Free Essay

Indiana Religious Freedom Law

In:

Submitted By gxec
Words 739
Pages 3
Indiana Religious Freedom Law
In March 2015, Indiana governor Mike Pence signed a Religious Freedom bill into law that will take effect in July 2015. The backlash from the left was vocal with a correspondingly loud response from the religious right. A friend forwarded me an article from The American Conservative, written by Patrick J. Buchanan. In his article, Mr. Buchanan’s argument is that the turmoil surrounding the bill is about “the replacement of Christian values with secular values as the operating premises of society” Buchanan (2015). Buchanan’s premise is that there is a cultural battle occurring and that religious rights can and should be protected above all else.
The Argument
Indiana, along with 19 other states, enacted a law to protect the right of people to live their lives and conduct their business in accordance with their personal religious beliefs. Indiana’s law prohibits any state laws that place a substantial burden on a person’s ability to exercise their religious beliefs. The laws definition of a person includes institutions, associations, and businesses (O'Malley, 2015). Buchanan believes that Indiana’s law does not discriminate against anyone. It merely provides a shield for those who believe, on a religious basis, that homosexuality is wrong and do not wish to associate with homosexuals or participate in their celebrations (Buchanan, 2015). In his argument, Buchanan ignores the fact that there are other religions and the unintended consequences that might arise when others, besides Christians, exercise their religious beliefs. One wonders, whether there would be such support for this law should a Muslim auto repair shop refuse to repair a woman’s car because the owner’s religious beliefs did not allow women to drive.
It is Buchanan’s view that the outcry over this new law is a sure sign that the cultural wars have come to Indiana. Buchanan lists several people and companies who rushed to express their displeasure in the new law. He only quoted one specific person, Hillary Clinton. Prior to quoting Mrs. Clinton, he commented that she had tweeted from “now empty server” (Buchanan, 2015). This was innuendo with sarcasm by Buchanan to remind the readers of the questions about Clinton’s use of a personal server for her government emails as well as her deleting the emails on the server. Buchanan also quoted Clinton due to her lack of credibility with his audience. He uses the lack of credibility along with the circumstantial ad hominem fallacy to transfer the audience’s feelings for Clinton to the Indiana law.
Buchanan argues that the debate is really a battle between two religions with Christianity on one side and Liberalism on the other (Buchanan, 2015). This is an appeal to popularity for many Christians. Buchanan uses scapegoating to blame liberals for the changing views in society. Buchanan ignores that many Christians have had to change their religious views over the years due to societies changing views on slavery, racial equality, and divorce. While conservatives championed many of the past changes, he blames liberals for the changes currently occurring in society.
Buchanan goes on to question the punishment that Liberalism is trying to place on Christians for following their beliefs and wonders how far it will go. He compares the implementation of Liberalism punishment to the enforcement of Sharia law. He wonders if in addition to depriving business owners of their livelihoods, caning or imprisonment were next (Buchanan, 2015). Here Buchanan uses an appeal to popular beliefs along with a slippery slope argument to provide an emotional point to sway his audience.
Conclusion
It is clear in reading the article that Buchanan knows his audience well and is skilled at using rhetoric and fallacies to support his premise that a cultural battle between Christianity and Liberalism is occurring, which Christians need to win.
While Buchanan uses nearly every type of fallacy available to support his argument, the underlying fallacy of his article, as well as overall discussion, is the false dilemma. These situations rarely need to be the either or position being described. Sadly, this type of argument is leading people to act in ways that may have a negative on their livelihoods. Just not in the way Buchanan is stating.

