Premium Essay

Nummi Case Questions

In:

Submitted By higgins
Words 514
Pages 3
(1.) The article states that the lack of trust between management and workers at the GM plant most significantly contributed to the loss of GM’s competitive edge. NUMMI’s philosophy was to treat workers like partners and empower them with decision making capability and control over certain aspects of production. How workers should be treated was according to the article, directly responsible for the quality problems that lessened GM’s competitive advantage. The attitude of GM’s management and GM’s labor’s mistrust of management created an adversarial relationship that hampered production and reduced quality and efficiency of the facility. NUMMI’s attitude and culture with respect to workers created an environment where problems could get solved, workers were free to provide input into production and were free to stop the line or make changes where necessary. NUMMI workers felt accountable to their peers not to a perceived oppressive management. Workers depended upon one another to be on time and do the job right. Performance as a result was higher. Additionally, NUMMI understood that in addition to the concept of the way people were organized and managed, a good design and production system were vital.
(2.) (a.) NUMMI’s philosophies created an environment where both workers and management strived for the same results of Kaizen and Kanban. NUMMI built an organization based on mutual trust, stressed team performance and treated every employee as a manager. Communication and team work was strongly encouraged. (b.) NUMMI effectively reduced GM’s prevailing culture of mutual mistrust of management and labor. As a result according to the article “The Japanese system itself, with its constant follow-up on details, and ongoing improvements, helped create an environment where problems could get solved without confrontations.” (c.) NUMMI effectively did this

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Nummi

...RUDE AWAKENING Chapter 6 A Tale of Two Plants: NUMMI Teamwork Versus GM Bureaucracy One might not recognize Rick Madrid as the same man who carried, by his own admission, "a pen and a punch" as an inspector (wo years ago. Oh, the outward appearance hasn't changed much—tattoos and mirrored shades continue to be his trademarks. But the "Iron Maiden" T-shirt is now cleverly concealed beneath his sharply pressed shop coat provided by the company. He's a team leader now, qualified and sanctioned by his peers. He prefers to be called a team motivator, however. "I'm part of the team; I don't have a team. Let people maintain their own personality." —CM Today publication 41 workers. There is a pervading attitude that "if you give them an inch, they'll take a mile," because they don't really want to work. The idea, for example, that a worker in the plant would have the power to stop the line in order to eliminate a problem was heresy. Wouldn't such permission lead to widespread line-stoppage for every whim? Not, according to Toyota, if you instituted a system of worker responsibility and accountability. American companies might think they had a tight rein on employees, but with little responsibility resting directly in the workers' laps, there was also little accountability. And what were the workers being held responsible for? In the first instance, quality. In Japanese companies, quality was part of the process, not something added on in the inspection phase. American...

Words: 7944 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Vinamilk

...managers in the present day. A successful manager denotes leading subordinates by proceeding and applying new management procedures (Drumea 2011, cited in Lazaroiu 2015) that is required by organizations for its strategic achievement, which in this case is employee motivation. In the given Fremont plant of General Motors after nearly decades of internal conflicts, The Fremont Plant of General Motors (GM) had encountered bankruptcy. It was reopened and under the collaborative management of Toyota and GM with more effective management practices that were successfully at boosting employee motivation, which was formed as a legal entity, namely NUMMI. Motivation is defined as psychological process that induces employees to contribute to their work and perform “voluntary actions” that directly related organizational goals (Mitchell 1982, cited in Ramlall 2004). According to McShane et.al 2010, employee motivation can be categorized into different foundation of theories regarding how employees can be motivated. The composition will now explain how the alteration in management style reflects these theories. Afterwards, some recommendations will be provided in order to resolve the facing challenges as well as to give more suggestions on how NUMMI management can even further improve. Equity Theory (Adams’s Theory) Firstly, The UAW Labor Contract has diminished the payment and performance evaluation between highly professional employees and newly hired employees. According to Levine (1991)...

