Premium Essay

Capital Structure Recommendation

In:

Submitted By maura83
Words 1822
Pages 8
Capital Structure Recommendation
There are a number of capital structure options available to provide funding for a Canadian expansion. Capital structure strategy should have two main objectives: align with operating strategy and maximize total shareholder returns. Too much debt leverage can lead to credit default and insolvency. Capital financing using bonds has risks because some types of bonds may place responsibility on the company to provide dividends, which could impact shareholder earnings.
Capital structure is how operations and growth are financed. Different sources may be used; a combination of long term debt, short term debt, equity and preferred debt. Proper capital structure planning should strengthen the balance sheet, and increase the ability to face loss and change.
Based on this strategy, review and analysis of the options presented, the approach of 50% preferred and 50% common stock is recommended. This approach maximizes Earnings Per Share, EPS, or shareholder return. The chart below details the results of using the Canadian Budgeted Earnings, moderate forecast, and calculating a 5 year average Earnings Before Interest and Tax, EBIT, of $112,581. By plugging $112,581 into the Capital Structure Analysis, we see the 50/50 approach maximizes EPS, as detailed in the chart below. The Alternative Capital Resources and EPS chart below presents each option and the expected EPS. For financing using only bonds, the EPS is .045, using 20% bonds EPS is .052, using 40% bonds, EPS is .051 and using 60% bonds, EPS is .049. By using 50/50 stock, the EPS is .054, which is the highest EPS.

9% bonds only 50% preferred stock and 50% common stock 20% in 9% bonds and common stock 40% in 9% bonds and common stock 60% in 9% bonds and common stock
0.045 0.054 0.052 0.051 0.049

The 50/50 choice is the best alternative to strengthen Competition

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Nike

...13/3/2013 Nike, Inc. Cost of Capital 1 Discussion Questions • What is the WACC and why is it important to estimate a firm’s cost of capital? What does it represent? Is the WACC set by investors or by managers? • Do you agree with Joanna Cohen’s WACC calculation? Why or why not? If you do not agree with Cohen’s analysis, calculate your own WACC for Nike and be prepared to justify your assumptions. What mistakes did Joanna Cohen make in her analysis? Which method is best for calculating the cost of equity? • Calculate the costs of equity using CAPM, the dividend discount model, and the earnings capitalization ratio. What are the advantages and disadvantages of each method? • What should Kimi Ford recommend regarding an investment in Nike? 2 1 13/3/2013 Background • Kimi Ford needs to decide on investing in Nike, Inc. • To do so, Kimi Ford needs to derive fair value of Nike stock to compare with current market share price • Kimi Ford tasked Cohen to compute Nike’s Cost of Capital 3 Scope 1. Review of Cohen’s Analysis 2. Nike’s Cost of Equity 3. Valuation Methods and Selection a. Market Approach b. Income Approach 4. Choice of Valuation Method 5. Risk Assessment a. Sensitivity Analysis b. Scenario Analysis 6. Investment Recommendation 4 2 13/3/2013 Cohen’s Analysis Issues Opinion Single or Multiple Cost of Capital Appropriate to use Single Cost of Capital as business segments in Nike subject to...

Words: 1203 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Canvas

...decisions. Two case examples in Australia are presented to illustrate how two former investment bankers have used the FRICTO framework to help clients make financing decisions that take into account flexibility, risk, income, control, timing and other considerations. They have found the analytical framework prompts decision-makers to consider other important issues beyond risk and the effect on earnings per share that reflect a company’s unique and often complicated circumstances. INTRODUCTION Modigliani and Miller (1958) advanced the proposition that based upon several simplifying assumptions, capital structure has no effect on the value of a firm. However, recognizing the impact of taxes, bankruptcy, agency costs, and asymmetric information, capital structure theory has evolved to acknowledge that the use of debt does affect the value of a firm. Modern theories of capital structure can be classified into two categories: “static tradeoff models” and the “pecking order hypothesis.” Static tradeoff models imply an optimal debtequity mix which is determined by a tradeoff between the benefits and costs of debt (i.e., balancing the tax advantages of debt against the risk of bankruptcy and agency costs). The pecking order hypothesis implies a hierarchy in raising funds, in which the firm prefers internal to external financing and, if it obtains external funds, debt to equity. This empirically motivated hypothesis, which has been theoretically justified on the basis of asymmetric information...

