Free Essay

Diamond Foods Inc: Fraudulent Walnut Prices

In:

Submitted By raka1978
Words 1287
Pages 6
Main Facts
In February 2010, Diamond Foods Inc.’s then-Chief Financial Officer Steven Neil asked his team of accounts an unusual question. How much could the snack-food company pay for walnuts that year and still top Wall Street estimates? According to the complaint released by the Securities and Exchange Commission, the answer was 10 cents less than the expected 82 cents that the company was expected to pay. To cover the difference, Mr. Neil devised a plan to put the extra cost into the following year which all the company the report better-than-expected results.
The alleged fraud gave the company a string of earning beats and a strong rise in its stock. It also allowed Diamond Foods Inc the necessary currency needed to clinch a deal to buy the Pringles snack brand from Proctor and Gamble for $2.35 billion. Everything unraveled after the Wall Street Journal and some skeptical investors questioned the company’s accounting.
According the Diamond Foods Inc, they conducted an internal investigation and ultimately restated its finances for the 2010 and 2011 fiscal years. The restated numbers showed the stock price per shared dropped from $90 a share to $13 a share. The fraud also had a negative impact on acquiring the Pringles snack brand. Diamond fired Mendes and Neil in early 2012 and restated its earnings after an internal probe concluded that the accounting was improper. (Hamilton, 2014)
On January 9th 2014, the Securities and Exchange Commission charged Diamond Foods and its former SFO in an accounting scheme to falsify walnut costs in order to boost earnings and meet estimates by stock analysts. The SEC also charged Diamond’s former CEO for his role in the company falsifying financial statements that were filed with the SEC.
Diamond Foods agreed to pay $5 million to settle the SEC’s charges. Former CEO Michael Mendes also agreed to settle charges against him. The SEC’s litigations continue against Neil.
Diamond Foods Fraud and the Fraud Triangle According to the SEC complaint, Neil was facing pressure to meet or exceed the earnings estimates of Wall Street stock analysts. With sharp increases of walnut prices in 2010, Diamond now had a situation where it needed to maintain longstanding relationships with walnut growers by paying them more. Yet Diamond could not increase the amounts paid to growers for walnuts, which was its largest commodity cost, without also decreasing the net income that Diamond reports to the investing public. (SEC, 2014) Faced with this pressure, Neil had the opportunity to orchestrate a plan to have it both ways. He created two special payments to please Diamond’s walnut growers and bring the total yearly amounts paid to growers closer to market prices. He excluded portion of those payments from year-end financial statements. To cover up the plan, Neil instructed his finance team to consider the payments as advances on crops that had not yet been delivered. By disguising the reality that the payments were related to prior crop deliveries, Diamond was able to manipulate walnut costs in its accounting to hit quarterly targets for earnings per share (EPS) and exceed estimates by analysts. (SEC, 2014) Neil also misled Diamond’s independent auditors by giving incomplete and false information to justify the unusual accounting treatment for the payments. Neil personally benefited from the fraud by receiving bonuses in the amount of $875,00 and incentive compensation in the amount of $1.1 million because of the EPS that was stated in fiscal years 2010 and 2011. Mendes also personally benefited from the fraud by receiving approximately $1.4 million in bonuses and $2.6 million in incentive compensation. The company benefited from the fraud by being able to have the funds to bid for the purchase Pringles. According to Neil, he followed Diamond Foods long-standing practice and accounting treatment approved by the company’s outside auditors.
My Thoughts Regarding Diamond Foods Fraud I think the main reason Neil committed this crime was because he was under pressure to achieve what stock analyst had predicted the company’s EPS would be. Knowing that the new cost of walnuts had risen, he knew that he could not achieve that goal. He came up with a scheme to achieve that goal but he went overboard. His accounting team should have blown the whistle on him in the very beginning. The fact that he made up two special payments without the approval from the audit team should have been a cause for concern. The omitting half of the payments from the financial should have been a red flag for his team and someone should have reported him immediately. Not only the CFO and the CEO be punished for this crime, but so should his accounting team. I think it speaks volumes on the accounting team’s work ethic and integrity. In regards to very close acquisition of Pringles, I do not think it was part of the reason to commit the fraud. I think the acquisition was just a ripple effect of the fraud. The company thought that it had enough money to purchase Pringles and the company went for it. If it was not for Neil and the fraud he committed, I do not think the company would have thought twice about purchasing Pringles. Neil increased compensation and bonuses were also a ripple effect of the fraud. I do not think that receiving extra money was his main concern. Neil seemed more worried about the company’s well being than his own well being.
Fraud Prevention
The fraud could have been prevented if more controls were put in place. For example, in changes in how accounting is done, should be first be approved by an outside auditor. According to an article, certain checks could have also been performed to help prevent Diamond Foods from cooking the books. The examples listed in the article are a balance sheet check, accrual ratios and the manipulation score.
Does the Punishment Fit the Crime? In my opinion, since Diamond Foods settled, I do not think the punishment was enough. The fact that both the CEO and the CFO only had to pay back a portion of the earnings received due to the fraud is outrageous. I think they should return all funds they received during the period of the fraud plus interest. I also think that Diamond Foods should be accountable for pay all of the losses that investors accrued during the time of the audit. Lastly, I also think that company and its audit team should be on probation with the SEC. This “slap on the wrist” is not letting the company know this is a very serious crime and that it will not be tolerated. I think it leaves the door open for future fraud cases because they have seen that you will get off easy for the first offense. References
Hamilton, W. (2014, January 9). Diamond Foods agrees to pay $5 million to settle SEC case. Retrieved October 20, 2014, from LA Times: http://articles.latimes.com/2014/jan/09/business/la-fi-diamond-foods-fraud-20140110
Henning, P. (2012, February 13). Next Steps in Diamond Foods Accounting Inquiry. Retrieved October 20, 2014, from NY Times: http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2012/02/13/next-steps-in-diamond-foods-accounting-inquiry/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0
Jun, J. (2012, January 20). Could You Have Predicted Diamond Foods Accounting Fraud? Retrieved October 20, 2014, from Old School Value: http://www.oldschoolvalue.com/blog/valuation-methods/could-you-have-predicted-diamond-foods-accounting-fraud/
SEC. (2014, January 9). SEC Charges Diamond Foods and Two Former Executives Following Accounting Scheme to Boost Earnings Growth. Retrieved October 20, 2014, from SEC: http://www.sec.gov/News/PressRelease/Detail/PressRelease/1370540598296#.VE1cu5RdXgs

