Free Essay

Poem Response Paper

In:

Submitted By jb315
Words 873
Pages 4
In “Yet Do I Marvel,” Countee Cullen expresses an ambivalence that many of us are familiar with. It is not too difficult to sympathize with the poet’s opening lines: “I doubt that God is good, well-meaning, kind,/And Did he stoop to quibble could tell why/The little buried mole continues blind.” Here, it is made plain to us that his beliefs dictate that God is ultimately good and righteous, yet, nonetheless, life has apparently given him reasons to question his. As the title indicates, Cullen is marveling at life and human beings as God’s creations and the relationship we have with Him. Although he says he is free of doubt, skepticism appears to be present in this remark. Here perhaps the rather rhetorical question of why life is the way it is is being posed. It seems, at least up until this point, that Cullen is supposing that a truly good God would not subject His creatures to such paradoxical, even cruel, situations. Upon closer analysis of the mole and its scenario (“The little buried mole continues blind”), which may function as a metaphor for the poet himself, the possibility is not ruled out that the poet is hinting to us what seems to be an inescapably bad situation may in fact be a fixable one. A mole, like all creatures, has adapted in ways that allows it to survive, and it may be that Cullen is suggesting to us that thing are not as random and as terrible as they may seem and that there is a way out of challenging situations. The following line, though, counters this acknowledgement, corresponding more to the original direction the poem was headed in: “Why flesh that mirrors him must some day die.” Here he recognizes the absurdity in a God that would create beings in his likeness only to watch them expire. Cullen goes on to give more examples: “Make plain the reason tortured Tantaslus/Is baited by the fickle fruit, declare/If merely brute caprice dooms Sisyphus/To struggle up a nerve-ending stair.” He has come to the point of speculating about the apparent pointlessness of such strife and toil that is wrought upon those who already suffer. Again, he expresses his bewilderment: “Inscrutable His ways are…” Certainly, the ways of the universe are mysterious to us all and Cullen is no more enlightened than the most enlightened man, but the power does take note of a double standard that exists between God and all of us: “…and immune/To catechism by a mind too strewn/with petty cares…” With these lines he extends this logic, saying that we will continue in futility to question God’s actions, to no avail. And here, the usage of the word “catechism” is rather noteworthy: “To catechism by a mind too strewn.” It has a double meaning, being both a series of questions put to an individual and a book summarizing Christian religion, written in the form of questions and answers. Essentially, no matter how we question Him, God is going to do His thing. When Cullen says “petty cares,” there is a definite ironic tone there, again articulating how whatever we concern ourselves with pales in comparison to how God has planned out the fate of the universe. Cullen showcases another irony when he reveals that these “petty cares: we both with are in regards to understanding “what awful brain compels His awful hand.” Choosing to use the world “awful” is a pretty blatant example of hostility, although is it far from difficult to understand where he is coming from here. More subtle implications may be indicative of a play on words, though, conveying a feeling of intimidation on the part of man in the face of an awe-inspiring god. Nonetheless, it is almost absurd that we can carry on sanely having to accept the fact that our most fervent of worrying and deepest of pondering won’t bring us to life’s solutions. Our paranoia and inadequacy about whatever powers that be only continues to fuel our assumption that some untouchable, superior being does possess these answers. All of that being said, when we reach the closing of the poem, Countee Cullen is basically reduced to a “still, I gotta ask…” kind of mentality: “Yet do I marvel at this curious thing…” he says. The last line, “To make a poet black, and bid him sing!” brings the poem together in the perspective of the paradoxical theme that has been underlying throughout. Cullen brings back the ultimate irony to his own personal situation, withdrawing from the broader view of the general human struggle. We see singing as something beautiful, celebratory, and when blacks are given this divine gift in the context of their being regarded by our society as not worthy of it in the first place, is this not like a cruel joke? If a black were to sing and then be made a mockery of, derided and belittled, he would soon realize that to engage in such an otherwise glorious form of human expression would be self defeating. If singing is a gesture to be acted out with gaiety, then here there is certainly nothing for the black man to celebrate.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Nothing

