Premium Essay

The Amnesty Plan

In:

Submitted By indigrace
Words 3058
Pages 13
THE PLAN OF AMNESTY:
The Solution to Illegal Immigration
Michael Mays
ENG 102: Composition II
February 10, 2012

The Plan of Amnesty
How much would it cost to put 10 Million people in busses or airplanes and ship them back to their countries of origin? Is there a better way to deal with illegal immigration in the United States? Is the answer a strict and enforceable amnesty, allowing illegal immigrants to report themselves in order to achieve legal status, or is mass deportation of the estimated 10 million illegal aliens living in the U.S. the solution? A well laid-out, simplified, yet fair and enforceable amnesty plan could solve the multi-billion dollar battle of amnesty, deportation and illegal immigration.
The cost of illegal immigration to the United States is estimated in the billions by numerous news avenues but what are the actual numbers and their impact on the United States? “More than 10 million illegal immigrants live in the United States, and 1,400 more arrive every day” (Katel, 2005). This number seems very high and somewhat scary to people but the truth is that “illegal immigrants only make up about 5 percent of the U.S. work force” (Ketel, 2005). Nonetheless, strong actions have been taken by the government to try to put a stop to illegal immigration. Over the past decade or so, billions of dollars have been spent on border-control measures such as walls, fences, and increasing border patrol personnel. From 1993 to 2004, the federal government quintupled border enforcement spending to $3.8 billion and tripled the Border Patrol to more than 11,000 officers (Cornelius, 2004). Seeing these totals without drastic results makes amnesty supporters wonder if this money could be better spent elsewhere.
Currently the law is if a person is suspected of being an illegal alien, they will go through a long process of deportation. Deportation is a scary

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration

...| Illegal Immigration: The Story Behind Amnesty | Is Amnesty the Answer? | University of Montevallo | Lachera S. Huntley | 3/12/2012 | Although thousands of immigrants come to the United States Illegally, most of them are in this country for the jobs that Americans will not do. That is why so many illegal immigrants come to the United States. However, everyone that breaks the Immigration Law should be punished, even if they are not citizens of the country. According to Perez (2001), “In 1986 Congress passed the Immigration Reform and Control Act that, among other things, granted amnesty to illegal immigrants who could demonstrate continual residence in the United States prior to 1982” (Perez, 2001). Because of this law, millions of illegal immigrants can use this act to become citizens of the United States. | According to Mirram-Webster (2012), “amnesty means that the act of an authority (as a government) by which pardon is granted to a large group of individuals” (Mirram-Webster, 2012). Therefore, amnesty is unfair and unconstitutional because all of the illegal immigrants that come into the United States are pardon after they have violated the laws in this country. Why do we continue to allow these illegal immigrants to go unpunished? If it were some of the U.S. citizens breaking this law they would not be granted amnesty; they would be treated differently, so why illegal immigrants should be pardoned? Robert Byrd (2001), a West Virginia senator, says, “Illegal...

Words: 1845 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Amnesty International

...Amnesty International Date of Establishment: July 1961 in London, U.K. Founder: Peter Benneson Amnesty International was founded in 1961 to protect human rights internationally. Amnesty international also stands up for victims of oppressive regimes and other abuses. The official objective of the organisation: “to conduct research and generate action to prevent and end grave abuses of human rights, and to demand justice for those whose rights have been violated.” Amnesty international is currently active throughout the world, with over 3 million members in 150 countries worldwide. The organisation is a worldwide watchdog regarding human rights/abuses. . As Christian men and women it is very important that we support the work that Amnesty international is doing globally. Many of the organisations principles echo the message that we learnt from Jesus Christ. For example, Jesus told us that we must be defenders of the weak and the helpless. Similarly, Amnesty International stands up for individuals who cannot defend themselves or their families. By supporting this noble foundation we can make life better for the millions around the world suffering from oppression. It is very easy for one to become a member of Amnesty International. All you have to do is go to their official website (there is one for many different languages) and select how much money you plan to donate (donations range from $21-$100; to be paid once a month). Once this section is done...

