Premium Essay

Finding and Evaluating Information

In:

Submitted By tlx223
Words 1028
Pages 5
TCHE2079 – Tertiary Teaching and Learning

This model is from a different subject, but the process of evaluation is the same.

Evaluating a Source
1. Refer to the most important source (book/article/webpage) you used in your Synthesis Essay. Respond to the topics and questions below and evaluate the source. Source: Davies M 2009, „Computer assisted argument mapping: a rationale approach‟, Higher Education, vol. 58, no. 6, pp. 799-820.
Full citation of the source, according to RMIT referencing guide for “Reference Lists”

Topic

Evaluation

Authority (50 words)

 Is that author an expert?  What evidence is there to support this?

Martin Davies is an expert in this field. I Googled his name and found that he has 2 doctorates and is presently a Senior Lecturer in Higher Education in the Teaching and Learning Unit and an Honorary Research Fellow in the Department of Economics at Melbourne University. His page on the Melb. Uni. website lists all his publications (about 70), many of which are concerned with critical thinking in tertiary learning.

Validity & Accuracy (50 words)

 How do you know the information is accurate?  Is it from a valid source, e.g. an educational institution?  Find out if it is peer reviewed or been passed by an editorial panel, eg is it in a refereed journal?

His article includes an appendix in which he has placed all the data from the quantitative study he conducted. Though I can‟t be sure that this data were analysed correctly, I will assume it is accurate. After searching for the journal name, I found out that it‟s considered the leading journal in tertiary teaching and learning. I couldn‟t find out if it is peer reviewed, but I assume that it is, because its webpage lists an editorial panel who—I think—review articles before they‟re published.

Student demonstrates that she researched the author of the

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The in Credible Web

...The “In” Credible Web: Evaluating the Credibility of MedlinePlus Cecelia Chamberlain College of Nursing Course Number: NR 500 September 2012 The “In” Credible Web: Evaluating the Credibility of MedlinePlus Accessing health information via the Web has become the “In” thing. According to a 2010 survey conducted by the Pew Internet & American Life Project, 74% of all U.S. adults are using the Internet, and of those accessing the Web 80% are looking for health information (Fox, 2011). This paper will evaluate the credibility of MedlinePlus at http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/. This website was located using the search engine Google and was chosen for its .gov domain. According to Brenner (2005), Web addresses ending in .gov, .edu or .org offer greater authority and are more reliable sources. MedlinePlus is a health information website produced by the U.S. National Library of Medicine (NLM). This site provides a wide variety of health and wellness topics as well as interactive tools designed to educate, inform, and guide consumers and medical professionals on health related issues (NLM, 2012). The following criteria; authority, information, and objectivity, ease of navigation, and privacy and security policies will be used to evaluate and identify MedlinePlus as a credible health information resource. Furthermore, implications to nursing practice will be discussed. Authority Authority is consistently identified in the literature as being of the upmost importance....

Words: 1152 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Scientific Method and Steps in Scientific Inquiry Paper

...Paper In this paper in will provide details on how scientific methods can be used in the Human services. Explaining the steps of scientific methods, and how it serves as an important key to Human services professionals. Each steps will be included on how they are define and what purpose it serves will scientific methods are applied. Human services professionals use the scientific methods to gain information on the client as well as how to approach the clients issues. Also researching other resources to meet the needs of the client to ensure the client is receiving accurate help. Scientific Method Scientific method is a method that used to research and study that involves investigation and evaluation of present or future problems. Scientific method helps with produce the right answers to questions that cannot be answered with common sense alone. Researchers can use scientific methods to exploit all the facts, evidence, opinions, and records to find the right plan. As a Human service professional using scientific method can help with identifying the solution of the client’s problem and finding a resolution to ensure it will help to rebuild the client’s life. No matter field an individual is in when it concerns Human services, research will always be needed to ensure self-thoughts, bias, and ones on solution is not used. The high level of individuals whom are homeless, abused, jobless, and have health issues will need a full research to assist with sending them in the right direction...

