Free Essay

Distrust in Health Care

In:

Submitted By kealiagrace
Words 1016
Pages 5
According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, trust is defined as having a belief in something or someone that is honest, good, and dependable. Having trust in any relationship is vital but especially important in regards to the patient and physician dynamics. Certain past experiences can influence a person’s trust in the health care system and a negative experience can impact their ability to trust and receive effective treatment. Throughout history African Americans have been subjected to racism and discrimination in which these past experiences can be pasted down from generation to generation effecting their beliefs in the health care system. Experimentation on slaves and the Tuskegee Experiment are just a couple of negative experiences to impact African Americans and their trust in physicians and health care in general that continue to this day. Mistrust in the health field for African Americans stems from numerous events, one being that of the experimentation on slaves. Back in the day when the white population owned slaves, they were subjected at times to very painful and unethical experimentation. In the South African Americans filled hospital beds where they were used as dissection experiments to help doctors perfect their practice in the medical field (Harris, Gorelick, Samuels, & Bempong). They were also used to test new techniques and remedies. One such example is that of a slave named Fed. Fed was “secured in an open pit in the ground that was then covered and heated to test which medication enabled him to withstand heat. Each session ended when Fed finally succumbed to the heat and fainted” (Harris, et al.). Slaves were also used to test the safety of vaccines, which was obtained by injecting them with certain diseases such as small pox. Distrust in health care only continued post slavery and into the 1930s with the Tuskegee Experiment. African Americans feared they would be tested on had they had to enter a hospital and the Tuskegee Experiment only proved their fears to be correct. The Tuskegee Experiment was a government-sponsored study in which they took 600 black men from Macon County, Alabama; 399 had syphilis and 201 did not have the disease. Researchers told the men that they were being treated for “bad blood” but in reality they were not given the appropriate treatment for their disease once penicillin became the preferred drug of choice for treatment in the late 1940s (CDC, 2013). The study was suppose to only last six months but continued for forty years. The Tuskegee Experiment only reinforced African Americans distrust in health care that continues to the present day. Trust is important in any relationship but especially important with the relationship that a patient and physician has. Without trust the patient will not be willing to do such things as disclose their full medical history, want to partake in any physical exams, or follow any recommendations for follow-ups, tests, or treatments. Having a lack of trust does not allow for effective treatment of any patient. Without trust patients may be less likely to even visit a physician when they are sick which in return can affect their over all health. They will exhibit “less doctor-patient interaction, reduced adherence to recommendations, worse self-reported health, and reduced utilization of health care services; thus, Blacks’ relatively lower trust in the health care system puts them at a greater risk of all these negative outcomes” (Musa, Schulz, Harris, Silverman, & Thomas, 2009). Exuding trust thus allows for all services to be used and better patient satisfaction. If trust is not had for the health care system, patients will be less likely to see a physician and untimely creating lower life expectancies for themselves. The United States health care system has not been too kind historically to the African American population. They have been subjected to multiple events of discrimination throughout the years. Once the Tuskegee Experiment was put to an end because it was found to be ethically unjustified a lawsuit soon followed. A settlement was reached in 1974 that resulted in the government promising to pay lifetime medical expenses along with burial services to those men who participated in the study. A year later the program that was established to give the men benefits (The Tuskegee Health Benefit Program) expanded to their wives, widows, and children (CDC, 2013). African Americans are considered to be a minority in the United States and research shows that minorities have poor access to health care services. The Office of Minority Health was established to help secure a usual source of care for minorities, which would allow for better management of care (Shi & Singh, 2013). The office is imperative because it “plays a role for other federal agencies and the minority health initiatives they support. The programs developed at both the federal and state levels provide extensive services that address some of the key pathways leading to racial disparities..” (Shi & Singh, 2013, p. 265). In 1998, President Clinton launched the Radical and Ethical Health Disparities Initiative. It was aimed to eradicate racial and ethnical disparities in such cases as “infant mortality, diabetes, cancer screening and management, heart disease, AIDS, and immunizations” (Brooks, 1998). Programs and initiates such as these allow for minorities to be able to get equal care no matter what their race is or their background. In conclusion, trust plays such a vital role in the health care system. Negative events have a tendency to be pasted through generations affecting the ability to get proper care. African Americans have endured their fair share of discrimination through out time such as experimentation of slaves and the Tuskegee Experiment, all of which has lead to their distrust in health care. Having a lack of trust does not allow for proper care of any individual, as they would be less likely to seek medical attention when needed. This lack of care can compound into worse health and eventually a lower life expectancy. With initiates set up through the government and states, health care is readily available to African Americans and other minorities to allow everyone the ability to access proper health care.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Building Trust

