Free Essay

Comparison of Setting

In:

Submitted By Caamus
Words 963
Pages 4
Fiction Essay: Comparison of Setting
ENGL 100
Jonathan Jones
February 2, 2015

Thesis – Can two completely different stories have similarities in their setting and how the setting was used to support the story? I. Introduction – YGB and The Destructors took place during different time periods and in completely different locations. (Young Goodman Brown (YGB) – Nathanial Hawthorne published 1835, setting 17th century. The Destructors – Graham Greene published 1954 – setting mid 1950s) a. Different time period b. Different country c. Different time of day II. Why does the setting matter? d. Include character impact. e. The setting in both stories makes them believable III. Both stories rely on their settings to support the plot f. YGB – The setting creates a dark atmosphere. Allows the readier to believe there is witch craft happening and the devil is involved g. The Destructors – The setting creates a desolate location, much of a city after war time. The entire plot is based on symbolism and would not be able to occur if the town wasn’t recovering from war. The whole block was bombed, except the one house that the story is about. IV. Conclusion – both stories took place during different era’s, in different countries and had different conflicts. Similarly, the setting of each supported the plot that showcased conflicts true to the time period. Both stories were written by authors that were from the area. Both stories used the setting (place and time period) to deliver a moral that required thought to comprehend.

Fiction Essay: Comparison of Setting
To create a story that can truly be imagined by a reader, it is important to have a believable setting that coincides with the premise of the story. The setting of a story can greatly impact the entire foundation for which the story was created. Comparing two influential short stories from history to discover the likeness will showcase many variances, from the differences in time period, to the location and the conflict; however the critical thinking that was inspired can be equivalent. A short story tends to leave much interpretation to the reader, requiring analysis of the author, theme, setting, and possible morals embedded in the story.
The stories “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathanial Hawthorne and “The Destructors” by Graham Green are both popular short stories written by influential authors. “Young Goodman Brown” takes place during the seventeenth century in Salem Village, Massachusetts. Young Goodman Brown is a newly married young man that leaves his home at night to walk through the forest with devious intent. The entire story takes place over a few hour time span with the exception of the conclusion that summarizes the future. “The Destructors” takes place in England in the mid-1950s, after WWII and follows a gang of young boys over the course of several days. This story happens during the day, as many of the characters are young boys that are required to be home at a certain time.
The setting of a story can validate or create credibility. In the cases of “Young Goodman Brown” and “The Destructors” the setting makes both stories believable. “Young Goodman Brown” takes place in Salem Village during the time of the Salem Witch Trials. If the story took place in another time period or another location, it would take away from the credibility. The forest in the story symbolizes darkness and further develops the believability. “The Destructors” takes place in London after WWII. The location, Europe and London specifically, make this story believable. Without a post war zone setting, the story would only signify naughty children acting out. Due to the impact the war has on the area, the story introduces symbolism of society. The house survived 200 years of aging, and later bombings, while nothing else in the neighborhood survived. The history behind this house offers credibility to the story by offering an unstated explanation of the plot.
While these stories take place in different countries, during different time periods, both stories rely on the setting to support the plot. “Young Goodman Brown” creates a dark atmosphere with use of nighttime and the forest. This allows to reader to believe there is witch craft happening and that the devil is involved. “The Destructors” creates a desolate location. The entire plot is based on symbolism and would not be able to occur if the town were not recovering from war. The entire block was bombed with the exception of one house and that house happened to be over 200 years old and lived in by a man that was upper class and has come down due to the war.
The connection between the authors and the setting are significant to both stories. “Young Goodman Brown” was written in the past, during a time prior to when the author lived. The author, Nathaniel Hawthorne, did not live during the Salem Witch Trials, however, his great-great-grandfather, John Hathorne was responsible for questioning the accusers and the accused to determine the validity of allegations involving the practice of witchcraft. This ties the author to the time and place in which the story occurs. He has personal ties to this and his beliefs are tied into the story through the setting. Graham Greene served during WWII as part of MI6. Living in England during the time in which the story takes place gives the author direct realization of what occurred in society. Both authors are linked to the time and place the stories too place. “Young Goodman Brown” and “The Destructors” took place during different eras, in different countries and both stories had different conflicts. Despite the differences, the individual settings allowed the same level of emotion to be felt and made the stories more believable. These two stories, while inherently different, have shown similarities not originally expected.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Cloud Computing and Risk Accessment

