Free Essay

Environmental Impacts of Dams

In:

Submitted By ttmprice
Words 1270
Pages 6
Environmental Impacts of Dams
By
Tania M. Brown
Instructor: Timothy Butcher
Environmental Site Assessment
10/27/2008

Throughout the past few years, the negative impacts of dams have become so well known that most countries have stopped building them altogether and are now forced to invest their money into fixing the problems created by existing dams. The environmental impacts of dams have come under renewed examination in recent years. Dam advocates have historically understood that dams largely improve the status of water-related energy and environmental issues by, for example, producing hydroelectric power and increasing the water supply for irrigation. The construction of large dams completely change the relationship of water and land, destroying the existing ecosystem balance which, in many cases, has taken thousands of years to create. Currently there are around 40,000 large dams which obstruct the world's rivers, completely changing their circulation systems: this is not going to occur without dire environmental impacts.
. Dam advocates have historically understood that dams largely improve the status of water-related energy and environmental issues by, for example, producing hydroelectric power and increasing the water supply for irrigation. The damming of a river creates a reservoir upstream from the dam. The reservoir waters spill out into the surrounding environments, flooding the natural habitats that existed before the dam’s construction. To date, over 400,000 km2 of the earth have been flooded due to damming. The newly created reservoir has more surface area than the river would have had, and therefore more evaporation occurs than is normal. According to Science Encyclopedia, Volume 2, this can lead to an increased loss of up to 2.1 m3 of water per year. According to recent studies, reservoirs contribute to greenhouse gas emissions as well. The initial filling of a reservoir floods the existing plant material, leading to the death and decomposition of the carbon-rich plants and trees. The rotting organic matter releases large amounts of carbon into the atmosphere. The decaying plant matter itself settles to the non-oxygenated bottom of the stagnant reservoir, and the decomposition, unmitigated by a flow pattern that would oxygenate the water produces and eventually releases dissolved methane. (www.newscientist.com)
A dam also acts as a barrier between the upstream and downstream habitat of migratory river animals, such as Chinook and Steelhead salmon in the USA and Atlantic salmon in Europe. Dams block their migration upstream to spawn, threatening to decrease reproduction numbers and reduce the species population. In light of this consequence, efforts have been made to allow the fish a passage upstream, and newer dams often include artificial fish ladders. Some communities have also begun the practice of transporting migratory fish upstream to spawn by using a barge. Sometimes fish have difficulty migrating downstream through a dam, meaning that downstream populations are often reduced unless; the fish are able to swim safely through the dams’ spillways.
Permanent inundation caused by reservoir flooding also alters the wetlands, forests and other habitats surrounding the river. Further ecosystem disruption occurs along the banks of the river and downstream. The areas surrounding riverbanks are of a particularly rich bio-diversity, supported by the natural flooding of a dam-free river. Dammed rivers reduce flood rates, and this has negative consequences on the floodplains downstream that depend on seasonal waters for survival. The comparatively invariable ecosystem created by a reservoir-river supports a far-reduced range of wildlife. (Keller, Edward. Environmental Geology) Endemic (normal for that particular geographic area) species may or may not survive the environmental change, and new species are likely to adopt the altered habitat as a home. However, since dams change a key ecosystem to which all surrounding ecosystems have adapted dam construction nearly always reduces wildlife diversity, for better or for worse.
Rivers carry four different types of sediment down their riverbeds, allowing for the formation of riverbanks, deltas, alluvial fans, braided rivers, oxbow lakes, levees and coastal shores. The construction of a dam blocks the flow of sediment downstream, leading to downstream erosion of these depositional environments, and increased sediment build-up in the reservoir. While the rate of sedimentation varies for each dam and each river, eventually all reservoirs develop a reduced water-storage capacity due to the exchange of storage space for sediment. (Ecology and Politics of Large Dams) Diminished storage capacity results in decreased ability to produce hydroelectric power, reduced availability of water for irrigation, and if left unaddressed, may ultimately result in the expiration of the dam and river.
Dams also have a range of social impacts. Most importantly, dams have compelled the relocation of millions of people. For example, it has been estimated that since the independence of India, about 14 million people have been displaced by dams and related construction, such as irrigation canals. Perhaps another 10 million people have been displaced in China. This, at least, is the government's own figure. Others have estimated that somewhere between 40 and 60 million Chinese have been relocated. (www.idsnet.org)
Dams can also have range of other human impacts. Various diseases have become more prevalent, as a direct consequence of dams and related projects. One example is schistosomiasis, (an infectious blood disease that is usually caused by contaminated water) which now affects about 200 million people. Malaria is also becoming increasingly prevalent, and now affects about 300 million people. Dams create excellent habitat for water-borne disease parasites responsible for these diseases, i.e. large areas of standing water created by dam reservoirs or irrigation projects in tropical countries, which provide a good habitat for the snails that spread schistosomiasis, and the mosquitoes that spread malaria.
In recent years, dam removal has become a commonly used restoration tool. American Rivers has reported 465 successful dam removals across the county. In Wisconsin more than 70 dams have been removed. Their studies have shown that dam removal is one of the most cost-effective stream restoration techniques and is almost always cheaper than repair or rebuilding options. Many local residents who were initially opposed to dam removal found that restored rivers added significant value to their communities.
Management of sediment accumulated behind a dam is often the most critical issue. Release of large amounts of fine sediment is not desirable and could affect downstream areas. Extreme care must be taken if sediments are contaminated. Rivers routinely move large amounts of sediment during high flow periods; therefore, some release of dam sediments may be acceptable. Typically, the long term benefits of dam removal outweigh the short term impacts.
As an alternative to removal, other solutions have been used to address dam problems. Fish passage structures have been used with some success, but do not address the habitat and water quality problems upstream of the dam. Other alternatives such as bypass channels, roughened ramps, dam lowering, and/or combinations of these techniques have been used. These solutions are typically more expensive and less effective for restoration than removal, but allow maintenance of useful dams and may help retain accumulated sediment. (Dept. Of Natural Resources, Illinois)
The impacts of dams are both positive and negative, but with the negative outweighing the positive, it is very apparent that changes have to be made in a timely fashion before it is too late to reverse the negative effects and our wildlife is endangered even more and more of .our human population is forced to move to other regions.

