Free Essay

Argumentative Research Paper

In:

Submitted By hparke6
Words 2151
Pages 9
Pot, Weed and Mary Jane: Whichever Name, Keep it Illegal November 6th 2012, a date that will live in infamy for more reasons than one. While one may associate this day with the election of Barack Obama into his second term as President of the United States, weed smokers across the nation rejoiced for another reason. That very same day, a groundbreaking law was passed legalizing the recreational use of marijuana in Colorado and Washington. In the eyes of many avid smokers, this law was just as monumental as landing on the moon was for Neil Armstrong: one small step for man and one giant leap for mankind. Despite the fact that marijuana is legalized for recreational use in these two states and legalized for medicinal purposes in 16 others, the drug is still forbidden under federal law, meaning marijuana is still an illegal drug. For decades, the subject of legalization has been a recurring theme in Washington and state governments. Should marijuana join the ranks of alcohol and cigarettes and be made legal? No, we must realize the damaging health effects and the detrimental societal/cultural effects that legalizing marijuana could have on Americans in the future. Although there are some advantages to legalizing marijuana in the United States, the disadvantages tremendously outweigh any advantages when considering this touchy topic in politics. Of course, there has been research conducted that states that marijuana could be positive for the nation. Advocates to legalization suggest that if marijuana were legal, it would tremendously boost the economy, forcing drug dealers out of business. Roberto Trevino and Alan Richard explain the economic gain America would experience, stating “economists for the most part support the legalization of drugs…they argue that the legalization of dugs will lower drug prices and drive the economic rents enjoyed by drug deals to zero”(93). Running hand in hand with the economic boost, legalization of the drug could decrease crime in America. Advocate of general decriminalization of marijuana and director of government relations at the Washington D.C, - based Marijuana Policy, Steve Fox states, “If we take marijuana off the streets and regulate it, we will diminish organized crime problems.” (qtd. in Marshall). In addition to the illegal drug cartel being diminished, legalizing could authorize taxing on the substance. Commander Marc Alcantara of the San Mateo County Narcotics Task Force states that the marijuana industry makes at least $250,000 of untaxed revenue per crop, throwing out nearly 3 crops a year (qtd. in Katel 527). In addition to a potential boost in economy, advocates managed to dig out some positive health effects that marijuana may have on certain people. According to information gathered by Eric Barnes in a publication of Bioethics 2000, marijuana contains a dosage of Tetrahydrocannabinol otherwise known as THC. Barnes states, “THC is a drug that has been effective in relieving vomiting and nausea in patients being treated for cancer or AIDS”(18). This is one of the primary arguments that suggest marijuana may have positive effects that could potentially be helpful to people in pain. However, most of the nation is able-bodied and not in pain. Therefore, although pain is temporarily relieved for some, America is not in need of an illicit substance to be legalized, especially when a cure is not present in it. Instead of looking at the temporary medicinal effects of marijuana, people need to look at the long term and damaging effects marijuana has on the body. The Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) states, “marijuana can cause a variety of health problems, including cancer, respiratory problems, loss of motor skills and increased heart rate” (qtd. in Marshall 131). Furthermore, it can also make it more difficult for the immune system to combat infections, which will ultimately do more harm in people with pre-existing immune problems. Almost immediately the notion that marijuana can serve as a medicinal agent is eliminated when the facts are stated proving otherwise. In addition, marijuana causes great damage to the brain. THC, the same chemical that is said to have helpful pain relieving abilities, is found to also have detrimental qualities that interfere with the functioning of the brain. Essentially, marijuana is normally abused to alter consciousness and to to mask feelings of fear, anxiety, pain or anger. According to the Scholastic Scope, THC throws the endocannabinoid system off balance, preventing the natural chemicals in the brain from reacting properly. In doing so, the effect on the user can include: paranoia, impaired memory, hallucination, psychosis, etc. Playing and experimenting with the brain is dangerous, irreversible and irresponsible. We only get one brain in our lifetime, tainting it with marijuana isn’t a wise decision. To this day, there is still no agreement on whether marijuana is an authentic medicinal agent. The Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP) emphasizes the fact that the FDA has not permitted medical marijuana, because its medicinal value hasn’t been proved. Like any other medicine that is approved, it has to go through many clinical tests with numerous patients and intense analysis. James McDonough, opponent of legalization and director of Florida’s Office of Drug Control, disagrees with the idea that marijuana is a reputable medicine as well. He states, “until medical science determines that smoked marijuana can pass muster as medicine, we should refrain from dignifying marijuana as anything more than what it is – a harmful drug” (qtd. in Koch 707). Because it is grown from the earth, it is often misinterpreted that marijuana isn’t toxic. Yes it is from the earth, but there is nothing natural about being high and out of the