...Cloud Computing Benefits, risks and recommendations for information security Rev.B – December 2012 2 Cloud Computing Benefits, risks and recommendations for information security Document History Date December 2009 Version 1.0 Modification Initial Release, Rev.A Author Daniele Catteddu, Giles Hogben Thomas Haeberlen Lionel Dupré December 2012 2.0 Rev.B About ENISA The European Network and Information Security Agency (ENISA) is a centre of network and information security expertise for the EU, its member states, the private sector and Europe’s citizens. ENISA works with these groups to develop advice and recommendations on good practice in information security. It assists EU member states in implementing relevant EU legislation and works to improve the resilience of Europe’s critical information infrastructure and networks. ENISA seeks to enhance existing expertise in EU member states by supporting the development of cross-border communities committed to improving network and information security throughout the EU. More information about ENISA and its work can be found at www.enisa.europa.eu. Contact details This report has been edited by: Lionel Dupré, Thomas Haeberlen For contacting ENISA or for general enquiries about this report, please use the following details: Email: resilience@enisa.europa.eu Internet: http://www.enisa.europa.eu Cloud Computing 3 Benefits, risks and recommendations for information security Legal notice Notice...

Words: 12166 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay

Handwashing

...for changes in behavioral patterns, and a total of 62 questionnaires were completed. | A quasi-experimental design with a convenient sample was used. | Improvement in hand hygiene and a decrease in infections was noted at 83%. | No comparison group or random assignment to group | Bisset, L.(2003) | The purpose of this study was to identify whether different healthcare professionals understand the definitions of proper handwashing. | A total of n=105 nurses and n=18 doctors | The design used to complete this study was through questionnaires. | The findings revealed additional training and changes to policy and procedures need to be implemented. The study revealed over 60% of the staff did not know the correct definition of hand hygiene. | No inferential statistics were offered.No comparison group or random assignment to groupNo educational resources were completed. | Smith, S. (2009) | To identify the most effective handwashing practice. | The sample consisted of 5000 deaths that were reviewed. | The design was a systemic review. | Few studies described the effectiveness of handwashing. | No comparison between TBL courses and non-TBL courses. | Duncan, C. 2007 | To identify patients belief of effective hand hygiene in clinical settings. | A total of 224 health questionnaires. | A semi structured questionnaire was designed to use in a descriptivesurvey to explore patient opinion about asking healthcareprofessionals to wash their hands prior to a clinical procedureand...

Words: 668 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Essay on 'the Most Dangerous Game'

...John Swenson English 11 1st Hour Comparison/Contrast Essay In this essay of comparison and contrast there will be comparisons and contrasts- or in other words similarities and differences- in Jack London’s “To Build A Fire” and Richard Connell’s, “The Most Dangerous Game”. The comparisons will be constructed of the settings, characters, and conflict. First topic to be compared is conflict. The two stories share two conflicts, a struggle for survival. In Jack London’s “To Build A Fire” the main character, not named, thinks in his head, “Without doubt he would lose some fingers and toes and some of his face…” (London 703). In the same manner, the main character, named Rainsford, kills a dog and the “bad guy” says to him “… I’ll see what you can do against my whole pack” (Connell 28). However, the two stories differ in what they struggle against. In “To Build A Fire” the conflict is person versus nature. For example the guy builds a fire and from the spruce tree falls some snow and puts out the fire; to quote “He should not have built the fire under the spruce tree” (London 700). Meanwhile, in “The Most Dangerous Game” the conflict is person versus person which is Rainsford being hunted down by General Zaroff-the “bad guy”- in the middle of a baron island. To quote from General Zaroff “Your strength and stamina against mine” (Connell 24). Secondly, literary item number two is setting. In both stories the setting is set in isolated places. Like in “To Build A Fire” its...

