Free Essay

Reorganization of the Intelligence Community

In:

Submitted By dhinkins
Words 1157
Pages 5
Much like other agencies of the United States Government, the Intelligence Community was very big, stretching across several departments and agencies with similar or conflicting responsibilities. And some of the agencies operated entirely independent of others with no intelligence collaboration and sharing. After being dealt a huge blow on September 11, 2001, those in the government felt that is was necessary to reorganize the various agencies tasted with intelligence gathering. According to the 9-11 Commission Report: the sorrow, loss, anger, and resolve so evident immediately following the September 11, 2001, attacks have been combined in an effort to help assure that our country will never again be caught unprepared. As the 9/11 Commission notes, we are safer today but we are not safe, and much work remains. Although in today's world we can never be 100 percent secure, and we can never do everything everywhere, we concur with the Commission's conclusion that the American people should expect their government to do its very best. GAO's mission is to help the Congress improve the performance and ensure the accountability of the federal government for the benefit of the American people. GAO has been actively involved in improving government's performance in the critically important homeland security area both before and after the September 11 attacks. In its request, the House Committee on Government Reform has asked the GAO to address two issues: the lack of effective information sharing and analysis and the need for executive branch reorganization in response to the 9/11 Commission recommendations. Further, the Committee has asked GAO to address how to remedy problems in information sharing and analysis by transforming the intelligence community from a system of "need to know" to one of a "need to share (GAO, 2004)." These findings led to the creation of the NCTC. The National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC) was established by Presidential Executive Order 13354 in August 2004, and codified by the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004 (IRTPA). NCTC implements a key recommendation of the 9/11 Commission: “Breaking the older mold of national government organizations, this NCTC should be a center for joint operational planning and joint intelligence, staffed by personnel from the various agencies” (Rights Watch, 2004). The NCTC filters information from various sources about potential terrorist attacks and puts it in the hands of analysts so that they can plan the appropriate response. Investigations of the 9/11 attacks had demonstrated that information possessed by different agencies had not been shared and thus that disparate indications of the looming threat had not been connected and warning had not been provided. As a component of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, the NCTC is composed of analysts with backgrounds in many government agencies and has access to various agency databases. It prepares studies ranging from strategic assessment of the future terrorist threats to daily briefings and situation reports (Best, 2010). The NCTC is in charge of planning the US counterterrorism posture though authority granted by the President. It is the duty of the NCTC to put together all terrorism related information and pass along to the appropriate channels. The NCTC’s focus shifted to prevent domestic terrorism after the Fort Hood attacks on November 5, 2009 in which a US soldier murdered 13 junior soldiers. The shootings at Fort Hood in Texas and the attempted downing of a Detroit-bound airliner on Christmas Day 2009 gave new impetus to efforts to aggregate and analyze terrorism-related data more effectively. In the case of Fort Hood, Maj. Nidal Hasan had had contact with radical Yemeni cleric Anwar al-Awlaki, but that information had not been shared across the government. The name of Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, who tried to detonate a bomb on a transatlantic flight, had been placed in a master list housed at the NCTC but not on a terrorist watch list that would have prevented him from boarding the plane (Horwitz & Nakashima, 2012). The NCTC was blamed for failing to recognize the signs that Major Nidal Hasan was becoming radicalized and was planning an attack. Senate investigators released an 89-page report about the missed opportunity to prevent the rampage at Fort Hood that killed 13 and wounded 32 others. The FBI conducted only a cursory investigation into evidence that the radicalized American-born Muslim made wire transfers to Pakistani militants and was frequently in communication with an al-Qaida affiliated terrorist overseas, the year-long investigation concluded. NCTC, as it originated in the US after 9/11, is only a "shared knowledge bank on terrorism" and clearing house for integrating and analyzing all such intelligence. This is because the experience of 9/11 revealed that all 16 US intelligence agencies operated on parallel tracks without adequately sharing information with each other. Some like FBI acted without horizontal or vertical dialogue on what they noticed. It is not that such counter-terrorist centers had not existed earlier. The CIA had its Counter-Terrorist Center since 1986, which created a "Bin Laden" cell in 1996. The FBI too had a "Counter Terrorism Division" from 1999. Yet, the integration of intelligence was faulty. The 9/11 Commission observed that the machinery could not connect the dots. Clues on 9/11 attack "slipped through the cracks". It is to connect these "dots" that the NCTC was created by law in 2004. To quote the 9/11 Committee recommendations: "The NCTC should perform joint planning. The plans would assign operational responsibilities to lead agencies, such as State, the CIA, the FBI, Defense and its combatant commands, Homeland Security, and other agencies. The NCTC should not direct the actual execution of these operations, leaving that job to the agencies. The NCTC would then track implementation; it would look across the foreign-domestic divide and across agency boundaries, updating plans to follow through on cases." Also: "A 'smart' government would integrate all sources of information to see the enemy as a whole. Integrated all-source analysis should also inform and shape strategies to collect more intelligence (Balachandran)."