...contribute to why most of the population distrusts the healthcare system, such as trustworthiness, trans cultural communication and cultural competence. “Distrust in the health care system is relatively high in the United States, between twenty and eighty present of people distrust the Health Care System.” (Armstrong, Rose, Peters, Long, McMurphy & Shea, 2006). Gaining trust with a physician and/or a doctor is essential, because, “…Trust promotes communication, timely care, healing, patient loyalty to physicians, less litigation, and adherence to treatment recommendations.” (Kosoko-Lasaki, Cook & O’brien, 2009, p. 41). Language barriers are an obvious effect of communication and building trust. The United States commonly use the language of English, but that’s not always the primary language for other nationalities and cultures. Some techniques that the author would use to over come the language barriers would be to speak slower, ask for clarification, check for understanding, be more specific, be patient and lastly choose an effective communication skill such as, an follow up email which the patient would state what they understood in the previous meeting. Another method would be showing examples like pictures or drawings, that would help the patient visually comprehend. Secondly, cultural and religion barriers. “Health professionals should be aware of cultural and religious beliefs that may affect the way they relate and care for some patients.” (Kosoko-Lasaki, Cook...

Words: 585 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Specialized Population

...Why specialized population distrust the united state health care system To begin with elements that are part of distrust in the health care system Are also seen as specialized population. These groups of individuals that fit in this category are the homeless, rural areas, underserved, immigrants, and the disable or handicap, elderlies and the mental disorders individual that have the most impact in getting health care or receiving health services, medical treatment for their illness, diseases and preventive care needs. Secondly, what elements contribute to this disadvantage populations in having distrust issues in the health care system? Are discrimination acts or indifferences in cultural diversity, poverty or classification asset level, unaware or in alerted to public safety and health services, uninform of current illness or diseases affecting society their signs or symptoms of this medical conditions. Also lack of communication barriers and challenges, and lack to access to health care and medical treatment because of inefficiency and miscommunication or misinform do to communication barriers and cultural differences. These effects are community, society and populations in many ways because many deaths could be avoided or prevented if we would reach out to the underprivileged or underclass and set aside our indifferences or disbelief and treat them as any other human being with respect , integrity, and dignity. all humans deserve to be informed ,treated equally...

Words: 837 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hlt 205 Week 3 Complete Latest

... the health care professional, and the health care system form a relationship in which each is dependent upon the other. What is the significance of trust in this relationship? Describe the ethical framework for establishing “trustworthiness.” Cite references to support your response. HLT 205 Week 3 Topic 3 Discussion 2 View the video clip, “Cultural Diversity in Health Care”: http://library.gcu.edu:2048/login?url=http://digital.films.com.library.gcu.edu:2048/PortalPlaylists.aspx?aid=12129&xtid=43850&loid=125382 . After watching the video, explain how you would go about overcoming cultural differences in order to gain the trust of patients from different populations. HLT 205 Week 3 Assignment Gaining Trust With Cultural Disparities Details: For this assignment, you will apply critical thinking to what you have learned up to this point in this course regarding the successes and failures of the U.S. health care system as it relates to issues of cost, access, and quality. You are expected to address these topics from the perspective of a medical professional that is both ethical and respectful. Select a vulnerable population as described in your textbook and complete a 1,000-1,250 word paper that addresses the following: 1. Describe elements that contribute to this population’s distrust of the health care system and/or medical treatments. Why is trust important? Can we effectively treat a patient whose trust we do not have? Why? 2. Discuss how the U.S. health care system...

