Free Essay

Economic Mobility

In:

Submitted By TOYAASSETS
Words 831
Pages 4
Yallander Ford
Eng 101-113
Prof. Susan Horowitz
April 4, 2012

This idea of economic mobility, which is defined, as one’s ability to move up the economic ladder by means of hard work and a good education, is an idea deeply entrenched in the Psyche of the American society. It is taken for granted that once you obtain a college education and have a good work ethic, you will move through the economic rank. However, this premise is being severely challenged and by all accounts, not holding up. This is a point reverberated by both Holly Sklar in her piece “The Growing Gulf Between the Rich and the Rest of Us” and the publication “The Economist through their piece “Inequality and the American dream.”
Holly dismisses this idea by pointing out the fact that we have become a downward rather than an upward mobile society. This is quite evident when you examine the growing gap between the rich and the rest of us. She points out that median household income has fallen for the fifth year running, while at the other end of the spectrum the opposite holds true. She argues that to make it in the Forbes 400, one would have to amass $900 million, an increase of $150 million from four years ago. Sklar states they are bringing windfall profits to companies like Bechtel while they suspend regulations that shore up wages for workers. This is based on the no-bid contract given to father and son team Bechtel, although they had budget overruns and performed a shoddy job on a prior government project. Personally I notice many small businesses are struggling. Many of them would like the opportunity to receive a no-bid project so they can accumulate some earnings. But this opportunity has been disbursed to an already wealthy American.
While the basic premise of “The Economist” is that the present model works fine, it too cannot ignore the highly ever widening gap between the rich &poor. Hence, it contradicts itself. On the one hand it argues that the model is productive, prosperous and it’s one of the most effective in accumulating wealth. On the other hand, He emphasizes that many Americans are not happy with the model. Research shows that it is easier for poorer children to rise in society in European Countries than in America. The article states that the United States only meritocracy is its education system. The only probably with the education system is that it is unfair. I agree because based on experiences, in many poor neighborhoods, there is a lack of resources available for public schools. For example my sister, a NYC Board of Education teacher who teaches at a middle school for technology, hence the name technology. She just received a smart board for her classroom this year and she has been teaching for 5 yrs. Walking into the school you would not recognized that this was a technology based school. The technology aspects of the classrooms are missing. The economist complicates matters further when it mentioned Democrats who are afraid to defend this issue. They are not willing to offend the paymasters in the teacher’s union. This is a very cold-hearted move on the Democrats part. It fails the Poor Americans who cannot speak for themselves.
Both articles support the issue of Economic Mobility. They have similar views when it comes to the Rich and Poor. Although “The Economist” agreed with the American model, it questioned some of the irregularities of the American Model. Most definitely some of its practice needs to be reevaluated. The poor should benefit from the economy as well. Sklar makes it known that being rich in America is a benefit and for poor Americans the fight to reach upward is challenging. The Economist also emphasizes on the point that meritocracy is not practice as it should be. The school systems are failing the students. They are not receiving a fair and evenhanded education. In comparison to Sklar, “The Economist” focused more in depth on ways the system can improve economic upward mobility. Sklar focused on the rich moving upward and poor losing their place in society. While I agree with both articles, I cannot collaborate with the statement that the American model is a good one.
In conclusion, since it has been long established in America that if you work hard and get a good education you are almost certain to raise your economic profile and guarantee an opportunity to make a better life. I can go under the assumption that this meritocracy that once was believed to be one of the great systems of America is moving further away from the truth. The poor are losing the battle in economic mobility, instead of moving upward we are moving downward. Imagine no matter how educated you are, the fact is if you start out in the bottom 10% of society that’s where you will remain. The rich progress, while we regress.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Income Mobility: Up & Down the Economic Ladder

