Free Essay

Enviromental Law

In:

Submitted By ishani
Words 1518
Pages 7
CONSTITUTION AND ENVIROMENTAL LAW
Environmental protection has found a special mention in the Indian constitution. The preamble to the Constitution provides that our country is based on socialistic pattern of society. The basic aim of socialism is to provide a decent standard of living to all, which can be possible only in a pollution free environment. Also, in a democratic republic, people have the right to know and access information on government policies which is very important for the success of environmental policies. The starting point of environmental protection is the fundamental rights and directive principles of state policy which underline our national commitment to protect and improve the environment. The interpretation given to article 21 of the Constitution contained in the Fundamental Rights has added new dimensions to the quality of life and its relating effect on the environment. The Constitution of India as originally enacted did not contain any specific provision to deal with environmental pollution though Article 47 made an indirect reference to improvement of public health as one of the primary duties of the state. Article 51 (c) provides that the state shall endeavour to foster respect for international law and treaty obligations in the dealings of organised peoples with one and another. Article 253 of the Constitution specifically empowers parliament to make any law for the whole or part of india for implementing any treaty, agreement or convention with any other country or any decision made at any international conference. This has been held in conformity with the 1972 UN conference on Human Environment at Stockholm and the 1992 UN Conference on Environment and Development Rio de Janeiro. The authority vested in the parliament under the provisions contained in article 253 has been exercised in enacting the air act and the environment protection act. The preamble to both these enactments specifically declare that these laws were enacted to inmplement the desicions taken at stockholm declaration 1992
Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum v. Union of India
The Supreme Court held that it is almost an accepted proposition of law that the rules of customary international law which are not contrary to municipal law shall be deemed to have been incorporated in the domestic law and shall be followed by the Courts of Law.

Constitution 42nd Amendment Act 1976 incorporated Article 48 A into the Constitution in the Chapter on Directive Principles of State Policy. The Amendment also inserted part 6A which enumerates fundamental duty of citizens. This shows the concern of our parlianmentarians to give priority to environmental protection by bringing it on the national agenda because the conditions existing at that time necessitated such an action.
DERICTIVE PRINCIPLES OF STATE POLICY.
Indian Judiciary has made use of these directives in a number of cases and these have been read as complimentary to the fundamental rights. Where ther is a right to use and enjoy the environmental bounties, citizens also have a duty to preserve such bounties to protection of environment.
T damodar Rao v. S. O Muncipal Corporation Hyderabad
The court pointed out that in view of articles 48A and 51A(g) , it is clear that protection of environment is not the duty of citizens but also the obligation of the state and all other state organs including courts.
Kinkri Devi v. State
The HP high court reiterated that in articles 48A and 51A g there is both a constitutional pointer to the state and a constitutional duty of citizens not only to protect but also improve the environment and failure to abide by the pointer is nothing short of a betrayal of the fundamental law which thw state and the citizens are bound to uohold.
The word “protect” and “improve” which occur in both provisions under discussion appear to contemplate a formative state action to improve the quality of the environment and not just to preserve the environment in its degraded form. The provisions leave ample scope for the judiciary to intervene and require public authorties to improve environmental quality.
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS VIS A VIS ENVIRONMENT A. The right to a wholesome environment.
It is the interpretation of article 21 which the courts have extended further so as to include the right to wholesome environment. Environmental pollution which spoils the atmosphere and thereby affects the life and health of a person has been guarded as the mounting violation of Article 21.

T damodar Rao v. S. O Muncipal Corporation Hyderabad
The slow poisoning by the polluted atmosphere caused by environmental pollution spoliation should also be regarded as violation of article 21. The AP high court also explained that the enviromenatl law has succeded in unshackling mas right to life and personal liberty from the crutches of the common law theory of individual ownership.

Charanlal Sahu v. Union of India
The Supeme Court put it beyond doubt that right to live in a heathly environment is a fundamental right under artcle 21 and has to be read with article 48A and 51A(g) therby putting obligation on the state as well as citizens to portect and improve it.

