Free Essay

Healthsouth

In:

Submitted By lamboak
Words 4758
Pages 20
As I have mentioned previously, provide a new file name for the assignment you are working on using the Northcentral naming convention: Learner’s last name, first initial, course code, dash, and assignment number (DoeJXXX0000-1) EXAMPLE: John Doe, PSY300, Assignment 1 = DoeJPSY300-1.

BUSINESS ETHICS
OKECHUKWU AKANNO Sr.
NORTHCENTRAL UNIVERSITY
ASSIGNMENT#8
MGT7019-8
Dr. JENNIFFER SCOTT
September 16, 2012

Learner: OKECHUKWU AKANNO

||
MGT7019-8| Dr. JENNIFFER SCOTT|
||
BUSINESS ETHICS | #8|
||

Faculty Use Only

TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE
Abstract --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4
Introduction ------------------------------------------------------------------------------5 & 6
The role of Auditors at HealthSouth ---------------------------------------- 7 & 8
SEC Investigation ----------------------------------------------------------------------------9&10
Impact on Stakeholders ---------------------------------------11, 12, 13 & 14
Outcome and Fairness In Punishment ---------------------------------------- 15, 16 & 17
Conclusion -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------18
References-------------------------------------------------------------------------------19, 20 & 21

ABSTRACT
This paper will investigate the financial reporting scandals of the past decade at HealthSouth and the resulting U.S. legislative attempts to impose ethical behavior and control the incidence of new reporting problems via Sarbanes-Oxley legislation. This paper begins with a brief historical perspective followed by assertions of ethical consequences of legislation with discussions of key recent corporate scandals, the motives for the frauds, greed, the impact on stakeholders and the consequences of the outcome of guilty verdict.

INTRODUCTION
Richard Scrushy, once a high school dropout, worked as a gas station attendant and a bricklayer before returning to school and earning his diploma. He studied at University of Alabama, Birmingham and graduated with a degree in respiration therapy in 1994. After graduation, he became an instructor at UAB. In 1979, Scrushy left the academia and took up a position at a Texas health care management firm. The firm was sold in 1983 and Scrushy decide to go on his own with a new business idea. In 1984, with the help from some of his friends and an initial investment of $50,000, he founded HealthSouth, in Little Rock, Arkansas. In 1985, he moved the company to Birmingham, Alabama, (Heylar, 2003) . HealthSouth went public in 1986.
Richard Scrushy spotted certain trends that he incorporated in his very successful business model for HealthSouth. These trends were: Lower reimbursement for medical care, new emphasis on rehabilitation as opposed to surgery, the need to get employees back to work faster, and the absence of brand names in health care. He also wanted his rehabilitation centers to look more like upscale clubs than a hospital. He used his super sales skills, boundless energy and entrepreneurial skill in setting up clinics, making acquisitions and expanding the company. He concentrated on acquiring contracts with managed care operations and self-insured companies for workers’ compensation rehabilitation. He focused on individual facilities on specific ailments. To keep costs down, he standardized the physical layouts of his facilities and used same floor plan and furnishing for all locations (Hoover’s 2006).
By 1988, HealthSouth had expanded to nearly 40 facilities in 50 states. Scrushy expanded HealthSouth through acquisitions. The company acquired most of the rehabilitation services, business of National Medical Enterprise and became the largest provider of rehabilitation services in 1993. By 1992, HealthSouth was generating revenues to the tune of $400 million and operated 145 clinics. Scrushy formed Med Partners and entered physician practice management (PPM) field. Scrushy engineered many acquisitions and Med Partners became the largest PPM in the country. HealthSouth further expanded into inpatient rehabilitation hospitals and outpatient surgery centers (Hoover’s 2006). HealthSouth also entered the traditional hospital field in 2000 through acquisition of a hospital in Birmingham, Alabama and announced plans for a $300 million “digital hospital” near its corporate center. By 2000, the company was dominated by the rehabilitation services market and was very profitable. Eventually, HealthSouth became the largest provider of outpatient surgery, diagnostic and imaging services as well as rehabilitation services in the United States with 1,700 facilities and 51,000 employees.
As head of third largest publicly held company in Alabama, and one of the fastest growing health care companies in the country, Richard Scrushy became a celebrity in Birmingham (Alabama). As a philanthropist, he made sizable donations to charities, churches and universities. However, Scrushy was also known as an ambitious man who wanted to be the highest paid CEO in the United States. He was a strong leader, surrounded by friends and colleagues who learned to do things his way, or get out of the way. He was even called “supercilious bully” by some ex-colleagues. Scrushy was terminated from the company after the SEC sued HealthSouth for “cooking the books” in March 2003 (Heylar, 2003).
THE ROLE OF AUDITORS AT HEALTHSOUTH
HealthSouth’s auditors, Ernst and Young (E&Y) failed to uncover the $2.5 billion systematic overstatement of earnings and they allowed the company to keep on its books’ $500 million of overvalued accounts receivables owed to it by financially distressed health care technology firms without insisting on establishing adequate reserves for these receivables (Glater, 2003).
E&Y also had other non-audit business dealings with HealthSouth. In 2000-01 the accounting firm conducted a janitorial, cleanliness and physical appearance inspection of HealthSouth facilities. E&Y used a 50-point checklist designed by Scrushy. The pristine audit scores were used by HealthSouth in its marketing campaign. The accounting firm received the $2.6 million fee for the inspection as “audit related fee.” The work clearly is not audit related. This raises suspicion about the impartiality and independence of the auditors (Weil, 2003, 2003a).
HealthSouth’s former head of internal audit offered the following testimony before Congress on the HealthSouth hearings:
My name is Teresa Sanders, and I currently live in Birmingham, Alabama. I am 39 years old. In 1986, I graduated from the University of Alabama with a degree in the accounting. I received my master’s degree in accounting in 1988.
I began working with Ernst & Young, (E&Y) in August of 1998 as a staff auditor, and I was laid off in February of 1990. In March of that year (1990), I was hired by HealthSouth as the Internal Auditor. During my employment, I received three promotions, and when I left, my title became Group Vice President and Chief Auditing Officer. My immediate supervisor was Richard Scrushy, and I reported directly to him for over nine years. I left HealthSouth in November of 1999.
As part of my duties as the Chief Auditing Officer, I had to make reports to the audit committee of the Board of Directors. All the meetings that I had with the audit committee were before the full board except one time in either 1997 or 1998, when I met separately with the audit committee. However, that meeting was attended by Tony Tanner. In 1996, Richard Scrushy approached me about establishing a fifty (50) point check-list which became known as the “Pristine Audit.” After Mr. Scrushy asked me to develop the check-list, I sent him a memo expressing my opinion about the check-list. Mr. Scrushy did not appreciate my opinion on the matter and again instructed me to develop the check-list for his approval. Mr. Scrushy informed me that the Pristine Audit was to be handled by Ernst & Young.
I developed the fifty (50) point checklist which Mr. Scrushy approved. As you can see, the Pristine checklist has nothing to do with auditing the financial books of a field facility. The Pristine Audit was nothing more than a cosmetic, white glove, walk through of a facility. It was in the nature of quality control and had nothing to do with the financial viability of a particular facility.
By the time I left HealthSouth, I was having problem with Mike Martin. He turned off my computer access to the general ledgers of the field operations. If I needed access to those ledgers to do my audits, I had to manually retrieve hard copies of those ledgers, if needed, which was very time consuming. I also did not like the way HealthSouth Handled an internal sexual harassment investigation. It was my opinion that the offending employee should have been terminated. I heard that, ”they were playing with the books,” I had no knowledge that anyone was committing fraud. I ultimately left HealthSouth because I received a better job offer with Eastern Health Services Systems in the compliance department as the Compliance Officer…67