Reference Page
Fred, Pearce. "The Dammed." Free The World (n.d.): 182-194.
Graham-Rowe, Duncan. "Hydro Power's Dirty Little Secret." NewsScientist (2005).
Keller, Edward. Environmental Geology. Prentiss Hall, Inc., 2000.
Wikipedia. Environmental Impacts of Dams. .

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Chilli Dam Fortis Case Analysis

...Introduction Fortis Inc., a company with interests in various North American electric utilities, is proposing to build the Chalillo dam on the Macal River in Belize, Central America. The dam would contribute to the economic development of the country by meeting the increasing demand from industry and consumers for electricity. The company believes that the dam is the most feasible, reliable, and cheap supply of electricity. Environmental non-governmental organizations (ENGOs) oppose the project because of the destruction of wild animal and plant life and the adverse downstream impact, and allege that there are more viable and cost-effective sources. Through a strategic analysis of the issues surrounding the case, we will analyze each alternative to present the best possible recommendation to Fortis Inc. Issues The most prominent issue faced by Fortis Inc. with respect to the Chalillo project is the potential environmental effects. A number of groups are opposed to the project due to the location, on a river where a rare ecosystem exists. The project would build a dam on the river, regulating the flow of the river, preventing flooding and providing a more consistent source of water. While this certainly is a benefit to the individuals residing downstream of the proposed site, it does cause a disruption in the natural environmental cycle. The area that would be impacted was host to a rare and discrete floral floodplain habitat. The system relied on the seasonal flooding and...

