C H A P T E R 12 Evaluate Your Argument on the Issue In this chapter you will learn how to identify and overcome errors in reasoning. This is a special step that applies only to issues because resolving issues involves finding the most reasonable belief. Two broad kinds of errors are examined—errors affecting the truth of your ideas and errors affecting the quality of your reasoning. A step-by-step approach to evaluate arguments is also included. ecause your main objective in addressing an
Words: 7555 - Pages: 31
weekend leading to her death at the hands of a drunk driver early on Monday morning. This article will analyze the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by Ms. Butow. It will also illustrate the logical fallacies in Ms. Butow’s argument. First we will analyze the author’s reliability and validity of data. In this instance they can be judged together. The data used and quoted by Ms. Butow is taken directly from Ms. Webb’s Twitter account and other social media pages. Also, Ms
Words: 852 - Pages: 4
right as a human to protect ourselves from a threat. Locke uses a premise that humans are intellectual enough to make the correct decisions about if something is a threat or not and how to handle it as humanly as possible. Locke provides a strong argument in state of war. He makes the case that in the society war is different than the actual laws that have been in existence since the beginning of living creatures. In the instance of right now how are we
Words: 1129 - Pages: 5
State each argument’s conclusion. The following are the conclusions for the arguments in Wk 6 – Logic Handout 1: Therefore, the slaves were freed Therefore, the slaves were freed All seniors are ugly (F) All ugly people are insightful (T) All talented people are insightful (T) For each argument, state the premises (i.e., reasons) that supposedly support each separate conclusion. Premiss 1: If the North won the Civil War, then he slaves were freed Premiss 2: The North won
Words: 408 - Pages: 2
it's raining then the streets are wet. The streets are wet. Therefore, it's raining. If p then q. q. Therefore, p. Argument from ignorance this fallacy is committed if it is argued that since p has not been proved true, it must be false (or that since p has not been proved false, it must be true). Argument 1 The building blocks of arguments The purpose of an argument establishing, rather than simply stating a point Attacking the person this fallacy is committed if it is argued that
Words: 607 - Pages: 3
Examining Different Arguments Pamela C Purvis HUM/111 July 29, 2012 Jennifer L. Bingham, JD Examining Different Arguments Title | Examining Different Arguments Related to the Choice of a Career | Assessment Part A: Critically Evaluating an Argument | Build your mindmap. | Arts and Sciences (Advantage): Lots of flexibility in career choices: Logically Sound | Arts and Sciences (Disadvantage): Leads to a career in food service - 'Do you want fries with that?':
Words: 649 - Pages: 3
to critique a fallacy in the argument regarding the dispute of a decrease of the current age of consumption and purchasing alcohol in the United States. I believe the arguments discussed in the selected article to be fallacious because they deal generally with the positive results portrayed as an outcome in the reduction of the legal age of 21 to 18. Through analysis of this article, it will be evident that a reduced legal drinking age is a fallacious and flawed argument. Through research, I discovered
Words: 565 - Pages: 3
Instructions: Using Johnson’s Power, Privilege and Difference text as your primary source …Answer the three (3) questions below. Assessment criteria: a. Critical argument – In addition to making a substantive statement; have you made sure to include the evidence (citations) supporting the statement? b. Soundness of argument - Is your line of thought logical and complete? c. Clarity of writing - Can a reader easily follows and comprehend the meaning conveyed in the response? d. Quality of
Words: 754 - Pages: 4
ASSIGNMENT 1 Kylie Pang Caro v. Bron Claim against Bron for assault Assault occurs when the defendant directly produces apprehension in the plaintiff of battery. It is clear that because Caro attempted to spin around and avoid Bron, that she was aware of and anticipating a direct physical act on her person. Bron would argue that she did not intend to cause physical harm but there does not need to be intent to cause harm – only intent to act. By “skating full speed into a crowd of people”
Words: 1028 - Pages: 5
Chic-Fil-A, coming out against gay marriage. Though clear, fair, and evidence based arguments can be given for both opponents and proponents on gay marriage, Shapiro only whimsically urges readers to wake up to Cathy’s mistakes with an argument from pity while also begging the question; claiming that his choices were a biased hatred towards the gay community. The article fails to show both sides of the argument and only makes an attempt to pull sympathy from readers by one sided views of those
Words: 743 - Pages: 3
