Premium Essay

Expropriation

In:

Submitted By rocodiho
Words 309
Pages 2
Nationalization &; Expropriation
Nationalization is defined as the concept of a government seizing the private property of foreign nationals. In other words, nationalization is the alteration or assumption of control or ownership of private property by the state. It is historically a more recent development and differs in motive and degree from “expropriation” or “eminent domain,” which is the right of government to take property for particular public purposes (such as the construction of roads, reservoirs, or hospitals), normally accompanied by the payment of compensation. Nationalization may occur through the transfer of a company’s assets to the state or through the transfer of the share capital, leaving the company in existence to carry on its business under state control.
Nationalization has often accompanied the implementation of communist or socialist theories of government, history tells us, as was the case in the transfer of industrial, banking, and insurance enterprises to the state in Russia after 1918. More recently, a further impetus has been resentment of foreign control over industries upon which the state may be largely dependent, as in the nationalization of the oil industries in Mexico in 1938 and Iran in 1951, and in the nationalization of foreign businesses in Cuba in 1960. In my view, another motivating factor for recent nationalizations may be the belief in some developing countries that state control of various industrial operations is at least temporarily necessary because of the lack of a developed capital market or supply of entrepreneurs in the domestic private sector.
Venezuela and Bolivia’s political uncertainty and a recent history of actual and threatened nationalizations, and increasing state intervention in the private sector has created a debate in the international scene. There a many talks about whether or not these actions by

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Nationalization

...investment law, the initial meaning of protecting foreign investors equals to protecting them from illegal expropriation by the host countries. The trend of investment liberalization is marked with and resulted from the conclusion of most BITs and some important regional investment treaties since nineties of the 20th Century, the existing of all the stereotype expropriation clauses have confirmed the principle that host countries must compensate the foreign investors due to expropriation. The problem concerning compensation standard, which is once sensitive and disputable, has also led to a specific and unanimous answer. The composition and finding of expropriation are much clear for a long period of time. However the answer becomes unclear again with the rapid expansion of expropriation concept. The modern investment treaties define the expropriation clause in three forms, direct expropriation, indirect expropriation and any measure equivalent to or similar to expropriation. Although it is held that the so called “equivalent to or similar to” do not create the third form of expropriation, the expression of indirect or similar expropriation will continue to be widely used and will expand the concept of expropriation in an effective way. The expropriation clause has become the first choice for the investors to claim the host country for compensation. The claims of indirect expropriation have been regarded as a threat to the regulation power of host country in the current international...

Words: 287 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Imputable Acts and Nonimputable Acts

...outside their scope of authority if the state provided the means or facilities to accomplish the act. States are not responsible for the acts of private persons, acts of officials of other states or international organizations, or acts of insurrectionaries within their own territories. (4) Classical Case: Sandline International Inc. v. Papua New Guinea (5) Conclusion – What is your stand? Expropriations Question 4. (1) Summary of case in Question 4. (2) Concept to be used: Imputability, Terrorism (3) Discuss the case: This is a case of expropriation post the major political change in Ruraltania. Expropriation or nationalization is the state’s taking or deprivation of the property of foreigners. The right of states to expropriate foreign property is universally recognized. Expropriation is regarded as proper so long as it is done for a legitimate public purpose and the state pays prompt, adequate, and effective compensation. By “adequate” compensation is meant the...

Words: 332 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Case Study: Julia Lemon's Vs Eminent Domain

... Julia Lemon's versus Eminent Domain Devaira Welch Social Studies Mrs. Chidester March11, 2015 Abstract What would you do and how would you feel if someone stole your property and home. In most cases this would be unlawful theft. But the government and big companies uses lawful theft under the eminent domain law. Eminent Domain is a legal way for the government and big companies to steal your property and home. How would you feel if someone stole your property and home? In most cases this would be unlawful theft. But the government uses lawful theft to do just that. Eminent domain also known as the right for the government to take your property and home for the public good, it is the power of the state to snatch a person’s land for public good or use. They have to pay you something for stealing from you even if it does not meet your needs. What they don’t need however is your consent. This law lets the government and big companies to steal from the poor and give to the rich. Now isn’t this something Robin Hood stole from the rich and gave it to the poor and they wanted to hang him for it. Just as many people that you have for eminent domain there is just as many people that are also against eminent domain. Mrs. Julia Lemon’s a 93 year old woman in Georgia had the place she lived for 26 years stolen off from under her by a big hospital in Georgia. Mrs. Lemon fought for her rights. There is always people for and people against eminent domain. There are pros and cons to eminent...

