Premium Essay

Analysis of Case “Are We Ready for an Automotive Plant” Using Smart Method

In:

Submitted By isanisun
Words 1158
Pages 5
Strategic Decision Making and
Negotiation
Midterm Test

Analysis of case
“Are we ready for an automotive plant” using SMART Method
Muhammad Nur Ikhsan
29114400
YP52B

8 Main stages of SMART

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.

Identify decision maker(s)
Identify alternative courses of action
Identify the relevant attributes
Assess the performance of the alternatives on each attribute
Determine a weight for each attribute
For each alternative, take a weighted average of the values assigned to that alternative 7. Make a provisional decision
8. Perform sensitivity analysis

Page 1 of 17

Stage 1

Identify decision maker(s)

In ‘Are we ready for an automotive plant?’ case, the decision maker is automaker itself.
They are seeking a site for a new manufacturing plant.

Page 2 of 17

Stage 2

Identify alternative course of action

Alternatives:
• Detroit, Michigan
• Norfolk, Virginia
• Louisville, Kentucky
• McAllen, Texas

Page 3 of 17

Stage 3

Identify the relevant attributes

Attributes

Cost

Labor Cost

Benefit

Living Cost

Union
Activity

Financial
Leverage

Environment
Availability

Supplier
Availability

Workforce
Availability

Page 4 of 17

Stage 4

Asses the performance of the alternatives on each attribute

Labor Cost Rating

Manufacturing Industry
McAllen, Texas
Detroit, Michigan
Norfolk, Virginia
Louisville, Kentucky

$
$
$
$

2008
26,560
47,740
39,310
40,910

Rating
100
0
40
32

*Lower cost is better

Page 5 of 17

Stage 4

Asses the performance of the alternatives on each attribute

Living Cost Rating
Manufacturing Industry
McAllen, Texas
Detroit, Michigan
Norfolk, Virginia
Louisville, Kentucky
*Lower cost is better

$
$
$
$

2008

80
73
96
78

Finance Incentives Rating
Rating
70
100
0
78

Manufacturing Industry
McAllen,

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Marketing Management-Mercedez Benz

...Introduction Founded & Head quartered in Stuttgart, Germany by Daimler Motoren Geselleschaft in 1998,DaimlerAG formerly known as DaimlerChrylser AG is amongst the world’s most successful German automotive corporation established in the year 1883.Daimler-BenzAG was formed when the company combined with Benz and Cie in 1924 and 1926 respectively(Thornton & Meyer-Larsen, 2000). The Newyork Times magazine 2010 considers them to be the world’s second largest, manufacturer followed by BMW in terms of the luxury cars (The NewYork Times, 2010). This industry has about 256000 employees with the production plant distributed in almost five different continents. It is also the largest manufacturer of commercial vehicles that includes Mercedes-Benz Cars, Mercedes-Benz Vans, Daimler Trucks, and Daimler Bus. (Benz Insider, 2010).In 2007 private firm namely Cerberus Capital management, the specialist in restructuring troubled companies brought Daimlers former subsidiary Chrysler which was later titled Daimler AG on October 4, 2007. Key Business Activities The Automotive service and Financial service together forms the two key business activities of organisation. Mercedes-Benz Charter Way is the international commercial vehicle financial arm of DaimlerChrysler established nearly fifteen years ago that offers financial services, fleet management, insurance services, banking and credit/debit card services in more than 40 countries. Reports have shown that Mercedes-Benz Charter Way...

Words: 4114 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Future of Autos

...The Future of the Automobile Industry Diala Albirini, Karen DuBois, Missy Habig, Craig Naugle The Future of the Automobile Industry Industry Scope When we first started organizing our thoughts on what to focus on within the automobile industry we found ourselves drawn to the population size and safety features (safety for individuals and for environment). We stimulated our strategic thinking by asking the following questions: What will the automobile industry at large look like in 2025? What trends/shifts will shape mobility in the years to come? What will drive the success of future winners? We quickly realized that our project scope needed to be broader to cover all of the megatrends we indentified and address them as it pertains to specific geographic regions of the world. Cars being mass produced on the assembly line will be a thing of the past. The commercials today for Buick of not ‘driving your father’s Buick’ will even be more pronounced in 2025. In fact, my father would have thought he was living in a science fiction movie! The mantra of ‘have it your way’ will become the mission statement of the automobile industry – both from a consumer and an employee perspective…if they want to remain successful in the industry. Our results? The automobile industry will remain a capital-intensive business model and thus limited in terms of its margin growth. However, over the next fifteen years the automobile industry will remain an exciting place. The industry’s center of...