Words: 1537 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Trust Factor

...are many elements that contribute to the specialzed populations’ distrust of the healthcare system. A few of them are trustworthiness, trans cultural communication, and cultural competence. Knowing more about these elements will help to break down the distrust of the healthcare system and help to build up more trust which is extremely important because when there is no trust, patients do not seek preventative care or specialty care. According to Cook, Kosoko-Lasaki, and O’Brien (2009) trust and distrust play significant roles in the interactions with in the healthcare system (p.16). This trust drives the frequency of the interactions between the culture and healthcare professionals. Trust can also be generational deriving from family members past experiences, also from others within the culture and this can affect future relationships within a particular group. Just like distrust can drive down interactions trust and increased understanding can increase a cultures competence. Trustworthiness can go a long way in helping clients and healthcare as a whole. Cultural competency has been attempting to improve starting at the caregiver and institutional levels. Policies have been made to heighten the sensitivity awareness when caring for others. “A big challenge to the adoption of cultural competency education is that no single method or body of knowledge has been proven to be the most effective for educating health professionals”(Cook et al, 2009, p21). There have been no daily...

Words: 1286 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

What Spiritual Issues Surrounding a Disaster Can Arise for Individuals, Communities, and Health Care Providers? Explain Your Answer in the Context of a Natural or Manmade Disaster. How Can a Community Health Nurse

...effects can include: distrust in the community, hopelessness for individuals, and a sense of struggle for health care providers. Spirituality is an aspect of life that is important to some and non-important to others. In my personal opinion, we all have some form of spirituality and sense of being within us, even though it may be blocked out consciously and emotionally from someone. Disasters can change someone obviously physically, but internally as well. Disaster can cause a sense of impending doom that can come and go after the disaster has ended. This may lead someone to lean on spiritual aspects, or it may cause the reverse and enable someone to change their beliefs and initiate negativity and hopelessness. Communities can develop a sense of distrust in each other, in their faith, and in their future. The spiritual strength that held a community together previously to the disaster could become disrupted and can result in complete chaos and misunderstanding. For healthcare providers, the aspect of spirituality can be brought to light quickly when being involved in a disaster. The feelings of sadness, despair, and grief from viewing trauma to innocent individuals may cause healthcare providers to seek religious and spiritual healing to restore their faith and guidance. Understanding an individual’s view on spirituality and its possibility to help an individual heal is necessary, especially in a time of disaster, regardless of the cause. A community health nurse can assist...

Words: 425 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

...AFFORDABLE CARE ACT Tammy R. Carr Grand Canyon University: HCA-675 April 2, 2014 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act was signed into law by President Barack Obama in March of 2010. This law provides equal access to medical care, lowered health care costs and eliminates denial of coverage of pre-existing conditions to the millions of the uninsured and insured Americans that were without and denied health care coverage. Patients who were denied coverage due to pre-existing conditions can now look forward to relief and great improvement because their illness is covered in the new policy, and care is now provided for them at next to minimal cost (Stehly, 2014). The PPACA is set up to provide and ensure equal access to medical services to all Americans that are signed up for the insurance. One aspect of the PPACA that seems to be a great asset to the health care reform is that it will allow for extended coverage to children that remain under the care of their parents’ insurance until the age of 26 (University, 2014). This provision is a gap closure for those who are still in college and may be looking for employment. The PPACA will be a godsend to many families that have been denied medical insurance or medical coverage due to poverty, not being able to financially afford services for the whole family or pre-existing medical conditions. Those services can be limited only being in the form of free general medical care that...

Words: 1119 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Still Alice Reflection

...shifting of our ideologies, highlighted in this weeks readings regarding our health care system, has challenged my own ideologies towards what our health care system should be modeled towards. I believe it is immoral to have a system that benefits from the chronically sick, but, what I think is even more disturbing is how this privatized model does little to care for its patients and instead treats our bodies health like a ‘routine’ or a machine. On the one hand our current system tells us to “take the blue pill and live with your chronic disease” while the other hand says to “take the red pill so we can see the effectiveness of our new miracle drug!”. What our health care system is lacking is a patient-centered health care model that cares for patients like human beings instead of test subjects. What I found most intriguing about this weeks reading is how we have been tricked into believing that the “New Right” ideology is morally based and has nothing to do with increasing the profits of big corporations. In fact some of us are led to believe that corporate interests lie within improving our lives with ‘fancy new medical machines’ and ‘high tech’ facilities, along with new miracle drugs that ‘make it easier to live’ with our newly developed chronic diseases. We have internalized the notion that our health care system is the best, and changing the status quo or returning to pluralist care systems (which are ‘socialist thoughts’ by todays standards) would be immoral...

