Free Essay

Modernization and Dependency Theory Paper

In:

Submitted By bertesfa
Words 1654
Pages 7
Abstract Over the past hundreds of years our world went through many social and economical changes. After the birth of the industrialized society, our world economical growth was fast. Many scholars and researchers have been trying to understand why the developing nations are still under developed. The modernization and Dependency theories will explain some of our world socio-economic differences between the developing and developed countries. This essay discussed about the major differences between Modernization and Dependency theories, and their impact on the developing nations.

Modernization Theory
A theory designed to explain the process of modernizing societies. The theory considers the internal factors of development of any country, based on the installation, that the "traditional" countries may be involved in the development the same way as are the developed countries. According to Gavrov (2005), modernization theory endeavors to recognize the social variables, which add to social development and expansion of society, and will attempt to elucidate the procedure of social development. At the same time Gavrov (2005) stated that none of the scientists does not deny the process of modernization of society (the transition from traditional to industrial society), the theory itself has undergone considerable criticism from both Marxists and the representatives of free-market ideas, and supporters of the theory depend on the reason that is a simplified representation of the historical process. According to Tipps (2003) the basic structural changes in this phase of modernity clear four elements:
a. Differentiation of the bureaucratic structure (social complexity)
b. Secularization of political culture (democracy)
c. Increasing the capacity of the political system of a society (bureaucracy)
d. Promoting practices of capital accumulation (growth and self-reliance)
According to Topik (1998) one of the key factors in the modernization theory is the belief that development requires developed countries to assist developing countries to benefit from the progress on their own. In addition, Gavrov (2005) stated that it was thought that the least developed countries, and can grow faster than developed countries to catch up, and it is possible for development on an equal footing, which will be reached.

