Free Essay

True Detective

In:

Submitted By evonnarose
Words 1104
Pages 5
Sawall 1
Evonna Sawall
Professor Kaefer
English 1A
12 April 2014
Evaluation Essay: True Detective True Detective is an extraordinary TV series, written by Nic Pizzolatto, about two Louisiana State Police detectives investigating a series of ritualistic murders. Pizzolatto has created a series beyond brilliant. The amazing structure, impeccable writing, marvelous acting, and frame story have made True Detective an immediate classic. At the end of each episode you will be on the edge of your seat craving another hour.
True Detective is based on two investigators, one of them is a typical overconfident investigator, Woody Harrleson, and the other is an intellectual, nihilistic man, Matthew McConaughey. This series alternates between 1995, when detectives Martin Hart (Harrelson) and Rust Cohle (McConaughey) start working a case together, and 2012, when the two detectives work a new case that has strong similarities to the case in 1995. State internal affairs detectives are interviewing both men separately and believe that Rust may have committed the old crime, new crime or both. Rust and Marty investigate a ritualistic murder in rural Louisiana. As they attempt to uncover leads in this disturbing case, their own lives intersect in fascinating, yet explosive ways. Though the investigation itself is interesting, the interpersonal behavior of the obsessive and frequently conflicting lead characters makes this drama seem so much fresher than all other criminal television series.
The structure in this series is unique. In 2012, two detectives are interviewed about a case that occurred in 1995. This series is primarily set in 1995, but has several scenes in 2012. We get to watch Rust and Marty at the beginning of their journey and at their rock bottom. This is a drama that began with its ending in mind. This series is in no rush, so it is able to go at a slow pace. I’m sure there are many people that desire their answers A.S.A.P., but the slow pace throughout the series helps give the show a more realistic feeling. This series’ anthology structure makes it different than most television shows. Although it would be nice to see more of Matthew McConaughey (Rust) and Woody Harrelson (Marty), there’re gone for good. Season two will have a whole new cast and storyline, which is refreshing.
The writing in this series, by Nic Pizzolatto, is excellent. The plot is witty and intriguing, the dialogue is legitimate and believable. The way Pizzolatto portrays Marty and Rust is clever. Marty is unable to "think outside the box" like Rust always does. Although Rust is the better investigator, police administrators look at Marty as the superior one because unlike Rust, he obeys their directions and plays well with others. Rust may be a little psychotic, but in a good way. He just has a different way of doing things. The stunts he pulled, when trying to find the killer of Dora Lang, were insane, but his spontaneous acts lead to Rust and Marty to the killer. Marty, however, is boring. He goes along with everything Rust says; he doesn’t have his own opinion. The fact that Rust and Marty are so different from one another makes things much more intriguing, that’s what really hooks the audience. Pizzolatto’s work is brilliant; he has helped create a masterpiece.
A great deal of credit should go to McConaughey and Harrelson for bringing liveliness to these two characters. It is the strange chemistry between Rust and Marty that gets you hooked right away. The dialogue between Rust and Marty is astonishing. They bicker in almost every conversation they have. Rust generally talks about meta-psychoses, while Marty tries his hardest to avoid the strange babble. They are complete opposites, which makes their relationship even more interesting. McConaughey and Harrelson are doing a fantastic job. They are compelling and believable. Rust and Marty each change dramatically throughout the series. Rust is at his rock bottom in 2012. He transformed into a hobo looking maniac. His hair, streaked with white and diminishing on top, is tied in a ponytail down to his mid back. On the other hand, Marty changed into a calm, depressed, bald-headed man. They both do an outstanding job with the characters they have. They are a big reason as to why this show is so successful. Overall, their performances are breathtaking. The frame story by its self increases the show’s attraction. The frame story leads readers from a first story into another, smaller one (or several ones) within it (Wikipedia). True Detective may be about the criminal case of a Louisiana serial killer, but it’s dominantly about the cast and expressing how these two detectives have transformed from 1995 to 2012. True Detective examines one’s effects when he/she faces demons that are unexplainable. Marty went from being an arrogant family man to a calm, depressed, family-less man. Rust descends into extreme alcoholism and transforms into a hobo looking hippie, but he still has his nihilistic thoughts and crazy obsessiveness.
Although True Detective received outstanding reviews and ratings, Emily Nussbaum, one of New Yorker’s critics, wrote, “True Detective wreaks of macho nonsense. The series, for all its good looks and its movie-star charisma, isn’t just using dorm-room deep talk as a come-on: it has fallen for its own sales pitch.” In a sense Emily is right. It is a very male-dominated series. Neglecting women may be one of the show’s minor downfalls, but it is a key theme in the series. On True Detective, each female character is a prostitute, psychotic killer, or a nag. True Detective is about the terrible things males do to females, things that commonly get looked over. No one cared about Dora Lange, the girl Rust and Marty found dead in 1995. Marie Fontenot, another young lady who was found dead in 1995, vanished and the police allowed a hoax from continuing their investigation. True Detective is not about women. Everyone else, despite his or her gender, have little purpose. True Detective not only neglects women, it neglects all other characters as well. The show’s main focus is simply on two characters, Rust and Marty.
With two talented actors, brilliant writing, magnificent structure, exquisite frame story, and spectacular acting, True Detective is ranked one of the highest rated TV series of 2014. It is truly a marvelous series. Work-Cited
Nussbaun, Emily. "Cool Story, Bro The Shallow Deep Talk Of "True Detective"" New Yorker. N.p., 3 Mar. 2014. Web. 8 Apr. 2014. Wikipedia. "Frame Story." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 30 Mar. 2014. Web. 10 Apr. 2014.
True Detective. Dir. Carry Fukunaga. Home Box Office (HBO), 2014

