Premium Essay

Civil War Guatemala

Submitted By
Words 1176
Pages 5
As a matter of scholarship, civil wars lack the extensive breadth and volume of study that interstate conflict enjoys in international relations. This is especially surprising considering the remarkable longevity and death toll associated with intrastate wars. The Republic of Guatemala, a post-colonial representative democracy, is the most populous Central American country; incidentally, this nation of sixteen and a half million people have been wrought with the military and socio-political disputes provoked by the ethnic and socio-economic status of its citizens. The resulting civil war had been one of the most deadly and enduring military contests on the American continent. The fighting between the government and rebel groups lasted over …show more content…
Barbara Walter applies James Fearon’s bargaining theory to intrastate conflict. The information asymmetries and commitment problems present in interstate wars are even more pronounced in intrastate war (Walter 2009:244); accordingly, the new Guatemalan government lacked information about the military and economic capacity of the rebels and was uncertain about the peasant’s resolve. Neither side had sufficient knowledge about the capability or willpower of the other; therefore, the rebels lacked information about the true capacity of the military government, the resolve of the different heads of state, or the willingness of the United States to sustain monetary support for an unstable regime, As the military initiated several campaigns of one-sided violence against its citizens, the commitment problems of the Republic would have been heightened for rebel groups considering negotiations. In that climate, opposition groups would be even more inclined to suppress or distort their private information to evade reprisal. Land ownership may have also been a source of indivisibility for both sides of the conflict. The state’s revenue stream was agriculturally based; thus, it would have been disinclined to relinquish or redistribute any private land, territory or other properties that it controlled. In summation, the …show more content…
Huntington, author of The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order (2006) would use an identity-based argument to explain the inordinate length of the Guatemalan Civil War. Western colonization had created multiple civilizations in the same geographic space. The rebel leftists were mostly from native tribes that were indigenous to the land. Altogether, the tribesmen spoke 27 native tongues, 22 of which were Mayan. They worshiped traditional gods, and when the became oppressed by the west, the people summarily embraced the Marxist Leninist ideologies of communist Soviet Union. The military aligned with the existing power structure, the Criollos (upper-class and ethnically of Spanish descent) and Ladinos (middle-class mixed-blood Mestizos) that had wealth, spoke a homogenous tongue, Spanish, and partnered with the United States. The civil war could essentially be framed as a clash of civilizations: US vs. USSR, capitalism vs. communism, Caucasian vs. Mayan, each of the identity-affiliated elements compounds the complexity and duration of the combat; comparatively, Stuart Kauffman’s identity-based hypothesis highlights security dilemmas and the influence of “symbolic politics”. He ascribes the continued escalation of military conflict to three preconditions: “(1) a mythology justifying hostility between or among ethnic groups; (2) fears on the part of one or more ethnic groups that their existence is threatened; and (3) political opportunities to

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Civil War In Guatemala

...The Civil War in Guatemala that ran throughout the Cold War Era had very devastating effects on the country and its citizens. With military conflict’s continuously being the case in the nation, and counter insurgencies to attempt to overthrow the government, nobody seemed safe in Guatemala. It was obvious that this conflict needed to end, and eventually, the United States backed coup and the Guatemalan government came to an agreement known as the Guatemalan Peace Accords. Although these accords attempted to bring peace to the nation, problems ensued as agreements were not fully met, and fighting continued through the Seven year negotiations. The reasons for these peace negotiations were obvious; to conclude the civil war and create a better...

Words: 301 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Montt's Pentecostal Rhetorical Analysis

...From 1982-1983, President Efrain Ríos Montt executed one of the most brutal, scorched earth campaigns in modern Latin American history. Cultivating support not only among Guatemalan elites, but from transnational Evangelical networks and the Reagan administration, the dictator’s tenure is widely regarded as the most dangerous time in the protracted 35-year civil war. While a plethora of historians have studied the extent of the violence during Ríos Montt’s reign – the pressing question in the historiography is how Ríos Montt’s professed Pentecostal piety played a role in his administration. Among the myriad academics who have examined this question, David Stoll, Lauren Turek, and Patricia Harms illuminate the relationship between Ríos Montt’s...