...October 7-11 1. Think: 2. Read: Lots of reading this week—both poems and prose explanation of how to approach and understand them. Ready??? a) Read “Images,” pages 399-411; b) Read “Figures of Speech,” pages 412-427; c) Read “Symbol, Allegory, and Irony,” pages 428-445; d) Read “Sounds,” pages 447-463; e) Read “Patterns of Rhythm,” pages 464-480. Finally and perhaps most important, f) Read and study pages 950-964. 3. Respond: After you have read pages 950-964, you will have learned how to construct and write an explication of a poem. For this week’s response paper, you will be writing an explication of your own of one of the poems you have read in this week’s assignment. Your paper will be at least two full pages and will include a works cited page. You will be writing about the poem’s meanings, not about your personal response to or feelings about it. You should use the sample student outline and paper on pages 954-960 as a guide. Due on Monday, October 14. 4. Discuss: In this week’s forum, you will be asking a question about and discussing one of the week’s poems. Begin by asking a question in which you identify the poem and poet (you may use one of the questions printed at the end of the poem, or you may create one of your own that relates to the topic of the chapter: eg. Images, Figurative Language, etc.). Then you will write a discussion of and response to the question—incorporate at least four quoted phrases or words as...

Words: 304 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How to Get a in En

...A* GCSE English Literature Poetry Response Copyright © 2008 www.englishteaching.co.uk + www.english-teaching.co.uk How to Write an A* GCSE English Literature Poetry Response 2 The Poetry Component of the GCSE Literature Paper The poetry task is the second question on the GCSE English Literature exam paper. It is perhaps the more demanding of the tasks on the paper, because unlike the question on the prose, in this section you are being asked to compare four poems simultaneously throughout your answer. In the exam you should spend one hour on this section of the paper. Given the greater demand of the task, your response to the poetry is worth more marks than the response to the prose. In order to perform at the highest level on this paper, it is important that you develop a nuanced and sophisticated comparative written style. However, this is achievable if you adopt a systematic approach to ordering and writing your responses. It does, however, demand considerable practice prior to the final examination. What is the Examiner looking for in a response to the Poetry? The exam is designed to test your ability to do the following things:    Can you respond to the poems critically, in detail, and sensitively using textual evidence? Can Can you explore language, structure and form contribute to the meaning of texts? Can Can you compare the ways that ideas, themes and relationships are presented in the poems by selecting Can pertinent details...

Words: 5638 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Yolo

...DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH AND FOREIGN LANGUAGES AND LITERATURE College of Arts and Sciences San Beda College COURSESYLLABUS First Semester, AY2014-2015 San Beda College, a Catholic educational institution, is committed to the Christian formation of the Bedan Community as its service to the Church, the Philippine society, and the world. Vision : San Beda College envisions a community that is Fully Human, Wholly Christian, Truly Filipino, and Globally Competitive. Mission : San Beda College aims to form its members in Faith, Knowledge, and Virtue Core Values : Inculcate in the students the Benedictine core values of Study, Community, and Pursuit of Peace ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________ Course Title Course Code Pre- requisite Credits : : : : World Literature Lit 02 Lit 01 3 Units Vision-Mission Statement : Instructor : Email : Office : Consultation Hours: MWF Venue : Consultation Rm. I. Course Description: Socorro D. De Jesus, Ph.D. Associate Professor 1 socorro_dejesus@hotmail.com General Education Faculty Rm, 2 nd floor, St. Anselm's Building 1 The course will introduce students to the writings of persons from selected countries across the different continents of the world. Students will gain an understanding of literary concepts to be able to interpret, analyze and evaluate various genres. Furthermore, students will have the opportunity...

Words: 1595 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

A Girl in the Box

...The poems in Wind in a Box cover a wide variety of topics The poems in this book cover a vast array of topics and emotions, but they all have one thing in common, they all are colored by Terrance Haye’s experiences and his perception of the world. In the two poems, “Girl in the Woods” and “Wind in the Box”, Terrance Hayes tells the story of two victims of traumatic experiences and their response to that experience. In the first poem, “Girl in the Woods”, the story teller describes the story of a girl who catches a ride home with some of her friends and ends up getting raped. After being raped, the girl is brought home and does nothing to her attackers. In the second poem, “Wind in the Box”, the speaker of the poem contemplates how he feels after killing someone that wronged him. Both poems make references to traumatic experiences. These two poems are different because of the way that the subject of the poem reacts; in the first poem the subject takes no action against her attackers while in the second poem the subject kills his enemy. Both poems have a clear meaning: while traumatic experiences happen in life, different people respond very differently. Hayes is a poet that has the great talent of conveying the emotions from a traumatic experience very effectively. He paints the picture of the experience using many different tools in his poetry. These tools include Hayes’ theme that different people respond to situations differently is echoed not only in these two poems, but...

