Premium Essay

The Role Of Lying In The Crucible

Submitted By
Words 629
Pages 3
Fabrication is looked at the same way lying is, wrong. Coming up with fiction when the truth needs to be told. John Proctor in The Crucible, is a farmer in a Puritan society. Proctor has a wife, Elizabeth, and three boys, but only two are baptized. In Arthur Miller’s, The Crucible, John Proctor was a dishonest man by lying, being dishonest towards Reverend Hale, and betraying his family by being actively involved in adultery. John Proctor is a dishonorable man because he lies.This is an issue because his wife is becoming weary of him. In Act I, John Proctor was alone in a room with Abigail Williams. When Abigail asked how Proctor calls her a child, Proctor replies with, “...I may think of you softly from time to time” (Miller 146). This quote relates directly to Proctor; he states, to Elizabeth, that he does not think …show more content…
Proctor had a clue about what was actually happening to the girls, but has not told Reverend Hale about it. In Act II Proctor and Elizabeth are talking in their home. Elizabeth asks John if Abigail had said that it did not have anything to do with witchcraft. To which Proctor replies, “Aye, she did, she did” (162). Yet Proctor does not tell Reverend Hale then. John Proctor could have told Reverend Hale about Abigail when he was in his home asking Elizabeth about witchcraft. By not telling Reverend Hale about this, John Proctor was not telling the whole truth, therefore being dishonest. Reverend Hale asked Proctor why he had kept this from him.In the same act, Proctor responds with, “I never knew until tonight that the world is gone daft with this nonsense” (169). Before this, Proctor did not tell anyone other than Elizabeth about his conversation with Abigail. Now that the truth is out, proctor needs to be fully honest. Proctor should have told Reverend Hale all of his suspicions from the beginning. John Proctor could have told Reverend Hale about Abigail and told the whole truth in the first

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Role Of Lying In The Crucible

...protect yourself, even if it meant lying, right? The play The Crucible by Arthur Miller takes place back in the day where the people in Salem, Massachusetts are put to this exact test.When Betty, Reverend Parris’ daughter, along with her cousin Abigail and other girls are caught dancing in the forest people immediately assumed the girls conjured the Devil. Reverend Hale comes into town hoping to help dispose of evil spirits, his process probably wasn’t the best it brought on lies. Tituba, the slave, confessed to working with the devil to protect herself after being whipped she decided to take people down with her. Abigail, selfishly rattled off the names of people she had “seen with the devil” In suit of Tituba. 150 people went to trial for witchcraft and the girls played into whatever Abigail did. Not only were many innocent people executed, but unless they confessed to witchcraft they were convicted. Abigail Williams and Tituba are responsible for the mass hysteria in Salem, Massachusetts....

Words: 378 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why Is Abigail Important In The Crucible

...salem, many people are known for being good people, and with good character. Some of these characters are odd good,and some are dark. There are many important things that happen in the crucible, and there are many important characters in the crucible that i will be talking about in the. All these characters are important in the crucible because they all have to deal with a big part in the crucible. The three characters that i will be talking about from the book are john proctor, abigail williams, and giles corey. All these characters have an important role in the crucible and i feel like you should know about these characters. My first character that i will be talking about is abigail because she is one of the most important characters in this book. Abigail is really concerned with her reputation because she knows that she is lying about the whole thing but abagaile just doesn't want to get in trouble. This starts to change the way abagail acts because she doesn't want to get in trouble she acts like this with all the other girls because she doesn't want any of the other girls telling people about what they did in the woods with tituba. Abigail's situation is different now because she had nothing to hide but now that she got caught dancing in the woods with tituba and all the girls she is lying saying that all they did was...

