Free Essay

Breach of Contract Hadley vs Baxendale

In:

Submitted By comwhiz
Words 910
Pages 4
BREACH OF A CONTRACT

Hadley vs Baxendale.
About the Companies.
Hadley carried out an extensive business as millers. Their business was stopped due to a breakage of the crankshaft on which the whole mill worked. They gave the crankshaft carrying order to Baxendale , a carrier company. But due to some reasons the delivery of the crankshaft was delayed by the carriers and because of that the plaintiffs(Hadley) had to incur losses. The plaintiffs claimed that the defendants(Baxendale) should pay them for the special damages as well since it was because of the delay of the delivery that they had to incur huge losses.

Case
Scene 1
Mr Hadley() (calling Mr Baxendale on phone ): Hello Mr Baxendale, this is Mr hadley speaking.
Mr Baxendale() : Hello, Mr Hadley, good to hear from you. I hope you have got your delivery of the crankshaft by now.
Mr Hadley : Yes Mr Baxendale, I have got the delivery. But I am afraid to say that it was late by three days!! And because of that, my company could not operate for all this duration and had to suffer huge losses because of that.
Mr baxendale : I am really sorry to hear that Mr Hadley.
Mr Hadley : U had signed the contract for carrying the shaft in three days and I think you must pay us for the losses we have suffered because of your negligence in the delivery of the crankshaft.
Mr Baxendale : Mr Hadley, We had signed the contract but I Do not think we should be paying for your losses. After all we carriers and we did our duty!!!
Mr Hadley : I am afraid then I will have to take you to the court for this
Mr Baxendale : I am ready for it Mr Hadley, See you at the court then!!!

Scene 2 (Court Room)
Judge(: Let us start the proceedings for the day. (Lawyer for Baxendale) : So, Company A(Hadley), what are your claims?
: My company suffered huge losses because of the negligence in the delivery of the crankshaft by company B(Baxendale).
: and on what basis are u claiming this?
Bax : We had signed a contract which clearly stated that company B will carry the crankshaft. They delayed the delivery and we had to stop functioning for a longer period.
Law22 (Lawyer for Hadley): My lord , it was because of Company B’s delay that my client suffered losses. They did not carry the shaft within the time mentioned in the contract and they had to shut down till the delivery arrived!!
Law2 : Objection My lord ! It is too early to say anything right now. If you may allow , I would like to ask Mr Hadley some questions.
JUDGE : You may go ahead.
Law2 (to Hadley) : So tell me Mr Baxendale, What was written in the contract?
Hadley : My lord, It was stated that we had to deliver the crankshaft for company A , with in three days.
Law2 : Were you informed about the criticality of the shaft?
Hadley : No.Never.
Law2 : Point to be noted my lord!!!! My client was never informed about the criticality of the shaft and it was not mentioned in the contract also that the shaft was so critical.
Law22 : But my lord, Company B has breached the contract and because of that my client suffered huge losses.
Law2 : Objection My lord, I want to ask company A, if the shaft was very critical to its operations, y did not they have a back up for it?
Law22 : but my lord, The point is about the breach of the contract and not about the operations!!
Law2 : But my point is Why would my client pay for such SPECIAL (EXEMPLARY) DAMAGES when they were not even informed about the criticality of the shaft?

Law2 ( to Bax) : so tell me , Mr Hadley,The amount that you have claimed, Is it your normal day to day turnover?
Bax : No
Law2 :Then y have u claimed such a huge amount?
Bax :My company was working on a big project during those days and we had to stop that because we had no crankshafts!!
Law2 : Did u inform this to my client?
Bax : No.
Law2 : So do you usually get such big projects?
Bax : No.
Law2 : Point to be noted my lord.As you can see my client was not informed about 1)The ongoing project 2) also, the company gets this project once in a blue moon 3) If the project was so critical , y dint they have any spare crankshafts ?
That’s is my lord.
Law2( to law22) : Your witness please.
Law22 : I do not have any questions My lord.

Pause..JUDGE noting down the points and coming to a conclusion .

JUDGE : After hearing the arguments from both the sides, The court has decided that
1)Company B will pay a compensation for the damages.
2)But the compensation claimed by company A are too exemplary. Since Company B were not informed about the criticality of the project , they will only pay for the damages caused due to the daily operations. It will not compensate for the damages caused by the non delivery of the consignment.
JUDGE : Case is closed and the Court is adjourned.