Words: 1047 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Diversity

...Assignment 2.2 While Google is a great search engine, there are many other search engines to consider when trying to locate information on the Internet. Conduct searches for a topic of your choice using the following search engines, and document the similarities and differences in the search results: * Google.com * Clusty.com * Dogpile.com * Rollyo.com After conducting my research over the following search engines I was kind of interested in what some of the sites had to offer on specific subjects but I notice that google kind of gave me a more about the subject that I chose, and even though clusty and dogpile had a few category listed I really feel that google gave more. What do these variances in search results suggest about the information you find? How can you apply that concept as you do Internet research? I feel the variances suggest that the information that is given might have to ensure that you actually break down the topic that you are actually looking for. And try to pinpoint what you really need to find. Visit http://thesearchenginelist.com to learn about specialized search engines and do the following: * List three all-purpose search engines that were not discussed in the textbook. Hotbot, alltheweb, galaxy. * List three blog search engines. Icerocket, sphere, Technorati. * List four job search engines for U.S. positions. Careerbuilder.com, craigslist, CV fox, dice. * List a game search engine. Cheatsearch...

Words: 562 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How to Write a Critical Review

...you are required to: • • • ask questions about the ideas and information presented in the text and; to comment thoughtfully by engaging in a process of evaluating or; making judgements about the validity or relevance of the text to your research or field of study. Part of the process of being critical is to use the information gathered from questioning to understand the topic from different perspectives and in relation to relevant theoretical frameworks in the field. Furthermore, asking the right questions will help you to make links with previous information, develop a position and arguments to support it. What is meant by evaluation? Evaluation is the process that encourages you to show an understanding of the text content by analysing the purpose and the structure of the text, assessing and making judgements about its appropriateness according to various academic criteria. What is meant by analysis? To approach a topic analytically is to examine carefully the content, issues and structure, by separating them into component parts and explaining how they interrelate. The ability to summarise is another skill that is essential to writing a critical review. To summarise means to express the main points of an idea or topic in fewer words and without including examples or details. Criteria For Evaluating Academic Texts Critical evaluation necessitates understanding and analysing the text and then evaluating according to various criteria. The following is a list of criteria...

Words: 655 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Eng 102 Learning Consultant / Tutorialrank.Com

...ENG 102 Assignment: Quoting, Summarizing, and Paraphrasing Sources (UOP) For more course tutorials visit www.tutorialrank.com Assignment: Quoting, Summarizing, and Paraphrasing Sources Resources: Finding, Evaluating, and Utilizing Credible Information; Appropriate Style Guidelines; the Axia College Writing Resources Web Site; Appendix D; and Appendix E Due Date: Day 7 [Individual forum] Review How to Work with Information from Sources at the Axia College Writing Resources Web site at http://www.bedfordstmartins.com/researchroom/sources regarding when and how to quote, summarize, and paraphrase sources. Practice note-taking techniques by quoting a source you plan to use for your research paper, summarizing a second source, and paraphrasing a third source. Follow APA style guidelines at the Center for Writing Excellence to cite your sources: http://www.apollolibrary.com/cwe/pdfs/AXIASampleAPAReferences.pdf Use Appendix E to complete this activity. Answer the following questions: How do you decide what information is noteworthy and what is not? How do you determine whether to quote, paraphrase, or summarize a source? Post Appendix E as an attachment ------------------------------------------------------------ ENG 102 Assignment: Bias, Rhetorical Devices, and Argumentation (UOP) For more course tutorials visit www.tutorialrank.com Assignment: Bias, Rhetorical Devices, and Argumentation Resources: American Rhetoric Web site and Bias, Rhetorical Devices...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

10 Qualitative Principles

...nine states the importance of evaluating the quality of a study. In other words, it is to determine the trustworthiness of the research. Besides the characteristics of reliability, quality is also dependent on whether the research is congruent with other similar studies and if there is an excellence in the conclusion found in the study. Four principal areas were formed in “describing research practice in a multidisciplinary context: credible, contributory, communicable, and conforming” (Martensson, Fors,...

Words: 525 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Appendix a Midterm Exam

...and solicitation. Thomas Hutchison felt that all ties need to be maintained with England to keep the peace between them and their colonies. Therefore weighing out all the pros and cons to increase the trade for the colonies so that it would put them in a better position financially, could have been a strategy they likely used. Basically the pros and cons show the positive and negatives of taxation without representation. This could have likely been determined through solicitation of opinions among the colonists, in which a number of them agreed with the radicals.       2. Explain the importance of building a foundation for critical and creative thinking when evaluating historical events such as the Boston Tea Party. The importance of building a foundation for critical and creative thinking when evaluating historical events is to consider the facts of the things that happened. In other words the things that we know were true. The reason it is important to create a foundation of creative thinking is because along with the facts we should also consider other possibilities and outcomes of what could have happened that we...