References
Buchanan, P. J. (2015). Stand Up for Indiana. Retrieved from http://www.theamericanconservative.com/buchanan/stand-up-for-indiana/
O'Malley, J. (2015). A Look at Widely Criticized Indiana Law on Religious Freedom. Retrieved from http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/widely-criticized-indiana-law-religious-freedom-30084390

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Hard to Buy on Sundays

...years later consumers in Indiana are still affected by its continuing impact. Indiana is one of just three states that do not allow Sunday carry out sales of beer, wine, and liquor. Illinois, Ohio, Michigan, and Kentucky are all benefiting of this law. The tax revenue generated to the states surrounding Indiana should be going to the state of Indiana. The ban of the sale of carry out alcohol on Sunday’s should be lifted in Indiana because, the year is 2012 and religious views should not be dictating consumers lives, thousands of dollars of tax revenue can be gained, it will increase sales to small businesses, and it would also make football fans happy to not have to rush on Saturdays to get their beer before Sunday. Hoosiers should be allowed to buy any form of alcohol and any amount of alcohol on Sundays. It is important to understand the meaning of why laws like banning liquor and beer sales on Sunday are put into effect. Indiana is one of many states that maintain a ban on Sunday liquor sales, even though Sunday sales of alcohol could bring in much needed revenues to the state. Sunday closing laws, often referred to as “blue laws,” generally proscribe all labor, business and other commercial activities on Sunday. These laws prohibit activities ranging from racing motor vehicles and dogs, hunting, operating pawnbrokers, conducting “games of chance,” operating adult-oriented establishments, and selling motor vehicles: “These are old blue Collar laws, which date back to...

Words: 1224 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Difference Between Law and Morality

...Difference between Law and Morality Instructor: Mr.Garmon Student: Mr. Rupert L.Griffith 03/31/15 The Debate between Law and Morality: Laws are absolute rules prescribed by government representatives, while morality has to do with personal views on what is right or wrong. A major difference between these two concepts is that a law is formal public policy that has consequences for those who violate it. Someone who murders or steals, for instance, goes to jail if found guilty in court. In contrast, someone who violates what others view as a moral standard may have no tangible consequence other than damaged relationships. Laws are sometimes viewed as legislation on moral issues. Many people lean on religious beliefs to frame their moral viewpoints. Politicians and some citizens also point to faith-based principles in suggesting that laws should follow what God commands. Others believe that laws should protect individual rights and freedoms but should not extend to topics viewed as ethical gray areas. In some cases, laws and morals evolve over time based on changing societal views. The Civil Rights laws of the 1950s and 1960s developed as Americans became more supportive of an end to segregation. Sometimes, though, principle-based politicians and leaders look to enact laws based on personal convictions, even though they may contradict the popular opinion of the time. My Position on this View: This would lend itself to the current “Religious freedom Law” recently passed by...

Words: 584 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Edu 555 School Vouchers and the Law

...The Law and School Vouchers July 24, 2013 Grand Canyon University: EDA 555 The Law and School Vouchers School choice is a very controversial topic and aggressively disputed today. There are various types of choices which provide many educational opportunities. Can parents afford it? School vouchers are only one choice in this divisive topic. No matter which side of the issue regarding vouchers you agree with, people are very passionate about it. Texas has been trying for years to pass it in Congress; however, it has not passed. There are many pros and cons regarding this topic. First of all, there are many choices for parents today to provide educational opportunities for their children according Chen (2011). There are the public schools. These are schools which require no tuition and the students are zoned to that particular school in their district. Charter schools are another option. They are free, public schools established independently. They are not subject to the same state and federal requirements, but they are held to a high accountability. Parents can request this option. Magnet schools are also free, public schools. They have a specific focus such as science or art. In order to qualify to attend this school, the student may have to take a test and have satisfactory behavior. Another type of school is the virtual school. This is distance learning and learning at your own pace. It has strict government and district...

