Premium Essay

Farming It Out

In:

Submitted By abfancy
Words 388
Pages 2
Summary of “Farming it out” by Maria Amuchastegui

Maria Amuchastegui’s article “Farming it out,” explains and argues how Canada, along with the Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program (SAW), allows guest-workers from Mexico to work and receive the benefits Canadian citizens appreciate until health issues arise.
Ms. Amuchastegui reviews the pros and cons for the migrant workers in Canada. Through the Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program (SAW), they are offered job opportunities and some medical benefits that Canadian citizens enjoy; however, they are not treated equally as promised. As Amuchastegui states, “They’re not wanted as citizens by Canada, they’re wanted as labourers”.

By alternating between the narrative incident and general information, Maria Amuchastegui acknowledges the difficulties that can arise with migrant workers who come to Canada through the Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program (SAW). For example, Hermelindo Gutiérrez, a guest-worker from Mexico, is revealed to have kidney failure. Gutiérrez has been working for Pioneer Flower Farms for 7 years and is Henk Sikking Jr.’s right-hand guy. Gutiérrez advises the Mexican consulate of his condition; however, the consulate demands he returns to Mexico. Usually, when a migrant worker becomes ill in Canada, they can legally remain in the country for the duration of their permit. Unfortunately, for Gutiérrez he suffers from a long term illness which would normally send a worker home. Sikking Jr., fights for Gutiérrez to stay and be treated in Canada as he is one of the best workers. “We depend on these guys for our livelihood” he said, while arranging for Gutiérrez to file for refugee status. As he continues to await a court date for his refugee hearing, Gutiérrez was lonely and missing his family. A member of the Ste. Marguerite d’Youville parish anonymously purchased tickets for Gutiérrez’s

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Rhetorical Analysis

...In Blake Hurst’s article, he argues why modern farming methods are more preferable than organic farming methods. In his article he points out the reasons as to why farmers do not benefit from organic farming. He starts by mentioning his frustration towards a airplane passenger who lacks the knowledge of livestock farming. He quotes, “I’m so tired of people who wouldn’t visit a doctor who used a stethoscope instead of an MRI demanding that a farmer like me use 1930s technology to food”. (Hurst 2009) Through this quote Hurst is explaining that if people do not trust a doctor who practices old medical methods then why do they demand farmers to practice old farming methods. He later states, “Farming has always been messy and painful, and bloody...

Words: 950 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Factory Farming

...Benefits of Factory Farming What are the benefits of factory farming? Factory farming or industrial agriculture involves the exploitation of animals so as to ensure profits, particularly in the dairy and meat industries. As such, engaging in this kind of farming not only offers high profits, but it also guarantees more productivity. Cheap food production: Due to the use of technology and “economies of scale,” they produce food at less cost than smaller farms, thus enabling customers to save money on food purchases (1). Efficiency: The ability to efficiently produce and distribute huge quantities of food to feed large cities (1). Employment: Factory farms provide employment to nearby communities (1). Capital: Supporters argue that factory farms do invest in the communities in which they operate (1). In today’s technology factory farming and also applying chemical products, food is produced at lower costs as compared to smaller farms. A cheaper production that benefits the producers and the consumers. Meaning producers will have better profits. Consumers can enjoy on the lower priced products. The capability of providing large amounts of food is vital in huge cities. This high efficiency will benefit the people in those particular cities ensuring they always have food. Stopping food shortages is a major factory farming benefit. The produced food product can be quickly distributed to its consumers, thus supporting better overall health. Employment of factory farming requires lots of...

Words: 345 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Food Inc

...is steadily declining through the practice of "factory farming." Factory farming is performed by the few large companies controlling food processing in America, it is vile and takes away humanity from those who continue to do it. It is the process in which farms "manufacture" food in unhealthy environments rather than safely breed livestock. It negatively affects the welfare of animals and the companies put the value of efficiency and profit before the health and safety of the animals. The repercussions of the choice to make these environments unhealthy by large corporations and keep them that way without trying to fix them further the damage to the treatment of livestock and the nutritional damage to America. It is imperative that America takes a stand as a nation to stop the process of factory farming and its effects, before the corporations go too far to the point where it is unstoppable. Factory farming is an increasing epidemic in the world of farming, we need to stop this before it is no longer preventable. A large portion of the population in America actually have no idea how livestock is taken care of by the corporations that they buy from. They do not know that the animals are so carelessly handled, that the animals are looked at as materials rather than actual living produce. In the documentary "Food, Inc." (2010) the producers of the movie actually get an inside view of the process of factory farming. The scene from Chapter 1: "Fast Food to All Food" shows...