...Income Mobility: Up & Down the Economic Ladder by Tom Thompson Dr.Walker Senior Seminar 7/29/2009 Thomas L. Thompson Dr. Christopher Walker Senior Seminar July 29, 2009 Income Mobility: Up & Down the Economic Ladder People always say they do what they do to make life better not only for themselves, but for the future well-being of their children and hopefully those actions will get passed on to their children. This is my way of thinking of the paying it forward theory; giving all I have, to make the lives of my children better than the one I grew up with and the one I currently live. One of my most favorite quotes about getting ahead in life came from a philosopher and pastor Russell Conwell that is hand-written by my grandmother in a Bible that was given to me some years ago. It goes like this, “For a man to say, I do not want money, is to say, I do not wish to do any good to my fellow men" (Conwell). Everyone wants money, only if it is to do good for your family’s future. From the rich business professional perched high in their penthouse to the lowly street peddler on the corner, everyone has a story on how and why they ended up in that position. The United States is seen as the place where everyone has the opportunity of the “American Dream”. That includes the opportunity for one's children to grow up and attain to their fullest potential in which they are capable of, and seen for what they are and not what they are born with. It is the opportunity...

Words: 4631 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Investigating a Social Issue - Social Mobility

...Describe how society defines the social issue. So, what is Social Mobility? First, let’s go to its technical or dictionary definition. Social mobility is the movement of people from one social class or economic level to another (“Social Mobility”, Random House Unabridged Dictionary, 2nd Edition). This term is widely used both in Sociology and Economics. It usually refers to vertical movement or moving up or down in rank. For example, if a soldier becomes a sergeant from a corporal, that would be vertical movement. However, it may also refer to horizontal movement or moving from one rank to another of the same social level. Example of this would be a principal who resigns from one school to become the principal of another school. With this definition in mind, we can see that Social Mobility is “movement”. The technical definition doesn’t restrict about the direction – whether you move up or down or just within what’s mentioned before as horizontal movement. Social Mobility is a term used in the objective comparison of economic or social states. Looking at the events around us, we can see that people care more about upward movement. When people talk about Social Mobility, they are likely referring to progress or development. Everyone wants to move up. Like what we commonly see in families. Almost everyone gives importance to good education. Parents keep reminding their children to be good in their studies so they can have good jobs. People want the opportunity to move up. People...

Words: 1311 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Social Mobility Paper

...Social Mobility Paper Lori Bair University of Phoenix Soc/100 Dr. Audrey Morrissette, PhD. July 27, 2010 Workshop #5 Social Mobility Social mobility refers to the degree to which an individual's family or group's social status can change throughout the course of their lives through a system of social hierarchy or stratification. Social mobility refers to the likelihood that a child will grow up into adulthood and attain a higher level of economic and social wellbeing than his/her family of origin (Little, D. 2009). The purpose of this paper is to reflect on the similarities and differences between myself, my parents and my grandparents in regard to various stratification variables such as: education, religion, income, occupation, area of residence, consumption patterns, and political participation. What caused the differences, have they changed or influenced my attitudes and behaviors. Last I will explain how these differences change my life from how it was when I was young. Similarities and Differences The similarities between my parents and me are obtaining our high school diploma, attended college, stable job, and always had income. The similarities between my grandparents and me are getting our high school diploma, attend church service, Republican Party and always had income. The differences between my parent and I are we don’t believe in the same religion...

Words: 796 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Joe Bao

...hierarchical arragngement of a large social groups based on their control over basic resources “Life changes” the extent to which individuals have access to important societal resources such as food, clothing, shelter, education and health (102) Stratification systems are described as being closed or open closed: the boundaries between levels in the hierarchies of social stratification are rigid and peoples position are set by ascribed status Open: the boundaries between levels in the hierarchies of social stratification are flexible and may be influenced (positively and negatively) by people’s achieved status Social mobility the movement of individuals or groups from one level in a stratification system to another Intergenerational mobility: the social movement experienced by family members from one generation to the next intragenerational mobility: the social movement of individuals within their own lifetime (203) Slavery: until the 19th century in quebec, ontario, new Brunswick, nova scotia in N.a it consisted of : for life and it was...

