...RESOLVING ASBESTOS CLAIMS: THE MANVILLE PERSONAL INJURY SETTLEMENT TRUST MARIANNA S. SMITH* I INTRODUCTION There was no precedent for the Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust ("Trust"). A grantor trust, its genesis, birth, and evolution were influenced by-and its operation is still influenced by-many groups with differing agendas: the Manville Corporation, multiple federal and state courts, legal experts, investment bankers, victims' groups, plaintiffs' attorneys, Trust staff, and other trusts. The development and evolution of the Trust were further affected by a myriad of state and federal laws on, inter alia, trusts, securities regulation, contracts, fiduciary responsibility, bankruptcy, and civil procedure. These often conflicting constituencies and laws were forced into a compromise "peace" during the upheaval of the Johns-Manville Corporation' 2 chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. The Trust, an independent organization, was created by the bankruptcy court to distribute funds as equitably as possible while balancing the rights of Copyright © 1990 by Law and Contemporary Problems * Executive Director, Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust. This article was last revised in February 1991. In May 1991,Judge Jack B. Weinstein issued an order restructuring the finances and operating procedures of the Manville Personal Injury Settlement Trust. 1. In 1988 the Johns-Manville Corporation was renamed The Manville Corporation, and will be referred to...
Words: 4594 - Pages: 19
...if you need to hire a good personal injury attorney? Do you wish to meet with a personal injury attorney to check if your injuries are valid for a lawsuit? Well, if this sounds like your situation then you are in luck! This article will give you information on how to file a lawsuit and you may evaluate if you wish to purse a lawsuit or not. A personal injury claim is a legal contest, commonly among private individuals, in which one side is seeking financial damages from the opposite side as compensation for injuries. Understanding whether or not you have a legitimate personal injury claim can be challenging to ascertain. Many times the person or business that caused your personal injury will attempt to persuade you that your claim isn't valid. If you feel that you had been hurt due to another person's carelessness, then under the law you've got the right to demand reasonable payment for your injury, from the person or...
Words: 525 - Pages: 3
...Standard Federal Tax Reporter (2007), .04, Compensation for Injuries or Sickness: Damages for Physical Personal Injuries or Sickness: Damages for physical personal injuries or sickness Click to open document in a browser The amount of any damages received on account of physical personal injuries or sickness are excludable from gross income (Code Sec. 104(a)(2)). The word "damages" includes not only amounts awarded by a court in a lawsuit; it also includes amounts received as the result of an agreement in settlement of a suit (Code Sec. 104(a)(2)). This exclusion is subject to the exception for previously reimbursed medical expenses (¶6662.021). The exclusion is not available in the case of damages awarded to a corporation, because a corporation cannot sustain "personal" injuries (P & X Markets, Inc., 106 TC 441, Dec. 51,400. Aff'd, CA-9 (unpublished opinion), 98-2 USTC ¶50,613; ¶6662.523). Damages received on account of a nonphysical injury (e.g., age discrimination and injury to reputation) are generally not excludable from gross income (P.L. 104-188). Prior to this amendment by P.L. 104-188, the courts had reached differing results in determining whether the exclusion applied to nonphysical injuries (see ¶6662.041). This restriction on the exclusion from income of nonphysical damages is generally effective for amounts received after August 20, 1996, but does not apply to amounts received under any written binding agreement, court decree, or mediation award in effect on, or...
Words: 598 - Pages: 3
... 2011 in Articles The quick answer is damages or awards received for physical injuries or sickness are generally not taxable. However, punitive damages or awards are generally taxable if they are paid to compensate a taxpayer for non-personal injuries. Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 104 is the area of law that defines the taxable treatment of compensation for injuries or sickness. In general if a taxpayer received an award or damages for a personal injury or sickness, then the income can be excluded from taxable income. If a taxpayer received punitive damages for non-personal injury or a non-sickness then it is typically going to be treated as taxable income. I say typically, because tax law allows damages received for nonphysical injury or sickness to be reduced for any medical expenses which meet the IRC definition of 213. Or the attorneys might craft the settlement to be worded as a physical damage. There are many court cases regarding these issues. One to look at for damages received for non-physical damages is O’Gilvie, Kelly v. U.S. (1996, S Ct) 78 AFTR 2d 96-7454. IRC section 104 states, the gross income doesn’t include: amounts received under workmen’s compensationfor personal injuries or sickness; amount received through accident or healthinsurance for personal injuries or sickness; amounts received as a pension, annuity or similarallowance for personal injuries or sickness resulting from activeservice in the armed forces of any country or in...