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Abcd

...The Crucible Act Three Questions Short Response Answer the following questions based on your knowledge of the drama. Write a response on a separate sheet of paper. 1. Describe one piece of evidence that Giles, Francis, or Proctor bring before the court to show that the girls are lying. 2. What does Abigail do to distract Danforth from Hale’s accusations that she is lying? 3. How does Hale show that he believes that the court is not doing the right thing? Use three details from the text in your response. 4. Danforth explains that “. . . a person is either with this court or he must be counted against it, there be no road between.” What conclusion can you draw about Danforth’s character from this line? 5. How does Hale excuse Elizabeth’s lie about Abigail’s affair with Proctor? 6. Danforth explains that witchcraft is an invisible crime and that only the victims are reliable. How does his philosophy flame the hysteria? Use details from the drama to support your response. 7. How do Hale and Parris try to thwart each other, or act as foils, in regards to Danforth and the court? Use details from the drama to support your response. 8. Describe the point at which you think the plot reaches its highest intensity, or climax. 9. After the outbreak in court, Mr. Danforth makes the following short statement to Mr. Hale: I will have nothing from you, Mr. Hale! In your own words, describe what Mr. Hale has said or done to instigate Mr. Danforth’s...

Words: 3241 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Compare And Contrast Elizabeth Proctor And Abigail Williams

...The Crucible: Compare and Contrasting Elizabeth Proctor and Abigail Williams The Crucible, by Arthur Miller, was about this town in Salem Massachusetts that was driven by greed and lust. out of this small town, two characters played a major role in this horrible event that occurred. These two are Abagail Williams and Elizabeth Proctor. They have multiple differences while having one big thing in common. Abagail was a lying, evil, and mischievous as well as manipulative character. She was caught in the woods dancing with other girls and was being accused by her uncle of doing witch craft and decided to shift the blame to others. When the girl started to discuss among themselves if they should tell the truth Abagail says (Source: EsaayForum.com)...

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Crucible Paper

...Katie Lewis Mrs. Miller English 11, Period 1 26 November 2014 The Good, the Bad, and the Witches Buddha once said, “There has to be evil so that good can prove its purity above it.” His words describe how there is both evil and good in the world. There is also both good and evil in Arthur Miller's play, The Crucible. In 1692, the witch trials played a huge role in the lives of people in Salem, Massachusetts. The townspeople feared witchcraft so much that it created confusion regarding who was actually a witch and who was not. Many accusations were made leaving innocent people responsible for the mysterious acts of witchcraft. Abigail Williams reveals her impurity by doing just this. Abigail constantly lies to the court and does everything in her power to save herself, even if it means falsely accusing others. In Miller's play The Crucible, Abigail Williams proves her impurity of soul by having an affair with John Proctor, lying to the townspeople, and attempting to kill Elizabeth Proctor. Abigail first reveals her impure heart through her love affair with John Proctor. Although Abigail is aware that John is married to Elizabeth Proctor, she does not let their relationship get in the way of her own selfish desires. Johns fends off Abigail when he says “Abigail, I may think of you softly from time to time. But I will cut off my hand before I’ll ever reach for you again. We never touched Abby” (15). Abigail argues, “Aye, but we did” (15). Here Abigail shows no guilt...

Words: 953 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

False Accusation In The Crucible

...The play The Crucible By Arthur Miller is an example of false accusation by everyone being accused of something during their time of life. Arthur Miller connects himself with John Proctor through accusation and how all fingers are pointed to people from one In the little town Salem Massachusetts, 1692, the theme Witchcraft was brought upon a lot of people, from accusation. Everyone being framed of Witchcraft had either the choice to admit to it, or to be hanged, because Witchcraft was not allowed in Salem at the time. Witchcraft had turned many people against other and showed the true colors of them. Through John Proctor’s response to Witchcraft of Abigail, Arthur Miller conveys his beliefs about false accusation of his wife. Arthur Miller’s...

