Premium Essay

Critque

In:

Submitted By Nini456
Words 3313
Pages 14
Research and Evidence

INTRODUCTION

The author of this assignment will critically appraise a research report in the Nursing Times titled Young people's perceptions and access to health advice (Sherman-Jones 2003) (appendix 1). This article was chosen for a number of reasons. Firstly the topic of young people's health is frequently discussed in the media, often negatively. A search on BBC news online resulted in 46 articles within the month 27 October to 27 November 2003 (appendix 2) and similarly Scotsman Newspapers online facility produced over 100 articles for the same period (appendix 3). Sexual health was one of the 5 key areas that the Health of the Nation (Department of Health 1992) report highlighted, including teenage conceptions. Teenage health is an area that the Scottish Executive (2003) is also interested in promoting through its Improving Health in Scotland document.

On a personal level, adolescent health is of great interest to the author and it is intended that this assignment will increase her knowledge, not only of young people's health experiences but also the importance of research to her continuing professional development. The article is directly related to other modules undertaken by the author namely family planning and health promotion.

It is proposed that the author will examine both positive and negative aspects of the article and provide a personal evaluation using a systematic analysis of the research that follows a set criterion (McSherry 2001).

Research is important in healthcare today and is part of the evidence-based practice that underpins nursing. This stemmed from government policies and the introduction of clinical governance (Kopp 2001, McSherry et al 2002). Not all research is relevant and that is why it is important to do a thorough critique.

CRITIQUE

The title of the study is 'Young people's

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Network Critque

...Kudler Fine Foods Network One of the considered “best fine food stores” around is the Kudler Fine Foods. However, Kudler is in serious need of a network infrastructure upgrade of their old one. To introduce the latest technologies in data collection, company communication, and information protection while providing the best data speeds and network access are the main goals of the enterprise network. This huge step is significant as this will increase the revenue and will reduce the costs of operation throughout the Kudler Fine Foods stores. Kudler Fine Foods will go back up to technological speed as the network upgrade is completed, while at the same time improving the way they keep track of inventory and sales by using data mining techniques, which will be collected and analyzed in real time. Network Overview The review of the current network used at Kudler Fine Foods was able to determine that the network topology that is being used is the bus topology. The bus network is set-up in such a way that all the network components are connected via CAT5 to the bus or communication line. This configuration is true at sites in the corporation for their workstations, servers, and standalone UPS. A 56k modem is the device that is used by all of the networks communicating to the internet. Although the bus network is very reasonable when it comes to cost, the downfall is that when the backbone goes down, the entire network can encounter an outage that is very difficult to troubleshoot...

Words: 1871 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Music Critque

...Concert Critique # 1 On February 9th, 2013, I attended a concert that was performed by the Charleston Symphony Orchestra. This concert was organized by the Moncks Corner, South Carolina, Mayor’s Office and Recreation Department, and was performed in the Berkley High School Auditorium. The Charleston Symphony Orchestra would actually have 2 instrumental sets with a brief intermission between them. The 1st musical set was played by their String Quartet and they would be playing Mozart’s String Quartet #19. The 2nd musical set would be performed by the Woodwind Quintet, and they would be playing the Beethoven - Quintet, Op.71. Below you will find a critique primarily on the 1st set that was played by the Charleston Symphony Orchestra String Quartet. In 1785, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart wrote a six string quartet which he dedicated to his friend and mentor Joseph Haydn. The one that was played tonight was arguably the most popular one and I was written and performed in C major. The piece was also called the "Dissonant Quartet". It was arguably Mozart's finest quartet writing, most beloved chamber music piece and the performance tonight did an excellent job at captivating every minute detail to the piece. This piece had a total of 4 movements. On 1st Violin was Alex Wathrow, on 2nd Violin was Asico Cramer, On the Viola was Christopher Manning, and on the Cello was Damion Cramer. Adagio. Allegro Just listen to the opening bars of this movement and you will see where this quartet gains...