Words: 5229 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Case Bed, Bath & Beyond

...Bed Bath & Beyond “The Capital Structure Decision” Advanced Corporate Finance Everaars, Tim 6160492 Groenenberg, Erik 6178944 Kruitwagen, Max 6359744 Veldkamp, Max 6270581 1. What is wrong with building up cash? Provide (at least two) reasons in favor and against keeping cash in the firm. You need a cash reserve for bad economic times. If business is not going very well, you’re making losses, you need some reserves to absorb these losses. If you haven’t built up any cash you won’t be able to absorb these losses and in the worst case you can go bankrupt. When one of your customers or a company you delivered to can’t pay their bill there is a possibility you get short on cash. To be able to still purchase equipment and pay your own bills you need a cash reserve to absorb this loss without going bankrupt. When you have cash you can invest when an opportunity comes by. This can be a favourable thing or a bad thing. When decision making is hasted or a decision is made to invest in a bad investment it is not favourable. You pay tax twice over the cash you build up. The first time you pay tax is when you report it as income. The second time is when it is on your bank account because you pay tax every year over your company’s value. Shareholders also don’t like excess cash because the cash can be used to invest and make a profit, or can be used to repurchase shares, both leading to...

Words: 1501 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Select One

...University of South Carolina Moore School of Business FINA 761 (800): Advanced Corporate Finance Fall 2013 Instructor: Eric Powers |Class time: |T/TH 2:50 – 5:35 | |Location: |364 | |Office Hours: |TBD | |Office Hour Location: |BA 462 | |E-mail: |epowers@moore.sc.edu | |Course website: |blackboard.sc.edu | The objective of this course is deepen your understanding of the many issues faced by firms as they identify valuable investment opportunities, raise funds for those investment opportunities, distribute profits to share-holders and debt-holders and deal with the consequences of both good and bad investment financing decisions. We will expand on the concepts that you have learned in FINA 760 or in DMSB 715. Class time will be divided between lectures and case studies. My lectures will briefly review concepts from prior courses. The bulk of my lectures will present advanced material that will be new to you. It is assumed that you understand the concepts from your earlier finance and accounting courses. If not, it is your responsibility to review. In order to reduce your note-taking, my lecture notes will be available...

Words: 2338 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Printicomm

... Current Financial issues in raising capital Ralph Norwood has just recently been appointed treasurer of Polaroid. Faced with notes outstanding of $150 million which will mature in less than a year, as well as the restructuring plan of the new CEO which needs funding, Norwood decided to present a larger review of the company’s financial policies to the board of directors. Based on the circumstances, there are several challenging objectives which the new financial policy of Norwood would have to meet: 1. Serving the maturing debt 2. Maintaining an investment grade rating 3. Provide funding for the new plans of the CEO 4. Attaining an optimal capital structure for the firm Financing alternatives As for any firm, Polaroid has three possible sources of capital available: internal funds, equity markets and the debt market. Internal funds Internal funds are the cheapest form of capital and easily available. This would keep the existing capital structure intact while generating requisite funds. The flipside of such a measure is that it may hamper growth. Polaroid’s operating income has been steadily declining whilst operating expenses have been rising. Sales growth has been poor during. All of this indicates a lack of generation of funds internally. Therefore, the company will have to look for external sources. Equity capital The next option for Polaroid is to raise capital through the equity markets. This source of capital is expensive for the firm in the current...

Words: 1446 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Capital Structure

...Vol. 2 No. 19 [Special Issue - October 2011] Perceived Relationship between Corporate Capital Structure and Firm Value in Nigeria Semiu Babatunde ADEYEMI Department of Accounting University of Lagos Lagos, Nigeria Collins Sankay OBOH Department of Accounting University of Lagos Lagos, Nigeria Abstract This study examined the empirical effects of corporate capital structure (financial leverage) on the market value of a selection of firms listed on the Nigerian Stock Exchange. Both primary and secondary data were obtained for analysis employing both descriptive and inferential statistics for analysis. A sample size of 150 respondents and 90 firms were selected for both primary data and secondary data respectively. Descriptive statistics was used to analyse the primary data, while Chi-Square was used to draw inference of perceived relationship between capital structure and firm value. The results of the study suggested that a positively significant relationship exists between a firm’s choice of capital structure and its market value in Nigeria. The study suggested that listed firms in Nigeria should strategically plan and manage their capital structure in order to maximize their market values. Keywords: Capital structure, market value, Nigeria, debt, equity. 1. Introduction 1.1 Background to the Study After the Modigliani-Miller (1958 and 1963) paradigms on firms’ capital structure and their market values, there have been considerable debates, both in theoretical and empirical...

