Stanley Milgram’s “Issues in the Study of Obedience: A Reply to Baumrind” addresses his concerns regarding the argument she presents in her article in which she critiques his notable experiment on obedience. Correspondingly, he attempts to defend his premise as well as the chosen experimental methods he employs. However, Milgram’s response is ineffective in conveying his assertions to the article’s intended and likely audience because Milgram proves himself to be an unreliable authority. This fraudulence
Words: 921 - Pages: 4
Robert Nozick designed a thought experiment that contained an experience machine that could give you any experience you desired. (Nozick, 42) This experience machine was designed to challenge hedonism. By plugging into the machine you are given the chance to program your experiences through life for the next two years. Then you must endure ten minutes of distress to reprogram the machine and then jump back in for the next two years. This cycle continues for the rest of your life. However, by plugging
Words: 771 - Pages: 4
This experiment became one of the biggest solved mysteries by John B. Watson, and a graduate by the name of Rosalie Rayner. The subject name was Douglas Merritte, a nine-month-old toddler, and the son of a wet-nurse by the name of Arvilla Merritte. She let them experiment on the child, and for letting her son be in the experiment, she received a dollar. The child nicknamed “AlbertB” for the experiment, was first exposed to a couple of items a rat, a dog, a monkey, a mask, and cotton. The now 11-month-old
Words: 521 - Pages: 3
experiment is often questioned due to unethically perceived procedures of the study. In Milgram’s famous study researching the implications of authority figures on obedience, subjects of the experiment were deceived into thinking that they were the “teachers” of an experiment testing how a stimulus could affect learning; these teachers were instructed to shock the learner, which was actually a confederate in the study, after they incorrectly answered a question, and throughout the experiment the
Words: 1197 - Pages: 5
representative of the general population in terms of age, sex, and ethnicity. In addition, it was more ethically conducted in a variety of ways. Many of the participants were given indicators that there would be no loss of money if they refused and no negative repercussions. It would seem that with the addition of these diverse variables that there would be more than a slight difference in results, but this was not the case. Burger concluded the same thing that Milgram concluded, which is that situational
Words: 546 - Pages: 3
The experiment that I chose was “How can you make an ice cube melt faster than it does in air?” My findings were the following; putting the ice in hot water melted faster than any of the other procedures at 30 seconds. Apart from having the ice cube melting by air, the other procedure that took the longest was putting it on the floor. This took 2 hours and 8 minutes. What I liked about this experiment was that I could see myself implementing this into my classroom. When I looked at ice, I didn’t
Words: 268 - Pages: 2
results were constant between the “relatively homogeneous group”(Bourne) of children of the professors of Stanford and groups of children from lower income families, such as the trial in the Bronx (Lehrer), the home environment of the children had no effect on the children’s self-control. The success of the children had a direct link to their ability to delay gratification, and Mischel wanted to study this link more
Words: 793 - Pages: 4
A Few Good Men, Colonel Jessup and Lieutenant Kaffee believe they are entitled to an absurd amount of respect compared to the manner in which they regard their fellow soldiers. Philip Zimbardo, the psychologist who conducted the controversial Stanford Prison Experiment, found that when regular individuals are granted power over others with no restraints, those in power will forcefully separate themselves from the subordinates (Zimbardo 109). Crispin Sartwell also explains how military killing machines
Words: 987 - Pages: 4
The Solomon Asch, Stanley Milgram and the example of the Milgram-related Hoax Case informs humanity that we need to stay true to our moral conscience, independent with our thoughts and fully incorporated in the decisions we make, they remind us of the importance of a clean political process and the right to be informed they warn us of the dangers that can come from surrendering to the decision of the majority and the blind obedience to authority. In “Perils of Obedience” by Stanley Milgram he states
Words: 367 - Pages: 2
outlining and evaluating agency theory and legitimate authority. It will then go onto evaluate the contrasting research of Milgram and Hofling’s studies into obedience, also looking at other similar studies. The third section will discuss and analyse the ethical issues into social psychological research referring to the specific issues contained in the studies of the previously mentioned psychologists. A conclusion will sum up the entirety
Words: 1058 - Pages: 5
