Premium Essay

Do Illegal Immigrants Help or Hurt the Economy

In:

Submitted By saliani
Words 2477
Pages 10
Argumentative Research Paper
DO ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS HELP OR HURT THE ECONOMY
There are several people who exist in this country, who are legally unwelcomed, but they find a way to maneuver themselves into the economy. These people are known as illegal immigrants. They do not follow the established legal migration procedures of this country and resides in this country without proper visas or other documents (Illegal Immigrants). Illegal immigrants are sometimes referred to as illegal aliens or undocumented workers. Though many people may dismiss illegal immigrants as a strain on the economy because they take American jobs, increase the U.S crime rates and drain health care resources; illegal immigrants contribute to the economy as workers, taxpayers, and consumers.
The first invasion of illegal immigrants, into the United States was during World War II. Countless, Americans left the Country and went overseas to fight for the freedom of our nation. Several Mexicans saw this as an opportunity and illegally entered the United States to take advantage of employment opportunities, especially as agricultural laborers. “Most of those who worked in the farm fields of California during the 1930’s were illegal immigrants known as Okies, a term applied collectively to the hundreds of thousands of migrants who poured out of not only Oklahoma but also Texas, Arkansas, Missouri, Kansas, and Colorado. By the end of World War II, there were close to two million illegal immigrants living in California, Arizona, and Texas” (McGrath 1-2). Also, “An official estimate in 2007 put the number of undocumented immigrants living in the United States at 11 million to 12 million; many believe that the true figure is much higher than this. A high proportion of these, particularly from Mexico and other Latin American countries, are labor migrants” (Policy & Practice 1). The number of illegal

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

How Does Illegal Immigrants Affect The Economy

...Illegal Immigrants Hurt our Economy Our nation has often been referred to as a “melting pot”, which is one of the many great things about America. Many people come here for a better life for them and their families and everyone deserves the freedoms and opportunities that America has to offer. As a great nation, laws are in place for the greater cause of our people, meaning that lawbreakers are typically punished and dealt with accordingly; However, it doesn’t seem to hold much truth in today’s immigration laws. Today’s economy is hurting more than ever. With our growing unemployment rate, and our depleting funds, it doesn’t make much sense to keep letting the economy and it’s legal citizens suffer because of lawbreakers. Illegal immigrants are hurting our economy by taking unrightful employment, placing a financial burden on the economy, and lowering the social system of the United States. Illegal Immigrants take the jobs that should be given to our legal citizens. As a result, many American citizens are losing their jobs, while many others are competing for the jobs that illegal immigrants hold illegally.“ Some research estimates that nearly two million Americans a year are displaced by immigration” (Federation for American 2). With Americans losing their jobs at that rate and being replaced by the growing number of illegal immigrants, the...

Words: 802 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Immigration

...big problem. The ongoing problem is what are we going to do about illegal immigrants. According to Oxford English Dictionary, immigration is “the action of immigrating; entrance into a country for the purpose of settling there” (OED). Immigration is a very hot topic in the United States today. There have been many debates and discussions about the issue in regards to if immigration is beneficial to our country or if it’s not. There are millions of illegal immigrants in the country today. Many people think that these immigrants area big problem for our economy and other factors of the government. In reality these people have been doing the opposite. Immigration is all over the country and you have more than likely encountered some before. Immigration is a very important topic for a reason. The United States has been running well because of it but then again these immigrants are stealing many Americans jobs to an extent. There are many positive benefits that come from immigration. These include an increase in demand, more investment, increased operation, and more jobs being taken (Nadadur 1041). These all affect the economy of the United States in a positive way. Demand for jobs is increased because of the incoming flow of people that are looking for jobs. They come to America with the intent of getting a good job and being able to support their family. These jobs might not always be the best jobs but they still get to do more than they could at homeland country. Investment will...