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Comparison Between 'From Ragged Dick And' Horatio Alger

...In America we have something called the American dream. To us the American dream is for everyone to be able to be financially stable and be able to maintain a good stature. The dream is for everyone to be able to maintain a social rank that can make you respectable. If you want to be well respected in America you have to have a good job if you aren’t you’re portrayed as a failure. When you’re a failure you are not apart of the American dream and are placed in the category of the ones who disappoint. After Analyzing “From Ragged Dick” by Horatio Alger and “Horatio Alger” by Harlon Dalton as they argued against each other on social mobility and economic prosperity as they express different views . After analyzing both readings and considering...

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Impact of Inequality

...October 29, 2014 IS 206GENDER ANALYSIS AND DEVELOPMENT THE IMPACT OF INEQUALITY Box 1: COMPARATIVE STUDIES ON INEQUALITY AND SOCIAL MOBILITY ACROSS OECD AND LATIN AMERICAN COUNTRIES Presented by Del Mundo, Maria Naida Box 2: SOCIAL AND POLITICAL COHESION, SOCIAL TOLERANCE OF INEQUALITY Presented by Gutierrez, Cherry Lou THE IMPACT OF INEQUALITY ABSTRACT October 29, 2014 There is growing evidence and recognition on the powerful and corrosive effects of inequality on economic growth, poverty, social mobility and political cohesion. This paper finds that the real and potential impacts of inequality in relation to economic growth, poverty, social mobility, social stability and cohesion. KEYWORDS: Inequality, Economic Growth, Poverty, Social Mobility, Political Cohesion, Gender I. INTRODUCTION In relation to the worldwide gender gap, in so far as inequality also exist in political imbalance in the Philippines distinguished through the partisan move of a party, wherein, such intent, policies and term of their advocacy is their ultimate road map and reluctantly to engage in the opponent’s adherence. Colonial mindset, attributable to the Spanish era wherein their colonial stay in the country portrays the strictness and conservative ways in precluding to whom or to which is one’s belief will end up to, and upon the continuance of the American regime, where westernized ways has gotten in the minds of the Filipinos, that every choice of an American decision draws correct conclusion...

Words: 7088 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

Part 1

...Mod 6: Discussion Questions Actions for Mod 6: Discussion Questions Part 1 Read the article People Can Equal Profits or Problems. Briefly identify the author’s position on personal relationships in the workplace. Do you agree with the author's position? Why? Why not? Have you encountered similar dilemma at your job, school, or other settings? How did you resolve it? Part 2 How do you see American society today in terms of class relations and social mobility? Do you see the American education system as reinforcing the opportunity for social mobility or perpetuating the class division in this nation? Why? Part 3 Referring to your readings in Mor Barak, what is the most prominent cultural style and relational mental model at your workplace or other organizations to which you belong (e.g. school) Part 1 In the article “People Can Equal Profits or Problems” by Joseph Schmitt, I believe that the author is against the personal relationship in the workplace, and he also points out that having a great leader is important for attracting good people. According to the article, “If companies have people problems, they probably have a problem with the leadership that is administering the people programs. If companies want to attract good people, then the first step they need to take is to be certain great people lead them. Worse than bad hiring processes, layers of nepotism and cronyism send clear messages that who you know and to whom you are related are much more important than...

Words: 616 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Wealth Inequality In America

...In December of 2013, President Obama gave a speech regarding economic mobility. Many problems that may hinder the mobility of the economy were addressed, including the technological advancements that eliminate certain jobs and the ability for companies to ship jobs out of the United States. These changes resulted in fewer benefits, lower wages, and fewer jobs. The economy that was once content with a relatively even wealth distribution became intensely unequal and insecure. According to President...