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Racial Disparities In Health Care

...Health disparities are defined as unequal burdens in disease morbidity and mortality rates which are often experienced by the minority racial/ethnic groups. In today’s population ethnic and racial disparities exist for various and intricate reasons, which has grave impacts on an individual’s access to health care. These disparities have been around for several centuries and continue to be problematic despite the little progression being made with the revisions of preexisting health care laws. Laws and regulations are continually being revised to allow further health insurance expansions in hopes to reduce the ethnic and racial disparities for access to adequate care. Even with the increase in awareness, policymakers and clinicians have...

Words: 1320 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Health Care Cost

...TO: Council Members FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Rising Health Care Cost Health care in America is in crisis. Health care costs are skyrocketing. This problem is not new, nor is the recognition of it. The size, complexity, and political clout of the health care industry political distrust, particularly among people who are currently well insured and geographic diversity in spending, coverage, and delivery systems have frustrated past reforms. Furthermore, health reform means income redistribution among payers and across service providers. Health insurance premiums have doubled in the last 8 years, rising 3.7 times faster than wages in the past 8 years, and increasing co pays and deductibles threaten access to care.i_ The medical expenditure rate is now increasing more rapidly than ever, and control of medical costs has reemerged as a major national imperative. Failure to solve this problem has resulted in most of the other critical defects in the health care system. Least investment in primary prevention and public health: America faces epidemics of obesity and chronic diseases as well as new threats like bioterrorism. Yet despite all of this less than 4 cents of every health care dollar is spent on prevention and public health._iii Many Americans are uninsured because of rising insurance costs: Over 45 million Americans lack health insurance.iv_ Even those with health insurance are struggling to cope with soaring medical costs. Increased healthcare costs are making it difficult...

Words: 347 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Applying Ethicak Framework in Practice

...2013 Applying Ethical Frameworks in Practice Care providers strive to provide care that is patient focused that maintains confidentiality and respect. This paper is about the maintenance of patient confidentiality and the trusting relationships that must be maintained between the patient and the healthcare providers. Ethical Implications of Breaching Confidentiality Patients seek care and treatment in hopes of receiving confidential, unbiased, honest, and respectful treatment. They also expect that care providers maintain their personal values and beliefs related to their care. As healthcare providers, everyone has the responsibility to uphold the confidentiality of patients. Patient confidentiality includes information about the patient that is collected based upon what the patient reports and what the physician enters in the medical record. In a situation where confidentiality has been breached, serious implications can arise. A breach in confidentiality can result in a failure to respect patient's autonomy and poses a form of betrayal (Ministry of Ethics, 2012). The betrayal that can result in legal implications such a HIPPA violations but an even greater ramification can be the distrust of the patient and family in the caregiver and the healthcare system. Patients may also question the care provider's true intentions including values and morals. They may also question if the patient is truly the center of care. Breach of confidentiality can result in a non-trusting...

Words: 1140 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Barbara Ehrenreich's Nickel And Dimed

...The electric bill is at least $100 a month; hopefully you don't have to pay for water bill or trash. A cell phone bill is at least $75, if you have any emergencies away from home, especially with children you will need a cell phone, people survive without these but it’s very hard. Health insurance, $300 on the cheap end, some has it paid through their employer and kids with the state, but most people aren't so lucky. A vehicle is at least $150 a month on the cheap end or some pay in cash so you don't have to pay a monthly bill. Vehicle insurance is around $60 and fuel is at least $150 monthly. Basic groceries are around $300; most low income single parents are on WIC which provides formula and other healthy products for their infants. Child care is the biggest expense for many parents with young children, ahead of housing and food. Although the federal government provides some child care, for the parent who doesn’t make a high income is still paying a lot out of their pocket for child care, most of the paycheck is going toward child care...