Words: 959 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Judge Danforth In The Crucible

...” The Crucible, a play written by Arthur Miller in the early 1950’s, has an exemplary character that shows a defective result. Mr. Lincoln’s quote shows that power defines the strength or weakness of a character. As The Crucible transitioned into its third act, Judge Danforth, a round character, begins as a self-justified and aware judge. As the play progresses, This truth becomes an act to cover his multiplying flaws. In The Crucible, Judge Danforth had his power and authority protecting him, but let his foolishness bewitch him. This cocky and oblivious man ruled Salem’s courthouse. Originally the deputy governor of Massachusetts, Judge Danforth presumptuously took collateral control(Wikipedia). He started his tyranny with unjustly condemning 72, eventually 12 during the Salem witch trials(Miller, 1190,1222). Such unrequited power was abused by leading...

Words: 496 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Crr- the Devil and Tom Walker

...Nwobi 1 Odera Nwobi AP Language & composition September 21, 2014 CRR #1- The Crucible I. Author/Introduction Arthur Miller; an American playwright, born in the early 1900’s, 1915 to be precise. He was born into a very wealthy family. He was not very wealthy for a very long time, after the stock market crash in 1929. He had to do odd job to be able to pay for his college. After college, he career was a little rocky after his first play The Man Who Had All the Luck closed after four performances. After a while, his show All my Son earned him his first award. He wrote over 50 different works ranging from plays, novels, articles. His best play was Death of a Salesman which earned him a lot of fame. Another popular play he wrote was The Crucible. This play was a reflection of the Salem witch trial back in 1692. He was considered a communist because he advocated principles of equality among the classes, and social justice. He was married three times. He was once married to the popular actress Marilyn Monroe. Arthur Miller died in 2005 at the age of 89. II. Vocabulary Gibberish- meaningless or unintelligent talk. Trepidation- trembling or quivering movement. Subservient- serving or acting in a subordinate capacity. Shudder- to tremble with a sudden convulsive movement as from horror, fear, or cold. Calumny- a false and malicious statement designed to injure the reputation of someone or something. Titillated- to excite or arouse agreeably. Sniveling- to weep...

Words: 1792 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Un-American Play Themes

...In 1950, Arthur Miller was blacklisted. During the time he had been writing The Crucible, Miller was fearful that he would be labeled as a communist if he was protesting too strongly by publishing this play. He was overwhelmed with all of the paranoia of communism. Miller was called to testify for HUAC and was uncooperative and refused to name anyone that was affiliated with him. This time in his life was increasingly difficult for him, but nonetheless, he continued the production of his plays and was successful in doing so (Arthur Miller...

Words: 998 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Examples Of Guilt In The Crucible

...Everyone is motivated by guilt sometime in their lives. There are a few examples of how guilt motivated certain characters to make decisions throughout The Crucible. Everyone in the town was being accused of witchcraft to get back at one another. There are a few characters who were motivated by guilt and show it throughout the play. John Proctor is motivated by the guilt of having an affair. “‘Abby, I may think of you softly from time to time.”’ (Miller 23) John Proctor was having an affair with Abigail Williams. John Proctor called Williams out on the affair and she would not answer it. Although John Proctor had an affair, Elizabeth Proctor still thought of John Proctor a good man. Also, Elizabeth felt sorry for not loving John Proctor enough, she kept a cold house. Because of this guilt he went into the courtroom to confess which would result in saving people's lives. He didn’t want to ruin his name so he tore up the document he signed saying that he was guilty. God knew he confessed and no one else needs to know other than the court. Because of this, he was hanged but knowing that he did the right thing....

Words: 504 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Who Is To Blame In The Crucible

...Who is to Blame? In Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible, there are many different characters that could be blamed for the Salem Witch Trials. Abigail Williams is a seventeen year old girl that is in love with an older married man. In her hunt to have him as her own, she leads her group of friends to accuse his wife and many others of witchcraft. It is most clearly demonstrated that it was Abigail William’s flaws – envy, dishonesty, and lust – that led her to be most responsible for the tragedy of the witch-hunt in Salem. Throughout The Crucible Abigail is envious of Elizabeth Proctor, and tries to get rid of her. One example is, ‘Oh, I marvel how such a strong man let such a sickly wife be’ (Miller 470). Abigail is commenting on Elizabeth’s health. She does not understand why John would rather have a sick wife than her. She is jealous that he chose His wife over her. Then she commented, ‘You loved me John Proctor, and whatever sin it is you love me yet,’ (Miller 471). This shows that Abigail thinks John loves her, and she is trying to convince him to be with her again. Abigail’s envy of Elizabeth drives her to get many people killed. In the play, Abigail is dishonest, pretending that there are actually witches. She does this in order to prosecute Elizabeth proctor. She...