Words: 600 - Pages: 3
...and suspended from a shelf to display sales goods. During trial, the employee testified that he gave the piece of plastic to a member of K-Mart’s security force and the piece of plastic had been lost. Hence, K-Mart did not introduce the piece of plastic at trial. Issue- Is there sufficient evidence that K-Mart was negligent on keeping their floors free of debris? Is there sufficient evidence that Mrs. Morris allegedly slipped on this piece of plastic without noticing it? Rule- According to http://www.hg.org/slip-and-fall.html, Slip and Fall law refers to the area of law governing personal injury claims which involve specific types of accidents wherein the party’s injury is the result of a fall. This area is a subset of Tort law and overlaps with Litigation law. Specifically, slip and fall cases fall under premises liability law. Analysis- Mrs. Morris’ slip and fall caused her injuries to her right hip and leg. The piece of plastic that she retrieved and gave to the employee of K-Mart was lost, the evidence could not be presented at trial. Conclusion- The decision of the judge was in favor of Mrs. Morris. Bell v. Grandville Cooperative, Inc. 950 N.E.2d 747...
Words: 700 - Pages: 3
...Article 2- Injury Rehabilitation Groin Rehabilitation Many injuries occur each year however every rehabilitation program is different. In groin injuries there are several techniques that you can use that can help you get better. The key is for athletes to rest and ice the groin. You should ice for 15 minutes for 2 to 3 times per day, with at least one hour in-between. Followed by abductor stretches, isometric ball squeezes, leg raises, weighted leg raises, slide board exercises, and resistant band exercises. By doing all of these over a period of time you will strengthen the injured area and hopefully won’t have to deal with more groin problems. Abductor stretches will help stretch your hip flexors by doing various exercises so you’re not tight and feeling stiff while doing sports. Next is ball squeezes, this should be repeated in 3 sets of 10 and this helps work the injured area get stronger making sure everything is done pain free. Leg raises and weighted leg raises show how much range of motion you have and when the groin is getting better the easier it is for you to do longer reps without feeling any pain. Finally is slide board and resistant exercises these happen near the end of your rehab program when you have full range of motion and are getting back into the line up of the sport you play. This will show the trainer if you still need further rehab exercises or if you are ready and are fully recovered. "Groin Pain Rehab." Rehab for your injury. 1....
Words: 265 - Pages: 2
...experiencing pain and suffering, you need a personal injury attorney. Before hiring the first person you see, be sure to explore a few tips so that you make the right decision. Reputation Although you may have seen plenty of TV ads or heard radio spots that discuss how a certain lawyer can help you when you have been hurt, it’s important to consider a number of factors. One of the biggest things you want to keep in mind is whether or not the person you hire has a good reputation. There are plenty of people that say they are a personal injury attorney yet they do not have your best interest at heart. Therefore, you want to make sure you do your research and ask around to see about the type of reputation this person has in the industry. Costs When you’re trying to handle the costs of having someone represent you in your case, it’s not an easy or cheap task. That’s because as a personal injury attorney, this person has fees that need to be paid for before any real work can be done. It’s a good idea to try to get the money that’s necessary early in order to have this person represent you. This way, you can feel at ease knowing that someone is there to handle your case and help you get your future back on track. Location...
Words: 463 - Pages: 2
...events at which a spectator might not be held to have assumed the risk of an injury? Are there injuries that a spectator or a participant in a sport would likely not have assumed the risk of? Yes there are sports events a spectator might no be held to have assumed the risk of an injury,for example track. Yes, for example baseball Rangers reliever pitcher Frank Francisco after threw a chair that hit a woman and broke her nose and was charged with felony battery. 3. Suppose that George, the owner of a softball park, has a duty to provide a backstop to protect spectators who want the protection against the risk of being hit by a ball. Nikita, a visitor from Eastern Europe, sits in the stands behind the plate where the backstop should be. Nikita has never seen softball, knows nothing about it, and does not understand the danger. During the game, Nikita is struck and injured by a ball. Can Nikita recover from George for the injury? Yes Nikita can recover from George for the injury because it was his liability for not having the backstop there and she was not aware of the risk. 4. Under the circumstances described in the previous question, Eldon, another spectator, also sits in the stands behind the plate where the backstop should be. Unlike Nikita, Eldon is fully aware of the risk. During the game, Eldon is struck and injured by a ball. Can Eldon definitely recover from George for the injury? Because he was aware of the risk he was taking and knew he could get hurt...
Words: 312 - Pages: 2
...Section 320 IPC – An Appraisal Dr. Dasari Harish, Prof & Head; Dr. K H Chavali, Assoc. prof; Dr. Amandeep Singh & Dr. Ajay Kr, Asst. Profs Dept. Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, Government Medical College & Hospital, Sector 32, Chandigarh – 160030 Correspondence: dasariharish@gmail.com Abstract: S. 320 defines grievous hurt and lists eight kinds of hurt which it lables as “grievous”. These clauses are not mutually exclusive, for there can be injuries which may fall in more than one clause. However, the list is exhaustive in the sense that, the framers of the Code have used the term “only”, while listing the type of hurts which they designated as “grievous”. To make out the offence of voluntarily causing grievous hurt, there must be a specific hurt, voluntarily inflicted, and coming within any of the eight kinds enumerated in this section. A simple hurt cannot be designated as grievous simply because it was on a vital part of the body, unless the dimensions or the nature of the injury or its effects are such that it actually endangers life. In the backdrop of the verdicts by the Hon’ble courts wherein it was held that the extent of the hurt and the intention of offender should be considered to determine whether a given hurt is grievous, an attempt is made in this article to review the Section with a view to put forward certain fallacies. These, need to be addressed to, in tune with the changing times and in accordance with the modern trends of treatment...