Words: 1059 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration Understanding

...English 1A/ Conklin MW 11:00 – 1:00 5/1/08 Illegal Immigration Understanding We read: French President Nicolas Sarkozy says, “America did not say, ‘Come, and everything will be given to you.’” Instead, he said, "Come, and the only limits to what you will be able to achieve will be those of your own courage, your boldness, and your talent” (qtd. in “Speech,” pars.12). Sarkozy is correct about the American ideal, it has driven millions of people here for the past 200 years. because this ideal is what drives millions of people since the first settlers came in 1492 to America. For some immigrants, this drive for a better life is so strong that they risk and sacrifice their lives in their attempts to attain it. For example, some immigrants are willing to come to America illegally. Norbert Santana, a writer for The Orange County Register, writes “the U.S. Bureau of Labor, the Pew Hispanic Center and the Center for Immigration Studies generally agree there are about 12 million unauthorized immigrants in the U.S.” (pars. 18). There is no accurate method of counting how many illegal immigrants actually live in America; however, there are enough here to cause conflicts. Some illegal immigrants come to America for a few years to make money, and then they take their fortunes back home, while others come to live and to raise their families. All of these immigrants are unwelcome by many Americans because they perceive the immigrants illegal entry into the United States (U.S.) as a blatant...

Words: 1929 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Health Care Reform

...Solutions to Illegal Immigrants Impact on Health Care Solutions to Illegal Immigrants Impact on Health Care The effect of immigration on health is controversial. “In recent history, large influxes of immigrants have not resulted from social benefits provided by the United States government. Rather, immigration increases are far more impacted by changes in immigration policy or by political conflict or natural disaster in the immigrants’ home countries. And the availability of direct economic incentives, jobs, prospects, higher wages, and the ability to send money back home, are more than enough to continue incentivizing immigration to the United States regardless of the status of health insurance” (Garg, 2010, p. 1025). Illegal immigrants do not have health insurance coverage; their primary resource for health care is by using emergency room services. Illegal immigrants often use emergency services because of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act of 1986. This act commands hospitals that offer emergency services to exclude certain ones, have to provide care to anyone needing emergency health care regardless of legal status or ability to pay. Undocumented immigrants are overrunning medical institutions with their inability to pay. Uncompensated care threatens the financial viability of a unit’s ability to provide care to other patients. Illegal immigrants are a burden to the United States health care economics. Is it an ethical and moral responsibility for...

Words: 1147 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Competition Between Immigrants and Natives for Low-Wage Jobs

...The competition between immigrants and natives for low-wage jobs Among all nations, immigration is always a hot topic especially in the Untied States because the country is highly mixed with people from different nationalities. Immigration contains two kinds of immigrants, legal and illegal. Undocumented immigrants that come to the U.S. under the low are illegal immigrants. Their presence come into notice by people who naturally born in the U.S. Some people say that illegal immigration is a great stimulation that can improve the economy in many ways. For example, immigrants quickly fill the low-wage jobs which employers need, and spending the money back to the economy by purchasing products to live off. Others say that illegal immigration reduces wages for native-born Americans since the immigrants are taking over the low-wage jobs and willing to work even for lower wage. I say that even though illegal immigration has some undeniably positive economic effects, the impact on the working poor is negative. Even the illegal immigration generally helps economic growth, it hurts native working poor who live in poverty in the U.S. indeed. These days, more and more people try to come to the U.S. illegally to try to get better opportunities for jobs or make a better living. They quickly fill in low-income jobs, and work hard with lower wages than native-born Americans. It makes employers hard to reject them because the intense competition in the U.S. economy; they need to find a cheaper...

Words: 1039 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration in America

... Mr. Martin Adv. 100 June 23, 2013 Illegal Immigration in America One of the most controversial political issues today is illegal immigrants. Illegal immigrants is a serious problem that has to stop, because it is unfair to the people here in America. Illegal immigration is also unfair for the country that the immigrant left. It is public knowledge that the majority of the illegal immigrants in America come from Mexico. This is a problem that must me stopped as it hurts America’s economy and tax paying citizens. Illegal immigrants live off tax payers, take jobs and housing of hard working citizens, and leave there country of birth without skilled workers and help leave their own country into poverty. Legal American citizens pay taxes that help support welfare, health care, public schools and many other social services, many of which are taken advantage of by illegal immigrants. Illegal immigrants do not have to pay as many taxes as citizens do, illegal immigrants don’t have to pay social security. This isn’t fair to Americans. I personally don’t care if people migrate here I just want them to have to pay taxes just like everyone else. Illegal immigrants need to abide by the same laws as Americans. If a child is born in America, even if the parents are illegal, the child is a American citizen, making this child a burden to the state to make sure the child receives adequate care. So...