element whenever one pleases. As previously discussed, marijuana is harmful to the body, and it isn’t a natural or positive contribution to the natural workings of the body. Think about it, there has to be a reason that employees have to be tested for substance abuse before receiving a job, and similarly athletes undergo random drug tests throughout their prospective seasons. If marijuana were so good for the body, there would be no reason for tests like these to occur. Besides the minimal health and economic benefits, the American society is better off without marijuana being a legal substance. People are often misguided in believing that they can smoke weed and still have a good quality of life, when in reality it will most likely be the exact opposite. Oftentimes avid smokers have no motivation to partake in anything other than smoking, thus proving that smoking is a bad influence on one’s quality of life. Devoted smokers oftentimes compare marijuana abuse to alcoholism to make their situation seem lighter. In reality, just like alcohol, marijuana puts America’s citizens under the influence. As a result, many dangerous risks such as car accidents emerge, adding to the drunk driver death rates that already cripple the American society. In addition, more people are becoming dependent on marijuana, especially adolescents. Researchers at the Department of Epidemiology at Columbia University conducted a study in 2011 testing the relationship between marijuana use, abuse and dependence. They found that “states that legalized medical marijuana had higher rates of marijuana use”(Cerdaa et al. 22). In addition, researchers have found that the numbers in adolescent dependence on marijuana are rising. “Monitoring the Future” is one of the nation’s most reliable sources when it comes to changes occurring in the legal and illegal drug use among young adults. Through their 30+ year research program, it has been found that marijuana is the most commonly used prohibited drug amongst adolescents because it “is seen as the least risky of the illicit drugs” (Bachman et al. 182). Lets examine the common fallacy that many smokers have which suggests that marijuana is not addictive. Researchers stated in the “Psychology of Addictive Behaviors” that “Marijuana dependence develops in approximately 14-17% of adolescents who ever use it and may lead to an increased risk of other illegal drug use and depressive symptoms.” (qtd. in Roffman et al. 727). These findings illustrate and emphasize that not only are young adults becoming more dependent marijuana, but also that it is an addictive gateway drug. Legalizing just opens the door, inviting the use of other harsher substances. After marijuana, will heroin and cocaine be accepted as well? Think about the children. Dr. Alain Joffe of the Committee on Substance Abuse and Dr. W Samuel Yancy of the Committee on Adolescence, explain that alcohol and tobacco are the most widely abused substances by the youth and like those two substances, “legalization of marijuana could result in advertising campaigns for its use, some of which may be directed toward adolescents” (e634). They further their claim saying that advertisements coerce adolescents into thinking that tobacco and alcohol is the “cool thing to do” and that “one can speculate that distributors of marijuana quickly would recognize the profitability of portraying marijuana in a similar manner” (e635). Furthering this claim on the effect marijuana advertisement can have on children, popular culture practically endorses smoking. Music artists brag about their smoking habits in their songs, and similarly actors are frequently getting caught in the media abusing marijuana and other drugs. Most recently, one of college football’s most prized possessions Tyrann Mathieu, has been in and out of the media, and on and off LSU’s football team because of failed drug tests. Sports franchises and college teams have a certain image to project, and a pothead player on their team doesn’t give off a positive image. Mathieu had the potential to be a Heisman winning college football player with hopes of entering the NFL, but unfortunately marijuana clouded his vision not once, but twice. Decriminalization will officially make it suitable to smoke weed, otherwise making it acceptable, and more enticing for children to try. As a result, those same children will grow up to be our future leaders, raised on the notion that smoking is not a threat. If the misconceptions that marijuana is pure and healing continue to outweigh and overpower the damaging truth, Americans are in for a rude awakening. Other countries admire America and look to emulate what we portray, but legalizing marijuana does not portray that America cares about its inhabitants. Therefore, the federal government should not legalize marijuana. Yes, the availability of marijuana could contribute to the economy, just as tobacco and alcohol continue to do, but adding another health stigma to the list will not encourage a better America for future generations. The government and law officials should continue to crack down on marijuana and drug usage and look for alternatives to the health benefits that marijuana is perceived to have. Instead of legalizing smoked cannabis and making it acceptable, the government should look into the research and production of medicine that may include the healing affects of some ingredients in the substance. There are other ways to encourage a strong economy that don’t include putting the nation’s health at risk and creating a society where it is acceptable to be under the influence whenever one pleases. Two wrongs don’t make a right, and the government must realize that before they make this big decision. The United States has made it this far without marijuana being a legal substance, and should continue to be a nation that encourages its citizens to stay above the influence.