SEC INVESTIGATION
HealthSouth is perhaps the most egregious illustration of unethical and fraudulent behavior. Recent estimates indicate the accounting fraud may have manufactured $4 billion of false earnings (MSNBC, 2004). Once again, the tone at the top led to a slippery slope of unethical actions. According to the SEC indictment, senior officers would present actual results to the CEO, each quarter and if they were short of explanations, he would tell them to fix them. The accounting personnel then convened in “family Meeting” and discussed what false accounting entries to make in other to inflate earnings. The focus was on altering the contractual adjustments account (Common in Health care to recognize differences between gross billings and what health care providers will pay) to increase net revenue. The adjustment was balanced by falsifying fixed assets accounts. To further the fraud, many HealthSouth’s accounting personnel were prior employees of the auditor, Ernst and Young, and knew the adjustment they could make that would not be detected in audit procedures. If the auditors did question an entry, the HealthSouth accountant creates false documents to support it (SEC, 2003c).
The CEO, Schrushy, personally profited selling $7.7 million shares of stock when the price was artificially inflated by accounting numbers as well as bonus payments and salary payments.
HealthSouth’s ethical problems also existed at the Board level. Three directors’ had significant ties to the company, one earned $250,000 in consulting fees, one has owned expensive resort property with the CEO, and one had a $5.6 million contract to install glass at HealthSouth hospital. The same three served on the combined audit and compensation committee (Lubin and Cams, 2003). The SEC accused Former HealthSouth management of fabricating $2.74 billion in earnings and charged them with fraud, reporting violations, and internal controls violations. Fifteen financial employees pleaded guilty. Scruchy has been indicted on 85 counts and he has pleaded not-guilty (Bassing, 2003). Scrushy was the first CEO to be charged under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act for signing a false certification of financial statements. Scrushy’s attorneys have fought the charge with rebuttal that Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 is unconstitutional and should be repealed (National Accounting News, 2003). Meanwhile, Scrushy has become a religious talk show host (CBSNews, 2004).
HealthSouth case, illustrate a corrupt tone at the top that emphasized making the numbers at the expense of doing the right thing. Collusion, top management pressure on employees to act unethically, personal greed and gain, audit failures and a corrupt corporate culture were common across HealthSouth Corporation. Is it possible for the legislation to prevent further unethical and fraudulent behavior in the corporation like we have witnessed in this case? The U.S. Congress has attempted to do so with the Sarbanes-Oxley legislation of 2002, however, the regulations are aimed not only at Corporate America but also at the CPA firms who perform their audits. The major international CPA firms have demonstrated similar ethical problems. “Too many CEOs are being judged today not by how effectively they manage operations, but by how they manage the street. And, too many auditors are being judged not just by how well they manage an audit, but by how well they cross-market their firm’s non-audit services” (Levitt, 2000).
IMPACT ON STAKEHOLDERS
The eighties proved to be very profitable to Amcare who formerly changed the company’s name to HealthSouth in 1985. Scrushy took the company public the following year and between the years of 1986 and 1994. With a style worthy of jealously, Scrushy built his empire to the point where they surpassed the $1 billion mark in revenues with record breaking expansions. Perhaps more importantly than general industry expansion for HealthSouth during the 1980s was Scrushy’s and his fellow managers’ unique operating strategy. When HealthSouth got started in 1984, rehabilitation were stereotyped as drab, institution-like facilities with generally, mediocre staff. Scrushy wanted to change that image. Borrowing from Health clubs, he designed his rehab centers as bright, open-spaced, mirrored rooms with trained physical therapists and sporty equipment. The centers more closely resembled high-priced health clubs than traditional hospital-styled rehab centers, and doctors became increasingly willing to send patients to a HealthSouth facility for treatment. Scrushy added a few more HealthSouth outlets and by 1985 was generating nearly $5 million in annual revenues.
HealthSouth added new rehab centers to its chain throughout the middle and late 1980s. Because of the company’s unique recipe for success, its centers became known as effective and cost-efficient, and as models for other companies in the rehab industry.
Rather than focusing on a specific rehab niche, such as head and spinal injuries, HealthSouth differed from many of its competitors in that it targeted the market for less expensive, general outpatient rehabilitation services. HealthSouth’s facilities were built around a large gymnasium, in which some patients rode exercise bikes while listening to rock music. Old and young people worked out side by side, often with the help of therapist, while others enjoyed physical, occupational, or speech therapy in private treatment rooms. Some of the machines even were hooked to computers that fed reports to doctors about how patient were responding to treatment. HealthSouth appealed to the medical community by offering a number of rehabilitation programs tailored for different ailments. At the urging of Dr. Scott Burke, a Denver spinal rehabilitations specialist, HealthSouth designed a program to treat back problems. Becoming widely used, the whole package—incorporating stretching, aerobic conditioning, anatomy education, and simulation exercises about four weeks and cost a total of only $3,700, which was much less than the patient might otherwise spend on unnecessary surgeries and hospital costs. HealthSouth also began offering special services for the lucrative sports rehabilitation market. To that end, HealthSouth eventually launched an entire sports division with separate facilities and prominent doctors. Dr. Jim Andrews, one of HealthSouth’s most renowned surgeons, treated such celebrities as Bo Jackson, Jane Fonda, and Charles Berkley, among others, (Company Histories, 2000).
HealthSouth began series of acquisitions and by 1988 they were operating 21 outpatient facilities, 11 impatient facilities and seven rehabilitation equipment centers in 15 states. Sales had spiraled upward at an average of more than 100 percent annually since 1984, peaking at $75 million in 1988, Revenues shot up to $114 million in 1989 and then to $181 million in 1990, about $13 million of which was netted as income. In fact, HealthSouth managed to post successive profits every year after 1985. Aside from increasing its customer base at existing centers, the company grew by purchasing other rehab and health care companies and restructuring them to fit into the HealthSouth organization. It was in December 1989, for example, that Scrushy jumped into the sports rehab business when he paid $21 million for a 219-bed general hospital in Birmingham that specialized in orthopedic surgery and sports medicine, (Company History, 2000). HealthSouth continued to grow and by the mid-1990s was operating 31 outpatient and 14 inpatient rehabilitation centers in 21 states making a leader in the U.S rehabilitation industry. The company continued to add new general rehabilitation centers to its chain in 1991 and 1992.