Similar Documents

Free Essay

True Detective

...“True Detective” – The meaning behind this controversial Tv series (Season One) By: Kaveh Shahidi PART 1 Ok guys, here it goes. Ever since I watched True Detective it’s been distracting my mind, confusing me with all sorts of symbols and mysteries, just waiting to be solved. Mysterious men, Satanic rituals, Murders with no strings attached.. all of these have been a part of the season, but what caught my attention was the dark force behind the whole shit. What is this force? What is the deeper meaning behind this mind-blowing show? I’ll cut the chase and go straight to the main point. The murderer was a crazy redneck who was actually identified by the detectives a few episodes beforehand. So no mind-blowing twist here right? No conspiracy right? Well actually that left me disappointed a little, I was expecting something more of shocker but I guess it doesn’t always end with aliens and men in dark suits from parallel universes. However, the symbolism, and the dialogue throughout the whole episodes was fascinating. And it also makes me wonder mostly about MARTY’S family and what it got to do with the investigation. There is deeper message my friends, it’s not just about a lunatic redneck but a dark environment that goes way back to generations before. If you remember what Rust used in the first episode, you’ll know what I’m talking about. The word “Psychosphere”. True Detective shows the sick obsessions of the elite through the everyday lives of the masses. This...

Words: 578 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Give Our Police Guns! Guns and Police Do Not Mix

...is no need to arm the police in the article ‘Guns and police do not mix’. This essay will evaluate several main ideas in both of these articles. Firstly, Public points out that arming the police does help protect people. When citizens see police who are carrying weapons, they probably feel safer. Nevertheless, Wright believes that there will be an increase in the amount of weapon usage on duty if police are armed. As a result, police may not use less dangerous ways to catch criminals. Secondly, Public mentions that police needs to have weapons to protect themselves. They mainly use them as a tool to defend rather than to injure criminals. Conversely, Wright emphasizes that it is possible to neglect some fundamental issues of society, so detective work and policing strategies need to be concerned about more than arming the police. Discussion: In these two articles, there is a contradiction between the authors’ ideas. While Public seems to fail to argue the idea about the protection for citizens, the point about police’s self-defense may be persuasive. However, Wright’s explanation about the increase in using weapons is unconvincing while there may be success in the point about the ignorance of society’s failures. Firstly, Public’s claim about protecting law-abiding citizens may be unconvincing. According to the author, people may have safer feeling when seeing police having weapons. Nevertheless, this can not be applied in all situations because arming the police can help raise...

Words: 980 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Seprico

...the police academy and his first assignment where he is partnered with a cop who willingly admitted that he accepted free food and looked the other way for minor infractions such as double parking. This scene becomes important as we begin to realize that, even though this I minor, there is a level of acceptable corruption within the New Your City police force and the Frank was not a willing participant in it at all. The next time we see Frank, he is responding to a possible rape call which he and his partner break-up and arrest one of the suspects. The lead detective, I assume, later beats the suspect and Seprico seems reluctant to want to participate in. Once the suspect is being taken to prison Seprico talks him into giving up the names of the other two assailants, Frank calls for assistance, receives none and makes the arrests himself. Once he gets the suspects back to the police station, he is bullied by the detectives to give the credit for the arrest. He relinquishes the arrest but here you can see that he is interested in getting promoted fast. We now cut to a few different scenes involving hes love life, family and living arrangements that, in my opinion, took away from the story a bit. Especially the scene where he is with the dancer at a night club and wanting people to call him Paco. The part about another name wasn't really...