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Diamond Foods Accounting Scandal

...Diamond Foods Accounting Scandal BACKGROUND: Founded in 1912 as a walnut grower cooperative, Diamond Food’s primary business involved buying walnuts from local California growers, processing the product, and reselling it. The San Francisco-based company converted from a cooperative to a public corporation in July of 2005, issuing its initial shares for $17. By 2010, Diamond Foods (DMND) had expanded and acquired a number of snack food companies including Kettle Brand® Chips and Pop Secret® popcorn and was negotiating the acquisition of the Pringles brand from the Procter & Gamble Company (Diamond Foods, 2014). The addition of the Pringles brand would make Diamond the second-largest global snack foods company behind PepsiCo, Inc., owner of the Frito-Lay brand (Byron & Ziobro, 2011). Although the new ventures took precedence, Diamond’s walnut business remained the highest commodity cost to the company. In order to maintain relations with the growers, Diamond had to assure they offered a competitive price for the product; however any recorded increase in walnut price would decrease both the company’s reported earnings and their reported earnings per share (EPS). Despite rising walnut prices, the company consistently posted EPS that defied analyst projections. Between the 2010 SEC Form 10-Q second quarter filing and the SEC Form 10-K of FY 2011, the price of Diamond stock jumped from $39 dollars per share to $90 per share (SEC, 2014). On January 9, 2014, the Securities and...

