Free Essay

Federal Reserve Criticisms

In:

Submitted By youthfulgarden
Words 1631
Pages 7
A large number of criticisms have been leveled against the United States federal reserve system. Conduct a web search on the criticisms about the system. Do you agree with these views? Why or why not? What changes would you recommend to the system?
Criticisms of the Federal Reserve have existed since its evolution and official inception with democrats wanting the Central Bank to be out of the hands of Wall Street control. Some of the more interesting characters who have criticized aspects of the Federal Reserve are profiled below along with my input.

CHARLES AUGUST LINDBERGH
Lindbergh stated that "The problem of private banks working against the best interests of the citizens: The financial system has been turned over to the Federal Reserve Board. That Board administers the finance system by authority of a purely profiteering group. The system is Private, conducted for the sole purpose of obtaining the greatest possible profits from the use of other people's money." [Lindbergh]. When the President signs this act [Federal Reserve Act of 1913], the invisible government by the money power -- proven to exist by the Monetary Trust Investigation -- will be legalized. The new law will create inflation whenever the trusts want inflation. From now on, depressions will be scientifically created. [Lindbergh2]

I believe Lindbergh, a Democrat, had foresight into the possible dangers that were realized later with the Great Depression. He was justified in his belief that the Federal Reserve could not maintain stability with the financial market.

MILTON FRIEDMAN
The late economist did not support the Federal Reserve system and wanted it abolished. During a 1996 National Public Radio interview, he said "The Federal Reserve definitely caused the Great Depression by contracting the amount of money in circulation by one-third from 1929 to 1933."

Ben Bernanke made a speech in 2002 paying homage to Friedman on his birthday with the following comment "I would like to say to Milton [Friedman] and Anna [J. Schwartz]: Regarding the Great Depression. You're right, we did it. We're very sorry. But thanks to you, we won't do it again."[Bernanke].

Milton Friedman was a brilliant visionary ahead of his time. His theories on keeping the government small and letting the free market flourish and fluctuate won him a Nobel prize in 1976 for his achievements in the fields of consumption analysis, monetary history and theory and for his demonstration of the complexity of stabilization policy. I have to agree with all of his views. The man was absolutely a blessing to the human race for his forward-thinking ideas of how we could all flourish in a free society. If he were alive today, I'd go along with whatever he thought was best.

RON PAUL, U.S. CONGRESSMAN
Ron Paul, Congressman and U.S. Presidential candidate argues that "Abolishing the Federal Reserve will allow Congress to reassert its constitutional authority over monetary policy. The United States Constitution grants to Congress the authority to coin money and regulate the value of the currency. The Constitution does not give Congress the authority to delegate control over monetary policy to a central bank. Furthermore, the Constitution certainly does not empower the federal government to erode the American standard of living via an inflationary monetary policy.

In fact, Congress' constitutional mandate regarding monetary policy should only permit currency backed by stable commodities such as silver and gold to be used as legal tender. Therefore, abolishing the Federal Reserve and returning to a constitutional system will enable America to return to the type of monetary system envisioned by our nation's founders: one where the value of money is consistent because it is tied to a commodity such as gold. Such a monetary system is the basis of a true free-market economy." [Paul].
While what Ron Paul says is true, it has been disregarded by the fact that case law prior to 1913 allowed the federal government to execute its powers and define how money could be made and managed. The case of McCulloch v. Maryland confirms that the federal government can issue notes without interference from individual states [McCulloch] and "the specific case that the government must back paper money with "precious metal" was dismissed as frivolous in Milam v. United States. [Milam]. I believe Congressman Paul's ideas are good about exposing the true nature of the U.S. "welfare/warfare" state and make transparent the amount of money really spend by the federal government on their abundant programs and wars, at the same time I find it hard to believe that his proposal of a new system exists in the complexities that would be required to throw out the old system and replace it at this time.

THE HETERDOX AUSTRIAN SCHOOL AND ALAN GREENSPAN
Ron Paul is a supporter of the Heterdox and has written six books on the subject of this economic philosophy. At the beginning of his career Alan Greenspan, former chairman of the Federal Reserve, was a strong advocate of the Gold Standard as a protector of economic liberty.

