Free Essay

What Is Strategy

In:

Submitted By skizhak
Words 1366
Pages 6
What is Strategy? – Michael E. Porter

I. Operational effectiveness is not strategy

So in the quest to beat competition managers focus on improving quality, speed and productivity all related to operational effectiveness. But in this way, they move further away from viable competitive positions which can only be achieved by an appropriate strategy. Positioning which was once the way to go about beating competition is now rejected, since its too static. Rivals can easily copy the market position and competitive advantage. However, that is not entirely true as hypercompetition is a self-inflicted wound. It is important to watch out for what your competitors are doing, but improving operational effectiveness alone is not enough, and that cannot be your only strategy.

Operational effectiveness and strategy are both important for superior performance which is what a firm aims for. A company can beat rivals if it can stand out, establish a difference it can preserve. Basically a company can either provide greater value to customers or comparable value at low prices, or both. Delivering greater value means higher unit prices, greater efficiency means lower unit costs.

Cost arises from performing activities and cost advantage comes from performing activities more efficiently than your competitors. This can be in the choice of the activity or how the activity is performed. So activities are what creates competitive advantage.

Operational effectiveness means performing similar activities better than rivals. Strategic positioning means performing different activities or similar activities in a different way.

Productivity frontier is the sum of all existing best practices at a given time. Maximum value a company delivering a particular product can create. Improving operational effectiveness helps companies move towards the frontier. Emerging new technologies have made shifts in the frontier a continuous process. In order to keep up with the frontier shifts, managers have invested in continuous improvement, empowerment, change management and learning organization.

* Constant improvement in operational effectiveness is necessary but not sufficient to achieve superior profitability. This is because even the best practices can be copied by rivals, this being accelerated by consultants :D Also OE competition extends the productivity frontier even further. * Also improving operational effectiveness leads to competitive convergence, where all rivals start to look alike. Here, everyone is trying to do things the best way possible, which in the process leads to them going for generic ways and leads to no real advantage in the end. The only way to survive competition at this time is to buy each other out, and the ones that survive are the ones who managed to last and not the ones with any particular advantage.

II. Strategy rests on unique activities

Competitive strategy is about being different. Most managers describe strategy based on their customers, but strategy is mainly all about activities. Eg. Southwest and Ikea.

Strategic positions are of 3 types, which can overlap – 1. Variety based positioning is all about providing a specific set of products or services, rather than serving a particular customer segment. Eg, Jiffy Lube and Vanguard. 2. Needs based positioning, which in a way coincides with traditional positioning is all about meeting the needs of a particular set of customers. Eg. Ikea Differences in needs does not translate into meaningful positions unless the activities to meet those needs also differ. Otherwise all competitors will also be able to meet those needs, just like you. Eg. Bessemer, Citibank 3. Access based positioning where the needs of the customers are similar to other segments but the way to meet those needs (best configuration of activities) are different. This could be scale or geography. Eg. Rural vs urban based customers.

Regardless of the mix of positioning, it requires a tailored set of activities because it is always a function of differences on the supply side, that is of differences in activities.

Thus strategy is the creation of a unique and valuable position, involving a different set of activities.

III. Sustainable strategic position requires trade-offs

Ways incumbents can copy a valuable position – 1. Competitor can reposition itself to match the superior performer. 2. Straddling – that is trying to maintain its current competitive position while also trying to match the benefits of a successful position. Eg. Continental airlines trying to copy Southwest.

But straddling is not always possible since it could lead to trade-offs. Trade-offs occur when certain activities are incompatible. Eg Neutrogena’s specially made soap which is available through drug stores and not through supermarkets. To achieve this they had to avoid using skin softeners and deodorents that most people desire in their soaps to stick to their commitment to “soap that is gentle to the skin”.

