Free Essay

Bio and Socio Medical

In:

Submitted By janetfiona
Words 682
Pages 3
Biomedical and Socio medical model of health
Biomedical and Socio medical model of health

The main purpose of the biomedical model of health is to cure diseases in which health professionals will use scientifically tested methods to address a diagnosed illness. The biomedical model of health focuses on purely biological factors, and excludes psychological, environmental, and social influences. This model relates to the functionalist approach of health as it specifies that health is the absences of disease and it’s regarded as dysfunctional for the society as individuals cannot make a positive contribution to the running of society. According to the perspective of Marxists, he argued that doctors encourage the production rate of the society by explaining health as the potential to work, he also disseminated that "working is better than idleness"(Waitzkin, 1989).It was emphasized that the health professionals are blamed of medicalization if they consider the societal influence of patient and if they ignore, the accusation still holds (Nettleton, 1995).
On the other hand, the socio medical model focuses on the social factors that contribute to health and wellbeing in our society. From analysing the functionalist theory it shows that the socio medical model would explain and discuss the high rates of ill health and the short life expectancy among those who are poor relating to the inequalities in society and life circumstances of those whom may be disadvantaged. Secondly, Relating to the Marxist critique of the bio-medical model as it is a direct consequence of capitalism that a class that is more at risk to contract illness through sue to the cause of economic status. Some sociology theorists may believe that the medical profession is under the educated upper classes who are interested in keeping the lower class content while using the workforce for growth and economy.

Strengths of the biomedical model of health * Diagnoses the cause of ill health through the methods of observations, examinations and tests. * Focuses on the physical processes of bio chemistry, pathology and the physiology of the illness. * Illness is a temporary state that can be changed by the intervention of medical skill. * Does not address the social and psychological factors that contribute to good health. * Is criticised for being technology centred and expensive. * In the 21st Century the model remains powerful in Western medicine.

Weaknesses of the Biomedical model * Assumptions of generic disease however symptoms treated like disease * If individuals take upon a sick role one must be exempt from social responsibilities. * Refers to the abnormal changes in the body’s structure or the functioning as a disease * Only medical professionals have the expertise to identify and diagnose the illness. * Little regard is paid to environmental and social factors that may have led to ill health
Strengths of the socio medical model * Understands and considers the patients experiences. Government recommends topics of improving mental health. *
Recognises the effectiveness of the promotion of health via polices and legislations. * Introduced the treatment for mental health problems

* Omits the dimension of power so as to avoid inequality in health. * Believes that health can be improving the social conditions as it can affect health of some particular groups.

Weaknesses of the socio medical model * Failure to fully discuss the psychosocial factors which have proven to be powerful factors of disease in the modern society. * It can be time consuming in studying the factors affecting illness and lack of prevention methods. * It’s been a success in diagnosing and treating several diseases in centuries. * Does not assess the causes of ill health genetically or research in depth. * Is not satisfactory in the understanding of the development of policies of the disability and the disadvantaged.

In regards to the case study it can be argued that the children have permanent colds in winter due to the socio medical factors. Meaning it can be a result of them living in poverty causing them to have colds. Tamsela’s father suffers from Bronchitis which can be down to the environment he lives in which is poor. Tamsela’s mother has developed depression this can be a result to the social and environmental factors.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Health Care

...diet. In addition, these factors can lead to ill heath, which can result in the increase of death rate and infant mortality. Rogers and Pilgrim emphasise the correlation between the two models as it can be demonstrated unequivocally that social stress is in correlation with the social class. Relating to the Marxist critique of the bio-medical model as it is a direct consequence of capitalism that a class that is more at risk to contract illness through sue to the cause of economic status. Some sociology theorists may believe that the medical profession is under the educated upper classes who are interested in keeping the lower class content while using the workforce for growth and economy. In conclusion both of these models have some strengths and weaknesses, for example the bio medical model of health tries to ensure there is an absence of ill health and the socio medical models tries to focus on the environment and social factors in order to prevent ill health. However, the bio medical only focuses on the individual and it ignores the environment, which might be a contributing factor towards the individual?s illness. In addition the socio medical model of health does not assess the causes of ill health genetically or research in depth. Moreover, both of these models on there are own are very weak, but together they work really well as they would both be looking at the individual holistically. In addition the models can be seen as two complementary approaches to the study of...