Words: 3150 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Strategy Management

...CONNECT FEATURES Interactive Applications Interactive Applications offer a variety of automatically graded exercises that require students to apply key concepts. Whether the assignment includes a click and drag, video case, or decision generator, these applications provide instant feedback and progress tracking for students and detailed results for the instructor. Case Exercises The Connect platform also includes author-developed case exercises for all 12 cases in this edition that require students to work through answers to assignment questions for each case. These exercises have multiple components and can include: calculating assorted financial ratios to assess a company’s financial performance and balance sheet strength, identifying a company’s strategy, doing five-forces and driving-forces analysis, doing a SWOT analysis, and recommending actions to improve company performance. The content of these case exercises is tailored to match the circumstances presented in each case, calling upon students to do whatever strategic thinking and strategic analysis is called for to arrive at a pragmatic, analysis-based action recommendation for improving company performance. eBook Connect Plus includes a media-rich eBook that allows you to share your notes with your students. Your students can insert and review their own notes, highlight the text, search for specific information, and interact with media resources. Using an eBook with Connect Plus gives your...

Words: 219639 - Pages: 879

Premium Essay

Freakonomics-Expanded

...FREAKONOMICS A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything Revised and Expanded Edition Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner CONTENTS AN EXPLANATORY NOTE In which the origins of this book are clarified. vii PREFACE TO THE REVISED AND EXPANDED EDITION xi 1 INTRODUCTION: The Hidden Side of Everything In which the book’s central idea is set forth: namely, if morality represents how people would like the world to work, then economics shows how it actually does work. Why the conventional wisdom is so often wrong . . . How “experts”— from criminologists to real-estate agents to political scientists—bend the facts . . . Why knowing what to measure, and how to measure it, is the key to understanding modern life . . . What is “freakonomics,” anyway? 1. What Do Schoolteachers and Sumo Wrestlers Have in Common? 15 In which we explore the beauty of incentives, as well as their dark side—cheating. Contents Who cheats? Just about everyone . . . How cheaters cheat, and how to catch them . . . Stories from an Israeli day-care center . . . The sudden disappearance of seven million American children . . . Cheating schoolteachers in Chicago . . . Why cheating to lose is worse than cheating to win . . . Could sumo wrestling, the national sport of Japan, be corrupt? . . . What the Bagel Man saw: mankind may be more honest than we think. 2. How Is the Ku Klux Klan Like a Group of Real-Estate Agents? 49 In which it is argued that nothing is more powerful than information,...

Words: 105214 - Pages: 421

Premium Essay

California an Interpretive History - Rawls, James

...CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA An Interpretive History TENTH EDITION James J. Rawls Instructor of History Diablo Valley College Walton Bean Late Professor of History University of California, Berkeley TM TM CALIFORNIA: AN INTERPRETIVE HISTORY, TENTH EDITION Published by McGraw-Hill, a business unit of The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 1221 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020. Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Previous editions © 2008, 2003, and 1998. No part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior written consent of The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., including, but not limited to, in any network or other electronic storage or transmission, or broadcast for distance learning. Some ancillaries, including electronic and print components, may not be available to customers outside the United States. This book is printed on acid-free paper. 1234567890 QFR/QFR 10987654321 ISBN: 978-0-07-340696-1 MHID: 0-07-340696-1 Vice President & Editor-in-Chief: Michael Ryan Vice President EDP/Central Publishing Services: Kimberly Meriwether David Publisher: Christopher Freitag Sponsoring Editor: Matthew Busbridge Executive Marketing Manager: Pamela S. Cooper Editorial Coordinator: Nikki Weissman Project Manager: Erin Melloy Design Coordinator: Margarite Reynolds Cover Designer: Carole Lawson Cover Image: Albert Bierstadt, American (born...

