Free Essay

Cyrano de Bergerac

In:

Submitted By benhollett
Words 871
Pages 4
Argumentative Essay Imagine that you have an obscenely large nose; you would most likely be self conscious or embarrassed. This is in most cases true for Cyrano. The play Cyrano de Bergerac, written by Edmond Rostand, takes place in the 1600’s in Paris France. It displays the main character, Cyrano, who is in love with the woman Roxane but is disappointed after realizing that his love for her is not mutual. Although in some cases Cyrano’s huge nose brings him pride, the majority of the time it brings him pain. Cyrano’s nose causes him a lot of pain when interacting with other people. This is evident during his first real encounter with Roxane. Cyrano becomes extremely nervous and anxious when he learns that Roxane wants to meet with him. Roxane begins describing all the qualities of the man she loves to Cyrano during their meeting in Ragueneau’s pastry shop. At this point Cyrano is extremely excited because all of them are fitting his own description. This is true until she says, “His face shines with wit and intelligence. He’s proud, noble, young, fearless, handsome…”(Cyrano 2.6.77). Cyrano stands up quickly with a stricken expression and it is here that he realizes that it is not him that Roxane loves. This causes a lot of pain to Cyrano because he is rejected for his unattractive nose. Cyrano’s pain is enhanced when she tells him that he is her best friend. Cyrano is not anticipating this and realizes that he will not have a chance with Roxane. It is reasonable to say that if Cyrano were to have a more normal nose, Roxane’s description will fit Cyrano exactly. After this point in the story, Cyrano has a completely different attitude and becomes very depressed. When Le Bret tries to ask about his meeting with Roxane, he is very quick to deny him and not answer. This first interaction with Roxane is the worst thing Cyrano could imagine and it causes him a lot of pain. Cyrano goes through a lot of pain again when people criticize his nose. Christian does exactly this to prove his courage to the other Cadets. Cyrano tells his story to the Cadets of how he fought 100 men. During his story, Christian begins to interrupt him countless times to make jokes about his nose. After he is furious, he gets up and furiously goes towards Christian and asks who he is. Carbon says he is Christian and Cyrano replies “Oh!” his face takes an expression of shock, then anger and he makes a movement as though to attack Christian. “I…” he controls himself and speaks dully “Very well… as I was saying…” (Cyrano 2.9.96). The reason for Cyrano not attacking Christian is due to the promise that he made to Roxane to protect him. This is extremely hard for Cyrano to stay relaxed and not fight him because he is used to fighting anyone that even looks at his nose. He is facing a huge internal conflict whether or not to fight him or to keep his promise. He goes against his instinct to fight, and chooses to keep his promise. Cyrano feels a lot of pain while Christian was making nose jokes. Other people may believe that Cyrano’s large nose brings him pride rather than pain. This is evident when Cyrano gets in an argument with the meddler. Cyrano tells the meddler “I carry it with pride and that a big nose is a sign of affability, kindness, courtesy, wit, generosity and courage” (Cyrano 1.4.37). Cyrano feels a lot of pride due to his nose because he is the only one with a nose that big and he claims that it brings out those desirable traits. Another scenario where Cyrano’s nose makes him proud is when Cyrano makes up at least 20 jokes about his own nose. Valvert makes an attempt to make fun of Cyrano’s nose and Cyrano turns it around on him. He tells him that he does not have any wit and therefore cannot even make a good joke about him. Cyrano makes Valvert look a like a fool for even trying to make an insult and results in making Cyrano proud. However, there are far more instances where his nose is looked down upon causing him to feel pain rather than him being proud of it. A large nose alone cannot bring about the traits of wit, affability, kindness or courage. They must be achieved so this statement does not prove that his nose brings him pride. Many fights break out with him and others due to them giving his nose just a quick glance. It can reasonably be concluded that Cyrano’s nose evokes much more pain than pride. From the information given, it is obvious that Cyrano’s nose evokes much more pain than pride. The many scenarios that Cyrano goes through show that his nose is an encumbrance. From almost killing a man to sitting still accepting the criticism, there is always a strong negative result when regarding his nose. Having and enlarged nose will result in most cases with strong negative feedback.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Essay On Cyrano De Bergerac