Words: 473 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Literatures I English Cape Syllabus

...re tu ra li CAPE Modern te ng Languages Literatures nE e siniEnglish ur e at l er g it En sin ur e at er it L Caribbean Examinations Council ® SYLLABUS SPECIMEN PAPER CSEC® SYLLABUS,MARK SCHEME SPECIMEN PAPER, MARK SCHEME SUBJECT REPORTS AND SUBJECT REPORTS Macmillan Education 4 Crinan Street, London, N1 9XW A division of Macmillan Publishers Limited Companies and representatives throughout the world www.macmillan-caribbean.com ISBN 978-0-230-48228-9 © Caribbean Examinations Council (CXC ®) 2015 www.cxc.org www.cxc-store.com The author has asserted their right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Design and Patents Act 1988. First published 2014 This revised version published 2015 Permission to copy The material in this book is copyright. However, the publisher grants permission for copies to be made without fee. Individuals may make copies for their own use or for use by classes of which they are in charge; institutions may make copies for use within and by the staff and students of that institution. For copying in any other circumstances, prior permission in writing must be obtained from Macmillan Publishers Limited. Under no circumstances may the material in this book be used, in part or in its entirety, for commercial gain. It must not be sold in any format. Designed by Macmillan Publishers Limited Cover design by Macmillan Publishers Limited and Red Giraffe CAPE® Literatures...

Words: 121889 - Pages: 488

Premium Essay

Third Person Omniscient Point of View Is Constant Throughout the Story. an Example of This Would Be “the Old Woman Stood at the Top of the Steps Looking About in Bewilderment. She Had Begun Singing in Her Head. They Had

...Instructor Kristina Munz Reading Reflection In any stories, poems, plays, and any other written piece of art contain a mixture of literary themes accompanied with literary works. In fiction, the theme is not intended to teach or preach. In fact, it is not presented directly at all. The reader extracts it from the characters, action, and setting that make up the story. In other words, the person reading the paper must figure out the theme himself/herself. The theme of a fable is its moral; the one of a parable is its teaching, and the theme of a piece of fiction is its view about life and how people behave. Within any piece of literature, plot, point of view, and tone are found incorporated into the literary art. They are used in developing the short story and presents annotations accompanying a short story to illustrate how each element contributes to a story's effectiveness. Chapter 1 page 1 states, “Reading a story, a poem, or a play introduces you to an imaginary world. You are pulled away from a living, breathing world into one that was created in the mind of the author. Its situations and experiences may resemble ones you are familiar with; many of them may even be based in part on real situations, but they are imaginary–shaped by the imagination of the person who created the story, poem, or play you are reading.” I have chosen to write my paper on John Betjeman’s poem “A Subaltern’s Love Song.” This poem is a humorous look at a romantic relationship from the poet’s point...

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Dog's Death

...my heart. From the first line, I could tell that it was not going to be a good ending. I have lost animals before and I know what that emptiness feels like. I thought that I could not be whole again without my pet. In the poem, the author takes me through several emotions as well as several images and in the end sadness, sympathy for the owner and then empathy for the actions of the dog before she died (Clugston, 2010). The author uses the reader/response technique so that we can see and feel all the emotions of having a loved one die, whether it is a pet or a human being. The author sets the tone in the first line when he says that the dog must have been kicked or hit by a car (Clugston, 2010). The tone is apprehensive in the beginning because the dog is not acting as rambunctious as a puppy normally would, when the author talks about “her shy malaise” (Clugston, 2010). The tone goes from apprehensive to worry when the owner finds the dog under the bed barely alive. Then when the dog dies in his arms, there is grief and sadness. The last emotion in the poem is sympathy for the dog because even when she was dying, she still tried to please her owner by dragging herself over to the paper because she had diarrhea. When reading this poem, the author uses image to show me how the dog was acting when he says, “We thought her shy malaise was a shot reaction” (Clugston, 2010). He also uses image when he says, “we found her twisted and limp but still alive” (Clugston...