HealthSouth sustained its aggressive growth drive throughout 1995, snapping up several smaller competitors. Significantly, in October 1995 HealthSouth announced that it had agreed to purchase the rehabilitation services operations of Caremark International for $127 million in cash. The Caremark operations consisted of 123 outpatient rehabilitation facilities that were generating about $80 million in annual revenues. That gave the company a total of about 440 outpatient facilities and about 40 percent of the total rehabilitation market. HealthSouth also bought Diagnostic Health Corporation, which offered outpatient imaging services. Perhaps most notable was the early 1995 acquisition of Surgical Health Corporation, which represented HealthSouth’s diversification into an entirely new market: outpatient surgery services. The $1.1 billion acquisition, the company’s largest to date, immediately catapulted HealthSouth into the lead as the top operator of outpatient surgery centers in the nation, (HealthSouth, 2010).
HealthSouth’s steady string of acquisitions did not end as the company headed into the second half of the decade. Purchases in 1996 included Surgical Care Affiliates, Inc, which included 67 outpatient surgery centers in 24 states, for an estimated$ 1.4 billion, Advantage Health Corporation, which owned about 136 inpatient and outpatient rehabilitation centers in 11 states, for about$315 million; Professional Sport Care Management, Inc., which included 36 outpatient rehabilitation centers in New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, for about $59 million occupational health; and Ready care , Inc which operated 37 surgical facilities in 14 states, and also acquired 34 surgery centers from Columbia/HCA Healthcare Corporation.
HealthSouth had nearly 2,000 locations in 50 states, Puerto Rico, the United Kingdom, and Australia by the end of the decade. The company had enjoyed phenomenal growth since its inception in 1984 and believed it was poised to overcome the obstacles of the rehabilitative health care, outpatient surgery, and diagnostic imaging markets. HealthSouth hoped to realize and maintain its standing as ‘the healthcare company of the 21st century, (HealthSouth, 2010).
What was actually going on behind the closed board room doors of HealthSouth some experts believe corporate America should have been able to see coming. Geoffrey Calvin, in an article written for Fortune Magazine would give his opinion regarding what was happening to HealthSouth and compare it to what happened in companies with similar make ups. Calvin writes, “With the continuing stream of juicy revelations from HealthSouth, already on the A list of business scandals, we’re in for another round of hand-wringing over the widening crisis in corporate America. But what’s most striking about the HealthSouth debacle is not what’s new but what’s familiar, how perfectly it fits the highly specific pattern already established by Enron, WorldCom, Adelphia and Tyco. While these scandals are certainly a crisis for corporate America---polls show most Americans now think CEOs are crooks until proven otherwise---the crisis seems to be in a remarkably narrow slice of it, (Calvin, 2003). “We have learned the same thing again and again: financial fraud does not start with dishonesty, your boss does not come to you and say, ‘let’s do some financial fraud’. Fraud occurs because the culture has become infected. It spreads like an unstoppable virus”, (Young, 2003). The company’s damages have led HealthSouth to lay off a lot of workers whose lives and families have been thrown into confusion, and possibly into desperation. Millions of families have had their healthcare in jeopardy as a result of the fraud at HealthSouth and the company’s later “downsizing” have taken its toll, (people’sworld.org) .
OUTCOME AND FAIRNESS IN PUNISHMENT
The Scrushy trial began in January 2005. Following jury selection, the chief federal prosecutor, Alice M. Martin, alleged that Scrushy was the mastermind behind the financial fraud at HealthSouth and that he knew about, participated in, and profited from the conspiracy. The defense contended that Scrushy was a victim of the fraud; that the fraud was conceived and perpetrated by senior accounting personnel who misled Scrushy and the outside auditors. The defense attacked the credibility of HealthSouth’s CFOs, claiming that they agreed to the plea bargain and to testify against Scrushy to gain reduced sentences.
Former CFO William T. Owens in cooperation with the Federal Bureau of Investigation wore a recorder in a meeting with Scrushy. The tape indicated that Scrushy was a hand-on CEO who exhorted his senior executives to take measures to keep profits high and prevent losses on their stock investments. On the tape, Scrushy had warned of dire financial consequences both to Owens and to the company. However, Scrushy never used the words fraud, illegal or scheme in nearly three hours of the tape, (Johnson, 2005). Owen could not point to any memo or document that would indicate Scrushy’s involvement in the fraud. Owens was later sentenced to five years in prison along with two years of probation. Owens testified that Ms. Diana Henze, a former assistant vice president of finance at the company had figured out the fraud and she took her suspicions to HealthSouth’s compliance department. She was transferred to another division and was subsequently passed over for promotion (Reeves, 2005). Ms. Henze’s testimony did not directly implicate Scrushy but it did corroborate that the financials submited by the company to the government did not reflect reality.
Kenneth Livesay, a former assistant controller at HealthSouth also testified that Scrushy was aware of the fraudulent scheme. His testimony also did not implicate Scrushy directly since the CEO was not present at any of the “family” meeting that he had attended. Livesay also listed all nine of the executives who were members of the family: Scrushy’s name was not on that list. When asked why he did not confront Scrushy on the issue, he replied that it was not a common practice to discuss the fraud openly and that Scrushy was an intimidating leader whom you would not want to cross (Shmuckler, 2005). The defense contended that Livesay and others lied to hide the fraud from Scrushy and to keep their own overpaid position in the company. Livesay was later sentenced to six months of home confinement, five years of probation, a fine of $10,000, and forfeiture of $750,000in capital gains. Former Chief financial Officer Michael Martin pleaded guilty to fraud charges. Martin testified that he oversaw the accounting fraud from 1977 to his leaving in 2000 at the behest of Scrushy. He asserted that Scrushy asked him to rework the accounts to help meet Wall Street analysts’ expectations. He gave pep talks at the “family” meetings assuring the members that they will not have to do this forever and they will figure out a way to end the fraud. The defense portrayed Martin as a hothead who made idle treats to employees. In response to defense question on why he did not leave the company, Martin replied that he did not see a way out (Morse and Shmuckler, 2005). Martin was later sentenced to six month of home detention, forfeiture of $3,375,000 in capital gains, and a fine of $50,000.