Trade-offs arise due to three reasons – 1. Inconsistencies with image or reputation – basically two conflicting images cannot be portrayed eg. Ivory soap trying to copy Neutrogena. Millions of dollars will need to be spent to create a new image. 2. Trade-offs amongst activities themselves – Ikea has worked towards lowering costs and thus they will nto be able to provide high service levels. a. Value is destroyed if an activity is overdesigned on underdesigned b. Productivity can improve when variation of an activity is limited 3. Limits on internal control and coordination – risk of confusion amongst employees.

Trade-offs arise when companies try to provide a variety of qualities. Low cost could mean quality in low price airlines. The false trade-offs between cost and quality occur primarily when there is redundant or wasted effort, poor control or accuracy, or weak coordination. Basically a company can improve on differentiation and costs only when it is far behind the productivity frontier or if the frontier has shifted outward. Otherwise it would be difficult to achieve both at the same time.

So the essence of strategy is choosing what not to do.

IV. Fit Drives Competitive Advantage and Sustainability

OE is about improving on different individual activities, strategy is about the best combination of activities. A certain fit of activities locks out imitators by creating a chain that is as strong as its strongest link.

There are three types of fit although they are not MECE – 1. First order - Simple consistency between activities 2. Second order – activities reinforce each other 3. Third order – optimization of effort a. Coordination b. Information exchange c. Minimize wasted effort and redundancy
Competitive advantage arises from the entire set of activities and such activities are governed by specific themes. Eg low cost

The greater the order of fit amongst company activities, the harder it will be for rivals to imitate and the greater will be its competitive advantage. It also leads to the need to improve operational effectiveness as poor performance in one activity leads to the decline of others. In such a situation finding a new strategic position is more viable than blatantly trying to copy your competitor’s strategic position / set of activities.

Also a certain set of activities should be planned for a longer period of time, since with time activities get optimized and operational effectiveness improves. Having to switch to a different set of activities is extremely expensive, thus frequent shifts of strategy is a costly endeavour.

Thus strategy is fit amongst company’s activities, it is important to do many things well not just a few and integrating them.

V. Threats to Strategy

1. Inability to choose – managers chase every strategy possible and do not realize the importance of trade-offs, some mention customer focus as an excuse to their lack of strategy while others mention flexibility 2. The growth trap – trade-offs and limits appear to constrain growth and managers are tempted to take incremental steps that would blur the company’s strategy. 3. Profitable growth – deepening a company’s position involves making the company’s activities more distinctive, but most of the time managers chase the easy way out without adhering to strategy 4. The role of leadership – leadership has degenerated into simply making deals and improving operational effectiveness, however leadership is far beyond just that.

Strategic continuity does not imply a static view of competition rather a company must actively try to improve its operational effectiveness and try to shift the productivity frontier outward. Ongoing efforts for maintaining uniqueness and strengthening fit amongst activities is absolutely essential.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy?

...What is Strategy? By Michael Porter Business Strategies and Policies Decision Making Rosalyn Blanco Kerly Olivares Carlos Rojas Jose Blas Gomes Juan Carrillo Millennia Atlantic University What is Strategy? By Michael Porter Nowadays in this globalized world and evaluate as advance the transformation of business in the world. Operational effectiveness is no longer enough for companies, analyzing the view of Michael Porter; the strategy is the heart for positioning and competitive advantage in these very dynamic markets with rapidly changing technology. Many managers or leaders do not understand the strategy; many prefer short-term results by focusing on operational effectiveness. Well make things better than rivals now is not enough. The only result is companies of imitation and homogeneity. Superior performance is achieved with the strategy. A manager should evaluate the big picture and not lose focus and not just use tools such as benchmarking, outsourcing, best practices, etc. A manager must be able to create competitive advantages for positioning the company against its rivals and provide high profitability. Working together operational effectiveness and strategy are mutually constructive. The essence of strategy lays on to perform chosen or designed activities different than competitors do. Porter emphasize that competitive strategy is about being different. It means deliberately choosing a different set of activities...