Words: 2098 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Arslan

...Problem satement: “Factor effect on consumer buying behavior” Objective: I want to find out what variables effect on consumer buying behavior. MODEL Consumer buying behavior Social income class Independent variable Dependent variable Literature : BUYING BEHAVIOR AND CONSUMPTION: SOCIAL CLASS VERSUS INCOME Mirelia milnic, Gordana culina Survey methodology was used to collect data. The questionnaire consisted of 22 questions of Social class formed by three determinants: occupation, education and income. The largest weight (4) was given to occupation, as the most important determinant of the social class, while education and income were given the same weight (3). Income information is obtained by asking the respondent to which of the 10 income groups his/her family belongs. house keeper scores (10) students (9) prisoners (8) Machine operators skilled and unskilled jobs (7) Skilled employees - workers in manufacturing,. (6) (office workers), (5). school teachers, engineers, (4) Middle management, owners of small businesses, (3) Higher level business executives or managers, 2) Government top officials, “rich” business owners (1). Social class and income groups for certain products/services social class and income have a considerable influence on buyers' behavior. Consumption or usage of all product/service categories we tested, significantly differ based...

Words: 1105 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

American Dream And Social Mobility

...American Dream can be defined as every citizen having an equal opportunity to obtain success or security through hard work, determination, climbing the social ladder, and undergoing social mobility. I disagree with the idea of social mobility being achievable for most Americans and The American Dream being attainable. There are different types of social mobility. Intergenerational mobility is the change that family members make in social class from one generation to the next. Upward and downward social mobility which is the movement up the social class ladder or down the social class ladder. Structural mobility, movement up or down the social class ladder that is due to changes in structure of society. Finally exchange mobility, the large number of people moving up the social class ladder, while a large number of people move down. Social class is a large group of people who rank closely to one another in property, power and prestige. People tend to believe that there is the rich, the poor and people who are in the middle. Carl Marx argues that there are two classes, capitalists and workers, while sociologists have denounced this view by arguing that these...

Words: 601 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Sociology

...and then they continued every seven years. The final interview takes place when they are all 56 years old. 56 Up contains many sociological terms, such as the various types of social mobility. To begin, one sociological term used in this documentary is social mobility. 56 Up represents many of the types of mobility with the subjects. First, Sue shows intragenerational mobility. Sue is a woman who at 56 works in the administration department of a big university in London, despite never going to college. Typically, women with no education are in a lower class; however, Sue moved up within her lifetime, which demonstrates intragenerational mobility. Along with this, Sue experienced vertical mobility. Sue experienced vertical mobility within her job changes. Her part time jobs were viewed as lower than her administrative job now. Paul, on the other hand, started in a lower class. He lived in a children’s home and never went to college. His daughter, Katie, was the first in the family to ever attend a university. This shows intergenerational mobility because going to college and getting a good education could lead to a higher social class. Since this is experienced through more than one generation, it is intergenerational mobility rather than intragenerational. Paul also experienced horizontal mobility with his job changes. He never went to school and had factory, building, and maintenance jobs. All these jobs are in the same social class, so he didn’t necessarily move up or down....

Words: 386 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Women’s Social Mobility in the United States of America

...Women’s Social Mobility in the United States of America We live in a world full of obstacles where it’s said that the one who is born poor will remain poor. Like many other country in the world the United States of America is also struggling with the difficulties regarding social mobility. The American dream is that the poorest suburban person can be a rich person too and America is the home and land of unlimited possibilities. The main idea is that if you work hard enough you can make it to the top. Is it true for everyone? Can women make it to the top? But before I start my essay on Women’s Social Mobility in the United States of America let me clarity certain definitions. The concept of social mobility has two main meanings: a) in the narrow sense, represents the moving in a stratification system, b) broadly refers to the space movement (territorial mobility) and / or change of employment (or mobility fluctuation labor). Studies (theoretical and empirical) say that social mobility can be placed in three categories: - those using a hierarchy criteria, tracking movements between strictly hierarchical layers. It’s the American tradition, which uses the social status as a hierarchical criteria. - those who use as a classification criteria exclusively the individual’s occupation, this leading to the establishment of a social space consisting some number of socio-professional categories: tradition - those using as a criteria social classes and social strata. Here fall particularly...

