Premium Essay

Johnny Got His Gun By Dalton Trumbo Analysis

Submitted By
Words 910
Pages 4
With coming of age comes change, treading on its heels. In his novel Johnny Got His Gun, Dalton Trumbo illustrates a young man shouldering the guilt of telling his father that he would prefer to fish with a friend rather than with his father. Although the young man and his father clearly maintain a close relationship, as shown through the author’s continuous use of “they” in the initial paragraph and the son’s struggle with guilt in the last few paragraphs, the son is beginning to move on with his life and thus distance himself from his father, as shown through the limited perspective of the son in the later half of the excerpt and the carefully selected details surrounding the interactions between father and son. With the author’s continuous …show more content…
After the initial “you” to immerse the reader into the scene in line 2 — thus heightening the reader’s empathy for the events later in the passage — Trumbo introduces “him” and “his father” and immediately begins grouping these two people into a single entity of “they”. Rather than differentiating and thus dividing the two, Trumbo simply states that “they” came at this place every summer, and that “they” fished and “they” slept. By constantly referring to the son and the father in a single word, the author implies their close relationship and their tendency to look to each other for company, even before explicitly stating the latter aspect in the next paragraph. Additionally, the son regards his choice to choose another’s company over his father as “a very serious thing”, which sheds more light on how closely he’d been intertwined with his father in the summers they spent together and how new the idea of going fishing with someone else is. In the second half of the …show more content…
Whereas in the beginning the son had always been experiencing activities with his father and knows his father’s preferences for company as well as his own, this transparency between father and son falters during the conversation regarding the son’s decision to fish with someone else. The son evidently hadn’t mentioned the possibility of his friend coming over to his father earlier, as he had to introduce the idea at the beginning of the conversation. With a relationship as close as the one the son and father share, it’s odd that the father would’ve been left out of the loop, particularly as it seems that the friend’s visit must’ve been planned beforehand. This indicates that the son is beginning to form and agree to plans without his father, despite their tradition of spending the summer completely together with no one else. Although the father does give his son permission to fish with his friend and even lends him his closely treasured rod, for a while before then, “his father didn’t say a thing”. The brief silence could indicate many things — possibly feelings of betrayal or shock, in his situation — but the reader doesn’t know for sure, because the reader is limited to the son’s perspective. Despite learning much about the father and

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Johnny Got His Gun Dalton Trumbo Analysis

...The passage from Johnny Got His Gun by Dalton Trumbo shows a complicated but loving relationship between a father and his son. In the passage, the tradition of Joe and his father fishing together is broken. The father, however, reacts calmly. For eight years, they had gone camping together, preferring each other’s company over anyone else’s. And that year, Bill Harper and Joe were going fishing together. This coming of age tale shows a young man separating from his father and becoming independent, and an abandoned father showing acceptance instead of anger. Through syntax, point of view, and selection of detail, and symbolism, Trumbo creates a complicated and vivid relationship between a father and son. The use of diction and syntax in the...

Words: 878 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Johnny Got His Gun By Dalton Trumbo Analysis

...December. In Dalton Trumbo’s novel, Johnny Got His Gun, the author tells a story of a young man and his father’s tradition of going fishing. Through the third person point of view and lack of dialogue, the story shows the detached relationship the father and son have. The third person point of view of the passage interprets the true feelings of the son and the father’s relationship upon the breaking of the tradition. The third person point of view makes it clear to show that the father is actually upset that the son had broken a tradition of nine years, while the son didn’t think twice about it. The passage begins with the mixed feelings of the son. The son sat in front of the fire and looked across at his father and wondered how he was going to tell him that he wanted to fish with Bill Harper this camping trip, rather than going with his father,...

Words: 601 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Johnny Got His Gun By Dalton Trumbo Analysis

...In Dalton Trumbo’s excerpt from his novel Johnny Got His Gun, Trumbo uses the selection of detail, and point of view to characterize the father and son’s relationship. This valued, thoughtful, and strong relationship is developed and revealed gradually throughout the excerpt. Trumbo introduces the backstory of the father-son trip by revealing the tradition of the trip. “They had been coming… was seven,” and “...for the first time in all their trips…” set a precedent of the tradition of the trip, and the quality bonding that occurs during this occasion. Trumbo choosing to include the importance of the father-son bond on the trip, and the quality time that is spent sets the tone that this is a valued relationship, one that while strong, holds...

Words: 545 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mammitas Garden Cove

...sweet heaven waiting for him. How couldn’t it be? After all he was in Canada. He wanted to laugh all of 10 He continued walking along, thoughts drifting back to the far-gone past. Was it that far-gone? He wasn’t sure . . . yet his thoughts kept going back, to the time he was on the island and how he used to dream about 15 being in Canada, of starting an entirely new life. He remembered those dreams clearly now; remembered too thinking of marrying some sweet island-woman with whom he’d share his life, of having children and later buying a house. Maybe someday he’d even own 20 a cottage on the edge of the city. He wasn’t too sure where one built a cottage, but there had to be a cottage. He’d then be in the middle class; life would be different from the hand-to-mouth existence he was used to. 25 His heels pressed into the asphalt, walking on. And slowly he began to sense a revulsion for everything around him. Maybe he was really happy on the island —more than he realised. Once more he thought about a job; if he didn’t find one soon he might starve. But 30 as the reality of this dawned on him he began laughing. No! No one starved in Canada; that only happened in such places as India or Africa. But definitely not Canada! A growling in his...

Words: 37585 - Pages: 151

Premium Essay

Mammitas Garden Cove

...sweet heaven waiting for him. How couldn’t it be? After all he was in Canada. He wanted to laugh all of 10 He continued walking along, thoughts drifting back to the far-gone past. Was it that far-gone? He wasn’t sure . . . yet his thoughts kept going back, to the time he was on the island and how he used to dream about 15 being in Canada, of starting an entirely new life. He remembered those dreams clearly now; remembered too thinking of marrying some sweet island-woman with whom he’d share his life, of having children and later buying a house. Maybe someday he’d even own 20 a cottage on the edge of the city. He wasn’t too sure where one built a cottage, but there had to be a cottage. He’d then be in the middle class; life would be different from the hand-to-mouth existence he was used to. 25 His heels pressed into the asphalt, walking on. And slowly he began to sense a revulsion for everything around him. Maybe he was really happy on the island —more than he realised. Once more he thought about a job; if he didn’t find one soon he might starve. But 30 as the reality of this dawned on him he began laughing. No! No one starved in Canada; that only happened in such places as India or Africa. But definitely not Canada! A growling in his...

Words: 37585 - Pages: 151