Narration(Law22) U can read this out. (or ppt)
“We learned that – An injured party may recover those damages reasonably considered to arise naturally from a breach of contract, or those damages within the reasonable contemplation of the parties at the time of contractin.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Marekting Eco Shack

...Week 1 Introduction to law Australian legal system * The first primary source of law is legislation, known as statutory law (parliament law) E.G Goods act or Consumer law such as section or act 1.1 * The second source of law is case law, which is also known a precedent Law E.G contract law (offer, acceptance, etc) * Doctrine of law which is when the court would revise a past case that relates to the issue to determine the verdict of the current case * Common law Week 2/3 State Court System * Supreme court * County court * Magistrate court * tribunal court Contract defined * Agreement that the law will enforced * offer+ acceptance + intention + consideration = contract * contract law is a case law Types of Contract * Simple contract (written, partially written, partially spoken, Spoken) * Formal Contract Week 4 Contract definition * Offer and acceptance together constitute agreements, Clarke v Earl * Two presumptions test for the existence of intention 1st presumption is domestic or social in nature (do not usually involve legal relationship, not legally bounding) domestic contract: {Balfour v Balfour} {Cohen v Cohen}, {Murphy v Simpson} Social agreement: Coward v Motor Insurers Bureau 2nd presumption is the commercial in nature( this can be legally binding) Edwards v Skyways Rebutting the presumption of Intention * {McGregor v McGregor}, {Merritt v Merritt}, {Wakeling v Ripley}...

Words: 3033 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Hfjfgfjhf

...Constitutional Law- Supremacy Clause- “This Constitution, and the laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof…… shall be the Supreme law of the Land; and the Judges in every state shall be bound thereby …..” Article VI Judicial Review- U.S. Constitution doesn’t provide that federal courts can declare a statute unconstitutional and void, but they can./Marbury v. Madison, 1803 introduced judicial review Activism v. Restraint- Over time, not a liberal vs. conservative issue.In the early days of the New Deal, judicial activism was responsible for striking down progressive measures. Originalism v. Living- When interpreting the Constitution, ask what the people who wrote it – or wrote the amendments – understood the provisions to mean. VS. To interpret the Constitution look to the language in the document and the understanding of the framers, but do so in light of the long history of common law which preceded and followed it. That gives you a mechanism for applying the document to situations which could never have been envisioned when the Constitution was written. Public v. Private Action- Companies and individuals can’t deprive you of your Constitutional rights, only a govt can. Commerce Clause- “The Congress shall have Power ……… To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States …….”Article 1, Section 8 Affordable Healthcare Act- Nat. Fed. of Independent Businesses v. Sibelius (2012)/Focus: The individual mandate – a requirement...

Words: 2002 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Law of Contract

...13 MBA 16 – Business Law & Practice Module 01 - Law of Contract Coverage of: • Law of Contract: Definition, Essentials • Types of Contracts • Offer – Definition & Essentials • Acceptance - Definition & Essentials • Consideration – Definition & Essentials, Exceptions • Capacity of Parties • Free Consent • Quasi Contract • Legality of Object • Performance of Contract – Termination of Contract – Remedies for Breach of Contract Case Studies 1 The Indian Contract Act, 1872 The Indian Contract Act consists of the following two parts:  General principals of the Law of Contracts – covered under section 1 to 75; the principles apply to all kinds of contracts irrespective of their nature  Special kinds of contracts – covered under section 124 to 138 ; These special contracts are Indemnity & Guarantee (u/s124 to 147), Bailment & Pledge (u/s148 to 181) and Agency (u/s 182 to 238) in Chapter X – refer next Module 2) Section 76 to 123 – repealed by Sale of Goods Act, 1930 (refer Module 4) • • Section 239 to 266 – Chapter XI has been repealed by the Indian Partnership Act , 1932 ( not being covered separately; but major issues under different modules) The act does not affect any usage or custom of trade (u/s 1) – these prevail if reasonable & not illegal; an unique feature of this Act – most important branch of business law Some of the contracts not dealt with by the this Act are those related to Partnership, Sale of Goods (refer module 4), Negotiable...