Words: 2541 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

The Benefit and Danger of Education Technology

...The rapid changes in technology over the last 75 years have created enormous opportunities for education. While some technologies such as the computer were adopted early on, a reluctance to embrace change coupled with a lack of funding has resulted in a continuing dependence on chalkboards and other anachronistic technologies. The extent to which schools adopt new technologies, not surprisingly, often depends on how well they’re funded. It isn’t uncommon for schools that are separated by very little physical distance to be at opposite ends of the technology gap. Many folks familiar with this scenario understand the inherent lack of fairness in the disparate funding of schools. What many people don’t understand however is that it also threatens the uniquely American ideals of democracy and equality. One of the bedrocks of our democracy is the idea that we’re governed by the electoral choices of a well-informed citizenry. Having equal access to a decent education is the assumption that underlies this premise. But the ways in which rapid advances in technology are adopted have both positive and negative implications for schools and for broader society in general. Preparing For The Workforce One of the most positive results of schools embracing new technologies is found when low-income students gain skills they otherwise wouldn’t. The ability to type, use email and execute basic computer functions like Word and Excel are imperative in today’s workforce. When students who...

Words: 1018 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Social Mobility

...SOCIAL MOBILITY Since the ancient times, humans have been living in a society were in a social stratification is observed. Moreover, in a social stratification an equal opportunity for social mobility is given in each individual. Social Mobility pertains to the movement of a person from a social status to another social status. This movement can be either upward or downward, depending on whether people rise to higher status or fall to lower ones. Intergenerational mobility is one of the focuses of the study of sociologist. Intergenerational mobility is the upward or downward movement of the hierarchy by the family members from one generation to another. The amount of this movement – which occurs, for example, when a janitor’s son becomes a doctor, or a doctor’s child becomes a janitor- tells how rigidly inequality is structured into society. In other words, social mobility refers to the relative movement of an individual, family, or group, up or down the stratification system of the society. There are two types of social mobility; vertical mobility and horizontal mobility. Types of Social Mobility I. Vertical Mobility refers to downward or upward movement in social rank, which occurs when there is a major change in wealth, prestige or power. When a person is said to move upward, this means that there is an increase in level of wealth through job promotion, small-scale businesses that have prospered. This change is symbolized by setting up residence in an affluent neighborhood...

Words: 445 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Buss 499 Assignment 1

...Telecommunication industries is rising and becoming more of a demand on a daily basis. One of the top telecommunication companies is Sprint, which has extensive operations in the United States and three United States territories (Virgin Island, Guam, and Puerto Rico). Sprint offers communication services (wireless, wireline) to businesses, government users and consumers. The company engineers, builds, and implement technologies, which includes the first 4G (fourth generation) wireless service in the United States from a national carrier. The company’s services also entail contract services and pre-paid services. In 1990 Sprint offered basic phone lines and branched out in 2000 to walkie talkie services using an analog network. On July 10, 2013, Sprint merged with Nextel, became Sprint Nextel, and being its directly owned subsidiary. Sprint Nextel was changed to Sprint Communications, Inc. Sprint is now a 4G LTE network and also one of the most fast network services. Sprint caters to consumers’ needs by providing and producing enhanced products to communicate, such as, surfing the internet, talking, listening to music, watching television and having a face to face conversation from your phone and that is just to name a few. Sprint not only offers services in the United States but also in some of the international countries. Sprint not only provide services for cell phones but have advanced to home phone services, tablets, I pads, MIFI hotspots, and laptops. As of...

Words: 1098 - Pages: 5