Rural litigation and Entitlement Kendra, dehradun v. State of Uttar Pradesh
The entertained complains alleging that the operation of lime stone quarries in the Mussorie Dehradun region resulted in degradation of the environment affecting the frigid ecosystems in the area. The Supreme Court was moved under article 32 and ordered the closure of some of the quarries on the ground that these were upsetting the ecological balance.

Ganga Pollution tanneries case
“ we are conscious that closure of tanneries may bring unemployment, loss of revenue, but life, health and ecology have greater importance to the people.”
M. C Mehta v Union of India
The Court was conscious that environmental changes are inevitable consequences of industrial development in our country, but at the same time the quality of environment cannot be permitted to be damaged by polluting the air, water and land to such an extent that it becomes a health hazard. The Court retreated that every citizen has right to fresh air and live in a pollution free environment.
Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum v. Union of India
By virtue of Constitutional provisions and statutory provisions, the precautionary principle and polluter pays principle are part of the environmental law of the country. The two basic principles of sustainable development can derive from various provisions including the right to life.

B. Right to livelihood
Banwasi Seva Ashram v State of Uttar Pradesh
The case arose out of a PIL petition on behalf of local people who raise their voice against reservation of forest land by the state. The tribal forest dwellers were using the forest as their habitat and means of livelihood. It was contended that state action which contemplated eviction of the forest dwellers violated the Fundamental right to life of the local people guaranteed by Article 21. The Supreme Court gave directions for safeguarding and protecting the interest of the backward peoples who were being ousted from the forest land. The Court permitted the acquisition of land only after the corporation agreed to provide certain facilities to the ousted forest dwellers.

Whether the right to livelihood could be asserted to prevent environmentally harmful projects which tend to uproot the local people and thus deprives them of their livelihood. It is submitted that the entire matter including the installation of such projects, their impact on the life pf the people vis a vis their rehabilitation will have to be taken into account failing which Article 21 may come into operation. C. Right to know
S. P Gupta v. Union of India
The Supreme Court recognised the right to know to be implicit in the right of free speech and expression. Therefore, disclosures of information in regard to the functioning of the Government must be the rule and secrecy is an exception justified only when the strictest requirement of public interest so demands.
Bombay Environmental Action Group v. Pune Cantonment
The court held that peoples participation in the movement for the protection of the environment cannot be exercised. It is wrong to think that by trying to protect the environment, their posing various development projects. One who is prepared to pay the requisite fees and is asking for inspection or copies of site plan bonafied is entitled to it. The inspection was contemplated only to decide the question as to whether the relevant provisions of law are complied with or not or the construction of the building is likely to create any environment problems.

D. Fredom of trade and environment
Whether a person, agency or industry has right to carry on business or trade in a manner which is causing injury to the public and posing health hazards to the society at large.

Abilash textiles v. Rajkot Municipal Corporation
It was acknowledged that after 19(1)(g) confers a right upon every citizen to carry on trade and business however, is rightly subject to reasonable restrictions which may be imposed in the interests of general public as provided in 19(1)(g). Therefore, no one has the right carry on business so as to cause nuisance to society.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Enviromental Law

...Enviromental Law There are many differences between corporate law and environmental law; however, the similarities that exist are numerous as well. Although the environmental and business world are constantly changing due to advances in technology, law ethic, and human rights issues, the world of law changes and develops just as quickly to govern the two ever changing types of law. Although changes are made to corporate and environmental law somewhat often, the differences and similarities are always easily seen. To begin with, lawyers interpret the law through actions and words for the protection of an individual, a business, concern, or an idea. They must be highly educated in several important areas: the law, economics, history, human motivation and behavior, and the practicalities of day to day living. The education of lawyers never ends because they must constantly be informed of important information, which may be of use to the client. Their education is also considered never to end because of the fact that the law is always changing and evolving. Environmental law is one of the newest entries in the legal world. Environmental law requires a concern for the nation's resources, knowledge of where the resources are, what they are used for, how and why they may be endangered, damaged, or exploited. Environmental law also requires a concern for those whose job it is to protect them (Vig 120). Environmental lawyers may work alone or in a group. Environmental lawyers...