Words: 1843 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Research Paper

...Newton Research Project April 12, 2016 English 120 Research Should illegal immigrants be granted a path to citizenship in the United States? This is a major topic in todays politics and is one that many have different views on. The most talked topic today is the Syrian refugees and whether or not United States should accept these people into our country and let them gain citizenship and also if by letting them enter our country is hurting our economy. So this is a major headline in our country as to let them in or not. In today’s presidential views with the current candidates running for office many of them have very different views and some many citizens find aggregable while some of the plans seem outrageous and foolish to some. Immigration whether that’s illegal or legal and also refugees was a big problem in the US but is now currently the most talked about topic as it is affecting jobs, taxes, political stances, and the economy as a whole and is something that our country needs to fix and address in hope we resolve this issue. During the WWI immigrants and being “illegal” was a huge factor as to whether or not to keep the Jews or kick them out as what was happening while Hitler was in rule in Germany and parts of Europe. A major controversy that many other countries have during this time and even some to this day have, is what the United States policies were on immigration and also the illegal ones from Nazi Germany into our country. Beginning in around 1940 the United...

Words: 3139 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Persuasive Essay On Illegal Immigration

...Coykendall Illegal immigrants from Mexico have been coming into America for a better life for hundreds of years. Many people believe that illegal immigrants are bad people. They think that they are trying to take over America. However, most immigrants aren’t bad people at all they are nice and loving and are looking for a better life. We should support immigration to our country for the people that are looking for freedom and to better themselves but should have safety screening to keep our country safe. The immigrants are real people also and they have families to take care of. They are just any other family and should be treated as so. Infact one of the biggest reasons they come into America is because they want a better life. Sometimes they come to America because their homes in Mexico are bad. Some of them barely have roofs on their houses, they have bad drinking water or no water at all, and some families even have to search the dump for food or things to sell just to support their families. They want to make things better so badly that they are willing to get shot to get here. We need them and they need us for many other reasons. There are already about 8 million illegal...

Words: 561 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration Benefits

...There's a very large population of illegal/ undocumented immigrants in the U.S today and it has upset some and others think it's a good thing. As you look into how many immigrants are behind the scenes of making your food or why there’s always an option for Spanish dialogue or why presidential candidate Trump says they bring in rapist and murderers, what does immigration actually mean to the nation. To what extent is illegal immigration a burden or a benefit to the U.S. economy? If it's a benefit who does immigration actually burden? Immigrants have throughout the history of America been very well welcomed, but this recent spurt of illegal immigrants have been largely controversial to the nation. The information i found proved that these illegal...

Words: 1386 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Immigration Reform

...Almost 350,000 immigrants sneak into the United States illegally each year. Typically these people immigrate to the United States in hopes of finding employment to support their families. Once here, about 70% of them will obtain employment. The jobs that illegal immigrants occupy are the lower end jobs, which hurt unemployment rates especially for the lower class. Illegal Immigrants costs the United States about 113 billion each year. These costs are spread out over our education system, medical care, judicial system, and more. The information presented in this research paper will address the seriousness of this issue. Illegal immigration has a negative impact on the United States in many ways. Immigrants have entered our country illegally and stolen millions of jobs, crippled a struggling education system, manipulated welfare programs, and drastically raised crime rates. Without immigration reform, the crippling effects of illegal immigrants will break this country. With illegal immigrants willing to work for less pay and in poor work conditions, they negatively impact employment rates. Illegal-immigration has a negative impact on the available jobs for U.S. citizens. People often protest that the illegal immigrants do the jobs that Americans don’t want to do. However, that is not the case. They are able to work for low wages and in poor conditions, where citizens must follow minimum wage and labor laws. The more employers use illegal immigrants for cheap labor...

Words: 1876 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration

...The United States has been known as the “nation of immigrants”, but only legal immigrants really help our country to thrive. Most illegal immigrants come to America for good reasons, to live the “American Dream” and help their families, but most don’t know that they are putting the U.S. in greater debt and putting all of its citizens in danger. “More than 10 million undocumented aliens currently reside in the U.S., and that population is growing by 700,000 per year.” Illegal immigrants put our security at risk, raise the costs for the US, and raise crime rates; they fill up prisons, get free education, and get free emergency medical services, even though they are not citizens. Background: Most claims-makers who believe that illegal immigration is good for the country are economists looking at the economic factor of having illegal immigrants. These economists agree, “that the U.S. economy is larger, and growing faster, due to the supply of illegal immigrants, and that most Americans with higher job skills are better off for their presence” and that without them the country’s workforce would decline a few percentages. They want to prove that it is good that we have illegal immigrants in our country and that they are helping our economy, but that is only a small aspect of how they effect the United States. The fact is that “About 85.5 of every 100 new workers are new immigrants in this decade” and “we've ignored that illegal immigration has put a lot of young adults into economic...

