...I. INTRODUCTION The main instruments of International Humanitarian Law (hereafter referred to as IHL) are the four Geneva Conventions of 12 August 19491 for the protection of war victims. These treaties which are universally accepted, protect the wounded, the sick, prisoners of war and civilians in enemy hands. They also protect medical services personnel such as medical personnel, medical units and establishments, and medical means of transport. As a matter of fact this kind of concern for the humanitarian aspect can be found in our ancient epics like the Mahabharata, where the rules of conduct of war as to the timing of attack and the prohibition attacking the unarmed were strictly laid down. The laws of Manu, a compilation of encyclopedic scope, which the British Professor Duncan M. Derrett a known authority on Hindu Law describes as a text "which constitutes India's greatest achievement in the field of jurisprudence" and regards this work as one of the world's premier compositions in ancient law, more valuable in every sense than Hammurabi and able to hold its own in comparison to the covenant and Priestly codes of Moses2 . Manu, while describing the duties of a King, warns against unusual cruelty even against an enemy in warfare, and has this to say, "fighting in a battle, he should not kill his enemies with weapons that are concealed, barbed, or smeared with poison or whose points blaze with fire. He should not kill anyone who has climbed on a...
Words: 3960 - Pages: 16
...INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW TERM PAPER NOVEMBER, 5, 2013 CLIENTS NAME INSTITUTION 1950 WORDS Introduction According to the rules of customary international law (IHL), parties to a conflict need to distinguish between the civilians and combatants and military objective and civilian objectives . It is essential to offer a guide on what might be attacked in order to free the civilian populace from the impacts of hostilities. The most important guide regarding armed conflicts is that the combatants may only attack military objectives . However, despite the right to attack only military objectives, the attack will be illegal if the combatants’ use of force may lead to excessive collateral damage on either the civilians or the civilian objects . In addition, the combatants need to take precautionary measures to ensure they do not harm civilians even if they are attacking lawful targets . In this light, it is important to define military objectives and offer an explanation why there are limitations on the attacks on military objectives. Pursuant to Article 52 (2) of Protocol 1, military objectives need to fulfil two criteria. First, it must be a factor in the military action of the adversary. This is often highlighted by the objects “nature, locality, reason or use”. Secondly, the destruction, capture or neutralization must present a clear military benefit to the combatants. Therefore, an attack on a specific area may be tantamount to a...
Words: 2082 - Pages: 9
...International Humanitarian Law – jus in bello 1. Geneva Conventions The law in this area is covered by the four Geneva Conventions, signed in 1949 after the atrocities of WW2 and two additional protocols signed in 1977. 1. Geneva Convention on the Amelioration of the Condition of the Wounded and Sick in Armed Forces in the Field (GC I) 2. Geneva Convention on the Amelioration of the Condition of Wounded, Sick and Shipwrecked Members of Armed Forces at Sea (GC II) 3. Geneva Convention on the Treatment of Prisoners of War (GC III) 4. Geneva Convention on the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War (GC IV) Protocols of 1977 – in response to the conflict in Vietnam 1. Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts (Additional Protocol I) 2. Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts (Additional Protocol II) 2. International Armed Conflict – application of the GC’s • International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) states that an armed conflict within the meaning of the Geneva Conventions is any difference of opinion between two states that leads to intervention or action by the members of their armed forces • Common Article 2 of GC (ie in all of them) states that it will apply: o To all cases of war, and armed conflict between two or more parties to the treaty (even if “the state of war” is not recognised by one of them) o To all cases of partial or total occupation of the territory...
Words: 5052 - Pages: 21
...prevention programs and relief disaster and conflict. Their area of excellence is * disaster management, * community resilience and Capacity Building * Health and Social program * Violence, abuse and injury prevention * Humanitarian issues international humanitarian law The Canadian Red Cross Society involved 6,484 employees with 67% in domestic activities and 33% international operations. Major achievements In Kenya, The Canadian Red Cross has been involved in mosquito net distribution for seven years protective vulnerable young children and pregnant women for mosquito bites that spread the malaria. They were able to raise 47 million dollars in turn,, it has supported the distribution of seven million nets in 12 campaigns. The Canadian Red cross helped rebuild Liberian Red Cross , a west African nation of 3,4 million people that endured almost 20 years of vicious civil war which saw a quarter of a million of its citizens killed. Today Liberian Red Cross delivers program for health, water and sanitation, disaster risk reduction and humanitarian values. They respond to the floods that affect each year thousands, help communities rebuild and become more self reliant. Red Cross in collaboration with International Red cross developed a program Just in case for isolated seniors in case of disaster, creating a network , increasing their safety and also first responders to focus on the more vulnerable. In Maldives , Canada Red Cross together with Australian...