Work Cited
Barnes, RE. "Reefer Madness: Legal & Moral Issues Surrounding The Medical Prescription Of Marijuana." Bioethics 14.1 (2000): 16-41. CINAHL Plus with Full Text. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.
Cerdaa Magdalena, et al. "Medical Marijuana Laws In 50 States: Investigating The Relationship Between State Legalization Of Medical Marijuana And Marijuana Use, Abuse And Dependence." Drug And Alcohol Dependence 120.(n.d.): 22-27. ScienceDirect. Web. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.
Bachman Jerald, et al. "Monitoring The Future: National Survey Results On Drug Use, 1975- 2007. Volume II, College Student And Adults Ages 19-45, 2007. NIH Publication No. 08-6418B." National Institute On Drug Abuse (NIDA)(2008): ERIC. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.
Joffe, AlainYancy, W. Samuel. "Legalization Of Marijuana: Potential Impact On Youth." Pediatrics 113.6 (2004): e632-e638. Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection. Web. 26 Nov. 2012.
Katel, Peter. "Legalizing Marijuana." CQ Researcher 12 June 2009: 525-48. Web. 28 Oct. 2012.
Koch, Kathy. "Medical Marijuana." CQ Researcher 20 Aug. 1999: 705-28. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.
Marshall, Patrick. "Marijuana Laws." CQ Researcher 11 Feb. 2005: 125-48. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.
Roger A. Roffman, et al. "Social Norms And Self-Efficacy Among Heavy Using Adolescent Marijuana Smokers." Psychology Of Addictive Behaviors 25.4 (2011): 727-732. PsycARTICLES. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.
"The Science Of Marijuana How The Thc Affects The Brain." Scholastic Scope 60.7 (2012): 22. Primary Search. Web. 26 Nov. 2012.
Trevino, Roberto A., and Alan J. Richard. "Attitudes Towards Drug Legalization Among Drug Users." American Journal Of Drug & Alcohol Abuse 28.1 (2002): 91. SPORTDiscus with Full Text. Web. 17 Oct. 2012.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

An Argumentative Research Paper on Research Topic: What Is Science?

...PERU E. M COLLINS COMMUNICATIONS SKILLS TERM PAPER ARGUEMENTATION STUDENT ID NO: D33/34238/2010 AN ARGUMENTATIVE RESEARCH PAPER ON RESEARCH TOPIC: WHAT IS SCIENCE? TOPIC: Dispelling Misconceptions; Physical and Natural Sciences are not superior over Social Sciences. TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract. 3 Introduction 4 Recommendations 22 REFERENCES 25 Abstract. Science in general is a great and highly developed human enterprise. Its intricacies are clearly not limited to the scientists alone, but it is essential for the entire human race. If we think of science as a space within the larger space of society then it is at the interfaces between these two spaces that human beings are involved with science. To see this interface clearly from the space of science is not the same as seeing it as a mere collection of facts that should be construed to be true and nothing but the truth. Science is beyond facts, ideals and thoughts. It is a process and a model that has undergone tests, been tried, reviewed and accepted as a true representation of the processes and occurrences in the natural world However, due to the broad nature of science, and the work, time and resources involved in pursuit of knowledge in different science fields which entails different interests, and thereby different values too; and the different...

Words: 9230 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Argumentative Essay On Galen Research Paper

...his message. On the Death Star, Krennic ordered a low-powered test shot which destroyed Jedha's capital. Galen in his message directed Jyn to the Imperial databank on planet Scarif where the Death Star schematics lied there. Before the message was about to end, the transmission was interrupted by the blow from the Death Star. Jyn kneeled and tears dropped from her eyes. Jyn realized her father's sacrifices. From that on, Jyn threw off her selfishness to contribute to the galaxy. Jyn and her group took Rook and fled the moon, but Gerrera remained to die with the city. Grand Moff Tarkin congratulated Krennic before using Rook's defection and security leak as a pretext to take control of the project. Rook lead the group to Galen's Imperial research facility on the planet Eadu. Because of bad weather stormed the planet and the crews had to fly low to keep undetected by the Imperials, their ship crashed. Fortunately, all the crews were safe but the incident triggered the Alliance to send backups on killing Galen Erso. At that time, Cassian chose not to kill Galen. In just a blink, Jyn made her presence to her father before Rebel bombers attack the facility. Galen was wounded and died in her daughter's arms, before she escaped with her group on board a stolen Imperial cargo shuttle. Krennic was summoned by Darth Vader, a dark lord commanding behind the Empire government to answer for the attack on Eadu. Krennic seeked his support for an audience with the emperor of the Galactic Empire...