Words: 1040 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Doctor Martin's Office

...Summary of Findings The Professor felt ill and decided to go home but during the drive he experienced discomfort and in the succeeding hours experienced severe diarrhea and persistent nausea and vomiting. Eventually the nausea ceased but his stomach was still upset. The following day he called Dr. Martin, his primary health care physician. Betty, the doctor’s nurse assisted him over the phone and after the professor explained his condition she told him that Dr. Martin cannot see to him because of his packed schedule. The professor asked for a referral to go to the HealthCheck Clinic but the nurse declined claiming that Dr. Martin is not willing to send him there and was instead prescribed with medicine for the diarrhea. The prescription was placed in the pharmacy for the professor to pick up. Unsatisfied, the professor called up Candy, the director of the Employee Benefits Office, but Wendy picked up and relayed everything to Candy who then expressed her surprise and distress over the situation. She too did not understand that the request for a referral was denied as the professor asked for it. The professor picked up the medicine from the pharmacy, drove home, took a pill, and went to bed. The following day the diarrhea was under control but the gastric discomfort was still a problem. He decided to go to work but in the afternoon he gave up and went home. He called Dr. Martin’s office and once again Betty answered the phone. She informed him that the doctor is out all...

Words: 1928 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Missouri Department Of Health And Senior Services Case Study

...The mission of the Missouri Department of Health and Senior Services is to be the leader in promoting, protecting and partnering for health. The Missouri Department of Health and Senior Services seeks to “improve the health and quality of life for Missourians of all ages” by providing: information and education effective regulation and oversight quality health services surveillance of diseases and conditions Why was the company started? In 1883, several epidemics, such as smallpox and cholera, threatened Missourians. were threatening the citizens of Missouri. Physicians started a campaign pushing for a state agency that would be responsible for helping with the prevention of disease. As a result, the Missouri legislature created a State Board of Health. Over time, the organization has been reorganized a handful of times and is now called the Missouri Department of Health and Senior Services, which combines services for seniors and overall public health issues. Core values The Missouri Department of Health and Senior Services provides care for Missourians in the areas of disease control, food and product safety, environmental factors, and wellness and prevention. Furthermore, the department places emphasis on accountability, collaboration, commitment, communication, diversity, excellence,...

Words: 1750 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Tuskegee Experiement Case Study

...Biomedical and Behavioral Research. This group identified basic research principles and con-ducted ways to ensure the rules are followed. Voluntary informed consent from all persons was key for anyone doing research funded by the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (now HHS). In addi-tion, institutional review boards had protocols to decide whether ethical standards were met. Human sub-jects rules were revised constantly. In 1980, the President Commission for the study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research and ensured that rules are followed (please ex-plain)An Ethics Advisory Board was formed in the late 1970s to review ethical issues of biomedical re-search. Lastly, 16 federal agencies in 1991 adopted the protection of federal policy for the protection of human rights. Ethical standards of research continue to be updated to ensure highest standards today (Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC),...

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nursing

...perspective of health care are those people who have many health issues that are exposed to more than average risk in terms of, physical, psychological, or social health. The main victims of Vulnerability are the elderly. The elderly are more susceptible to functional deterioration and therefore need special support and medical attention in the health care context.  Caring for elderly people, especially those with medical problems can be nerve-racking, and that can combine with other stressors, such as financial or marital problems, and will further cause caregivers to become neglectful .In the long run caregivers become encouraged to send their old folks to medical facilities or senior homes. Elderly people, like many young people prefer to stay at their own home that is made up of treasured memories; they feel a sense of belonging at their own home than a senior home. In my culture caring for elderly people in their most difficult time of their lives is considered an honor and a blessing and an opportunity for great spiritual growth.  In my culture it is not enough that we only check up on our elders like parents, grandparents, aunts, and uncles, but we act with limitless compassion, are kind, and are patient with them. We always try to remember that when we were helpless children, they were patient with us, gave us their love and preferred us to themselves.  As a nurse, there are instances I forget the confines of the elderly and look at them with distrust and abhorrence...

Words: 373 - Pages: 2