Words: 1249 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Social Characteristics of Poverty, Illiteracy and the Civil War in El Salvador

...| Social characteristics of Poverty, Illiteracy and the Civil War in El Salvador: | EL Salvador | | BY: Yvette Rodriguez | | While El Salvador is the smallest nation in Latin America, it has been plagued with a myriad of issues that affect many third world countries. The social issues stem from a long history of violence and government mandated reforms. Civil unrest for decades led to a twelve year civil war, this being the most defining issue in El Salvador’s history. The affects of the war are still present today, such as high poverty rates, illiteracy, high crime rates, and public health concerns. Michael Ring, director of U.S. El Salvador Sister Cities is quoted saying; Since the January 1992 signing of the historic United Nations-sponsored Peace Accords, El Salvador has experienced a series of dramatic changes-some contributing to peace and development, other’s threatening the lives of El Salvador’s majority. The sociological perspective of El Salvador is formed by these effects, as that they are still prevalent today. Conflict and revolution are significant factors in shaping a national consciousness in third world countries; consequently the consciousness of the people of El Salvador is still divided. Externally, the large group of migration to the United States in the last two decades has added to the sometime rocky relationship between the U.S. and El Salvador. Aid from the United States influences current practices in the struggling nation and have...

Words: 2533 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Aviation Law

...the high seas, but never over territorial sea of another state -Art.1 1944 Chicago Convention on International Civil Aviation: “every state has complete and exclusive sovereignty over the space above its territory” -It is a serious breach of international law for a state to order to violate the air space of another state (for e.g. USA military aircraft attacked, forced to land or shot down by Hungary, USSR, Czechoslovakia-a number of incidents) -Does the states have an unlimited right to attack intruding aircraft in all circumstances? -Lissitzyn principle (from 1953)-important (book!) -Some states support Lissitzyn principle and that flexible approach to civil aircraft as well as military craft, but other states including ICAO-International Civil Aviation Organization, believe that civil aircraft must never be attacked in such circumstances -The rule that (it is not indeed a rule) trespassing civil aircraft must never be attacked does not mean that they have a legal right to trespass -Assembly of ICAO in 1984 adopted an amendment to 1944 Chicago Conv. On the Int. Civil Aviation which confirms that “every state, in the exercise of its sovereignty is entitled to require the landing at some designated airport of a civil aircraft flying above its territory without authority.” and that “every state must refrain from resorting to use of weapons against civil aircraft in flight and that, in case of interception, the lives of persons on board and the safety of aircraft must...

Words: 2165 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Ethnic

...Evaluating the role of ethnic identity in explaining the occurrence of contemporary civil conflicts in sub-Saharan Africa. High hopes for many newly independent states of Africa became diminished as the 1990s saw over a quarter of the continent's states facing armed insurgencies within their borders (Young, 2002: 534). Commentators often point to pathological, deep-seated hatreds in an African tribal mosaic as the bases of such conflict. The fact is, however, that the continent is awash with political grudges, ethnically-framed and otherwise, but civil wars rarely break out. Thus this essay seeks to take a more nuanced approach to understand the analytical challenge posed by such disorder. Starting out by countering the centrality of ethnic identity, it firstly seeks to demonstrate that ethnic identities do not exist primordially, but that they are constructed on weak foundations. Secondly it endeavours to show that where cleavages do exist along lines of cultural difference, simple heterogeneity is insufficient to account for the outbreak of conflict. Next, it moves to underline the fact that more important in explaining civil conflict is whether such conflict is feasible. This is understood both in terms of the perceived capacity of the state and in terms of the viability of insurgency for would-be rebels. A final conclusion will then be expounded that ethnicity is not a central factor, but that it is simply one of a number of strategies under which conflict may be framed...

Words: 2475 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Fighting in Syria

...predecssors. “The Arab Spring” as it was called began in Tunisia and spread across the region (Al Jazeera). The protestors in this revolt wanted a myriad of things. Some wanted democracy, respect for civil rights, and some want Islamization of government and a movement to theocracy. Syria, once a province of the Ottoman Empire, is a small middle-eastern nation between Lebanon and Turkey. In March 2011, pro-Democracy Arab Spring protestors who were marching to decry the arrest and torture of teen graffiti artists were fired upon by police. After the shootings, many more protestors joined the public displays of defiance (BBC ). After nationwide unrest and a refusal by President Assad to abdicate, the protestors began to arm themselves (Semple). The violence in the country escalated so quickly that by June of 2013, 90,000 people had been killed in the fighting and that number moved to 250,000 by August of 2015 (BBC ). Into the fray came the self-stylized Islamic State. This terrorist group which is opposed to Assad is fighting to create a Muslim caliphate throughout Iraq and Syria. In June of 2014, the group claimed that it’s caliphate had been established, which lead to US airstrikes to destroy the group, thus entering another belligerent into the fight (BBC). The Syrian Civil War was killed more than 250,000 people and approximately 11-12 million of the nation’s 22 million people are displaced. Approximately 6.5 million people are displaced inside of the country, with ~4.5...

