Premium Essay

Vitality Health Case

In:

Submitted By bunga3
Words 2944
Pages 12
Third Case
Question 1.
Vitality’s old Performance Management System presented some problems that were affecting some of its most talented employees. The analysis of those problems as well as the identification of their root causes will allow us to make a reflection about the company’s previous Performance Management System in the following paragraphs. Firstly, the old system was prone to central tendency error. It had 13 rating levels and lacked a described evaluation criteria. As one can understand, if the rating scale is large and the different levels are not sufficiently explained, the evaluators will be more likely to evaluate less accurately. In the case, one can read that managers gave almost to everyone a B or a C, provided few A or D ratings. This is a problem because it shows that the managers do not take the performance and evaluation system as a serious and fundamental tool, which consequently affects employees who are not able to receive valuable feedback on their performance. In our opinion this problem has two main root causes. The first one is that managers do not want to upset employees and the sense of teamwork and egalitarianism, so they give medium ratings to everyone. They might believe that a medium grading does not affect neither positively nor negatively employees’ performance. We believe that the other cause could be the lack of clarity in the rating levels description. The fact that the grading system is not clear for managers hampers a precise evaluation of all employees. Second, in addition to the lack of evaluation criteria, there is a problem of absence of assessment of the attributes of specific jobs and consequent alignment with the company’s strategic goals. There are no clear job descriptions, so besides not knowing well how managers should evaluate, they also do not know individual or team goals that should be

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Vitality Health Enterprises Case Study

...Harvard Business Review Case study Analysis BY John Raphael Marty Vitality Health A better Corporate Performance Management System to Retain Top Talent Vitality Health Vitality Health Introduction Issues Beth Williams stepped in to fill the shoes of Fred Kikuchi in 2009 as the new CEO. Her primary stated purpose was to “find a better way to identify and reward top performers in order to keep ‘A’ players in their positions and accelerate company growth by attracting new top talent.” To do this, Beth created a new performance management team (PMET) to study the existing rewards & compensation, and uncover changes that needed to be made. With over 50% of the staff in Des Moines consisting of scientists and engineers, and a total R&D budget nearing 30% of total gross revenue in 2009; Vitality’s growth depended heavily on continued human resources for R&D, especially due to Vitality’s focus on emerging markets and the volatility that comes along with such growth. Beth’s prompt delivery of a new performance management system only eight weeks after discovering problems likely delighted Vitality’s board as well as some staff, but her no-nonsense approach must have also been a shock internally as she was “a notable contrast from Kikuchi’s more conciliatory management style.” The email sent to management to simply review the online guidebook of the new performance management system hardly created “buy-in” within the organization, that was...

Words: 3093 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Vitality Health Enterprises Case Study Summary

...Vitality health enterprises was formed by kikuchi when his wife complained tat she cudnt find the kind of cosmetics she wanted whn she was in japan. Vision : outer beauty can only be achieved as inner harmony is reached. So they brought in the Herbalpure nutraceuticals which included health, wellness and beauty products. They expanded their consumer target. In mid 2008, global economic crisis hit, which brought vilitiy’s growth to stagnation. So kikuchi decided to bring in fresh executive suite. So he brough Williams. Points to be noted: - There was a poor earnings in 2009. Exhibit 1a and 1b shows. So the PMS had to review the policies and track the perf goals of all non sales n non executive employees in the entire company. - PMS had to hold employees accountable for their actions n incentive strong employee performance by offering thoughtfully designed compensation packages, including salaries, bonuses n equity opportunities in the form of options. - The PMET studied evaluation n rewards system. Employed internal n external bench-marking, focus groups n employee interviews. PROBLEMS that PMET discovered: - There was problems for 2500 professional staff approx. Which consisted of mostly scientists n engineers in R&D labs. - 113 different rating levels (from A to E including pluses and minuses) - Managers were worried about offending employees so they gave almost everyone a C or a B, provided few D or A ratings n rarely gave Es/ this resulted in homogeneous ratings...

Words: 397 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Mba Mba Mba Mba

...Harvard Business Review Case study Analysis BY John Raphael Marty Vitality Health A better Corporate Performance Management System to Retain Top Talent Vitality Health Vitality Health Introduction Issues Beth Williams stepped in to fill the shoes of Fred Kikuchi in 2009 as the new CEO. Her primary stated purpose was to “find a better way to identify and reward top performers in order to keep ‘A’ players in their positions and accelerate company growth by attracting new top talent.” To do this, Beth created a new performance management team (PMET) to study the existing rewards & compensation, and uncover changes that needed to be made. With over 50% of the staff in Des Moines consisting of scientists and engineers, and a total R&D budget nearing 30% of total gross revenue in 2009; Vitality’s growth depended heavily on continued human resources for R&D, especially due to Vitality’s focus on emerging markets and the volatility that comes along with such growth. Beth’s prompt delivery of a new performance management system only eight weeks after discovering problems likely delighted Vitality’s board as well as some staff, but her no-nonsense approach must have also been a shock internally as she was “a notable contrast from Kikuchi’s more conciliatory management style.” The email sent to management to simply review the online guidebook of the new performance management system hardly created “buy-in” within the organization, that was...