Words: 1068 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Website Critque

...1. What is the box model? The CSS box model describes the boxes that are formed around elements in a Web page. In XHTML, every element is treated as though it were a box. The box model consists of four parts: a content area, padding, borders, and margins. 2. What is padding? Padding is the white space that surrounds the box content. 3. What is the margin? Margin is white space outside the border. 4. When using the border shorthand property, what value must always be specified? Border Shorthand Property is the shorthand property you can use to set the values for all four border styles with one declaration. • To set the border width, use: border-width: width; where width is one of the CSS units of measure. • To set the border color, use: border-color: value; where value is a named color, RGB color, or hexadecimal color value. • To set the border style, use: border-style: style; where style is either none, solid, double, dotted, dashed, outset, inset, groove, or ridge. • To use the border shorthand property, enter: border: style color width; where style is the border style, color is the border color, and width is the border width. Although not all three values need to be specified, and values can be entered in any order, you must specify a border style. 5. What are the values for the float property? The values of the float property are left, right or none. 6. What are the values for the clear property? The values of the clear property are left...

Words: 264 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Dracula Critque

...Bram Stoker’s Dracula was a piece of literature that was one of a kind in its time frame. The book was so out of the everyday norm for society back then the novel has stuck around for so long. The thought of vampires at this point in time was thought of, but never imagined like it is in this novel. This novel was so unique because Bram Stoker actually portrayed Van Helsing as himself, with all of Bram Stokers education. The way that the novel begins and the break down of how the flow of the novel starts was very entertaining, its as if they went away from the anti-climatic build up of the vampires lair and went to what is Dracula. Although the detail of the story and all the details that were so different of the time most definitely over shadowed Dracula as a character. The overhead of the story was of three males who are all suitors to the young Lucy. Eventually leading to her demise, Lucy is bitten and turned into what is considered a female vampire courtesy of yours truly, Dracula . While each one of the suitors for young Lucy is in a daze to try to grasp whats wrong with her the eventually figure out what is wrong. The transition in the story flowed very well and was most of time very easily understood. The whole concept of how they need to set young Lucy free i believe was very climatic in a sense to where these men had come to marry her also had to kill her which was unique of a novel of this time. Bram Stoker threw so many different little details which made the...

Words: 475 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Research Critque

...Research critique part 2: Developing patient nurse relationship Chinwe Obukwelu Grand Canyon University September 2, 2012 Introduction to nursing research Schlagel Martha The purpose of this study is set out to explore the interaction between patients and nurses in community practice settings, in order to understand the social meanings and understands brought to the interaction and at play within it. “Interaction is fundamental to the development of the patients perspective is quintessential in their experience of being a patient (Morse, 1991).” Practice nurse employees in four community health centers were approached and invited to participate. A sample of patient participants were invited to participate by means of direct approach to those attending the recruited nurses clinics. The subjects participated voluntarily and they agreed to participate when approached, written informed consent was gained from each participant, also ethical approval to conduct the study was granted by the health board ethics research committee. Eighteen patients and eighteen registered nurse participants from across the health center and the nurse participants were females aged 26-58 years old. Patient participants are in relation to age, gender and socioeconomic status. Data was collected using non-participant observation and informal and semi-structured interviews. Each observation was looking at the interaction between a patient and...

Words: 942 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Final Critque

...Final Film Critique Saving Private Ryan Sumer Gebo December 20, 2015 ENG 225 Introduction To Film Instructor David Preizler Going through and reading the requirements for this assignment and trying to decide which movie from the AFI’s top 10 list to do my final critique on I finally settled on the World War II epic Saving Private Ryan this movie has an A list cast of actors and director. This movie is one that will pull at your heart strings and make you wonder was this how life really was during this time and was this what was happening in the European theater at the time of the war. Trying to decide which theory to use while critiquing this movie the easiest one for me to chose was the genre theory not because it was the easiest one in the list but because I am the spouse of a combat veteran who has gone through many of the same things that the cast had to endure when they were filming this movie in a generalized sense. Saving Private Ryan begins with the storming of the beach at Normandy in June of 1944 with Tom Hanks and Tom Sizemore and their soldiers trying to destroy a German pill box or fortified machine gun emplacement. Once they have successfully cleared the beach and they move in land and finally have a chance to rest and re-equip all of their men and get food, they are given a mission, to locate and retrieve on Pvt James Francis Ryan who was played in this film by Matt Damon. During their time searching for Pvt Ryan they...