Words: 1790 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Lyrics

...tried, even if I wanted to…” Music can start revolutions. Through every decade and generation certain songs stick out that raise social awareness. The first song I remember as a child was “Paint it Black” by The Rolling Stones, when I hear this song I visually recall images of Vietnam, images from TV about the ugliness of war and fighting an invisible enemy. James Brown’s “I’m Black and I’m Proud,” brings forth images of the Civil Rights Movement and inner city youths in the 80’s used N.W.A.’s “[eff] tha Police” as their anthem to express frustrating oppression by those sworn to protect and serve. Music is our outlet, our voice, our push for change; sometimes it’s informative, sometimes it’s violent and obscene. Music is protected by freedom of speech; it can be politically incorrect, offensive but sometimes issues that need to be brought to light are done so through lyrics. “When I was in third grade I thought I was gay, ‘cause I could draw, my uncle was, and I kept my room straight,” Macklemore and Ryan Lewis tackled a hot topic with “Same Love” (Macklemore Lyrics "Same Love" with Ryan Lewis Featuring Mary Lambert). Homophobia is part of mainstream hip-hop and rap music. The song touches on stereotypes, politics, religion, and the social stigma of being gay. It was also the anthem for change in Washington State’s Referendum 74, legalization of same-sex marriage (Headlee). The first time I heard “Same Love” I was driving to work, it tells the story of a child confused about...

Words: 1462 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Politics

...The modern relationship between politics and religion can be described as “closer than ever”. Pope Francis recently spoke to congress in a joined House and Senate meeting while on his mission trip from the Vatican. This was Pope Francis first trip to The United States as Pope. The Pope spoke of issues that both the Republican political party and the Democratic political party have made their parties’ main issues and causes. However, hot topics of the republican base such as; abortion and same-sex marriage received scant mentions in the Pope's short address (Burke, 2015). Instead Pope Francis focused on immigration, the death penalty, racial injustice, the weapons trade, and poverty all items that the Democratic Party has stated as their cause or issue. With Pope Francis’s speech to lawmakers, he became the first pope to address a joint meeting of Congress which is a milestone in the journey of the Roman Catholic Church in the United States. “Not long ago, the prospect of the head of the Catholic Church addressing Congress would have been unthinkable. Catholics in politics were a source of suspicion and a subject of slander for generations. Today, the pendulum has swung. Nearly one in three members of the Congress that Francis addressed are Catholic” (Baker & Yardly, 2015). Another example of politics and religion that have joined forces is Kim Davis, the clerk of Rowan County, Kentucky. As the website, CNN.com states; “She stands at the crossroads of a controversy between...

Words: 1375 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Wisconsin V. Yoder Case Summary

...the case of Wisconsin v. Yoder was a significant statement for both public education and religious freedom. In terms of religious freedom, the requirement of the government to present a compelling reason to deny exercise of religious beliefs was reaffirmed. Meanwhile, public education continued to be presented as optional, provided that the objecting parents could present an adequate alternative for the education of their children. The case of Wisconsin v. Yoder began with the conviction of three Amish parents for refusing to send their children to public school after the eighth grade when Wisconsin law required attendance until the age of 16. The case underwent a series of appeals until it reached the United States Supreme Court in 1972. The state’s argument was based on an equal application of its role as parens patriae, which gives the government the right to act on behalf of children against abusive or neglectful parents. They argued that depriving the children of public education was...

Words: 1610 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Marriage

...explore and research the topic of gay marriage. I will be discussing topics in regards to religion and how it offends the religious communities. I will also be touching on the topics of Laws and States that approve and disapprove of Gay Marriages, and why gay and lesbian couples want to get married. The most common religious argument against same-sex marriage revolves around scripture, which many religious communities believe came directly from the mouth of God, and they interpret scripture to forbid homosexuality, and by extension, same-sex marriage. The most quoted scripture in the bible comes from Leviticus 18:22, cited from the new International classic Reference Bible, which says “ Do not lie with a man as one lies with a women; that is detestable” (1988,133). Marriage 3 Many people who are religious only view marriage as a man and a woman, never a woman with a women or a man with a man to them they think Gay or Lesbian couples are living in sin and will never be let into God’s Kingdom. Before the nay religious wars that ravaged through Europe, marriage was almost entirely wrapped up in religion, specifically the Christian faith. It was of course a time of little religious tolerance and if the authority of the church was questioned, it would bring dire consequences. But even in a climate so different...

