Premium Essay

Minuchin

In:

Submitted By NeedPaper
Words 1129
Pages 5
A pod of family psychiatrists is sitting around and chatting about the state of family psychiatry. They are preparing for a plenary at the Group for the Advancement of Psychiatry with the goal of showing how far family psychiatry has come since the first psychiatrists embraced the paradigm of systemic thinking. They also are debating why family psychiatry is ignored in current practice, especially since the evidence shows that family treatment dramatically improves recovery rates for many illnesses.

When family therapy had its first wave of popularity, the charismatic leaders were out front wowing the crowds. Dr. Sal Minuchin's sessions were heavily focused on structure and boundary making, and involved much chair rearranging and pulling family members, especially children, out from between the couple dyad and into their own space and chairs One of his most famous tapes involved putting an ashtray between the chairs of two family members to literally increase the distance between them!

Jay Haley, Ph.D., delivered strategic barbed arrows that pierced the hearts of the family members. Virginia Satir demonstrated the theater of families, sculpting organic shapes that pulsed with the gestalt of the family. There was much smoking of cigarettes during the sessions, by both the family psychiatrists and the family members. Psychiatry was exciting. The possibilities for change were endless. It was the 1960s.

Unfortunately, in those early days, family therapy was oversold as the sole treatment for schizophrenia and other mental illnesses. As a result, families have felt blamed by the negative attention and are still hesitant to engage in traditional family therapy. Nevertheless, quiet pioneers, like Carol M. Anderson, Ph.D., continue to research and practice a measured educational and collaborative approach aimed at involving families in mental health treatment.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critique of Article

...connectedness that they are unable to obtain from other systems. After describing the demographics and different types of street gangs, Ruble and Turner (2000), apply the “same concepts that are used to describe family systems, such as hierarchies, subsystems and suprasystems, entropy and negentropy, boundaries, communication, and homeostatsis (Broderick, 1990; Minuchin, 1974; Walsh, 1982), to street gangs. They conclude that because gangs function based on an interrelatedness that connects every aspect of gang life together within a complex web of interactions, researchers and professional who seek to provide effective intervention programs must aim to approach street gangs from a holistic and systematic perspective. Points of Agreement with Systems Theory Ruble and Turner are consistent in their theoretical application of the concepts found in family systems theory. For example, the family systems concept of hierarchies is explored. In families, parents are in the executive position of leadership and make decisions that will affect all family members while children assume a subordinate position (Minuchin, 1974). This hierarchal system is visible in street gangs...

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Systems Paper/Bshs312

...Systems Paper BSHS/312 Systems Paper Structural Therapy was first recognized by Salvador Minuchin in the structural school of counseling back in 1974. Minuchin observed that families developed patterns within the family that resulted in structure. Each family operates with transactional patterns that represent a system. Structure is a mutual agreements made between people until someone decides that they want to go in another direction. Families have a process of verbal and nonverbal communication that amongst family members makes it easy to understand. The goal of structural therapy is to transform dysfunctional family structures by creating imbalance. The attempt is done by the therapist to influence the family into positive change. Ultimately, the goal for the family is to focus on having change to better balance. Family-Directed Structural Therapy (FDST) is an approach to family therapy built upon traditional concepts of Structural Family Therapy, the strengths model, and group work therapy. This therapy is focused on a multicultural population in the Midwest being researched the last 12 years. The diversity that the Midwest had was one of the better options for observation having the different cultures. Sessions are set and timed as the initial assessment generally requires one 90 minute session and then seven to nine sessions with a therapist. Therapist assists the family in incorporating the process and vocabulary of FDST into their everyday lives....

Words: 453 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Structural Approach

...Structural family therapy (SFT) is a method of psychotherapy developed by Salvador Minuchin which addresses problems in functioning within a family. Structural Family Therapists strive to enter, or "join", the family system in therapy in order to understand the invisible rules which govern its functioning, map the relationships between family members or between subsets of the family, and ultimately disrupt dysfunctional relationships within the family, causing it to stabilize into healthier patterns.[1] Minuchin contends that pathology rests not in the individual, but within the family system. SFT utilizes, not only a special systems terminology, but also a means of depicting key family parameters diagrammatically. Its focus is on the structure of the family, including its various substructures. In this regard, Minuchin is a follower of systems and communication theory, since his structures are defined by transactions among interrelated systems within the family. He subscribes to the systems notions of wholeness and equifinality, both of which are critical to his notion of change. An essential trait of SFT is that the therapist actually enters, or "joins", with the family system as a catalyst for positive change. Joining with a family is a goal of the therapist early on in his or her therapeutic relationship with the family. Structural and Strategic therapy are important therapeutic models to identify as many therapists use these models as the bases for treatment. Each model...

