...APPENDIX 1 INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS IN FEDERAL SYSTEMS INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS IN FEDERAL SYSTEMS 1 Introduction 1 2 FEDERAL SYSTEMS 3 3 WHAT ARE INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS? 4 4 AUSTRALIA’S FEDERATION – HOW IS IT OPERATING? 5 5 INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 8 6 INTERNATIONAL FEDERAL SYSTEMS: A BRIEF OVERVIEW 9 7 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 PRINCIPLES OF INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS EFFECTIVENESS TRANSPARENCY ACCOUNTABILITY EFFICIENCY INDEPENDENCE 11 11 33 34 37 40 8 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 INTERGOVERNMENTAL FISCAL ARRANGEMENTS REVENUE RAISING SPENDING FISCAL EQUALISATION MONITORING POLICY 43 43 51 55 56 57 9 CONCLUSION 59 INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS IN FEDERAL SYSTEMS INTRODUCTION 1| INTRODUCTION Australia, like many other systems of government around the world, is a federal system. Federations, while divided into different levels of government inevitably have a degree of interdependency between governments. Inescapably there arises a degree of conflict or ineffective governance. For example, disputes may arise between different governments on the basis of service provision or infrastructure, constitutional jurisdiction, fiscal arrangements (e.g. vertical fiscal imbalance or spending powers) or environmental or social issues. Most federations have developed a system of intergovernmental consultation and ...
Words: 23183 - Pages: 93
...various sectors championing sin tax reform as it sought to retain the multitiered system and increase excise tax collection from tobacco and alcohol products by only P15 billion to P20 billion in the first year of implementation. This is significantly lower than the P31.35 billion that House Bill 5727, already passed on third reading, projects to raise, and an even farther cry from the P60.63-billion goal originally proposed by the Department of Finance. Senator Drilon’s substitute bill features an expected excise tax collection of P40 billion to P45 billion in the first year. Congress will adjourn for the holidays in six weeks, and there will be just three weeks of sessions next year before our legislators switch to campaign mode for the 2013 elections. Moreover, the Senate is also scheduled to begin deliberations on the proposed 2013 General Appropriations Act by next week. Thus, the need for the Senate to act and move the sin tax bill forward gains even greater urgency. Certainly, the passage of the sin tax bill has the full backing of the Aquino administration, which plans to use the revenue from the revised sin tax system to advance the government’s universal health care agenda. The campaign has garnered strong public support as well, particularly from the medical and health community. Last May, the Makati Business Club submitted its position to the House ways and means committee on the pending sin tax bill. In its statement “Tax Reform for a Healthier and Competitive...
Words: 845 - Pages: 4
...Austin Braham The American Association of Retired Persons is a powerful special interest group that protects the interests of retirees across the US by lobbying politicians to pass legislation in the organization’s favor. Inside you will find detailed information outlining AARP’s mission, purpose, and scope. Austin Braham The American Association of Retired Persons is a powerful special interest group that protects the interests of retirees across the US by lobbying politicians to pass legislation in the organization’s favor. Inside you will find detailed information outlining AARP’s mission, purpose, and scope. Politicians are elected in part on the basis of the issues by which they stand, and these issues are either held up or weakened by numerous interest groups that exist today. Interest groups target both major and minor issues, using all of their resources to sponsor or overpower the groups' concern. Interest groups are composed of a limited range of the body of voters who have a great stake in the issues that their group supports. It is made clear and evident which issues their group supports. Resources are used in an attempt to make their interests public policy. Interest groups are persistent; they do not give up until they succeed and they lobby congress, take legal action, and attempt to influence election results in order to benefit their cause. One such political interest group is the AARP (American Association of Retired Persons). Founded in...
Words: 1002 - Pages: 5
...Statement by the International Monetary Fund Delivered by Mohsin S. Khan Director, Middle East and Central Asia Department At the Pakistan Development Forum Islamabad, March 17-19, 2004 I. Introduction 1. The 2004 Pakistan Development Forum (PDF) provides a timely opportunity to discuss Pakistan's recently finalized Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP) "Accelerating Economic Growth and Reducing Poverty: The Road Ahead." Last week the IMF Executive Board endorsed Pakistan's PRSP as a comprehensive and feasible poverty reduction strategy, and a good framework for further reform after the expiration of the Fund program. The Fund staff appreciates this opportunity to comment on Pakistan's economic developments and outlook. 2. The Pakistani economic reform program has been supported by the IMF with a three-year arrangement under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF). This program was approved by the IMF Executive Board in December 2001 and it will be completed in December 2004. Since its approval, seven program reviews have been completed successfully and discussions for the eighth review are scheduled for April. 3. In light of the considerable improvement in economic fundamentals during recent years, the authorities have indicated to us that they will not request a successor arrangement to the current PRGF. This will be a very important milestone for Pakistan following a long history of financial assistancel from the IMF. The authorities should be commended for...