Words: 1400 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy

...Paper name: “What is Strategy?” Author: Michael E.Porter During the study process i have red few articles on company strategy planning importance and the process of it's implementation. The paper which is chosen as the base for this work goes under the title “ What is strategy?”, contributed by Michael E. Porter. The main idea of this paper is the importance of company's strategy and operation effectiveness for reaching the corporate goals. The author notes that both are essential for superior performance although they works in a different way. The difference of this two concerts is that operation effectiveness means performing similar activities better than the rival does, while strategy means perform different from the rival activities, or the similar activities in different way. Moreover, the article describes the ways of company activities imitations that could be used by the rivals. The author presents the number of tools and activities that should be regarded for strategy sustainability: unique activities, trade-offs and fit. The success of company strategy depends on entire system of activities. To my point of view, the best way to demonstrate understanding of red materials and my own vision on article presented concepts is to demonstrate good examples of perfect implementation of strategy. I tried to find some examples of strategies that become determined in companies success. The strategy highest priority is to be different from others, to have...

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy

...What’s Strategy? Introduction The ability to sustain the business in the market is definitely a tough job. That explains why behind every company there is a strategist to come up with innovative ideas to achieve specific goals. The need for a structural organization to grow, a plan such as a unique strategy is needed. A strategy is a unique plan, a long term plan for a structural organization to achieve a targeted goal. It involves unique activities that enhance the organization to outshine from the competitors and still preserve it. There are different strategies to take into consideration but the definition of strategy that this essay will outline here focus on three questions below: 1. What forms of value do organization wants to create? 2. How to create that value? 3. How to manage that value? In answering these three questions we will then have a better understanding of what is strategy. What forms of value do organization wants to create? Firstly, why do organization wants to create something valuable to consumer? The value benefit the consumers, therefore organization create the value consumers’ desire. Value can be in a form of service, a product or other different forms of value. A market research need to be done to have a better understanding of the consumers’ needs. After the above source being gathered, organizations are able to match the consumers’ needs with the newly created value. A win-win situation should be established for consumers...

Words: 848 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

What Is Strategy

...Case 1 – (information technology the internet and changing strategies in the fashion world) Question 1. What business model and strategies is Zara pursuing? Answer – Zara uses IT to manage the interface between its design and manufacturing operations efficiently. Zara’s designers closely watch the trends in the high fashion industry and the kind of innovations that the major houses are introducing. Then, by using their information system, which are linked to their supplier and the low cost manufacturers the company uses abroad, they can create a new collection in only five weeks and these clothes can then be made in a week and delivery to stores soon after where major fashion houses take six or more month for design. IT also gives Zara instant feedback on which of its clothes are selling well and which countries. Question 2. How has Zara’s business model changed the nature of industry competition? Zara’s business model changed the nature of industry competition like many of other design and retail companies have awakened to the threat posed by companies like Zara. Clothing designer like Ralph Lauren and Tommy Hilfiger have been forced to adopt similar approaches, bringing out new clothes collections several times a year and instituting price markdowns to sell inventory quickly. Question 3. What new strategies have emerged in the fashion industry as a result? Answer - Increasingly, many companies are realizing that a competitive advantage and superior profitable cannot be...

Words: 487 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy?

...DISCUSSION OF MICHAEL E. PORTER’S “WHAT IS STRATEGY?” Discussion of Michael E. Porter’s “What is Strategy?” Key Issues In today’s business, managers are trained and encouraged to focus on effectiveness and benchmark all activities in their business segment. Major goals for department heads are to achieve goals, which are often defined as measurable; for instance expenses, revenues, production numbers, activities per day, and the like. By doing so a company is thought to stay flexible enough to react instantly to changes in the market. Furthermore, positioning a company is considered as being too static. Another belief is that competitive advantages are temporary only at best and cannot be sustained. Porter (1996) describes this current business culture as dangerous, based on half-truths, and believes that it ultimately will lead companies down a path a mutual destructive competition. The main failure is to distinguish between effectiveness and strategy. While effectiveness is necessary it alone is not sufficient to achieve sustainable profitability. This can only be realized with a company-wide strategy. A strategy, which defines unique activities will differentiate a firm from its competitors and position the company strongly in the market. A strategy, which is company-wide, will ensure that these unique activities create a fit by complementing and reinforcing each other. Porter (1996) defines the key issues of today’s business philosophy as follows: • Failure to...