...Cyrano de Bergerac is a play that was written by Rostand Edmond in the 1800s, but the story took place in the 1600s. The play tells the story of an odd love triangle between three of the main characters, Cyrano, Christian and Roxane. According to modern literary definitions of a comedy and a tragedy, a comedy can be described as one where, “the protagonist succeeds in his or her goal,” or one where, “a story treats the characters and situations in a humorous manner and the novel ends happily for the protagonist.” A tragedy is described as one that, “end unhappily for the protagonist,” and one in which, “the protagonist fails in his or her goal.” Throughout the story, aspects of both can be seen, but overall, the story is more of a tragedy....

Words: 1144 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Roxane In Cyrano De Bergerac

...In the play entitled Cyrano de Bergerac, the principal character, Cyrano, falls in love with his precieuse cousin dubbed as Lady Roxane. Unfortunately, as a result of his substantially prolonged nose, Cyrano is seen by others as unsightly, despite the numerous prodigious skills he possesses. Due to this insecurity, Cyrano’s ability to confess his affection towards Roxane is sadly obstructed. Whilst Roxane becomes infatuated with an immensely handsome (but rather dull-witted) nobleman named Christian in the beginning of the play, her conception concerning her love interest(s) gradually enhances as one progresses through Cyrano de Bergerac. Attributable to her grand alteration in both maturity and disposition, her love in relation to Cyrano ought to be irrefutable as opposed to Christian’s....

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cyrano De Bergerac Analysis

...While reading Cyrano de Bergerac, I always wondered whether or not Cyrano had a happy life. Because Cyrano’s happiness and self-worth is the focus of this essay. Was he happy? I can’t say for sure. If I look at his life, it seems that he never really got Roxane because he always sacrificed his happiness for the others and he also felt his ugliness was the cause of not getting Roxane’s hand. I really feel he did not care about his happiness. In that, he did not sacrifice it, as he split and divided it when he saw it was the best action. To an even further extent, this spiting of himself probably came from his low self-worth, not only his nose, but Roxanne. Since Roxanne thought a man was handsome and smart Cyrano stopped loving Roxanne on...

Words: 547 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Cyrano De Bergerac Analysis

...In the story Cyrano de Bergerac the twisting love story between a love triangle is emotionally crazy. 3 peoples love for each other will affect them all. Everyone has a different type of love. The characters in this book all have different types of love and they don’t even know it. Arguing Cyrano's’ love is the spiritual type of love will be difficult but here’s why. In the beginning Cyrano describes his love for Roxane but feels as if he is too ugly for her. Reminding you of his unusually large nose. He tries to look or think of plans to make himself more admirable. “The simplest -- to make myself in all things more admirable”. (47) Throughout this book there he will say how he feels through poetry and with that it shows his love for Roxane...

Words: 853 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Cyrano de Bergerac vs. Roxanne

...Cyrano de Bergerac vs. Roxanne Shahaan Farrukh The play Cyrano de Bergerac and the modernized movie Roxanne draw many parallels with each other, a major one, of which, are the characters. Only four of the main characters are modernized into this movie, Le Bret into Dixie, Christian into Chris, Roxane into Roxanne, and most blatant, Cyrano and C.D. Bailes. These characters have equivalent traits but have differences that actually make some significant changes in the formula of the play. Although Cyrano and C.D. Bailes have many similarities and have the nose to reflect their exuberant personality, Bailes is not true at heart the Cyrano that we know in the play. Throughout the play it is evident that pride is very important to society especially to Cyrano, but in the movie Bailes tended to basically fight only when provoked. The difference being as Le Bret tells Cyrano in one scene in the play that his confidence, pride, and his own tendency to provoke people brought him lots of enemies. There is no scene in the movie like in the play’s opening where Cyrano was the one who started all the ruckus, beginning with Montfleury and leading to fights both physically and verbally. None of which would happen if he just let the crowd enjoy the play. This makes sense given that the movie is a modernization into a society where that type of pride is less abundant. It would be also much less likely for Cyrano to ask anyone to “fix” his nose, because that pride also would not allow...