Words: 3555 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Shreyash

...You are here: Home » About Sustainability > Environmental > Water Quality ------------------------------------------------- Water Quality Where water quality issues are prevalent, there are a number of design and operational systems that can be used to minimise impacts of a hydropower scheme within a reservoir and downstream. These begin with adequate data collection and a comprehensive environmental assessment process. Issue Changes in water quality may occur within and downstream of the development as a result of impoundment. The residence time of water within a reservoir is an influence on the scale of these changes, along with bathymetry, climate and catchment activities. Where water quality issues arise, they can vary greatly and can include reduced oxygenation, temperature, stratification potential, pollutant inflow, propensity for disease proliferation, nutrient capture, algal bloom potential and the release of toxicants from inundated sediments. Some water quality problems relate to activities within the catchment beyond the direct control of the proponent but which can cause water quality problems when compounded with the power station operations. Flooding of biomass, especially forests, results in underwater decay. In deep lakes that tend to stratify, colder de-oxygenated water at depths in the lake have in some cases released metals from the sediments e.g. methylmercury. Deep intakes can in some cases result in deoxygenated and hydrogen sulphide rich releases...

Words: 1532 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Summary: The 1960s Environmental Movement

...The 1960s environmental movement was a tidal wave that completely changed how Americans saw the process of action and consequence in regards to nature and human behavior. Although some form of environmentalism existed before, nothing compared to the political and social changes created by this new environmental collective consciousness. There were many events that pushed public and politicians to act upon protecting the environment. One of the famous events was the 1962 publication of Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring. Carson was not the first person to point out the reverberant effects of powerful pesticides like DDT, but her book tied together scientific research with the understandable metaphor of a silent spring. Shortly stated, her book made a powerful impact on the country. Chemical companies became the main target after the book was...

Words: 1573 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Qwwert

...HTC's Notable Projects » Environmental Risk Assessment of Proposed Agus III Hydroelectric Power Project, Lanao del Sur: Conducted the identification of major hazards due to the dam construction; quantitative characterization of risks; formulation of alternative risk-reduction measures; selection of appropriate risk reduction schemes. » Rapu Rapu Copper – Gold Project, Construction of the Tailing Storage Facility of the Lafayette Philippines, Inc. in Rapu Rapu Island, Albay. Scope of work included planning, design, construction supervision, quality control and monitoring of the repair and improvement of the tailings storage dam for the mining company; design of dam safety monitoring system. » JBIC Technical Assistance Study for Improving the Operation of Bohol Irrigation System of the National Irrigation Administration. The TA Study was aimed at assisting the NIA to effectively operate and manage three storage reservoir dams to irrigate about 10,000 hectares. The scope of work of HTC included the review of the present system of dam operations: formulation of improved irrigation water management plan to optimize the utilization of the water resources of the reservoir schemes; demonstrate and supervise the actual operation of the system adopting the improved management plan; training of irrigation personnel and farmer beneficiaries. » Liguasan Marsh Development Master Plan, Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao: Risk assessment of potential agricultural development infrastructure...

Words: 1013 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Controversies Around Dam Reservoirs Benefits, Costs and Future

...2-4, 141-148 2009 Controversies around dam reservoirs: benefits, costs and future Ryszard Kornijów1, 2 of Life Sciences in Lublin, Department of Hydrobiology, B. Dobrzańskiego 37, 20-262 Lublin, Poland, e-mail: ryszard.kornijow@up.lublin.pl 2Sea Fisheries Institute in Gdynia, Department of Fisheries Oceanography and Marine Ecology, H. Kołłątaja 1, 81-332 Gdynia, Poland 1University Abstract The paper reviews the social and environmental problems concerning the functioning of dams including their local and global effects. Particularly emphasized is a trend toward removing dams in many countries. These are issues of significant importance, particularly in view of the current discussions on justification of investing in new dams, and seeking safe and economical solutions for aging dams, risky in their further operation. Key words: dam building and removal, local and global effects. „Dams are both a blessing and a curse” Dr. Ute Collier 1. Introduction The above citation accurately, although briefly, reflects general perception of dams. On the one hand, they have undoubtedly played, and still play a significant role in the development of the civilization. On the other hand, their construction and functioning entail incurring immense social costs, often disproportionate to the resulting advantages. Dams have also caused vast irreversible damage in the natural environment. Therefore, there is growing opposition against constructing dams, and even demands to remove the already...