Words: 2516 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Frederick Taylor’s ‘Scientific Management’ Was for a Different Time and a Different Place

...Frederick Taylor’s ‘Scientific Management’ Was for a Different Time and a different Place “The principal object of management should be to secure the maximum prosperity for the employer, coupled with the maximum prosperity for each employee.” -Frederick Winslow Taylor Scientific Management was introduced by Frederick Taylor in the late 19th century. In this essay, I will address the question whether Scientific Management was for a different time and a different place. In this essay, I will analyze Taylor’s Scientific Management from different angles and base my argument on both sides. I will discuss that Scientific Management was introduced for manual labor industry, however, it can be applied and to today’s business world if it is carefully analyzed and reworked. I will argue that today’s management practice is derived from the foundations of Taylor’s Scientific Management and that in this sense his work is absolutely crucial. Finally, I will evaluate the relevance of Scientific Management to today, with help from a case study of the NUMMI car manufacturing plant. Taylors work focused on studying job processes, the way workers perform, learn the job and determine the most efficient ways of performing them. He found the formula of how to perform manual labor efficiently, quickly, with quality, error free and in a way to save energy. Motivation was kept by wage increases according to the amount of work the worker could possibly do. This is not t he way today’s...

Words: 2625 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Toyota

...A Brief Understanding of IBS ‐‐A Case Study of Toyota                              A Brief Understanding of International Business Strategy --A Case Study of Toyota   by Peter LIU, peterliu@acculine‐mfg.com    MSc International Business     P14B45 International Business Strategy Lecturer: Dr Yee Kwan Tang Sponsored by 10 May 2010   Acculine Precision Manufacturing Company Tel: 0086-574-28887315, Fax: 0086-574-28875303, Web: www.acculine-mfg.com, email: info@acculine-mfg.com A Brief Understanding of IBS --A Case Study of Toyota Page 1 / 12 Content  Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 2 Basic Concept of International Business Strategy ................................................................. 2 Brief Background of The World Auto Industry .................................................................... 4 Brief Background of Toyota .................................................................................................. 4 IBS of Toyota ........................................................................................................................ 6 Entry to US Market ........................................................................................................... 7 Americanization as A Way of Localization ...................................................................... 8 Recommendations...

Words: 3709 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Performance Objectives

...QUESTION 1 Using the specific operations performance objectives explain why do you thing TMC is a world-class company? A company should be concerned to satisfy its customers’ requirements for fast and dependable services at reasonable price, as well as helping its own suppliers to improve services they offer. There are five basic performance objectives and they apply to all types of operation: • Quality • Speed • Dependability • Flexibility • Cost (Slack, N. et al, 2001). These operations performance objectives are analysed here in accordance to TMC. 1) Doing things right by providing error free goods and services, which will satisfy the customers, is known as ‘quality’. According to the case study, Toyota’s vehicles consistently rank near the top in third-party customer-satisfaction surveys. Being voted by many market research and surveys as the car of the year for several years it shows that, Toyota has a successful record worldwide. Because of the good quality Toyota’s success kept going, where in 1995, Toyota was the best car in the Middle East. Also, TMC has produce a good quality cars that are quit and do not emit unpleasant fumes, such as more than 40 emission-control systems and dozens of technologies that have improved passenger-car safety (Ahmed, A., 2003, Coursework). 2) An other performance objective is speed, which means by doing things fast, to minimise the time between the order and the availability of the product...