Dependency Theory
According to Frank (1967), a Social theory whose base is the assertion that helps the resources to flow away from the "periphery” (the poor, undeveloped, underdeveloped, developing, and dependent countries) in the "core" (the rich, developed countries). This central position of dependency theory that the poor (underdeveloped) countries get poorer and the rich (developed) are getting rich with the fact that integrated into the global economic system. According Frank(1967) The dependency theory is a theory of the field of social sciences (sociology, history, economics and political science) who argues that poverty, political instability and underdevelopment of the South is the result of historical processes set up by the Northern countries has resulted in the economic dependence of developing countries.
According to Rodgers (2004), the inability of developing countries to develop was contradicted by a temporary economic take-off of four dragons in the 60’s which were followed later by the Asian economic crisis. Rodgers (2004) clearly stated that, against an obvious example is that of China and India since the 80's, however, these countries are still far from the front runners in terms of human development index (HDI), and the fact that these countries are developed does not mean the absence of obstruction.
It is clear that the proponent of this theory to follow the model of developed countries does not make sense, because their development occurred under certain historical conditions that are impossible to recreate in the southern countries. In addition, this model shows that this condition of poverty favors developed countries, and; therefore, they do not want them to change the global economic structure. Faced with this situation, the dependency theory urges developing countries to implementing the policies to generate internally the products on which they depend, and applying a more selective approach to engage in trade with the developed countries to implement measures of protection as tariffs and other taxes. According to Frank (1967), one way or another, this model influenced the various Latin American governments during the decades of the sixties, seventies and mid eighties, when starting with Chile; he gave way a model of free trade. And again Frank (1967) stated in Colombia, the trade policy change occurs during the administration of former President Gaviria and is known as economic openness.
As I have tried to show on the top, modernization is a process that has been seen as irreversible. In other words, once the third world countries come into contact with the West will not be able to resist the impetus for the modernization process. According to mass-society theory Tipps (2003) modernity augments the level of life, increasing the role of government and other formal organizations in transportation of everyday jobs beforehand executed by family members and neighbors. According to Gavrov (2005) cultural diversity and rapid social change make complicated for people in modern societies to define what morally is up to standard, develop stable distinctiveness, and find significance in their lives.
In the United States, modernization can present itself in many ways. According to Rodgers (2004) one way in which it is accessible is through changes in technology. The world’s technology as we used to recognize, or at least as our grandparents used to know it, has significantly changed. Rodgers (2004) also stated, in today’s world we possess some forms of technology, and some of this technology did not even be present until a short time ago.
Accountability from our government personnel, greater security and the ability for every citizen to make their own choices about their lives are more examples of our modernization. According to Tipps (2003) consumer spending is rampant in the US; we spend more than many other countries combined. Tipps (2003) also stated our medical, technological and scientific fields are expanding at a rapid pace, and education is given a high priority. We are expected 'leaders' and to be modern or urbanized people in order to compete with others for jobs, schools, even significant others.
According to Tipps (2003) this trend will continue and likely increase as we move forward. The job, housing and school markets are becoming increasingly competitive, and you are many times judged by your education, career choice and where you live. As the same time Tipps (2003) stated, people are encouraged to be entrepreneurs and to step out and create or expand industries and hopefully jobs for others. According to Tipps (2003) the information age has increased global awareness exponentially, and the US thrives off of this technology. Tipps (2003) also stated more people are marking their place in the World Wide Web, thinking of new or improved uses for it, and exposing their life, interests, and creations on it. It is not uncommon to apply for a job online, and then work online and never even meet the people you work with face to face. At the same time Tipps (2003) stated socially it is considered normal to meet and talk to people from around the world, either on a social or intellectual level that you would never even expect to meet in real life.
According to Topik (1998) in contrasting to the modernization theory dependency theory urges as those underdeveloped countries who are surviving in this economy under the pressure of the western developed countries. It also puts importance and responsibility for underdevelopment on external factors, unlike the dependency theory. Topik (1998) also stated that, this factor will make the countries that are undeveloped more dependent and poor. Topik (1998) also uses a key notion to give support to this theory is the ‘metropolis-satellite relationship’. Countries in the vein of London and Paris are all international metropolises; they bring into play their supremacy in the world marketplaces of goods. According to Topik (1998) there are more often than not controlling passing through the confined representatives in capitals of the third world, these capitals are the satellites. On the same article Topik (1998) stated this demonstrates that they are national metropolises and they, like the international metropolises, take advantage of the other local satellites and this procedure continues on until the poor peasant is finally browbeaten by their local property-owner. According to Rodgers (2004) Dependency theorists held to the underdeveloped countries that are developing, and should cut ties with developed countries and further internal growth. Rodgers (2004) again stated one of the policies developed from this insight import substitution industrialization. According to Rodgers (2004) Modernization theory failed to explain some of the critical issues decoration underdeveloped countries, such as demographic trends, and differences in culture, geographic location, etc.
In conclusion, the modernization theory is only positive and to the top of agreement. It is significant to appreciate the history of a state of affairs in a more sensible loom which can be taken to get to the bottom of it. Dependency theory investigates the history of countries and colonization. Attacking the subject of structural manacles on third world, the 16th century European invasion, and the familiarity of capitalism in third-world countries, Galliano has been competent to make available a clear clarification of how third world countries came to be undersized. The history is comprehended it is probable to work with it and correct its error so that the third-world will not be wedged to any further extent.

References

Frank, André Gunder (1967), “Capitalism and Underdevelopment in Latin America: Historical Studies of Brazil and Chile,” New York: Monthly Review
Gavrov, Sergey (2005), "The phenomenon of modernization,” Ithaca: Cornell University
Rodgers, Daniel T. (2004). "Tradition, Modernity, and the American Industrial Worker: Reflections and Critique," Journal of Interdisciplinary History
Tipps, Dean C. (2003). "Modernization Theory and the Comparative Study of Societies: A Critical Perspective," Comparative Studies in Society and History (1973) 15:199-226
Topik, Stephen (1998), “Dependency Revisited: Saving the Baby from the Bathwater,” Latin American Perspectives, 25(6), November, Issue