Words: 2427 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Law 531 Learning Team Reflection Week 5

...- Exide Technologies Business Law - Law 531 March 23, 2015 Instructor: Learning Team Reflection - Exide Technologies Exide Technologies in Vernon, California is an example of a company which failed to comply with government regulations requiring them to properly handle and dispose of toxic battery waste. This case also highlights the negligence in part by state officials regarding violations discovered over a period of almost two decades. These violations included battery acid draining into a manholes and lead waste stored in open containers causing the toxic waste to be exposed. There are consquences when a company such as Exide Technologies fail to comply with state and federal regulations which could ultimately hinder their sustainability and financial prosperity. Principles of regulatory compliance requirements. According to Exide Technologies website, they are committed to comply with applicable legal requirements and other requirements related to environmental aspect. Due to the numerous violations discovered in the Vernon plant, Exide agreed to shut down the plant as a plea agreement to avoid any future criminal charges and additional fines. In addition to the plant shutting down, they were order to decontaminate the site in which they worked due to high levels of lead and arsenic emissions. Exide Technologies was not only mishandling their toxic waste, but they were not complying with all applicable governmental laws and regulations with the Environmental...

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Procedure

...Criminal Procedure Policy Order and liberty are two areas within criminal procedure that have tension among one another (book). Order is a stronger approach toward the criminal justice system than liberty. Liberty concerns an individual’s rights to due process, which means everybody deserves the same rights when arrested regardless of the circumstances such as poor person versus a rich person. The two models that were developed by Herbert Packer were the crime control model and the due process model (book). Both models have similarities as well as differences and not one is “good” and the other “bad” according to Packer. The two primary goals within the criminal justice system are the need to enforce law and maintain social order and the need to protect people from injustice (defenseinvestigator). The fourth, fifth, sixth, and fourteenth amendments play a signifigant role when analyzing both the due process model and the crime control model. This paper will further explore both models as well as how the models view the fourth, fifth, and sixth amendments and how the fourteenth amendment gives the same rights on a state level as well as federal. Crime Control Model The crime control model is a stern approach to the criminal justice system. As described by Hubert Packer, “the crime control model is like a conveyer belt, moving cases starting from arrest to conviction in a swift and fast process (Book).” Fact finding is what defines this model. If an officer makes an...

Words: 1348 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Illegal Immigration

...that breaks the Immigration Law should be punished, even if they are not citizens of the country. According to Perez (2001), “In 1986 Congress passed the Immigration Reform and Control Act that, among other things, granted amnesty to illegal immigrants who could demonstrate continual residence in the United States prior to 1982” (Perez, 2001). Because of this law, millions of illegal immigrants can use this act to become citizens of the United States. | According to Mirram-Webster (2012), “amnesty means that the act of an authority (as a government) by which pardon is granted to a large group of individuals” (Mirram-Webster, 2012). Therefore, amnesty is unfair and unconstitutional because all of the illegal immigrants that come into the United States are pardon after they have violated the laws in this country. Why do we continue to allow these illegal immigrants to go unpunished? If it were some of the U.S. citizens breaking this law they would not be granted amnesty; they would be treated differently, so why illegal immigrants should be pardoned? Robert Byrd (2001), a West Virginia senator, says, “Illegal immigrants who have worked for many years in the United States should not be granted amnesty” (Byrd, 2001). Illegal immigrants who work in the United States should be punished because they do not have green cards or permission from the United States to come to America. Although amnesty is an approved law, many peoples do not agree with this law. On the other hand, some Americans...

Words: 1845 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Few Good Man

...Few good man Time from time you may hear stories of abuse by the military justice "system". There are multiple destroyed and financially devastated families out there suffering heartbreak and loss at the hands of an uncaring, unfeeling and unjust process which makes a mockery of our Bill of Rights. Military justice for the majority is prefabricated according to the wishes of the local Commander, and the "trial" or "court-martial" is tantamount to a pre-ordained verdict of GUILTY. How could any court proceeding be considered fair when the "convening authority," by right of title, is given the power to select the judge, the jury and defense and prosecution attorneys? It may go "unsaid," but the implication is very clear - if the convening authority "sees fit" to bring about a court-martial, then the accused can be assumed to be guilty. What's special, or even topical, about A Few Good Men movie is it speaks to how military honor can be so readily suborned by the authoritarian impulse. And second, how the same honest pride - not to mention competence - is necessary to bring such posturing would-be tyrants to justice. The main issue the movie touches upon is military justice. A good marine abides by the following code: 1. Unit 2. Corps 3. God and 4. Country For this code to be at its effective best, it must be governed by truth and justice. What happens when truth and justice fail to be active participants of this code? Justice has been defined in many ways...