"In the absence of the gold standard, there is no way to protect savings from confiscation through inflation. There is no safe store of value. If there were, the government would have to make its holding illegal, as was done in the case of gold. If everyone decided, for example, to convert all his bank deposits to silver or copper or any other good, and thereafter declined to accept checks as payment for goods, bank deposits would lose their purchasing power and government-created bank credit would be worthless as a claim on goods. The financial policy of the welfare state requires that there be no way for the owners of wealth to protect themselves. This is the shabby secret of the welfare statists' tirades against gold. Deficit spending is simply a scheme for the confiscation of wealth. Gold stands in the way of this insidious process. It stands as a protector of property rights. If one grasps this, one has no difficulty in understanding the statists' antagonism toward the gold standard."[Greenspan] According to this theory "interest rates should be naturally low during times of excessive consumer saving and high when high net volumes of consumer credit are extended."[Rothbard]
I like the laissez faire approach the Heterdox School advocates but I believe that deep down their philosophies lack more precise academic precision which may come about in time with more computerized data and proofs to back up their theories to see how they will play out in the long haul.

LOUIS T. McFADDEN, U.S. CONGRESSMAN (ASSASSINATED)
In 1932 Louis T. McFadden gave a speech mentioning his belief that the Fed caused the Great Depression. He was also an anti-Semite and sympathized with Adolf Hitler.[Michael]. "McFadden blamed Jews for president Roosevelt's decision to abandon the gold standard, and claimed that "in the United States today, the Gentiles have the slips of paper while the Jews have the lawful money." [Arad] McFadden was also a supporter of Hitler and the Nazis' anti-Jewish policies before the WW2. "McFadden encouraged Hitler's attempts to destroy the Jewish control of the German economy, media, education, and professions in the early 30's before the start of the WW2."[Michael] When McFadden ran for the presidency in 1936, one of his slogans was “Christianity instead of Judaism.”[Michael]

I believe McFadden was a bit of an extremist and suffered from paranoid delusions. We must take care to analyze the whole person when evaluating their fiscal recommendations to get a sense of whether or not their grip on reality is sound before implementing their recommendations today.

WHAT CHANGES WOULD YOU RECOMMEND TO THE SYSTEM?
I recommend running endless scenarios with computer financial models. I'm sure the Fed's R&D department is already doing this to predict future economic problems but the models are only as good as we program them. Our top economists can suggest possible variables but it's always the items that are not thought of that seem to cause the crashes over time. They are able to incrementally improve the model over time learning from mistakes and adding new factors but what about the factors not yet thought of?

Our society is generally reactive as seen with our recent mortgage crisis debacle. Even if the humans in charge saw problems coming, the financial system is so interconnected, they may not know how to best fix the problem. The complexities of the current system are immense. Any replacement or improvement would have to have less risk than our current system and proving that would be a colossal undertaking.

It is far easier to stand back and criticize the system then to implement a detailed, improved monetary safeguard system with all its complexities.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SOURCES

Lindbergh: http://www.seedoftruth.com/quotes.html

Lindbergh2: http://quotes.liberty-tree.ca/quotes_by/charles+a.+lindbergh,+sr.

Bernanke: FRB Speech, Bernanke—On Milton Friedman's ninetieth birthday—November 8, 2002

Paul: Before the US House of Representatives, February 4, 2009, introducing The Federal Reserve Board Abolition Act, H.R. 833.

McCulloch: Case Brief for McCulloch v. Maryland at Lawnix.com: http://www.lawnix.com/cases/mcculloch-maryland.html

Milam v. United States, 524 F.2d 629 (9th Cir. 1974).

Greenspan, Alan (1966). "Gold and Economic Freedom". The Objectivist. http://www.321gold.com/fed/greenspan/1966.html. Retrieved on 2008-09-20.

Rothbard, Murray (1926-95). "The Mystery of Banking" (PDF). The Ludwig von Mises Institute.

http://mises.org/Books/mysteryofbanking.pdf.