Words: 15475 - Pages: 62

Premium Essay

Management

...Commercial Transactions: Complete Notes: MacDougall: 2010/2011 Term 1 • These notes are a compilation of my class notes and the course package. I also used Atiyah Sale of Goods Act for clarification at times. • The spelling and grammar below is atrocious, but I couldn't be bothered to fix it.  • Good luck! Hopefully some of this is helpful. I. Introduction • This is mostly a common law course, since the SGA merely codifies as closely as possible the existent common law.  • US has replaced the SGA with the UCC, which is comprehensive and covers all of commercial law.  • The BC SGA also includes some material that is covered in the "Factors Act" in other jurisdictions • BC has the oldest version of the SGA in Canada o close to the original version • At its heart, commercial transactions is about buying and selling goods Property • May be real  • or Personal: "choses" o chattels real o Chattels personal ▪ chose in possession (goods), meaning things that are capable of being possessed ▪ chose in action (intangibles), which cannot be possessed or seized physically, like an an account or a debt.  • documentary intangibles (ie. a bank note), the document represents the intangible • pure intangible, which does not even have a document to represent it (increasingly common) Property Interests • ownership ...

Words: 46411 - Pages: 186

Premium Essay

Contracts Outline

...Part I: Principles of Contractual Obligation The Promise Principle and its Rivals A. Grounds for Enforcing Promises 1. FORMALITY Creation of a contract (§17): The formation of a contract requires a bargain in which there is a manifestation of mutual assent (offer and acceptance) to the exchange and consideration. a. When charitable promises are made without consideration or reliance there must be formality (evidence that the parties intended to be legally bound). (Deleo) i. Oral vs. Written ii. On death bed vs. more lucid with witnesses 2. BARGAINa. Consideration Elements (§71) i. To constitute consideration, a performance or a return promise must be bargained for. (§ 71(1))  Bargained for: sought by the promisor in exchange for his promise and is given by the promisee in exchange for that promise. (§71(2))(Whitten v. Greeley-Shaw: mistress; husband did not bargain)  Performance may consist of: (§71(3)) a) an act other than a promise; b) a forbearance (Hamer v. Sidway: no drinking deal w/ uncle) (Duncan v. Black: empty cotton suit); c) the creation, modification, or destruction of a legal relation ii. Warnings for a lack of bargaining (from Whitten):  The party proposing the contract also receives material benefit  One party is vulnerable and the other takes advantage of a duress-like situation b. Consideration as Motive (§ 81) i. The fact that what is bargained for does not of itself induce the making of a promise does not prevent it from being consideration for the...

Words: 11795 - Pages: 48

Premium Essay

Meaning, Characteristics and Types of a Company

...MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS AND TYPES OF A COMPANY INTRODUCTION Industrial has revolution led to the emergence of large scale business organizations. These organization require big investments and the risk involved is very high. Limited resources and unlimited liability of partners are two important limitations of partnerships of partnerships in undertaking big business. Joint Stock Company form of business organization has become extremely popular as it provides a solution to overcome the limitations of partnership business. The Multinational companies like Coca-Cola and, General Motors have their investors and customers spread throughout the world. The giant Indian Companies may include the names like Reliance, Talco Bajaj Auto, Infosys Technologies, Hindustan Lever Ltd., Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd., and Larsen and Tubro etc. 1.2 MEANING OF COMPANY Section 3 (1) (i) of the Companies Act, 1956 defines a company as “a company formed and registered under this Act or an existing company”. Section 3(1) (ii) Of the act states that “an existing company means a company formed and registered under any of the previous companies laws”. This definition does not reveal the distinctive characteristics of a company . According to Chief Justice Marshall of USA, “A company is a person, artificial, invisible, intangible, and existing only in the contemplation of the law. Being a mere creature of law, it possesses only those properties which the character of its creation of its creation confers...