Words: 1124 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cabeza De Vaca Religion Analysis

...Indigenous population formed through Andrew Jackson’s false sense of what was just and moral. In A Land So Strange Andres Resendez focuses on the colonist Cabeza de Vaca’s religious beliefs which led to a predetermined judgment of the Indigenous people and his duty as a colonist to free them through conversion to Catholicism even if they would lose their own freedom in the...

Words: 1679 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Meme

...Anti-vaccination Movements Influenza Pandemics Scientific Method in Vaccine History The History of the Lyme Disease Vaccine U.S. Military and Vaccine History Vaccination Exemptions Vaccine Injury Compensation Programs Vaccine Testing & Vulnerable Human Subjects Cultural Perspectives on Vaccination Public opinions about vaccination include varied and deepseated beliefs, a result of the tension between divergent cultural viewpoints and value systems. Several key cultural perspectives on vaccination stem from (1) individual rights and public health stances toward vaccination, (2) various religious standpoints and vaccine objections, and (3) suspicion and mistrust of vaccines among different U.S. and global cultures and communities. Individual versus Public Health Stances Many countries require their citizens to receive certain immunizations. In the United States, state laws dictate mandatory vaccinations, such as those required for children to enter school.[1] Controversies over the efficacy, safety, and morality of compulsory immunization stem from the longstanding tension between two, sometimes divergent, goals: protecting individual liberties and safeguarding the public’s health.[2] USAID/Mohammed Jiya-Doko Enlarge Polio survivors in Kano, Nigeria Individual versus public health priorities were first argued in the U.S. Supreme Court more than 100 years ago. In Jacobson versus Massachusetts, a resident of the city...

Words: 2235 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Biden's Struggle For Equality In The United States

...Many businesses refused to serve people because of who they are. These individuals were turned down because of something they can not control. Does the idea sound familiar? The same idea was in place with the segregation and discrimination of African American individuals in the past (law) and today (beliefs). Another instance at which deeming a certain population lesser for any reason is Hitler and Nazi Germany. Once people “found out” that the Jews “bankrupt” Germany, they turned against their own people. Obviously, the Nazi Party is an extreme example; however, the Nazi Germans practiced the same idea as people who are against the LGBT community. Subsequently, the outrage was so acrimonious that the law was quickly changed.A affinity between the Nazis and same-sex marriage is that the discriminatory law and beliefs behind the law will never be able to occur illegally again unless the ruling is changed in the future. Because of the landmark decision, another discriminatory action was subsided. The people within the LGBT community believed that “alternative ways of granting legal statuses, such as civil unions or registered partnerships,...

Words: 980 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Course Project - Islam - Global Concept and Practices (with Corrections)

...University Sociology – 350N – Cultural Diversity in Professions Spring Semester 2013 Introduction The history of Islam, its’ concepts and practices is one of the most intriguing yet controversial religions known today. Worldwide, Muslims make up about 23.4 percent of the population, while Christianity makes up about 30 percent (Goodstein, 2011). A study published in 2009 by the Pew Research Center to get global concept of the Muslim population found, “Of the 232 countries and territories included in this study, 50 are Muslim-majority” (p. 5). The Center also found “While 80% of the world’s Muslims live in countries where Muslims are in the majority, significant numbers – about one-fifth of the world’s Muslim population – live as religious minorities in their home countries” (p. 7). With so many countries adhering to Islam and the growth of the Muslim population here in America and worldwide; how will this affect how non-Islamic countries communicate and interact with Islamic countries and how we communicate right here in the United States? If Muslim fundamentalists were not at the forefront of controversy in the war on terrorism, would Islam be a religion that sparks so much debate? Even before September 11th, there had been much controversy related to Islam. However most of it occurred on foreign soil. With significant bombings and terrorist attacks in Europe, the Middle East and Asia, many Americans were more fearful of travelling abroad, not realizing that such an...