Words: 2294 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Urban Farming in Detroit

...Urban farming in Detroit Turning the Motor City into Farm City Urban farming in Detroit Turning the Motor City into Farm City Subject: Intercultural Communication Studies 2nd Term Date of release: 16.02.2011 Table of Contents 1 2 3 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 3 Characteristics ..................................................................................................................... 4 Urban farming in Detroit .................................................................................................... 5 3.1 3.2 SWOT analysis ............................................................................................................ 5 Urban farming projects in Detroit ............................................................................... 8 4 5 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 11 Bibliography ..................................................................................................................... 12 2 1 Introduction The term urban farming or agriculture recently pops up in the media. It is mainly applied regarding city development in third world countries, but as well it becomes more often a phenomena taking place in cities of industrial countries. After examining the general characteristics of urban farming...

Words: 3660 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Technological Transformations in Farming

...Technological Transformations in Farming Midterm Exam Paper UMUC HIST 125 Technological Transformations in Farming Technological advances and discoveries in the field of agriculture and farming were and continue to be such a vital factor in providing for food and produce for the ever so growing population worldwide. One advertisement in 1921 best sum of the result of progress in farming which claimed “that buying a tractor allows a farmer to keep his son in school, instead of taking him out to help with the farm work” (What is Progress, 1995) In this paper, I will be discussing some very important technological inventions and discoveries that helped to shape the future of farming today. The Neolithic Revolution, also known as the Agriculture Revolution, was a very important period in farming and agriculture because it was the very start of it. It was in this time period that people discovered that when you put seeds into the ground, it produced food. This discovery resulted in Nomads developing permanent settlements. They also learned to domesticate animals for food sources and slash and burn farming, which was the burning of forests in order to use its ashes for fertilizer for their crops during this period. (Global History and AP World Review in 12 Minutes, 2012) Now let’s look at the early civilizations in the Mesopotamia area. People here started settling by the water, after discovering that it was more suitable for farming and trade. They also discovered...

Words: 825 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Fish Farming

...Fish Farming | Benefits and Costs | Hailey Devitt 3/28/2011 | English 160 Module # 4 & 5 Assignment # 5 Formal Report North Island College Section: Distance Submitted To Derek Hanebury March 28, 2011 Submitted by: Ms. H. Devitt Table of contents Executive Summary…………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 1 Introduction & Background……………………………………………………………………………………Page 2 Major Issues…………………………………………………………………………………………………………..Page 2 & 3 Benefits………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 3 & 4 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………………………………Page 4 Works Cited……………………………………………………………………………………………….………….Page 5 Executive Summary Fish farming in Canada has recently taken quite the spotlight, for good or for worse that is the question that needs to be addressed. I feel the negatives greatly outshine the positives at this point in time; the wild salmon stocks are currently in danger and fish farming is taking double the amount of wild salmon to produce half the amount of farmed fish. The fish coming from the farms are dubious to say the least; they produce a chemical, disease ridden product that is not beneficial for consumption. There are many issues around the benefits of the actual fish, and what it might do to the wild if they are interbred and mixed among the wild salmon. However like everything along with the negatives come some benefits of these farms. There is a major industry with fish farming which...