Words: 2145 - Pages: 9
... The Productivity Commission has a very important role in Australia’s economic competitiveness in identifying reform priorities for Australia, and conducting detailed research and making recommendations on potential solutions. The Productivity Commission’s contribution to the understanding of our federal system has been seen in a number of reports it has produced, including the recent compilation of materials from the 2006 Roundtable Proceedings in Canberra entitled Productive Reform in a Federal System. The Productivity Commission’s role in federal–state relations is limited however: + The research priorities are set by the Commonwealth Government (and therefore potentially guided by political interests of the day rather than long-term objectives) and there is limited opportunity for the Productivity Commission to set its own work priorities. + There is no ‘buy-in’ by the state governments (either in terms of the direction of the Productivity Commission’s work agenda, the funding of the Commission or the outcomes). + There is no requirement for the Commonwealth Government to respond to the reports of the Productivity Commission, and therefore less accountability for the findings. Two considerations relating to independence are: 1. nsuring that a research body such as the E Federal Commission is able to consider reform priorities and initiatives that may not be politically palatable as well as propose solutions without influence...
Words: 6813 - Pages: 28
... 24 25 2 Executive Summary The National Board of Revenue (NBR), as the central authority of tax policy and administration in Bangladesh, plays a critical part in the development of the country. During the current fiscal year (FY 2010-11), NBR is expected to collect Taka 75,600 crore, providing much needed support to the government‟s development efforts. In recent years, Bangladesh‟s tax collection has recorded an impressive growth averaging 20% per annum. Despite this good achievement, a lot remains to be done. Bangladesh‟s tax-GDP ratio at 9.3% remains quite low when compared with other similarly placed countries in South Asia. Less than 1% of the population pays income tax and tax evasion is persistent even though a significant amount of tax revenue is given up in the form of tax incentives. Together, curbing tax evasion and dealing with tax incentives could add 5 percentage points to the tax-GDP ratio, potentially adding about 40,000 crore to the revenue collection. Most of NBR‟s processes are manual and there is little in the nature of taxpayer service and taxpayer education. The NBR also faces problems in its functioning due to its current administrative structure. Despite being under the same board, the different wings of the NBR (Income Tax, Value Added Tax (VAT) and Customs) operate almost independently providing little support to each other in combating tax evasion and providing a unified front to taxpayers. Moreover, the NBR faces the problems of acute shortage...
Words: 9249 - Pages: 37
...Healthcare in America B. Powers ENGL103-1204B-01: Composition: Writing and Research Colorado Technical University December 24, 2012 Improving the access and affordability of health insurance coverage for all Americans should be a primary concern for those who help create the laws of the land. At this date, there are roughly 44 million Americans without any type of healthcare coverage. Another 38 million people have inadequate health insurance (PBS, 2012). What this all means is that the people who need it the most are putting off seeing a doctor until last moment and then usually end up visiting an emergency room. If they cannot pay for the visit, the cost of that ER visit falls back on the taxpayers, people who have health insurance coverage, and the Federal Government. The young, under the age of nineteen, are usually covered by Medicaid and the elderly, 65 and up, are usually covered by Medicare. The people lost in the middle are mainly those aged 19-64, who are uninsured and do what they can to keep themselves healthy. When that does not work, the local health departments and emergency rooms are expected to take up the slack. Of those who may have health insurance coverage, that coverage comes through their employer. The people who have insurance through their employer make up about 56% of the population American workers, while about 11% have privately purchased insurance (Jovanovic, et. al., 2003). The people who do not have traditional jobs such as those who work...