Words: 1260 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Critque Article

...Toyota Takes On ‘Do or Die’ Cost Challenge in India October 21, 2010, 3:25 AM EDT By Makiko Kitamura and Siddharth Philip Oct. 21 (Bloomberg) -- Toyota Motor Corp.’s new Etios compact will be half the price of its cheapest model in India as the automaker seeks to win share from Maruti Suzuki India Ltd. The new car, also to be sold in China and Brazil, will be priced in the range of market leader Maruti’s 405,300-rupee ($9,200) Swift compact, Hiroshi Nakagawa, managing director of Toyota’s India unit, said in an interview in Bangalore. Maruti’s 229,000-rupee Alto is the country’s best-selling car, accounting for 13 percent of Indian auto sales. “It has been a challenge to build quality at a lower price,” Nakagawa said. “The Indian car market is one of the toughest markets in the world. Customers and car owners are very cost-conscious.” The Etios highlights Toyota’s struggle to balance sales in low-cost car segments in emerging markets without risking its reputation for quality. The automaker is lowering costs for its new model by increasing the amount of parts purchased in India, with initially 70 percent locally sourced. Engine and transmission production will also start in the nation in 2012. “Bringing procurement cost to a very competitive level is a do or die challenge for our procurement and production teams,” Executive Vice President Yukitoshi Funo said in an interview on Oct. 4. ‘Premium Over Competitors’ The compact arrives as Nissan Motor Co. plans to sell a...

Words: 935 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Critque Paper

...In Jennifer Mclunes article, "Hip Hop Betrayal Of Black Women," she defends women both in Powell’s presented article and in hip hop music in general. Mclune starts by degrading Powell and his article saying that his explanation was basically an excuse for sexism. Mclune also calls Powell out on the fact that he justifies what these so called "men" are saying in the hip hop industry. Just because they grew up in poverty doesn’t justify what they are doing to be right. It is no different that the women that have grown up in poverty and violence, but yet they aren't producing this music that the men are. Mclune speaks about how the degrading of women is what keeps hip hop thriving, and the sad thing about it is that if that was to stop that the fans would be disappointed and they would probably end up losing interest in there music if they took that out. Basically that girls and women that like this kind of music and keep encouraging it are setting themselves up to be victims. Mclune also talks about how these companies that sign with hip hop artist and people who continue to be fans and buying the music are really almost encouraging them to act out in this way. Mclune also speaks of a woman that is a hip-hop artist, Eve. Her appearance and her actions encourage men to act this way, and that women artist can be just like the males in an aspect. Mclune finds it astonishing that no one has gone to greater levels or even tried to do something about the way women are degraded in hip...

Words: 585 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Media Critque

...15 April 2016 Q & A News Article 1 1.) The title of article, source of article, and Link A- Science Says Those Who Watch 'Grey's' or 'Mad Men' Are Better People -Elite Daily, http://elitedaily.com/news/science-says-better-person-watch-drama/1237130 2.) The main research question(s) stated in the article: A.) The people watching these tv shows seemed to be more loving and concerned for their families. The non ficton group was shown as less lkving towards their families even though it was just right for their families. 3.) Q- The finding(s) and limitation(s) stated in the article A.) The main finding would be the author feels you are a better person or become a better person if you watch these tv shows. B.) The main limitations are the author believes there needs to be a better study before you can conclude what feelings and reactions people have. 4.) Q- The interpretation of the feeling(s)- how did the article define what the findings mean? A.) Findings would be the people who watch these programs are more compassioniate than people who do not. Research Article 1.) Q- The title of the article and Authors (use APA Style citiation) A.) Black J., & Barnes, J. L. (2015, September 28). Fictions and Social Cognition: The Effect of Viewing Award-Winning Television Dramas on Theory of Mind. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts. Advance only publication. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/aca0000031 2.) Q- The main research questions: A.) If the different...