Words: 1609 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ancient Egypt Research Paper

...My topic for the Gateway project is Farming in Ancient Egypt. I have chosen this topic because I was born in Pennsylvania. They farm a lot there so I would like to learn more about farming and the Ancient Egyptians. Also how times have changed in Egypt since the Ancient Times,such as new and necessary methods and different materials used in farming. Last, I would like to learn more about animals and water, how they help with farming. Some needs of Farming in Ancient Egypt are The Nile, Animals,and Tools. The Nile River is the longest river of the world. The Egyptians would have never survived without the Nile River. Each year the Nile would flood and wash out the fields. When flooded water, mud and silt from the river washed up over the river banks creating a fertile growing area (Source Card 14) . During the period of the flood, the Egyptian farmers spent time mending, making tools and looking after the animals. The flooding would make the soil very rich and creamy. Too little flooding with not enough area to be watered would be bad because there would not be enough fertililzed silt. This would mean poor crops even in the areas where plants were not even planted yet. Too much flooding could lead to loss of crops and a bad season for growing crops. The Egyptians called this season “The Gift Of The Nile”, (Note Card 15) . When this season came the Egyptians would work on making more tools....

Words: 651 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Research Paper

...theories as to what caused the Mayan's to fall and disappear however, the theory that seems to have the most support is that the one thing that allowed them to be most successful also doomed them in their final days... farming. The Mayan Civilization grew so rapidly due to their advanced agricultural techniques, their ability to develop and perfect these techniques based on their need to produce more food for their growing needs, however ultimately these farming methods failed them leaving their enormous civilization dependant on food THEY farmed hungry and forced to move on or die out. To start, the Mayan's weren't a very large nation nor did they have very usable land to be able to farm on. They were located in Mesoamerica in the center of many wetlands and hills/mountains, however they did not let these hindrances stop them, instead, they used their unique habitat, and developed new ways of farming that proved to be VERY successful. Archeological discoveries prove so, "Evidence comes in form of vegetation disturbance including; charcoal from burning for forest cleaning and the pollen/phytoliths of domesticated plants in lowlands AND highlands prior to 3,000 B.C." (SOURCE 3) This proves that there is evidence still being discovered today of past farming endeavors of the Mayan's from thousands of years ago. Of all the...

Words: 2537 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Student

...soils in sand in few years. Bio Fertilizer .Com is one organic center with information about natural products and eco friendly energies. Information Center about how to use Solar, Wind , BioDigestors and other sources of cheap energy for houses and business. Bio Pesticides are natural products that helps in the maintenance of gardens and organic food production. Read the Biology of Microorganisms to learn more about the scientific basis. Introducing the basics of the science of Biology of Microorganisms and its applications, as fertilizers or composting for example. Organic Farming State The World of Organic Agriculture: More Than 31 Million Hectares Worldwide The International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM), the Swiss Research Institute of Organic Agriculture (FiBL), and the Foundation Ecology & Farming (SOEL), Germany, presented the latest global data on organic farming at the BioFach fair 2006 in Nuremberg, the world leading fair for organic food. According to the survey, currently more than 31 million hectares of farmland are under organic management worldwide, a gain of around five million hectares in a single year. A major increase of organic land has taken place in China, where nearly three million hectares of pastoral land were recently certified. HUNGER: DO YOU KNOW THE FACTS? It is estimated that one billion people in the world suffer from hunger and...

Words: 7882 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Inca Research Paper

...surplus of materials easier they needed to make a surplus of materials and to do this, they need to farm big areas of land which is why they came up with the concept of terrace farming.. Even though the Incas developed stuff like medical tools, unique pyramid designs, and brain surgery. The concept of terrace farming was the most important. The development of terrace farming by the inca Civilization impacted both the ancient and modern...

Words: 1079 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Sustainability

...Individual Introduction One sustainability issue at a global and local scale is farming, how and why is farming the way it is, can we do anything to change it to make it more organic beneficial and sustainable? When it comes to farming, it is the main use of the agricultural system. The methods of farming are all based on the farming region where its geographically organized by the activities and generations of people that have lived there. (Pacini, 2013) To have a perfect agriculture, it must be sustainable. Everyone in the world could agree to have a sustainable agriculture, but how many of the world population would actually agree to put the effort into it and commit to it. That’s a different story. Sustainability is relation to organic farming, it’s a way of harvesting and using resources that cant run out of or permanently be damaged. The point of organic farming is to not only develop a more valuable and sustainable ecosystem but to also promote a healthy use of resources and maintain a process of organic products. (Rigby, 2013) Current efforts of contributing of sustainable farming is happening in the northwest in the area, the public is trying to go green by eating organic and purchasing locally grown produce. Places such as the Saturday market, where farmer owners come and sell their own grown produce. And even grocery places such as Whole Foods, which sells all organic food and products, has become a trend to the public. The demand...