Tadd McVay, Aaron Beam and Weston Smith were the other former CFOs who testified against Scrushy. They all testified that they had discussed the fraud scheme with Scrushy. Smith was sentenced to 27 months in prison, one year probation after his release from the prison and forfeiture of $1,500,000 in assets. Beam received a reduced sentence of three months in prison, $10,000 in fine, one year probation and a forfeiture of $275,000 capital gains
Prior to his indictment, Mr. Scrushy and his wife began attending weekly services at a primarily African-American congregation in Birmingham. He preached regularly at black churches in Birmingham area. He also hosted a Christmas themed TV program on which he invited prominent African-American ministers as guests. He also made large cash donations to these churches. Scrushy made an effort to build sympathy among religious conservatives and African-Americans (Romero and Wilson, 2005). Some have questioned if Scrushy’s motivation in all of this was to influence the predominantly black jury members. After 21 days of deliberation, the jury cleared Scrushy of all 36 criminal charges. The jurors, in the post-trial interview, suggested that the CFOs who testified against Scrushy lacked credibility (Johnson, 2005a). According to the jurors, the prosecutors did not present enough evidence to show that Scrushy was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
CONCLUSION
This paper has documented the failures of laws, corporate internal controls, and corporate culture to deter unethical and fraudulent financial reporting. None, alone, have stood the test of time in guaranteeing appropriate corporate ethical behavior. Sarbanes-Oxley Act broadens and deepens sanctions and penalties for unethical management behavior but does not address the relationship between management behavior and rewards. Sarbanes also calls for much greater focus on internal controls by senior management. Internal systems, including IT controls, can help reduce the opportunity for fraudulent or unethical behavior but cannot eliminate it in a world where nearly 50 percent of large corporations still use spreadsheets in some aspect of financial reporting (Hacket Group, 2004). Finally, corporate ethical failures arguably appear more likely to occur in every successful company lacking a solid ethical foundation when economic conditions changes as witnessed by our case studies and the work of (Kotter and Heskett, 1992). It is the combination of a strong ethical corporate culture (beginning with the board of directors), controls, laws, rewards, and penalties that provide a context for obtaining ethical and transparent financial reporting.
We believe that the research exploring the interactions between and among corporate culture, internal controls, social controls, and rewards/sanctions will provide better answers than we have for improving corporate financial reporting.
REFERENCES
Bassing, T (2003). HealthSouth’s Scrushy Indicted on 85 Counts: Birmingham Business Journal. Retrieved from http://baltimorebizjournals.com/Birmingham/stories/2003/11/03/
Daily9htm?Page=1
Calvin, G. (2003, March). History repeats itself at HealthSouth, Fortune Magazine.
Retrieved from http://money.cnn.com/magazine/fortune/fortune_arcchive/2003/05/12/34
2328/index.htm
CBS News (2004). Indeed CEO Turns TV Preacher: CBS News. (Retrieved from http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2004/03/18/eveningnews/main607222.shtml
Glater, J. D. (2003). HealthSouth looks Deeper into its Books. New York Times, (late Edition, East Coast). New York, NY: P. C.1
Hacket Group: (2004). Companies Ignore IT In Compliance Efforts. DMReview.com. Retrieved from http://www.dmreview.com/article-sub.cfm?article1d=8101
Helyar, J (2003, July). The Insatiable king Richard He Started A Nobody. He Became A Hotshot. He Tried To Be A Country Star. Then It All Came Crashing Down. The Bizarre Rise And Fall Of HealthSouth’s Richard Scrushy. Fortune Magazine
HealthSouth Company Profile (2010). Retrieved from http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/history2/77/HealthSouth_corporation.html Hover’s Inc. (2006, August). HealthSouth Corporation-Profile. Retrieved from http://premium.hoovers.com
International Directory Of Company Histories (2000). Saint James Press. Retrieved from http://www.fundinguniverse.com/company-histories/healthsouth-corporation-company- histories.html, Vol. 33
Johnson, C (2005). Credibility Of Ex-CFO Questioned: Owens Opportunistic, Scrushy
Lawyer said. The Washington Post (Final Edition). Washington, DC: Pg. E, 01
Johnson, C (2005a). Jury Acquits HealthSouth Founder Of All Charges. The Washington Post (Final Edition), Washington, DC: P. A.01
Korter, J., & Haskett, J. I (1992). Corporation Culture and Performance (The Free Press, New York)
Lawrence, D (2003). HealthSouth Fraud Impacts Millions, people’s world. Retrieved from http://www.peopleworld.org/healthsouth_fraud-impacts=millions
Levitt, A (2000). Renewing The Covenant with Investors, SEC Speech. Retrieved from http://www.sec.gov/news/speech/spch370.htm
Lublin, J & Cams, A (2003). Directors Had Lucrative Links at HealthSouth: Wall Street Journal, p. B1
Morse, D & Shmukler, E (2005). Executives On Trial: HealthSouth CFO’s Testimony May Bolster case for defense; Prosecution Witness Says He Punched a Co-Worker, want to kill others. Wall Street Journal, (Eastern Edition). New York, Pg. C. 4
MSNBC (2004). HealthSouth’s Fraud Larger Than Estimated. Retrieved from http://www.msnbc.msn.com/1d/40161s2
National Accounting News: (2003). Scrushy Attorneys to seek repeal of Sarbanes-Oxley: National Accounting News. Retrieve from http://www.tscpa.org/welcome/acctweb
121203.asp#1
Reeves, J (2010). Court upholds $2.9 billion verdict in HealthSouth case, USA Today. Retrieved from http://www.usatoday.com/money/companies/management/2011-01-28-healthsouth_scrushy_n.htm
Romero, S. & Wilson, G. (2005). Race, Religion and The HealthSouth Founder’s Trial: New York Times (Late Edition, East Coast): New York, NY Pg. C1
SEC: Securities and Exchange Commission v HealthSouth Corporation and Richard M. Scrushy, . Civil Action No CV 03-J-0615-S, March 19, 2003c (Government Printing Office, Washington, DC)
Shmukler, E (2005). Executives on Trial: Witness says Scrushy Skipped HealthSouth ‘Family’ Meetings. Wall Street Journal, (Eastern Edition): New York, NY. Pg C.1
67The Financial Collapse Of HealthSouth (2010, September). Subcommittee on Oversight and investigations of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. Retrieve From http://archives.energycommerce.house.gov/reparchive/108/hearings/10162003heari Ng1110/Cohen1747.htm Weil, J. (2003). HealthSouth-Proxy Document Says Company Performed Janitorial Inspection Sections, misclassified as Audit-Relate: Wall Street Journal. (Eastern Edition): New York, NY Pg. C1
Weil, J. (2003a). HealthSouth and Ernst Renew Flap Over Fee Disclosures. Wall Street Journal, (Eastern Edition): New York, NY Pg. C1
Young, M (2003). Fraud, What Starts Small Can Snowball. Financial Executive, 18(9), 18-20