Words: 1605 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Argumentative Term Paper

...How to Write an Argumentative Term Paper Brannon L. Hollis, Jr. MGT 521 September 13, 2012 Norma Sutton Writer’s block seems to haunt me every time one decides to write. One muse did not start to fully erupt until 5:21 last Thursday morning when I thought this paper was due to be submitted, yet as a newbie to the college homework cycle, I discovered that our learning team was on time with all team-related assignment. On the personal side, not so much – behind on one week’s assignment submission, I digress. Making an argument or taking an argumentative stance in writing requires on to build and case for or against something or some topic like baking a cake. In a step-by-step process depending upon how complex so simple one species is elected to be. This paper will explore these topics as follows: * How writers begin the process of writing an argumentative paper * The type of papers to take an argumentative stance * How all these elements come together to make an argument persuasive As a student, one can be challenged to find the note. According (Writing the Research Essay, 2012), taking notes is an essential part of the paper building process is advised in this section of the chapter that we could do one or more the subsequent when starting the process of writing an argumentative paper. (Writing the Research Essay, 2012, pp393,405-406) states that if one seeks to take notes in the following organizational styles: Taking notes by Source: Whatever on has...

Words: 961 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Syllabus

...Özgür Parlak | LAN 217 | 06 515 2684 | oparlak@aus.edu | Office Hours: * Office Hours will be posted on the office door as well as on iLearn. | H | Course Description from Catalog | Builds on the reading and writing skills acquired in WRI 101. Strengthens students’ reasoning skills and understanding of the various rhetorical strategies available to them in the writing process as they produce competently organized argumentative essays. Requires students to practice ethical, basic integration and documentation of sources. Hones students’ linguistic proficiency. | I | Course Learning Outcomes | Upon completion of WRI 102, the students will be able to 1. demonstrate the ability to write a structured and logical critical analysis of an academic text 2. demonstrate the ability to write lucid and cogent prose in a fully developed, audience conscious, academic argumentative essay (approximately 3-5 pages) that demonstrates logical development and arrangement of arguments, counterarguments and refutations 3. compose an audience conscious, academic argumentative essay (approximately 5-6 pages) that incorporates synthesis of multiple sources 4. demonstrate knowledge of library technology by using key words and data bases to find pertinent sources for integration into essays 5. locate,...

Words: 2113 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Some Unions Feel That the Organization Does Not Compensate Its Members Fairly, or That the Organizational Working Conditions Are Less Than Desirable. Conversely, Some Employers Feel That Unions Interfere with Management

...assignment, go to this week's Argumentative Paper link in the left navigation: Argumentative Paper An Argumentative Paper is due in Week Five. Below is a list of potential topics. Please see “Graded Writing Assignment Notices” in your Discussion Forum. This set of topics and the topics on the grading forum have all been tested over time and can be successfully argued from different perspectives. Thus you need to choose a topic where you can see at least two points of view and present both points. You will have your own opinion and need to present that in Part III of your argument. If you feel so strongly about a topic that you cannot see another point of view, avoid writing about it. Suggested Topics * Should abortions be legal? * Are Affirmative Action laws fair? * Should America have stronger Gun Control laws? * Should assisted suicide be legal? * Are charter schools/vouchers detrimental to the American educational system? * Should the death penalty be abolished? * Should homosexuals be allowed to legally marry? * Should homosexuals be allowed to be Christian ministers/pastors? * Should animals be used in medical research? * Is global warming a genuine threat to the planet earth? * Should human cloning be legal? * Should embryonic stem cell research be federally funded? Select one of the above issues and construct a six-to eight-page argument in which you use the following format. Your paper will have three parts: Thesis...