Words: 6151 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

Analyse the Feasibility of Two Different Techniques of Fresh Water Supply in Egypt

...than 1000 m3/year/person, while the figure in Egypt is about 963 m3/year/person. Although, from the geographic perspective,there are adequate water resources in Egypt, such as Mediterranean Sea, Red Sea and Nile River (CIA, 2012), the Nile water level is decreasing due to the result of evaporation, rainwater supply, hot and dry climate, vast desert and global warming . According to Kashef (1983: 163), comparing with entering water in Nile (35.69 km3/year), the losses are 29.29 km3/year. Thus, Egypt needs to seek some methods to alleviate the problem of water scarcity. Overall, this report offers two alternative measures, desalination and dams respectively. Generally, this report will analyse and compare the feasibility and differences between desalination and dams from three viewpoints: cost, environmental problems and social impact, by this means attempt to find the most effective and economical method to address the dilemma (water scarcity) in Egypt. 2. Background Egypt, an agricultural country, is located in the northern Africa (CIA, 2012) with three main water resources, namely Nile water, groundwater and rainwater (Abdel-shafy and Aly, 2002: 4-5). However, the desert region occupies more than 96% in Egyptian total land (Fouly and Khaill,1979:205-206) and the average annual rainfall seldom surpass 200mm (Allam et al, 2002:20). It seems that the geographical...

Words: 2479 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Gabčíkovo-Nagymaros

...Gabčíkovo-Nagymaros Project was a large river dam and canal project on the Danube, agreed to in 1977, although was abandoned by the Hungarian government in the early 1980s because of worries about its environmental impact and financial problems.The Czechoslovakians finished their side of the project in 1992. Dams can provide advantages and disadvantages for a community The dam system created several problems that upset the hungarians. Dams can provide advantages and disadvantages for a community. Electricity generated using hydropower is known as hydroelectricity and is generally considered to be reliable. Fossil fuels, coal, and oil release pollutants into the air but Hydropower is fueled by water which means it does not but provides fresh and natural power for the community. Dam systems can, however, have a noticeable adverse impact on the environment.(“Waterpower”) Large dam projects occupy enormous amounts of land and deprive plants and animals of their habitats which can cause endangerment of species. Sediments and nutrients tend to accumulate in the reservoirs of dams which this promotes the growth of algae and weeds and can give off greenhouse gases and promote global warming. Multipurpose dams, dams built to accomplish several goals at once seem to be more of a drawback than benefit. They are at the center of environmental concern due to their generally larger size and proportionately greater impact on their surroundings. Dams along with their reservoirs can destroy habitats...

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case in Point

...transform these sources for a better life. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge is a sleeping reserve of fossil fuels. The Yucca Mountain is storage for nuclear waste. The Three Gorges Dam in China is the biggest sources of hydroelectricity in the world. How viable is each of sources of energy? Is the exploitation indefinite? What is the environmental impact in the ecosystem? Which one of the sources is the best based on ethical and economical issues? The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) is a fossil fuel and natural gas energy source located in Alaska, USA. The fossil fuels reserve is very abundant. According to the US geological survey, on a 1980 research, ANWR has 17 billions of barrels of oils and 34 trillions of Natural Gas. The environmental impact, if it exists, is minimum; only 8% of the refuge will be used, and the maximum footprint development allowed by Congress is about 2000 acres. The new technology implemented at Prudhoe Bay has made the area more environmental friendly for wildlife. In order to protect the tundra, drill sites are constructed on 4' thick gravel pads. Even if a 1" drop of crude oil drips onto the pad, workers are required to shovel it up for proper disposal. (Prudhoe Bay, 2001). Drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge will be a huge impact to the United States economy. Revenues generated will help offset the United States deficit. Billions of dollars from bonus bids, lease rentals, royalties and taxes would enhance...