Words: 1071 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy

...NAME: NGO VU GIA LINH ID: BABAIU11026 GROUP 1 ASSIGNMENT 1 Why operational effectiveness is not strategy?? The success of organizations is critical by operational effectiveness and strategy because it required better productions than competitors. The flexibility in organization always changes the business and use for benchmarking of measure success but OE can’t be called strategy for many reasons. OE mentioned how best the company can perform in specific activities to win the competitors. The organization achieves OE by doing the same tasks but compete who does the best. In contrast, strategy occurs when something new is created. Organization can implement both similar and same things but bring in different manners from competitors. It can be innovation, creation or maintenance of sustainable advantage in long term that competitors can’t copy. In the other word, strategy success is when organization creates some unique actions which bring value for customers better and it can’t be duplicated. What are the unique activities strategy needed to rest on? Why a sustainable strategic position requires trade-offs? Unique activities strategy included three positions: Variety-based positioning, Needs-based positioning and Access-based positioning. The first one is based on the more appreciated decision of customers with availability of various product or service than customers segments. In contrast, need-based positioning completely based on customers’ segments. It mentions...

Words: 463 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy

...Michael Porter is associated with the positioning school (Mintzberg 2002:23), who‟s analytical approach sees strategy making mainly based on a process to identify drivers(forces) of intra-industry competition and its corresponding barriers. His reasoning is based on the assumption that a company who deliberately choose a position within an industry and at the same time is able to combine activities in a different fashion, can create sustainable competitive advantages that will lead to profitability and with it sustain competition. Aside this more general position of Porter, in an article from 1996, he asks “What is Strategy” and discussed operational efficiency in connection with strategy making and he advised that those two things should not (can not) be used interchangeably. Below their is a summary of Porter‟s main arguments from his article and what he sees as main components on strategy and how to distinguish between operational efficiency and strategy. SUMMARY The ability the make an informed decision about how, when and where to target a customer group, facilitate resources and set objectives(limits) makes the difference between a manager who thinks from a strategic perspective in light of what might emerge in future. Anticipating those movements into current decision-making helps to set a stage to create sustainable advantages. Porter argues that positioning is still a notable way to shape advantages within a company and sees hypercompetition as rather...

Words: 2194 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

What Is Strategy?

...disappointment of administration to recognize operational effectiveness and technique: Management instruments have taken the place of strategy. 1) Operational effectiveness is performing similar exercises superior to anything opponents perform them. Operational effectiveness incorporates however is not constrained to effectiveness. It refers to numerous practices that permit an organization to better use its inputs. Porter expresses that an organization can beat opponents just in the event that it can set up a distinction it can protect. It must convey more prominent worth to customers or make comparable value at a lower cost, or do both. Nonetheless, Porter argues that most organizations today contend on the premise of operational effectiveness. The productivity frontier is the aggregate of all current best practices at any given time or the greatest quality that an organization can make at a given expense, utilizing the best accessible technologies, abilities, administration methods, and acquired inputs. Hence, when an organization enhances its operational effectiveness, it moves toward the frontier. The frontier is always moving outward as new advancements and administration methodologies are created and as new inputs get to be accessible. To stay aware of the persistent moves in the productivity frontier, managers have received strategies like constant change, strengthening, learning organization, and so on. Rivalry in view of operational effectiveness alone is...

