Premium Essay

Juvenile Justice System Case Study

Submitted By
Words 858
Pages 4
In the next decade, I believe the “pendulum” of the juvenile justice system will continue to swing towards rehabilitation. The juvenile court's main focus was to use a more rehabilitation approach instead of restoring to incarceration since juveniles are just kids. With this approach, the juvenile court puts an emphasis on the whole child instead of the offense, used parens patriae as its foundation, discretion of the juvenile's behaviors, and has the judge be the sole determining factor of the juvenile's faith (Cauffman, 2018). Throughout history, it is evident that the pendulum tends to swing back and forth between rehabilitation and punishment, especially within the past century. In fact, cases such as In re Gault and in re Winship, have …show more content…
This will make it harder to control the juvenile's behaviors which will increase deviant and criminal behaviors (Kurlychek, 2014). Even during the "get tough" movement, Mendiola-Washington and Emeka (2014) argued that practitioners were focusing on new strategies that aim to prevent crimes by juveniles, early intervention and rehabilitating juveniles. To emphasize, the punishment approach is not more effective as the rehabilitation approach. One way that will cause a change in how juveniles are treated is by refocusing on the best interest of the child and addressing the racial disparities present in our justice system. Juveniles are still kids and the court should not impose harsh punishments for crimes they commit during their youth. It is evident that juveniles' frontal cortex is underdeveloped which affects their decision-making skills and increasing their risk-taking behaviors (Cauffman, 2018). The judges can use these developmental changes to fulfilled their philosophy of focusing on the whole child, not the …show more content…
In fact, statistics have shown that African American youth are nine times more likely, while Latinos are four times, to be given an adult sentencing than white youth (Cauffman, 2018). It is evident that minority youth are being targeted more often than white youth. The unconscious racism can also contribute to racial disparities found in the justice system. A study conducted by Graham and Lowery (2004) found that black youths are seen to have more "negative traits rating, greater culpability, more expected recidivism" and received harsher punishments (Piquero, 2008, pg.67). The results were the exact opposite when it involved a white juvenile offender. The disproportionate minority confinement requires the juvenile justice systems to address the overrepresentation of minorities in their system and attempt to reduce these number. To emphasize, the disproportionate minority confinement ensures that the youthful offenders "receive equitable treatment," without taking into account their social status and race (Leiber et al., 2011, pg.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Juvenille Justice Theory

...PS4115 – Juvenile Justice Practice April, 2015 Teen at Center Of Juvenile Crime Debate Trying juveniles as adults is a highly debated and controversial area of concern among law enforcement experts, the criminal justice system, and juvenile advocates. I remember a case that happen in Florida. Lionel Tate was accused of murdering his neighbor child that his mother was babysitting. This was a very highly controversy case, based on his age at the time of 12 years. My case study research was done on the case of Lionel Tate. Lionel was charged with and sentence as an adults to life in prison at the age of fourteen. Lionel Tate, who has been sentenced to life in prison without parole in the wrestling death of his 6-year-old playmate. Under Florida law, Tate faced a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole for his conviction on first-degree murder charges. Tate, who was 12 when he killed 6-year-old Tiffany Eunick, who faces an adult trial under Florida law had been being punished under strong laws designed to deter other juveniles from committing similar crimes. Some believe that the punishment was too harsh and it would deter other juveniles from committing such crimes. Tate: Case Study of a Failing System? Tate was tried as an adult under a 1981 Florida statute that gave prosecutors discretion as to whether to charge juveniles as adults. Florida is one of 15 states that grant prosecutors this type of power. A study by the...

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Future of the Juvenile Justice System

...Future of the Juvenile Justice System Lashanna Banks-Augustus Bryan Knight Samantha Mathis Barbara Minish Jenny Sutton CJA 374 July 2, 2012 Mecca Brown The Future of the Juvenile Justice System In 1899 the first separate Juvenile Court system opened in the United Sates. The Juvenile Justice system design was to separate juvenile delinquents from adult criminals. Documentation proves that juveniles do not have the maturity level or the responsibility level of an adult to receive the same punishment as adults should. Juvenile Justice System main focus is rehabilitation as a replacement for punishment in which the adult court system focuses on punishment. The juvenile system methods are based on causation theories throughout history. However, with new trends comes new theories and with new theories comes a new wave of both rehabilitation techniques and designing those techniques to fit each juvenile personal needs; proving that change is in need throughout the different areas of the juvenile justice system. Community Community helps juveniles in different ways. Juvenile law will place them accountable for their actions. The community can help to hold the youths accountable for each of their delinquent actions. The community could help intervene by providing an effective intervention for the offender and to have the child protection protect the neglect or abused juveniles (The future of children). Each community should help develop different programs that will help...