Michael, Robert (2005). A Concise History Of American Antisemitism. Lantham: Rowman & Littlefield. p. 180. ISBN 0742543137.

Arad, Gulie Ne'eman (2000). America, Its Jews, and the Rise of Nazism. Indianapolis: Indiana University Press. p. 174. ISBN 0253338093.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Importance Of The Federal Reserve System

...The Federal Reserve System “I cannot say with what deep emotions of gratitude I feel that I have had a part in completing a work which I believe will be of lasting benefit to the business of the country” (Woodrow Wilson, “statement on signing the Federal Reserve Act” December 23, 1913). The Federal Reserve System is the central banking of the United States. They are the banker for the community and the government. The congress created the Federal Reserve System to provide the nation a more stable, flexible and safer financial system. It has three main roles and those roles have helped the nation avoid another depression. A hundred years before we had the fed, the nation saw forty-four recessions and six depressions. The system isn't perfect and people can argue we can live without it, but the Federal Reserve System is very important to the nation, and without the system the United States would be a wreck....

Words: 991 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Current Economic State Paper

...impact on the economy. There were clues that the economy may have actually slightly contracted instead of expanding. “The United States economy reversed course in the final quarter of 2012 and contracted at a 0.1% rate and was the worst performance since the financial crisis in 2009.” (Mataconis, 2013) . Even with the overall contraction, the economy is not on the brink of a recession or an extended slump. Companies are still spending. The economy we have been living in since 2009 is going to be the new normal. The prime rate is the underlying index for most credit cards, home equity loans and lines of credit, auto loans, and personal loans. The current prime rate is 3.25%, federal discount rate is 0.75%, fed funds rate is 0.25%, and the 11th District cost of funds is 1.071%. Changes made with federal funds rate and the discount rate also dictate changes in the Wall Street Journal prime rate, which is the interest to borrowers. (Bankrate.com, 2013) The current fixed interest rate for credit cards is 13.02% and for variable interest rate for credit cards are at 15.14%. “The unemployment rate falls to 7.8% as the economy creates 114,000 jobs.”...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Current Financial Environment

...The Current Financial Environment FIS/260-Financial Markets & Institutions: You Can Bank On It Michael Ricks When I first took a look at this assignment I thought it would be easier than it this. I looked for days on the internet trying to find banks or depositories with credit cards with variable interest rates. What I found was many banks with many credits all with annual percentage rates (APR). So to keep my insanity I just looked at three commercial banks. I looked at Bank of America, US Bank, and Regions bank. I looked at all their credit cards student, business, rewards, and secured. Bank of America credit cards Apr varied anywhere from 12.99% to 20.99%. Here is how they get people, 0% introductory APR for the first 12 billing cycles only for purchases. When that cycle ends your rate will depend on your creditworthiness. US Bank does similar and their rates are from 11.99% to 23.99%. Regions is in the same neighborhood starting at 13.99%, 16.99%, or 19.99% based on credit, but can quickly climb to 24.99% or even 29.99%. Every bank I researched, including credit unions, all based the rate that you would receive on your creditworthiness when you open your account. After that, your APR will vary with the market based on the Prime Rate as set out in the Variable-Rate information section of your agreement. The current annual percentage rate (APR) for a new car can vary from bank to bank, amount to amount, and year to year. It is not something that is...

Words: 1653 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Aggregate Supply and Demand

...September. Both index increases infer growing confidence and positive expectation in current policy. These data will translate to more spending in the aggregate leading to more employment with the probability of increased productivity to supply the demand for goods and services. Consumer Income The US Department of Commerce Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) reports personal income increased 0.2 percent for the month of September 2014, and disposable income rising 0.1 percent during the same period. Of note, personal expenditures dropped 0.2 percent equaling this increase. Tis effectively negates any positive contribution to aggregate demand, and in fact, has potential to create an over-supply of goods and services. Interest Rates The Federal Reserve reports no significant changes in key interest rates during the past three months. The...

