Premium Essay

The Arguments Of Gifford Pinchot And John Muir

Submitted By
Words 289
Pages 2
In the documents written by Gifford Pinchot and John Muir, they were both about the building process of Hetch Hetchy Dam. The Hetch Hetchy Dam was built in the early 1900s in California. In both of the documents they both had different reasoning and logic behind each of their ideas. After reading both of the documents, I would say Gifford Pinchot put up a better argument. While reading the both the documents there was one major difference that stood out to me. The difference was between Pinchot and Muir’s argument. Pinchot argued that the wilderness manages they conservation of natural sources the best (History Matters). Muir disagreed, he argued complete different. When Pinchot argued, he gave more reasons and had evidence to back up all

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Opposing Muir's Argument Analysis

...strong arguments from Muir and his supporters against constructing the O'Shaughnessy Dam in the Hetch Hetchy Valley it is still more favorable to construct the dam. Conservationists such as Pinchot are correct in recognizing that the best use for the valley would be to supply water for the good of the population. In some situations the alteration of land for human use perhaps would not be the correct decision, but in this particular situation the city of San Francisco desperately needed a water and energy supply. Muir and his supporters believe that the damming of the valley would restrict the public use of the valley. Yet, relying on the theory that all resources should be put to use to serve the most number of people is the best ideology in this...

Words: 733 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Progressivisim

...Chapter 28 Outlines Progressive Roots • There was unrest throughout the land because industrialists concentrated more and more power in fewer and fewer hands. • Progressive theorists insisted that society could no longer use the “let-alone” or laissez faire policy. • Before 1900, politicians and writers begun to pinpoint targets for the progressive attack. Bryan, Altgeld, and the Populists flamed about the “bloated trusts” with corruption and wrongdoing. • Henry Demarest Lloyd wrote Wealth Against Commonwealth in 1894, it was about the Standard Oil Company and on its “predatory wealth” and “conspicuous consumption” • Veblen viewed parasitic leisure class engaged in wasteful “business” which was making money for money’s sake rather than the productive “industry” which was making goods to satisfy real needs. • Jacob A. Riis was Danish and immigrated to the U.S. He was a reporter for the New York Sun, and he wrote How the Other Half Lives. It shocked the middle class Americans in 1890; he talked about diseases, and how dirty and how bad off the New York slums were. It influenced New York City police commissioner, Theodore Roosevelt. • Theodore Dreiser wrote the The Financier and The Titan. He battered promoters and profiteers. • A lot of the socialists were European immigrants where there were already socialist movements in the old world. Messengers of the social gospel promoted a brand of progressivism based on Christian teachings. They used religious doctrines...

Words: 3667 - Pages: 15