Words: 1894 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Semistructured Intake Interview

...These issues must be dealt with from a semistructured intake interview. In the study of family dynamics and treatment it has shown that chemical dependency clinicians should learn about the contextual, systems, and structural treatment theorist (Buelow, Buelow, 1998, P.172). Structure treatment should be implemented to ensure the veteran is receiving the best method possible to move the veteran through the stages of change. This include non traditional such as Alcohol Anonymous (A.A.) twelve-step programs, Narcotic Anonymous (N.A.) twelve-tradition programs, and Al-Anon. These founders use every method available to move the veteran through the process of change. Religion, confrontation, and sponsorship for families were the methods for these organizations. These methods have last the test of time yet they are continuing to be use today. This is proven evidence that family intervention should be used from the initial interview. The treatment involving family members has shown better results than not involving family members (Velleman, 2006). Convincing the family member to participate in the initial process can be difficult. When a spouse, relative, or kin has enabled the veteran rather than confronting and opposing the use of substance, they are less likely to enter into the initial intake interview (Buelow, Buelow, 1998, p. 176). Family members are often confronted with shame, guilt and embarrassment. As a result, Challenges to convince the family members to participation often...

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Structural Family Therapy

...Structural family therapies goals are to reduce symptoms of dysfunction and bring change in the family unit by developing boundaries in the family system. The main idea of Structural family therapy is that an individual’s symptoms can be understood by looking at the interactional patterns within a family and evaluating the structural changes that must occur in order to alleviate the individual’s symptoms, (Corey, 2011.) Structural family therapy focuses on family structure, a family who has unorganized structures in the family system and boundaries and alignments, causes dysfunction within the family. Mendez, et. al. (2014), examine the main concepts of structural family therapy being structure, subsystems, boundaries, alignments and coalitions....

Words: 342 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Multidimensional Family Therapy (MDFT)

...Multidimensional Family Therapy (MDFT) is described as a science-based treatment for adolescent substance abuse and behavioral problems that place families in crisis, according to the multidimensional family therapy official website. While MDFT does cater to adolescents with substance abuse issues, they also reach out to those who have issues that are connected to their substance abuse issues like emotional problems, delinquency, antisocial and aggressive behaviors, and also school and family problems. Their purpose is very clear cut as their mission statement is to promote positive change in adolescents, help parents relate and influence their children, to help families communicate and love one another, and also to help the family dynamics...

Words: 260 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Structural Approach to Family Counseling

...Structural Approach to Family Counseling Beverly Manning COUN 601 – Marriage and Family Counseling I Liberty University July 5, 2013 ABST RACT Families are always growing and changing. They are considered living systems made up of many components. If families can’t adjust to change, the capability of the family and its individual members can be compromised. Structural family therapy (SFT) is a therapeutic approach that identifies that families have a lot of strengths. SFT tries to push families past dysfunctional patterns of interaction. This report details the application of the structural family therapy model, and I will specify my own therapeutic technique and explain how I would include faith into my counseling sessions. Structural Approach to Family Counseling One of the most important goals of a therapist is to understand how a family works. The family therapy movement has had the daunting task of trying to uncover the many facets of the family. Family therapy is full of many different approaches from psychoanalysis to the narrative approach. Each approach has been able to uncover a new aspect of the family. According to Nicholas (1999), the structural family therapy has had a significant impact on family therapy by introducing concepts of family hierarchy and boundaries. This allowed for the introduction to the idea of family as a new and organized strategy to cope...

Words: 3701 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Structural Family Therapy

...are also provided, in addition to an overall summary of what was learned in the process of researching Structural Family Therapy. Keywords: structural family therapy, structural family theory, family systems Structural Family Therapy Historical Overview Structural Family Therapy (SFT) was created based on a theory developed by Salvador Minuchin which focuses on functioning within a family system (Nichols, 2014). Minuchin was born and raised Jewish in Argentina prior to moving to Israel where he became a physician. During the early 1960’s, he worked with at-risk youth within underprivileged sectors of society and poor families. As a result of his work with minority groups, Structural Family Therapy is one of the only theories with a sense of multi-culturalism. In 1967, Minuchin wrote a book entitled Families of the Slums which described his experiences with these families. While he was trained in psychodynamic techniques, he opted to take a different approach in working with this population by focusing on sociological aspects and how families were impacted within a social context (The Minuchin Center for the Family, 2012). What Minuchin found while working with poor families was that the interaction styles between them were more action-oriented than verbal, so in response, the treatment team created techniques which entailed a more hands-on style rather than a classic psychodynamic or talk therapy...