Words: 420 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Fis 260 Week 9 Final Project the Current Financial Environment

...nt-Financial-Environment Final Project: The Current Financial Environment Research and compare the following services provided by three different commercial banks or other depository institutions: the current interest charged on a variable credit card account, the current annual percentage rate for a new car, and the current interest rate on a year fixed mortgage. List the depository institutions and each separate rate. Research and answer the following questions: What is the current prime rate? What is the current federal funds rate? What is the current Fed discount rate? What is the current GDP? Discuss, in a 1,050- to 1,400-word analysis of your findings, the current financial situation, and explain in detail how the federal funds rate and discount rate are related to the prime rate, and how the prime rate in turn is related to the services provided by the banks you researched. Address the following points in particular: a. The date of the last federal funds rate increase or decrease b. The amount of the increase or decrease c. The rational behind the latest increase or decrease d. The effect of the increase or decrease on the overall economy and upon you as an individual. Do not include any specific personal financial data. Cite your sources. Post your analysis to the Assignment section as an attachment. For more Assignments visit:...

Words: 258 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Federal Reserve

...This summary of the most recent report of the Federal Reserve shows steady growth in regards to the strength of the economy, but slightly less aggressive than last year. It is noted that payroll employment has increased by 210,000 on average per month in comparison to 260,000 last year. The unemployment rate dropped by a quarter percent to 5.3 percent in June. It is estimated that labor market resources are not being fully utilized because part time employees looking for full time remains high even though slightly decreasing. Consumer price inflation remains below the FOMC’s goal of 2 percent. The price index of consumer spending increased a quarter percent since last May. This in part is affected by lowered gas prices. Long run inflation estimates have remained stable and real gross domestic product has been little changed since last year in this first quarter. It is expected that inflation will rise to the expected level in the near future. Longer-term interest rates have increased since last year and auto and student loan balances continue to grow higher. This seems similar to the increase in housing loans in the prior decade. Hopefully the amount of default loans will not arise from poor bundling packages. Borrowing by lower rated businesses has increases rapidly as well. It has maintained to implement a low rate for the Federal Funds rate varying from 0-.25 percent. It plans to raise the federal funds rate once employment figures are up to par and the inflation...

Words: 280 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Whether the Interest Rate Pushes Equity Risk Premium Rate Up?

...risk premium can be an individual stock or the overall stock market provides over a risk-free rate. And the size of the premium will be a standard to compensate with a higher premium in the stock market. Thus, a portfolio manager when the equity risk premium increases in the future, the investors will sell out stock market because the stocks are over priced. So the legislators and pension administrators decide how much to set aside to meet future pension obligations, based upon assessments of equity risk premiums. However the history data of ERP (Equity Risk Premium) from Federal Reserve System shows it keeps low and stable state but increases suddenly since 2006. At the same time the Federal Funds Effective Rate goes down and keeps low state. We know that interest rate is a way to control inflation. Inflation is a factor causes too much money chasing too few goods. “Changes in the federal funds rate affect the behavior of consumers and businesses, but the stock market is also affected,” Said by Jim Mueller (2013), PhD Finance in Washington State University. “As the risk-free rate goes up, the total return required for investing in stocks also increases.” In other words, the "risk-free" rate of return goes up, making these investments more desirable. But is the low interest rate push the equity risk premium rate goes up?...

Words: 3534 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Criticisms of Fed Reserve

...A large number of criticisms have been leveled against the United States federal reserve system. Conduct a web search on the criticisms about the system. Do you agree with these views? Why or why not? What changes would you recommend to the system? While conducting a web search on criticisms concerning the federal reserve system, I found that most of the articles and encyclopedias included the same critiques. One criticism is the Fed’s inability to stop inflation, indicating that inflation was going up at a faster rate than wages, thus leaving people with overall lower wages. (“US real wages fall at fastest rate in 14 years” http://www.ft.com/cms/s/f269a8f4-c173-11d9-943f-00000e2511c8.html) Another criticism involves the legality of the federal system. As others have already stated, the constitution granted the Congress the authority to coin money and regulate the value of the currency. It doesn’t, as Congressman Ron Paul states, “give Congress the authority to delegate control over monetary policy to a central bank. Furthermore, the Constitution certainly does not empower the federal government to erode the American standard of living via an inflationary monetary policy.” (“Criticism of the Federal Reserve” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_Federal_Reserve) The Fed also stirs up controversy based on the fact that they are owned, through stock issuance, by private member banks, who most likely would not work in the interest of the people. “Charles...