Words: 948 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Root Causes of Corruption

...Akhil Kaushal P  According to The Transparency International 2006 Corruption Perceptions Index: • Most honest countries – Finland, New Zealand, Iceland, Denmark and Singapore • Most corrupt countries – Haiti, Guinea, Myanmar, Iraq, Bangladesh, Chad, Congo and Sudan • China, Brazil, Ghana, Senegal, Peru, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, India and Egypt all rank in the middle        Lack of resources Explosive population growth Need stronger and more effective institutions Lack of democracy Ineffective judiciary Unfair elections Lack of free media  From The Bulging Pocket and the Rule of Law: Corruption, Inequality, and Trust  Inequality –> Low generalized trust & High in-group trust –> Corruption –> Inequality The dilemma of low trust in strangers and high trust only in your own group Inequality and in-group trust lead to clientelism This pattern is difficult to break     Two types of inequality: Economic inequality Unfair legal system    Makes it more difficult for the poor to have access to the legal system Shielding people at the top   Democratic institutions are not sufficient to curb corruption Media consumption, centralization, federalism, the nature of the electoral system, the level of wages paid to officials also don't matter  Structural reforms may not matter much for corruption, however: • Democratic countries are far less corrupt than nondemocracies • Countries with strong democratic...

Words: 334 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Stand Your Ground

...Stand Your Ground Gerald Makey SOC 205 Strayer University The “Stand-your-ground law validates a person in using any physical force including deadly force, when they are not involved in illegal activity and is in a place where he or she has the right be, they have no obligation to haven and have the right to stand their ground. A quick breakdown of this law is that it give a person legal cover in the event that they find themselves in a certain situation in which their survival, or the preservation of their family necessitates them to stand their ground and use a weapon for defense. This law can be referenced back to the Supreme Court case Beard v. United States, 158 U.S. 550 (1895). It is defined in this case that, “A man assailed on his own grounds, without provocation, by a person armed with a deadly weapon and apparently seeking his life is not obliged to retreat, but may stand his ground and defend himself with such means as are within his control; and so long as there is no intent on his part to kill his antagonist, and no purpose of doing anything beyond what is necessary to save his own life, is not guilty of murder or manslaughter if death results to his antagonist from a blow given him under such circumstances (www.justia.com). In Houston, Texas a “Stand-your-ground” case has brought a lot of attention, but also a lot of controversy. In this case Raul Rodriguez was found guilty of killing his neighbor over a dispute over loud music. Rodriguez who was a retired...

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Marijuana: Medicine or Menace?

...Jacob Frederick 5-29-12 Buller Composition II Marijuana: Medicine or Menace? I have had strong feelings about this issue before it was even brought up as a topic for debate in our class. My opinion on the topic has not changed in the slightest, but I did learn a lot of interesting details concerning it. I have always felt that marijuana should be legalized, or at the very least, people with serious medical conditions should have access to it. And marijuana doesn’t even have to be legalized in my opinion, but it should definitely be decriminalized. I don’t think anyone who wants to smoke a plant that they grow themselves should have to suffer consequences, considering they are responsible in their recreational smoking. I do feel that if it were legalized, that there should be an acceptable age limit to buy and/or consume marijuana, comparable to that of alcohol. There are beneficial as well as harmful effects concerning marijuana, but that goes for a lot of things people do in everyday life. And I feel that a lot of time has been spent shining the spotlight on the harmful effects of marijuana, while little research has been done or even allowed, on the benefits of marijuana. While preparing for the debate, I encountered many sources on each end of the spectrum; including some in the middle. Many of the sources I looked at seemed rather credible, but others were most definitely biased. One example of a blatantly biased comment was, "Most pot smokers drink alcohol heavily...