Words: 7951 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Analyze the Performance of Metcash and Woolworths

...and average industry. Our estimation will show that both Metcash and Woolworth are undervalued and suitable for investment 1. Overview : Metcash Limited(MTS) and Woolworths Limited(WOW) 3 1.1 Metcash Limited 3 1.2 Woolworths Limited 3 2. Metcash DCF valuation within FCFF approach 4 2.1 Weighted average cost of capital 4 2.1.1 Cost of equity 4 2.1.2 Cost of debt 4 2.1.3 Capital structure analysis 5 2.1.4 Effective tax rate analysis 5 2.2Estimation of FCFF 6 2.2.1 Growth rate expectation 6 2.2.2 FCFF and present value 6 3. Woolworths Limited DCF valuation within FCFF approach 7 3.1 Weighted average cost of capital 7 3.1.1 Cost of equity 7 3.1.2 Cost of debt 8 3.1.3 Capital structure analysis 8 3.1.4 Effective tax rate analysis 9 3.2 Estimation of FCFF 10 3.2.1 Growth rate expectation 10 3.2.2 FCFF and present value 10 4. Relative Valuation 11 4.1 Price Earnings Model (P/E Ratio) 11 4.2 Price to Sales Model (P/S Ratio) 13 4.3 Enterprise Value to EBITDA Multiple 14 5. Summery and recommendation 15 6. Reference list 17 1. Overview : Metcash Limited(MTS) and Woolworths Limited(WOW) 1.1 Metcash Limited Metcash Limited...

Words: 2467 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Allianz Evaluation

...* Contents 1. Executive Summary 3 2. Analysis Model 3 3. Company Overview 3 4. Industry Outlook 3 5. Company Evaluation 4 Free Cash Flow Estimation 4 Cost of Equity, Cost of Debt, WACC Calculation 5 Discounted Cash Flows and Company Evaluation 5 6. Sensitivity Analysis 6 7. Final Recommendations 6 8. Appendix 7 Appendix 1: Historical Free Cash Flow Analysis 7 Appendix 2: Historical Free Cash Flow Analysis 8 Appendix 3: Growth Estimations 9 Appendix 4: 2012 Operating Expense Growth Estimation 10 Appendix 5: Income Taxes 11 Appendix 6 11 Working Capital, Depreciation and Amortization, Capital Expenditure Estimation 11 Appendix 6 Part II: Estimations Summary 12 Appendix 7: Free Cash Flow Estimation Analysis (in mln. €) 13 Appendix 8: WACC Calculation 14 Appendix 9: Equity Evaluation 16 Appendix 10: Sensitivity Analysis 17 9. References 18 Executive Summary This report discusses the possible profitability of investment in shares of the Allianz Group SE. Our analysis, based on discounted cash flows and weighted average cost of capital, suggests that under the assumption of stable economic growth, no drastic escalation of the European sovereign debt crisis and industry shocks due to natural disaster like the hurricane Sandy, the current share price of the company is currently below its estimated value and thus a promising investment opportunity. If the company manages to keep its stable growth in the last quarter of the year...

