Premium Essay

Informed Consent Case Study

Submitted By
Words 2028
Pages 9
During week four, my clinical instructor assigned me to a Cantonese patient and informed me on his inability to speak English. I was not however made aware of the fact that he was unable to understand English as well. As I walked in the room, it was just me and the patient. As per normal procedure, I began by introducing myself and continued with the assessment and vital signs. “How did you sleep last night?” is a question I ask during assessment, however when I asked my patient this question, he seemed to have a puzzled look on his face. As having previously dealt with patients, I understood that it was quite possible he did not want to talk to me, felt annoyed and just wanted to go back to sleep. However, after doing assessments, I concluded …show more content…
(2007) conducted a quantitative study on what issues can arise from language/communication barriers. They state that informed consent is significant in nursing as it provides ethical, legal, safe and client-centered health care (Schenker et al., 2007). However, when there is a language barrier, essentially the process of informed consent becomes more difficult (2007). In order to ensure such obstacles do not occur, consent discussion must be presented in languages the patient comprehends or simply, with an interpreter (2007). They heavily state that as the world is growing more diverse linguistically, language barriers have been the source of many complications that surrounds patient care (2007). This includes: unnecessary costs of medical services increases, patient satisfaction decreases, comprehension and adherence to prescribed medication routines are not completely followed and there is an increase in the length of hospital stays (2007). Language barriers can distort and alter the understanding of a message based on the interpreter and their ability to comprehend (2007). For instance, during my encounter with my client, I asked him if he felt pain and he responded by shaking his head no. It is possible that since he did not speak English, he may have assumed I asked something else. Lacking the skills on how to deal with language barriers, I went and charted that he did not have any pain when in reality, there was a chance that he very well could have. This would be an example of a distorted message; if he did feel pain, it could have not been recognized and treated. As a result, this places a burden on nurses when trying to provide care to culturally distinct individuals. Thus, nurses become responsible for figuring out ways to make their patients understand and ease communication between both

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Case Study: Informed Consent Case

...I chose to discuss the first case scenario because it is a compelling case and a lot to learn for it. It is true that before a patient undergoes any treatment or procedure an informed consent should be signed. It is the right thing because the patient has the right to choose what happens to their body. Allowing a patient to sign an informed consent also gives the patient a sense of respect and autonomy over their care. However, when there is an emergency, and patient autonomy is briefly impaired because of fear of pain, or distort body image such as in this week case scenario. The physician can save the patient life based on good paternalism. (Hall, Niekerk, & van Niekerk, 2017). The goal for the physician using the principle of...

Words: 426 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Belmont Report

...Belmont Report: Informed Consent and Subject Selection In the famous Belmont Report, several guidelines regarding informed consent, assessment of risk and benefits, and selection of subjects in addition to ethical practice and procedure in the area of human research are outlined. The Belmont Report attempts to summarize the basic ethical principles identified by the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research (Belmont Report, 1979). In particular I would like to discuss the standards for informed consent, assessment of risk and benefits, and selection of test subjects drawn out by the Belmont Report. These three areas of interest are said to be the applications of the general principles of research. Informed consent is broken down into three checkpoints: information, comprehension, and voluntariness. Assessment of Risks and Benefits has two similar components: identifying the nature and scope of the risks and benefits, and then the systematic assessment. Then there is the selection of subjects which is just an evaluation of the appropriateness of a group used in a research study. I will discuss these concepts as they apply to the infamous artificial heart case study. Informed consent is the application of the general principle of respect for persons. Remember, respect for persons requires that subjects be given the opportunity to choose what will or will not happen to them (Belmont Report, 1979). The first tier...