Words: 949 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethics in Marketing

...that shape the decisions people or organisations make(Termpaper warehouse,2012).http://www.termpaperwarehouse.com/essay-on/Ethics-In-International-Marketing/53994. Today, law suits are filed against erring companies found wanting or in bridge of ethical standards which has increased the need of cautiousness in the way most companies project their image . It summarizes the natural rights and universal values of the equality of all men and women to the law of the land. It also covers concern for the natural environment, health and safety. Read more: http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/ethics.html#ixzz28xWPwQco Ethics in marketing are the basic principles that governs the business practice of those involved in promoting their products to or services to consumers(Business dictionary.com). Sound marketing ethics however are those practices that do not impact negatively on the consumers. http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/marketing-ethics.html Ethics has always been the bane of moral studies and value and has been in practice since the ancient times. (Napoleon,1804) in his 36 codes of conduct, noted that all citizens in France, irrespective of place of birth or social status is entitled to fair and equal treatment. As a branch of philosophy, ethics deals with established laws that guide human relationship and behaviour with emphasis on good sense of judgement. Scholars like Aristotle identified character as ''ethos'' which he described as the...

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Rule of Law in Bangladesh 5th

...AL-HELAL Course Title: Administrative Law Class Roll: ZH-26, 4th Batch, 5th Semester Dept. of Public Administration, University of Dhaka. Cell : 01924202090, E-mail : helal_pad_du@yahoo.com RULE OF LAW IN BANGLADESH: AN OVERVIEW ABSTRACT: "No free man shall be taken or imprison or disseized or exiled or in any way destroyed nor will we go or send for him, except under a lawful judgment of his peers and by the law of the land". --MAGNA CARTA This paper is a presentation of the concept of rule of law, Dicey's theory of 'Rule of Law', rule of law in true and modern sense and rule of law in Bangladesh. In Bangladesh context I have discussed the provisions for ensuring rule of law in Bangladesh constitution. I also have discussed the provisions of the constitution, which are contrary to the concept of rule of law in Bangladesh. It has been also identified the difficulties of application of rule of law in Bangladesh. INTRODUCTION One of the basic principles of the English constitution is the rule of law. This doctrine is accepted in the constitution of U.S.A. and also in the constitution of Bangladesh. Now a days rule of law is one of the most discussed subjects of developing countries. Developed countries and donor agencies always instruct the developing countries for sustainable development and good governance. Actually sustainable development and good governance mostly depends on the proper application of rule of law. Laws are made for the welfare of the people...

Words: 3323 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Case Study

...The ethical problem in this situation is that through either negligence, unknowing or some other factor pages marked secret from a document that SFC Sharp certified was destroyed were found wedged in between the wall and his desk and another SGT is trying to get you to cover for him by saying all pages of the document were destroyed IAW AR 380-5. By doing what SGT Day is suggesting you are compromising the army values of; Loyalty: Bear true faith and allegiance to the U.S. Constitution, The Army, Your Unit, and other Soldiers. Duty: Fulfill your obligations. Respect: Treat others as they should be treated Selfless Service: Put the welfare of the nation, the army and your subordinates above your own. Honor: Live up to the army values. Integrity: Do what is right legally and morally. Personal Courage: Face fear, danger, or adversity. You would be breaking all these values because yes loyalty says to be loyal to other soldiers but the Constitution, Army, and your unit all play a part and not knowing what those documents could have been used for you don’t know how it would have harmed everything you pledged to be loyal to when joining the military. It’s your duty to report that secret documents were not properly disposed of just like it was SFC Sharp’s duty to make sure that they were properly destroyed to begin with. With respect you could bring what you found to SFC Sharp to inform him of your intentions. Selfless Service by not reporting the problem because again...