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Healthsouth

...Campus HealthSouth Rehabilitation Hospital 2935 colonial Drive Columbia, SC 29203 (803) 401-1331 HealthSouth: Columbia - www.healthsouthcolumbia.com HealthSouth is one of the nation's largest healthcare services providers, operating Acute Rehab and Outpatient Rehab Centers nationwide. Our vast network of highly skilled professionals and the latest equipment and technology offers patients access to high-quality healthcare. HealthSouth Rehabilitation offers a low therapist to patient ratio guaranteeing the patient gets the one-on-one attention they deserve. Treatment is available for individuals who have suffered a major accident or illness, including trauma, stroke, head injury, spinal cord injury, hip fracture, amputation, arthritis, chronic pain, neuromuscular and pulmonary diseases. HealthSouth treats people of all ages on an outpatient basis with specialized rehabilitation programs for adolescent, adult, and geriatric populations. HealthSouth Rehabilitation Hospital of Columbia offers comprehensive outpatient therapy services. HealthSouth Rehabilitation Hospital of Columbia is a 96-bed acute care rehabilitation hospital located in Columbia, S.C. Established in 1989, we are the only freestanding comprehensive medical rehabilitation hospital in the Midlands, serving Lexington, Richland, Kershaw and surrounding counties. Health South Rehabilitation Hospital is own and operated by The Gores Group, in Los Angeles, a private equity firm. For-profit HealthSouth operates...