Words: 1465 - Pages: 6
...The Fourth Demography Forum 6 and 7 May 2013 (Brussels) Employment, Social Affairs & Inclusion The Fourth Demography Forum Table of Contents Introduction ...................................................................................................... 3 Opportunities for young adults ............................................................................ 4 Improving the work-life balance .......................................................................... 5 Enabling people to be active longer ...................................................................... 6 Successful inclusion of second-generation migrants ............................................... 7 Regions in rapid demographic and economic decline and inequalities within regions ... 8 Investing in Europe's demographic future - how the SIP will support the drive towards extending Europe's demographic dividend ............................................................ 9 Conclusions .....................................................................................................10 May 2013 2 Employment, Social Affairs & Inclusion The Fourth Demography Forum Some 320 participants attended the Forum opened by Commissioner Andor. This report was drafted by the Forum organisers on the basis of the delivered speeches. Any possible errors or omissions are to be imputed to the Forum organisers Introduction In his welcoming speech, Commissioner Andor underlined our duty to...
Words: 3379 - Pages: 14
...Should We Switch to Flat Tax? In general, all over the world more than ninety percent of government’s income comprises taxes collected from the public and corporations. American economy is concerned; it is the largest economy in the world. Government collects taxes directly and indirectly from individuals and corporations. Government is not a business entity but the regulating authority of the country. Therefore, government needs to fulfill needs and wants of people through economic activities, regulating the country towards the economic growth. The government frequently changes the economic policies to run the country in an acceptable level. Therefore, taxes are the main weapon used to control the country. American taxation policy for more than decades is progressive. i.e., those who earn more income should have to pay more taxes. This is the main tax policy has been used in America, but tax rate is increasing at the end. Economists and politicians speak about a new topic i.e., flat tax revolution. What is this new tax? That is according to Sexon, “a tax that charges all income earners the same percentage of their income” (240). However, in practice, this is not a new theory; many countries have already been implementing flat tax as the government tax policy. The flat tax system operates well in many countries. Hong Kong introduced this flat tax system sixty years back and Eastern European countries have been using flat tax since the early nineteen eighties. The ...
Words: 1947 - Pages: 8
...Sarathchandra Should We Switch to Flat Tax? In general, all over the world more than ninety percent of government’s income comprises taxes collected from the public and corporations. American economy is concerned; it is the largest economy in the world. Government collects taxes directly and indirectly from individuals and corporations. Government is not a business entity but the regulating authority of the country. Therefore, government needs to fulfill needs and wants of people through economic activities, regulating the country towards the economic growth. The government frequently changes the economic policies to run the country in an acceptable level. Therefore, taxes are the main weapon used to control the country. American taxation policy for more than decades is progressive. i.e., those who earn more income should have to pay more taxes. This is the main tax policy has been used in America, but tax rate is increasing at the end. Economists and politicians speak about a new topic i.e., flat tax revolution. What is this new tax? That is according to Sexon, “a tax that charges all income earners the same percentage of their income” (240). However, in practice, this is not a new theory; many countries have already been implementing flat tax as the government tax policy. The flat tax system operates well in many countries. Hong Kong introduced this flat tax system sixty years back and Eastern European countries have been using flat tax since the early nineteen eighties. The...
Words: 1958 - Pages: 8
...Bolaji Olawoyin The word count for this essay is 1637 words including references. This figure excludes the cover page The word count for this essay is 1637 words including references. This figure excludes the cover page COMPETITIVENESS BSM018 This essay will discuss competitiveness of countries and account for a competitiveness indicator the United States (US), a member of the Organization of Economic Cooperation Countries (OECD) performs strongly in. It will also look at two competitiveness indicators where US underperforms and suggests ways in which such indicators could be improved. In addition to this, it will consider to what extent international practices match economic theories. First, the term competitiveness, and various methods used to measure it will be discussed. The second section will examine one competitiveness indicator in which the US excels. Two competitiveness indicators in which the US underperforms will be explored in the third section, and in particular, ways in which these indicators could be improved. Finally, the extent to which current practices match theories will be discussed. There is no accepted definition for the term “national competitiveness and it has become a much-debated concept. Clark and Tracey (2004) argued that the definition of competitiveness is one of the many unresolved debates posing significant challenges to contemporary academic inquiry and policy-making in the field of globalization and economic integration. Equally...
