...You are an audit senior in an accounting firm and you asked the audit partner about the 'audit expectation gap’. The audit partner provided his opinion on the issue as follows: There is a so called 'audit expectation gap', and it is associated with unreasonable expectations of users. They want all fraud found, and a guarantee that the company will continue forever. This is quite unreasonable and not what the audit is designed to do! Perhaps we could do more on these issues, but it would be more work, cost more, and I doubt whether the companies would be prepared to pay anyway. Discuss the views of the audit partner. The partner’s suggestion for the audit expectation gap is too narrow. I do not agree with his opinion. As the audit expectation was introduced by Liggio (1974), he claimed the audit expectation gap has the differences of expected performance between the user of a financial statement and the independent accountant (Tack &Azham, 2009). In 1978, Cohen Commission defined whether the audit expectation may exist in the public expects, the auditors should expect to achieve(Tack &Azham, 2009). So in 1970s, the audit expectation gap forward the different from financial statement user believe an audit provides and an audit actually do provide. It as a support for audit perceived credibility of audit function (Robyn, 2011). Auditing is difficult service in which to observe actual quality because all that is produced for user is a homogeneous report. From a user...
Words: 721 - Pages: 3
...BUSINESS & ACCOUNTING Towards Reducing the Audit Expectation Gap Possible Mission? Teck Heang Lee, Dr. Azham Md. Ali & Shamini Kandasamy 18 ACCOUNTANTS TODAY • February 2008 Towards Reducing the Audit Expectation Gap: Possible Mission? The auditing profession believes that the increase in litigation and criticism against auditors may be due to the audit expectation gap. The audit expectation gap is defined as the difference between what the public expects from an audit and what the audit profession accepts the audit objective to be. The audit expectation gap is critical to the auditing profession because the greater the unfulfilled expectations of the public, the lower the credibility, earning potential and prestige associated with the work of auditors. The objective of this paper is to review and evaluate some of the possible solutions that can be taken to narrow the gap. The study found the proposed solutions in the literature are unlikely to be implemented in view of the practical issues identified. Hence, the proposed solutions are only likely to be effective on theoretical grounds. It is hoped that this paper will provide some insights into proposed solutions which will enable the audit expectation gap to be reduced in a comprehensive and effective manner. E xternal auditing plays an important role in contributing to the effectiveness and efficient functioning of business operations, the capital markets, and the economy by adding...
Words: 3811 - Pages: 16
...“The Expectation Gap” By: Kiara Holmes ACC 371 Intermediate Accounting I Instructor: Lin Zheng Writing Assignment 1 9/5/2012 The auditor’s role in fraud detection has had a long history of confusion and controversy. Despite increasing professional guidance, which has focused more attention on auditor responsibility to detect fraud, there’s still considerable uncertainty about where the auditor’s responsibility ends towards detecting fraud. This uncertainty leads to “The Expectation Gap”. Lee, Ali & Bien (2009) defined the expectation gap as, “The difference between what the public expects from an audit and what the audit profession accepts the audit objective to be.” Accounting profession argues that one cause of the expectation gap is the public’s failure to appreciate the nature and limitations of an audit. “People expect more of an audit than it can give in practical terms, such as detecting all instances of fraud.” (Frank, Lowe & Smith 2001). The phrase “Expectations Gap” was first coined when the AICPA put the Cohen Commission together in 1974 to investigate whether the expectations gap existed. Since then, events ranging from the collapse of Enron and World Com to the ongoing savings and loan problems seemed to have made the gap become more and more evident. Porter analyses the total expectations gap into three separate components. Those components are: sub-standard performance (16%), deficient standards (50%) and unreasonable expectations (34%). Sub-standard...
