Premium Essay

Donald Cowart Case

Submitted By
Words 926
Pages 4
Nursing is a very intense field to pursue because nurses are essential to improving patient’s condition. The nurse must put orders into action; the quality of care given plays a huge role in the direction a patient’s health will go. Nursing care is founded upon the ethical principles of doing no harm, autonomy, beneficence, etc. These principles are the foundation of how nursing care is structured and carried out. When these principles are dismissed, the individual is no longer acting as a nurse. In the decision scenario 8, Shawn is acting as an executioner rather than a nurse. Shawn’s job is to kill people by lethal injection. Shawn’s job description does not state he should organize a plan of care around the patient’s wishes nor does it …show more content…
If a patient asks the medical professional to kill him/her, the professional should not do so. It is the responsibility of the health professional to do no harm to the patient. In the case of Donald Cowart, the doctor and nurse’s response to Cowart asking them to kill him were appropriate. They refused to kill him, because it is considered malpractice. Dr. Meier stated to Donald, “Don’t ask us to let you die…because in a sense what that means is we’re killing you. If you want to die, then let me fix your hands, operate on them and open them up so at least you can do something with them, and if you want to commit suicide then, you can. But don’t ask us to stand her and literally kill you (M/L, page 6).” Although Dax gave consent to killing him, it is not ethical nor is it lawful to kill a patient intentionally. Other than the example above, there is no other situation a medical professional should act against the patient’s consent or against a patient’s best medical interests. People entrust health professionals to improve or maintain health. Going against a patient’s best medical interests is unethical and …show more content…
Every patient deserves to take an active role in planning and carrying out their health care plan. Nurses should constantly refer to the ethical principles of nursing when making a decision pertaining to a person’s health. Health professionals are entrusted with a tough job of managing lives; therefore, the best efforts are needed to do the job efficiently. It is vital to develop a therapeutic relationship with the patient to understand why the patient would refuse certain treatments. Doing so, will help the health care provider to better assist the patient in his/her health management. Making sure the procedures and treatments being implemented is the best for the patient’s health and not causing any harm to the patient is the overall goal of the nursing profession. This goal will continue to be the standard of practice for all nursing

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Patients Right to Die

...twenty-first century, it is a given that patients have certain rights including the right to receive or refuse medical treatments. The common question is, should they also have the right to be allowed to die? This decision presents many concerns regarding ethical dilemmas for the health providers that are involved. In 1973, Donald "Dax" Cowart was 25 years old when he was critically injured in an explosion, sustaining severe burns on over 65 percent of his body (Hillard01, 2011). Dax underwent daily skin treatments that were described as cruel, agonizing and barbaric while only receiving low doses of pain medications (Burt, 1998). He refused all medical care and begged to his doctors as well as other hospital personnel continuously, to let him die (Hillard01, 2011). Doctors felt he was incompetent to make his medical decisions and accepted his mother's written consent to continue his medical care against his will (McGee, 1997). He is now blind, has no use of his hands, and has severe disfiguration (Burt, 1998). Dax has to have a personal caregiver living with him at all times, to assist him with his personal functions (McGee, 1997). In the Dax Cowart case, his mother and doctors both acted in a paternalistic manner, ignoring Dax's wishes and doing what they felt was in the best interest for him. Doctors felt he was incompetent to make his own medical decisions and accepted his mother's written consent to continue his medical care against his will (McGee, 1997). His mother...

Words: 749 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Assisted Suicide

...“The term assisted suicide refers to the practice of a physician prescribing legal drugs that allow terminally ill patients to end their own lives. The difference between assisted suicide and euthanasia (mercy killing) is that in assisted suicide the doctor may only provide the drugs, not administer them, while in euthanasia the doctor can provide and administer the drugs.” (Brochu B1). What is known as the “Right to Die Movement” is the fight for one’s complete autonomy. It is important not to look at assisted suicide as killing someone as if you are taking them for their life without their permission. This is about alleviating suffering for those who are not going to get relief any other way. Assisted suicide should be legalized because as human beings, we should have a freedom of choice, as well as an end to prolonged suffering, and this may cause a reduction of traditional suicide methods. Putting those who’s quality of life is dwindling out of their misery has been a dilemma for ages, but going as far back to the 1930’s in London it is recorded that the royal physician Lord Bertrand Dawson to King George V was in charge of making sure the king departed peacefully. On January 20, 1936, Dawson injected the dying King with the lethal dose of three-quarters of a gram of morphine and one gram of cocaine (Ekland-Olson, 63). It has also been recorded that on September 23, 1939, the great psychologist Sigmund Freud was put to rest by his former student, Dr. Max Schur, after Freud...

Words: 2447 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Serial Killers

...In the last three decades the USA has been troubled by an approaching problem, the serial killer. A serial killer is a person who kills a number of people, usually considered over five, with a cooling off period between each murder, usually one murder at one given time). Two murders at one time occasionally happen and these murders may go on for a period of months or years until the killer is caught. Throughout the last three decades the US serial killer rate has risen 94% and it is estimated that by the next millennium it will claim an average of 11 lives a day. Serial Murder is an epidemic; there are at least 35 serial killers active in the USA today who claim one third of the annual murder rate. The USA has 6% of the world's population yet it has three quarters of all serial killers. Not only are serial killers appearing in more numbers in the US but also all over the world countries are terrorized by serial killers, which are appearing in more numbers year and year after. KILLER TRAIT: A serial killer is a typical white male, 20-30, and most of them are usually in the USA. Their main motives are sex (even though the act of sex may or may not take place), power, manipulation, domination and control. The sex motive is usually rape for an organized killer and sadism for a disorganized killer. They act in a series of 5 or more murders with a cooling off period between each murder. Serial killers can go on for months and years before they are usually caught. The victim is usually...

Words: 4193 - Pages: 17