Words: 1574 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Decision - Making Case Study Analysis

...d.). These tools consist of six steps that will guide managers and decision makers in constructing well informed decisions. The steps are composed of; framing the question behind the decision, finding sources of information, assessing the accuracy of information, assessing the applicability of the information, assessing the actionability of the information and determining if the information is adequate are used by managers to consider if the decision they are making is well informed (Young, 2002). Framing Questions and Locating Sources By framing the question behind the decision, a manager must first identify what the decision is and then determine what information must be obtained in order to make a well informed decision. To properly make a well informed decision, a manager must frame a question that will properly translate what research must be conducted to begin research. The questions will be used as a foundation to set the interested outcomes, discover the population it will affect, and the settings and time frames in which it will take place. This method allows management to make necessary considerations on how the objective will be met to capitalize on the tasks necessary to complete the desired outcome (Rundall & Martelli, 2007). Finding sources of information is a skill that...

Words: 1138 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Evaluating a Website for Credibility. 2015

...Evaluating a Website for Credibility Chamberlain College of Nursing The era of computer has made education and the quest for knowledge easier and accessible. Health-related information is crucial to the nurse, patients, other allied health personnel and the public. An astute nurse or scholar must evaluate the content of a website for credibility before using the resources following a systematic approach. The criteria to be used when evaluating Web-based sources are, authority, information, objectivity, ease of navigation, privacy and security policies. (CCN, 2015). The criteria will be discussed later. The health-related website I choose to evaluate is the National Institutes of Health website. URL: www.nih.gov The purpose of this website is to support the mission of the NIH, and their mission is to seek fundamental knowledge about the nature and behavior of living systems and the application of that knowledge to enhance health, lengthen life, and reduce illness and disability. (nih.gov) The good thing about NIH website is that it can be located using many search engines like Google, yahoo, msn, AOL, mywebsearch, etc. NIH is a public domain image processing and analysis program for mackintosh. The software is located at http://rsb.info.nih.gov/nih-image/index.html My reasons for the selection of this website are: The NIH is one of the world’s foremost medical researchers and the focal point for medical research in the United States. (nih.gov). It comprises 27 separate...

Words: 1379 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Evaluating a Website for Credibility. 2015

...Evaluating a Website for Credibility Chamberlain College of Nursing The era of computer has made education and the quest for knowledge easier and accessible. Health-related information is crucial to the nurse, patients, other allied health personnel and the public. An astute nurse or scholar must evaluate the content of a website for credibility before using the resources following a systematic approach. The criteria to be used when evaluating Web-based sources are, authority, information, objectivity, ease of navigation, privacy and security policies. (CCN, 2015). The criteria will be discussed later. The health-related website I choose to evaluate is the National Institutes of Health website. URL: www.nih.gov The purpose of this website is to support the mission of the NIH, and their mission is to seek fundamental knowledge about the nature and behavior of living systems and the application of that knowledge to enhance health, lengthen life, and reduce illness and disability. (nih.gov) The good thing about NIH website is that it can be located using many search engines like Google, yahoo, msn, AOL, mywebsearch, etc. NIH is a public domain image processing and analysis program for mackintosh. The software is located at http://rsb.info.nih.gov/nih-image/index.html My reasons for the selection of this website are: The NIH is one of the world’s foremost medical researchers and the focal point for medical research in the United States. (nih.gov). It comprises 27 separate...

Words: 1382 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Terrence

...COMM 150 Introduction to Information Literacy and Research| This course syllabus is a contract between you and Bryant & Stratton College. It represents the minimum expected learning outcomes for this course. Your instructor will also provide a supplemental syllabus describing the approach to the course, instructional methods, tracking calendar, assignments, assessments and grading scheme, plus guidelines for your success. | Semester Credit Hours: 3|Instructional Hours: 4|Term: Fall 2012| Proficiency Available: Yes|Prerequisite(s):None|Co-requisite(s):|Date of Last Revision: 7/2012| COURSE CATALOG DESCRIPTION:Students study the evolution of information and the impact of technology on research, and learn how to access, evaluate, synthesize and communicate research findings. The research process and papers required of each student include inquiry into each student’s chosen career field along with assignments on how changes in technology have impacted the communication process in the career field.| LEARNING OUTCOMESBryant & Stratton College seeks to develop lifelong learning competencies in all students through the development of information literacy skills that assist students to formulate essential questions, research and apply the answers, and communicate the results within the dynamic communities of college, career, and life.Course Outcomes: Upon completion of this course, students will be able to:1. Examine the history of information, and identify the evolution of technology...