Words: 1895 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Healthsouth Scandal

...Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filed a civil law suit against HealthSouth Corporation and Richard M. Scrushy. The SEC charged that the company inflated their books by $1.9 billion since 1999 (SEC, 2003). The filing of these charges had a multiple impact on the stakeholders. The ethical dilemmas that caused the rise and fall of Richard M. Scrushy will be reviewed. Scrushy’s Beginnings Scrushy began his humble beginnings in Alabama. Watson (2003), biography of Scrushy reports he dropped out of high school and worked as a gas station attendant and later a bricklayer. He eventually returned back to school and earned his high school diploma. Later Scrushy enrolled at Jefferson State Community College in Birmingham. He did a year at Jefferson State and a year of clinical training at the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB). Scrushy graduated in 1974 as a certified respiratory therapist (Watson, 2003, p. 1). Once Scrushy graduated with the certification of a respiratory therapist, he began climbing the ladder. His accomplishments were as follows: * 1974 - Taught at University of Alabama Birmingham. * 1979 -1984 Vice President at LifeMark HealthCare Firm. * 1984-2003 Founded HealthSouth in Little Rock Alabama. The company began with the four colleagues from Lifemark and $50,000. Scrushy also became CEO and Chairman of HealthSouth. * 1985- Scrushy moved HealthSouth to Birmingham....

Words: 2596 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Healthsouth & the Scrushy Way

...use this as a reference. Table of Contents 1. Assignment cover sheet p. 0 2. Title page: HealthSouth and the Scrushy Way p. 1 3. Table of Contents p. 2 4. Introduction p. 3 5. Government Subsidies p. 3 6. Signs of Corruption p. 4 7. Ethical issues of HealthSouth p. 5 8. Management of HealthSouth p. 5 9. Intimidation and Cooperation p. 6 10. Culture of Corruption p. 7 11. Lavish Lifestyle and Philanthropy p. 8 12. Impact on Stakeholders p. 9 13. Charges p. 10 14. Outcome and Fairness of Punishment p. 10 15. Conclusion p. 12 16. References p. 13 HealthSouth and the Scrushy Way Richard Scrushy overcame challenging teenage years, dropping out of high school and later obtaining his GED to become one of the most successful executives in the United States. Scrushy did so by subsequently getting his respiratory therapist certification and opening his own rehabilitation center, an all-in-one medical facility that led many to copy his idea. Scrushy founded HealthSouth in 1996 using $1 million in seed capital and turned it into a hugely successful medical services empire worth over $4 billion at its prime (Haddad, Weintraub, & Grow, 2003). HealthSouth had become the largest provider of outpatient surgery, rehabilitation, and diagnostic and imaging services as well...

Words: 3288 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Healthsouth - the Scrushy Way

...HealthSouth: The Scrushy Way Vonetta M. Henderson Northcentral University Introduction The Enron and Tyco scandals brought visibility to corporate scandals. The magnitude of these scandals resulted in the Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Act in 2002. Richard M. Scrushy and HealthSouth Corporation were the first CEO and company to be indicted under the SOX Act. HealthSouth was charged with filing false financial statements with the SEC to hid poor financial conditions from Wall Street. An audit conducted by PricewaterhouseCoopers concluded that HealthSouth overstated its cumulative earnings between $3.8 billion to $4.6 billion (Weld, Bergevin, & Magrath, 2004). Although Scrushy was charged with 85 counts, he pled not-guilty, claiming that he was unaware of the fraudulent activities that had occurred. Scrushy was later exonerated as the investigation into the company found no evidence that Scrushy orchestrated or participated in any financial wrongdoings. Five financial executives and 10 other company officials pled guilty to a variety of charges. Background Richard M. Scrushy founded Amcare, Inc. in 1984. The company opened its first facility in Little Rock, Arkansas and one year later opened a facility in Birmingham and changed its name to HealthSouth Rehabilitation Corporation (HRC). In 1986, HRC went public with its initial public offering (IPO) on the NASDAQ stock exchange (HealthSouth Corporation, 2010). In 1988, HRC moved to...

Words: 1035 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Healthsouth: Fraud, Greed & Corporate Governance

...HealthSouth: Fraud, Greed & Corporate Governance Marilyn J. Bordeaux HCS 5339 Rachael Kehoe HealthSouth: Fraud, Greed & Corporate Governance During the 1990s, Richard M. Scrushy, the former CEO of HealthSouth Corporation, engineered many acquisitions of rehabilitation clinics, outpatient surgical care operators, nursing homes and other health care companies. In 2003, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) accused the company and Scrushy of inflating earnings to the tune of $1.4 billion since 1999. In November 2003, a federal grand jury indicted Scrushy on 85 counts including conspiracy, securities fraud, money laundering and charges related to overstating HealthSouth’s earnings by nearly $3.0 billion. According to federal investigators, the company overstated earnings to meet analysts’ earning estimates, while hiding the accounting fraud from the auditors. However, questions were raised whether the auditors failed to find or simply overlooked the fraud at HealthSouth. Central to the investigation was the issue of what role Scrushy played in “cooking the books.” However, as the case unfolded, it highlighted many other issues such as: The role of Board of Directors in corporate governance; the role of the auditors; the effect of conflict of interest between an accounting firm and its consulting arm on auditing; whether the relationship between an investment bank and a company affects the quality of the bank’s research reports on the company; whether the executive...

Words: 3204 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Business Research Ethics

...There has been five HealthSouth CFOs that have pleaded guilty to federal fraud charges, Beam being one of them. Richard Scrushy, founder and former CEO of HealthSouth Corp., denied that he was involved in this fraud and 36 of his fraud charges were dropped. But the following year, in 2006, Scrushy and former Alabama Governor Don Siegelman were found guilty of federal bribery charges and are now serving a six-year sentence at a Teaxas prison. Aaron Beam is a co-founder of HealthSouth. In 2005, Beam was convicted of Bank Fraud. He was sentenced to three months in jail and was fined for insider trading. He admits he made mistakes at HealthSouth and he documented the birth, the rise, and eventual crash of HealthSouth. Investigation started focusing on accounting fraud of HealthSouth in 1996, Beam decided to leave in 1997. Aaron Beam then wrote a book where he states the following information: Beam has said that fraudulent and unethical behavior has been going on for a while in the Business Industry. He also says that he wrote the book because he knows that there is a lot of unethical behavior in the leading markets and has also lead to banks closing. “What are some necessary checks and balances for ensuring accounting fraud doesn’t happen?” Board of directors plays a big role. An auditor’s job did not use to include fraud activity before. Accounting firms today are turning to forensic accountants because of this. Beam explains that the Board of Directors does a very poor job...