Words: 248535 - Pages: 995

Premium Essay

Kkswmddkmdkemwekdemkedmkdemkmdkmdkew

...MODERN DATABASE MANAGEMENT / JfFFREY A. HOFFER . Warehousing Success 426 Data Warehouse Architectures 428 Generic Two-Level Architecture 428 Independent Data Mart Data Warehousing Environment 426 429 C O NTENTS Dependent Data Mart and Operational Data Store Architecture: A Three-Level Approach Logical Data Mart and Real-Time Data Warehouse Architecture 432 Three-Layer Data Architecture 435 Role of the Enterprise Data Model 435 Role of Metadata 436 Some Characteristics of Data Warehouse Data Status Versus Event Data 437 Transient Versus Periodic Data 438 An Example of Transient and Periodic Data 438 Transient Data 438 Periodic Data 439 Other Data VVarehouse Changes 440 The Reconciled Data Layer 441 Characteristics of Data after ETL 441 The ETL Process 442 Extract 442 Cleanse 444 Load and Index 446 Data Transformation 447 Data Transformation Functions 448 Record-Level Functions 448 Field-Level Functions 449 More Complex Transformations 451 Tools to Support Data Reconciliation 451 Data Quality Tools 451 Data Conversion Tools 452 Data Cleansing Tools 452 Selecting Tools 452 The Derived Data Layer 452 Characteristics of Derived Data 452 The Star Schema 453 Fact Tables and Dimension Tables 453 Example Star Schema 454 Surrogate Key 455 Grain of Fact Table 456 Duration of the Database 456 Size of the Fact Table 457 Modeling Date and Time 458 Variations of the Star Schema 458 Multiple Fact Tables 458 Factless Fact Tables...

Words: 80097 - Pages: 321

Free Essay

Test2

...62118 0/nm 1/n1 2/nm 3/nm 4/nm 5/nm 6/nm 7/nm 8/nm 9/nm 1990s 0th/pt 1st/p 1th/tc 2nd/p 2th/tc 3rd/p 3th/tc 4th/pt 5th/pt 6th/pt 7th/pt 8th/pt 9th/pt 0s/pt a A AA AAA Aachen/M aardvark/SM Aaren/M Aarhus/M Aarika/M Aaron/M AB aback abacus/SM abaft Abagael/M Abagail/M abalone/SM abandoner/M abandon/LGDRS abandonment/SM abase/LGDSR abasement/S abaser/M abashed/UY abashment/MS abash/SDLG abate/DSRLG abated/U abatement/MS abater/M abattoir/SM Abba/M Abbe/M abbé/S abbess/SM Abbey/M abbey/MS Abbie/M Abbi/M Abbot/M abbot/MS Abbott/M abbr abbrev abbreviated/UA abbreviates/A abbreviate/XDSNG abbreviating/A abbreviation/M Abbye/M Abby/M ABC/M Abdel/M abdicate/NGDSX abdication/M abdomen/SM abdominal/YS abduct/DGS abduction/SM abductor/SM Abdul/M ab/DY abeam Abelard/M Abel/M Abelson/M Abe/M Aberdeen/M Abernathy/M aberrant/YS aberrational aberration/SM abet/S abetted abetting abettor/SM Abeu/M abeyance/MS abeyant Abey/M abhorred abhorrence/MS abhorrent/Y abhorrer/M abhorring abhor/S abidance/MS abide/JGSR abider/M abiding/Y Abidjan/M Abie/M Abigael/M Abigail/M Abigale/M Abilene/M ability/IMES abjection/MS abjectness/SM abject/SGPDY abjuration/SM abjuratory abjurer/M abjure/ZGSRD ablate/VGNSDX ablation/M ablative/SY ablaze abler/E ables/E ablest able/U abloom ablution/MS Ab/M ABM/S abnegate/NGSDX abnegation/M Abner/M abnormality/SM abnormal/SY aboard ...

Words: 113589 - Pages: 455