Words: 272 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Sociology

...P2 Explain different sociological approaches to health and ill health There are different approaches to health and ill health in sociology, and these include Functionalism, Marxism, Feminism and Interactionism. The World Health Organisation (WHO) in 1974 defines positive health as a state of complete physical mental, social, spiritual and well-being not merely the absence of disease. The holistic approach is based on addressing the individual’s physical, social, emotional and spiritual health needs. The functionalist approach to health and ill health In the functionalist model, Parsons argued that illness is a form of deviance that disturbs the social function of a society; within the functionalist approach to health it studies the relationship between a sick individual and the society as a whole. Parsons stated that for the society to function efficiently the members of the society must be free from illness and must be of well health. Functionalists argued that stability and cooperation are very crucial for a society to function efficiently; functionalists explain that through the process of socialisation we learn our society’s general norms, values and social roles. An example of this is, saying “thank you or please” these are some of the values that are treasured within societies, and an example of a social role would be a grandmother fulfilling the role as a grandmother. For the grandmother to fulfil her role, the individual has to look after the grandchildren so...

Words: 2558 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Social Determinant Of Health

...A higher socio-economic status results in access to better access to healthy food, alternative medicine options such as massage and counselling to deal with the psychological difficulties of the illness narrative and even the ability to travel and park at treatment facilities. Because women, Aboriginal people and Black Canadians all have a higher likelihood of living in poverty, this makes the social determinant of health not only the socio-economic standing but also one of gender and race. Hankivsky & Christoffersen (2008) identify that intersectionality has great potential to provide new knowledge that can more effectively guide actions toward eliminating health disparities across race and ethnicity but also across gender, sexual orientation, social class and socioeconomic status, and other critical dimensions of social...

Words: 882 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Comparison of Community Psychology and Public Health

...A COMPARISON OF COMMUNITY PSYCHOLOGY AND PUBLIC HEALTH. In this assignment the key differences and similarities of community psychology and the public health approach will be examined and critically compared. Community Psychology is a branch of psychology which is concerned primarily with achieving positive mental health in the broader context of the community rather than the individual. Public health is primarily concerned and focused on changing behaviours within the context of the public in order to lower the incidence of disease and lower the workload placed on professional medical practitioners. Community psychology is a relatively new field as far as the behaviour sciences go and was only established as a solution to the capitalistic and individualistic approach psychology had become after the Second World War. It does not stand as a unique and recognised field at the moment as there is little research and theories available in order to support further development. It is for this reason that when faced with challenges community psychology often reverts back to methods of individual psychotherapy. This damages the ultimate process and outcomes the initiatives. Community psychology also criticises conventional psychology for being elitist and only catering to the wealthy portion of the community as well as ignoring the low income groups who require the services. Community psychology strives to create equality to all social groups and therefore can often seem over...

Words: 1191 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Health & Social Care

...value the diversity within a society. The functionalist approach to health is identified through the relationship shared between an individual who is sick and the whole of society. Talcott Parsons strongly believed that for a society to run smoothly all individuals must be free of ill health and that ‘medicine serves the wellbeing of society as a whole’. Individuals in which believe the functionalist perspective believe that having a sick role in society is classed as an act of deviance and that they should exempt from the average rights. This means that if an individual is to obtain ill health they are not obligated to procced in completing the average day to day tasks within the family role. However, they are obliged to co-operate with medical professionals to gain full health. Additionally to this, critics of the functionalist perspective believe that groups of society...

Words: 3181 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Diabetes and Age Health and Social Care Level 3

...is estimated that five million people will have diabetes in the UK” (Diabetes UK). During my research I found statistics that showed the prevalence of diabetes in the UK. (The table below created by me using data from Diabetes.org). Age | Men | Women | 16 – 34 years | 1.8% | 2.1% | 75+ years | 15.9% | 13.2% | Age | Percentage of Type 1 | Percentage of Type 2 | Percentage of other | 0 – 4 years | 4% | 0% | 9.7% | 10 – 14 years | 42.5% | 39.1% | 35.6% | The Bio-medical model believes that “illness occurs naturally and independently of social behaviour or social influence” (Rasheed, E., Heatherington, A., Irvine, J. 2010.). This model focuses on science and reason over religion and superstitions their view on diabetes would be that, the individual regardless age should seek profession medical help were they can be diagnosed with the disease, when diagnosed the individual will receive medical advice on illness, medication and surgeries. Marxist view on health and ill health links in with the Bio-medical model as they also believe that medicine is the leading contribution to maintaining a healthy workforce. Marxist would say that individuals who have diabetes should receive medication from the doctor to...

