Premium Essay

Henrietta's Cervix And Ethical Theory

Submitted By
Words 1292
Pages 6
Section 2
Health care should always have a role in placing value as its core, determining what is right and good for patients. Our worldviews shape our values that tell us what is right and wrong, good and evil, and indicates how we should justify human behavior. Nevertheless, health care issues rarely have an easy answer with ethical dilemmas. Therefore, it was not ethical when the doctors “picked up a sharp knife and shaved two dime-sized pieces of tissue from Henrietta’s cervix” in the name of research and not to benefit to help treat her cancer.
We can acknowledge that individuals can derive to different opinions in regard to value issues, that goes into saying that not all opinions have the same worth or credibility, or that one particular answer is better than another. In this case of Henrietta, some may rationalize their opinions on philosophical or religious beliefs, while others will try to weigh the potential outcome. Does the mean justify the cause of unethical harvest of Henrietta’s cervix? As a result, taking the cells saved many lives, but it should not encumber on one’s rights to autonomy. Given the principle of equal consideration of interest, individuals are not allowed to increase his share of happiness at the expense of another (Edge/Grove p. 45). …show more content…
I can debate in a consequence-oriented perspective that the taken sample was not illegally wrong at the time, but still arguably morally wrong. One might put into perception that teleology decides that what is right also maximize the greatest good for the greatest number, but what if we consider this, if there were no success on immortal cells, would it be ethical to operate on human subjects without their knowledge? Even after the fact of the effective discoveries, Henrietta and her family was still objected to benevolent

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Why Is Henrietta Lacks Unethical

...Howard Jones took a biopsy from Henrietta and got the test results quite quickly. The news was not great: stage I cancer of the cervix, but Henrietta was told there could be a positive aspect. Richard Wesley TeLinde, the boss of Henrietta's doctor, Howard Jones. TeLinde argued that cervical carcinoma in situ (Henrietta's diagnosis), considered a "non-invasive" cancer, can still metastasize, or spread, becoming something more serious if not treated (Shmoop). Not everyone was convinced. The pap smear was a new technology and was only introduced ten years prior to the diagnosis of Henrietta’s cervical cancer. It still wasn't being used frequently or properly to diagnose abnormal cervical cells (Shmoop). TeLinde decided to prove his theory; with Hopkins being a place where many poor black families were treated, he figured the hunting ground was ripe with poor unintelligent test subjects. The medical experiments...

Words: 858 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Henrietta Lacks Thesis

...Hospital, diagnosed her with Epidermoid Carcinoma of the Cervix Stage 1. Then eight months later, Henrietta enters into her final rest on October 4, 1951. What made her demise different from other related death, is that her cancerous cells changed medical history. Henrietta cancer cells killed her, it metastasized throughout her...

Words: 1571 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethical Principles

...Ethical Principles Paper Nadia Brown University of Phoenix Ethical Principles Paper Henrietta Lacks was born on August 1, 1920, in Roanoke, Virginia and she died due to complications of cervical cancer on October 4, 1951.She had been receiving treatment at the Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore, Maryland. At the hospital she was treated with radium tube inserts, which is said to be the standard treatment for cervical cancer in 1951. As a matter of routine, samples of her cervix were removed without permission. Henrietta was 31 years old when she died. In this time it was customary for doctors and researchers to remove cells from a person for testing. Likewise cells were taken from Henrietta. The problem was that the cells were taken from her body without her knowledge or consent. These cells were later used to form the HeLa cell. The HeLa cell has been used many times over in medical research since they were removed from the body of Henrietta Lacks. The lack of consent in this case shined a light on the legal and ethical issues involved in medical research. On October 4, 1951 Henrietta Lacks died, but unlike others her cells did not die. Samples of her cells were removed from her body without her permission. During this time doctors frequently removed cells from patients without their permission or consent. Informed consent did not come into practice until the late 1970s due to another controversial case, the infamous Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment of 1932-1972.  ...

Words: 1151 - Pages: 5