Words: 2199 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Juvenile Justice

...Juvenile Justice Process and Corrections Cheryl Cooper CJA/374 July 8, 2014 University of Phoenix Juvenile Justice Process and Corrections Case Study A youth on parole in Louisiana, Mychal Bell, 17, was ordered back to prison for 18 months following numerous parole violations. He had been placed on probation on four previous occasions for violent incidents. Bell was a former member of the “Jena 6,” a group of six black teens who had beaten a white student, Justin Barker, in December 2006. The incident was a culmination of a fight between blacks and whites. Various religious leaders, including Rev. Al Sharpton, called Bell’s re-imprisonment “revenge” by the judge and called upon the governor, Kathleen Bianco, to intervene (Champion, D. J., 2010). Brief Corrections Plan Mychal Bell will be ordered back to prison for 18 months for parole violations. Upon his release, he will be required to attend and complete an Anger Management class. The extra 18 months complete the original sentence, so any new crimes committed by Mr. Bell will bring new charges. Mr. Bell will be an adult upon release, so no communication is necessary with Child Protective Services or school. Juvenile Justice Process in Ohio Juveniles’ first encounter with the juvenile justice process is usually his or her arrest by a law enforcement official. Other ways that youth enter the system include "referrals" by parents and schools, delinquency victims, and probation officers. A decision is usually...

Words: 921 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Juvenile Wavier Alternative Approaches

...B) Alternative Approaches Maryland Maryland’s rising juvenile rate has made the state become more of restorative justice and more so a system of graduated sanctions in those sanctions there is three basic goals: public safety and community protection; offender accountability; and competency and character development. In other hand these ideas give Maryland to go to new directions (Simms, 2008). In Maryland the juvenile justice system is different than most states. The “The juvenile court may waive its jurisdiction with respect to a petition alleging delinquency if the petition concerns a child who is at least 15 years old or a child who is charged with committing an act which, if committed by an adult, would be punishable by death or life imprisonment. The court may waive its jurisdiction only after it has conducted a waiver hearing held prior to the adjudicatory hearing and after notice has been given to all parties. The court may not waive its jurisdiction over a case unless it determines, from a preponderance of the evidence presented at the hearing, that the child is an unfit subject for juvenile rehabilitative measures”. (Chapter 8) furthermore, in Maryland the juvenile courts handles all case that deal with juvenile. However, any juvenal that committed a crime that if the adults could be punished by death than the juvenal gets waived and also the child have to be at least 14 years old at the time the crime was committed(Delegate Montague, et al, 2002) . In additions...

Words: 1033 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cjs 240 Complete Class

... CJS 240 Week 4-Checkpoint - Case Study Critique CJS 240 Week 5-Appendix D - The Justice Systems CJS 240 Week 6-Assignment - Corrections and Treatment CJS 240 Week 6-Checkpoint - Probation Presentation CJS 240 Week 7-Appendix E - Gang Development and Control CJS 240 Week 8-Assignment - Drug Czar Presentation CJS 240 Week 8-Checkpoint - Drug Use and Delinquency Response CJS 240 Complete Class Purchase here http://chosecourses.com/cjs-240-complete-class Description CJS 240 Week 1-Appendix B – Statistics CJS 240 Week 2-Assignment - Individual Theories CJS 240 Week 2-Checkpoint - Delinquency Deterrence Response CJS 240 Week 3-Checkpoint - Sociological Theories Response CJS 240 Week 4-Assignment - Gender and Family CJS 240 Week 4-Checkpoint - Case Study Critique CJS 240 Week 5-Appendix D - The Justice Systems CJS 240 Week 6-Assignment - Corrections and Treatment CJS 240 Week 6-Checkpoint - Probation Presentation CJS 240 Week 7-Appendix E - Gang Development and Control CJS 240 Week 8-Assignment - Drug Czar Presentation CJS 240 Week 8-Checkpoint - Drug Use and Delinquency Response CJS 240 Week 9-Final Project - Justice System Position Paper - Juvenile Justice System...

Words: 892 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Jeveniles

...Juveniles convicted as adults: Unconstitutional How does placing a child in an adult prison, where they risk sexual abuse that eventually leads to suicide, teach them a lesson? Juveniles, who commit serious crimes, are usually seen as convicts or criminals who should pay the price of what they committed even if that means sentenced as an adult and occasionally with no parole. Some of these juveniles who are being tried as adults suffered from psychological traumas caused at home by their parents or own family members. People need to know what can be done to prevent these crimes. Placing a juvenile in an adult trial is unconstitutional and is abusing their rights. Many of the juveniles prosecuted as adults are placed in adult jails pretrial, where they are at risk of harm, abuse and suicide. People need to understand the importance and dangers of incarcerating a child in an adult correctional facility. The administration of justice should implement meaningful juvenile justice reforms such as, rehabilitation centers, counseling, and they should correspondingly perform psychological test before being prosecuted in an adult trial so the U.S can uphold the dignity and human rights of our children and ensure that no child in our nation is considered a throwaway person. Juvenile crime rates soared in the mid- 1990s, and that is why every state initiated strict laws against juveniles and began incarcerating minors as adults. That high rates of juvenile delinquency dropped quickly...