Words: 561 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Fiction Essay

...The world today has faced many trials and tribulations. It is quite similar to the two short stories ‘Young Goodman Brown” and “The Lottery.” In these stories, characters are faced with situations beyond their own imagination and to makes things worse is how they are tested. They will encounter people and other things that are unjust. These stories bring a lot of comparisons such as the setting of the stories, but mostly there are contrasts such as the symbolism within the stories and the meaning each author put behind their stories. In comparing the two short stories “Young Goodman Brown” and “The Lottery,” it is easily noticed that both of these stories takes place well within the community setting. Each story has the involvement of the people who lives within the town. Details in the story showcase how the communities makes the characters feel accepted one way or another to a certain extinct. Within these communities, each has their own traditions, laws, and perimeters that justify the reasoning behind what they do. In turn it kind of makes these communities have a sense of uniqueness to them and that is why individuals are pulled in and want to be part of these communities. In addition, both of these stories showcase a sense of a happy ambience and exuberance. In “The Lottery,” the author, Shirley Jackson illustrates a perfect day by stating “The morning of June 27th was clear and sunny, with a fresh warmth of a full-summer day; the flowers were blossoming profusely...

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Psy 435 Self-Concept and the Self Paper

...self-perceptions and how he or she interacts in the social world is a significant factor in self-concept. Self-schemas are a significant element of self-concept, which are specific beliefs, mental temples, one uses to define him or herself, and organize his or her world. (Myers, 2010). Self schemas enable people to vision themselves in the future, their possible selves. It helps one to vision what he or she wants such as rich, thin, or successful. Such possible selves are beneficial, for it motivates individuals who want a successful future. The self-concept helps organize thinking and guide social behavior. Social experiences are also exceptionally influential in one’s development of self-concept such as the roles an individual play, social comparisons, success, and failure, and what others think have much to do with one’s development and how he or...

Words: 1449 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Aboriginal Struggles In Canada

...The Struggle of Canadian First Nations People Many first nation canadian families struggle day to day. This struggle comes from a long and drawn out process that Canada has put First nations people through in order to destroy them and their culture. though First Nation people have strived in order to make a better life for themselves in today’s society, many still struggle due to the problems that have hindered aboriginals for many generations. Some of the key issues that will be touched upon in this essay are: the comparison between urban privilege versus rural Aboriginal struggle, the comparison between aboriginal struggles today versus the struggles of previous generations, and the issues and horrors of residential schooling. The comparison...

Words: 908 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Imagery In One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest

...One reading One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest can relate to the pressure of society's oppressive rules in many ways. Kesey's usage of metaphors relating people to machines and the hospital to a factory leaves a relatable factor to models in the world, setting a standard for people being perfect. Kesey's usage of imagery helps the readers realize that they are too blinded to see what is going on, and need to look through the fog to see the truth. Finally, Kesey's usage of setting taking place just after World War II helps the reader realize that in the book, the Nurse is striving for everyone to be perfect in her image, hoping that everyone realizes that society is doing this to them, wanting to look a certain way to be perfect. Striving for perfection is something society dictates we all do, but at what cost? One cannot expect to be an individual if everyone decides to follow the same path to supposed perfection, and losing your individuality is not worth someone else’s definition of...