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Amnesty International

...Tara Mouton Political Science 4042 Mokeba Amnesty International Amnesty International is a non-governmental organization that has a primary focus of human rights and has over 3 million members and supporters around the world. They participate in international politics because they focus on relations among states and other political units across international waters. The mission statement of Amnesty International is to envision a world in which every person regardless or race, religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation or gender identity enjoys all of the human rights enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other internationally recognized human rights standards. Amnesty International unites people from all over the world to fight for human rights using their three signature tactics. The use research by keeping watch on rights of people around the world and publishing independent reports; action by using campaigns to gain attention of the international media, demanding attention of policy makers; and finally advocacy by promoting legislation that advances human rights. Amnesty International was created in 1961 in London when a British lawyer learned that two Portuguese students had be imprisoned for raising a toast to freedom and wrote an article that soon spread to newspapers around the world. The first meeting of Amnesty International was held shortly after with the original members of Belgium, the US, France, the UK, Germany, Switzerland, and Ireland....

Words: 1433 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Child Soldiers Research Paper

...Child soldiers responsible for capital crimes should not be allowed amnesty unless it has been proven that they were forced to become a soldier. If given immunity, victims would not receive justice. Victims would have to live knowing the killer of their friend or family member did not receive punishment. Also, many of these children become soldiers because they chose to. Some of them plan missions and war crimes. If there is no consequence for being a youth fighter, given the fact they received immunity, commands will recruit and use more of them. This will just increase the numbers of child soldiers. Child soldiers do not deserve amnesty, they need to be held accountable for their actions. Additionally, forgiving child soldiers denies victims...

Words: 502 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Tax Amnesty Case

...0 tax amnesties generate revenue D that the tax authorities would not otherwise collect? Will tax amnesties pro- vide continuing or long-run revenue gains not available from enhanced enforcement alone? And if a change in tax enforce- ment is to occur, in what sense is an am- nesty appropriate in the transition to the new regime? Although twenty-six states have conducted tax amnesty programs since 1982, there has been little analysis of them to date, and almost none based on actual amnesty results.' In this paper we examine individual participation in am- nesties, both from the point of view of what economic analysis would lead us to expect and on the basis of evidence from actual amnesty programs. The empirical analy- sis is based on detailed information gath- ered on a random sample of taxpayers participating in the Michigan amnesty, and on fragmentary evidence we have been *Michigan State University, East Iiming, MI 48824 able to gather on amnesties in other states. In our view, information about the types of taxpayers (or nontaxpayers) who par- ticipate in amnesties and the circum- stances that lead them to participate can be of considerable use in evaluating the effects of amnesties and for predicting the prospects for a federal tax amnesty from the state results. Under a tax amnesty, taxpayers are of- fered an opportunity to come forward dur- ing a specified period of time and pay pre- I 15 unpaid taxes. The carrot viousiy encouraging participation is usually for-...

Words: 7146 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

Compromised Solution to Illegal Immigration

...A Compromised Solution to Illegal Immigration The issue of illegal immigration is certainly a very pertinent and current issue of today. Currently there are two resolutions to the issue being proposed by the Democrats and the Republican parts. The Democratic plan works to try and legalize all those who are here illegally, whereas the Republican backed plan seeks to enforce the laws that we all ready have in place. Although both plans have advantages and disadvantages, the Republican backed plan seems to be a superior plan. The illegal immigration problem that is occurring in the United States is a mass crossing of the Southern boarder by Mexican and other central American residents. The number of illegal crossings is estimated to be close to one million a year (State Laws Related to Immigration and Immigrants 1). This number is only an estimate though, and only around 500,000 aliens, or people caught illegally in other countries, are apprehended each year meaning that the number could be even larger(1). These large numbers of illegal aliens entering our country brings with it great risk and danger to us. Every year U.S. citizens living along the boarder are killed by illegals crossing into the U.S. , as well as many Boarder patrol agents who are killed and wounded in the line of duty (U.S. Immigration Policy 1). The illegals crossing also usually bring many illegal substances, such as drugs and guns, which are then sold on the black market in the U.S.. Fears are also mounting...

Words: 1092 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How Did Johnston's Plan For Reconstruction

...The reconstruction era of the United States lasted from 1865 after the end of the Civil War to the beginning of President Hayes term. There were three main plans for reconstruction, Lincoln’s plan, Johnston’s plan and the Radical Republican’s plan. Lincoln’s plan included amnesty to Southerners who took a oath of loyalty to the United States with the exception of some, and that when ten percent of a state’s voters in the 1860 presidential election had taken the oath the state could organize a new government. Johnston’s plan required states to ratify the thirteenth amendment and offered amnesty to Southerners who took a vote of loyalty except former high ranking confederate leaders and those with over 20,000 dollars of property. The Radical...