Words: 114216 - Pages: 457

Premium Essay

Company Law

...LESSON : 1 MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS AND TYPES OF A COMPANY STRUCTURE 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.0 Objective Introduction Meaning of Company Characteristics of a Company Distinction between Company and Partnership Types of Company Summary Keywords Self Assessment Questions Suggested Readings OBJECTIVE After reading this lesson, you should be able to: (a) (b) (c) 1.1 Define a company and explain its features. Make a distribution between company and partnership firm. Explain the various types of companies. INTRODUCTION Industrial has revolution led to the emergence of large scale business organizations. These organization require big investments and the risk involved is very high. Limited resources and unlimited liability of partners are two important limitations of partnerships of partnerships in undertaking big business. Joint Stock Company form of business organization has become extremely popular as it provides a solution to (1) overcome the limitations of partnership business. The Multinational companies like Coca-Cola and, General Motors have their investors and customers spread throughout the world. The giant Indian Companies may include the names like Reliance, Talco Bajaj Auto, Infosys Technologies, Hindustan Lever Ltd., Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd., and Larsen and Tubro etc. 1.2 MEANING OF COMPANY Section 3 (1) (i) of the Companies Act, 1956 defines a company as “a company formed and registered under this Act or an existing company”. Section 3(1) (ii)...

Words: 114302 - Pages: 458

Premium Essay

International Business

...INDEX S.NO. TOPIC INDIAN CONTRACT ACT Nature and Kind of Contracts Offer and Acceptance of an Offer Capacity of Parties and Consideration Void Agreement and Contingent Contract Performance of Contract Discharge of a Contract Remedies for Breach of Contract and Quasi-contract Agency PAGE 2-10 11-22 23-34 35-49 50-62 63-72 73-81 82-99 SALES OF GOODS ACT Sales of Goods Act CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT Consumer Protection Act NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENT ACT Negotiable Instrument Act THE PARTNERSHIP LAW The Partnership Law THE COMPANIES ACT 1956 & COMPANIES LAW 2013 Companies Act 1956: Types of Company and Its Characters 101-127 129-140 142-167 169-191 193-211 Companies Act 1956: Memorandum, Article of Association and 212-239 Prospectus Companies Act 1956: Share Capital Companies Act 1956: Meeting Companies Act 1956: Management of the Company Companies Act 2013 240-275 276-302 303-340 341-364 THE CYBER LAW 2000 & AMENDMENTS IN 2008 CASES 0 MODULE-1 INDIAN CONTRACT ACT 1872 Chapters 1. Nature and Kind of Contracts 2. Offer and Acceptance of an Offer 3. Capacity of Parties and Consideration 4. Void Agreement and Contingent Contract 5. Performance of Contract 6. Discharge of a Contract 7. Remedies for Breach of Contract and Quasi-contract 8. Agency 1 The Indian Contract Act 1872: Nature and Kind of Contracts Learning Objectives In this chapter, students will come to know    What is an agreement and a contract? What are the essential elements...

Words: 151878 - Pages: 608

Premium Essay

Ip Ii Semester Syllabus

...SCHEME OF EXAMINATION & DETAILED SYLLABUS for BA LLB Five Year Integrated Course (w.e.f. 2008 – 2009) UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW AND LEGAL STUDIES Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University Kashmere Gate, Delhi – 110403 (With effect from the Academic Session 2008-2009) 1 FIVE-YEAR LAW COURSE BA LLB (H) PROGRAMME w.e.f. Academic Session 2008 – 2009 FIRST YEAR First Semester Paper Code LLB 101 BA LLB 103 BA LLB 105 LLB 107 LLB 111 BA LLB 113 BA LLB 115 SUBJECTS Legal Method History-I (Indian History) Political Science-I Law of Contract – I English and Legal Language Sociology-I (Introduction to Sociology) Economics-I (Microeconomic Analysis) Total Second Semester L 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 28 Credit 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 28 Paper Code LLB 102 BA LLB 104 LLB 110 LLB 112 SUBJECTS L 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 28 Credit 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 28 History – II (Legal History) Political Science – II Law of Contract – II Techniques of Communication, Client Interviewing and Counselling BA LLB 114 Environmental Studies BA LLB 116 Sociology-II (Indian Society) BA LLB 118 Economics – II (Macroeconomic Analysis) Total (With effect from the Academic Session 2008-2009) 2 SECOND YEAR Third Semester SUBJECTS L 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 28 Credit 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 28 Paper Code LLB 201 LLB 203 LLB 205 LLB 207 LLB 209 BA LLB 213 Business Law Family Law – I Constitutional Law – I Law of Crimes – I Advocacy Skills History – III (History of Modern Europe: 1740-1947) BA LLB 215 Political Science – III Total ...

Words: 26115 - Pages: 105