Words: 1765 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Toyota Motor Company

...Question 1: What is the main issue/challenge for this case? TOWS Matrix | Strengths | Weakness | | S1: Extensive production and distribution networkS2: Strong focus on R&DS3: Strong market position and brand recognitionS4: Product diversification. S5: Produce innovative models in a cost-efficient way | W1: Product recalls due to defect quality could affect brand image and reputationW2: Declining sales in key geographic segmentsW3: Poor allocation of resources as compared to peersW4: Lack of high technical skills of engineering designs when they have high level of skills in productionW5: Loss of control. The management failed to anticipate looming problems and expanded too quickly, ignoring Toyota’s style of disciplined growth. | Opportunities | S0 Strategy | WO Strategy | O1: Growing global automotive industryO2: Toyota poised to benefit from growing joint venture with GM called New United Motor Manufacturing Inc.(NUMMI)O3: Strong outlook for the global new car market04: Augmented worldwide distribution and servicing network to increase market penetrationO5: Expanding automobile market and opportunity launching new products | 1. Exploit engineering and R&D capabilities to produce new and innovative car models(S2,05) 2. Integrate the competitive advantage of both Toyota and GM to create strong brand name and competitive position in automotive manufacture industry(S3,02) | 1. Closely monitor quality and overhaul its design and manufacturing operations...

Words: 391 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Operational Management

...A company should be concerned to satisfy its customers’ requirements for fast and dependable services at reasonable price, as well as helping its own suppliers to improve services they offer. There are five basic performance objectives and they apply to all types of operation: • Quality • Speed • Dependability • Flexibility • Cost (Slack, N. et al, 2001). These operations performance objectives are analysed here in accordance to TMC. 1) Doing things right by providing error free goods and services, which will satisfy the customers, is known as ‘quality’. According to the case study, Toyota’s vehicles consistently rank near the top in third-party customer-satisfaction surveys. Being voted by many market research and surveys as the car of the year for several years it shows that, Toyota has a successful record worldwide. Because of the good quality Toyota’s success kept going, where in 1995, Toyota was the best car in the Middle East. Also, TMC has produce a good quality cars that are quit and do not emit unpleasant fumes, such as more than 40 emission-control systems and dozens of technologies that have improved passenger-car safety (Ahmed, A., 2003, Coursework). 2) An other performance objective is speed, which means by doing things fast, to minimise the time between the order and the availability of the product or service that gives the customer e speed advantage. The TMC’s techniques are focussed operations that reduce complexity by using simple and...

Words: 1635 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ikea Performance Objectives

...QUESTION 1 Using the specific operations performance objectives explain why do you thing TMC is a world-class company? A company should be concerned to satisfy its customers’ requirements for fast and dependable services at reasonable price, as well as helping its own suppliers to improve services they offer. There are five basic performance objectives and they apply to all types of operation: • Quality • Speed • Dependability • Flexibility • Cost (Slack, N. et al, 2001). These operations performance objectives are analysed here in accordance to TMC. 1) Doing things right by providing error free goods and services, which will satisfy the customers, is known as ‘quality’. According to the case study, Toyota’s vehicles consistently rank near the top in third-party customer-satisfaction surveys. Being voted by many market research and surveys as the car of the year for several years it shows that, Toyota has a successful record worldwide. Because of the good quality Toyota’s success kept going, where in 1995, Toyota was the best car in the Middle East. Also, TMC has produce a good quality cars that are quit and do not emit unpleasant fumes, such as more than 40 emission-control systems and dozens of technologies that have improved passenger-car safety (Ahmed, A., 2003, Coursework). 2) An other performance objective is speed, which means by doing things fast, to minimise the time between the order and the availability...

Words: 1763 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Wynn Resort

...General motors corporation (GM) filed for chapter 11 bankcruptcy protection, the second-largest industrial bankruptcy in history (worldcom was the largest). GM, which hadn’t made aprofit since 2004, declare in its filing that it had 172 billion in debt and 82 billion in assets. As any competent business student could tell you. The ratio doesn’t make a balance sheet balance, especially when the companys equity is worth little. Fritz Henderson, who named CEO of Gm on march 30,2009, was a numbers guy, but he knew the companys culture had to change. His vision of the new organizational culture revolved around four guidelines: risk taking, accountability, speed, and costumer-product focus. The problem was that GM had tried before to reinvent itself, with mixed success. “GM’s past is littered with the buzzords of culture change. It has struggled to impose cultural change across the highly bureaucratic company in which brands, departments, and regions operated like self governing and competing states within a federation. But GM’s executive said, this time would be different. After all, there was the bankruptcy and the selective elimination of entrenched leadership. Were things really changing, though? Despite his well intentioned plans, Henderson was fired by the board on December 1, 2009 some felt he wasn’t radical enough to change the company. His replacement was the person appointed by the obama administrations car czar to oversee the automakers revival after bankruptcy, ed whitacre...