Words: 1244 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Books

...all my friends at the 12th 3 of 110 05-05-2013 19:50 Heat Wave - Richard Castle file:///C:/Users/zainab/Downloads/Richard.Castle_Nikki.Heat.01_Hea... Contents One It was always the same for her when she arrived… Two Nikki Heat’s footsteps echoed back at her off the concrete… Three Heat and Rook trailed two steps behind Noah Paxton as… Four Nikki didn’t go home following the movie after all. She… Five There is very little chance of a high-speed pursuit on… Six Nikki stepped into the rooftop bar of the Soho House… Seven Even as she stood frozen in her hallway, Nikki’s first… Eight When Detective Heat nosed the Crown Vic out of underground… Nine Nikki Heat’s apartment building was not the Guilford. It was… Ten Nikki led him wordlessly into her bedroom and set the… Eleven Thirty minutes later, Detective Heat stepped off the Guilford’s elevator… Twelve The three detectives and Rook maintained a tense silence as… Thirteen In the precinct interrogation room, the biker, Brian Daniels, seemed… Fourteen Raley came back into the bullpen dangling his sport coat… Fifteen Jameson Rook stood in the precinct Observation Room staring in… Sixteen Nikki was tucking in her blouse as she sailed down… Seventeen The receptionist at Starr Real Estate Development popped back on… Eighteen On their drive back from the M.E.’s office, Nikki didn’t… Nineteen Heat, Raley, Ochoa, and Rook crossed through the lobby of… Twenty “Stop squirming,” said Noah...

Words: 70446 - Pages: 282

Free Essay

Things They Carried

...Tim O'Brien does a fantastic job of blurring the lines of what is true and what is fiction in The Things They Carried. In fact, he often points out that he has made entire stories up, after the fact. He defends his decisions by proposing that what he has done is, in fact, not lie, but rather tell a story-truth. He argues that his reason for doing this is to bring the story to life more than it could live through the happening-truth. 'I want you to feel what I felt. I want you to know why story-truth is truer sometimes than happening-truth' (O'Brien, 183). O'Brien believes that, when accompanied by vivid details which essentially make the reader view the scene as a dream, story-truths can carry greater emotional truths than ever possible to be achieved through actual, happening-truths. With this, he shows, contrary to belief, how story-truths are often truer than happening-truths, and demonstrates this through the addition of often graphic details. Happening-truth encompasses actual events that take place. However true these stories may be, they are often times viewed as unreal simply because they have no details to back them up. The entire shit field scene that was put into this book, for example, was turned from a happening-truth into a story-truth because the original version was not believable. The reader can see this through O'Brien describing the letters that he received from Norman Bowker. Norman writes to Tim, telling him that he should write about the event. 'What...

Words: 2289 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Theory of Knowledge Guide

...“What I tell you three times is true.” (Lewis Carroll) Might this formula – or a more sophisticated version of it – actually determine what we believe to be true? Repetition is our way of learning knowledge. Repetition is drilling something to memory, reinforcing the idea in our heads. It is the key to reflexive use (use without conscious thought). Your mind “learns” by repetition and reinforcement. Repetition and its effects on what we believe to be true, play a major role in the way that we accumulate general knowledge. The formula implies that repetition is equal to truth, when really repetition is just repetition. Repetition does not make a statement the truth. But a statement, if repeated often enough, can come to be accepted as truth. This leads us to the question whether a lie can be accepted as truth. From the standpoint of logic, the number of times an incorrect fact is repeated is irrelevant. It is still false. But research has shown that a statement, even an incorrect fact, if repeated often enough, can be accepted as truth. This paper will examine several research studies, influencing variables, and examples from everyday life to identify this occurrence. In addition to this, the possible effects of repetition will be discussed as well. One of the simplest ways to show how repetition causes a statement to be accepted as truth is gossip. First, someone tells a friend a statement, which can be true or false. This friend tells another friend, who tells another...

Words: 1530 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Burglary Case

...On the haunt to find the suspect who simultaneously disappeared after committing a burglary is found by our uniformed police officer and transported to the burglary squad. He matches the description given by the last witness Mr. Mitchell around 3:00pm near the time of the offense. Being asked by Detective Johnson, Mr. Mitchell remembers everything. He remembers the physical description and the vehicle description. He’s more than the last witness, he’s a concern neighbor. Once detective Johnson arrives to the burglary squad, he recognizes the fresh cut on the suspect’s hand, and with an insured look, he knows it’s him. Expressly, Officer Butler will conduct a warrantless legal search while notifying any watchers to remind nears their home,...