Words: 662 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Rostand's Cyrano De Bergerac

...Harris. Cyrano de Bergerac is a fictional play written by Edmund Rostand, which portrays the life of a real person called Savinien Cyrano de Bergerac, who lived in France in the early 1600s. The author Rostand (1858 - 1918), was a playwright and poet. Edmund Rostand is famously known for his classical work of literature and drama: the magnificent Cyrano de Bergerac, and other works such as Les Romanesques, which was his first play, La Princesse Lointaine, La Samaritaine, and L'Aiglon, which was a play about King Napoleone’s hair. Edmund Rostand was elected to the French Academy at the age of thirty-three...

Words: 1423 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Cyrano De Bergerac Characters

...Cyrano de Bergerac Essay In Cyrano de Bergerac there are many character arcs. This movie shows many changes in the characters. The greatest character arc is Christian. Christian has the greatest character arc for many reasons. Christian changes throughout the story in many ways. The first way is that he is shy and doesn’t want to tell Roxanne he loves her. He changes this action because after Cyrano starts writing his letters for him, he wants to talk to Roxane by himself but just doesn’t know how to do it. The second and final way he changes is he wants to tell Roxanne he didn’t write any of the letters and that Cyrano loves her more than he does. Christian changes because of Roxane. At the start of the movie he was shy and didn’t talk...

Words: 262 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Edmond Rostand's Cyrano De Bergerac

...Edmond Rostand’s play Cyrano de Bergerac is a play that was created during the Romantic era. During the Romantic era, people looked back at the works of Shakespeare and borrowed the characteristics from his writings. Shakespeare’s plays were full of emotions, action, and passion. Cyrano de Bergerac contains these characteristics, especially because Cyrano loves Roxane, but Roxanne likes someone else. Roxanne even asks Cyrano about the man she likes, which causes Cyrano to become sad. Lastly, there is a fencing scene that has a lot of action because of the quick movements, and because Cyrano cuts the loser on his face. The set and costumes are very realistic. They are important to the play because accuracy was important during the Romantic...

Words: 288 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Edmond Rostand's Cyrano De Bergerac

...In the discussion of Edmond Rostand’s Cyrano de Bergerac my classmate illuminated the meaning of the rankings. We learned that the cardinal was very powerful and second in rank to the king. This fact led me to the realization that when the cardinal was mentioned it was seen as both respectable and impressive. In addition, we discussed that De Guiche is a Count which is a middle class ranking. While, Cyrano is just a guard which is a low military ranking. Therefore, this furthered my understanding that their conflict also encompasses class struggle. Additionally, a classmate started the discussion on the difference in the time the play was set and the time period it was written. Cyrano de Bergerac takes place in 17th century France. This was...

Words: 336 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Is Cyrano De Bergerac Romanticism

...In Cyrano De Bergerac by Edmond Rostand, the character of Cyrano's defining trait is his romanticism, due to its role as a significant motivator of his actions as well as the cause of much of his internal conflict. When explaining his motivation in kicking the actor, Montfluery, off his stage, Cyrano explains to Le Bret, "I've hated him since the day he looked at... It was like watching a slimy slug crawl on a flower!" (Rostand 49) When he trails off he is referring to the woman he loves, Roxane, whom he imagines is so pure Montfluery should not even gaze upon her. This demonstrates how his deep sensitivity to beauty and romance drive him to defend those he loves, even if that person does not know of his actions or if the threat...