Words: 4641 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Toyota

...Corporation is one of the largest car makers in the world. Although headquartered in Toyota City, about 150 miles west of Tokyo, it has production or assembly facilities in many parts of the world. The company is known for its effective and efficient approach to production management, its quality products, and its outstanding labor relations. The Toyota production system (TPS) integrates craft with mass production, and it is now emulated by its competitors. The system aims at producing high-quality cars at low costs, accomplished in part by having parts delivered to the production line “just in time” to avoid the high inventory costs of the traditional assembly operation. It is sometimes called “just-in-case” inventory system, referring to the practice of storing additional parts just in case a part is defective or is needed because of unforeseen circumstances. The effectiveness of TPS is aided by close relationships with suppliers and by continuous improvement, teamwork, decentralized decision making, and a motivated work force. Vehicles are designed with customers in mind, who can order cars according to their needs. Even after the car is delivered, customers are kept happy by good customer service. Toyota uses several ways to improve production. Workers are trained in several kinds of skills so that they can operate several machines. Electrical signs, called andon boards, show daily production figures and problems on the assembly line. They also can indicate whether overtime may be...

Words: 1019 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Strategy

...by you may be the subject of copyright protection under the Act. Do not remove this notice. For more information please contact copyright@cqu.edu.au CASE 6 Tesla Motors and the U.S. Auto Industry (Case B) Michael Janovec Georgia Institute ofTechnology Frank T. Rothaermel Georgia Institute ofTechnology LON MUSK, CEO of Tesla Motors, sped past the security guard in his brand new Tesla Roadster without waving . Despite his reputation as a brash leader, Mr. Musk normally took the time t0 exchange pleasam tries in the morning . Today, however, Mr. Musk's mind was traveling a mile a minute. The company had just filed its first annual 10-K with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and Musk had an important meeting with Tesla's board of directors at the end of the week to discuss the company's future. As Mr. Musk walked into his office, a photo caught his eye. It was a picture of him ringing the opening bell at the NASDAQ on June 29, 2010, the day that Tesla went public. As he looked at the picture, he thought about how that day had changed his life and the life of his fledgling company. Tesla had gained a much-needed capital injection, but along with the financial boost also came increased scrutiny from the board of directors. Now instead of answering only to himself, Musk faced questions from the board about how he planned to reverse a troubling decline in Tesla's share price over the past five months. What would be Tesla's...

Words: 3458 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Organizational Behavior and Leadership

...Organizational Behavior and Work M, W. 3:55 p.m. – 5:15 p.m. Hickman Hall – Room 205 Cook/Douglass Campus Faiza Abbas E-mail: faizaa@eden.rutgers.edu Cell : 401-301-0481 Office: Labor Education Center, Office 156 Office Hours: By appointment ______________________________________________________________ This is a preliminary syllabus and subject to change. COURSE OVERVIEW: Why should we study Organizational Behavior? We will explore the answer to this question throughout this semester. Briefly, the importance of Organizational Behavior lies in the fact that it helps us understand organizations. It is not just important for individuals who are trying to enter the fields of Human Resource Management or Business Administration, it is important for any individual who plans to work in an organization. Organizational behavior increases individual understanding of how people work in organizations, how they interact with the organization and with each other, and as an employee how can they improve individual satisfaction and organizational productivity. In short, Organizational Behavior studies individuals, groups, and organizational structures and how they interact with each other. This being said, it would also be pertinent to add that Organizational Behavior is a very vast subject and it would almost be impossible to cover it extensively in one semester. Therefore, the purpose of this course is to give you a basic understanding of the field and to provide you with basic...