WORKS CITED
Best, R. (2010, January 15). The national counterterrorism center (nctc)—responsibilities and potential congressional concerns. Retrieved from http://publicintelligence.net/the-national-counterterrorism-center-nctc—responsibilities-and-potential-congressional-concerns/
Balachandran, V. (n.d.). Pc’s nctc is not an anti-terror magic wand. Retrieved from http://www.sunday-guardian.com/analysis/pcs-nctc-is-not-an-anti-terror-magic-wand
Horwitz, S., & Nakashima, E. (2012, March 23). Feds likely to let counterterrorism center keep intelligence on u.s. citizens for years. Retrieved from http://www.dailynews.com/ci_20235514/feds-likely-let-counterterrorism-center-keep-intelligence-u
RIGHTS WATCH. (2004, January). National counterterrorism center. Retrieved from http://www.nctc.gov/about_us/about_nctc.html
U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2004, August 3). Reorganization, Transformation, and Information Sharing. (Publication No. GAO-04-1033T). Retrieved from GAO Reports Main Page via GPO Access database: http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-04-1033T

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Contemporary Ethics

...and US Intelligence The United States Intelligence Community has had to change the way they run in order to prevent a future terrorist attacks like the one on the fateful day of September 11th 2001, when our nations security was severely attacked. To be able to understand more clearly the challenges of our intelligence agencies having stronger capabilities, it is important to note that many of today’s issues are well grounded in the past and we can find many examples of this in history books today. One great example is when the United States transitioned from just focusing solely on our nation to a more global view as a result of the attack on Pearl Harbor. Also, Sputnik was a huge reason for the United States to totally redefine their approach to space. These events and many more often serve as examples that changes should have and still must be be made within our intelligence communities and they helped prompt the largest reorganization of the intelligence community since 1947. Had these changes been made sooner, prevention of these and many more tragedies may have been a success. Beginning from the time when Pearl Harbor was stroked, the government sought to blame the Japanese Americans for the tragedy. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt made no hesitation to sign the executive order authorizing an internment of all “Japanese Americans” to proceed. This of course was during a time when racial prejudice was open, but their was a deeper issue within our intelligence community...

Words: 949 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Homeland Security Committee

...effort to restore funding to the Secure the Cities Program to protect the New York-Long Island region from nuclear dirty bomb attacks. What Sub Committees Border and Maritime Security- Chaired by Candice Miller Counter terrorism and Intelligence- Chaired by Patrick Meehan Cyber security, Infrastructure Protection, and Security Technologies- Chaired by Daniel Lungren Emergency Preparedness, Response, and Communications- Chaired by Gus Bilirakis Oversight, Investigations, and Management- Chaired by Michael McCaul Transportation Security- Chaired by Mike Rogers There Jurisdiction The Committee on Homeland Security was established in 2002 to provide Congressional oversight for the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and better protect the American people against a possible terrorist attack. The Committee is chartered to hold hearings and craft legislation for issues specific to homeland security. The Committee on Homeland Security has six Subcommittees each specializing in a subset of the Full Committee’s jurisdiction: The Subcommittee on Counterterrorism and Intelligence jurisdiction includes intelligence and information sharing efforts within the Department of Homeland Security. This includes the Office of Intelligence and Analysis and...

Words: 764 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

George Tenet and the Last Days of the Cia

...served as Director of the Central Intelligence Agency from 1997 to 2004, under the administration of Bill Clinton and George W Bush. An intense period covering the terrorist attacks on September 11 and the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan and Iraq. (Stillman, 2010) This outline describes the ethical obligations of Tenets’ career. The Concept of Ethical Obligations is concerned with the process by which we clarify what is right and wrong and by which we act on what we take to be right; ethics involves the use of reasons in determining a proper course of action. Ethics is also the search for moral standards (Denhardt/Denhardt, 2010) or rules that determine the way a person behave. (?) In this case study, George Tenet and the Last Great Days of the CIA. The CIA Director, George Tenet was challenged with major cross-coded ethical dilemmas in his agency, which impact his leadership abilities. First, ethical dilemma that impact his leadership skills was during the Wye Oak negotiations, Tenet was serving as the go-between for Yasser Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu (White, 2008) Members within the government did not think it was right for Tenet to play a significant role as it cause doubts in his cabinet and administration. Tenet was not honest to the people within the government about the role he played during the invasion of Iraq, his response to the al-Qaeda threat or the reorganization of the intelligence community. (Stillman, 2010). This impacted...