Words: 3093 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Performance Management at Vitality Health Enterprises

...Performance Management at Vitality Health Enterprises, Inc. The Health and Vitality of Vitality Health Enterprises James Hoffman, the newly appointed vice president of Human Resources of Vitality Health Enterprises, was pleased when he saw an early preview of the earnings figures for the fourth quarter of 2011. But he knew better than to relax. Competition in the personal care products sector was cutthroat, and complacency was a recipe for obsolescence and loss of market share, particularly in cosmetics and nutraceuticals. Vitality was riding high on a six-quarter string of strong revenue growth that had surpassed analyst expectations. However, as emerging markets represented a growing portion of business revenues, the company was becoming increasingly exposed to volatility and uncertainty and, without prompt corrective action, would soon be poised to trip over its own feet. The cost of research and development continued to climb, and Hoffman feared that the chain of success was allowing employees to relax, leading to a culture of ineffective performance management. There were even whispers of discontent from the marketing team about a growing number of missed product launches. Hoffman knew that Vitality had recently struggled to maintain its position as an industry leader in innovation and he worried about the slow but notable increases in employee turnover, especially among the highly talented research scientists. Without their expertise, Vitality couldn’t remain vibrant...

Words: 6731 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Xxxx

...JOURNAL OF WOMEN’S HEALTH Volume 14, Number 8, 2005 © Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. Changes in Health Status Experienced by Women with Gestational Diabetes and Pregnancy-Induced Hypertensive Disorders CATHERINE KIM, M.D., M.P.H..1 PHYLLIS BRAWARSKY, M.P.H.,2 REBECCA A. JACKSON, M.D.,3 ELENA FUENTES-AFFLICK, M.D., M.P.H.,4 and JENNIFER S. HAAS, M.D., M.S.P.H.2 ABSTRACT Objective: To examine changes in health status among women with gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) and pregnancy-induced hypertension (PIH). Methods: We examined perceived health status changes from the prepregnancy, as recalled at 12–20 weeks gestation, to the postpartum period in women with GDM (n 64) vs. unaffected gravidas (n 1233) and women diagnosed with PIH (n 148) vs. unaffected gravidas. We used patient survey and medical record data from a prospective cohort study. Health status measures included the Short Form-36 scales for physical function, vitality, and self-rated health and the Center for Epidemiologic Studies-Depression Scale (CES-D). Multivariate logistic regression models controlled for age, parity, race, education, prepregnancy body mass index (BMI) and exercise levels, food insufficiency, and GDM or PIH during a prior pregnancy. Results: Women with PIH more often reported a significant decline in vitality (odds ratio [OR] 1.51, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.02-2.23) and self-rated health (OR 2.12, 95% CI 1.193.77) and an increase in depressive symptoms from prepregnancy to postpartum compared...

Words: 5024 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Vitality Health Enterprises Inc

...POLYTECHNIC OF NAMIBIA HAROLD PUPKEWITZ GRADUATE SCHOOL OF BUSINESS Performance Management at Vitality Health Enterprises, Inc Case Report By Leonardo Imerne Strategic Human Resources Management (SHM910M) Date: 21 June 2014 2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report will focus on the performance management at Vitality Health Enterprises, Inc, which is a cosmetics and beauty products oriented business. The business started off well with a fast expansion approach. As the company grows, performance management of its staff was necessary to reward top performers as a motivation factor, and also to identify poor performers so they could be trained further or relieved from their positions. The report will therefore highlight the problems associated with performance management and rewards appraisals at Vitality Health Enterprises Inc, such as failure to reward top performers accordingly, identify worst performers, and recommends solutions thereof. STATEMENT OF KEY PROBLEMS OR ISSUES Vitality Health Enterprises Inc was founded in 1987 in Ames, Iowa by an Fred Kikuchi who identified a market niche of health, wellness and beauty products in the Ames where he resided after he left Japan. The company at the beginning of its operations relied on importing re-branded beauty products from Japan until it established its manufacturing plant in the United States of America. As planned, the company grew rapidly and later acquired Herba Nutraceuticals to increase its market share and profitability...