Words: 503 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Health Care Reform

...needing emergency health care regardless of legal status or ability to pay. Undocumented immigrants are overrunning medical institutions with their inability to pay. Uncompensated care threatens the financial viability of a unit’s ability to provide care to other patients. Illegal immigrants are a burden to the United States health care economics. Is it an ethical and moral responsibility for the United States to provide and promote health care to people regardless of legal status? As the debate around immigration continues to be the corner stone of ongoing discussion it is challenging to measure. These concerns compel one to examine the issue closely and identify potential solutions. A possible solution to illegal immigration is “Amnesty.” Amnesty for illegal immigrants refers to...

Words: 1147 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Negative Effects Of Abraham Lincoln's Assassination

...sides were caught together, stuck in an endless spiral downward. When Lincoln was assassinated restoring the nation was left to Johnson. A difficult task even for a strong man like Lincoln, but when Johnson, inexperienced in politics takes over the task become more or less impossible. Lincoln's assassination had a negative impact on the country after the Civil War because the South would have been better off with Lincoln's plan and Johnson accomplished nothing during his presidency. Lincoln's plan for governmental Reconstruction was flawless, until Johnson came along and ruined it. Lincoln's plan for Reconstruction was fair and peaceful; consequently he released the Proclamation of Amnesty and Reconstruction in 1863. He believed the proclamation would muster northern support for the war and meanwhile persuade tiring Confederate soldiers to give up (Coyne and Bolotin). The proclamation permitted full pardons to all Southerners - except high-ranking...

Words: 1512 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

“the Wealthier and Closer the Pressure Group Is to the Government the More Successful They Are”

...“The wealthier and closer the pressure group is to the government the more successful they are” A. How far do you agree? Pressure groups are organizations, which attempt to influence the government from outside, this means that they do not put candidates up for election and instead act as a bridge between the people and government. The are many different types of pressure groups ranging from wealthy insider groups like the B.M.A. to less wealthy outsider groups like Amnesty International. The wealthier and closer the pressure group is to the government the more successful they are. The success of the British Medical Association (B.M.A.) suggests that the wealthier and closer the pressure group is to the government the more successful they are. The B.M.A. is a voluntary association that speaks up for the interests of doctors at home and abroad, provides a range of services for its members and engages in scientific research. These activities involve lobbying not only the British government but also the European Union as well. The B.M.A. is undoubtedly one of the most influential and effective pressure groups as they have great influence over the policies of the British government regarding the health care system in matters such as the pay and training of doctors, the work of GP’s and hospitals, and the quality and quantity of medical facilities. This supports the view that the wealthier and closer the pressure group is to the government the more successful they are...

Words: 2406 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Robin Hood

...organization and close ties to Prince John. Robin also faced the problems that came with a growing band such as the lack of food for everyone, the high cost of feeding everyone, and the decreasing discipline among the men. Furthermore, Robin was also confronted with the vicious and volatile Prince John who would seek rancorous revenge if he were to find out that Robin was part of the conspiracy to remove him from power.   3. Robin Hood and the Merrymen’s Future Mission and Plan I believe that continuing their present course of action will only result in financial failure and therefore the end of the Merrymen. This is because, just like any company today, innovation and change is necessary for survival in a strongly dynamic environment. Robin’s operating environment was changing drastically, as people began avoiding the forest so that they could avoid having their goods confiscated by Robin and his men. For this reason it is imperative that Robin and the Merrymen change their future Mission and Plan. 4. Fixed Transit Taxation I believe that imposing a fixed transit tax to counter the decline in revenues is the only viable option that would ensure the survival of Robing and the Merrymen. This is because by not changing their operations they would be confronted with a changing environment which they are not adapting to. Even though they...

Words: 804 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Immigration to Texas

...contributing to the immigration of illegal immigrants into Texas. The majority of these immigrants are from Central America through the border shared with Mexico. There are push and pull factors causing them to move here. “The report from the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops identifies poverty, paucity of educational opportunities, the urge to join family already in the U.S., and the fear of growing crime as powerful factors propelling immigrants northward” (Millman). In a report from the United Nations, “homicide rates increased in five out of eight countries in Central America over the previous five years” (Millman). These factors make America more appealing than the countries being fled from, but this is not an excuse to break the law. A plan needs to be put into action to help these people seek refuge. The amount of...