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Montejo V. Louisiana

...was interrogated at the sheriff's office by police detectives thought the late afternoon and evening of September 6 and the early morning of September 7. On September 10, Montejo was brought before a judge for what is known in Louisiana as a "72-hour hearing" a preliminary hearing required under state law. Letter that same day, two police detectives visited Montejo back at the prison and requested the accompany them on an excursion to location to the murder weapon (which Montejo had earlier indicated he had thrown into a lake). He was again read his Miranda rights and agreed to go along. While in the police car, he wrote an inculpatory letter of apology to the victim's wife. Only upon their return did Montejo finally meet his court appointed attorney, who was quite upset that the detectives had interrogated his client in his absence. III. Case History At trial, Montejo's letter of apology was introduced into evidence by State of Louisiana, over defense counsel's objective. The jury convicted Montejo of first-degree murder and he was sentence to death. The Louisiana Supreme Court affirmed his conviction, concluding the since Montejo has never formally invoked his rights to counsel officers where not prohibited from further interrogation outside the presence of counsel. IV. Legal Issues May a criminal defendant that has never personally and formally invoked his right to consul be questioned by police officer or detective after waiving his rights to consul, consistent with...

Words: 321 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Love Actually

...8 hrs. - Fire service, they will continue to make sure that all fires are kept out. They may start to clear the debris away from where plane has hit. They will have one last look for trapped casualties and those casualties may either be in the plane or buildings that the plane may have hit. Ambulance, they make sure that all casualties have been dealt with either on the scene of the incident or at hospital. They will start to collect their equipment at the incident and they will also start to reduce the numbers of personnel and vehicles at the scene of the incident. They do this so that they can be used elsewhere. They will start to take the triage down also as it may be needed at the next big incident. Police, the police will continue to patrol the area so that opportunist thieves don’t try and loot damaged houses and shops. They will continue to make sure everything is kept in order. They will prepare the roads ready for opening when the recovery phase starts. They will continue to make sure that only the right people with have access to incident site as it prevents evidence from be tampered. This allows investigation teams to be able to identify clues more easily. Police will also appoint senior investigators. Fire service, they would help to move heavy debris away from the incident Ambulance Police, with the highways agency they would start opening roads so that cars, buses and other vehicles can start to get to where they...

Words: 381 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Red Flasining Lights

...speed chase, if the driver decides not to stop. When this happens, the officer is going to begin the chase, because he does not know whether the driver has committed some terrible crime, like robbery or, if he is a dangerous drug dealer, or perhaps a wanted sex offender. You never know when a high speed pursuit will start. They can sometimes start in a local area and continue into another jurisdiction. Although these chases are dangerous, neither the driver nor the police know what might be ahead of them. Although police chases are dangerous, police who allows suspects to flee run the risk that offenders will do even greater harm to citizens, says Michael Crivello, president of the Milwaukee Police Association and a city police detective. “They’re fleeing because they may be wanted for sexual assaults, shootings, homicides,” he says. “there are pursuits that are successfully concluded all the time, but you never hear about those.” Milwaukee changed its policy on pursuits last month after four people were killed by drivers fleeing police in three separate incidents in a two-month period. Police there now must have probable cause that a violent felony has occurred instead of reasonable suspicion before initiating a chase. Who do you blame when such dangerous chases end up taking the lives of innocent bystanders. The driver, nor the police wouldn’t know, what effect this action could cost a community, when the life of someone who is well known, not only locally, but...

Words: 746 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Police Officer Research Paper

...They gather facts and collect evidence in order to protect the people from further harm. Their job results in physically demanding, stressful, and dangerous everyday tasks. In fact, police detectives are some of the smartest people out there. The job outlook is 5%, which is slower than average. A police detective requires a high school education, lots of training, and a good sense of judgment. For one thing, becoming a police detective takes lots of rigorous training and just like any other career, an education. The education requirements consist of a high school degree; usually a police department will prefer a college education and sometimes even require it. Something that is a great addition to the education requirements is the knowledge of a foreign...