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Development Studies

...>>> español INTRODUCTION THEORY OF MODERNIZATION THEORY OF DEPENDENCY THEORY OF WORLD-SYSTEMS THEORY OF GLOBALIZATION A MODO DE COLOFON BIBLIOGRAPHY NOTES   1.  Introduction  The main objective of this document is to synthesize the main aspects of the four major theories of development:  modernization, dependency, world-systems and globalization.  These are the principal theoretical explanations to interpret development efforts carried out especially in the developing countries.  These theoretical perspectives allow us not only to clarify concepts, to set them in economic and social perspectives, but also to identify recommendations in terms of social policies.  For the purposes of this paper, the term development is understood as a social condition within a nation, in which the authentic needs of its population are satisfied by the rational and sustainable use of natural resources and systems.  This utilization of natural resources is based on a technology, which respects the cultural features of the population of a given country.  This general definition of development includes the specification that social groups have access to organizations, basic services such as education, housing, health services, and nutrition, and above all else, that their cultures and traditions are respected within the social framework of a particular country.  In economic terms, the aforementioned definition indicates that for the population of a country, there are...

Words: 6890 - Pages: 28

Free Essay

Modernization Theory, Strengths and Weaknesses

...interactions between various physical, technological, economic, social, cultural and political institutional factors (Singh, 1999). The thrust of this paper is however, not on definition of terms but a chronicle of the modernization theory, its basic tenants and its critical appreciation in the development context of the third world countries. In development discourse the modernization movement of the 1950s and 1960s is an economic theory that is rooted in capitalism. The concept of modernization incorporates the full spectrum of the transition and drastic transformation that a traditional society has to undergo in order to become modern (Hussain et al., 1981). Modernization is about Africa following the developmental footsteps of Europe. According to modernity, policies intended to raise the standard of living of the poor often consist of disseminating knowledge and information about more efficient techniques of production. The modernization theory assumes a total change of policies intended to raise the standard of living of the poor often consist of disseminating knowledge and information about more efficient techniques of production. For instance , the agriculture modernization process involves encouraging farmers to try new crops, new production methods and new marketing skills (Ellis and Biggs, 2001). In general, modernization led to the...

Words: 2167 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Development

...Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/AJHC ISSN 2141-6672 ©2011 Academic Journals Review A critique of modernization and dependency theories in Africa: Critical assessment J. Matunhu Department of Development Studies, Midlands State University, Zimbabwe. E-mail: matunhuj@msu.ac.zw. Accepted 6 April, 2011 The way states and development specialists rationalize how to commit economic resources to development is influenced, to a greater extent by their level of persuasion towards specific development theories. The discourse assesses the influence of modernization and dependency theories on Africa’s development. The conclusion is that both theories have failed to help develop Africa. The discourse pins hope on the African Renaissance theory of development. Key words: Modernization, dependency, rural underdevelopment, African renaissance. INTRODUCTION Africa houses plentiful economic resources. Paradoxically, the continent languishes in poverty as evidenced by high prevalence of famine, disease and ignorance (Buthelezi, 2007). This presentation attributes the poverty to theories of development because the way society deals with underdevelopment is influenced by development theories. The presentation assesses the effect of modernity and dependency theories on Africa’s development and concludes by recommending the adoption of the African Renaissance theory to Africa’s development. In this presentation, development is viewed as a gradual transition of society to a strong...

Words: 6577 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Wid Wad Gad Theories

...importance of the roles and status of women in development process. It is meant to give special attention to the women's role, while extending development assistance. For the effective and efficient implementation of assistance, it is essential to ensure that the women should have the opportunities to participate positively as important players in development process. Such enlargement of opportunities will also pave the way for the enhancement of women's status. Boserup's documentation of the regressive impact of development on women's lives and livelihoods signalled the start of liberal feminists' advocacy of the integration of women in to development, as workers and producers. Tiano(1984) notes that some scholars, upon seeing that modernization costs were being shouldered largely by women, advocated changes in...

