Leadership Handbook Scoring Rubric

Aspect|Criteria|
|0=Unsatisfactory|1=Needs Improvement|2=Satisfactory|
Articulation of Response (clarity, organization, mechanics)|The handbook demonstrates unsatisfactory articulation of response.|The handbook demonstrates weak articulation of response.|The handbook demonstrates adequate articulation of response.|
Score:|Comments:|
Cohesiveness (consistent look and feel)|The handbook is not cohesive.|The handbook has cohesive elements but is not consistent overall.|The handbook is cohesive and has a consistent look and feel.|
Score:|Comments:|
Overall Presentation (visual elements, report format)|The overall presentation of the handbook is not satisfactory and does not include visual elements or a report format.|The handbook presentation is satisfactory for some of the sections but not for the entire handbook.|The handbook provides an effective overall presentation with visual elements and all articles are in report format.|
Score:|Comments:|
Comprehensiveness|The handbook does not provide comprehensive coverage of the selected leadership topics.|The handbook provides some comprehensive coverage of the selected leadership topics but does not include major content areas critical for a new manager.|The handbook provides a comprehensive coverage of the selected leadership topics and includes the major content areas critical for a new manager.|
Score:|Comments:|
In-Text Citations and References in APA Format|The handbook does not include in-text citations or references. |The handbook includes appropriate in-text citations and less than 3 references with several major APA formatting errors.|The handbook includes appropriate in-text citations and at least 3 references accurately or with only minor APA formatting errors.|