Words: 538 - Pages: 3
...Mr. Ban Ki-moon Secretary-General United Nations New York, NY 10017 Dear Secretary-General, I am writing with some important recommendations as you embark on your trip to address the crisis in Gaza. We see an urgent need for measures and mechanisms that will protect civilians, provide long-term as well as short-term humanitarian relief and rehabilitation, and ensure accountability and deter future violations of international humanitarian law. We therefore urge you to give priority to these areas in your discussions in the region and your public calls for action. Protection of Civilians Given the exigency of protecting civilians in Gaza, we urge you to send several clear messages to both parties to the conflict and neighboring states. In particular, we would urge you to: * a strong statement, underscoring the importance of both parties' full and stringent compliance with international humanitarian law. All those who violate the laws of war must know that they will be held accountable in the future for their actions; a firm warning from you now can help save lives. * Insist that Egypt and Israel do the maximum to permit the evacuation of civilians through their borders as there is no safe place for civilians within Gaza. As the UN High Commissioner for Refugees António Guterres told the Security Council on January 8, Israel and Egypt must respect the universal right of those fleeing war to seek safety in other states, as well as their right to return upon the conclusion...
Words: 1010 - Pages: 5
...Drone strikes under International Humanitarian Law Feb 2, 2014 Aaron Mirza If there is an armed conflict, the legality of any drone strike must then be evaluated in accordance with IHL, including particularly the fundamental principles of distinction, proportionality, humanity, and military necessity. Distinction is particularly challenging in Federally Administered Tribal Areas, because fighters regularly intermingle with civilians, engage in routine activities and do not wear uniforms. Nonetheless, militaries engaged in an armed conflict must always attempt to distinguish between legitmate and illegitimate targets for an attack. Generally, “the civilian population as such, as well as individuals civilians, shall not be the object of attack.” Civilians lose this protection when they “take a direct part in hostilities.” Under the formulation of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) of what constitutes direct participation in hostilities, the act committed must adversely and directly affect the opposing party in a concrete manner or lead to the loss of life or property as part of a campaign in support of one party to a conflict. This definition adopts an approach focused on specific hostile acts of a certain magnitude rather than organizational membership or more indirect forms of support. The ICRC has further distinguished between civilians who participated in specific acts and those who maintain a continuous combatant function (CCF) by virtue of involvement...
Words: 785 - Pages: 4
...iTHE INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE OF THE RED CROSS (ICRC): MANAGING ACROSS CULTURE ‘We were an orgn made up of Swiss generalists. We are becoming a multicultural and professional enterprise.” 1. INTRODUCTION Dr. Jacques Stroun, M.D. – (1999) Director of Human Resources & Finance (before Head of Detention Division, Deputy Director of Operations) ICRC – provide humanitarian relief, Humanitarian ‘Multinational’ Organisation Home base: Geneva, Switzerland Orgn Values – Neutrality, Independence, Discretion & Humanism Total Workforce – (2008) over 14,000 over 100 nationalities Until recently – ICRC is very Swiss , very Genevoise Expatriate – open to all nationalities but 93% is westerners (1992) Changing expatriate composition – expatriates number increasing – Africa, Asia & Latin America HR Policy – recruitment from Geneva – sent to field with ‘learning by doing’, operate under sense of danger, meeting immediate challenges, focus on short term, quickly develops and reinforces team and team loyalties, rotation every 12 months, no formal training, no continuity for developing people, Career - little career planning, career developed through interpersonal networks & driven by opportunities, most recruits stayed for 2 to 3 years, no management development, those remain and reach top of HQ –mostly Swiss male (old school boys club) CURRENT CHALLENGES – greater diversity in mgmt ranks – more professionals, foreigners and women. NEW STRATEGIC PLAN (2007 -2010)...