Words: 760 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Nationalization &; Expropriation

...Nationalization is defined as the concept of a government seizing the private property of foreign nationals. In other words, nationalization is the alteration or assumption of control or ownership of private property by the state. It is historically a more recent development and differs in motive and degree from “expropriation” or “eminent domain,” which is the right of government to take property for particular public purposes (such as the construction of roads, reservoirs, or hospitals), normally accompanied by the payment of compensation. Nationalization may occur through the transfer of a company’s assets to the state or through the transfer of the share capital, leaving the company in existence to carry on its business under state control. Nationalization has often accompanied the implementation of communist or socialist theories of government, history tells us, as was the case in the transfer of industrial, banking, and insurance enterprises to the state in Russia after 1918. More recently, a further impetus has been resentment of foreign control over industries upon which the state may be largely dependent, as in the nationalization of the oil industries in Mexico in 1938 and Iran in 1951, and in the nationalization of foreign businesses in Cuba in 1960. In my view, another motivating factor for recent nationalizations may be the belief in some developing countries that state control of various industrial operations is at least temporarily necessary because of the lack...

Words: 1262 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Nationalization and Expropriation

...Article XII: Organization and Management Section 1.  Structure of the Fund The Fund shall have a Board of Governors, an Executive Board, a Managing Director, and a staff, and a Council if the Board of Governors decides, by an eighty-five percent majority of the total voting power, that the provisions of Schedule D shall be applied. Section 2.   Board of Governors * (a) All powers under this Agreement not conferred directly on the Board of Governors, the Executive Board, or the Managing Director shall be vested in the Board of Governors. The Board of Governors shall consist of one Governor and one Alternate appointed by each member in such manner as it may determine. Each Governor and each Alternate shall serve until a new appointment is made. No Alternate may vote except in the absence of his principal. The Board of Governors shall select one of the Governors as Chairman. * (b) The Board of Governors may delegate to the Executive Board authority to exercise any powers of the Board of Governors, except the powers conferred directly by this Agreement on the Board of Governors. * (c) The Board of Governors shall hold such meetings as may be provided for by the Board of Governors or called by the Executive Board. Meetings of the Board of Governors shall be called whenever requested by fifteen members or by members having one-quarter of the total voting power. * (d) A quorum for any meeting of the Board of Governors shall be a majority of the Governors having not...

Words: 1948 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Expropriation Of La Opinión

...The founding of La Opinión took place in 1971, amidst an accelerating heavy government hand within the press as a result of increasing dissidence by groups across Argentine society. In the prior decades, rather than a strict focus upon dissidence, the relationship between media and politics was that of using the former to pursue the ends of the latter. In other words, Colonel Juan Perón, elected president in 1946, was the first of his kind to use the Argentine media in order to sway the public “through direct expropriation, selective advertising, propaganda, nationalization politics, censorship and at times, thuggish intimidation” (Samples, p. 6). Many of these approaches were used in Perón’s well-known expropriation of La Prensa, a newspaper...

Words: 460 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Kuch Bhi

...------------------------------------------------- Team 129R 5th National Law School International Arbitration Moot Court Competition, 2012 ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- In the matter of an Arbitration at, Somali City, Democratic Republic of Calona under the Calona-Nolania Bilateral Investment Treaty ------------------------------------------------- Wayne Electronics.........................................................................................................Claimant v. Democratic Republic of Calona……........................................................................Respondent ------------------------------------------------- (Arb/Cas/12/35) ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Memorandum for Respondent ------------------------------------------------- Table of Contents Table of Abbreviations I Index of Authorities IV Statement of Jurisdiction XI Statement of Facts XII Questions Presented XV Summary of Pleadings XVI Arguments Advanced 1 I. The Tribunal Does Not Have Jurisdiction Over The Claims Brought Before It. 1 A. The undertaking of the Claimant does not amount to an investment. 1 B. The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction over contractual matters. 2 1. The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction over contractual disputes because of an exclusive dispute resolution clause...