Words: 1699 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Undocumented Immigrants

...I: Dr. Moon October 26, 2015 There are a lot of undocumented immigrants who come to the United States (US) for a better life for themselves and families. As it is shown on a circle graph by Cynthia S. Becker in 2005, “immigrants come from different countries; for example, 6.2 million 56% come from Mexico, 2.5 million 22% come from Latin America, 1.5 million 13% come from Asia, 0.6 million 6% come from Europe and Canada, and 0.4 million 3% come from Africa or other countries” Birthplace of illegal immigrants in U.S., 2005 (2007). These undocumented immigrants should be allowed to stay in the US for a variety of reasons. These reasons are, immigrants help boost the nation’s economy, it helps families access health care, and families maintain united. First, undocumented immigrants help boost the nation’s economy. One may ask why or even how? The immigrants who come here, come for one purpose, to make money. According to Bluestein, “From 1996 to 2011, the business startup rate of immigrants increased by more than 50 percent, while the native-born startup rate declined by 10 percent, to a 30-year low. Immigrants today are more than twice as likely to start a business as native-born citizens” Bluestein, A. (2015). If it were not for some of the undocumented immigrants, the US would probably not have a majority of jobs. Second, having undocumented immigrants in the US help families access health care. Many families do not have healthcare due to not having any legal documents or money...

Words: 1017 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration Research Paper

...In America, illegal immigration has since 2009 and the great recession been stable and has slightly decreased. And illegal Mexican immigrants have declined the most. Also, more Mexican immigrants and illegal immigrants have been leaving America than coming in. Most of them are leaving to reunite with their families, and others are leaving because they have found jobs or been deported. Illegal immigration nowadays is more coming from Central America and Asia. Even though most of the illegal immigrants living here are from Mexico, there isn’t a mass wave of illegal immigrants from Mexico that some people say it is (Preston) Illegal immigrants benefit the economy with by increasing our GDP. Meanwhile, if we deported all illegal immigrants it would...

Words: 253 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Citizenship for a Better America

...Citizenship for a Better America Introduction The United States of America has a long history of being a nation of immigrants. From the Native Americans, whose ancestors immigrated over the Bering Sea Land Bridge over 10,000 years ago during the last Ice Age, to people showing up today, from long oppressed parts of the world, we are made up of people who are descended from, or are from, different parts of the world. Many people have come here for a better life for themselves and their loved ones, and many have succeeded, driving more people to come to the United States of America and be able to “live the American Dream”. Many who come to the United States today, come without following the legal methods as they find that they either cannot afford them or cannot bare to wait the time that it takes to enter the United States legally. For these people, in particular, life can be a struggle and can also be full of fear, anxiety and stress due to their undocumented status. The people may be known by a variety of terms, such as; illegal alien, undocumented, undoc, unauthorized, illegal immigrant, undocumented immigrant. Many of these people would be difficult to distinguish from everyone else as they live in a home, drive a car, go to a job, go to school and participate in the community. These people even pay taxes, through are often excluded from reaping the benefits of the taxes that they pay. There are many who feel that they should be deported and there are many that...

Words: 1695 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Pros And Cons Of Immigrants

...Deporting Immigrants There are around 11 million or more illegal immigrants in the United States today. Mother Jones Writes, “Immigrants are worried at this time because they might be deported” (Jones 3) back to Mexico for not having documents to be here in America. Illegal immigrants should not be deported because they are valuable for the economy; by having immigrants working in the United States it allows the working industry to be more productive. Allowing immigrants to work high-skill and low-skill jobs it can lead to increased economic growth and aid society. A lot of immigrants live in America to get a better job or any job that can be available. Because immigrants are seldom hired for corporate jobs and are paid minimum wage most...

Words: 843 - Pages: 4