multi-faceted. Therefore, when you begin to engage in independent exploration and reflection prior to meeting with career counselors or other professional staff, you are able to have more productive sessions that help you to effectively identify possible academic majors, and more confidently explore your career options. The FYE Career Exploration website is now available to facilitate such self-guided exploration! A link for the site is available from the FYE {First Year Experience} web page in MyHCC. On the HCC homepage, click on <STUDENT SERVICES>. 1. Select <SUPPORT AT HCC>. 2. Select <FIRST YEAR EXPERIENCE>. 3. Under the heading “FYE CAREER RESOURCES”, click on <CAREER EXPLORATION>. 4. On the FYE Career Exploration website go to the “Career Exploration Registration” tab and complete the required information. 5. Go the “Career Exploration Activities” Tab. 6. Be sure to read the Topic Overview to begin your exploration and reflection. Feel free to explore other activities on the FYE Career Exploration site. 7. Click on the GREEN link for the “Personality Assessment” and click on “Register Here” {this second registration is required by the assessment vendor}. 8. Complete the “Do What You Are” [DWYA] assessment. Read your results...

Words: 278 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Mkt 441 Week 2 Learning Team Market Research Implementation Plan Problem Identification and Project Outline

...MKT 441 Week 2 Learning Team Market Research Implementation Plan Problem Identification and Project Outline To Buy This material Click below link http://www.uoptutors.com/MKT-441/MKT-441-Week-2-Learning-Team-Market-Research-Implementation-Plan-Problem-Identification-and-Project-Outline Select an organization with which you are familiar. This organization will be the basis for your Market Research Implementation Plan. Be sure to obtain your instructor’s approval before beginning this project. Select a scenario from the following list: An organization is planning to introduce a new product/service in another country An organization is considering introducing a new product/service An organization is considering launching a new business unit An organization is considering pursuing a new geographical market An organization is considering adjusting the pricing of an existing product/service An organization is considering enhancing an existing product/service to meet expanding customer needs An organization wants to evaluate its perceived customer service Prepare a 700 to1050 word detailed outline of your Market Research Implementation Plan in which you address the following: Write an introduction describing your selected organization and scenario. Based on your selected scenario, identify the detailed areas in which market research is needed (e.g., population, target market, per capita) and describe their importance to the organization in the selected scenario. Develop...

Words: 262 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Mt 400 Unit 8 Assignment: Establishing Baselines and Assessing Success

...MT 400 Unit 8 Assignment: Establishing Baselines and Assessing Success https://homeworklance.com/downloads/mt-400-unit-8-assignment-establishing-baselines-assessing-success/ Unit 8 Assignment: Establishing Baselines and Assessing Success In this Assignment, you are going to evaluate a specific business process based on criteria detailed below. If you already have selected a business process, continue using that and skip to the next paragraph. If you have not yet selected the business process you will use for these Assignments, then begin by selecting one. Email your instructor and clearly describe the objective of this process, the participants, and the strategic significance for the company. The business process you select must have a clear beginning and an end, with identifiable, specific steps. Your instructor will confirm that the process you selected is suitable or will ask you to select another one. For this Assignment, write a paper that answers the following questions (use the subheadings/numbered questions below to organize your paper): Part 1: Implementation Strategies Evaluate the suitability of the four implementation strategies discussed in step 2 for your project. ● For each strategy, explain the specific pros and cons of using it for your project. The analysis should be based on how each strategy applies to the process you selected and the nature of your selected organization. Do not simply repeat the generic pros/cons from the book. ● Select...

Words: 955 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Gut1 Task 4

...client and server functionality. The testing is performed manually from the end user point as documented in the herein contained Test Cases. The following requirements must be met to run the program: Java Integrated Development Environment (IDE), MySQL database. Netbeans 7.0.1 was utilized in making the program and testing it . MySQL is open source SQL database. They both can be downloaded for free of charge. Windows 7 OS was used to host both pieces of software. There are minimum requirements that can be referenced on download websites. Each option available in the program will be tested. The Use Case Diagrams may be referenced for further details on functions of each option. The test will test each available selection. The selections to be tested are as follows: 1-Add Student Information 2-Update Student Information 3-Query Student Information...

Words: 929 - Pages: 4