Words: 8290 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Nano Technology in Automotive Industry

...Nano technology in the automotive industry:- ABSTRACT What is Nanotechnology? Nanotechnology is the engineering of materials on the scale of 1 nanometer (nm) to 100 nm, a nanometer being 1 billionth of a meter. At this level, the basic physical laws governing macro objects undergo a drastic change. A macro particle is a cluster of atoms arranged together in random order. The formation of the structure is left to nature, and control over the properties of the material is difficult. Nanotechnology, on the other hand, is a bottom-up approach where materials are created by placing individual atoms together. This decreases the randomness in the structural formation, enabling significant control over the properties of the material. Mechanical properties such as strength, ductility, and resilience can all be incorporated into one material. Currently, nanotechnology is functioning as an enabling technology. It is being used to enhance the properties of existing materials. This is largely attributed to the fact that the technology has clearly not been understood and there is still much more to nanotechnology than meets the microscopic eye. It is rare for a single technology to have the power to dramatically influence almost every major industry in the world. Nanotechnology falls into this category and offers fundamentally new capabilities to architect a broad array of novel materials, composites and structures on a molecular scale. This technology has the potential to drastically...

Words: 8073 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Reasrch Paper

...Raju Sharma COMPARING AND ANALYZING FINANCIAL STATEMENTS TO MAKE AN INVESTMENT DECISION Case Study of Automotive Industry Business Economics and Tourism 2012 1 VAASAN AMMATTIKORKEAKOULU UNIVERSITY OF APPLIED SCIENCES Bachelor of Business Administration ABSTRACT Author Title Raju Sharma Comparing and Analyzing Financial Statements to Make an Investment Decision: Case Study of Automotive Industry. Year 2012 Language English Pages 72 + 5 Appendices Name of Supervisor Jukka Paldanius The purpose of the thesis was to evaluate and compare the financial statements of different companies to rate their performances. The emphasis was to be able to choose among several companies the best one to invest in. The aim of the study was met by comparing the risk of different companies, their rate of return, future trends and their strengths and weaknesses. In the theoretical section of the thesis different factors affecting the capital market were discussed, with the focus being on the risks of an investment. Basic financial statements and ratios were discussed briefly. Next cross sectional and time series techniques to compare the financial statements and ratios were revealed. Most of the information from the theories was later on used in the empirical part of the thesis. In the empirical study, initially the financial statements of different companies were taken to compute the ratios, risk, average return, to make trends and common size statements. Then a quantitative interpretation...

Words: 20085 - Pages: 81

Free Essay

Peugeot Ion: Rebuild an Innovative Product

...* CONTENTS I. Internal analysis 4 A. Key facts 4 B. PSA in brief 4 C. Company overview 5 D. The electric vehicle 6 E. Focus on Peugeot Ion, the tangible product 6 F. Services 7 II. Macro 7 A. Ecological and Economical factor 7 B. Political factor 8 1. Legislations and government interventions 8 III. Micro 8 A. PURCHASE behavior: environmental vs. economical concern 8 B. Competitors offer 9 1. Specialist carmakers 9 2. Renault – Nissan 9 C. Substitutes products 10 1. Other concepts of “green cars” 10 IV. SWOT 11 A. Strengths 11 1. Strong research and development capabilities 12 2. Increasing operational performance 12 3. Partnership with Mitsubishi 13 B. Weaknesses 13 1. High indebtedness 13 2. Autonomy/performances and Charging battery time 14 C. Opportunities 14 1. Strategic alliances 14 2. Poised to benefit from growing automotive markets in China, Latin America and Russia 15 3. Growing worldwide demand for more environmentally friendly vehicles 15 4. Stringent environmental regulations 16 D. Threats 16 1. Intense competition 16 2. Foreign currency risk 17 V. Segmentation 17 A. Criteria of segmentation 17 urrent target of the Peugeot iOn 18 VI. Current strategy 19 A. Objectives of the Group 19 B. Competitive advantage 20 C. Competitive environmental strategies 20 D. First Mover Advantage 20 E. BCG Matrix analysis 21 VII. Questionnaire results 22 VIII....

