...My first argument is that monuments can never be neutral, they always mean or represent something. The word monument itself derives from the Latin word monere, meaning to remind and instruct. In terms of the Confederate monuments, they are making a political statement about the Confederacy in Civil War. Even though it was the side that lost, the ideologies that the Confederacy stood for have been carried through into modern day southern America, and this has been represented in the monuments that honour the dead Confederate soldiers and leaders. This means that the public space they are in is no longer public, it is claimed by the belief or viewpoint that the monument represents. To be public means to concern the people as a whole, to be seen...
Words: 1334 - Pages: 6
...Quetzalli Terrazas 11/25/17 Strategic Reading and Writing Essay #4 The altercation along the removal of Confederate monuments has been a boiling topic for politicians and US citizens. A dispute over the meaning of confederate history that white supremacist seem to have escalated considering the Charlottesville incident. The monuments have been reported to be an appreciation to the south during the Civil War era, where slavery was a central disagreement. Times have alternated and America has seemed to acknowledge the direct message them on humans have displayed, while some might argue on the fact that it is an honor to the confederacy and what it stands for. This prevents people to move on from the history and face the diverse change...
Words: 275 - Pages: 2
...statues are no longer a suitable representation. To continue to honor and preserve these leaders is an undoing of all the progress made to ensure equality. I believe all confederate monuments should be taken down. I believe the monuments should be removed because the most memorable actions of the confederacy was based upon slavery. The leaders were wealthy slave owner who relied heavily on the abuse, oppression, and labor of many blacks. The general Robert E. Lee was honored for publicly being opposed to slavery in his statements but his actions contradicted during the times he went beyond beatings and even went as far as to separate the families. The slave owners did not want to lose their wealth and production methods so they devised ways to coerce other farmers into fighting and ultimately dying for their cause. They would perpetuate that any black person was dangerous and a threat to their families; wanting to protect their families this would convince many farmers to join the cause....
Words: 471 - Pages: 2
...Madhuri Sathish states, “A 2016 report from the Southern Poverty Law Center identified 718 Confederate monuments and statues scattered across the country — and not all of them are found in Southern states.” A substantial number of people are protesting and arguing over whether or not we should keep the Confederate monuments or destroy them. The monuments have distinguished themselves as a huge part of our history, and the monuments demonstrate the fact that our country has not been ever been perfect. If we destroy our Confederate monuments, then we will not be able to remember all the great things that come from our history; preserving all parts of our past and our history is crucial to remaining strong as a nation. The argument for why we should remove the Confederate monuments has many valid reasons. Americans should not praise the South because they seceded from the country and started a civil war, these leaders could be considered traitors against the U.S. Constitution, because they advocating the state's right to own slaves. Bob Cesca in his article states, “Consequently, it became publicly acceptable — normalized, as we say these days — to have monuments to traitors against the...
Words: 663 - Pages: 3
...removal of Confederate Monuments has been a controversial subject over the past few decades. Citizens of The United States have had many different personal views about these monuments and statues. They have argued back and forth whether the statutes are better off being left up, or should be scrapped and replaced with a more suitable memorial. The people of America say these monuments are a part of history, and represent America’s past struggles and hurdles and serve as a testament to the pain of millions of Americans. And to a certain degree, they’re right. Some of the monuments represented the good in people. But most others are only hollow statues that are only facades put up to help show a narrative. They were put up to help spread...
Words: 819 - Pages: 4
...equality is underway. The recent events in Charlottesville, Virginia where a fierce fight between White Nationalists and Black Lives Matter protesters over the presence of Confederate monuments across Southern states has quickly revamped the conversation regarding the morality of having Confederate monuments...
Words: 846 - Pages: 4
...Memorials are important to people all over the world . People wonder why these memorials are so important but the only real answer is to help with the grievance process. The great people of america grieve everyday because of the lose of loved ones and become into a depressed state of being without an grieving process. A memorial is a structure of some sort to remind the people of a person or a event. Some people wonder why would you want to remember events that ended badly? The reason is if someone died for something they should be remembered not forgotten. With wars and such like the world war 2 or vietnam war there should be memorials since good people died . No matter how stupid it was to go to war people needed America’s help . Sadly...
Words: 270 - Pages: 2
...If the moment creates a turning point in our country then it should be memorialized. This proves that we show respect for the moments that create the land we live on and the people who surround us. Source B is showing the Christopher Columbus Monument in Riverside Park. This memorial is showing the man that "founded" America and giving tribute to the events and deaths that made us who we are. Memorializing these historical events based on the purpose and effect the moment has gives the memorial a strong pull to the...