Words: 1273 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Football

...Tuskegee Syphilis Study Dr. Joseph Costa, D.H.Sc, PA-C Health Policy and Management MPH 525 Jessie McCarty April 2013 Table of Contents Chapter Page 1. Tuskegee Syphilis Study 2 2. Tuskegee Basics 3 3. What Went Wrong? 4 Informed Consent 4 Vulnerable Populations 4 Medical Profession Pursued 5 4. Personal Opinion 7 5. Basics of Research 8 Informed Consent 8 Individual Autonomy 9 Beneficence 9 6. Current Policies 11 Policies 11 Exceptions 11 7. Problems with Waving Consent 13 Flexibility 13 Vulnerable Populations 13 Ethical Dilemmas 14 8. Conclusion 16 Chapter 1 Tuskegee Syphilis Study Throughout the years, numerous research studies have taken place. In the United States, on a daily basis thousands of research studies are being conducted. Some of these studies will greatly influence science, while others will make little impact. Historically, some studies have been remembered not for the results, but for ethical dilemmas surrounding the study. The Tuskegee syphilis study is a prime example of a study which made many people aware of the ethical problems surrounding research. The Tuskegee syphilis study made the government begin to analyze how research was performed in the country, and the study opened many eyes to what changes needed to be made. Analyzing the Tuskegee syphilis study allows for one to understand what went wrong with the study and how this study lead to great changes in the world...

Words: 3472 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Medicine

...Profiles * My CEUs * My Reports * Support * Main Menu › VA Human Subjects Protection › Informed Consent  Informed Consent Content Author * Diane Paul, M.S., RN National Comprehensive Cancer Network Introduction It is important to understand that informed consent is a process that begins with the recruitment and screening of a subject and the signing of the consent document, continues throughout the subject's involvement in the research, and continues beyond study termination. It includes: * Recruitment efforts encompassing the means of first creating awareness or contact and spanning everything from medical record review to advertisements and other recruitment materials. * Providing specific information and answering questions about the study to subjects in a way that is understandable to them while giving subjects adequate time to consider participation. * Obtaining the voluntary agreement of subjects to take part in the study. While the subject may agree to participate in the study, subjects may withdraw at any time. Part of the ongoing nature of the consent process is verifying the subject's continued interest in participating in the study. * Making plans for the provision of new information to be shared with former subjects, even after the study ends. There is consensus regarding the importance of informed consent. Informed consent is a demonstration of how investigators and those involved in human subjects research show respect to...

Words: 3525 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Informed Consent

...Informed consent Name Course Date Informed consent Informed consent is the procedure of getting permission to take part in a research study or medical procedure founded on access to all vital and easily understandable information about the consequences of participation in terms of benefits and harms (Dolgoff et al, 2009). A healthcare provider may demand informed consent from a patient before providing care or a researcher may request it from a participant before enrolling the individual into a research trial. Informed consent is based on guidelines provided by research and medical ethics. To give informed consent, the person involved must have sufficient reasoning faculties and have all the relevant facts. However, not all individuals may have capacities for informed consent due to impairments to reasoning and judgment such as mental immaturity, severe intellectual disabilities, mental illnesses, high stress levels, being in a coma, Alzheimer’s disease, and severe sleep deprivation. Medical and research actions may be carried out due to lack of informed consent. When a person is considered unable to give informed consent, another person can be authorized to give consent on behalf of that person (Manson & O'Neill, 2007). For instance, legal guardians or parents may give informed consent for young children and the mentally ill. In case a person is given insufficient information to make a reasoned decision, severe ethical issues may arise. In clinical trials...

Words: 2720 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Informed Consent In Research

...The informed consent is a written document in which a person, whether client or participants in a research study, agrees with the course of treatment (for counseling) or to participate (in case of study) after having received specific and enough information on the procedures that would be subject to. The area of psychology that I will consider for this discussion is research. Informed consent in research involves many factors. Informed consent should be provided to participants prior the study takes place. This document should provide sufficient and clear information of the study: duration, any possible risks or discomforts participants may suffer, and if participants will be or not compensated (amount must be specified). Additionally, informed...