Words: 542 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Theories of Learning

...Most influential theories of learning Learning is defined as a process that brings together personal and environmental experiences and influences for acquiring, enriching or modifying one’s knowledge, skills, values, attitudes, behaviour and world views. Learning theories develop hypotheses that describe how this process takes place. The scientific study of learning started in earnest at the dawn of the 20th century. The major concepts and theories of learning include behaviourist theories, cognitive psychology, constructivism, social constructivism, experiential learning, multiple intelligence, and situated learning theory and community of practice. Behaviourism The behaviourist perspectives of learning originated in the early 1900s, and became dominant in early 20th century. The basic idea of behaviourism is that learning consists of a change in behaviour due to the acquisition, reinforcement and application of associations between stimuli from the environment and observable responses of the individual. Behaviourists are interested in measurable changes in behaviour. Thorndike, one major behaviourist theorist, put forward that (1) a response to a stimulus is reinforced when followed by a positive rewarding effect, and (2) a response to a stimulus becomes stronger by exercise and repetition. This view of learning is akin to the “drill-and-practice” programmes. Skinner, another influential behaviourist, proposed his variant of behaviourism called “operant conditioning”. In...

Words: 1556 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice Lessons Learned Post 9/11

...9/11 attacks many problems were revealed within the criminal justice system, especially those affecting the law enforcement community. One of those problems was the lack of interaction between the police departments and other local/state law enforcement with the federal law enforcement agencies. Local law enforcement agencies are the primary responders to any incident of crime or terror, therefore developing a better interagency collaboration in order to share information is essential in order to prevent future attacks. Prior to the 9/11 attacks many of the agencies believed in keeping information within their own realm due to protocols and security clearances. These criminal justice agencies each had pieces to a puzzle, but because these agencies never worked together, those pieces would never be put together to reveal the bigger picture. The 9/11 events revealed the lack of interaction and set about a positive change that would impact the way the criminal justice system approached their problem solving. One of those changes was the reorganization of the federal law enforcement agencies, including the creation of the Department of Homeland Security and the Transportation Security Administration (Brown, 2007). Another positive change was the reorganization of federal, state, and local governments for the purpose of increased information intelligence and sharing. Despite the positives changes that occurred to improve interagency collaboration, there were several challenges...

Words: 3147 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Policing

...brief History  Law enforcement is vital in the stability and progress of all nations. Thus, the conception of a unified national police was borne out of this premise. Giving rise to the unification of the Philippine Constabulary and the Integrated National Police whose functions is symmetrical to ensure the safety and security of the people. Republic Act 6975 was signed into law on December 13, 1990 by then President Corazon Aquino which called for the creation of the Philippine National Police (PNP) and the reorganization of the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) in keeping with the mandate of our constitution for a police force that is national in scope and civilian in character. In response to the call for public safety and reforms within the organization, Honorables Teodulo Natividad, Blas Ople, Regalado Maambong and Rustico delos Reyes authored the provisions in the 1987 constitution calling for the creation of a police organization that is national scope and civilian character thus paving way to the establishment of the Philippine National Police (PNP). The principal authors of the Republic Act 6975 entitled “An Act Establishing the Philippine National Police under a reorganized Department of the Interior and Local Government and Other Purposes” were Senators Ernesto Maceda and Aquilino Pimentel Sr, Congressmen Jose Cojuangco Jr and Rodrigo Gutang. They moved for the PNP's creation to professionalize the police force and make it susceptible...

Words: 1623 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Homeland Security Strategy

...other criminals from gaining access to the United States via the SWB. Now, to discuss the objectives created to reach the overall strategic goal reducing the flow of illegal drugs, weapons, and the associated violence that is connected to them. Section One: Strategic Context (continued) Strategic Objectives – these objectives are quite elaborate in nature, and require continued effort from various law enforcement agencies, on down to every citizen, who has a stake in protecting the homeland by taking an active stance within their local community. To successfully reach its goal, DHS, CBP, ICE and others must remain diligent. First, by enhancing intelligence and information sharing capabilities, and processes along the SWB for example: • Enhancing the coordination (between multiple agencies directly involved) with working drug issues along the SWB. • Expand the scope, quality, and timeliness of actionable information and intelligence that is shared with state, local and tribal partners. • Improve the coordination of information that is shared with Mexican partners. As previously stated, by working diligently to stop the flow of illegal drugs, monies associated with drugs, and other associated instruments of violence at entry points along the SWB, with the use of: • Employing enhanced technology, resources, and effective training to support interdiction. • Work with interagency partners, for example, Customs Border Patrol, Immigration Customs Enforcement (ICE), Mexican authorities...