Words: 11707 - Pages: 47

Premium Essay

Toyota Motor Corporation Swot Analysis

...Columbia Project: Use of Software to Achieve Competitive Advantage AUTOMOBILES: TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION Gaining and Sustaining Long-term Advantage Through Information Technology Case Prepared By William V. Rapp Co-Principal Investigator The College of International Relations Ritsumeikan University Kyoto, Japan 914-945-0630 (Fax: 914-923-1416; 011-81-75-466-1214) E-mail: william.rapp@aya.yale.edu April 2000 SOFTWARE AS A TOOL OF COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE: AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY 1 2 3 4 5 Introduction: Objectives of this Benchmarking Study……………………….…….3 Approach: Methodology and Questions…………………………………………....9 Introduction to Case…………………………………………………………….…10 The Industry Context: The Japanese and Global Automobile Industries………….10 Toyota’s Multi-faceted Global Strategy………………………………….………..21 Smart Production (scheduling, buffer stocks, interactive controls) Smart Design IT and Management of Supplier Networks Smart Marketing Responding to Demand Changes Through Smart Production & Design 6 Smart Car…………………………………………………………………….……...42 Environmentally Smart Cars Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) 7 8 Information Technology Infrastructure and Project Selection………………………60 Summary - Controlling the Future…………………………………………………..68 Exhibit 1 - Promotion Plan for Intelligent Transportation System………………………78 Exhibit 2 - Toyota’s ITS Businesses and R&D………………………………………….79 Exhibit 3 - ITS Evolutionary Development……………………………………………..80 Appendix I Summary Answers to Questions for Toyota...

Words: 31150 - Pages: 125

Premium Essay

Jerry York and Gm

...The Sustainability Business Case for General Motors April 22, 2014 Master’s Project for the University of Michigan School of Natural Resources and Environment Team Rose Buss Heather Croteau Steven Davidson Carole Kerrey Janet Van De Winkle Faculty Advisor Professor Thomas Gladwin Abstract The purpose of this report is to evaluate and articulate the business case for sustainability for General Motors Company (GM). After assessing the company’s exposure to risk and opportunities, the team recommends that GM should implement an internal price on carbon and a sustainable supply chain strategy. These recommendations will provide GM with tangible and substantial financial benefit in addition to improved risk mitigation and brand value. Additionally, the team found that these recommendations are viable within GM’s corporate structure and can generate systemic benefits throughout the company. Thank you to our client, David Tulauskas, and our advisor, Professor Thomas Gladwin. Executive Summary 4 Introduction 6 Client GM Corporate Overview 7 Sustainability & General Motors Sustinability & the Auto Industry Green Ranking Systems 14 Competitor Trends 17 About the Project Proposal & Opportunities Scoping 26 22 Contents 11 Research GM Interviews 28 Conferences 31 Corporate Trends & Innovations Regulations & Legislative Activity Recommendations Recommendation Development Carbon Monetization 39 Sustainable Supply Chain Strategy 32 35 36 42 Supporting Statements Support...

Words: 38081 - Pages: 153

Premium Essay

Finance

...Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION INDUSTRY PROFILE BUSINESS CONSULTING  In the corporate world the wants and needs of clients are constantly changing, becoming much more complex and specialized.  These needs can often exceed workforce and workplace capabilities.  When this happens, companies and organizations hire consultants to strategize solutions to business, organizational or industry specific problems Consultants are needed to help create new jobs, expand operations, and start new facilities. In short, consultants help organizations improve their performance These solutions can involve changing a company's problem solving initiatives, altering employee training techniques, and evaluating personal performance.  Employee engagement is a key element in this field.  A company's ability to build a corporate team with strong leaders will determine a company's ability to find answers to client and market concerns. Consultants help construct these teams and train the individuals in them.  These teams and their leaders can then innovate and create new ways to find new customers and markets while keeping the existing ones happy and engaged.  The people within the company will also start to think more like business owners and producers all on behalf of a clear strategic direction with adequate capacity to succeed.   Areas of Consulting  Consulting services include IT (Information Technology) consulting, management consulting, strategy consulting and industry specific consulting.  IT consulting...

Words: 9137 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Brazil Group Project

...vehicles and advanced electric vehicle powertrain components. Currently, Tesla’s presence internationally is limited to dealerships in Europe and a minor production plant in Britain. In order to be best positioned moving forward, we recommend expanding into Latin America and Asia Pacific to better fulfill CEO Elon Musk’s primary goal to commercialize electric vehicles all the way to mass market. As we predict slow growth for the standard auto industry, we believe the electric vehicle industry is extremely attractive for several reasons, including high oil prices, less greenhouse gas emissions and government incentives. Our best estimates suggest the electric vehicle industry will have average growth rates of 35 – 40% over the next 10 years. International expansion, if done correctly, can help improve upon Tesla’s current strategic position in order to become the global leader in electric vehicles. We have determined that the optimal points of entry for the market are in Brazil and Singapore. In addition to gained access to the two fastest growing regions in the segment, the two locations are attractive for many political, economic, financial, cost, and market reasons. In Brazil, we recommend that Tesla create an office for operations, including a team for supply chain management and a team for sales. In Singapore, we included a supply chain management team, a sales team, and also recommended the opening of a global R&D hub. In addition, these locations will be responsible for managing...