Words: 1225 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Docx

...Monrovia Civil War Massina Ballah Strayer University English 090 Professor Delicia Battle August 10, 2012 Monrovia Civil war Many years of war that suffered thousands of people, and many dead. As a result of this, there were no food or medication. Moreover, a war that many thought will never come to an end. Monrovia war, a war that started early Monday morning april 6, 1990. A bright sunny day. Women and children running to save their lives. From a distance, I heard a very big sound of machine guns, bullet flying all over the place. We all ran for safety. As a got dark, it was a terrible night I didn’t know what to do. I felt stomach sick, because of the heavy guns sound. After many hours sitting in the house, I felt that this is the end of our lives. The next day the rebels told us to get out of the house. While working out there, there were many dead bodies in the street. I was afraid, especially my first time looking, and working over dead bodies. We walked for many hours. When it was night time, we slept in a school building. Women were taken from their husband by rebels. I knew that it was not safe for us. No one to protect us. We didn’t have safe drinking water. We drank from the creek, or the riverside. After many day of struggles, we had no food to eat, or medication. My elder brother got ill. We needed medicine. There were no medicine. My brother sickness got worst and he died. I felt so bad. My brother and I were so closed . He was everything...

Words: 388 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why War Is Bad?

...from the 21st century, my first and quick answer will be war Wars have been going on for centuries. War unavoidably.Brings death, destruction and suffering, which both ruin lives and nations. The most unjustifiable consequence of war is the loss of innocent civilians' lives. Civilians, who could have lived to make a huge impact on the world, pose no direct threat to the 'enemy' and might not even share the motives of the side they have been presumed to support. War eradicates hopes and dreams of millions, destroys homelands, frightens and oppresses people. Nothing that, in the end, brings more bad than it does good can be justified. Any kind of war is unjustifiable because it involves only killing. And what kind of victory does one get? Victory over millions of dead human flesh.Victory over the broken hearts of the family and relatives. We must not forget the horrors of the two world wars. In these wars, there was mass-killing and destruction of property. Thousands were made widows and orphans. War brings hatred and spreads falsehood. People become selfish and brutal. Finally I believe Wars are not the solution of the problems. Instead they generate problems and create hatred among nations. War can decide one issue but gives birth too many. Hiroshima and Nagasaki are the greatest horrible faces of the consequence of wars. Even after 60 years people are suffering from the miseries of war. Whatever be the cause of war, it always results in destruction of life and property at...

Words: 1148 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

War Has No Boundaries In The Sniper

...War Has No Boundaries The short story “The Sniper” was written by Liam O’Flaherty. The Sniper was published on January 12, 1923. Liam O’Flaherty was born on August 28, 1898. Liam grew up in a poverty-stricken village on Irishmore Island in County Galway on the western coast of Ireland (Cummings,2007). O’Flaherty joined the British Army during the First World War in 1915. He wrote the sniper on his findings during the Irish Civil War. The main ideas that Liam was trying to represent are war has no boundaries, that war reduces humans into mere objects, and individualism. The Irish Civil War began on June 28, 1922 and ended May 24, 1923. The war claimed more lives than the war of independence did. The conflict broke out between two opposing sides: The Free State, and Republican Opposition. The Anglo-Irish Treaty arose from the Irish War of Independence. The treaty provided for a self-governing Irish state in twenty-six of Ireland’s thirty-two counties. The Free State supported the treaty while the treaty represented the republican side. The split between the two opposing sides was very personal. The leaders on the opposing side were very close friends, and were comrades during the Irish War of Independence. The leader of the republican was...