Words: 902 - Pages: 4
...they own stock in an auditee; as I have just inherited a 3% shareholding in bluebird, the quality of the audit may be lacking as a financial self interest may be obtained by me, for example excluding some pieces of vital information from the audit to serve my own financial interests. Another kind of threat, known as Self-review may be brought about. These are threats that emerge from inspectors inspecting their own particular work or the work done by others in their firm. It might be harder to assess without predisposition one's own particular work, or that of one's firm, than the work of another person or of some other firm. As the auditor has a 3% shareholding in bluebird, a self-review threat may arise if I was to review judgements and decisions I, or others within the firm, have made. Familiarity (or trust) threats are threats that emerge from auditors being impacted by a close association with an auditee. Such a risk is available when auditors are not adequately suspicious of an auditee's declarations and, therefore, too promptly acknowledge an auditee's perspective as a result of their commonality with or confide in the auditee. For instance, this threat may emerge when an auditor has an especially close or long-standing individual or expert association with an auditee. Bluebird limited is one of the firms audit clients and has been for 7 years and with me being the audit...
Words: 2616 - Pages: 11
...the use of technical language. For example, from the independent auditors’ report in the annual report of SP Setia Berhad 2012, it was mentioned that the audit was carried according to approved auditing standards in Malaysia. However, it does not clarify which standards are being applied during the course of auditing. The misinterpretation arose from the use of technical language also lead to an expectation gap in the nature and responsibilities of the independent auditors and the public’s expectation of them (Enyi, Ifurueze and Enyi, 2012). Again, example can be obtained in the annual report of SP Setia Berhad 2012. In the independent auditors’ report, it was stated that the auditors perform the audit to get “reasonable assurance” that the financial statements do not contain material misstatement. However, the word “reasonable assurance” may hold different meanings for different individuals. By utilising these words in a report, people will have different perception of the work of the independent auditors compared to the actual responsibilities of the auditors during an audit. There are three main causes to the occurrence of the expectation gap which are auditor’s performance, audit environment and users of financial statements (Mohammed Al-Alimi and Katdare, 2013). In the auditor’s performance cause, the expectation gap exists due to the auditor’s deficient...
Words: 1258 - Pages: 6
...continuously being change, dependent on the scale of interconnection among the audit profession and the public (Flint, 1988; Power, 1997; Sikka et al., 1998). From one viewpoint, the audit profession seeks to certify that auditing is viewed as important to the changing needs of the public through the progression of the audit function. Flint (1988), Power (1994; 2000), Epstein and Geiger (1994) and Petland (2000), for instance, maintain that, this development was in effect to a professed need of the society who look for information or assurance about the behavior of others. Researchers such as Fogarty et al. (1991), Sikka (1992; 2002), Humphrey et al. (1993),...
Words: 771 - Pages: 4
...AUDITORS IN FRAUD DETECTION, PREVENTION AND REPORTING IN NIGERIA" (2010). Library Philosophy and Practice (e-journal). Paper 517. http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/517 THE ROLE OF AUDITORS IN FRAUD DETECTION, PREVENTION AND REPORTING IN NIGERIA OYINLOLA OLUWAGBEMIGA oluwagbemiga@in.com Tai Solarin University of Education, Ijagun , Ijebu-ode Ogun State. Abstract This study investigates the role of auditors in the detection, prevention and reporting of fraud. Data were obtained from 184 respondents in Nigeria. The findings revealed that the respondents are very concerned about the problem of fraud. In addition, the respondents placed very high expectation on auditors’ duties on fraud prevention and detection. This perception is in contrast with the stated primary objective of an audit, as stipulated in ISA 200, which merely required auditors to form an opinion on the financial statements, but not of fraud detection. Keywords: Auditors, fraud, detection, prevention Introduction That an auditor has the responsibility for the prevention, detection and reporting of fraud, other illegal acts and errors is one of the most controversial issues in auditing, and has been one of the most frequently debated areas amongst auditors, politicians, media, regulators and the public (Gay et al...