Words: 2520 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Cjs 240 Complete Class

...Deterrence Response CJS 240 Week 3-Checkpoint - Sociological Theories Response CJS 240 Week 4-Assignment - Gender and Family CJS 240 Week 4-Checkpoint - Case Study Critique CJS 240 Week 5-Appendix D - The Justice Systems CJS 240 Week 6-Assignment - Corrections and Treatment CJS 240 Week 6-Checkpoint - Probation Presentation CJS 240 Week 7-Appendix E - Gang Development and Control CJS 240 Week 8-Assignment - Drug Czar Presentation CJS 240 Week 8-Checkpoint - Drug Use and Delinquency Response CJS 240 Week 9-Final Project - Justice System Position Paper - Juvenile Justice System Item #: CJS 240 Complete Class CJS 240 Complete Class Purchase here http://chosecourses.com/cjs-240-complete-class Description CJS 240 Week 1-Appendix B – Statistics CJS 240 Week 2-Assignment - Individual Theories CJS 240 Week 2-Checkpoint - Delinquency Deterrence Response CJS 240 Week 3-Checkpoint - Sociological Theories Response CJS 240 Week 4-Assignment - Gender and Family CJS 240 Week 4-Checkpoint - Case Study Critique CJS 240 Week 5-Appendix D - The Justice Systems CJS 240 Week 6-Assignment - Corrections and Treatment CJS 240 Week 6-Checkpoint - Probation Presentation CJS 240 Week 7-Appendix E - Gang Development...

Words: 910 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Crime

...Margie P. Permenter CJ 606: The Transferring of Juvenile Offenders Commentary Three Dr. Yaschica Williams The most serious juvenile crimes have always been the political Achilles’ heel of the American juvenile court Fagan & Zimring (2000). Even when public opinion is tolerant of juvenile delinquency, the teen killer is the nightmare case for the juvenile justice system. In an age where the phrase juvenile super predator is often heard in the federal congress and state legislatures, the deep-end adolescent offender is a particular threat to public acceptance of the mission and objectives of juvenile justice. It is little wonder, then, that legislation concerning transfer is a near-universal feature of the politics of juvenile justice. The traditionally stated purpose of judicial wavier is to permit individualization of the decision whether a particular person is capable of being rehabilitated in the juvenile system-the amenability decision Fagan & Zimring (2000). In addition, the judicial wavier procedure provides a safety value for the juvenile system to exclude children who commit offenses that are believed to require the imposition of sanction that are beyond the capacity of the juvenile system to provide. Some form of judicial wavier or a substitute safety value is necessary in order to preserve the juvenile justice system politically within the context of modern penological expectations. It is difficult empirically to evaluate the contemporary role of judicial...

Words: 1870 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Future of the Juvenile Justice System Proposal

...Future of the Juvenile Justice System Proposal Gina Tompkins, Marcus Hall, Terri Washington, Victor Jones CJA 374 November 24, 2013 Bruce Clingan Future of the Juvenile Justice System Proposal The juvenile justice system is designed to correct and change the behavior of juvenile offenders. Change in behavior is an indication the system is working. If there is no change, the system is deemed ineffective and a team of juvenile justice consultants are called in to make corrections. In reality, this team is composed of four state officials whose sole purpose is to develop a proposal to present to the state legislature for recommendations of adjustments to the juvenile justice system. This team of consultants is creating these recommendations including all aspects of community, law enforcement, courts, corrections, and the private sector or privatization involvement. The community should be involved in the future of the juvenile justice system along with funding, awareness, and assistance from the state. Characteristics of the Golden Program and the Reclaiming Futures Program The recommendation to the state legislature is to improve the juvenile justice system by introducing proven ways of enhancing community involvement through community-based programs such as the Golden Program and the Reclaiming Futures Program. One proven way to improve effectiveness according to Nissen (2007), is a program named Golden (the integrated care network) that involves court personnel...

Words: 2603 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Juvenile Diversion Programs

...Abstract This study was concerned with juvenile diversion programs in the State of Texas and whether they work in reducing recidivism rates among offenders of both minor crimes as well as serious crimes. The study looked at four different treatment programs and the services provided by each. All juveniles were referred to the diversion programs following a preliminary hearing within the court system. This project ran from January 2017 until December 2017, during which time 562 youth were referred. The recidivism rates for each program type were calculated 24 weeks post diversion program through self-administered surveys as well as a review of court cases and a statewide warrant check. I. Introduction The juvenile justice system was created...