Words: 14275 - Pages: 58

Free Essay

Renationalization of Ypf Under International Law

...THE RENATIONALIZATION OF YPF UNDER INTERNATIONAL LAW; A CASE STUDY Nina van Limburg Stirum Brouwersgracht 48-1, 1013GX Amsterdam 0621500446 Ninavls@hotmail.com 10127305 Bachelor essay supervisor: Jim Mathis Contents THE RENATIONALIZATION OF YPF UNDER INTERNATIONAL LAW; A CASE STUDY Introduction 3 Chapter 1: Expropriation and Nationalization in general 3 Chapter 2: Nationalization under international law 5 1: Public Purpose 6 2: Discrimination 7 3: Due Process 8 4: Compensation 9 Investment Treaties 9 Chapter 3: YPF; Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales 13 Short history 13 April 2012 14 Chapter 4: Nationalization of YPF under international law 15 Access to the ICSID 17 Application of the law 18 Ad. 1: Public interest 18 Ad. 2: Discriminatory measures 19 Ad. 3:In accordance with the law (Due process) 20 Ad. 4: Adequate compensation 20 Conclusion 23 Bibliography 24 Introduction On the 16th April 2012 Argentine president Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner stated that her government was going to renationalize 51 per cent of the 58 per cent share of Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales (YPF) owned by Repsol. YPF is the biggest Argentine oil company, since 1999 partly owned by the Spanish multinational Repsol. After months of negotiations the Argentine government accused Repsol of not investing sufficiently in YPF to maintain or recover reserves. Due to Repsol’s alleged neglect towards YPF the country...

Words: 8411 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Nafta and Environmental Protection

...the use of Chapter 11 to defend foreign investor rights. The poignant question remains whether these rights do and should take precedence over environmental considerations. This Paper looks at the treatment of investor protection measures and environmental protections contained within NAFTA with a view to their application within international arbitration cases. | NAFTA and Environmental Protection: Falling Short of the Mark A Look at some of the lasting consequences of investor protection Measures Contents Introduction 2 NAFTA Investor Protection Measures 3 Article 1102: National Treatment 3 Article 1103: Most-Favored-Nation Treatment 6 Article 1104 & 1105: Domestic & International Minimum Standards 7 Article 1110: Expropriation and Compensation 8 The Basis for Legal Challenges 11 NAFTA Environmental Protections 13 Article 104: Environmental and Conservative Agreements 14 Article 1114: Environmental Measures 16 Language across all Environmental Provisions 17 Enforcement of Environmental Protections 18 Cases of NAFTA Chapter 11 Arbitration 19 Ethyl Corporation v. Canada 20 S.D. Myers v. Canada 21 Concluding Remarks 22 Bibliography 26 Introduction In Canada, we are proud of our resource driven prosperity and the standard of living it provides us through international trade. In 1992 the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was negotiated between the leaders of Canada, the United States, and Mexico, with the intent of encouraging a new age of...

Words: 7424 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Acco 320 Assignment

...Nesrine Jebali January 17th, 2012 ID# 9219986 ACCO 320 – Section F Problems 13-12 & 13-13 * 13-12 a) * PE GAAP 1. | Loss from Accident | $800,000 | | | Liability for Accident | | $800,000 | Note to financial statements: Hamilton Airlines is faced with a personal injury suit for $4,000,000. The company estimates that it will likely have to charge $800,000 in estimated losses for the accident in 2011. 2. Loss from uninsured accident | $3,000,000 | | Liability for uninsured accident | | $3,000,000 | Note to financial statements: The company is faced with 18 personal injury suits of $5,000,000 due to an accident on Flight No. 901 that occurred in 2011. Hamilton Airlines is recording a charge of $3,000,000 as the appropriate estimate for expected losses that it is likely to have to pay. * IFRS 1. | Loss from Accident | 800,000 | | | Liability for Accident | | 800,000 | Note to financial statements: Hamilton Airlines is faced with a personal injury suit for $4,000,000. The company estimates that it will probably (more likely than not) have to charge $800,000 in estimated losses for the accident in 2011. 2. Loss from uninsured accident | $3,000,000 | | Liability for uninsured accident | | $3,000,000 | Note to financial statements: The company is faced with 18 personal injury suits of $5,000,000 due to an accident on Flight No. 901 that...

Words: 694 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Summary Of The Many Headed Hydra

...In chapter one (The Wreck of the Sea-Venture) of their book The Many Headed Hydra, authors Peter Linebaugh and Marcus Rediker argue that the “development of English Atlantic capitalism in the early seventeenth century (is characterized by the themes of) expropriation, the struggle for alternative ways of life, patterns of cooperation and resistance, and the imposition of class discipline.” Essentially, the authors contend that the development of capitalism was enabled by the systematic exploitation of the English commoner in order to turn a profit for the Virginia Company and its shareholders. One means of such exploitation was through expropriation, whereby landowners in England enclosed lands which commoners would formerly toil. “The partisans...