Words: 3686 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Family Counseling

...Family Counseling Approach: Structural Model Jennifer Tankard Liberty University Abstract Structural family therapist takes an approach to therapy that seeks to help the entire family rather than looking at the family member that has a presenting problem. Healthy families have a healthy balance within the family subset when clearly defined roles are present. Structural family therapy was developed by Salvador Minuchin and a team of researchers from New York. The techniques of the theory are centered on creating a healthy relationship among family members. Structural family therapist looks at creating a healthy partnership with each member of the family to help the family find a solution to their problem. Structural family therapy can be integrated with a biblical worldview. Counseling from a Christian perspective will help families understand God’s design for the family, and understand the role of each member as stated in scripture. Christian counselors using an integrative approach to structural therapy will be able to help families see the biblical roles that God has set for the husband/father, wife/mother and the children/siblings to develop a functional family. Keywords: Theory, intervention, psychosomatic, integration, structural therapy, dysfunction, family. Part I Introduction Everyone has a family. Each family is different in how the system functions. A family is defined in many different ways. Some consist of the traditional definition of father, mother...

Words: 4305 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Essay #1

...stress in the relationship between these two people, a third person or thing is brought in to relieve this tension, known as triangulation, where two individuals are on the inside and another is on the outside of the relationship (Helm 2010). For example, if a married couple is having difficulty with each other, they may focus on their children instead of confronting the problems within their marriage (Helm 2010). When addressing the healthy family structure versus an unhealthy family structure, Helm (2010) describes Salvador Minuchin’s structural family theory. According to Helm (2010), Minuchin describes a healthy family structure as one that shows some flexibility in boundaries over time. Helm (2010) presented an example of when young children become adolescents, they are usually allowed more freedom in making decisions than they were as children. However, Helm (201) states that Minuchin described dysfunctional families as inflexible and unchanging over time....

Words: 945 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Mavis Family

...CASE STUDY:MAVIS, JOHN AND APRIL BIRD ASSIGNMENT 3 FOR PYC4808UNIQUE NUMBER .STUDENT : Siwa Gv Case Study: Bird Family Pg1 1. 3-generational genogram: Bird FamilyNotes on Map:  Size of Icon determined by significance of relationship and/or influence  Considered significant: information regarding Mavis’s deep distrust towards others  Considered significant: information regarding John’s deep attraction towards the “instant family”  Lack of information regarding relationship between Mavis with mother and siblings: assumed none  Lack of information regarding relationship between John with father: assumed none  Lack of information regarding relationship between April and biological father: assumed none PYC 4808 Assignment 03 Student 3350-133-5 August 2013 Fiure: Authors own Case Study: Bird Family Pg2 2. Eco map: Bird Family in ContextNotes on Map:  Size of Icon determined by significance of relationship/influence to client  Absence of arrows where direction of influence is uncertain  Spheres of influence outside of family is assumed  Lack of information regarding the interconnection between the two families of origin  Lack of information regarding relationship between April and biological father: assumed none PYC 4808 Assignment 03 Student 3350-133-5 August 2013 Figure: Authors own Case Study: Bird Family Pg3 3. Perspectives:a. Perspective of each family member: Mavis Bird: Mavis Bird grew up in what appears to have been an unstable...

Words: 3393 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Assign Two Pyc4808

...PYC4808 Ecosystemic Psychology Assignment Two Question 1 : Name and define the first-order cybernetic principles as described in your prescribed textbook. When viewing first-order cybernetics, we observe from the outside of what is going on in the system. We do not view ourselves as part of the system and do not concern ourselves with what the system does or why it does it. What we are concerned with is describing what is happening in the system. We aim to answer questions such as, “who are members of the system?, what are the characteristic patterns of interaction in this system?, what rules and roles form the boundaries of the system and distinguish it as separate from other systems?. “(Becvar & Becvar 2014. Pg 69 ) In first-order cybernetics we also attempt to find out how freely information is transmitted in and out of the particular system, as well as view the balance between change and stability within the system. Consistent with the element of recursiveness, the system is one that has reciprocal causalty and not linear and both people and events are mutually interactive and influenced. In order to analyze the family system, relationships and interactions amongst members are viewed instead of viewing the individuals in isolation. From the perspective all systems are influenced and influence each other. From a cybernetic perspective, we acknowledge that an isolated cause/effect event is only a small part of a large pattern of circularity. “Feedback refers to the...