Words: 1744 - Pages: 7
...The Syrian civil war[74] is an ongoing armed conflict in Syria between forces loyal to the Syrian Ba'ath Party government and those seeking to oust it. The conflict began on 15 March 2011, with popular demonstrations that grew nationwide by April 2011. These demonstrations were part of the wider Middle Eastern protest movement known as the Arab Spring. Protesters demanded the resignation of President Bashar al-Assad, whose family has held the presidency in Syria since 1971, as well as the end to over four decades of Ba'ath Party rule. In April 2011, the Syrian Army was deployed to quell the uprising, and soldiers were ordered to open fire on demonstrators. After months of military sieges,[75] the protests evolved into an armed rebellion. Opposition forces, mainly composed of defected soldiers and civilian volunteers, became increasingly armed and organized as they unified into larger groups. However, the rebels remained fractured, without organized leadership. The Syrian government characterizes the insurgency as an uprising of "armed terrorist groups and foreign mercenaries".[76] The conflict has no clear fronts, with clashes taking place in many towns and cities across the country.[77] The Arab League, United States, European Union, and other countries condemned the use of violence against the protesters. The Arab League suspended Syria's membership because of the government's response to the crisis, but granted the Syrian National Coalition Syria's seat on 6 March 2013.[78]...
Words: 411 - Pages: 2
...------------------------------------------------- Advice to the Minister Date NOTE: PLEASE DELETE INSTRUCTIONS AS YOU FILL THIS TEMPLATE OUT ISSUE: * Two and half years have now passed and the Syrian civil war is getting further out of control with no clear indication of things getting better anytime soon. If anything the situation in Syria is getting worse by the day. Syrian Civilians are fleeing the country to neighbouring borders such as Lebanon, Jordan, and Turkey, in hopes of a better future for their families. Unfortunately thousands of people have already fallen victim to shameless crimes committed by the Syrian government, with no end in sight. BACKGROUND: * Syria has seen constant unrest for the better part of almost two and a half years. Close to 100,000 people have been killed and millions of Syrians displaced due to the internal conflict that has now become a full-blown civil war. The killing started when peaceful protests inspired by earlier revolutions in Egypt and Tunisia rose up to challenge the dictatorship running the country; namely President Assad. Government forces started quickly kidnapping, killing, torturing, raping, and mutilating bodies of activists and their families before dumping them on the sides of roads. Then troops simply disregarded any judgement of humility and simply just started opening fire amongst crowds of people. Eventually, civilians started shooting back. Syria’s government has been trying to supress a popular...
Words: 851 - Pages: 4
...results with them being labeled as an unqualified authority. Furthermore, the story commits a straw man fallacy to knock down the definition of “imminent threat” as well as to distort using the story about the sheriff from the “Old West” to simplify killing terrorists and murdering civilian casualties as justification for being morally right. In addition, this challenges the author's viewpoint because the 40:1 [terrorist to civilian death] statistics clearly reveal inaccurate information demonstrated from the President and his administration—a false cause fallacy. My recommendation would have been for the author to ask the government to provide factual statistical evidence and unbiased legal attorneys who are educated in those countries laws. Essentially, no one has asked the administration to provide classified information or to supply Personal Identifiable Information that would be construed as leaky information. Next, the article gives support and strength to convince its readers that it is legitimate. For example, the appeal to force gives readers motivation to call for the killing of innocent nearby civilians as a moral defensive circumstance. Indeed, the leaked “legal memo” gives sound moral reasoning and justification to advocate for neutralizing civilian targets as a means of preventive terrorist violence. Also, Mr. McMahan's argument about killing a known terrorist and mass murder that will save hundreds of lives is forecasting his own cognitive bias in a strong...
Words: 727 - Pages: 3
...The Purpose of War and Its Effects Time and time again, Americans are told how necessary and essential war is by their government. While Americans sacrifice their lives for the United States, so are citizens of other countries. But, also individuals are telling everyone how inhumane war. The fact of the matter is war always seems to be a repeating factor in life. Whether people try to justify war or not, there are many reasons and circumstance that are ignored and hidden. War could be defined as a nation’s means for protection. Many could probably say war is a nations way of showing off, but clearly everyone has their own opinion. Protection is also a very broad way of describing a reason to go to war. Protection from what exactly is the question to ask. Protection is rarely the substantial reason as to why a nation is going to war. In many cases though, countries do need protection and can not sustain by themselves. Case and point to the previous argument would be, the Invasion of Panama. A topic, dealing with war, which is very taboo, is how the soldier is affected. Many have mentioned the topic of the soldiers’ state of mind, but who is actually listening? The government is supposed to care, but war seems to be a constant. Soldiers are supposed to be studied and evaluated, but ultimately, soldiers are not truly cared for. That fact that soldiers are sent over to a foreign land, to kill someone, should be a red flag to any official that the human psyche will...