Words: 387 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Research Paper

...critique a qualitative research study about how nurses manage patients who refuse nursing care procedures. These articles also explains how nurses view informed consent as not being essential to nursing care procedures. PROBLEM STATEMENT The clinical problem being examined in the research study is the way in which nurses obtain consent prior to administering nursing care procedures, and the way nurses manage patients who refuse any nursing care procedures. By stating that nurses “do not regard obtaining consent as an absolute requirement” also stating that “consent is preferred but no considered essential” the significance is established and a clinical problem identified (Aveyard, 2004). The author identifies the need for further education of nurses on the need to obtain informed consent for nursing care procedures, and the need for more research of this topic. The role of persuasion in situations of informed consent has been widely commented on. Many commentators argue that the health care provider has a duty not only to give information but also to persuade the recipient of care to accept the course of action considered most appropriate for the patients’ safety. PURPOSE and RESEARCH QUESTIONS The study clearly identifies the aim of the study as “to examine the way in which nurses manage patients who refuse nursing care procedures (Aveyard, 2004).” The study identifies two main purposes for the research study as: To examine how consent is obtained prior to nursing...

Words: 902 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Citi

...importance of informed consent in research. Most people have the expectation that they will be treated with respect and as autonomous individuals. They also expect that they have the right to make decisions about what will and will not be done to them and about what personal information they will share with others. However, researchers also are aware that there are circumstances in which obtaining and documenting consent in social and behavioral research may be a complex, and often challenging process. For instance, potential subjects may be fluent in a language but not literate. Researchers may need to deceive research subjects in order obtain scientifically valid data. Asking subjects to sign consent forms linking them to a study about illegal activities could put them at risk of harm. The federal regulations provide sufficient flexibility to address some of these concerns, particularly for research posing no more than minimal risk of harm. For example, the regulations allow waivers of and alterations in the requirements for the consent and documentation processes. Learning Objectives By the end of this module you should be able to: • Distinguish between consent as a process and the documentation of consent. • Recognize the elements of consent. • Determine when waivers are appropriate. • Identify methods for ensuring comprehension of consent. Overview of Informed Consent Federal regulations require researchers to obtain legally effective informed consent from the subject...

Words: 2868 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Jesse Gelsinger Case Summary

...This type of condition is known as mosaicism. Jesse Gelsinger lived in Tucson, Arizona. He was the 18th and final subject in the study, and at age 18, he was the youngest person enrolled. He had learned about the trial in 1998 from his physician, and was only allowed into the study because another subject had dropped out. His father was stated in saying that he “was doing this for other people.”1 Jesse Gelsinger set aside his personal life to participate in the study, and took an unpaid leave from his job. On September 13, 1999, Gelsinger became the second subject to receive the highest dose of the adenovirus. In the other study participants, including the first to receive the highest dose, the adverse effects were only temporary muscle aches and fever. These side effects were not life threatening.1 About 18 hours after the infusion of the adenovirus vector, Gelsinger started to develop an altered mental status and jaundice. He then developed a systemic inflammatory response to the virus,...

Words: 2011 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Informed Consent in Emergency Situations

...INFORMED CONSENT IN EMERGENCY SITUATIONS 1 INFORMED CONSENT IN EMERGENCY SITUATIONS IVA SHIELDS LEGAL & REG ISSUES-HLTH INFO / HIT 220 PROFESSOR: ANDREA THOMAS INFORMED CONSENT IN EMERGENCY SITUATIONS 2 A patient has the legal right to be informed and knowledgeable concerning any procedure performed by all medical personnel. The fact that an emergency situation has occurred does not change those rights. Being in a vulnerable state of mind when facing an emergency situation can be scary enough without facing the situation uninformed and unknowledgeable as to how the circumstances may affect you and your family. We, the patient or patients are protected by rights that are put in to place to help reassure us that we will receive the best care possible, without the fear being taken advantage of or our lives taken for granted. Informed consent is defined as a voluntary agreement given by a person or a patients' responsible proxy (for example, a parent) for participation in a study, immunization program, treatment regimen, invasive procedure, etc., after being informed of the purpose, methods, procedures, benefits, and risks. The essential criteria of informed consent are that the subject has both knowledge...