Words: 579 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nike Paper

...Nike, Inc. was founded in 1964 by Phil Knight and Bill Bowerman through an investment of $500 by each individual. Nike, Inc. was then called Blue Ribbon Sports and has evolved from being an importer and distributor of Japanese specialty running shoes to becoming the world leader in the design, marketing, and distribution of athletic footwear. Nike's business model was developed by Knight while attending Stanford Business School in the early 1960's. Knight realized that the United States' consumer appliance and electronic markets were beginning to be dominated by the lower-cost, higher quality Japanese producers. Most of the leading footwear companies were still producing their own shoes in higher-costing companies such as the United States and Germany, and Knight believed that by outsourcing shoe production to lower-cost Japanese producers, Blue Ribbon Sports could undersell its competitors and break into this market. As a result of this model, Blue Ribbon Sports began to import sports shoes from Japan and sales increased to almost $2 million in the early 1970's. Nike employers approximately 25,000 people on worldwide. In addition, approximately 650,000 workers are employed in Nike contracted factories around the globe . Nike owned over 200 Nike Factory Stores and over 100 sales and administrative offices. Many people these days are angered by the steps that corporations take simply to make money, and it is quite disgusting in some of the ways a corporation operates. Rallies...

Words: 2105 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Cry Freedom

...ESTONE NJUGUNA I.D. 000447804 THE SCOTTSBORO BOYS This account clearly depicts the civil rights violation and the extent to which racism was deep rooted especially in the Southern states. The entire systems in place did not favor black people and harsh conclusions were drawn without enough or substantial evidence. The way the white’s reacted after the announcement of the invasion and their regrouping at the railway station armed with guns shows the urge to kill and eliminate black people. It was widely believed that the black men’s desire was to rape white girls, a notion that further worsened the hatred among the two races. To substantiate this belief, the two girls who claimed to be victims of rape knew pretty well that they would cover their immoralities by framing the black boys and still get away with their sins by attracting the mercies of the entire white community. Judicial System The right to a fair trial during this era of civil strife was a more than a privilege among the black community. The judicial system: prosecuting counsel, the judges and the defense lawyers was comprised of white people only. That meant that as a black person, getting legal representation was a compromise since you were at the mercies of white attorneys. According to this case, the way the New York attorney describes his clients after going back home leaves a lot to be desired. He even goes further to confess that his clients were guilty, an act that can only be referred to as being...

Words: 407 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Censorship Is Justified

...censorship is justified is always a controversial issue that attracts great public attention, and views of different people might vary greatly. As far as I am concerned, I tend to think that the censorship in China is somehow justified otherwise how can China developed so rapidly for the recent years. I know there are many voices against the censorship of our country, but let’s think from another way, how can we build our welfare and prosperity culture without certain kinds of proper censorship in china? Censorship is the best justified method to make sure everyone's rights. In a society which is made up by variety of people, there must be some law that everyone follows to make the society in order. Justification means everyone is treated the same; anyone who obeys the law will have their rights equally; anyone who offends the law will be punished or circumscribed. Justification doesn't mean that, as someone thinks, everyone can do whatever you want to do because that will make the society happens to be in chaos. In today's modern society, censorship is everywhere in all sorts of media, TV, Internet, etc. It is necessary for government to use censorship to prevent illegal or harmful information which is now contaminating the minds of many people, especially those teenagers like me. As one of the teenagers myself, I am sure that all of us can be easily addicted to these materials. These will do great harm to both our mental and physical developments. How to prevent teenagers'...

Words: 631 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Legal Case Scheduler

...Introduction A case scheduler is a program that enables an enterprise to schedule, initiate and manages jobs automatically. It is a control program that selects from a job queue the next job to be processed. The whole essence of using a case scheduler is organization and time factor. Proper time management makes an institution quite successful and Evelyn Avi’s firm is not an exception. The Legal Case Scheduler service offers an efficient interface for all Lawyers and administrative staff to plan their office and business endeavours resourcefully. Until you value yourself, you won't value your time. “Until you value your time, you will not do anything with it” (Peck M.S. 2010) This write up provides a comprehensive explanation of the development of a Legal Case Scheduler. The new system intends to resolve the problem of, case/data mismatch, improper time management technique experienced by the administrative staff of the firm. The workers shall also be able to search and retrieve data from the database. Also included in this report will be the problem statement, aim, objectives, scope and the justification of the project. Firstly, the problem statement shall be discussed comprehensively with the best methodology approach to be applied. Then the aim shall be mentioned. From the aim, the objectives shall be outlined. The scope and justification of the entire project shall be discussed in details too. The entire project goes through some process like planning, analysis,...

Words: 1000 - Pages: 4