Words: 392 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Personal Critque

...Monique Lee Student ID: 110199493 Monique Lee Student ID: 110199493 Leisure Concepts – Personal Critique Leisure Concepts – Personal Critique Reflective Study (Personal Critique) Week 11 – The Dark Side of Leisure Gambling: When defining the term leisure, it is able to be distinguished by the three components of; intrinsically motivating, enjoyment, and freedom of choice. Therefore, any activity that is able to demonstrate these three components must be seen as a leisure activity. However, in society some of the reflection of these activities that people are merely participating in are seen as been on the verge, in terms of being outside acceptable norms of behaviour and having a negative impact on the wellbeing of the individual if overused. These leisure activities are commonly derived as being seen as the ‘dark side of leisure’ or ‘leisure deviant’. Leisure can be a time for self-expression, even if it is outside the self-normality of society, however who can define it as being either a good or bad activity to participate in. If it’s giving the individual an overall sense of pleasure and positive experiences from participating, shouldn’t it be considered as an acceptable leisure activity to take part in? Based on the three components of leisure, I will evaluate whether gambling provides any overall benefits to the individual overall in relation to their wellbeing, specifically focusing on the question, ‘Does gambling have any beneficial leisure...

Words: 2005 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Journal Article Critque

...JOURNAL ARTICLE CRITIQUE of Andrew, Stephen L. “Biblical Inerrancy.” Chafer Theological Seminary Journal 08, no. 1 (January 2002): 2-21. THEO 525-B04 LUO (fall 2013) Systematic Theology I Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary Jennifer C. Wood (ID# L25703677) September 1, 2013 Contents Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………….1 Brief Summary…………………………………………………………………………………….1 Critical Interaction………………………………………………………………………………...2 Conclusion Selected Bibliography Introduction This paper is a critical examination of Stephen Andrew’s “Biblical Inerrancy” as published January of 2002 in the Chafer Theological Seminary Journal. Andrew writes the article as a graduate student at Fuller Theological Seminary pursuing a Master of Arts in Theology. In the exposition he presents a historical overview of the biblical inerrancy debate and reviews arguments concerning inerrancy of the bible as relevant to modern evangelicalism. Due to spatial limitations, Andrew restricts his focus to examining the views in support of and against inerrancy from four major perspectives: the slippery slope, epistemological, historical, and biblical arguments. Brief Summary The article is written as an exhortation for the promotion and defense of the inerrancy doctrine while warning against a universal acceptance of all supporting arguments. Andrew opens by defining inerrancy according to Paul D. Feinberg1, as well as Article XII of the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy2;...

Words: 1046 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Critque Paper Methods

...CRITIQUING A RESEARCH PAPER Student's Name: Elements of the Critique: 1. TITLE: 3. ABSTRACT 4. INTRODUCTION & REVIEW of LITERATURE: 5. MATERIALS & METHODS 6. RESULTS 7. DISCUSSION & CONCLUSION, 8. REFERENCES 9. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS & IMPLICA TIONS 2. AUTHOR(s) Instructions: For each of the 39 items below respond using one of the following three options: - S for “Satisfactory” - Detailed comments concerning elements critiqued. A simple "No" is not sufficient. You must explain why the element is open to criticism. - ITJ for "Incompetent To Judge" and indicate the person in your own setting form whom you would obtain a valid opinion. The number of points assigned to each element is proportional to the number of elements that can be critiqued in each section (see decimal points in parentheses next to each item number). If you need more space to answer, please use the back of the page. Reference: Bordage G. Considerations on Preparing a Paper for Publication. Teaching and Learning in Medicine. 1989. 1(1):47-52. I. TITLE 1. (.33) The title correctly represents the content and breath of the study reported: the title is not misleading. 2. (.33) The title is clear, concise and gives importance to the study; the title captures the attention of the reader. If not suggest a title. II. AUTHOR(S) _ 3. (.33) The titles (diploma. appointment) and address of the author(s) are clearly indicated: the author(s) credentials can be appreciated. III. ABSTRACT 4. (.33) The abstract...