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hydroelectric Energy

...the commencement of time, water has been a vital necessity to mankind. As time progressed through the early ages of civilizations, the need to consider water as a basic need has stayed the same. Instead it has developed tremendously. This is due to the continuous growth in population throughout the planet. Since it was first invented, hydro- powered electricity has played a critical role in the improvements made by mankind. This will therefore help us in advancing for many generations to come. Humans have settled in a location with an available source of water, such as a river, a lake and so on. People had to come up with a way of harnessing this valuable natural resource and using it to our benefit. Hence the construction of mills, and dams gained some momentum. For instance, “during the industrial revolution in Britain, in the late 18th century water power played a key role in developing the industrial base of the country”(Dell & Rand, 2004). During the 18th century, the applications of water energy began to spread. According to Dell and Rand (2004), water power entered a new era in 1882 when the world’s first hydro-electric power plant began operation on the Fox River in Appleton, Wisconsin, USA. Producing 12.5 kilowatts (kW) of power, this paved the way into new ideas and projects throughout the United States and later around the world. A hydro-electric power plant works in a very organized way. Before the creation of a power plant, the land has to be surveyed in order...

Words: 3377 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

The Advantages Of Renewable Energy

...heat-capture technology like a molten salt to provide heat for generation during nighttime.  Environmental Impact Hydroelectric power generation has a considerably large footprint of impact to the environment compared to solar generation. Hydro plants often change the natural flow of the waterways where it was erected, forming new lakes and diminishing downstream water flow. Hydro installations can also affect wildlife in the area, serving as a blockage for migratory fishes and changing their habitats. Solar panels require some toxic chemicals to produce during its beginning processes, but once installed, they have a very minimal negative effect to cause on the local environment outside of taking up large amounts of leeway in industrial-scale generation facilities.  Water Management While hydroelectric power can significantly cause changes to the nature of a waterway, this occurrence can have benefits to the community extending to the downstream environment. Hydroelectric plants and also dams can form reservoirs, storing water against droughts and creating new habitats for fish and waterfowl and can also become a recreational area for nearby populations. In addition, dams can assist to minimize the effects of intense rainfall, preventing potentially catastrophic flooding by freeing water to the downstream in carefully controlled intervals. International Actions (Environmental Management July/Aug 1989 Fearnside, Phillip M.) Since International Movements for Rivers and Rights...

Words: 1522 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Engineering Ethics

...engineering is the desire to design and create technology that will benefit humanity. In particular civil engineering is concerned with the design and construction of large scale infrastructure such as dams, bridges, roads and railway. Mostly all civil engineering projects have a significant impact on the public and the environment. It is therefore necessary for engineers to make morally responsible decisions that will result in the most positive outcome for the public and environment. Three concepts that must be analysed by engineers to ensuring a positive outcome are: safety, environmental impact and cultural consideration. A number of cases will be presented to illustrate the complex nature of engineering decision and to offer potential ways in which morally responsible engineers should act. Engineering requires a high level of knowledge and expertise. As well as having a high level of technical knowledge, engineers are required to make important moral decisions which may have significant future impacts. A morally responsible engineer is an engineer who goes out of their way to make sure they are doing their job to the best of their ability. This not only includes applying their skills to make an effective product, but making sure their end product has a positive impact both on the users and the environment. An example of an engineer who may be considered morally irresponsible is someone who only completes the minimum requirements for a project. Morally responsible engineers...

Words: 1631 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Taming the Dragon - the Paradox of the Three Gorges Dam

...Taming the Dragon The Paradox of The Three Gorges Dam CHE 546 Economics, Environment and Ecology Stuart School of Business, IIT Executive Summary The title of this paper is Taming the Dragon – The Paradox of the Three Gorges Dam. I chose this title because as I researched this topic, I realized that almost everything about the Three Gorges Dam is a paradox, beginning with the reason it was planned, designed and constructed in the first place. The primary paradox of the Three Gorges Dam is that in its quest to make life better for the country and people of China, the dam also made things unbelievably and irrevocably worse on a number of levels. For centuries, China has depended on the Yangtze River. The river travels south from high in the Himalayas and then east toward the Pacific Ocean. The beauty of the pure water from the melting glacier at its source will turn into a ravaging, murderous river that robs people of their homes, food, livelihoods and even their loved ones and their own lives. Another paradox of the Three Gorges Dam is that it is an enormous monument of industrialization. It is more than a way to control water levels, protecting people from uncontrollable storm water. It is a symbol of China’s commitment to its future. Abundant, clean energy. There are those who argue that the resulting damage of the dam project is worse than the damage the river produces when it’s out of control – essentially the cure is worse than the...