Words: 12486 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

Rbv Analysis

...| Analysis Of Indian Commercial Vehicles Industry | | | Abstract | | | This project analyzes the Indian Commercial Vehicles Industry using Porter’s Five Forces Analysis framework including the competitive positioning and RBV analysis of the different players. | PROJECT TEAM GROUP – 9 S.No. | Name | Roll Number | 1 | Ashish Kumar | 1514013 | 2 | Hari Sharma | 1514017 | 3 | Pranal Dongare | 1514033 | 4 | Souveek Bose | 1514053 | 5 | Sujatha Krishnamurthy | 1514057 | 6 | Vinod Vijayakumar | 1514070 | Industry Overview Performance of commercial vehicles industry in India is one of the most important indicators as well as enablers of economic activity. Commercial vehicles account for 3% of the total domestic market for automobiles in India1. The net sales turnover for this industry in FY2014-15 was 72,264 cr. and the number of units sold was 6.15 lakh units2. The industry is segmented into Goods and Passenger vehicles with each segment further divided into LCVs (Light Commercial Vehicles) and M&HCVs (Medium and Heavy Commercial Vehicles). A detailed classification of commercial vehicles can be found in Figure 1. Figure 1: CLASSIFICATION OF commercial vehicles Source: CRISIL Research, 14-Mar-2015 report Three major domestic players, namely Tata Motors, Mahindra and Mahindra and Ashok Leyland, dominate the industry. Strong positive outlook and space for growth has enticed foreign players, such as Volvo, Daimler and Isuzu Motors, to make...

Words: 13366 - Pages: 54

Free Essay

Daimler Case

...Imprint and contact Key figures 2014 Imprint and contact. Key figures 2014. 01 Financial year 2014 Unit 2012 2013 2014 Corporate profile Revenue1 Editing and design SLau Konzepte & Kommunikation (consulting/editing) TEAMKOM Kommunikation&Design (design) Netfederation GmbH (interactive online report) Photography Bildarchiv Daimler AG, Fotolia (icons p. 18/19) Production l in millions of € 8,116 10,139 10,179 j in millions of € 6,830 8,720 7,290 l Total vehicle sales in millions 2.2 2.35 2.55 j 1,451,569 1,565,563 1,722,561 j Unit sales of Daimler Trucks 461,954 484,211 495,668 j Unit sales of Mercedes-Benz Vans 252,418 270,144 294,594 j 32,088 33,705 33,162 l in millions of € 79,986 83,538 98,967 j in millions of € 2,369 2,471 2,383 l in g CO2/km 140 134 129 l Unit sales of Mercedes-Benz Cars Unit sales of Daimler Buses Contract volume of Daimler Financial Services Product responsibility Dr. Cantz’sche Druckerei Medien GmbH (reprography) Bechtle Druck + Service GmbH und Co. KG (printing) Contact j 10,752 CO2 emissions of the European fleet (vehicles from Mercedes-Benz Cars) Mirjam Bendak 129,872 10,815 Group net income Daimler Sustainability Report 2014. Publications Manager Thomas Fröhlich 117,982 8,820 Research and development expenditure on environmental protection For the publisher Daimler AG, Mercedesstraße 137, 70327 Stuttgart, Germany 114,297 in millions of € Profit before taxes on income1...

Words: 50904 - Pages: 204

Premium Essay

Holly Farm

...Robert Johnston Stuart Chambers Christine Harland Alan Harrison Nigel Slack Cases in Operations Management third edition Cases in Operations Management We work with leading authors to develop the strongest educational materials in operations management, bringing cutting-edge thinking and best learning practice to a global market. Under a range of well-known imprints, including Financial Times Prentice Hall, we craft high quality print and electronic publications which help readers to understand and apply their content, whether studying or at work. To find out more about the complete range of our publishing, please visit us on the World Wide Web at: www.pearsoneduc.com THIRD EDITION Cases in Operations Management Robert Johnston Warwick Business School, University of Warwick Stuart Chambers Warwick Business School, University of Warwick Christine Harland School of Management, University of Bath Alan Harrison Cranfield School of Management, Cranfield University Nigel Slack Warwick Business School, University of Warwick Pearson Education Limited Edinburgh Gate Harlow Essex CM20 2JE United Kingdom and Associated Companies throughout the world Visit us on the World Wide Web at: www.pearsoned.co.uk First published 1993 Second published 1997 Third Edition 2003 © Robert Johnston, Stuart Chambers, Christine Harland, Alan Harrison and Nigel Slack 1993, 2003 The rights of Robert Johnston, Stuart Chambers, Christine Harland, Alan Harrison...