Words: 1491 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Nursing Intervention Program

... 7. A time schedule suitable for nurses was developed to conduct the program that included; date, place, topic, time and duration of each session. Intervention program designed for this study has been implemented through 15 sessions. These sessions have lasted for 30 hours (10) hours of theory and 20 hours of practice). These sessions were conducted for each M.C.H separately all nurses for every M.C.H and a copy of the intervention program contents was given to each nurse. Nurses participated in the intervention program. 8. Implementation phase beginning by assess the staff nurses' knowledge of health care waste management before starting the intervention program topics include definition, sources, important, of waste, segregation of bio medical waste…. ect ,using the teaching strategies in the program were discussion, paper, data show, pen and paper, handouts. The teaching course included 2 parts: The first part was theoretical part which included 5 lectures, 2 hours for each. It was given within 11days. The second part was practical part; this part was implemented within 10 days for each MCH center covered Wash hand, antiseptic hand, personal protective devices like gloves, mask and segregation infectious procedures related to precautions and application...

Words: 1285 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Health and Illness

...Sociology Health and Illness The medical definition of health is: the state of being whole and free from physical and mental disease or pain, so that all the parts of the body carry on their proper function". This is a negative definition where health is defined as to be free from pain and discomfort. (Critchley, 1978, p.784). The World Health Organisation (WHO) definition of health (1947), states that “Health is a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity”. This is a positive definition which defines health as being fit and able to undertake reasonable task. The criticisms are that the definition deals with “a state rather than a process” and puts no boundaries on what is considered as ‘health’. (Macionis J. et al 2012 p. 741) The conditions recognised as illnesses differ quite significantly from one society to another. Illness is thought to be any obvious departure from a sickness that is subject to medical treatment. There is difference of opinion in most people mind between who think they are ill or and those who are really ill. In modern society doctors have the role of deciding who is truly ill. If the doctor decides that a person is ill then a series of benefits will follow either formal or informal. Formal help is where the doctor will give medical help such as treatment or time off work or college. Whereas informal help is like giving sympathy or release the ill person from household duties...

Words: 1885 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Bio-Medical Model

...John Germov (2009) in ‘Imagining health problems as social issues’ talks about the social origins of health and illness, emergence of bio-medical and social model of health and limitations of bio-medical model which has been explained as follows: The emergence of the biomedical model In 1878, Louis Pasteur (1822–96) was the first person who came up with the idea of ‘germ theory of disease’. This theory stressed the role of germs as the causative agents for the development of disease in the human beings. Robert Koch (1843–1910) refined the idea of germ theory and came up with a term ‘Specific Aaetiology’ (meaning specific cause of disease) in which he stated that every disease is caused by a specific kind of bacteria. The central idea was that...

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Biomedical Waste Management Case Study

...Table. Status of Biomedical Waste Management in India Year 2012 2011 2010 2009* Total no. of HCF (approx.) 159838 151535 13994 129511 Total no. of Beds (approx.) 1612600 1491147 1420563 1368839 Total no. CBWTF / private (operational) 190 179 188 168 No. of HCF utilizing CBWTF / Private 121279 112199 98764 95410 Total quantity of BMW generated (kg/day) (approx.) 416039 415194 354992 405702 Total quantity of BMW treated (kg/day) (approx.) 379509 377876 301993 291983 No. of HCFs violated BMW rules 12990 5472 6653 13037 Total no. notices/ directions issued to HCFs 11583 3585 5829 14898 *Information does not include Sikkim Source: Annual Report – Information on Bio-medical waste management in the country (Submitted by SPCBs/PCCs for the years...

Words: 951 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Case Study

...Purification Group Mary May pushed the door to her office thinking about her plan to enrol her daughter for a medical degree at a private university. The private university is the only institution of higher learning that her daughter can apply for, considering her high school results. Mary sat down at her table and a smile came to her lips. Her financial situation will definitely improve after the company, Bio-Organics, announce this year’s bonuses. Project ORG7 she was working on is already in the completion stage and as a project manager, she was sure Project ORG7 will bring in the targeted profits. With that in mind, Mary pulled open a file marked ORG7 from her drawer. The file was submitted by her secretary yesterday, just before Mary left the office. Mary’s smile abruptly left her face when the latest cost sheet was staring at her from the file. Clearly written in the cost sheet was an amount of RM2,000,000 for R&D expenditure related to Project ORG7. A year ago, Mary has approved R&D expenditure of RM5,000,000 for Project ORG7 and the final RM2,000,000 was only recently incurred. Mary quickly scanned Project ORG7 cost documents and disappointedly realised the RM2,000,000 will reduce Project ORG7’s profits to a negative! BIO-ORGANICS The company was founded in 1988 and had obtained the largest market share in the large-scale provision of clean water. Bio-Organics had developed membrane-based and other advanced technology systems for municipal and industrial markets...