Words: 691 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Qualitative Research

...Abstract The various methods by which information about consumers can be obtained are broadly classified into two categories; Qualitative Research and Quantitative Research. The purpose of this paper is to translate my course learning into a reflective question paper on the topic of Qualitative Research. This paper will also seek to describe a research project where qualitative research would be most appropriate, discuss key challenges in collecting and evaluating qualitative data, recommend actions for addressing the challenges identified for each of the three qualitative methodologies, and discuss whether mixing qualitative and quantitative methods would result in better research for your particular learning community. Qualitative Research Qualitative research, also called naturalistic inquiry, developed within the social and human sciences, and refers to theories on interpretation (hermeneutics) and human experience (phenomenology). They include various strategies for systematic collection, organization and interpretation of textual material obtained while talking with people or through observation. The aim of such research is to investigate the meaning of social phenomena as experienced by the people themselves." (Malterud, 2001, p. 398). It is important to understand that qualitative research is not a single type of social inquiry. It surfaces from a number of different research traditions...

Words: 1040 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Communication - Schoolanduniversity.Com

...Evaluating Business Communication BCOM/230 January 30, 2012 Evaluating Business Communication The learning team assignment for the previous week has a formal memo sent to William, the CEO; a regular memo sent to Mark, the sales manager, and Dana, the marketing manager; and an email to the accounting department. These communiqués were to inform the individuals about the accounting team’s findings on JJJ Company’s files. Upon reviewing each communiqué from the previous week’s learning team assignment I have made the following evaluations. Each communication seemed to clearly convey the message of not moving forward with the acquisition of JJJ Company. The risk of acquiring JJJ is too great of a risk to take for Riordan at this time. The memos and email covered the unstable finances of JJJ Company and discussed the possibility of finding other channels to advance the growth Riordan Manufacturing. Other forms of communication may not have been better, but attaching JJJ’s financial reports to the memos may have benefitted the managers. The managers may not understand the financial reports, but the accounting team could have highlighted the information used to determine if JJJ was financially stable or not. Attaching these reports may have allowed for a better understanding of how the accounting team made the decision. The forms of communication were appropriate for the intended audiences and were kept professional. The individuals had all worked together before...

Words: 308 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Wal-Mart Information Technology

...solution (Bateman & Snell , 2011) . Step 2: Generating Alternative Solutions Step two is determining which solution has the best possible outcome. After the problem is identified a resolution to the problem is chosen based on solutions that have already been implemented before (ready made) or solutions that have been customize to fit the particular problem (custom made) Bateman & Snell , 2011. Step 3: Evaluating Alternatives Step three is determining which solution is the best. This is achieved by examining all aspects of the problem (Bateman & Snell, 2011). An essential aspect of evaluating alternatives is to determine what the potential outcomes of each alternative may be which affects which alternative is decided upon. Step 4: Making the Choice Step four is making a choice. The key aspect to remember is that the decision should produce the best possible outcome. Outcomes include having a balance among which goal to meet or achieving the greatest benefit at the lowest possible cost (Bateman & Snell, 2011). Remember, do not spend a large portion of the time evaluating the decision and its solutions than actually making one (Bateman...

Words: 693 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Textbook Evaluation

...Introduction The learners and teachers of English and EFL (English as a Foreign Language) textbooks are three major inter-related elements in the process of present day education. Hutchinson, 1994 cited in (Evaluating an EFL textbook - A new English Course) states that, “The textbook is an almost universal element of ELT teaching”. Therefore, a textbook can be mentioned as a useful instrument which serves as a guide or an instructional manual for studying a particular subject. Against the common belief that students are the key in this direction, many scholars hold the view that textbooks are the heart of education with regard to the fact that both teachers and students are to a large extent dependent on the books (Sarem, S. N., Hamidi, H., Mahmoudie, R., 2013).Therefore, it is clear that a textbook facilitates the teaching and learning process and thus, is helpful both for the teacher and the students. Textbooks are compiled and developed because they are the most convenient means of providing the structure that the teaching-learning system requires. Textbooks are a good solution to overcome the weaknesses in teaching materials. Ansary and Babaii (2002) cited in (An Evaluation of English Language Textbook 'Say it in English' for first year intermediate Grade in South Arabia, 2012) state that, “Although the textbook is not the only tool for the teaching and learning process, it is still of a significant impact for achieving the language learning objectives...

Words: 5865 - Pages: 24