Words: 3964 - Pages: 16
...Expanded audit report Empirical studies have been conducted in the US, the UK and Australia to examine whether using an expanded audit report is effective in reducing an audit expectation gap. A survey conducted by Nair and Rittenberg (1987) in the USA revealed that an expanded audit report changes the users’ perceptions with regard to the responsibilities of the auditors. Likewise, Gay and Schelluch (1993) found that audit reports based on the revised Statement of Auditing AUP3 (i.e. an expanded audit report) in Australia significantly improved users’ perceptions of the purpose of an audit, the audit procedures, as well as the responsibilities of the directors for the financial report. A similar study on the revised AUP3 conducted by Monroe and Woodliff (1994) confirmed the previous findings of Gay and Schelluch (1993). Over-all, the Australian findings are generally similar to the previous studies in the USA (Kelly and Mohrweis, 1989; Miller at al., 1990) and the UK (Hatherly et al., 1991) that longform audit reports improve and clarify users’ perceptions of the auditor’s roles and responsibilities in the financial reporting process. The above studies provide evidence that an expanded audit report can be used as a way to reduce the audit expectation gap. This is because it provides a better understanding of the nature, scope and extent of an audit; as well as the roles and responsibilities of the auditors and the management. Structured audit...
Words: 682 - Pages: 3
...INTERNATIONAL APRIL/MAY 2010 ACCOUNTANT FEATURES INCLUDE Issue 52 Banking & Finance Risk & Compliance International Financial Reporting Standards Global outlook Banking & Finance Feature Is corporate governance a modern fantasy? Andrew Higson discusses the reality of financial reporting and asks if corporate governance still has a role to play in the modern business world. W hat is the difference between the collapse of Enron and the recent collapse of the banking sector? Well, the obvious answer is that Enron’s demise was not as significant. Yet, in the wake of Enron’s collapse, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act was rushed into law in the USA in order to cure the perceived corporate ills of, and give back credibility to, corporate America. Organisations around the world have since spent thousands of hours becoming Sarbanes-Oxley compliant in order to be able to continue trading with companies in the USA. At the centre of Sarbanes-Oxley was its focus on strengthening corporate governance procedures to prevent fraud and mismanagement – but the chaos in the banking sector must raise a question over the success of Sarbanes-Oxley and, more significantly, over the whole idea of corporate governance. way in which an organisation is run and the way in which its results are presented to the outside world. So where does this leave the non-executive directors? One of the main elements in the recent development of corporate governance has been the growth in the...
Words: 1559 - Pages: 7
...are two main issues affecting the usefulness of auditor reporting which are “expectations gap” and the “information gap”. Thus, possible options for change are necessary to diminish the “information gap” and improve the communicative value of the auditor’s report. Besides key users and other parties, IAASB is considering possible options to make audited financial statements of smaller entities useful and welcomes any additional suggestions of other options for not being addressed issues. Additional and relevant information about entities...
Words: 755 - Pages: 4
...the demand for audits, and then surveys current challenges and issues such as the audit and regulatory environment and the expectation gap. You will also study issues related to the economics of auditing and their impact on auditor motivation and standard-setting; in the process, you will consider different perspectives on protecting the public interest and the public accountant’s role in helping to advance the profession. The various topics integrate information sources related to research in the field and readings from the Ethics Readings Handbook (ERH) , drawing on concepts from your prerequisite accounting theory course. In AU2 , you will study a wide variety of technical, practical, and theoretical material. This module lays the foundation for exploring some of the more difficult areas of professional judgment you will encounter as you progress through the course. When faced with issues that challenge your professional judgment, you are encouraged to think back to the concepts studied in this module to help frame your decision making. Please be sure that you have purchased the CPA Canada Handbook, CGA Student Edition mentioned in the course introduction, as it is required for AU2 . You are responsible for reading the paragraphs from the CPA Canada Handbook as referenced in the course module notes. The expectation of a professional is to be able to research material using the CPA Canada Handbook and to interpret it at a level in keeping with the expectations of an Advanced...