Words: 1581 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Delima

...Purification Group Mary May pushed the door to her office thinking about her plan to enrol her daughter for a medical degree at a private university. The private university is the only institution of higher learning that her daughter can apply for, considering her high school results. Mary sat down at her table and a smile came to her lips. Her financial situation will definitely improve after the company, Bio-Organics, announce this year’s bonuses. Project ORG7 she was working on is already in the completion stage and as a project manager, she was sure Project ORG7 will bring in the targeted profits. With that in mind, Mary pulled open a file marked ORG7 from her drawer. The file was submitted by her secretary yesterday, just before Mary left the office. Mary’s smile abruptly left her face when the latest cost sheet was staring at her from the file. Clearly written in the cost sheet was an amount of RM2,000,000 for R&D expenditure related to Project ORG7. A year ago, Mary has approved R&D expenditure of RM5,000,000 for Project ORG7 and the final RM2,000,000 was only recently incurred. Mary quickly scanned Project ORG7 cost documents and disappointedly realised the RM2,000,000 will reduce Project ORG7’s profits to a negative! BIO-ORGANICS The company was founded in 1988 and had obtained the largest market share in the large-scale provision of clean water. Bio-Organics had developed membrane-based and other advanced technology systems for municipal and industrial markets...

Words: 1694 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Comparing Community and Public Health

...Terre Blanche, Martin Apr 21 Dear Yasmin Not a problem – an extension is fine. Please just try not to go more than a week or two past the deadline and please put a note at the start of your assignment saying I said it is fine. We won't penalise you for late submission. Best of luck with your family responsibilities and heavy workload this year! Kind regards Martin Yasmin Moosagie 44670540 UNISA Pyc4811 Assignment 1: Unique no: 805932 Yasmin Moosagie 44670540 UNISA Pyc4811 Assignment 1: Unique no: 805932 2016 2016 Write an essay in which you critically compare and contrast the community psychology and public health approaches to social problems. At first glance, there seems to be a fine line between community psychology and the public health approach, however on further examination it is more than semantics that separate these two principles. Both, community psychology and the public health approach, started as a result of the frustration of main stream psychology not being able to address broader social issues. The realisation that psychology needed to focus a great deal more on community and social change in order to address mental health and illness. Although community psychology and the public health approach seem to share the same intrinsic values, the focus of community psychology seems to be more aimed at the cultural and political aspect of social behaviour and outcomes, whereas the public health is focused more on health and prevention...

Words: 957 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Tissue Bioprinting

...Interestingly, printing of meat for human consumption as an alternative to harvesting meat from animals is currently being researched. In 2008 PeTA offered a $1 million X-Prize style reward for the first group to synthetically develop such commercially viable meat. This is one case in which proposing ethical dilemmas exist, and the many alternative controversies this topic entails. Further bioethical dilemma’s and considerations exist and will be discussed in detail. Technology To fully understand any ethical dilemmas encapsulating this technology, a considerate knowledge of 3-dimmensional printing is required. First, we will look into the general technology of designing, preparing and yielding products. Only then, applications of bio-printing, and the corresponding controversies and ethical dilemmas can further be discussed....

Words: 3171 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Climate Change

...Annex 14 Center for International Forest Research Southern Africa Regional Office Lusaka, Zambia Report Climate Change in Zambia: Opportunities for Adaptation and Mitigation through Africa Bio-Carbon Initiative By Samuel Mulenga Bwalya Peaks Environmental Management Consultants P.O Box 32632 Lusaka, Zambia January, 2010 Table of Contents Contents Page Table of Contents................................................................................................................. i List of Tables ...................................................................................................................... ii List of acronyms ................................................................................................................ iii Acknowledgements............................................................Error! Bookmark not defined. Executive Summary ............................................................................................................ v 1. Introduction................................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Objectives of the study........................................................................................ 1 1.2 Approaches and methodology............................................................................. 2 2. Climate variability and impacts .................................................................................. 2 2.1 Climate...

Words: 15235 - Pages: 61