Words: 1765 - Pages: 8
...With its near-global membership of 187 countries, the IMF is uniquely placed to help member governments take advantage of the opportunities—and manage the challenges—posed by globalization and economic development more generally. The IMF tracks global economic trends and performance, alerts its member countries when it sees problems on the horizon, provides a forum for policy dialogue, and passes on know-how to governments on how to tackle economic difficulties. The IMF provides policy advice and financing to members in economic difficulties and also works with developing nations to help them achieve macroeconomic stability and reduce poverty. Marked by massive movements of capital and abrupt shifts in comparative advantage, globalization affects countries' policy choices in many areas, including labor, trade, and tax policies. Helping a country benefit from globalization while avoiding potential downsides is an important task for the IMF. The global economic crisis has highlighted just how interconnected countries have become in today’s world economy. Key IMF activities The IMF supports its membership by providing * policy advice to governments and central banks based on analysis of economic trends and cross-country experiences; * research, statistics, forecasts, and analysis based on tracking of global, regional, and individual economies and markets; * loans to help countries overcome economic difficulties; * concessional loans to help fight poverty in developing...
Words: 760 - Pages: 4
...Leadership Challenges and Opportunities Rita Ludeman Grand Canyon University PSC-410 February 23, 2014 Companies today face a number of issues or challenges that can have drastic effects on the company if not handled correctly. Two of the issues are; finding the right staff and keeping up with the changing regulatory environment. According to Conner (2013) one of the biggest challenges faced by organizations today is, “finding the right staff, retaining them, and ensuring they buy into the vision of the organization” (Finding the right staff). The key is to figure out how to deal with individual personalities, what motivates each employee, and develop the management accordingly. The other problem is the changing regulations regarding environment. According to Conner (2013), “the problems to be solved are to understand the meaning of regulation in your industry, its implications for your business, and to develop the skills necessary to deal with it. Two key areas are taxes and health care” (Regulation). The hiring process within an organization is one of the most important tasks to be fulfilled. The difference between good employees and great employees can make a huge difference in the effectiveness of the company. Great employees possess a habit of success and find ways of completing their jobs where good employees see an obstacle as a dead end. Competency is a must for a great employee. They must have knowledge and understanding of the position they are being hired for...
Words: 1018 - Pages: 5
...Caesar by crossing the Rubicon River and taking over Rome in 49BC definitely scared the Senate and the Roman population and he probably seemed as an imminent threat to the state. However, everything changed as he adopted a clementia attitude and faced little to almost no resistance from the Italian communities which made his takeover of Rome and easy mission. Nonetheless, Caesar overtaking of Rome and declaring himself Dictator in Perpetuum by no means followed mois maiorum or roman policies nor his actions were justifiable. However, while in power his reforms seem to be taking into account the Roman people and the future of the empire. In the limited time, he was in charge of Rome, he tried to improve the situation by carrying construction projects, trying to alleviate the debt crisis, implementing a new calendar and helping the poor. His assassination on no account was justifiable, however, this kind of solutions became popular in Rome political life as a consequence of fear and disorder. Additionally, his assassination was probably driven by the Roman dread towards monarchs and past experiences with generals crossing the Rubicon River. By early 48BC Rome faced a huge debt crisis, even though Caesar did not solve the problem “he was responsive and creative enough to...
Words: 881 - Pages: 4
...Tax Havens pull up socks in ‘transparency’ era The great ‘subprime’ crisis has had its share of fallouts over past 24 months; yet there is a silver lining emerging from under the dark clouds which has the world order gearing up for a brand new era of financial discipline and enhanced regulation. Ironically, one of the positives borne out of the recent economic upheaval has been staggering focus on ensuring robust transparency standards in tax matters. Before delving further into how tax transparency and information exchange are critical for sorting financial disorder across economies, let me try and explain the concept of ‘money laundering’ and how the absence of strict standards in tax discipline have abated this menace. This also helps putting in perspective the role that the international tax policy, in tandem with other non-tax measures, plays in combating tax evasion, whether with or without aid of money laundering. What’s the color of money!! Money laundering is loosely used to describe ‘washing’ of unaccounted or illicitly sourced money through a cobweb of complex financial transactions, usually involving more than one jurisdiction. The objective of the process deployed to ‘clean’ the money is to hide either the ownership or the destination of such funds. A typical ‘laundering’ scheme could see three stages: a) Placement stage – at this stage, the objective of stakeholders is to move the illicit funds away from source location; sources of such funds can be...
Words: 1511 - Pages: 7