Words: 2167 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Gender Issues

...V March 1989 WID, WAD, GAD: TRENDS IN RESEARCH AND PRACTICE Eva M. Rathgeber* International Development Research Centre Ottawa * The views expressed here are those of the author and This paper was do not necessarily reflect those of IDRC. originally presented at the meetings of the Canadian Institute for the Advancement of Women held in Quebec City, November 1988. 2 During the past few years, the term "women in development" has become common currency both inside and outside academic settings. But while "women in development" or "WID", is understood to mean the integration of women into global processes of economic, political and social growth and change, there often is confusion about the meaning of two more recent acronyms, "WAD" and "dAD". This paper will begin with in an examination of meanings and "WAD" and "GAD" and assumptions embedded look at the "WID," then will extent to which differing views of the relationship between gender and development have influenced research, policymaking and international agency thinking since the mid1960s. it is suggested that each term has been associated with a varying set of assumptions and has led to the formulation of different strategies for the development strategies. participation of women in ORIGINS 1. women in Development The term "women in development" came into use in the early Women's Role in 1970s, after the publication of Ester Boserup's Economic Development (1970). Boserup was the...

Words: 6049 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Gender Empowerment and Development

...V March 1989 WID, WAD, GAD: TRENDS IN RESEARCH AND PRACTICE Eva M. Rathgeber* International Development Research Centre Ottawa * The views expressed here are those of the author and This paper was do not necessarily reflect those of IDRC. originally presented at the meetings of the Canadian Institute for the Advancement of Women held in Quebec City, November 1988. 2 During the past few years, the term "women in development" has become common currency both inside and outside academic settings. But while "women in development" or "WID", is understood integration of women into global processes the of to mean economic, political and social growth and change, there often is confusion about the meaning of two more recent acronyms, This paper will begin with assumptions embedded look at the in an "WID," "WAD" and "dAD". examination of meanings and "WAD" and "GAD" and then will extent to which differing views of the relationship between gender and development have influenced research, policymaking and international agency thinking since the mid1960s. it is suggested that each term has been associated with a varying set of assumptions and has led to the formulation of different strategies for the participation of women in development strategies. ORIGINS 1. women in Development The term "women in development" came into use in the early 1970s, after the publication of Ester Boserup's Economic Development (1970). Boserup was Women's Role in...

Words: 6049 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Criticizing the Modernization Theory

...Housiny POLS 310 Professor Ahmed Abd Raboh Term Paper Criticize the modernization theory using all available materials on modernization and its critique, providing your own opinion on how modernization leads to development. The way people, societies, and countries develop and interact with each other have a strong influence on deviance. Although societies may differ in appearance and way of life, they all have crime, religion, family structure, politics, and economy. The vast differences in societies are constantly studied and theorized. Grand theories, for example, are meta-theories that examine an aspect of society on a global or national scale. One particular theory of interest is the modernization theory. The modernization theory suggests that the main causes of crime are the repercussions of the rapid development and modernization of nations (Howard 148). The theory of modernization is composed of three distinct Parts: (1) Identification of types of societies, and explanation of how those designated as modernized or relatively modernized differ from others; (2) specification of how societies become modernized, comparing factors that are more or less conducive to transformation; and (3) generalizations about how the parts of a modernized society fit together, involving comparisons of stages of modernization and types of modernized societies with clarity about prospects for further modernization. (Defining Modernization) Part one explains that there must be qualities...

Words: 1985 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Sociology Information

...Introduction To Sociology II notes by Mutangi G T Sociology is the study of human social life. Because human social life is so expansive, sociology has many sub-sections of study, ranging from the analysis of conversations to the development of theories to try to understand how the entire world works. This chapter will introduce you to sociology and explain why it is important, how it can change your perspective of the world around you, and give a brief history of the discipline. History Sociology is a relatively new academic discipline. It emerged in the early 19th century in response to the challenges of modernity. Increasing mobility and technological advances resulted in the increasing exposure of people to cultures and societies different from their own. The impact of this exposure was varied, but for some people included the breakdown of traditional norms and customs and warranted a revised understanding of how the world works. Sociologists responded to these changes by trying to understand what holds social groups together and also explore possible solutions to the breakdown of social solidarity. Early Sociological Studies Early sociological studies considered the field to be similar to the natural sciences like physics or biology. As a result, many researchers argued that the methodology used in the natural sciences were perfectly suited for use in the social sciences, including Sociology. The effect of employing the scientific method and stressing empiricism was the...