Words: 270 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Factory Farming

...December 2015 Should Factory Farming Be Acceptable in Our Society? Since the past fifty years, farming operations in the United States have developed from individualized production to mass production, which is known today as factory farming. Factory farming is a method of food and fiber production which exploits animals in a confined environment (Marcus). As the demand for meat continues to increase, the modern agricultural practice of factory farming also continues to increase to meet the food consumption of humans. Factory farms consist of a large number of animals confined in small spaces to minimize operation costs; this mass production has decreased the price of meat as the factories produce an excess amount of meat to satisfy the demand. However, although Americans are fulfilled with the abundant amount of cheap meat, the practice of factory farming causes serious consequences for animals, humans, and the environment. This unhealthy practice has led to problems such as pollution, inhuman animal treatment, and human illness. Therefore, for all these reasons, many people have stated that factory farming is morally and ethically wrong. Since factory farms wield tremendous power in our society, they have become a controversial topic, with many people questioning whether they are detrimental or beneficial to our society. While opponents believe that the costs of factory farming outweigh the benefits, supporters rather believe that factory farming is needed in our current society...

Words: 3860 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Fish Farming

...Fish farming Fish farming or pisciculture is the principal form of aquaculture, while other methods may fall under mariculture. Fish farming involves raising fish commercially in tanks or enclosures, usually for food. A facility that releases juvenile fish into the wild for recreational fishing or to supplement a species' natural numbers is generally referred to as a fish hatchery. Worldwide, the most important fish species used in fish farming are carp, salmon, tilapia and catfish.[1][2] There is an increasing demand for fish and fish protein, which has resulted in widespread overfishing in wild fisheries, China holding 62 percent of the world's fish farming practice.[3] Fish farming offers fish marketers another source. However, farming carnivorous fish, such as salmon, does not always reduce pressure on wild fisheries, since carnivorous farmed fish are usually fed fishmeal and fish oil extracted from wild forage fish. The global returns for fish farming recorded by the FAO in 2008 totalled 33.8 million tonnes worth about $US 60 billion.[4] In 2005, aquaculture represented 40% of the 157.5 million tons of seafood that was produced, meaning that it has become a critical part of our world's food source even though the industry is still technically in its 'infancy' and didn't really become well known until the 1970s. Because of this rise in aquaculture, there has been a rise in the per capita availability of seafood globally within the last few decades.[5] Major categories of...

Words: 4225 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Earthquake In Haiti

...engineers explored the wreckage and decided that they could create a prodigious city with it, and thus, the city of Monwa was born! In the year, 2254 and with a growing population of about 50,000 citizens each year, Monwa was ameliorating every single day. However, as the population grew, problems also began to grow and soon, Haiti was in grave danger. Jobs for farming were almost unbearable, and people were becoming quite miserable. Today, the problem with agriculture is growing like wildfire, never burning out, forever ruining the lives of cities throughout the world, and Haiti is one of the victims. There is less farmable land, more water pollution and scarcity, increased fuel costs, pesticide resistance, and in Haiti, recent hurricanes and earthquakes make our agriculture issues even worse than in other cities....

Words: 973 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Small Scale Approach to Rural Development

...of which is the best approach to rural and agriculture development. It will start by defining key terms; large-scale and small-scale approaches. Thereafter, it will critically examine each of these developmental approaches; and later state which between the two offers the best approach to rural and agriculture development. Later in, a conclusion will be drawn. The focus of this paper will be on Small scale farming as an answer to rural development. Large-scale development approach refers to large scale type of farming as a means to bring about development to rural areas. Large scale farming can therefore be defined as the production of crops and rearing of animals for sale intended for widespread distribution for consumption by others. The main objective of large scale development approach is achieving higher profits, (Sen, 1991). Small-scale development approach refers to the use of Small scale farming as means to bring about development in rural areas. Small scale is closely related to subsistence farming and these terms are often used interchangeably. Small scale farming can be defined as production of crops and livestock on a small piece of land without using advanced and expensive technologies.(ibid). Over the past 200 years, nearly every part of the...

Words: 1758 - Pages: 8