Words: 12339 - Pages: 50

Free Essay

Essay

...cooking. A quarter of all early deaths are caused by respiratory diseases. This hazardous problem like uncountable diseases and death resulting from advancement in the field of science and technology and this becomes a big issue forcing scientist and economist to research and discover the most efficient and faster way to development with little impact to the living standard and lifestyle of the people. Today, the decision to build more hydroelectric dams is a controversial topic in many parts of the world as people re-examine the environmental impact of flooding large areas of land on wildlife, fish habitat and communities surrounding sites where new hydroelectric dams are being considered. Hydroelectricity also produces more power than any other energy solution, like nuclear power, wind power, solar power, and coal and gas power plants. Hydroelectric power also does not emit greenhouse gases. So it does not hurt the environment by destroying the ozone layer of the Earth. While it does not give off any emissions, it creates a tremendous problem with the environment of the river from which it is harvesting power. For example, a dam and turbine stop salmon from going up the river to spawn every year, hence greatly decreasing salmon populations. So in some ways it really is, but in some ways it isn't the case that supposed to be. Water is a unique and valuable resource. The hydraulic energy generated from water offers unique advantages: It is environmentally friendly, carbon-neutral...

Words: 976 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Environmental Sustainability

...Keonte Stevens September 20, 2014 Module 5 Assignment 1 Ecology and Environmental Sustainability Examining Your Community’s Source of Energy Each community has their own source energy that they get their power from. This type of power allows energy to be powered from their homes from solar panels then to win power. Each area is different depending on where you live, for example the power company that my family uses is Georgia power. This company has many different type of energy sources, that helps power not only my home, but many homes here in Georgia as well. Our power company produces 1100 megawatts of renewable energy as well as nuclear energy to help power our home. The main type of energy that they use for and energy source is solar energy. This is one of the most valuable types of energies around. In order to be able to use this energy, you first must use solar water heating system, so that it can absorb the suns energy. For it to do this, solar panels are placed on the roof of your home or apartment complex building, allowing it to get the power it needs to power your home. This method is more preferred to many people here in Georgia, to help get the energy they need into their homes. Hydropower is another form of energy that we use here as well. Hydropower is fuel by the water that fall from the dams. Once powered, the water is then released and begins to generate the power that is needed. The thing that makes this energy...

Words: 1770 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Water Diversions

...water diversions AP Environmental Science Water Diversions Purpose: - Analyze the effects of water diversions on surrounding ecosystems and human communities. - Compare and contrast the problems and successes of various water diversions and describe possible remediation. Introduction: Humans have been diverting water for irrigation, flood control, and a constant drinking supply for thousands of years. When populations were small, the diversions were small. Over the last 150 years human populations have grown rapidly and our technical abilities have vastly improved. These two changes, worldwide, have led to many large-scale projects that have altered the environment of sizable regions. This investigation focuses on three major water diversions- the Salton Sea, Aral Sea, and the Colorado River. Part 1: The Salton Sea 1. Describe the location of the Salton Sea. What is the climate and geography of the area? 2. How did the Salton Sea form? Explain what role humans played. 3. What is the present condition of this body of water? How has it changed over the last 25 years? Why? 4. Describe several ways the Salton Sea has altered the ecosystem of the region. Explain the stability of that ecosystem. How is it changing over time? 5. Outline 3 environmental and 3 economic reasons the Salton Sea is important. 6. What steps are being taken to remediate the Salton Sea? What are the chances of success? Explain...

Words: 733 - Pages: 3