Words: 14959 - Pages: 60
...the demand for audits, and then surveys current challenges and issues such as the audit and regulatory environment and the expectation gap. You will also study issues related to the economics of auditing and their impact on auditor motivation and standard-setting; in the process, you will consider different perspectives on protecting the public interest and the public accountant’s role in helping to advance the profession. The various topics integrate information sources related to research in the field and readings from the Ethics Readings Handbook (ERH) , drawing on concepts from your prerequisite accounting theory course. In AU2 , you will study a wide variety of technical, practical, and theoretical material. This module lays the foundation for exploring some of the more difficult areas of professional judgment you will encounter as you progress through the course. When faced with issues that challenge your professional judgment, you are encouraged to think back to the concepts studied in this module to help frame your decision making. Please be sure that you have purchased the CPA Canada Handbook, CGA Student Edition mentioned in the course introduction, as it is required for AU2 . You are responsible for reading the paragraphs from the CPA Canada Handbook as referenced in the course module notes. The expectation of a professional is to be able to research material using the CPA Canada Handbook and to interpret it at a level in keeping with the expectations of an Advanced...
Words: 15035 - Pages: 61
...Chapter 3 Audit Reports Key objectives: 1. Describe the parts of the standard unqualified audit report for non-public entities under AICPA auditing standards. 2. Specify the conditions required to issue the standard unqualified audit report. 3. Understand reporting on financial statements and internal control over financial reporting required under PCAOB auditing standards. 4. Describe the five circumstances when an unqualified report with an emphasis-of-matter explanatory paragraph or modified wording is appropriate. 5. Identify the types of audit reports that can be issued when an unqualified opinion is not justified. 6. Explain how materiality affects audit reporting decisions. 7. Know the key terms that identify different audit reports. 8. Determine the appropriate audit report for a given audit situation. 1. Purpose of audit report • Communicates auditor's work and conclusions reached. • It's the auditor's product, and the only visible outcome of the audit process. 2. Short-form report (unqualified or "clean" opinion) A. When appropriate 1. All 4 statements and appropriate disclosure (An opinion can be issued on less than a full set of financial statements - see Ch. 24). GAAS specifically provides that in the case of omission of the cash flows statement, a qualified opinion is issued. 3. Auditor has gathered sufficient appropriate evidence in accordance with GAAS ...
Words: 2397 - Pages: 10
...Chapter 3 Audit Reports Key objectives: 1. Describe the parts of the standard unqualified audit report for non-public entities under AICPA auditing standards. 2. Specify the conditions required to issue the standard unqualified audit report. 3. Understand reporting on financial statements and internal control over financial reporting required under PCAOB auditing standards. 4. Describe the five circumstances when an unqualified report with an emphasis-of-matter explanatory paragraph or modified wording is appropriate. 5. Identify the types of audit reports that can be issued when an unqualified opinion is not justified. 6. Explain how materiality affects audit reporting decisions. 7. Know the key terms that identify different audit reports. 8. Determine the appropriate audit report for a given audit situation. 1. Purpose of audit report • Communicates auditor's work and conclusions reached. • It's the auditor's product, and the only visible outcome of the audit process. 2. Short-form report (unqualified or "clean" opinion) A. When appropriate 1. All 4 statements and appropriate disclosure (An opinion can be issued on less than a full set of financial statements - see Ch. 24). GAAS specifically provides that in the case of omission of the cash flows statement, a qualified opinion is issued. 3. Auditor has gathered sufficient appropriate evidence in accordance with GAAS 4. Statements in accordance...
Words: 2398 - Pages: 10
...corporate governance' (Company Law Review Steering Committee, 2001: para. 8.1). To understand the ®nancial statements, one needs to appreciate the auditors' work and opinion, and, conversely, to understand the auditors' work and opinion, it is necessary to appreciate the scope and limitations of the ®nancial statements. All too often, ®nancial reporting and external auditing are treated and discussed in isolation despite being inextricably linked. However, the ®nal ®gures in the ®nancial statements may come about as a result of negotiations between management and their auditors ± with the auditors examining the reasonableness of management's justi®cations for their representations. Indeed, the modern audit with its emphasis on high-level business risks could almost be viewed as the `audit of motivations' ± to understand the ®gures in the ®nancial statements, it is important to understand management's motivations. Financial reporting and auditing are not just technical subjects, but they...
Words: 6204 - Pages: 25