Words: 3389 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Multicultural Experience

...Multicultural Experience Blake Runkle PSY/400 August 15, 2012 Rockel Etinne Multicultural Experience There are many uncomfortable situations that people deal with, situations such as eating foods that a person does not usually eat or attending a religious service other than his or her own. In this paper the topics that will be discussed will first be to describe an experience that I was in and felt uncomfortable at the time of this experience. The next topic discussed will be to discuss the preconceived notions about the experience. After this topic explaining how the notions were affected by a group influence will be discussed and the final topic being discussed will be to describe the reaction of the individuals who were in the presence during the situation and discuss the affect of these reactions on the writer’s behavior. The cultural situation the writer selected was attending a Mexican cookout. Working in a group home environment a person experiences different culture. The writer took one of his clients home for a home pass where the cookout was being held. The client and his family are of Mexican descent. On the way to the client’s house the writer felt nervous knowing that he or she was going somewhere that he or she had never been. The writer began to discuss with the client the kind of activities would be there to gain a little knowledge before attending the home...

Words: 1413 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Gay Marriages

...same sex marriages ban nationwide. The gay and lesbian are using the law to have the same sex marriages pass and there have been about 3 states like Maine, Maryland, and Washington that have passed the same sex marriage. In other states like Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Rhode Island, Minnesota, and New Jersey are against the same sex marriage. I don’t think that it should change what marriage is referring to between two men or two women; it is based on a man and woman marrying in holy matrimony. This is stated in the Bible and thru the standard government law and constitution. The government shouldn’t change the law of the constitution or the bill of rights because of same sex marriages. The gays and lesbians want the same rights as a man and a woman do when they get married, for instance if the significant other happens to pass away the significant other would inherited what their significant other left behind. It is not the same when a man inherited his wife life insurance policy or the wife inherits her husband’s life insurance. Marriage should only be between a man and a woman not two men or two women getting married. When it comes to being in an abusive relationship it is still not the same when it’s between the same sex marriages. When it comes to being physically abused when you’re in a marriage is the woman with an abusive husband or vise versa and abusive wife. This is not possible in the court of law. Gays and lesbians want to be treated equal like everyone else and...

Words: 2517 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

African American Progress to Equality

...color. Disfranchisement, legalized segregation, discrimination, and exploitation had become a part of the American way of life. But, through vehicles as the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, migrations to the North, several activists including Nat Turner, Fredrick Douglas, Richard Allen, and Booker T. Washington just to name a few, rose from the depths of slavery and the terror of lynching to win an equal place in American democracy. How African-Americans Worked to End Segregation and Discrimination Segregation is defined as “the practice that divides people in terms of color, religion, and even wealth” (Student Notebook, Webster’s Dictionary). African Americans went through a rough period where segregation laws and practices were in place to encourage racial separation. They were forced to ride in separate railroad cars, have their own hotels and courthouses, and even get water out of their own drinking fountains. Also voting regulations eliminated the political voice of African Americans. The N.A.A.C.P. from 1945 to 1954 attacked legalized segregation and devices for denying blacks the right to vote, bias in transportation and segregation in recreation and educational facilities....

Words: 2508 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Business Law

...Dream is a national ethos of the United States in which freedom includes the promise of prosperity and success. In the definition of the American Dream by James Truslow Adams in 1931, "life should be better and richer and fuller for everyone, with opportunity for each according to ability or achievement" regardless of social class or circumstances of birth. The idea of the American Dream is rooted in the United States Declaration of Independence, which proclaims that "all men are created equal" and that they are "endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable Rights" including "Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness”. Yet, it is still legal in 29 states to be fired for just being gay. In 33 of the 50 states of the United States of America, one can be fired for being transgendered. These states do not have legal protections for members of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) Community (Solmonese, 2009). So does the “American Dream” only apply to “first class citizens”? This paper explores if the Employee Non Discrimination Act (ENDA) would protect employment decisions, which should be based upon a person's qualifications and job performance, not sexual orientation or gender identity (Solmonese, 2009). For over 50 years when there has been a case of an American being denied employment or promotions for reasons that were unrelated to their skills in the workplace, Congress responded by passing laws which were aimed at designing a system based solely...

Words: 3185 - Pages: 13