Words: 1909 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Cisco Systems (2001): Building and Sustaining a Customer-Centric Culture

...challenges to Cisco as the company had to lay off 18% of its employees and reorganized its structure, transforming from decentralized organizational structure with three business units to centralized organization. However, these changes stabilized the volatile situation of the economy but threatened Cisco’s customer focus, a key element of its competitive advantage and a principle of its core operating processes. In order to overcome the disharmony between the structure and the culture, Cisco introduced a Customer Focus Initiative to hold the favor of its key customers. Nevertheless, Allred had no confidence that this action would fix the perceived gap between the structure and the culture. Situation Analysis: The main problem in this case is that how to keep enough resources to be used on the customer focus, which is the core component of the Cisco Company, under the reintegrated decentralized structure. At the beginning of the establishment of Cisco, Lerner, who is one of the founders, “realized that success was developing cutting-edge technology that was relevant to the consumers”.i Thus, she set up the organization which was called “ Customer Advocacy” to centralize all of the functions of the corporation that directly touched the customer. This means every member of this company, no matter which department he/she was in, he/she should keep in mind that the customer satisfaction was his/her greatest pursuit. The early success of Cisco...

Words: 1711 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Strategy Evolution

...The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania Management 223 - Business Policy & STRATEGY Spring Semester, 1999 Course Description and Syllabus Instructors: Phanish Puranam (PP) & Michael G. Jacobides (MGJ) Office: 2061(PP) /2055(MGJ) SH-DH (Management Dept. Suite) Tel: 898-1231 (PP) / 898-1224 (MGJ) Email: puranam@management.wharton.upenn.edu jacobides@management.wharton.upenn.edu Class Hours: Tuesdays and Thursdays 12:00 to 1:30pm Office Hours: By appointment (PP) Course Overview This course focuses on strategic management and strategic decision making and examines issues central to the long-term and short-term competitive position of the company or division / business unit. Students are placed in the role of key decision-makers or their advisors and asked to solve problems related to the development or maintenance of the competitive advantage of the firm. We start the course by looking at strategy at the level of the business unit, which is the fundamental level for competitive analysis. The perspective taken is of a manager in a given unit with particular assets, capabilities and competitive challenges. We look at industry analysis, examine the sources of competitive advantage, and explore generic strategies: How can we analyze the competitive environment, and what are the basic options for business-unit level strategy? What are the bases of competitive advantage? What is the nature of the value chain? Following...

Words: 5591 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

What Does the Matsushita Case Teach You About the Relationship Between Societal Culture and Business Success?

...Hill 7e End of Part Case Notes Part One: Globalization There are no Part One cases. Part Two: National Differences in Political Economy; Differences in Culture; Ethics in International Business Nike: The Sweatshop Debate 1. Should Nike be held responsible for working conditions in foreign factories that it does not own, but where subcontractors make products for Nike? Answer: Most students will probably agree that Nike should be held responsible for the working conditions in foreign factories where subcontractors make products the company sells. Students taking this perspective are likely to argue that since the workers are there to produce the products for Nike, the fact that the company does not actually own the facilities is immaterial – Nike is the beneficiary of the work done in the factory. Some students may suggest that Nike be resolved of some responsibility if the factories also produce products for other companies. 2. What labor standards regarding safety, working conditions, overtime, and the like, should Nike hold foreign factories to: those prevailing in that country or those prevailing in the United States? Answer: The question of whether of whether to hold foreign factories to the same standards as domestic factories is difficult. Some students might argue that Nike should require all factories regardless of their location to maintain the same standards when it comes to working conditions, overtime, and so on. Other students however, may suggest that...

Words: 13231 - Pages: 53