Words: 916 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Moore V. Catalona Case Digest

...and others which were never informed and consented. The case was settled out of court and recognized that researchers illegally used tissue samples outside the scope of authorized use (NCIA 2010). In the case of Moore v. Regents of the University of California (Dorney 1990), the subject was treated for leukemia and had his infected spleen removed. He had blood, bone marrow, skin and sperm extracted and thought they were necessary to monitor his condition. His physician then patented and commercialized his cell line from those extractions. Moore sued the UCLA and physician for lack of informed consent and breach of their duty. In this case, the court ruled in favor of the physician and University of California that Moore had no initial interest in property and financial profit of the samples taken from his body, so he could not share the commercial profit of the research....

Words: 521 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Nursing Accountability Related to Informed Consent

...Accountability of Nursing Professionals for Patient Safety Practices Related to Informed Consent Lavonia Deanne Bishop Grand Canyon University NURS-430V Professional Dynamics 23-Aug-2010 (0106) September 19, 2010 Accountability of Nursing Professionals for Patient Safety Practices Related to Informed Consent Accountability in nursing can be defined as the state in which the nurse is responsible for upholding a professional agreement with the patient to provide services and be held answerable for the outcomes of behaviors related to these services (Hood, 2010). One of the main areas we are held accountable for as professional nurses is the safety of our patients. After an evidence-based review of patient safety practices, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality has identified numerous opportunities for quality improvement. The practices identified were rated by strength of evidence, with the highest rated being listed first. This paper will examine practice number five, asking patients to recall and restate what they have been told during the informed consent and the responsibility of the professional nurse in this process. The Informed Consent Process According to Terry (2007) informed medical consent occurs when a patient autonomously and expressly permits a professional to perform a medical act on that patient or include the patient in a research project. Patients are now encouraged to be more informed consumers and take an active part in their own healthcare. Terry (2007)...

Words: 1294 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Informed Consent

...qualitative research concern the issues of informed consent procedures, the researcher-participant relationship, risk-benefit ratio, confidentiality and the dual role of the nurse-researcher. The aim of this paper is to discuss these ethical issues and illustrate how they may be resolved using examples from a multiple case study. Data were collected using semi-structured interviews with students, staff and educators. In the context of research ethics, the challenges that arose during this research project will be...

Words: 705 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Citi Informed Consent Sbe Quiz Answers

...data she has and will collect about the children for a case-based research project. Which of the following statements about parental permission is correct? Your answer : The parents of the children might feel pressure to give permission to the therapist to use their children's data so that she will continue to provide services to their children. Correct Answer : The parents of the children might feel pressure to give permission to the therapist to use their children's data so that she will continue to provide services to their children. Comment : When a care provider becomes a researcher, both the child clients and their parents may not feel free to choose not to participate in the provider's study. A researcher who is also a care provider needs to be very clear that a decision not to participate in a study, or to allow records to be used, will not affect the care provided in the future. The fact that the therapist has access to her clients' records as a clinician does not entitle her to use information in the records for research purposes without parental permission and child assent. A school authority's permission to conduct the research does not replace the need for permission or assent. Finally, the children's right to choose cannot be overridden in the pursuit of an indeterminate community interest. Points Earned : 1 Question 2 Question : A general requirement for informed consent is that no informed consent may include any exculpatory language. Exculpatory language...

Words: 942 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Unit 7 Tuskegee Studies

...University of the People Written assignment Unit 7 Bioethics (HS 4812) Professor: Pankaj Mehrotra. 1. What is the difference between a. and a. What would constitute informed consent in the case of the Tuskegee Study? If such informed consent had been obtained from the subjects, would this remove all questions about whether the study was ethical? Informed consent to participate in the Tuskegee Study would require ensuring that the participants fully understood the purpose, nature, and potential risks and benefits of the study before giving their voluntary consent to participate. This would have included disclosing that the study aimed to observe the natural progression of syphilis without providing treatment, as well as explaining the potential...

Words: 879 - Pages: 4