Words: 1459 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Obesity

...individual's tallness, surpasses 30 kg/m2, with the reach 25-30 kg/m2 characterized as overweight. Some East Asian nations use stricter criteria. Heftiness improves the probability of different ailments, especially coronary illness, sort 2 diabetes, obstructive rest apnea, certain sorts of disease, and osteoarthritis. [Haslam, 2009] Obesity is most regularly brought on by a mix of over the top sustenance vitality admission, absence of physical movement, and hereditary vulnerability, despite the fact that a couple cases are created fundamentally by qualities, endocrine issue, solutions, or psychiatric sickness. Confirmation to bolster the perspective that some fat individuals eat little yet put on weight because of a moderate digestion system is constrained. All things considered, corpulent individuals have a more prominent vitality use than their slight partners because of the vitality needed to keep up an expanded body mass. Eating fewer carbs and practicing are the principle medications for heftiness. Diet quality can be enhanced by lessening the utilization of vitality thick sustenances, for example, those high in fat and sugars, and by expanding the admission of dietary fiber. With a suitable eating regimen, hostile to corpulence medications may be taken to diminish hankering or reduction fat retention. On the off chance that eating regimen, activity, and medicine are not compelling, a gastric inflatable may...

Words: 673 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Hello

...happens by the natural cycle of earth however as of now human exercises are still significant wellspring of environmental change. Expanding level of greenhouse gasses including carbon dioxide conveys more warmth to the earth as they have capacity to ingest and discharge heat in the environment and hence keep earth warm. A few of the human activities that contribute to the greenhouse gasses to the atmosphere are deforestation, burning fossil fuel and invention of new technology. All the greenhouse gasses make temperature of earth to increment at higher rate which is not in the support of life of people, animal and plants. A gigantic level of environmental change bothers the equalization of the global ecosystem will affect in increase in health risk and death. There are numerous reasons of environmental change including natural cycle of earth however the significant supporters of the environmental change is global warming. Some human exercises and the advancement of technology are forcing the greenhouse gasses to grow and also, getting gathered to the environment which will make the surrounding of the earth to become more hot. Higher temperature causes issues to the presence of life on this planet even numerous essential types of the plants and creatures have been in risk. What are the main indicators of climate change? Firstly, air temperature onto land are developing. It's reasonable that climate...

Words: 1224 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case Study Lindlahr's Three Primary Causes Of Disease

...PART A: CASE ANALYSIS (30 MARKS): Case report: 50 year old woman lives alone but has several very close friends that she spends time with. Her spiritual life is extremely important to her; she listens to church services regularly on the internet, as well as reading many religiously oriented books and engaging in twice daily prayer. 6 months ago and has not been working BP is lower, her bowel movements are more regular when she is taking the magnesium for her blood pressure, a strong desire to get past it., She takes a walk outdoors four times each week, walking, usually about 30 minutes 1. Consider Lindlahr’s Three Primary Causes of Disease as they relate to this patient. For each of the three causes, discuss particular aspects of this patient’s...

Words: 1316 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Living Life with a Purpose

...producing delicious cherries), and everyone for miles around seems to benefit in the process. The entire lifecycle of the cherry tree is rewarding, and the only “waste” involved is an abundant sort of nutrient cycling that only leads to more good things. Best of all, this show of productivity and generosity seems to come quite naturally to the tree. It shows no signs of discontent or resentment — in fact, it looks like it could keep this up indefinitely with nothing but good, sustainable outcomes. The cherry-tree scenario is one model that renowned designer and sustainable-development expert William McDonough uses to illustrate how healthy, sustainable systems are supposed to work. “Every last particle contributes in some way to the health of a thriving ecosystem,” he writes in his essay (coauthored with Michael Braungart), “The Extravagant Gesture: Nature, Design and the Transformation of Human Industry”...

Words: 4042 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Healthcaee Sector

...INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT INDORE HRM Assignment Vitality- Case Analysis Section E - Group 1 Submitted By: Abhijeet Singh Dialine Lazar Manish Tuljapurkar Priya Parmar SudhanshuRanjan Vartika Agarval 2012PGP004 2012PGP103 2012PGP197 2012PGP277 2012PGP877 2012PGP423 Executive summary Management Concerns in 2011 Vitality Health Enterprises, a medium-sized firm that manufactures health and personal care products, has experienced six straight quarters of strong revenue growth. James Hoffman, the new Senior Vice President of Human Resources, fears that the chain of success is shifting the company's focus away from effective performance management. Recently, Vitality has been faced with increasing turnover among the company's talented research scientists that may be due to a performance management system that leaves top performing employees slighted by the practice of uniform ratings. In an effort to retain top employees, the company institutes a forced distribution model of performance rankings, moving from an absolute ranking system to a relative one. Hoffman and his performance management evaluation team must assess the practical and strategic effectiveness of the new system and present their findings and recommendations to the Board. Original Performance Management System (Till 2009) Due to decreasing earnings in 2009, the company decided to adopt a new business strategy that would focus on:- 1. Adopting cost-cutting...