Words: 1231 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy

...S8341201A BAM 1st Intake UMSD38 Strategic Management What is Strategy? Introduction Before we look into the above topic, we always need to question ourselves on why do we need strategy? To answer this question, we have to look into the values that organizations seek to create for their group of consumers. We will also look into how values are created and managed. Competition, an ongoing and endless journey for all organizations. Marketers got to constantly look out the market trend and changes as every action taken by or within the industry or any external factors will contribute a significant impact to each and every companies within the country, region or internationally. Companies will need to need understand and analyze on how to be proactive and reactive to such situations and best plan on how to respond and remain competitive or even better than what others are doing. However, many companies now constantly benchmarked themselves with competitors and outsourcing to strengthen their productivity, quality and speed as it is now a key fundamental to gain efficiencies to stay ahead of the competition. Never do the organizations and companies aware that the path way is leading to a mutually destructive competition. In today competitive world, different marketing strategy has been used by organizations and companies over the past thirty years. Throughout this discussion, we will also look into the different types of strategies adopted by different companies & organizations...

Words: 1811 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy ?

...What is strategy? Strategy is the creation of a unique and valuable position, involving a different set of activities such as: * Few needs of many customers * Broad needs of few customers * Broad needs of many customers in a narrow market Today, in this globalized world, each and every sector of economy has been integrated into a single platform by technology. The businesses and markets are becoming dynamic and advancement in technology have questioned the sustainability of competitive advantage. All the industries and organizations all over the world are under tremendous pressure to improve productivity, quality and speed. In order to manage these factors, managers are using the tools such as TQM, benchmarking, and re-engineering. Operational improvements are taking place but it has not been able to provide sustainable profitability to the organizations. And gradually, these tools of measurement have taken the place of strategy. In his five-part article, Michael Porter explores how that shift has led to the rise of mutually destructive competitive battles that damage the profitability of many companies. As managers push to improve on all fronts, they move further away from viable competitive positions. Porter argues that operational effectiveness, although necessary to superior performance, is not sufficient, because its techniques are easy to imitate. In contrast, the essence of strategy is choosing a unique and valuable position rooted in systems of activities...

Words: 1105 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

What Is Strategy

...effectiveness is representative of outperforming competitors on similar activities such as product development or product delivery. It is beneficial to better allocate the resources and capabilities as well as to maintain the competitive advantages to achieve more profits. While operational effectiveness is not equal to strategy and the drawback of being imitated by rivals will threaten the companies’ best practices. Therefore to keep the sustainable competitive advantage companies should apply strategic positioning principles by retaining the most valuable and distinctive aspect of the company. There are three disciplines of strategic positioning: 1. Being different: Establish differences among competitors, which indicates the company either performs similar business activities differently or performs different activities to enhance the value perception to its customers. The sources of strategic positions range on the basis of variety need or access. 2. Making trade-offs: Strategic positions always attract rivals to imitate the success and reposition themselves to gain more benefits. Trade-offs are needed to preserve sustainability because by cutting down what the company could offer, it prevents competitors from copying the value or position because this will undermine the rivals’ core values. 3. Creating fit: Fit means to link and reinforce each activity to each other. Rivals could not easily to find a match when several activates mutually affect each other, thus it ensures...

Words: 474 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Review of What Is Strategy

...Review of What Is Strategy Introduction The article---‘What is strategy’ is mainly concerned with exploring the definition of the strategy by distinguishing ‘operational effectiveness’ from ‘strategy’. To explore the real meaning of strategy, the author defines this term from three different perspectives: strategic position, trade-offs and fit. Main part Understanding of the article Some concepts of this article are based on theoretical foundations. Firstly, operational effectiveness is based on the Five Forces Frame Work (Porter, 2008), as its definition ‘performing similar activities better than rivals perform them’ (Porter, 1996) links with external environment, especially for the competitors. Another concept ‘strategic position’, performing different activities from rivals’ or performing similar activities in different ways (Porter, 1996), is related to RBV (Barney, 1991), because both them emphasize on the distinctiveness and uniqueness. The other two concepts ‘trade-offs’ and ‘fit’ are based on VRIO criteria (Barney, 2007), which is the basis of the company to generate sustained competitive advantage. The V of VOIR, value, is consistent with ‘trade-offs’, as they indicate that company should decide what to do and not to do. The ‘fit’ is line with the ‘I-inimitability’, since both of them stress that interlinkages among corporate activities makes difficult for organization to imitate. Wider context of strategy theory Besides, this article could also be...