Words: 1396 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Liam O 'Flaherty's The Sniper'

...John Adams once said, “Great is the guilt of an unnecessary war.” This means that killing in war is most felt when it could have been avoided. Justification for killing in war is a very debated topic. Some deem it as necessary for freedom, but what is necessary about killing another human being? Liam O’Flaherty was a short story writer from the early to mid-1900s. The Editors of Encyclopedia Britannica (2015) disclose that his various novels and short stories guided the course for other authors in the literary Irish Renaissance. In his story, “The Sniper,” O’Flaherty stresses the importance of the human feeling soldiers obtain when amidts battle. “The Sniper” takes place in Dublin, Ireland in the middle of a heated Irish civil war between the Irish Republican Army (IRA) and the Free Staters. An IRA sniper has been...

Words: 883 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Liam O Flaherty's The Sniper

...War is the one situation that has no room for mistakes. The slightest mistake can cost a person his life when in the line of war. War can change people who may have never wanted to harm a person into someone who is willing to live at all cost, even if it means killing. The short story “The Sniper” written by Liam O’Flaherty incorporates the realities of war all the way down to its finest details. It also shows its extremities and how an option of simply whether to light a cigarette or not can be the decision whether someone lives or dies. People are fighting in these wars and may not know what they are fighting for or why they are fighting. Cummings (2007) found, “Liam O’Flaherty was born on August 28, 1896, in Inishmore, Ireland.”...

Words: 1346 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Conflict Is Often Indiscriminate Analysis

...“Conflict is often indiscriminate”. I think that the statement means that sometimes wars and other various types of conflict occur regardless of who you are and just at random. My gut reaction regarding the statement is that conflict can be very indiscriminate equally to how conflict can be discriminative. For example, 9/11 was indiscriminate as the attack targeted multiple groups of people and was an attack just to psychologically damage the confidence of US Homeland Security and the US government; as well as other countries around the globe which saw the news broadcasts and thought that their country was going to be attacked next. However, conflicts like the Stonewall Riots, were discriminative, violent conflicts that attacked innocent people...

Words: 373 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Conflict Between The Mestizos And The Miskitos Of The Northern Region Of Nicaragua

...Throughout the world conflict persists. This is evident in Nicaragua where the country is facing a land disputes, “a territorial dispute is a disagreement over the possession/control of land between two or more territorial entities” which has divided into what can be described as a small civil war of ethnicity with the prize being valuable land along the coast of the country (7,. The two ethnic groups who are responsible for the conflicts are the miskitos of the southern region of Nicaragua, and the mestizos of the northern region of nicaragua. There fighting for land hs spread throughout the Caribbean coast, where most of the indigenous miskito citizens live on and or in close proximity to the area.(6) Both sides of the conflict the mestizos and the miskitos have had casualties since the start of the disputes....

Words: 806 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Sniper Thesis

...The effect of a civil war has a variety of emotions on the soldiers involved. In the short story “The Sniper”, written by Liam O’Flaherty, takes place during the Irish Civil War. The Irish Civil War took place during 1921 and lasted until 1922. The treaty of Anglo-Irish Treaty was the foremost cause that led to the civil war. The treaty provided the Irish Free-State with a tremendous amount of independence and separated the power the IRA had in war. The protagonist’s, an unknown IRA sniper, mission is to take out an enemy Free-State sniper. Throughout the story he is face with war like challenges that he has to embark on. The short story “The Sniper” is about an experienced sniper and the lasting effects that the civil war is having...

Words: 1242 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The National Liberation Army Of Colombia (ELN)

...Over the last 60 years across the world through both violent and non-violent regime changes long lasting insurgencies can be found tearing at the fabric of civilized society. From Boko Haram in Africa, ISIS in Syria and Iraq, and the FARC in Colombia, insurgencies are wide spread and consistently causing harm to civilian populaces and undermining the sovereignty of legitimate governments. A prime example of a long lasting insurgency and the topic of discussion is the National Liberation Army of Colombia or the ELN (Ejercito Liberation National). Established formally on July 4 1964 in Colombia, the ELN arose after the La Violencia period whereby an alliance formed between radical Catholic clergy and liberal college students. The two groups found a common ground stemming from the radical revolution movement in Cuba that went on throughout the 1950’s and 1960’s. The main goal of the ELN was to establish a more Marxist approach to government within Colombia (National Liberation Army (Colombia), 2012). Throughout the years the ELN has established it’s self as a formidable guerilla force throughout the country. Using methods such as extortion, kidnapping and murder they held a strong hand against the Colombian Army and Police for more than 50 years. Although they have operated throughout the country, the majority of all operations have been in the North Eastern area of the country, near the Venezuelan boarder where they use the porous area to move in between the two countries...

Words: 674 - Pages: 3