Words: 524 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Crucible Reputation Analysis

...Pride and reputation have prominent role in all societies. Often times, maintaining one’s reputation can influence how a person act. This theme is evident throughout Arthur Miller’s play, the Crucible. Miller presents a 1690’s town with a rigid system and an extremely religious-oriented people. In this Puritan society, private and public integrity interweave and the threat of tainting their names is ever present. The stressed importance of maintaining pride and reputation results in influencing many of the characters within the play. The importance of reputation is instantly apparent, when Reverend Parris is more concerned about the hints and rumors of witchcraft and how that might blemish his good name, rather than his own daughter’s health....

Words: 505 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Precarious Parris In The Crucible

...Precarious Parris Most people would agree with Katherine Paterson that ”To fear is one thing. To let fear grab you by the tail and swing you around is another.” However, there are many that are consumed by fear everyday. In The Crucible by Arthur Miller a certain character stands out as a self centered, cowardly, yet loyal man. Not only do we find out who he his, but he realizes what fear has prompted him to be. Reverend Parris plays a substantial role in the church, but isn't the most faithful man on the planet. Being a reverend in a church doesn't normally associate itself with being self-centered, yet Parris isn't your ordinary reverend. When Parris catches his daughter Abigail red handed defying the church he is only thinking about one thing, himself. He suspects Abigail of lying and demands that “If you trafficked with spirits in the forest I must know it now, for surely my enemies will, and they will ruin it with me” (I, 76-8). Abigail could be tried in the court for her unlawful...

Words: 640 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Comparison

...Conflict in Arthur Miller’s ‘The Crucible’ Set in Salem, Massachusetts, Arthur Miller’s ‘The Crucible’ was written in 1952, the play which successfully portrays the witch trials in 1962 as an allegory for the prosecution of communists. The play contains many conflicts set to tear apart or destroy the small community of Salem, and to cause havoc with neighboring towns. Arthur Miller gives the reader a chance to experience the dangers of hysteria in a community through the conflicts experienced by his characters in a puritan society. Conflict is a strong disagreement between people or groups that often leads to strong arguments. Various elements of the plot are woven together in such a way that we are often left on a mini cliff-hanger, wondering what will happen next, which creates tension. Writer’s craft is the writer’s use of techniques to create an effect on the reader. The opening of the play immediately grips the audience. Betty Parris is lying motionless on a bed, Reverend Parris is kneeling next to her praying, but he conveys no sense of religious calm and faith. He is weeping and desperate. He cries out “Oh my God! God help me!” and he is very disturbed. When Tituba the household slave, enters Parris is in a state of “fury” and yells “Out of here! Out of my sight!” then is “overcome with sobs”. Miller is careful to specify in the stage directions just how the actor should deliver the lines and what type of emotions the character is holding. The opening is powerful...

Words: 1023 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Crucible Abigail Williams Reputation Essay

...The prevalent theme in The Crucible is reserving one’s reputation. There are many characters who demonstrate concern for their reputation as well as a change in the way they act. Two characters who validate concern for their reputation are Abigail Williams and John Proctor. To begin, Abigail Williams continues to accuse people to save her own reputation. The woods marked the foundation of Abigail’s lies. When asked by Danforth about the activity in the woods, she tells him that dancing was the only commotion that occurred. Many people in the community believe the girls encountered witchcraft. Abigail gets the girls to remain quiet about the night in the woods by saying: “Now look you. All of you. We danced. And Tituba conjured Ruth Putnam’s...

Words: 594 - Pages: 3