Words: 1250 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

What Is Marketing Strategies?

...What is Marketing Strategy? Marketing strategy is defined by David Aaker as a process that can allow an organization to concentrate its resources on the optimal opportunities with the goals of increasing sales and achieving a sustainable competitive advantage. Marketing strategy includes all basic and long-term activities in the field of marketing that deal with the analysis of the strategic initial situation of a company and the formulation, evaluation and selection of market-oriented strategies and therefore contributes to the goals of the company and its marketing objectives. Effective marketing starts with a considered, well-informed marketing strategy. A good marketing strategy helps organization define vision, mission and business goals, and outlines the steps need to take to achieve these goals. Marketing strategy affects the way organization run entire business, so it should be planned and developed in consultation with team. It is a wide-reaching and comprehensive strategic planning tool that: * Describes business and its products and services * Explains the position and role of products and services in the market * Profiles customers and your competition * Identifies the marketing tactics will use * Allows building a marketing plan and measuring its effectiveness. A marketing strategy sets the overall direction and goals for organization marketing, and is therefore different from a marketing plan, which outlines the specific actions you will take...

Words: 1942 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

What Is Business Strategy

...Business Strategies 14.1 Introduction business strategy describes how a particular business intends to succeed in its chosen market place against its competitors. It therefore represents the best attempt that the management can make at defining and securing the future of that business. A business strategy should provide clear answers to the questions: A s s s s What is the scope of the business (or offering) to which this strategy applies? What are the current and future needs of customers and potential customers of this business? What are the distinctive capabilities or unique competence that will give us competitive advantage in meeting these needs now and in the future? What in broad terms needs to be done to secure the future of our business? These questions should have been addressed during the process of strategy formulation. The processes and techniques and processes described in Part III may have contributed to answering them. In this chapter, we are concerned with some of the practical issues that arise when thinking and analysis leads into action and commitment. We are concerned also with what makes the difference between good and indifferent business strategies. We suggest that a good business strategy will meet six tests of quality: s s s s s s It will be correctly scoped. It will be appropriately documented. It will address real customer needs. It will exploit genuine competencies. It will contribute to competitive advantage...

Words: 1859 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

What Is Business Strategies

...Strategy evaluation is an attempt to look beyond the obvious facts regarding the short-term health of a business and appraise instead those more fundamental factors and trends that govern success in the chosen field of endeavor. Strategy can also be defined as a set of objectives, policies and plans that, taken together, define the scope of the enterprise and its approach to survival and success. Alternatively, we could say that the particular policies, plans, and objectives of a business express its strategy for coping with a complex competitive environment. A good business strategy can be broadly categorized into functions like consistency, consonance, advantage, and feasibility. A strategy that fails to meet one or more of these criteria is strongly in suspect. It fails to perform at least one of the key functions that are necessary for the survival of the business. Inconsistency in business is not simply a flaw in logic. A key function of strategy is to provide coherence to organizational action. A clear and explicit concept of strategy can foster a climate of tacit coordination that is more efficient than most administrative mechanisms. Organizational conflict and interdepartmental bickering are often symptoms of managerial disorder, but may also indicate problems of strategic inconsistency. It is no exaggeration that to say that competitive strategy is the art of creating or exploiting those advantages that are most telling, enduring, most difficult to duplicate. Competitive...

Words: 285 - Pages: 2