Words: 1199 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Internal Validity In Research

...Selection--The subjects in comparison groups should be functionally equivalent at the beginning of a study. Experimental Mortality--Subjects drop out of studies. If one comparison group experiences a higher level of subject withdrawal/mortality than other groups, then observed differences between groups become questionable. Selection Interactions--In some studies the selection method interacts with one or more of the other threats, biasing the study's results.These variables can be controlled to limit their effect on the experimental conditions.Therefore, is not relevant in observation or descriptive studies that are merely report findings.When internal validity is associated with experimental research it refers to how well the study was run ,and how confidently one can conclude that the change in the dependent variable was produced only by the...

Words: 724 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Avoiding Racism in Care Work

...relationship gives us understanding to how prejudices and racism are acted upon. I am going to compare Rosie Purves and Elvis Malcolm’s experiences of racism at work and discuss how racism can be avoided in the care work. A comparison between Rosie and Elvis was that Rosie didn’t have the support from management that Elvis had. Rosie was under racist actions due to the colour of her skin. The consultant went along with the mother’s request to move her child away from Rosie’s care. This was due to the mother not wanting anyone who was black looking after her child. By the consultant not challenging the mother made it look like he was agreeing with her actions and saying that racism was ok. ‘Nobody at the hospital apologised. The priority was the child, according to the consultant. The team was saying, “We don’t see you as being black” but they were still prepared to move the child’. (Purves, 2010, p 23) By the consultant going a long with the mother’s request caused the hospital to be institutionally discriminative. One of the reasons why the NHS trust was guilty of showing racial discrimination was due to there being no recognition of racism and ‘no policy setting out what action should be taken to address it’. (K101, Unit 11, p159) However in comparison with Rosie, Elvis felt he had full support from his manager. This is due to Somebody Cares having an equal opportunities...

Words: 1833 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Title

...The Age Old Debate: ADN vs BSN, a comparison Seth Ronning Grand Canyon University Professional Dynamics Kimberly Hammerton September 4, 2013 The Age Old Debate: ADN vs BSN, a comparison In battles of good versus evil through out history, good almost always triumphs in the end. For example the New York Yankees have won a total of twenty seven World Series Championships compared to the Boston Red Sox who have won a meager seven World Series. Another example would be Darth Vader returning from the dark side to vanquish the evil Emperor by means of hurling the villain over a rail to unseen depths and certain death. In the case of Bachelors level nursing compared to Associates level nursing however, there really is no good versus evil to compare. There is no dark versus light there is just a different level of attained educational degree. The question is what does the difference in education level provide in the level of competency of each nurse. The aim of this paper is to discuss what is the definition of competency in nursing and how is it measured, what are the advantages in nursing care for associates and bachelors degree care, and how do the differences in educational level affect overall patient outcomes. What is competency in nursing? The American Nurses Association, or ANA, defines competency by stating, “competency is an expected level of performance that results from an integration of knowledge, skills, abilities, and judgment” (ANA 2004). A nurses’ ability...

Words: 1686 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Sql Performance Analyzer

...operating system, or hardware configuration changes. •Database initialization parameter changes. •Schema changes, such as adding indexes or materialized views. •Refreshing optimizer statistics. •Creating or changing SQL profiles. Unlike Database Replay, the SQL Performance Analyzer does not try and replicate the workload on the system. It just plugs through each statement gathering performance statistics. The SQL Performance Analyzer can be run manually using the DBMS_SQLPA package or using Enterprise Manager. This article gives an overview of both methods. •Setting Up the Test •Creating SQL Tuning Sets using the DBMS_SQLTUNE Package •Running the SQL Performance Analyzer using the DBMS_SQLPA Package •Creating SQL Tuning Sets using Enterprise Manager •Running the SQL Performance Analyzer using Enterprise Manager •Optimizer Upgrade Simulation •Parameter Change •Transferring SQL Tuning Sets Setting Up the Test The SQL performance analyzer requires SQL tuning sets, and SQL tuning sets are pointless unless they contain SQL, so the first task should be to issue some SQL statements. We are only trying to demonstrate the technology, so the example can be really simple. The following code creates a test user called SPA_TEST_USER. CONN / AS SYSDBA CREATE USER spa_test_user IDENTIFIED BY spa_test_user QUOTA...