Words: 519 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Fwefw

...salary of $900,000 in 2011, but due to stock options he will receive 376.2 million dollars in shares (Satariano, 2012). Now as the company grows those stock options will increase drastically, making his yearly salary look like chump change. This is what encourages CEO’s to commit financial fraud by altering the company’s books to drive the stock price up, which drives his pay up. In 2002 the CEO of HealthSouth sold $100 million dollars in stock just days before the company posted a huge loss. HealthSouth over the course of seven years beginning in 1996 overstated their income by 2.7 Billion dollars ("Sec charges healthsouth," 2003). The CEO was accused of having senior accountants inflate the earnings of its facilities in order to drive up the company’s value. In addition they also misreported the sale of technology to a related party resulting in 29 million in overstatements as well. By middle of 2002 HealthSouth’s assets were also overstated by more than 800 million dollars ("Accountant describes how," 2005). How the fraud happened was the assistant controller at HealthSouth would download the companies true earnings on his computer and figure how much was needed to be made up to meet wall street’s predictions (Hamilton). While the...

Words: 616 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Fraud Triangle

...The Fraud Triangle 9/22/2012 Allison Walton | The Fraud Triangle The fraud triangle are conditions for fraud arising from fraudulent financial reporting and misappropriation of assets. These conditions are: a. Incentive/Pressure b. Opportunities c. Attitude/Rationalization The fraud triangle is depicted by the following image: Incentive/Pressure Management or other employees will have incentives or circumstances of pressure to commit fraud. If the decision is made by management to report fraudulent financial statements, the most common reason for this will be threat by economic, industry or entity operating conditions to the financial stability and profitability of the company. Excessive pressure is placed on management to meet the forecast of an analyst, company projections or to repay debt obligations. The personal net worth of the stockholders and board of directors may be materially threatened by the company’s financial performance, and management may feel obligated to meet these demands. Management may inflate stock prices to preserve their reputation and be required to do whatever it takes to meet the goal. The bonuses of management may be tied to the company’s earnings and this is a big motivator for fraudulent reporting (Fox School of Business 2009). The misappropriation of assets in a company may be done because of personal financial pressure such as a home foreclosure, or a non-sharable problem such as drug use or gambling debts (Wells 2007)...

Words: 978 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Helathsouth

...Intro to HealthSouth Fraud Case Review In 2003, HealthSouth was accused of one the largest accounting fraud cases in healthcare history and those involved are still being tried today, nine years later. HealthSouth was founded in Birmingham, Alabama in the year 1984 by a respiratory therapist name Richard Scrushy. By the year 1999, HealthSouth had grown to house 230 surgical centers, 120 inpatient hospitals, 5 medical centers, 129 diagnostic centers and 1379 outpatient rehab centers and was worth an estimated billion dollars. It was revealed that HealthSouth started their downward spiral in the year 2002, which paralleled the timeframe that Scrushy sold of ~ $100,000 in HealthSouth Stock Options. Within the following 6 plus months to follow, the FBI announced allegations against HealthSouth and opened a criminal investigation for probable SEC violations. The FBI investigation initially uncovered wrong doings from the years 1999-2002 where Scrushy had overstated his salary 1 million + dollars to meet expectations of shareholders and Wallstreet. Unfortunately, this was just the beginning, and as forensic accountants dug deeper, the FBI soon found that HealthSouth’s corporate accountants were adjusting entries to offset liabilities, reduce expense accounts and state elevated salaries to balance their bookkeeping. It was reported ~$373 million dollars of cash on the books was fictitious. It was eventually revealed that all four Accounting Statements were incorrect and that...

Words: 578 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Evaaaakkkk

...“The HealthSouth Scandal of 2003” SERRAON, ABIGAIL E. Accountancy 4Y2-1 ENGR. ANTHONIO CHAN March, 2016 INTRODUCTION Embezzlement, misappropriation, cheating or stealing is a form of fraudulent act done with an organization. There are television and newspaper stories nearly every day about all kinds of corporate schemes and scams. Behind every fraud is a person or a group of people who has taken what is not theirs to take. Some of those people intended to steal they just never thought they would get caught. Others were pulled into the original crime or some aspect of the cover-up and before they knew it they were labeled a co-conspirator. This study will examine the people behind the much publicized fraud scheme at HealthSouth. Some did not set out to commit white-collar crime but found themselves as defendants in criminal trials for fraud. In the HealthSouth case in observation, real life examples of people who were "just doing their job" but at some point crossed the line from law-abiding citizens to law-breaking villains. Seemingly small compromises in ethics and morality led to a full-scale commitment to fraud. Finally, we will conclude that nobody sets out in their career to end up in prison cleaning toilets and on the front page of the Wall Street Journal after they are arrested for fraud. At some point, though, many end up that way. A. Background of the Study The study all about the recent accounting scandal that were reported : “The HealthSouth Scandal...