Words: 678 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Research Paper

...day now), I am at the hotel room writing this.  So here are the facts from the ground: The park is not packed and according to my family the line ups or waiting for any ride or attraction are very small.  In fact two days ago they reported that several rides and/or attractions had no line ups at all.  The hotels are not full. EVERY SINGLE hotel here (that I can see) has vacancy.  Remember, this is on a school holiday! So just like McDonald’s Big Mac is a good inflation indicator (check it online if you are not familiar with it), in my book Disney World is a good proxy (indicator) of the REAL economic health; based on that I am still very cautious about the strength of the US economic recovery and what I am being fed by the Cartel (Federal Reserve), the White House, the various US government agencies and of course the typical US media which is nothing more than the “repeat after me” (reporting what they are being fed, not what they searched and/or investigated)...

Words: 7148 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

Fed Reserve

...the Federal Reserve System is too secretive, too independent, too insensitive to the hopes of small borrowers. A sharecropper's son, he often charges that it is a tool of Wall Street bankers. http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,870767,00.html Banking: Fight over the Federal Reserve Intense criticism among the general public was a major feature of the 2010 midterm elections. Critics reached a wide audience that reacted against the Troubled Asset Relief Program of 2008-9 and the bailout of major banks, insurance and mortgage companies, as well as the industrial companies General Motors and Chrysler. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_Federal_Reserve Criticism of the Federal Reserve The fundamental promise of a central bank like the Federal Reserve is economic stability.  The theory is that manipulating the value of the currency allows financial booms to go higher, and crashes to be more mild.  If growth becomes speculative and unsustainable, the central bank can make the price of money go up and force some deleveraging of risky investments - again, promising to make the crashes more mild. During the Panic of 1907, "Depositors 'run' on the Knickerbocker Bank. J.P. Morgan and James Stillman of First National City Bank (Citibank) act as a "central bank," providing liquidity ... [to stop the bank run] President Theodore Roosevelt provides Morgan with $25 million in government funds ... to control the panic. Morgan, acting as a one-man central bank...

Words: 1003 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Who Is the Federal Reserve Chairman?

...Who Is The Federal Reserve Chairman? Ben S. Bernanke is the chairman for the Federal Reserve. Dr. Bernanke was born in December 1953 in Augusta, Georgia, and grew up in Dillon, South Carolina. His father Philip was a pharmacist that managed a theater part-time and his mother Edna was an elementary schoolteacher. Bernanke has a brother and sister and is the eldest. His younger brother, Seth, is a lawyer in Charlotte, North Carolina, and his younger sister, Sharon, is a longtime administrator at Berklee College of Music in Boston. As a teenager, Bernanke worked construction on a new hospital and waited tables at a restaurant at nearby South of the Border, a roadside attraction in his hometown of Dillon, before leaving for college. Bernanke met his wife Anna, a schoolteacher, on a blind date. She was a student at Wellesley College, and he was in graduate school at MIT. The Bernanke’s have two children. He received a B.A. in economics in 1975 from Harvard University, and a Ph.D. in economics in 1979 from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Bernanke originally took office as Chairman on February 1, 2006, when he also began a 14-year term as a member of the Board. Before his appointment as Chairman, Dr. Bernanke was Chairman of the President's Council of Economic Advisers, from June 2005 to January 2006. By virtue of the chairmanship, he sits on the Financial Stability Oversight Board that oversees the Troubled Asset Relief Program. He also serves as Chairman of the...