Words: 804 - Pages: 4
... Drones Kill Innocents Is it worth killing many innocents? Drones, weapons that are used to end and help prevent war, not to keep others in fear. Drones should not be allowed to help kill in war, drones are killing many innocent people. Even Though drones will soon be here to help with deliveries or “delivering emergency medical supplies, fighting fires, and protecting endangered animals in africa from attacks by poachers” (Source A). It is just not right to have drones flying around killing innocent and having people kept in fear. One of the main reasons why drones should not be used in warfare is, because “Drones kill innocent people by mistake, War is ugly and deadly” (Source I). There are those who claim that “Drones have already transformed modern warfare. Sitting in front of a video screen at a military base in the U.S.,drone operators use joysticks to pilot drones over targets thousands of miles away” (Source A); however, in reality when the drone’s operators are so tranquil. “Drone strikes kill large number of civilians and traumatize local populations” (Source J). Source J stating that civilians and local population live in fear by the Drone, thinking at any minute they can strike and take away their family or loved ones. Just like in (Source F) when the boy questions the killing of his innocent family, leaving him all alone. Drones are operated by the U.S military, but can “escape their operators control and crash because of software glitches, wind...
Words: 449 - Pages: 2
...Drones of Warfare Since October 1, 2015, alone two thousand three hundred and twenty-six United States Military officers have died. If there was any way to save those two thousand brave men and women would you take that chance? The solution for that problem is military drone use. Drones should be used for military actions. By defining the benefit of drone usage in the military, refuting arguments that drones are not worth the risk and are pressing up against international laws, and presenting evidence one will be persuaded to believe that drones should be used in the military. By using drones in the military thousands of lives will be saved each month by taking those men and women out of the crossfire. “ A drone strike can kill a person in one room of a house and spare the lives of other people in other rooms.” (source A) This evidence is proving that drone strikes have a more precise aim than that of armed military men especially with many civilians in between the army man and the target. “The traditional weapons...
Words: 585 - Pages: 3
...Law of War PE 1 1. What would your response to the order be? The order is violating the Laws of War. You can’t force civilians to leave if they don’t want to. Also, you are supposed to protect civilian property more than government property. Destroying the homes could be considered hostile act against civilians. 2. Would you change it? Yes 3. How? Inform the mayor that at 0600 the evacuation will begin and he should gather every one up that is willing to leave. Ask him to inform the people that staying could get them killed and that we will make every effort to keep their homes safe. We will help rebuild any homes that are damaged. 4. What actions would you employ to prevent Law of War violations and crimes? The best thing I could do is to ensure proper training of my soldiers and enforcing the standard as spelled out in FM 27-10. 10.00 out of 10 Law of War PE 2 1. As a senior squad leader how would you respond to this? I would speak with the commander and state that I understand that the destruction of these weapons is a necessity to the safety of the Military, but civilian casualties are always our concern and never an option. 2. What would be your course of action? My course of action would be to ensure an evacuation the sector of town surrounding the weapon manufacture and the warehouses storing the weapons. An operation order outlining a plan to overtake the manufacture and weapon warehouses without civilian casualties must be created...
Words: 272 - Pages: 2
...Advances in technology and weaponry have revolutionised warfare since time immemorial, where inventions such as the chariot, canon powder and the airplane effectively changed the landscape of warfare.1 The law of armed conflict (LOAC) that exists today has developed as a reaction to the atrocities committed in the past; the four Geneva Conventions and the Additional Protocols of 1977 originated as responses to the increased suffering of civilians in armed conflict due in part to developments of weapon technology.2 The legal instruments to regulate the application of these advances in technology can barely keep up with challenges resulting from the rapidness of the advancement of contemporary military technologies. Moreover, recent technological advances raise the prospect of upheavals in practice so fundamental that they challenge assumptions underlying long-established international laws of war.3 This is because advances in technology have dramatically affected the weapons and tactics of future armed conflict, the “places” where conflicts are fought, the “actors” by whom they are fought, and the “means and methods” by which they are fought.4 These changes stress the fundamental principles of the LOAC, thus undermining its ability to regulate the conduct of hostilities; namely, by posing challenges to the principles of distinction, proportionality, military necessity and unnecessary suffering. This essay aims to assess the impact technology has had upon the LOACs...
Words: 3294 - Pages: 14