Words: 1680 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

History of Police

...History of Police A system of rules is required to maintain a sense of normalcy that can be free from harm in communities. Policing today has proven to be effective after years of improvements and changes. Policing ensures everyone is looking out for each other. This paper will discuss; the history of policing, the relationship of government and policing organizations, and how that relationship may affect police practices. Sir Robert Peel was the home secretary in London. According to (Grant & Terry, 2012), Sir Robert Peel created the London Metropolitan Police an efficient system of law enforcement. Sir Robert Peel laid the foundation to the history of policing. In 1829, he created principles in policing that through time made the first modern police force effective and time- standing. His advancement in policing included chains of command, uniforms, and, rules of conduct (Grant & Terry, 2012). Sir Robert Peel has made an everlasting impact on policing and his format to policing is still in practicing existence. The government plays a major role in assisting policing organizations throughout the United States of America. There are various sectors in the government that aim to assist in keeping in accordance with the law. According to (Grant & Terry, 2012) U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) enforce U.S. laws while it investigates and gathers intelligence on national and international criminal activities that threaten the security of the homeland. ICE also investigates...

Words: 717 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case Study of George Tenet

...Ladreka Daniel PAD 500 November 16, 2011 Case Study of George Tenet George Tenet was the director of the central Intelligence Agency from 1997 to 2004; it was a very trying time for the Clinton and Bush administration. Tenet would cover many things in his career and that would have a major impact on the terrorist attacks of September 11 and U.S. invasion of Iraq. There were many intelligence directors that sever before him, but none that were more establish or had a drive for controversy. During George Tenet career, he played a big role in many events, such as invasion of Iraq and reorganization of the nation’s intelligence. Tenet involvement with the White House decision making, intelligence priorities, and his own agency kept him occupied (DANIELSON). George Tenet dealt with many cross coded ethical dilemmas, which were in violation of national and international human rights. He was also faced with ethical dilemmas and his dishonest to the People within the government. Tent was a laissez for Israel Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Yasser Arafat was an ethical concern to the United States. His involvement with those ethical dilemmas left a bitter impression on his effectiveness in more ways than one. When the CIA administrator chooses to act as laissez faire among Israeli prime minister and Yasser Arafat, some of his affiliates inside of his administration did not see it in a positive way. Tent always acts as though he was the best man for his position. This...

Words: 1160 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Nature vs Nuture

...What are your thoughts on the Nature vs. Nurture argument? One of the biggest debates that continue to remain unsolved is the Nature vs. Nurture argument. My opinion is that the answer is not definitely one or the other but a mixture of the two. This argument tries to establish the role of genes and the environment in human nature. In some situations it is obvious that genetics have a greater role in shaping a person. An example of that is a person that desires to drink alcohol. Some people would say that the feeling is pre-determined by their genetics, while some people would believe that outside sources such as manufacturers and peers have a greater influence. This debate turns out to be one that is hard to explain because there are many factors involved. Some people express concerns that could be applied scientifically, some have true legitimacy that may not be answerable, and some just do not make sense. To make things more complex with this debate, it seems that things are blended together and there is no distinctiveness to separate the roles. Another issue is that some of the uncertainty comes from the genetic language itself. It seems like we try to sort out the contributions from nature and nurture when in fact the distinction is between what is in born and what we receive after birth. It will always go back to genes and the environment which keeps the debate on going. It is obvious the truth lies within nature and nurture, but it has been difficult to determine...

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The End of the Iraq War: Unrest in the Middle East

...The End of the Iraq War: Unrest in the Middle East Media- The news media, are often unpopular with the brass, for they function independently, without rules, regulations, or even a Code of Conduct except for some that are self-imposed. The media’s Newspapers, Radio, TV and Cable have a variety of interests of their own and set goals to be achieved. They have their fulsome share of rogues, incompetents and avaricious vultures. Yet at their best, the media provide the nation with a vital service it can get nowhere else. It is one of the pillars of the state. US military action against Islamic State jihadists in Iraq and Syria began on a small scale three months ago but has steadily expanded in size and scope, raising the stakes for Washington, experts say. The mission has morphed from protecting religious minorities in Iraq to a vow to "destroy" the IS group in both Syria and Iraq, a dramatic shift for an American president who as a candidate was an outspoken opponent of the previous US war in Iraq. Transnational actors-Globalization provides international actors with additional tools for enhancing their interests and power. More actors which assume the shape of threats are actively and directly involved in everyday international  affairs. That is why extremist and terrorist ideological groups for example achieved the ability to manipulate an audience by cultivating fear on the global scale. Rebel or resistance movements, warlords, criminal organizations, local militias, ethnic...