Words: 3580 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

American Chemical

...20%. We will evaluate the acquisition of the Collinsville by Dixon at the proposed price. Table 1 identifies the assumptions that have been used for the evaluation of this acquisition. Table 1 Assumptions Laminate Technology reduces power by a mean of 17.5% Laminate Technology is depreciated over 10 years Sodium Chlorate price growth is 8%, per annum Power cost (per KWH) growth is 12%, per annum Plant Life is 10 years Plant Salvage Value is zero EBIT is flat after 1984 Capital Expenditures: $600,000 per annum after 1984 Net Working Capital Remains flat after 1984 Definition of “Flat” Reference Pg 3, HBS 9-280-102 Pg 3, HBS 9-280-102 Pg 4, HBS 9-280-102 Pg 4, HBS 9-280-102 Pg 1, Assessed work Sheet Pg 1, Assessed work Sheet Pg 1, Assessed work Sheet Pg 1, Assessed work Sheet Pg 1, Assessed work Sheet Pg 4 http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/wp06218.pdf 6.5% is the Equity Risk Premium Tax rate is 48.69% From 1984 to 1989, the following growth rates are used 4 year Growth rate is used for Variable Costs Capital investment is based on figures from 1980-1984 PPE and depreciation is based on figures from 1980-1984 Beta Debt is zero Debt to Equity Ratio: 35% : 65% Plant: Valuation starts in 1980 Laminate Tech valuation starts in...

Words: 2360 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Determinants of Bank Capital Structure

...Mekelle University College of Business and Economics Department of Accounting and Finance THE DETERMINANTS OF CAPITAL STRUCTURE Evidence from Commercial Banks in Ethiopia By K i b ro m M e h a ri F i s s e h a Reg.No.-CBE/PR0025/01 Research Project Submitted to the Department of Accounting and Finance, College of Business and Economics, Mekelle University, for the partial fulfillment of the degree of Master of Finance and Investment Under the Guidance of Aregawi Gebremichael (Ph.D. Candidate) Assistant Professor May, 2010 Mekelle, Ethiopia i THE DETERMINANTS OF CAPITAL STRUCTURE Evidence from Commercial Banks in Ethiopia By Kibrom Mehari Fisseha Reg. No. CBE/PR0025/01 ii DECLARATION I, Kibrom Mehari Fisseha, hereby declare that the project work entitled “The Determinants of Capital Structure: Evidence from Commercial Banks in Ethiopia” submitted by me for the award of the degree of Master of Science in Finance and Investment of Mekelle University, is original work and it hasn’t been presented for the award of any other Degree, Diploma, Fellowship or other similar titles of any other university or institution. Place: Mekelle Signature: Date: May, 2010 ………………….. KIBROM MEHARI FISSEHA iii CERTIFICATION I certify that the project work entitled “The Determinants of Capital Structure” is a bona-fide work of Mr. Kibrom Mehari who carried out the research under my guidance. Certified further, that to the best of my...

Words: 26591 - Pages: 107

Premium Essay

Capital Budgeting

...Office: 636 TNRB Christian Hsieh Phone: 422-3017 Office: 324 TNRB Office Hours: MW 2:00 - 3:00 p.m. Phone: 422-6835 e-mail: Office hours: forthcoming Home page: Course Description and Objectives This course introduces basic financial concepts all business managers should understand regardless of functional specialization. Topics include financial analysis and planning, time value of money, valuation, capital budgeting, risk/return trade-offs, cost of capital, and capital structure. The pedagogical approach used is a mixture of lectures and case examples. Cases are often used as a vehicle for discussing the complexities of real-world financial problems. To benefit most from this method of teaching, you will want to come prepared to discuss the cases in detail. By the end of the semester, students should be able to: (1) describe essential characteristics of the finance profession and institutions, (2) be conversant in basic financial jargon, (3) value paper assets (stocks and bonds) and tangible assets (capital budgeting) using the tools of time value of money, including NPV and IRR, (4) explain the various sources of financing, their associated costs, and their advantages and disadvantages, (5) calculate and use financial statements and ratios to analyze a business and create and use pro forma statements for planning and decision-making purposes, (6) appreciate the complexities international business, and (7) demonstrate team skills by actively...