Words: 1856 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Finance

...HealthSouth Corporation: Fraud, Greed and Corporate Governance Manmohan D. Chaubey, Ph.D. The Pennsylvania State University One College Place Du Bois, PA 15801 (USA) Tel: 814-375-4846 Fax: 814-375-4784 Email: mdc13@psu.edu Case for ICMC2006 International Conference on Management Cases 4-5 December 2006 IMT Ghaziabad, India HealthSouth Corporation: Fraud, Greed and Corporate Governance During the 1990s, Richard M. Scrushy, the former CEO of HealthSouth Corporation, engineered many acquisitions of rehabilitation clinics, outpatient surgical care operators, nursing homes and other health care companies. In 2003, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) accused the company and Scrushy of inflating earnings to the tune of $1.4 billion since 1999. In November 2003, a federal grand jury indicted Scrushy on 85 counts including conspiracy, securities fraud, money laundering and charges related to overstating HealthSouth’s earnings by nearly $3.0 billion. According to federal investigators, the company overstated earnings to meet analysts’ earning estimates, while hiding the accounting fraud from the auditors. However, questions were raised whether the auditors failed to find or simply overlooked the fraud at HealthSouth. Central to the investigation was the issue of what role Scrushy played in “cooking the books.” However, as the case unfolded, it highlighted many other issues such as: The role of Board of Directors in corporate governance; the role of the auditors; the...

Words: 3975 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Scrushy

...The Scrushy Influence Table of Contents Table of Content…………………………………………………………………………………. 2 Abstract……………………………………………………………………………………………3 Introduction………………………………………………………………………………………..4 Richard Scrushy-Biography……………………………………………………………………….5 Health South History………………………………………………………………………………6 Health South Down Fall…………………………………………………………………………...7 Sentence…………………………………………………………………………………………...8 Sentence…………………………………………………………………………………………...9 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………….10 References……………………………………………………………………………………….11 Abstract This paper looks at the rise and fall of the Health South Corporation along with its founder and CEO, Richard Scrushy. One of the biggest fraud cases in recent history, this one company over- stated its revenue by four billion dollars, causing many people to lose both their life savings and their jobs. Over fifteen people received jail sentences, and even the Governor of Alabama went to prison. Richard Scrushy was sentenced to seventy (70) months in prison. Introduction Mr. Scrushy started his company in 1986, and by 2003 he had lost everything. However, what happened in those seventeen years was spectacular. Scrushy started a small firm which grew into a nationwide company employing over sixty thousand employees. By all appearances he was the golden boy in the medical insurance industry - acquiring other, smaller companies in order to expand his own corporation and enhance his own income. During those...

Words: 2030 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Accounting Ethics

...REVIEW OF ACCOUNTING ETHICS: HEALTHSOUTH CORPORATION SCANDAL Dannie Lover Professor Seedgrass Financial Accounting South University October 9, 2013 THE ORGANIZATION In 2003, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged HealthSouth Corporation, the nations’ largest provider of outpatient surgery, diagnostic and rehabilitative healthcare services, and its Chief Executive Officer and Chairman Richard M. Scrushy with a massive accounting fraud. Scrushy, along with several of his former colleagues allegedly inflated HealthSouth’s pre-tax earnings. [Knapp] Founded in 1984 in Birmingham, Alabama, with more than 50,000 employees and nearly 2000 facilities across all states, HealthSouth earned recognition as a top-five performer in the S&P 500 index. This thriving company grew rapidly and became publicly traded within two years of existence. The company is believed to have overstated its profits by at least 1.4 billion since 1999, in order to meet or exceed Wall Street earnings expectations and maintain market price for stock. [Press Release 2003] THE ALLEGIATION The allegation came just after an earnings restatement and insider-trading charge triggered the investigation, sending HealthSouth stock tumbling to a record low. [Romano 2003] Many attempts at whistle blowing were suppressed, when employees expressed concerns due to falsification of documents. One accountant in particular, was quickly silenced and moved to a dead end job outside of Accounting...

Words: 1328 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Financial Analysis

...Assignment: Financial Analysis Company Overview HealthSouth Corporation is one largest rehabilitation healthcare providers. Healthsouth was founded in 1983 and the companies headquarters in Birmingham, Alabama. The company has hospitals in 27 states throughout the United States and in Puerto Rico. They employ 22,000 team members. Healthsouth primarily operates inpatient rehabilitation hospitals and long-term acute care hospitals. Their hospitals provide treatment on both an inpatient and outpatient basis. The inpatient rehabilitation hospitals offer services to patients who require institutional rehabilitation care, and patient care is provided by nursing and therapy staff as directed by a physician order. HealthSouth’s hospitals provide a higher level of rehabilitative care to patients who are recovering from conditions such as stroke and other neurological disorders, orthopedic, cardiac and pulmonary conditions, brain and spinal cord injury, and amputations. Healthsouth strives to return patients to full strength in less time. The company operates 97 inpatient rehabilitation hospitals, including 68 owned hospitals and 29 jointly owned hospitals; 6 freestanding long-term acute care hospitals; 32 outpatient rehabilitation satellite clinics; 25 licensed hospital-based home health agencies; and managed 4 inpatient rehabilitation units through management contracts. HealthSouth was involved in a corporate accounting scandal in which its Chief Executive...

Words: 828 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Healthsouth Case

...B1. Client Confidentiality Fraud investigators are responsible for upholding the ACFE Code of Ethics when dealing with client confidentiality, integrity, and objectivity during a fraud investigation. A fraud investigator is not allowed to reveal confidential information obtained during a fraud investigation unless proper authorization is given from the client or a lawful order. Therefore, any information discovered during the fraud investigation remains confidential unless HealthSouth gives permission or the SEC requests the information. For example, the fraud investigator is not entitled to subpoena HealthSouth for their information. Therefore, the fraud investigator relies on HealthSouth’s cooperation to complete their fraud investigation. If the fraud investigator discloses the confidential information without proper authorization, the relationship with HealthSouth becomes irreparable resulting in the company’s lack of...

Words: 1744 - Pages: 7