Words: 314 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cyrano De Bergerac Tragic Hero

...In Edmond Rostand’s play Cyrano de Bergerac, loosely based off of 17th century french Cyrano de Bergerac, it is about a skilled swordsman, a romantic poet, and a physically grotesque man with beautiful words. Because Cyrano’s insecurities, he is unable to truthfully profess his love to Roxane, causing him to use Christian, a handsome soldier whom Roxanne is in love with, as a proxy between him and Roxanne. Despite Rostand defining this play as a heroic comedy, Cyrano holds many characteristics that define him as a tragic hero. According to Aristotle's idea of a tragedy, it is when the story ends unhappily for the protagonist. In addition, in order for a character to be defined as a tragic hero, a character must arouse pity from the audience,...

Words: 1276 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Cyrano De Bergerac Tragic Hero Essay

...fear but not every hero depicts those certain characteristics. In the classic play, Cyrano de Bergerac by Edmond Rostand, Cyrano, a swordsman and romantic poet, represents the qualities found within a tragic hero. Cyrano lacks self-confidence and ends up living more of an unfulfilled life knowing he fights a war within himself than against enemies, therefore he dies as a tragic hero in the end. To begin, Cyrano sets an excellent example of what qualities a tragic hero obtains and how those qualities apply to the decisions Cyrano make throughout the play that potentially lead to a dreadful denouement. In the beginning, Cyrano hides the fact that he struggles to accept his one and only obvious flaw, that being his nose. As a result, Cyrano acts as if he is superior to other who appear to challenge his authority such as the meddler who came to simply judge Cyrano’s looks and Cyrano is quick to acknowledge his nose by addressing,”For a great nose indicates a great man- / Genial, courageous, intellectual” (Edmond Rostand 29). Cyrano is commonly mistaken as an easy target but due to his cockiness, Cyrano simply humiliates whomever just to see his or her reaction since he views himself as an stupendous individual. Also, Cyrano portrays prosperity from the start of the...

Words: 967 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Edmond Rostand's Cyrano De Bergerac

...In the romantic comedy Cyrano De Bergerac, written by Edmond Rostand, there lived a tremendously beautiful woman named Roxanne. The people in Paris loved and/or wanted to be her, for she had most of the men there falling to their knees, including Christian and her cousin, Cyrano. Cyrano, a romantic hero, as brave and as charming as he acted, only had one flaw, his colossal nose. Even though he loved Roxanne, she did not notice. She was to busy falling head over heels for the immensely attractive Christian, the new individual in town. Too worried that he would ruin everything between him and Roxanne, due to his inability to talk to women, Christian convinced Cyrano, who could woo the ladies with just a rhythmic word, to write letters for him to Roxanne making her believe that Christian was a poetic genius, unknowing that this would be a secret they would carry with them for the rest of their lives....

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Play Cyrano De Bergerac

...Cyrano de Bergerac journals The play Cyrano de Bergerac written by Edmond Rostand starts with everyone waiting to see the play La Clorise. The reader gets to meet, Cyrano, a very well know man who is a poet, playwright and a member of the Cadets. Despite his many talents, Cyrano is described as a very unattractive person, with an incredibly large nose. His nose makes him feel insecure and because of it believe that he cannot be loved back by Roxane, his cousin and the woman he loves. “She might laugh at me; That is the one thing in this world I fear!” (Cyrano, 42). This shows the reader just how self-conscious he is of his nose. He is afraid that because of his nose Roxane will not love him back and, criticize him for it. The quote also...

Words: 288 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cyrano De Bergerac Analysis

...In the play Cyrano de Bergerac, Cyrano is in love with Roxane but he doesn't want Roxane to know how much he loves her because he is scared and insecure that she will not love him back. “Through my nose? She might laugh at me; That is the one thing in this world I fear!” pg.50 Roxane claims to be in love with Christian and Christian claims to be in love with her but he isn’t the brightest so Cyrano offers to help him write to Roxane and help Christian sound intelligent, so Roxane will fall in love with Christian. Cyrano uses this as a way to express himself to Roxane and how much he loves her without Roxane really knowing its Cyrano talking to her. All Cyrano wants if for Roxane to be happy so he writes as Christian and makes Christian look like the perfect guy Roxane imagined him to be. Cyrano is selfless when it comes to...

Words: 694 - Pages: 3