Words: 2362 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Du Pont Case Study

...Summary & Recommendations: Given Du Pont’s financial history and current position, we recommend that they forego a low debt capital structure for a 40% target debt ratio and attempt to cut their dividend. In the period of 1965-1981, Du Pont had undergone drastic change in their capital structure policy. Increases in industry capacity surpassed demand growth, driving prices down. Along with inflation’s effect on required capital spending, the oil shock driving up costs, a recessionary environment for the industry, and the vertical acquisition of Conoco, Du Pont’s capital structure was near unrecognizable by the end of the transitionary period. Du Pont’s debt ratio stood at 42%, up from less than 20% and eventually led to a downgrading of the firm’s credit rating to AA. Due to Conoco’s performance after the acquisition, the firm was in a troubled situation. Du Pont sold a part of Conoco’s assets dropping its debt ratio to 36%; Despite questionable financial ratios and poor earnings in ’82, Du Pont maintained its AA rating. Key Issues • The pecking order theory postulates that maintaining a 40% debt level would be ideal over the target 25% debt scenario. Reducing the debt ratio would require large issuing of equity, a source of capital that is more expensive than debt. Additionally, Du Pont’s diversified business units provide extra protection from the added-on risk of debt • Du Pont’s shares are undervalued due to investor conceptions from previous financial performance...

Words: 357 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Teachings Note California Pizza Kitchen

...aversion to debt, CPK management is considering a debt-financed stock buyback program. The case is intended to provide an introduction to the Modigliani-Miller capital structure irrelevance propositions and the concept of debt tax shields. With the background of a pizza company, the case provides an engaging context to discuss the “pizza graphs” that are commonly used in corporate finance curriculum to illustrate the wealth effects of capital structure decisions. The case serves to motivate the following teaching objectives: • Introduce the Modigliani-Miller intuition of capital structure irrelevance; • Establish how the cost of equity is affected by capital structure decisions by defining financial risk and introducing the levered-beta capital asset pricing model (CAPM) equation; • Discuss interest tax deductibility and the valuation tax shields; • Explore the importance of debt capacity in a growing business. Suggestion for Advance Assignment to Students Students may consider the following study questions: 1. In what ways can Susan Collyns facilitate the success of CPK? 2. Using the scenarios in case Exhibit 9, what role does leverage play in affecting the return on equity (ROE) for CPK? What about the cost of capital? In assessing the effect of leverage on the cost of capital, you may assume that a firm’s CAPM beta can be modeled in the following manner: βL = βU[1 + (1 − T)D/E], where βU is the firm’s beta without leverage, T is...

Words: 2393 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Business Management

...What is the capital structure of your business? Discuss the ratios that are used to describe capital structure and assess their importance. * How can you use operating leverage in your business? * · Assess the level of financial and operating risk for your business * · What factors are likely to influence your CFO's debt policy? You often hear corporate officers, professional investors, and analysts discuss a company's capital structure. You may not know what a capital structure is or why you should even concern yourself with it, but the concept is extremely important because it can influence not only the return a company earns for its shareholders, but whether or not a firm survives in a recession or depression. Sit back, relax, and prepare to learn everything you ever wanted to know about your investments and the capital structure of the companies in your portfolio! Most corporate financing decisions in practice reduce to a choice between debt and equity. The finance manager wishing to fund a new project, but reluctant to cut dividends or to make a rights issue, which leads to the decision of borrowing options. The issue with regards to shareholder objectives being met by the management in making financing decisions has come to become a major issue of recent times. This relates to understanding the concept of the agency problem. It deals with the separation of ownership and control of an organisation within a financial context. The financial manager can raise...

Words: 1363 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Case of Northern Forest Products

...US E RE VI PR EW O P ON E R LY T Y ± N OF OT C E NG FO A R GE SA LE LEA OR R N CL ING AS SR O Northern Forest Products OM Case 90 Cost of Capital Directed FO R Northern Forest Products (NFP) was established in the 1800s to log timber in the Great North Woods. In response to changing conditions, the company underwent radical changes in the way it operates and currently it is a large multidivisional corporation. The major focus of the company remains managing over one million acres of timber production and overseeing the manufacture of consumer paper products from pulp derived from its land holdings. Over the years the company has diversified into several other related businesses, such as a moderately sized mill that produces paneling and wood flooring. This operation has developed a consistent outlet for all of its output and therefore is stable. The company is also involved in real estate as a result of developing some of the prime lake front properties from its forestlands for residential and private recreational use. Successful property development during the 1970s resulted in expanded real estate holdings. However, residential development was particularly hard hit during a recent economic downturn, and the company struggles in this area. NFP is aware of the increasing international demand for wood products and is concerned about recent environmental pressures concerning logging. The company believes that diversification strengthens...

Words: 3896 - Pages: 16