Words: 695 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Sociology

...Essay Three: Research-based Argument, Chapter Six Overview: The word research fills some with dread, and to be asked to write a research paper is an insurmountable task that affords only some relief when it is over. But research doesn’t have to cause such anxiety. Exploring multiple topics and choosing one that piques your curiosity will help you write this essay. Considering this assignment an opportunity to become an expert on a topic that you find fascinating will make your research and writing much more enjoyable. After you’ve explored a number of topics and written your first draft, you should arrive at a claim about your topic (thesis), conduct your research, back up your claim with reasons (points), state the grounds on which you base your reasons (evidence from sources), and rebut opposing viewpoints. Purpose: The purpose of this essay is to write an effective research-based argumentative essay. In writing your argumentative essay, you will learn how to correctly summarize, paraphrase, and quote various sources and to correctly document your sources in MLA format. Audience: Your audience consists of those who hold opposing viewpoints. As you sketch out your argument and conduct your research, you should think carefully about your hypothetical readers and compose an audience statement in which you describe those readers in detail (what is their position? what is their educational level? gender? class? geographic location? what hobbies/interests do they have? what is their...

Words: 482 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pit Bulls Argument Essay

...For my first artifact, I wrote an argumentative research paper over the myths associated with Pit Bulls a breed-specific legislation. This essay’s intended audience is adults who live in communities where breed-specific legislation is either in effect or in areas where they are thinking about instating it. The purpose of this artifact was to disprove the myths associated with the Pit Bull and breed-specific legislation, through the presentation of scientific evidence and expert testimonials. In order to persuade this particular audience the paper needs to contain numerous facts and statistics from various credible sources, like peer-reviewed journals, in order to persuade them into accepting facts rather than the popular myths associated with this topic. In order to create a successful argumentative research paper one must follow several rules and expectations. For example, in the introduction of the paper, the author must give the thesis, research question, or overall purpose of the paper so that the audience knows what to expect from the rest of the paper, as well as providing context and...

Words: 974 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Essay On Racial Profiling

...I have chosen three essays; Racial Profiling Argumentative Paper, Bullying Research Paper, Brave New World Literary Analysis and three pieces of process work; annotated articles, peer editing, and evidence charts, as the basis for my personal evaluation. From this work, I will reflect on what I learned about create a claim or thesis, find evidence to support my claim, write topic sentences, write relevant commentary or analysis, create a first draft that I have developed, and my strengths; MLA, evidence. I will address my academic essays, create works cited skill that I have learned, grammar and commentary where I need to improve, and I want to improve on write a relevant commentary or analysis and integrate quotes...

Words: 549 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Personal Narrative: What I Learned In The Writing Process

...During this course I have learned there is in fact a great deal of work required, in writing. Throughout my lifetime, I have been required to write numerous essays and papers for various subjects, all requiring different styles and techniques. Before immersing myself in the writing process I would try and think of whom I am writing to and what I am writing about. I always assumed I was writing for the audience of my teacher. Writing an argumentative research paper is something I had yet to accomplish in my college career, not only was it thought provoking, this paper also challenged me in numerous ways, such as, understanding who I should be directing my thoughts towards throughout the essay, as well as the simple steps of organizing my thoughts...

Words: 795 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Yep This Is It

...About Us Samples FAQ Our Prices Order now Writers Contact Us We write: Essays Research Papers Coursework Thesis Dissertations Term Papers UK Essays # Count of pages: Number of words: Choose your academic level: Term: Discount Code (optional): Discount: 0% Price: $0 Official PayPal Seal website security Types of Essays A big problem that most students and new essay writers run into is “How to write an essay.” usually roughly all essays follow a common structure of writing which comprises of an introduction, the body, and the conclusion. Once the writers are lucid about the technique of writing an essay and how to write an essay outline, the next step that they face up to is how to move toward a particular research paper topic. And what type of writing works best? Students often complain about a certain type of essay they have been assigned with. It seems to them that writing within essay type boundaries doesn’t allow them to think out the box, limits their potential. But writing a paper without any directions could be even more confusing than the class assignment you got. Do not think about the limitations as of the prison walls, but as of the walls in your room where you feel free to paint murals or change nothing whatsoever, simply being in control of it, being yourself. Tweet Quick Navigation through the Types of Essays Page Basic Types: Narrative, Descriptive and Persuasive How Can We Help Personal...

Words: 2955 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

English 102 Class Reflection

...Another key element that has helped to illustrate the writing process for the two essays in my portfolio was the use of reading various types of literature. This included but was not limited to, editorials, newspaper articles, books, and specific disciplines of research in course related fields. These two essays essentially reshaped my ability to write for specific audiences...