Words: 680 - Pages: 3
...“Once you crossed the gate to the Camp , There was no chance to get out of there alive”.- Chaim Hirszman.Memorials and monuments show, in part, the ways that communities and people have answered these questions. The gallery of images below exhibits a variety of memorials and monuments that have been constructed to remember the Holocaust. The introduction that follows explores the complex questions that memorials raise about how we choose to remember history. Memorials raise complex questions about which history we choose to remember. Some people distinguish between the two, saying that memorials are a response to loss and death and that monuments are more commemorative and celebratory . “Thou shalt not be a victim, thou shalt not be a perpetrator,...
Words: 1314 - Pages: 6
...Memorialize “The Discussion of Monuments” As a matter of fact when building monument many things have to be taken into consideration; such as the location, the size, and the materials that they may use when they are building it. The reason why monument are so remembered is because of all the things that the builders take into consideration like the size of the monument they are building. The Abraham Lincoln is one of the most seen monuments because of the size and where it is at. Since the Abraham Lincoln monument is so important it shows that the builders had to take many things into consideration. People who built the monuments had to take many things into consideration when building a monument, like the size and place. If people take the location, size,...
Words: 1013 - Pages: 5
...Monuments are all around the world, and are made for a certain reason. They can represent things, or they can just show the culture and history of that place. They all stand for something significant like independence, a war, a great accomplishment, and much more. When you look at a monument, you begin to think of the situation that took place during that time. They are a symbol to that country, state, town or region and it is something big that went down in history. The Statue of Liberty is the upper New York Bay, on Ellis Island, and is a symbol of freedom. The Statue of Liberty is a monument that was a gift from France. It was given to America in 1886 to celebrate the friendship between them during the Revolutionary War. The statue stands...
Words: 792 - Pages: 4
...Monuments are a symbol of a considerable time in history. They represent life, death, success, and struggle. They transport the past lively to new generations, and good or bad memories to those who were present in that. Many people feel a well-built sense of loyalty and patriotism when they view a monument. Also, those monuments help bring out those feelings of nationalism. Millions of people from all over the world go to the city where they are building just to appreciate them. Monuments make people reflex and think about an important event. Some of them are places where people go to spend time with their families and to experiments new experiences. One of those national monuments that are very famous in the United States is called Poverty...
Words: 1003 - Pages: 5
...The French Revolution of 1789 brought an upset of the social order in France: monarchy and religion, the two institutions that had retained order and promoted the growth of a great society for decades, were rejected. It is not difficult to see Chateaubriand’s René as an allegory describing post-Revolutionary France and the predicaments that the Revolution brought to French citizens. Chateaubriand’s short interlude draws a parallel between René and France- both have been cut off from previous social order, which provokes a feeling of nostalgia. In René’s world, like in the new France, there is no connection to the former religious way of life or the traditional government. Even the title of Chateaubriand’s work can be seen as a metaphor for a need for return to the past due to the fact that René means reborn or born again in French. The title provokes contemplation for the renewal of pre-Revolutionary society. Furthermore, Chateaubriand focuses on lack of memory to point to the necessity for the rebirth and restoration of pre-Revolutionary French society. The first time there is a lack of memory in René, it occurs on an individual basis. On the very evening of the passing of René’s father the “indifferent passer-by trod over his grave”; “aside from his daughter and son, it was already as though he had never existed” (89). René’s father, a ruin of the past himself, stands as a symbol for pre-Revolutionary society. Just as the ideals and morals of pre-Revolutionary France -which...
Words: 1613 - Pages: 7
...heaven confronts the issues of hate , love and their battle to reign supreme. The young protagonist an inexperienced teen just learning to drive is killed in a tragic auto accident that also takes his mother and sister as well as a couple in an oncoming car. the accident is caused by his swerving into anotherlane to avoid hitting a little girl on a runaway trycycle in the antechambers of heaven , described in dazzling and delightful detail , there are monuments to great things done for god in this life. our young driver has an monument inscription ''greater love has no one than this to lay down one's life for one's friends''. To his heroic sacrifice of his own life to save the child he reflexively did what he could to avoid hitting the child , a good and natural reaction normally , but he sacrificed four other lives , just as valuable to god and others as that of the child without their consent , there is nothing heroic in this , just a tragic set of circumstances and certainly nothing to be rewarded for with an external monument in heaven. Overall i highly recommend this book because scriptures are used to support a interesting story about what god could hold in store for us in heaven. it also does a good job in telling how...
Words: 376 - Pages: 2
...Victoria Pompei Acts of terror during the Korea War Many visit the Washington Mall without ever having seen the Korea War memorial, which is indicative of how misunderstood the Korea War is, hence its other name : The Forgotten War. Overshadowed by the Lincoln monument just a few feet away, this memorial commemorates the American men who served during the war that took place between 1950 and 1953. Nineteen stainless steals statues stand in a triangle form, surrounded by bushes and on their right a wall representing the 38th parallel. These statues evoke feelings of sorrow and anguish unlike any other monuments on the Mall, but what it fails to do is recall the lives lost due to acts of terror committed by US troops during that time....
Words: 507 - Pages: 3