Words: 357 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Master

...Multinational enterprises A multinational enterprise (MNE) is a company that has a worldwide approach to markets and production or one with operations in more than a country. An MNE is often called multinational corporation (MNC) or transnational company (TNC). MNC as beauty - Potential contribution to economic growth and national welfare. - Important agent of change. - Increases competitive pressures on domestic firms. - Demonstrates and diffuses new technology. - Upgrades the quality of indigenous resources and capabilities. - Governments (in general) praise FDI. MNC as beast - Negative impact on the environment, labor and human rights. - MNCs’ and national state goals are not always compatible - MNCs out-compete local firms. MNCs have immense political power. 51 of the 100 biggest economies in the world are now MNCs. Business is in the driver’s seat, corporations determine the rules of the game and governments have become referees, only enforcing rules. Are MNCs really agents of technological change? Some scholars question the efficiency of MNCs, suggesting that they have become too large and bureaucratic to compete against more nimble and innovative smaller firms that are rapidly gaining advantage in highly competitive global markets. What is the three primary states of mind / attitudes toward the MBC? Ethnocentric (home-country oriented) - Home nationals are the best person to do the job - What works at home must work in the host country Costs: Fewer Innovations, lack of...

Words: 3130 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Merge and Acquisition

...Philip Morris Companies and Kraft, Inc. Case #1 Student questions - Philip Morris Companies and Kraft, Inc 1. Why is Kraft a takeover target? 2. Should Philip Morris buy Kraft? 3. Does the market think this offer is good for Philip-Morris? 4. Does the market think this offer is good for Kraft shareholders? Why? Set of events 1. Kraft stock price around $60 in early October of 1988 2. October 18th, Philip Morris offers $90 cash for each share of Kraft 3. Kraft management does not like this --argue that offer is too low --on Oct. 24th, Kraft management proposes a restructuring- argue it is worth $110 per share Question #1: Does the market think this offer is good for Philip-Morris? * Market did not like Philip-Morris’s prior diversification moves * Stock price goes down on October 18th by $4.50 per share (-5.5% abnormal return) -+ shareholder loss of $1.3 bil. Question #2: Does the market think this offer is good for Kraft shareholders? Why? * Stock price goes up to above $90 * Kraft shareholders are much richer * Potential for --improved offer --a restructuring plan --an offer by another potential acquirer Question #3: What does the market think of the restructuring plan? Stock price goes up to $102 -+ market believes restructuring will not occur or is not worth $110 a share Would a restructured Kraft be worth much more than the old $60 per share- appears to be a well-run company ...

Words: 483 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Multicultural Business Quiz

...Chapter 1 – Assessing the Environment – Political, Economic, Legal, Technological Multiple Choice Questions 1. One indicator of globalism is that foreign direct investment has grown ____________ the world output of goods. a. as fast as b. twice as fast as more than three times as fast as (difficult, page 5) c. negatively compared to 2. The European Union (EU) has now caught up with the United States to share the position of the world’s ____________. a. largest debtor largest investor (moderate, page 5) b. largest market c. largest tariff-free market 3. The TRIAD market consists of which regions? a. Western Europe, Eastern Europe, and North America b. Western Europe, Asia, and the United States c. Western Europe, Asia, and North America (moderate, page 5) d. Europe, Southeast Asia, and the Americas 4. Which of the following countries is not one of the Four Tigers? a. South Korea b. Hong Kong c. Taiwan d. Thailand (moderate, page 6) 5. Which of the following best describes the keiretsu and chaebol? a. control b. globalize c. conglomerate (moderate, page 6) d. culturally diverse 6. Which of the following does not characterize keiretsu and chaebol? a. financially linked entities b. market the same products (moderate, page 6) c. play a significant role in their nation’s economies d. function like a trade barrier to U.S. firms ...

Words: 3640 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

234534523423423

...entity's financial statements but before those financial statements are issued or are available to be issued (as discussed in Section 855-10-25), information may become available indicating that an asset was impaired or a liability was incurred after the date of the financial statements or that there is at least a reasonable possibility that an asset was impaired or a liability was incurred after that date. The information may relate to a loss contingency that existed at the date of the financial statements, for example, an asset that was not insured at the date of the financial statements. On the other hand, the information may relate to a loss contingency that did not exist at the date of the financial statements, for example, threat of expropriation of assets after the date of the financial statements or the filing for bankruptcy by an entity whose debt was guaranteed after the date of the financial statements. In none of the cases cited in this paragraph was an asset impaired or a liability incurred at the date of the financial statements, and the condition for accrual in paragraph 450-20-25-2(a) is, therefore, not met. [pic] SUBMIT FEEDBACK[pic][pic] PERSONAL ANNOTATION[pic] 25-7      If a loss cannot be accrued in the period when it is probable that an asset had been impaired or a liability had been incurred because the amount of loss cannot be reasonably estimated, the loss shall be charged to the income of the period in which the loss can be reasonably estimated and shall...

Words: 2101 - Pages: 9