Words: 414 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Federal Reserve System

...FEDERAL STATE-FUNDED EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION OF HIGHER PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION FINANCIAL UNIVERSITY UNDER THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION Department of Macroeconomic Research paper “Banking system and its role in national economy of the USA” Prepared by Yusifova Sevindzh Supervisor: Orusova O. V. Department of Macroeconomics Moscow-2014 Contents Introduction 1. Federal Reserve System as the central banking system in the USA 1.1. The essence of Federal Reserve System and its main functions 1.2. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation and Member Banks 1.3. The role of Federal Reserve System in national economy of the USA 1. Special features of the Federal Reserve System 2.1. The implementation of Monetary Policy 2.2. Integration with International Sphere 2.3. Rise and fall in the Fed’s balance sheet Conclusion References Introduction The Federal Reserve is the central bank of the United States. It was created by Congress to provide the nation with a safer, more flexible and more stable monetary and financial system. The Federal Reserve was created on December 23, 1913, with the signing of the Federal Reserve Act by President Woodrow Wilson. Today, the Federal Reserve’s duties fall into four general areas:conducting the...

Words: 5503 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Quantitative Easing

...by introducing money directly into the economy to achieve a desired level of inflation. This is what is referred to as quantitative easing (Rothbard, 1999). The central bank does this by buying financial assets from both banks and the private sector, and thus introducing new money into the economy. This paper investigates the efficacy of quantitative easing and its effects to the economy. Typically, central banks stimulate economies by purchasing government bonds to lower short-term interest (Krugman, 2003). However, when the central bank has lowered interest to the point that it is at zero or close to zero without achieving its goals, then it cannot lower it any further. Quantitative easing has the effect of increasing a bank’s excess reserves and increasing the value of said assets. Stripped to its bare bones, quantitative easing basically derives from the belief among some economists that to improve an economy, it is pivotal to have more money circulating (Rothbard, 1999)....

Words: 2848 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

News

...Global Economy News: U.S. Tells Berlin To Spend More Url:http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702303393804579307722825726640?mod=WSJ_economy_LeftTopHighlights BERLIN—The U.S. Treasury renewed its criticism of the German economy's dependence on exports, just as new data showed that the country's trade surplus swelled in November. Treasury Secretary Jacob Lew, visiting Berlin, urged the German government to do more to boost lackluster domestic demand, which the U.S. and others argue is partly to blame for the anemic economic growth in the euro zone as a whole. Do Tax Cheats Solve the U.K.’s Productivity Puzzle? URL:http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2013/10/22/do-tax-cheats-solve-the-u-k-s-productivity-puzzle/?KEYWORDS=productivity abstract: Economists in Britain have long been scratching their heads over the nation’s troubling “productivity puzzle.” Now Markit, the financial information provider that publishes the purchasing managers’ indexes used to gauge activity in the global economy, has tentatively suggested that former tax cheats might be muddying the waters. Britain has a bigger workforce than it did before it tipped into recession in 2008 yet is producing far fewer goods and services. This mismatch between output and jobs has led to a collapse in productivity, a measure of how effectively an economy uses its resources that’s an important driver of future growth prospects. Bank of Mexico’s Carstens: Inflation to Move Above 4% URL:http://blogs.wsj...

Words: 4940 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Bretton Woods

...What was the Bretton Woods system? Outline its main pillars and discuss to what extent, if any, its architecture led to both post-war stability and prosperity in the developed world throughout capitalism’s ‘golden age’ “50 Years is Enough” In the final months of the Second world war, an architecture of stability for the international economy emerged. The United States and Britain, having already committed to each other with the signing of Mutual Aid Agreement(1941)1, vied to create a multilateral economic system to replace the international gold standard and its structural rigidity. The Bretton Woods agreement of 1944 established a dollar-gold standard of fixed, but adjustable, exchange rates of $US35 an ounce2. Which, according to Milton Friedman, “carried within it the seeds of its own destruction”3. The Institutions of neo-liberal global economic governance4, were formed; International Monetary Fund, & International Bank for Reconstruction and Development. The Twin Pillars of post-war order5, an “economic super-government”6 essentially adopting both; U.S. Inflation rates.7 and US political policies8. There has been no country in history that has emerged from war into such happy economic circumstances as the United States in 19459. General Maximum Price Regulation(1942) was signed after the attack on Pearl Harbour, controlling most prices beneath a price ceiling until '46, and imposing penalties on violations. In addition to a comprehensive ration system. In order to maximise...

Words: 1986 - Pages: 8