Words: 12675 - Pages: 51

Premium Essay

Demographic Transition Theory

...The world and most districts and nations are continuing to experience phenomenally fast demographic change. Demography is involved with everything that impacts or can be affected by populace size, development or decrease, spatial dispersion, structure, and attributes (Weeks, 2015). Demography is a power on the planet that impacts change in human prosperity of which the world has seen in the course of the last couple of hundred years. Demographic transition theory is from the early 20th century and is a collection of demographic data on a much larger scale. It is quantitative studies across different societies based on fertility, morality, and resultant growth rates. The demographic transition theory was developed in an attempt to make sense of all of this international data. From the demographic transition theory, we observe very different modern demographic regimes from Western Europe, central Europe and the developing world. This paper abridges key patterns in populace size, fertility and mortality among these transitions and the causes and consequences of population change. There are three fundamental stages of demographic change. The first stage is of high growth potential. In this stage, there is high fertility and high morality and the population is stable. Additionally in the first stage, an economy is primitive and in reverse. Agriculture is the principle occupation, which gives low level of pay to individuals. The way of life is exceptionally poor and individuals...

Words: 1932 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Impact of Foreign Aid in Kenya

...as exposing its shortcomings. Judging from the level of aid that the developing world receives and the economic development that takes place in third world countries, there appears to be an inverse relationship between aid and development. With this continuing debate, my interest of study has been to find out foreign aid’s impact to development in Kenya as it is dependent of aid but poverty still seems impossibility in the country for many decades. Therefore, the study will seek to expose these pitfalls of foreign assistance to a nation’s growth and development, using the Kenyan example to illustrate this relationship. The prevailing research methodology shall be of a qualitative positivist nature. Debates still exist around foreign aid dependency and economic development in the “Third World” countries as despite the input from developed countries there hasn’t been much change witnessed in the developing nations which are still drowning in poverty since 1960’s. The study will highlight on the demerit of excess foreign aid has development whereby the more dependent a state is on donors, the lower the development in that state. INTRODUCTION Context of the Research Question Development assistance also known as foreign aid is offered by developed countries to their less developed counterparts to aid in political, social, economic and environmental growths. Foreign aid commenced in post-World War II as an instrument for reconstruction...

Words: 10863 - Pages: 44

Free Essay

Politics and Develpment

...of the Third World viz a viz Theories of Development Student’s Name: Course: Tutor’s Name: 17/05/2013 Outline i. Abstract ii. Introduction iii. Literature Review iv. Method of Analysis v. Analysis vi. Conclusion vii. Works Cited Abstract This paper analyzes the politics and economics of the third world. It seeks to provide information about development and the steps that countries in the developing world ought to follow in order to attain economic development and growth. The rationale is that the countries in the developing world have continued to experience challenges that hinder growth. This study will use theoretical models of development and discuss various aspects of development and politics in the third world. Keys Words: Third World Development; Modernization; Globalization; Global South Introduction Various theories propose ways through which a developing country can achieve economic growth while at the same time attaining development. This has precipitated politics in the global south. This paper seeks to explore various development theories proposed by various authors. Besides, the paper will explore elements of economics that are pertinent to the third world countries. This is in recognition of the fact that many countries in the third world still grapple with poverty and slow economic development. From Immanuel Wallerstein to Rostow, the paper will provide incisive information...