Words: 777 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business and Management

...cultures. Policies Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: • University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. • Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies at the beginning of each class. Policies may be slightly different depending on the modality in which you attend class. If you have recently changed modalities, read the policies governing your current class modality. Course Materials Barnet, S., Cain, W.E., & Burto, W. (2011). Literature for composition: Essays, stories, poems, and plays (9th ed.). New York, NY: Longman. All electronic...

Words: 2590 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Reading Refection

...point in their life have to make in his poem, “The Road Not Taken”. In this paper I will explain why this poem caught my interest, using terms and concepts from the text, describing one of the analytical approaches, using details from the text to support my interpretations, and evaluate the meaning of the poem, using the analytical approach I selected. I am not usually drawn to poetry and normally would not choose a poem to analyze or to read for pleasure. In reading this week’s text I was drawn to “The Road Not Taken” because of its imagery which puts the reader right in front of a road which is forked and a decision is needed for further progress on the journey. In this poem so many individuals can relate to having to make decisions and coming to that point in their life where there is “Two roads diverged in a yellow wood” (as cited in Clugston, 2010 Section 2.2). In this line of his poem he is referring to a decision you have to make and a decision everyone has to make in their life. I have come across many times having to decide on a path in which the decision would affect my life. For instance, I was at the bar and had a few too many drinks and the decision I came up on was how I was going to get home. I could have decided to drive myself and end up hurting myself and someone else but I decided to call a cab and get home safe. This decision could have impacted my life a lot more than most realize. Being able to relate to this poem really grasped my attention to this...

Words: 820 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Documebt English Thing

...Registered address: AQA, Devas Street, Manchester M15 6EX. Report on the Examination – General Certificate of Education (A-level) English Literature A – Unit 1: Texts in Context: The Struggle for Identity in Modern Literature – January 2013 PRINCIPAL EXAMINER’S REPORT: January 2013 LTA1C The Struggle for Identity in Modern Literature The entry was around 2000 candidates, compared to nearer 7000 last summer and about 1400 the previous January, with the large majority of students choosing to answer on Duffy’s The World’s Wife as it was the last time this text would be offered. With the majority of entrants being re-sitters, this was only to be expected. A significant number of students answered on the new Duffy text, Feminine Gospels. Numerous responses to Angelou’s And Still I Rise were seen where quality, on the whole, had improved. Sheers' Skirrid Hill appeared less popular than in previous years...

Words: 9361 - Pages: 38

Premium Essay

A Poem by Robert Frost

...about her experiences, regardless of the perceived success of her efforts. This is achieved by excellent use of tone, rhythm, and imagery. The tone of the poem is consistently light and pleasant. From the beginning the girl remembers the experience fondly, as shown in lines -4 “likes to tell how one spring when she was a girl on the farm, she did a childlike thing.” The poem goes on to describe how the young girl asked her father for a garden of her own. The father’s response of “Why not?” and decision to give her a small, walled-off piece of useless land, as well as his comments in lines 1-16 suggests that he was humoring her because he knew it would be quite an undertaking. In lines 7 � 40 “her crop was a miscellany when all was said and done, a little bit of everything, a great deal of none”, the text at first seems to change tones. Yet the speaker ends the poem by reiterating the woman’s pleasure of telling the story of when she was a “farmer”. When taken into context with the rest of the poem, the tone has not changed. Regardless of the outcome, the theme is that the value was in the learning experience and the pleasure the woman has even as an adult. The poem is mild-mannered and seeks to take the reader away from their daily life, as opposed to requiring heavy philosophic or morbid contemplations. The poem is very rhythmic and melodic. It follows a prescribed pattern with every second and fourth lines rhyming. Each...

Words: 884 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

What Connections Have You Found Between the Way Duffy and Pugh Present Relationships in Their Poetry.