Words: 5053 - Pages: 21
...it was forced and the man was fabricating about what happened. While searching the area, I noticed the banana that the man claimed his wife slipped was yellow, in other words the peel was fresh. From my experience in working in food service, I know that by the banana peel still being yellow it means the peel was just placed on the mat. Also, the peel was lying on top of a ribbed rubber mat which. These mats are we specifically used to prevent “Slip and Fall” accidents. The woman was wearing five inches and slipping on a banana peel would cause a lot of damage to the woman and cause a lot of pain. But as I stated the woman did not seem to be in pain, the woman was forcing herself to appear believable. Slip and fall are a term used personal injury case in which a person slips or trips...
Words: 1276 - Pages: 6
...PERSONAL INJURY PROTECTION Personal injury protection (PIP) reimburses medical expenses for covered individuals, regardless of fault, for treatment due to auto accident. PIP covers the driver and any other passengers injured in the vehicle. PIP coverage may also be available for pedestrians injured by a vehicle. Personal injury protection also pays for funeral expenses, lost earnings, rehabilitation, and replacement of services such as child care if parent is disabled. PIP does not cover damages made on the car or any other personal property; it is just an extension of car insurance that is available in some U.S states. Not all states require personal injury protection insurance. Some states actually make it mandatory to have PIP insurance. Reimbursement from PIP payer is based on individual state laws and is provided on a per-person, per-occurrence basis. Personal injury protection is also referred to as “no fault” coverage because the statutes enacting it are generally known as no fault laws. Personal injury protection is designed to be paid without regard to “fault”, or legal liability. To determine coverage, the automobile insurance company’s medical adjuster reviews healthcare bills submitted to company for treatment of injuries sustained. The minimum benefits given are: 1. Up to 10,000 for reasonable and necessary medical expenses for each person injured in an auto accident. Available...
Words: 476 - Pages: 2
...Personal injury claims are unique for a number of reasons. To begin with, approximately 95% of all personal injury claims do not go to trial. Of the small percentage that actually make it to the inside of a courtroom, 90 percent of them end up in a loss. This means that your success in filing a personal injury claim is often tied to how well you do your homework and set yourself up for success in the beginning. Unfortunately, a slew of mistakes and problems can crop up as you deal with life after your injury. If you know what to look for, though, you can avoid these missteps and achieve a positive result with your claim. Common Mistake #1--Failure To Document In the world of personal injury lawsuits, no detail is insignificant. You'll want...
Words: 646 - Pages: 3
...When and How to File a Personal injury Claim From sustaining serious injuries in a car accident, to suffering a damaging fall on a spill while at work or out shopping, there are many routes that can lead you to suffer injury through no fault of your own and decide to file a personal injury claim. The legal territory surrounding personal injury is complicated, but there are some tried-and-true steps that you can take to determine when and how to file a claim. A Step-By-Step Guide to Filing a Personal Injury Claim Sorting Out Insurance If you feel that someone else may be liable for the injury or injuries you’ve sustained, the first important step will be to find out whether this person has insurance that can cover the damage. For instance, if you’ve been injured in an automobile accident, the other driver’s insurance may provide for damages....
Words: 487 - Pages: 2
...Personal Injury Attorneys possess the appropriate knowledge and expertise to negotiate with insurance companies. When you sustain an injury, whether it be from malpractice or an automobile accident, it is crucial to receive advice from someone who is passionate to make sure that you receive the most impartial settlement possible. In the case of an automobile accident, the other party may try to get you to sign away your right to a lawsuit knowing that you are not necessarily familiar with all your rights and the severity of your injuries. Hiring a personal injury attorney will make all the difference in helping you deal with your claim. Unless you work for a car insurance company, you are most likely not dealing with them on a daily basis—but these lawyers do. Because of their recurrent encounters with these insurance companies, they are very familiar with the process of negotiating a settlement. Because these attorneys are experienced with many difference cases, there is a high probability that they have formerly reviewed a case similar to your own. Therefore, they may already have a good idea as to what kind of a settlement you can expect at the establishment of inquiry. In addition to having...
Words: 567 - Pages: 3
...Why You Shouldn’t Settle Your Personal Injury Claim Many people assume that when you sue another person for a personal injury, it automatically goes to court and is decided by a judge. Many personal injury cases never actually go that far, since they are settled in mediation where each party has some control over what the settlement will be. If you involved in a lawsuit for your personal injury, here are some reasons why you shouldn’t settle and either go to court of continue with mediation. Your Future Medical Expenses Won’t Be Covered It can be difficult to come up with a settlement amount if you’re still dealing with the injury past when the settlement is agreed to. While it is easy to determine an exact dollar amount for existing bills,...
Words: 410 - Pages: 2