Words: 1906 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Management Term Paper

...* * Help Desk Operations for the Operating Forces Wilfredo Santiago Park University Author Note This is an insider view on how to streamline and improve the services provided by MCTSSA (Marine Corps Tactical Systems Support Activity) Help Desk to the Operating Forces. Abstract MCTSSA Help Desk was established over 10 years ago to provide technical support to the operating forces. Today the Help Desk is referred to as OFTSSC (Operating Forces Tactical Systems Support Center) with a specific mission stated as: to provide continuous, distributed technical support, troubleshooting, and problem resolution for Command, Control, Communications, Computers and Intelligence (C4I) systems, in order to optimize those systems as force multipliers in assisting Marines to win battles. While the OFTSSC focuses on the needs of the Marine Corps, it offers technical assistance to all C4I system users across the entire Department of Defense (DoD), U.S. Government and all U.S. Foreign National Allies. The OFTSSC provides its customers with remote technical assistance by facilitating online access to supported system documentation, system software and offering live interaction with system subject matter experts (SMEs), via phone, online chat, and email. If a solution to a customer problem is not immediately available, OFTSSC personnel will actively work to obtain a solution by elevating customer issues to MCTSSA support engineers, system vendors, Marine Corps Systems Command program...

Words: 1516 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency

...Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), U.S. government agency administered by the Department of Defense. It was established in 1958, in reaction to the successful launch of Sputnik by the USSR, as the Advanced Research Projects Agency. Although DARPA is only one of many military agencies administering research and development funds, it has been crucial to the development of several important technologies, especially military computers and the Internet. It funds a high percentage of all artificial intelligence research in the United States, as well as significant projects in microelectronics, materials, and behavioral science.[1] DARPA's mission is to maintain the technological superiority of the U.S. military and prevent technological surprise from threatening our national security. DARPA programs focus on high-risk research with that will have payoffs that could provide dramatic advances in military capabilities. Each DARPA office manages a large portfolio of programs.[3] DARPA’s original mission, inspired by the Soviet Union beating the United States into space with Sputnik,[2] was to prevent technological surprise. This mission has evolved over time. Today, DARPA’s mission is to prevent technological surprise for us and to create technological surprise for our adversaries. [2] By focusing on high-risk research that could provide dramatic advances in military capabilities, DARPA maintain its mission which is to prevent any new technological attack from any...

Words: 1534 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mordenization Management

...The Origins of Modern Management Consulting In 1993, AT&T spentmore on management consulting services than on corporate research development, AT&T is notalone[8, p. 60]. Wall Street and and analystsexpectbillingsfor consulting services advanceat twice the rate of to corporate revenues over the next decade. Yet, despitethe size, growth,and influence consulting of firms,business historians haveremained uncharacteristically silent aboutthe origins,development, impactof management and consulting, or "management engineering" was asit known before Second the World War. In this 2 paper, will describe professional I the origins management of consulting firmsat the turnof thecentury anddiscuss why, after slow,gradualgrowththroughthe 1920s, thesefirms took off duringthe 1930s. I argue(1) that historians have wrongly assumed that management consulting arosedirectly out of Taylorism,(2) that engineers,accountants, and lawyers, often supervised merchantbankers, by provided counselthat later became the primary repertoire of management consultants, (3) thatthelegalseparation investment commercial and of and banking in 1933drovetherapidprofessionalization growth management and of consulting duringthe GreatDepression. Recent historiansof scientificmanagement, includingDaniel Nelson, StephenWaring, and JudithMerkle, have tracedthe impact of Taylorismon contemporary institutions diverse business as as education, public administration, andBritish industry longaftertheProgressive-era for...

Words: 3244 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Change Diagnosis

...Nashville, Milwaukee, and Chicago with Milwaukee being the largest of the three. The offices are designated as the support center (Milwaukee), the corporate office (Nashville) and Chicago is just a satellite office that houses the Co-President and other executives. Of all the departments in the company, the IT department is the largest of the corporate departments and is housed in the Milwaukee office, the support center. There are currently over 120 associates in the department and there are always openings for more. Prior to the change, there were five areas within the IT department. Those areas were network operations or infrastructure, telecom, security, project management, and end user services. All areas reported to the Chief Intelligence Officer (CIO) Scott Ranson, with very little room for growth or advancement. Change Drivers There was a need...

Words: 5955 - Pages: 24