...Duffy and Pugh both present their poetry in similar and different ways. In the title of Duffy’s poem ‘whoever she was’ it suggests to be a nostalgic poem of someone without an identity, with the ‘whoever’ suggesting a careless attitude towards the character. Similarly in Pugh’s poem ‘hello’ the title suggests loneliness and the character wanting to create a relationship with someone. Duffy’s ‘whoever she was’ is written predominantly in third person, to create a careless attitude and detach the reader from the character, emphasising the lack of her relationship. However, Duffy uses a confusion of pronouns, ‘she, myself, I’ to exaggerate her confusion over her identity. Pugh’s poem is also written in third person, as we get to hear the onlooker’s views towards the man, emphasising that people don’t really understand that he’s lonely. However Duffy’s poem ‘Mrs Lazarus’ is written in first person, allowing the reader to emphasise and connect more with what is happening throughout the poem, and also Mrs Lazarus’s feelings. Imagery is used in Duffy’s poem to present the uncomfortable memories of the character. ‘Clumsy tongue’ gives the impression that these memories of the past relationship are hurtful to her. The contrasting imagery of ‘six silly ladies torn in half by baby fists’ suggests an abrupt end to the relationship with her children. The innocence of ‘six silly’ massively clashes with ‘torn in half’ to emphasize the idea of the relationship being unfixable, as it was ‘torn’...

Words: 680 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Essay

...[pic] JPPSS ELA COURSE GUIDE 2011-2012 ENGLISH I The JPPSS Instructional Sequence Guides are aligned with the LA Comprehensive Curriculum. JPPSS Implementation of Activities in the Classroom Incorporation of activities into lesson plans is critical to the successful implementation of the Louisiana Comprehensive Curriculum. The Comprehensive Curriculum indicates one way to align instruction with Louisiana standards, benchmarks, and grade-level expectations. The curriculum is aligned with state content standards, as defined by grade-level expectations (GLEs), and organized into coherent, time-bound units with sample activities and classroom assessments to guide teaching and learning. The units in the curriculum have been arranged so that the content to be assessed will be taught before the state testing dates. While teachers may substitute equivalent activities and assessments based on the instructional needs, learning styles, and interests of their students, the Comprehensive Curriculum should be a primary resource when planning instruction. Grade level expectations—not the textbook—should determine the content to be taught. Textbooks and other instructional materials should be used as resource in teaching the grade level expectations...

Words: 21740 - Pages: 87

Free Essay

The Victims, by Sharon Olds

...“The Victims” Response 1) What are the main ideas in the poem? When I read “The Victims,” by Sharon Olds, the main ideas that came to my mind were vengeance, karma, and the effects of divorce on children and parents. The poem starts being written from a child’s perspective, and it ends with a grown up point of view. It seems that not only the child has suffered the father’s abuse, but the mother and siblings too. Throughout the poem, the children in that family are taught to hate their father while the mother takes everything away from him until he is reduce to be a beggar. The poem ends with the same person reflecting on who the real victims were in the story. 2) What about the structure/movements of the poem? The poem has two very well differentiated parts: the first part that is written in past tense, and the second part, which is written in present tense. The poem starts hating the father and being happy when the mother divorced him, and it ends feeling some kind of sympathy towards the father. The author accomplished this shift in the poem thanks to the descriptions and the change of tense, but most importantly, thanks to the comparison of the father to bums. Another thing that I noticed about this poem is that every phrase in each line is not complete; it’s like the author chose to cut the phrase to jump to the next line. I mean, the ideas and phrases in the poem are complete, but Olds cut them to create some kind of “mystery”. This resource or device made...

Words: 1078 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Author, the Text, and the Reader

...A study of reader-response theories, and some views on how the objectivity of the literary text is or is not distinguished from the subjectivity of the reader's response by Clarissa Lee Ai Ling In the academic study of literature very little attention has been paid to the ordinary reader, the subjective individual who reads a particular text. David S. Miall and Don Kuiken, in their paper The form of reading: Empirical studies of literariness state. Almost no professional attention is being paid to the ordinary reader, who continues to read for the pleasure of understanding the world of the text rather than for the development of a deconstructive or historicist perspective. The concerns that an ordinary reader seems likely to have about a literary text, such as its style, its narrative structure, or the reader's relation to the author, the impact on the reader's understanding or feelings - such concerns now seem of little interest. In this paper I should like to study a few kinds of reader and the subjectivity of their responses to the objectivity found within literary texts, quoting some views found within reader-response criticism. Before I begin, I should like to consider what is meant by the term 'literary text', and what is meant by the objectivity of it. According to Terry Eagleton, [1] the definition of 'literary', as advanced by the Russian formalists, (who included in their ranks are Viktor Shklovsky, Roman Jakobson, Osip Brik, Yury Tynyanov, Boris Eichenbaum...

Words: 3773 - Pages: 16