Words: 2828 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Pyc4805 Mind Map Assinment

...TABLE OF CONTENT CONTENTS | PAGES | 1 Question 1: Three-generational genogram | 2 | 2.Question 2: Ecomap | 4 | 3. Question 3: a) Story as seen from perspective of each family members | 6 | b) The story from the vantage point of the family position in the family life cycle | 7 | 4. Question 4: First-order cybernetic description | 9 | 5. Question 5: Second-order cybernetic description | 12 | 6. Reference | 15 | Ecosystemic Assignment no: 3 PYC4808 UNIQUE NO: 536936 QUESTION 1 Three-generational genogram of the Bird family Mavis’ stepmom Mavis’ stepmom John’s mom John’s mom Family A (John’s family) Family B(Mavis’s family) Mavis’s father Mavis’s father Mavis’s mom Mavis’s mom ? ? John’s father John’s father Alex Alex ? ? B.F’ Mom B.F’ Mom S S B2 B2 Alexandra (John' stepbrother Alexandra (John' stepbrother John (45yrs) John (45yrs) B3 B3 B.F B.F Mavis (42) Mavis (42) Howard (50yrs) Howard (50yrs) Weak relationship April (15yrs) April (15yrs) KEY : Male: Female: Marriage: Divorce: Relationship abuse: Moved to: Foster home: S: Mavis’s sister B1: Mavis’s brother number 1 B2: Mavis’s brother number 2 B.F: Mavis’s best friend Mavis’s deceased friend : B.F mom : Best friend’s mom Weak relationship: _ _ _ Affected: alcoholic: QUESTION 2 Ecomap of the Bird family John’s dad John’s dad Mavis’s brother Mavis’s brother Mavis’s dad Mavis’s dad Mavis’s stepmom Mavis’s stepmom ...

Words: 2946 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Struc

...specific issue that someone outside of the family can help with better than then members involved as sometimes it is difficult for members to determine what their role is and how to have proper cohesion with their loved ones as we are all emotional people. There are several models used to address families, depending on the situation and what they are needing to improve. This particular model is called structural family therapy (SFT), this model is a method of psychotherapy developed by Salvador Minuchin which addresses problems in functioning within the family. SFT is slightly different from the usual techniques of psychoanalysis and psychotherapy within family therapy. The usual models suggest the family is a unit that operates within larger systems, such as culture, the community, and organizations. The goal is for this particular system to grow and change overtime, but sometimes a family gets “stuck,” often resulting from behavioral or mental health issues of one of its family members. Minuchin says a family is function or dysfunctional depending on its ability to adapt to various stressors. Structural family therapy is a model of treatment that is based on systems theory. The model focuses on structural changes as the main goal of therapy (Colapinto, as cited in Home, 2000). It is a way of thinking and...

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ecosystemic Psychology

...STUDENT NUMBER 46600361 PYC4808 ECOSYSTEMIC PSYCHOLOGY ASSIGNMENT NUMBER 2 UNIQUE ASSIGNMENT NUMBER 588438 TOPIC: FIRST AND SECOND ORDER CYBERNETICS TABLE OF CONTENTS Page 1. Introduction 1 2. First order cybernetics 1 3. Second order cybernetics 1 4. How reality is seen by each approach 2 5. How health and pathology is addressed by each approach 3 6. Role and function of therapists 4 7. Ethical concerns 4 8. How first and second order cybernetic approach can be integrated In a useful and complimentary way 5 9. Conclusion 6 10. References 7 1 1. Introduction Cybernetics refers to the principles that regulate the dissemination of information or messages. Cybernetics has to do with the basic principles underlying the control, regulation, and exchange and processing of information. The influence of cybernetics is apparent in the Eco systemic approach because it stresses relations and connections and highlights the study of interactional patterns between and within systems. Cybernetic theory regards the construction of reality as a non-linear concept, it is concerned not so much with what systems consist of, but how they function. First and second order cybernetic approaches are consistent with each other, in the assumption that reality is understood as perceptually constructed or created. (Becvar and Becvar 2006). This reality may be explained and interpreted in the first order therapy from...

Words: 2726 - Pages: 11