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Organizatinal Behavior in Police Departments

...Organizational Behavior in Police Departments Organizational Behavior in Police Departments The study of the behavior of humans in an organization is called organizational behavior (Schermerhorn, Hunt, Osborn, & Uhl-Blen, 2010). Organizational behavior is a discipline that attempts to understand group and individual behavior, organizational dynamics, and interpersonal processes in an effort to improve the performance of the people in an organization and the organization itself. In a police department, organizational behavior can benefit by becoming critical for management to succeed in meeting the organizations goals. To understand the complex forces that make up human behavior in organizations, the nature of the organization must be reviewed first. An organization is described as a group of people working together to achieve a common goal or purpose. In the police department, the core purpose is to serve and protect. Many police departments have evolved from past generations of officers, and many departments are influenced by the local history and cultures. Three other influences effect the police agencies and the organization, the size of the department, the technology available, and environmental factors. In a large police department, information management, and direction need more organization to be maintained. The technology in a police department is also important in the matter of archiving information and how it is managed...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Coast to Coast Killer

...Chapter Four “You feel like shooting some hoops?” Said Officer Thompson to Detective Carpenter as he was pretending to shoot a jumpshot from his seat in front of the detectives desk. “I think we need to take a little break.” “You know, tired minds don’t think to well.” He continued. As he was now tucking in his shirt upon rising from his chair. Officer Thompson was a pretty good former N.B.A. reserve player. Having played for the Philadelphia 76ers before injuring his knee in his rookie season. Second team All-American out of Temple University. 6-6 and only 28. He was still a formidable opponent between the blocks. And nobody wanted to play H.O.R.S.E with him either. Hardly anybody could match his dunks. “Yea.” “Maybe you’re right.” “Not for too long though.” “This fucker ain’t resting to much so we can’t afford to either.” Responded the detective. He was tapping on the desk with his pencil while looking at the list of victims. They had been in the office since early this morning working on the case and had been going over several stacks of paper concerning the victims and all of the new data seemed to be a bit over whelming by now. At this point, they were yet unawares of the latest victim, the girl in Florida had not yet been found. Charlie had pulled her into the bushes and covered her up with a stack of delivery pallets he had found nearby. “I keep thinking about number 29.” Said the detective. “You mean the pizza delivery guy?” “Yea.” “You know, I don’t think he even planned...

Words: 493 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Asta Interview Questions

...Margret Ritschel What Would You Do for Love? After much trouble in The Agency, everyone can rest easy because I have found the culprit of The Asta Situation. After two rounds of interviews with everyone in The Agency, I have found who shaved Asta. On top of that, I also found what they used to shave Asta, when they shaved Asta, and why they shaved Asta. In secret agent terms, these pieces of evidence are called the means, the opportunity, and the motive. Since I am a fabulous agent, I know that Cara is clearly the culprit of the Asta Situation because she has access to the letter opener, she was seen going into the room where Asta was sleeping, and she was doing it all for her love of Dickie. Cara had the means to shave Asta. In my second interview with Dickie he told me, “Yes, I did ask Agent MacGuffin for the letter opener. Cara appeared very intrigued by this antique device when I described it to her during one of her visits to my work station. I requested that Agent MacGuffin bring it to my station so Cara could examine it herself.” This means that the letter open was left for Cara to use when she came into Dickie’s office next. In my second interview with Agent MacGuffin he shared this intriguing quote, “Do I have any tools for such a job? I did. I had my fabulous letter opener; I believe you saw it once in the Debriefing Room. But I gave it away a while back. Strangely enough, Dickie asked me to leave it at his work station. I'm not sure what Dickie wanted with it. He...

Words: 925 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Detective Paper 3

...Luck in Crime Solving Detective fiction is a branch of crime fiction that centers upon the investigation of a crime, usually murder, by a detective. It is the most popular form of hardboiled crime fiction and mystery fiction. In the story, the detective uses reasoning to piece together various clues left behind by the perpetrator to form a coherent story of how the murder took place. It is even written down as rules that “the culprit must be determined by logical deductions” and “the means of detecting it (the murder), must be rational and scientific” (Van Dine, 1928). Through the years, three major forms of reasoning have been frequently used to solve the cases- deductive, inductive and abductive. Although these three methods vary in terms of uncertainty involved, a common intuition that can be inferred about gaining knowledge from the rules is that knowledge is true belief that has been acquired in a non-accidental or non-lucky fashion. However, I will be drawing on specifically three types of luck- evidential epistemic luck, content epistemic luck and pure luck, and how luck is often underestimated as a contributing factor towards solving crimes along with reasoning. The first type of luck I will be discussing is evidential epistemic luck, where the detective is lucky to be able to possess certain knowledge in the first place (Pritchard, 2005). The animated series “Detective Conan” follows the adventures of Kudo Shinichi, a teenage detective prodigy who was inadvertently...

Words: 1391 - Pages: 6