Words: 1784 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Robin Hood

...Gestão Estratégica e Comercial 2014/2015   Robin Hood Case Study                                     1    II. Table Index   Table 1. Market Segmentation………………………………………………………………..6  Table 2. PESTL Analysis……………………………………………………………………...7,8  Table 3 ­ Benchmarking ……………………………………………………………………...12        III. Image Index   Figure 1. Porter Analysis Diagram …………………………………………………………...9  Figure 2. Porter’s generic Value Chain………………………………………………………10  Figure 3. SWOT analysis……………………………………………………………………...13                                                      2  IV.     Index 0. Executive Summary…………………………………………………………………………....4  1. Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………...5  2. Definition of the Market – Market Segment………………………………………………..5,6  2.1. Geographic segmentation…………………………………………………………….....5  2.2. Demographics………………………………………………………………………….....5  2.3. Psychographic…………………………………………………………………………….5  2.4. Behavioural………………………………………………………………………………..6  3. Analysis of the External Environment…………………………………………...…………....6  3.1. PESTL Analysis…………………………………………………………………………..7  3.2. Porter Analysis………………………………………………………………..……..…8,9  4. Analysis of the Internal Environment…………………………………………………….10,11  5.Analysis of the Competitive Position of the Organization…………………………..….11,12  5.1. Critical Success Factors………………………………………………………...….11,12  5.2. Benchmarking……………………………………………………………………….…..12  6. SWOT Analysis……………………………………………………………………...…….13,14  7. Recommendations………………………………………………………………………...

Words: 3963 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Robin Hood Case Study

...Merrymen. Robin Hood himself was the leader of the band and delegated different functions among his four lieutenants: Will Scarlett (intelligence and scouting, collecting information on Sherriff’s moves and on the travel plans of rich merchants and tax collectors), Little John (discipline and archery skills), Scarlock (finance, converting loot to cash, paying shares of the take and finding hiding places for surplus), and Much the Miller’s son (provisioning the band). Through time, the band grew larger and larger as Robin Hood welcomed everyone who wanted to join. The band eventually became too big and that started to cause issues. Vigilance and discipline were becoming smaller and food scarcity grew, as provision for more and more people was needed. Robin Hood’s band became known for robbery and travellers started to avoid the forest, thus leaving the band with less revenues. In the mean time, the Sherriff was growing stronger and became better organized and financially wealthier. He started to mock the Band and so he had to be dealt with, before the Band itself was dealt with. Killing the Sherriff seemed not to be the solution, but his failure in collecting taxes did not remove him from office due to his alliances with Prince John. In return for amnesty, Robin Hood was given the opportunity to join a conspiracy to have King Richard the Lionheart released from jail in Austria and returned to his throne. There were many dangers involved, would they be worth it? A number...

Words: 1342 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Use of an Annotated Bibliography

...Use of an Annotated Bibliography Before being given the assignment of creating an annotated bibliography, I had never known of the term or the advantages that the annotated bibliography provides. The version that I have created below is my first , and I will continue to improve upon my technique in future attempts. I feel that this will be something that I will ensure I do for all future projects due to its usefulness. The annotated bibliography will allow me quick access to all of my sources that I intend to use, as well as helping me in remembering what each source is about and how it will fit into my project. Another big plus to this is that it essentially is my reference page, with a few things added. I don’t know why this was not introduced to me in earlier classes, but I do know that I will not go without its advantages any longer. Annotated Bibliography Dixon, P. B., Johnson, M., & Rimmer, M. T. (2011). Economy wide effects of reducing illegal immigration in U.S employment. Retrieved January 28, 2012, from https://ehis.ebscohost.com/eds/detail?vid=15&hid=23&sid=8d0ff197-79f4-4c2e-a56e-95e5597cb064%40sessionmgr14&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWRzLWxpdmU%3d#db=eoh&AN=1150873 Dixon, Johnson and Rimmer give info about the labor market and immigration policies that affect the economy. Also contains charts and figures that can be useful in my essay. Francis, E. (2010, August 4). Debate Over Birthright Citizenship Aims at 'Baby Tourists'. ABC World News...

Words: 509 - Pages: 3