Words: 207956 - Pages: 832

Free Essay

Analyzing the Author's Purpose

...7 ANALYZING THE AUTHOR’S PURPOSE AND TECHNIQUE he writer’s overall purpose determines the techniques he or she uses. The writer’s reason for writing a particular article or book may be manipulative, as in propaganda or advertising, or may be more straightforward, as in informative writing. In either case, understanding the writer’s underlying purpose will help you interpret the context of the writing. It will also help you see why writers make the decisions they do—from the largest decisions about what information to present to the smallest details of what words to use. The chapter concludes with instructions on how to write an analysis of purpose and technique. This kind of rhetorical analysis will provide the perspective required to keep you from being pushed by words in directions you don’t want to go. T 103 104 Part 1 Writing About Reading The Writer's Purpose Insofar as people know what they are doing, they plan their actions to achieve their purposes. Someone who selects the purpose of being rich will design and carry out a set of actions, legal or illegal, to gain the desired wealth. A person who wants to gain great wisdom will design an entirely different life course. Writers, whether they want most to be wealthy or wise, have specific purposes they hope to achieve by any piece of work. If they are skilled writers—that is, in control of what they write—they design each aspect of what they are writing to achieve their purpose. Being aware of the writer's...

Words: 14135 - Pages: 57

Free Essay

Nit-Silchar B.Tech Syllabus

...Chemistry/Physics Laboratory Workshop Physical Training-I NCC/NSO/NSS L 3 3 3 1 3 0 0 0 0 13 T 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 4 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 P 0 0 0 3 0 2 3 2 2 8 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 6 0 0 8 2 C 8 6 8 5 6 2 3 0 0 38 8 8 8 8 6 2 0 0 40 8 8 6 6 6 2 2 2 40 6 6 8 2 Course No EC-1101 CS-1101 MA-1102 ME-1101 PH-1101/ CH-1101 CS-1111 EE-1111 PH-1111/ CH-1111 Course Name Semester-2 Basic Electronics Introduction to Computing Mathematics-II Engineering Mechanics Physics/Chemistry Computing Laboratory Electrical Science Laboratory Physics/Chemistry Laboratory Physical Training –II NCC/NSO/NSS Semester-4 Structural Analysis-I Hydraulics Environmental Engg-I Structural Design-I Managerial Economics Engg. Geology Laboratory Hydraulics Laboratory Physical Training-IV NCC/NSO/NSS Semester-6 Structural Design-II Structural Analysis-III Foundation Engineering Transportation Engineering-II Hydrology &Flood Control Concrete Lab Structural Engineering Lab L 3 3 3 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 15 3 3 3 3 3 0 0 0 0 15 3 3 3 3 3 0 0 T 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 P 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 2 2 6 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 2 4 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 C 6 6 8 8 8 2 2 2 0 0 42 8 8 6 8 6 2 2 0 0 40 8 8 8 6 6 2 2 MA-1201 CE- 1201 CE -1202 CE -1203 CE-1204 CE-1211 Semester-3 Mathematics-III Building Materials and...

Words: 126345 - Pages: 506

Premium Essay

Operations Management

...Class Six: Design of Work Systems and Learning Curves 7 Class Eight: Location Planning and Analysis 8 Class Nine: Management of Quality and Quality Control 9 Class Ten: Inventory Management 10 Class Eleven: JIT and Lean Operations 11 Class Twelve: Supply Chain Management 12 Conclusion 13 Tale of Things to Come I am going to take you on a whirlwind of wonder and learning all based around operations management. At least that is what I saw it as. Coming in to a class with no expectations, mainly because I have never heard of the topic, I was pleasantly surprised. Coming from a person who has hopes and dreams to own or at least run a successful company someday this class had a plethora of information that I will hopefully someday have the opportunity to use. I decided to break the class down week by week. The reason I chose to do this is partly because of the material and partly because of the teaching method. One thing I loved about the class is that as you go along you always continue to use the stuff you learned previously. When we were doing supply chain management during week 12 we were incorporating things like forecasting that we learned week 3. This was a great asset for me because it made me able to retain more information instead of learning it, applying it to a quiz, and then forgetting it. The teach style for the class had us constantly recalling information that we had previously learned to apply it to current and relevant...

Words: 5303 - Pages: 22