Words: 1007 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Survey Writing Critque

...Survey Critique Exercise By Rachel Di Cesare 3a) Unclear wording /terminology in the question (respondents may not understand the question) With a need for improvement, the following question vaguely asks the reader: How do you define yourself in terms of your friends? * This is would not make sense to the respondent as there is a poor choice of wording that makes it confusing. To correct the question, a better choice of expression would make much easier to comprehend. E.g. What qualities would your friends use to describe you? b) Unclear directions in how to respond to the question What five characteristics do you most look for in a friend? Please CHOOSE FIVE of the following characteristics. ___Loyalty __Popularity ___Appearance __Grades ___Self Control __Empathy ___Being Assertive _Compassion ___Athletic Ability __Integrity ___Honesty __Courage ___Respect __Wealth ___Competitiveness * The question asks the reader to choose 5 characteristics, but not how to choose it. More specification should be considered into the question, such as asking the respondent to place a check mark beside the desired answers. c) Ambiguity in responses-respondent may be confused about how to answer because some answers overlap or they perceive no correct answer. What does bullying mean to you? -Emotional abuse -Physical abuse -Sexual harassment -Other * Physical abuse and sexual abuse and emotional abuse...

Words: 1518 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

User Manual Critque

...User manual User Manual Critique Robert L. Jordan, Sr ENG/221 February 14, 2011 Janet Chappell User Manual Critique Canon PowerShot SX130 IS I. Introduction The user manual I have chosen to critique is from Canon Inc. for the Canon PowerShot SX130 IS camera, a digital camera with High Definition capabilities. It can shoot in 720p HD video with stereo sound. The SX130 also has a large 3 inch LED screen with high resolution and a wide viewing angle. It also has a 12 X digital zoom for perfect pictures from close ups to wide angle shots of the whole gang. Advanced Smart Auto detects and analyzes faces, brightness, colors, distance and movement, then selects an appropriate setting based on 28 predefined shooting situations. The complete manual can be found at http://gdlp01.c-wss.com/gds/5/0300003855/04/PSSX130IS_CUG_EN_03.pdf . II. Document Organization This user manual has 180 pages divided into ten chapters. The first five chapters explain the basic use of the camera and the final five chapters expand on that knowledge by showing advanced functions. The first five chapters cover such topics as getting started, learning more about your camera, shooting with commonly used functions, choosing settings yourself, and getting more out of your camera. The last five chapters concern more advanced topics such as using various functions for shooting movies, using the various playback and editing functions...

Words: 466 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Critque of David Alessandro

...Outside Reading 1 Why Employees DON’T DO what they’re supposed to do.. and What TO DO about it. By David F. Alessandro The book opens up with discussing hidden influences that affect employees. He suggested though out the book that it is primarily a lack of quality management that leads to poor performances. His approach is to utilize 16 predetermined influences and offer examples and solutions to each. The format of the book is very simple and easy to read. The author uses each chapter to address the influence and breaks each one of them down systematically and consistently. The book in itself could almost be used as a quick reference for managers. It does have some quality advice and suggestions on how to deal with the situations. The flaw that I believe the author does not fully address or develop is that he places all of the blame for each suggestion on management. He is not inclusive with management. They to have their own issues and learning opportunities and will need assisted. He does attempt to address this situation in his Q&A at the end of the book, but simply relies on the 16 influences and that everything else is covered in this report or that report. I am to read the book and believe that this is the absolute solution and yet the last stance is if it is not in my suggestions then it is somewhere else and we do not have to deal with it. The Author references “They don’t know why they should do it” in the first chapter. The first issue is...

Words: 501 - Pages: 3