Words: 660 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Final Summary: Why I Hate This Class

...Final Summary At the beginning of the year, I expected to hate this class. I have never enjoyed writing whatsoever. But now that I’m looking back, I surprisingly liked this class. My writing skills greatly improved over the year. For example, on our first paper, the Educational History Narrative, Paper Rater gave me a 73. With every paper I wrote I improved point by point. On the last paper we wrote, the Argumentative Research paper, Paper rater gave me a 92. With my scores improving, the difficulty to write my papers decreased. The most challenging paper was the Ad Analysis paper. For my analysis, I chose PAM cooking spray. Looking back on it, this probably wasn’t a great idea. The ad campaign I chose only had two short one minute commercials....

Words: 385 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Imagining

...!1 ENGLISH 1130 - 006: Academic Writing Douglas College (New Westminster Campus), South Building, Room 2690B Summer 2014 stephensonr@douglascollege.ca Phone: 604-527-5611 (Local 5611) Office: 2635, New Westminster Campus ! INSTRUCTOR: Dr. Ryan Stephenson Class Hours: Friday, 10:30 - 12:20 Office Hours: Friday, 9:30 - 10:20 Course Prerequisites: A minimum score on the Douglas College writing assessment, or equivalent, as listed in the College calendar. ! Courses for which this Course is a Prerequisite: In combination with another 1100-level English, with any CRWR course, or with English 1200, this course is a prerequisite for any 2300level English course. ! A Note on Hybrid Learning: ! ! You are enrolled in a hybrid section of ENGL 1130. Only 50% of your instructional time is delivered in class, with the remaining 50% delivered online. This means that you are expected to spend an average of 2 hours per week on the assigned Online Learning Modules. This time is over and above any time spent on readings and assignments. Hybrid learning is not for everyone. If you are not self-motivated and not able to keep yourself on track without a great deal of guidance, or if you do not feel comfortable using Blackboard or sending and receiving email attachments, then you should strongly consider taking a different section of this course. I will assume basic internet/online/computer competency. Technical difficulties should not prevent you from completing your work...

Words: 2484 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Reasining

...theargumentativetheoryofreasoning The argumentative theory of reasoningBack to projects. Current philosophy and psychology are dominated by what can be called a classical, or ‘Cartesian’ view of reasoning. Even though this view goes back at least to some classical Greek philosophers, its most famous exposition is probably in Descartes. Put plainly, it’s the idea that the role of reasoning is to critically examine our beliefs so as to discard wrong-headed ones and thus create more reliable beliefs—knowledge. This knowledge is in turn supposed to help us make better decisions. This view is hard to reconcile with a wealth of evidence amassed by modern psychology. Tversky and Kahneman (and many others) have demonstrated the failures of reasoning in decision making. Johnson-Laird and Evans (and, again, many others) have shown how fallible reasoning can be. Others have shown that sometimes reasoning too much can make us worse off: it can unduly increase self-confidence, allow us to maintain erroneous beliefs, create distorted, polarized beliefs and enable us to violate our own moral intuitions by finding handy excuses. Sperber claimed that the full import of these results has not been properly gauged since most people still seem to agree, or at least fail to question, the classical, Cartesian assumptions. The theory Dan Sperber suggested—the argumentative theory of reasoning—proposes that instead of having a purely individual function, reasoning has a social and, more specifically, argumentative function. The...

Words: 2312 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

None

...Rubric for Research Paper | 5-6 points | 3-4 points | 1-2 points | Purpose | The paper has a well-developed argumentative thesis. The introduction establishes the issue(s) at stake and the conclusion indicates what will change as a result of this argument. | The paper has an undeveloped or under-developed thesis, or lacks an introduction or conclusion that adequately communicates the consequences of the argument. | The paper lacks an argumentative thesis, or the thesis does not accurately convey what the paper develops. | Content | The paper demonstrates excellent development of each idea and focuses on relevant details. Clearly explained examples support the claims and the topic is thoroughly researched. | The paper contains adequate evidence to support its claims but will benefit from more research or development OR lacks sufficient evidence or a clear sense of purpose. | The paper needs more details on every level (main ideas, related ideas, specific ideas). | Audience | Author is attentive to the values of intended audience (fellow undergraduate students and professor). Author defends beliefs and handles counter-arguments with respect. | The paper contains words/examples likely to appeal to a specific audience, but could benefit from more effective handling of counter-arguments OR relies on beliefs that the audience might not share. | The paper does not appear to have a specific audience in mind or is disrespectful to its intended audience either by failing to...

Words: 389 - Pages: 2