Words: 1566 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Deprivation Of Sleep In Macbeth

...crucial part of what makes life worth living are shown. This feeling that he has lost the one thing that truly acts as a brace and to an extent make life worthwhile, slowly leads Macbeth’s mental health to deteriorate to a point where it is noticeable by all. After, Macbeth’s crazed outbursts and claims of being able to see Banquo’s ghost, Macbeth’s mental state transgresses past mildly disturbed to something that can be seen by all the goers of the banquet. Lady Macbeth in order to keep the secret of their king’s worsened mental health pleas to...

Words: 1140 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Community Based Arts as a Tool for Community Development

...LITERATURE REVIEW EXPLORING COMMUNITY BASED ARTS DEVELOPMENT: AS A TOOL FOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT. This thesis explores how community based arts as a tool for community development. Exploring how and for what purpose community based arts organisations can create social capital and to provide insight on how the arts sector can be a leader in the transformation of Cork county communities and regions around Ireland and the globe. The perspectives of artists, community development practitioners sponsors and beneficiaries of the arts provided insight on how and in what ways the arts can evoke change by building connections and inspiring participation. Abstract The Lords mayor’s message: ‘’The Arts & Cultural Strategy for Cork City Council 2011 – 2015 is a statement of intent. It outlines our policies and strategies as we develop the services and facilities available to all of our citizens’’(Lord Mayor Cllr. Michael O’Connell,2015 p1) The Arts play a major role as an economic engine to promote local and regional development. Research shows that the presence of creative arts in the raise the quality of community life and there is a growing evidence that communities with high quality of life will prosper in the global economy. Arts development can also be important in renovating aging neighbourhood. Providing tenants for vacant store fronts and promote tourism. City of Cork and their alliance and the Arts alliance...

Words: 3653 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Strategy

...By 2006, Whole Foods Market (WFM) had evolved into the “world’s largest retail chain of natural and organic foods supermarkets.” (Case Analysis-Whole Foods Market 2005 p.1). An example of strategic decision making is WFM implementation of “Health Starts Here” ; an initiative to offer healthier pre-fab food options with limited add-ons such as refined flour and sugar and processed ingredients. The purpose is to encourage better eating among its shoppers. To make it successful they hired healthy eating specialist for each store and created wellness clubs. This is unconventional, and WFM is performing different activities from rivals, and more important this new activities fit and reinforce the other activities such as: selling the highest quality, least processed natural food, satisfies and delights their customer, active support of organic farming, sustainable agriculture that helps protect our planet and decentralized, self-directed team culture. Their Strategic Based Position is a Needs-Based; they seek to meet organic grocery needs of its target customers which are college educated residence interested in eating natural and organic foods. There strategic position is sustainable because of the trade off of being so streamlined with their organic options that tend to be higher priced, by doing so gives up their service to lower income families by not providing lower cots options. As well as only purchasing from farmers that meet WFM’s organically certified requirements...

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Perceptions of College Students Toward Rh Bill

...I INTRODUCTION The Responsible Parenthood and Reproductive Health Act of 2012 (Republic Act No. 10354), informally known as the Reproductive Health Law or RH Bill, is a law in the Philippines, which guarantees universal access to methods on contraception, fertility control, sexual education, and maternal care. While there is general agreement about its provisions on maternal and child health, there is great debate on its mandate that the Philippine government and the private sector will fund and undertake widespread distribution of family planning devices such as condoms, birth control pills, and IUDs, as the government continues to disseminate information on their use through all health care centers. Passage of the legislation was controversial and highly divisive, with experts, academics, religious institutions, and major political figures declaring their support or opposition while it was pending in the legislature. Heated debates and rallies both supporting and opposing the RH Bill took place nationwide. The Supreme Court delayed implementation of the law in March 2013 in response to challenges. As of August 18 this delay was still in force "until further orders". REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE One of the most controversial issues confronting the Philippines today is about reproductive health. Many written materials and publications are available asserting about elements of reproductive health with different perspectives. Their ultimate goal is to improve...

Words: 3683 - Pages: 15