Words: 1661 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Christopher Pittman Verdict Opinion

...anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”. Human beings are not entirely fit. Thus judges just like any other human being are bound to make mistakes in dispensing justice. However, Judges are obliged to be ever watchful and mindful in their endeavors of delivering justice. Every day, all over US judges dispense justice to convicted persons and defendants. However, absolute justice ideally is hardly realizable across board since its effectiveness demands human infallibility. Although it might be even harder to reap justice, justice is achievable and pursuit for justice remains a noble order. In this case, a 12 years old boy, Christopher Pittman from the state of South Carolina on February 15, 2005 shot his two grandparents using his father’s shotgun while they lay on their beds, he then set the house on fire, drove his grandparents truck and fled with cash and weapons in his possession. The petitioner, Pittman was only 12 years of age when he committed this malicious acts. He was charged with premeditated murder and put on an adult court for trial. Christopher Pittman’s defense team claimed that young Christopher Pittman remained an innocent child because he still could not differentiate what was right or wrong while under influence of Zoloft, an antidepressant. The defense urged the court to consider Pitman a child thus unable to plan and execute premeditated murder as an adult will do. The defense urged the judges to consider an equivalent reaction of a juvenile actions of such...

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Juvenile Justice System History

...The History of Juvenile Justice system: The juvenile justice system began in the 18th Century, when children as young as 7, could stand trial in criminal court and is found guilty they could be sentenced to prison. Around 1825 the separation of juveniles and adult offenders were in effect and soon after, facilities for juvenile were established. In 1899 the first juvenile court was established in Illinois. The British doctrine of parens patriae, where the state would intervene in the lives of children and act as the parent and focus on the welfare of the children. By 1910 many states established juvenile courts services and by 1925 the juvenile courts were trying to figure out a way to merely help children through treatment rather than punishing...

Words: 953 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Juvenile Delinquency

...Juvenile Delinquency Juvenile delinquency has been on the decline in recent years. The study of the variables, and distinction between the adult and juvenile systems, has helped in the decline. Delinquency is a criminal behavior that is committed by a juvenile. Depending on where in the United States the juvenile lives, they will be considered an adult between the ages of 16 to 18. This age has been lowered for serious crimes like murder. In those cases, juveniles have been tried as adults in court. Delinquency refers to conduct that does not conform to legal or moral standards of society; it usually applies only to acts that, if performed by an adult, would be termed criminal (“Encyclopedia Britannica”, 2013). This helps to distinguish delinquency from a status offense. Status offense is a word used in the United States to describe acts that when committed by a juvenile are illegal, but not when an adult does it is legal. These offenses are considered to be a violation because the individual is...

Words: 1265 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Pros And Cons Of Punitive Rehabilitation

...When an adolescent commits a crime, should that make them an adult in the eyes of the law? Or should their age be considered and acknowledged as a shortcoming of a undeveloped mind, impacting their capacity for not fully comprehending their actions? These questions have plagued the juvenile justice system both in our current time and its history. The choice between harsh punishment or attentive rehabilitation as convictions for youth offenders I think the best choice is rehabilitation because it gives juveniles to another shot. Youth offenders are different from adult offenders biologically and this should pose a greater impact in the sentencing made on the adolescents in the juvenile justice system . Punitive punishment have...

Words: 500 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Juveniles

...Contact in Juvenile Justice System Statement of the Problem or Objective Youth of color have been overrepresented in the American juvenile justice system. Youth of color are more often arrested, court referred, placed in lock facilities, and transferred to adult criminal courts. Analysts attribute the unique age- and race-specific crime pattern to the confluence of broader structural changes including the deindustrialization of cities, the racial concentration of poverty and single-parent households, and the inner-city crack cocaine epidemic. In turn, media depictions of gang and gun violence by minorities—‘‘if it bleeds, it leads’’—fanned public fears and provided political impetus to ‘‘criminalize’’ more youths and punish them as criminals and to adopt more-punitive juvenile justice policies. Despite the lack of standardization in data collection and analysis, 32 of the state jurisdictions studied reported that race=ethnicity effects existed independent of criminal record offense involvement, whereas 12 states attributed DMC solely to legal factors. The proposed study contribute to our understanding of crime and policy response to crime. Youth of color make up 78% of those in the juvenile justice system. Literature Review & Theoretical Perspective Mallett and Stoddard Stated that African American youths are 6 times more likely than white youths to experience facility placement. Vazsonyi and Chen stated that even though there are a lower percentage of juvenile offenders...

Words: 2093 - Pages: 9