Premium Essay

Nacierma

In:

Submitted By msbf2001
Words 573
Pages 3
While reading the article about the Nacirema, I was taken aback from the extreme rituals of the Nacirema. But after careful consideration, I do see similarities to the American society. In some of the Nacirema’s “ritual” practices, there is a parallel to similar “rituals” in our society. We think of similar instances as everyday life, just as Nacirema do. While we practice similar rituals, we are different in that we live in a society of choice. The behaviors of this society resembles cult like tendencies to most observers, however, the behaviors are as innate as breathing to the Nacierma.

The “shrine” ritual of the Nacierma could be compared to our own bathroom experience. This is a private practice of ours also. The ”holy mouth man” could be equated to a dentist, the person that we entrust with our oral hygiene health. We do not however, place any religious practice with the act of good or bad oral hygiene. We are educated enough to know that cavities are formed from poor hygiene and sugars, not evil spirits. We also live in a status based society where the wealthy may live at a higher quality than the poor. In Nacierma culture, the wealthy had a better structure of shrine than the poor. And could afford to go and see the medicine man, while the poor will die attempting to pay for the care. Status is the same way for the wealthy in America. We do however; attempt to live in an equal society of the sexes, races and economic class.
We live in a democracy; I do not believe the political and economic system in this society is a democracy. I believe it’s more of a dictatorship. The people mentioned in the reading seem like they’re being forced to undergo the unusual rituals to fit in with their own society. Although the rituals performed are supposed to cleanse and be for the better of the people involved, they still seem forced upon the people. If it were a

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Summary Of Body Ritual Among The Nacirema

...seems almost impossible for such a culture to be able to survive with their customs, these sorts of things are what have helped humans reach the heights they have today. I found this reading on the Nacirema people to be quite confusing and almost unbelievable at first. The customs that Miner described sounded so over-the-top and at times grotesque that I found it impossible to have never heard of such a group before. However, after attempting to search them u on Google Images, I realized that it wasn’t even a different group of people when I noticed that “Nacirema” was actually American spelled backwards. It occurred to me after finding numerous similarities to Americans that Miner did this on purpose because he was trying to parallel the Nacierma society to our own. He is being satirical of the values and culture of America by making fun of our concerns over our appearance and our desire to make our bodies a certain “perfect” way. Miner criticizes Americans as being superficial because we care way too much about how we appear and will endure pain to fit in, exemplified by how we go to the “holy-mouth-man”, or the dentist. He also points out our reverence for medical practitioners and how we seem to believe that everything they do will help us regardless of what it is. The fact that this was supposed to mimic the characteristics of America made me realize how I was actually looking at things from my own cultural standpoint because initially when I read it, I only thought about how...

Words: 663 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Body Rituals Used by the Nacrimea

...misinterpretation and incorrect assumptions, which is exactly what Miner was trying to tell us. Being able to subjectively take a step back from the safety and comfort of our own well placed and overtly understood glass houses, while acknowledging that to know another culture requires a full understanding of that cultures beliefs and motivations. Given our normal every day rituals, we interpret what we do or say as the truth, despite the fact the different people have different cultures binding and guiding them as their norms. Therefore, the diversity can be just as surprising for the outsider, as perhaps it is for us at times. The author (Minor, 1956) details his script while using qualitative research methodology of the Nacierma (American) people and their explicit body rituals and beliefs through humorous observations and cleverly defined language defaults. He thoughtfully defines our ideologies with our economic pursuits, along with our stronger sense of development with the improper self -diagnosed images, known as our bodies, appearances and the American way of living. We as Americans, a unique cultural group, can be viewed by many others as being extreme or bias in our own self impressions, beliefs, and even undefinable...

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5