Words: 1591 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Theoretical Models

...increase departmental functioning in the future. In health care managers have diverse staff to motivate. Employees may be of varied ages, experience, educational levels, and job descriptions. Staff ranges from minimally educated secretarial staff to professionals such as licensed professional nurses, physicians, and physician extenders (Borkowski, 2005). The manager who takes the time to get to know the employees he or she is responsible for will know the individual positive or negative attributes of each employee. This will assist in determining how best to motivate everyone for the good of the department. Many motivational theories exist but only equity and goal-setting theories will be discussed here. Equity Theory Theory Description Equity theory basis relies on the comparison of inputs to outcomes. In the work setting an employee’s education, skill set, and anything else he or she brings to the job position provides the input. The salary, promotion, bonus or anything else attributed to the inputs provides the employee’s outcomes. Equity exists when the ration of inputs to outcomes of one employee equates to those of another employee (Borkowski, 2005). Equity Theory in...

Words: 840 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Use Of Similes In Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde

...In the novel The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson, similes are used to help bring better meaning to readers by describing the setting, comparing two unlike things, and creating an image in the reader’s head. For example, the first simile is used at the beginning of the story to describe what the setting is like. Mr. Enfield walks the streets that are “as empty as a church” (Stevenson 4) when he is alone that night. The use of this simile is emphasizing the stillness portrayed when Mr Enfield was walking the streets. It helps the reader understand the emptiness around Mr. Enfield and how quiet it was. The simile gives the setting a dark and lonely tone and gives the reader a better understanding of the character’s...

Words: 403 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Social Interation of Student's with Autism (Rol)

...Autism 2 The purpose of this paper is to review a research article examining the social integration of autistic students in inclusive elementary school classes. The article is: Boutot, E. A. & Bryant, D. P. (2005). Social integration of students with autism in inclusive settings. Education and Training in Developmental Disabilities, 40(1), 14-23. The article by Boutot and Bryant (2005) begins with a fairly comprehensive review of the related literature that is used to establish a reason to believe that the social integration of student’s with autism in elementary schools may be difficult and hard to attain. The literature indicates that student’s with autism may, in fact, have difficulties gaining social status and establishing friends. The article also defines autism, explains the various deficits common to elementary students who are autistic, and discusses the components that comprise the concept of social integration. The discussion of social integration as a concept is extensive. Each component is separately discussed in terms of what the literature typically shows as to how autistic children function relative to the component, especially when they are in inclusive settings. The components include measures of social status and establishing friendship. Specifically, they are: social preference, social impact, and social network affiliations. The study ended with the formulation of two research purposes. These were: 1.) To examine for differences...

Words: 989 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Short Story Analysis

...Setting Read more Setting is a description of where and when the  story takes place. In a short story there are fewer settings compared to a novel. The time is more limited. * How is the setting created? Consider geography, weather, time of day, social conditions, etc. * What role does setting play in the story? Is it an important part of the plot or theme? Or is it just a backdrop against which the action takes place? Study the time period which is also part of the setting. * When was the story written? * Does it take place in the present, the past, or the future? * How does the time period affect the language, atmosphere or social circumstances of the short story? Characterization Read more Characterization deals with how the characters in the story are described. In short stories there are usually fewer characters compared to a novel. They usually focus on one central character or protagonist. * Who is the main character? * Are the main character and other characters described through dialogue – by the way they speak (dialect or slang for instance)? * Has the author described the characters by physical appearance, thoughts and feelings, and interaction (the way they act towards others)? * Are they static/flat characters who do not change? * Are they dynamic/round characters who DO change? * What type of characters are they? What qualities stand out? Are they stereotypes? * Are the characters believable? Plot...

Words: 711 - Pages: 3