Words: 3288 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

International Financial Organisations

...Course Overview This course seeks to examine the major international financial organizations which have emerged and survived in the international system in the post World War II era. Emphasis will be placed on the Bretton Woods institutions, namely the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank (WB). Course Objectives • To show the relationship between the theoretical and practical dimensions of International Financial Organizations in relation to mainstream IR theories and in the subfield of International Relations known as International Political Economy • To introduce students to the major international financial institutions which have impacted on world politics in the post World War II era • To critically assess the roles, contributions, operations and prescriptions of these organizations particularly in the context of developing countries • To locate these organizations within the theoretical realm of the development problematique of the Third World You can realize these objectives by • Regular and punctual lecture and tutorial attendance. • Tutorials are mandatory, roll will be taken and there will be no pandering to absenteeism. Students must attend 75% tutorials otherwise students will be debarred from writing exams. • Frequently assimilating and reviewing lecture notes • Reading all recommended articles and relevant chapters from the designated textbooks before attending class since lectures frequently make references to and offer perspectives...

Words: 2386 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Ethiopia`S Development from Famine to Economic Growth

...Ethiopia`s development from famine to economic growth The classic theory of modernization has its origins in the 1950`s, a post-war period which challenged strategists to investigate the problems faced by the underdeveloped countries, in their attempt to provide aid programs and technological assistance and promote long-term economic growth and political stability. Typical traditional societies were analyzed in the processes through which they should develop into modern social structures by following an unidirectional path similar to the ones already tested by the Western societies. Several factors that contribute to the development of a modern society (including technological, economic, social, political, military and cultural innovations) were illustrated in many studies of this theory. The complexity of outcomes was generally overlooked, making necessary more than just the classic theory for a proper analysis of a country`s modernization. Thus, the Harvard Project, the most relevant study on the social and cultural aspects of development, emphasized that an ideal model can`t be defined, as the modern personality corresponds more to a desirable plan of modern society than to the contradictory nature of modern reality. Therefore, I will further seek to determine Ethiopia`s (one of the countries severely affected by famine for the last years) development in its process of modernization. Ethiopia has been plagued by famine going back to the 16th century. While climatic conditions...

Words: 2386 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Long Journey

... The Globalization and Development Reader. Perspectives on Development and Global Change. 2nd Edition Description: This revised and updated second edition of The Globalization and Development Reader builds on the considerable success of a first edition that has been used around the world. It combines selected readings and editorial material to provide a coherent text with global coverage, reflecting new theoretical and empirical developments. It provides original texts, including classics in the field and others at the cutting edge, which have been carefully edited for the non–technical reader, and offers concise definitions of key terms and concepts, requiring no prior knowledge about globalization and development or related theories. The second edition expands the collection of classic texts and, at the same time, provides the most important and readable articles and book selections on recent developments. More than half of the readings are new for the second edition, with a higher degree of editing for a student readership, and with increased coverage of China and India supporting its genuinely global coverage. New pieces help to capture the implications for developing countries of the recent Great Recession of the global North. There is more on global inequality and uneven economic development, as well as on women, international migration, the role of cities, agriculture and the environment, and especially climate change. There is also new material on the...

Words: 1212 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Project

...11. Understanding Development Theory In the Context of Social and Community Change by Michel Adjibodou[1] I. INTRODUCTION If you are fortunate enough to have walked the land and worked with the people of South Central Los Angeles in California, the mountains of Chiapas in Mexico, the plains of Tanga in Tanzania, the hills of Save in Benin, the streets of Hartford, Dorchester and Roxbury, the hills of Funyula in Western Kenya, one common characteristic you probably noticed is the resolve and resilience of those communities. Despite the daily challenges and stresses on their health, income, environment, land, and physical security, the residents are determined to improve their communities and create greater opportunities for their children. Many of us who chose to work in “development”, or who accidently ended up doing this work, must learn how to work in communities which face horrendous challenges. Engaging people in improving their own communities and, perhaps, working on broader issues demands that we develop great skills and knowledge, not to mention a certain attitude, some character, plenty of courage, and listening skills. Most of us simply behave like backpackers on our way to solve the world’s problems and save humanity from itself. Mistakes are made along the way, success stories abound, lives are damaged and rebuilt, hopes restored, and life goes on. Many practitioners working in communities around the world, and people who want to become...

Words: 11505 - Pages: 47