Premium Essay

Life Is Beautiful

In:

Submitted By jasminmora012
Words 2096
Pages 9
Mars lopez
Mr. Osman
English 201 71335
November 11, 14

The events of the Holocaust evoke such strong emotions that films portraying the horrors of the time period are considered inappropriate depictions of them. Films such as Schindler’s List and The Pianist take a serious historical approach to the Holocaust, while films like Life is Beautiful take a different approach to it. It is the combination of romance, comedy, and tragedy that triggered many viewers into criticizing Life is beautiful as being oblivious to the Holocaust’s reality, therefore making it inappropriate. However, A filmmaker is not a historian, and is not responsible for Depicting the holocaust as accurate as possible, the film does in fact present the dichotomy of life before and after the holocaust, without leaving out the fact that thousands of people were murdered and battered in the duration of the holocaust. it is the honest presentation of human relations, the main focus between the love of a father and son and the artistic form presented in the film that make the film appropriate. It’s appropriate because filmamkers who portray the holocaust are not obligated to depict the horrors of the events.
Holocaust filmmakers are not necessaraly historians who seek to portray historic events as they actually happen. It IS appropriate because the film presents, the dicotamy of Life before the holocaust and after. It is apporpiate becausebinigni was never oblivious to the holocaust in his film, because there are scenes that actually show the raw heartlessness of the holocaust. “Life is Beautiful” is a movie about the holocaust famous for the perspective the director chose to portray it. The movie isn’t about the brutality and deaths that other films are notorious for displaying, but about the story of a father, who works so hard to keep the truth from his only child. “Life is

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Comparing Genocide In Life Is Beautiful And Hotel Rwanda

...In "Life is Beautiful" and "Hotel Rwanda” they were showing two different genocides. Each film showed the genocide in a different way than the other. "Life is Beautiful” had a hidden theme of genocide and "Hotel Rwanda” showed the genocide in a more dramatic and up front way. In "Life is Beautiful” Guido would hide all of the painfulness and the killing from his son. This represent what Hitler would do to the Germans. Hitler would like to pretend that there was no Holocaust or that what they were doing to them was not bad. Guido in the last scene were he died was not seen shot only the sound effects were shown. This represent how Hitler would hide the true death of the Jewish people and only tell them that they were being taken care of. He...

Words: 374 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

A Story of Love and Courage

...terrible times. In the movie Life is Beautiful, director Roberto Benigni shows the quality of bravery through the experiences of the main characters as they attempt to survive a concentration camp during World War II. When Guido Orefice, an Italian Jew, arrives in Arezzo, he meets Dora, who comes from a wealthy Italian family. Even though she is engaged, she falls in love with Guido, and they marry and have a son, Giosue. At Giosue’s fifth birthday, Guido and Giosue are taken by Nazis to a concentration camp, and Dora insists on voluntarily going with them. At the camp, Guido convinces Giosue that everything is just a game, and he will earn points towards winning a tank. Unfortunately, when Guido goes looking for Dora, he is caught and shot to death by a Nazi soldier, but Giosue and Dora survive. Love is a powerful emotion which leads to acts of bravery, that people perform, even when they are scared. This is shown by Dora’s love for Guido and Giosue, by Guido’s love for Giosue, and by Guido’s love for Dora. Undoubtedly, Dora loves her husband and her son with all her heart; she shows courage when she runs away with Guido, and later again when she volunteers to join Guido and Giosue at the concentration camp. Dora is in a relationship for years with a man she doesn’t love. Then, she meets Guido and she knows at first sight that she wants to be with him. At her engagement party she runs away with him, and follows her heart for the first time in her life. Dora shows that she can...

Words: 1119 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Life Is Beautiful

...The Seven Archetypes of Life is Beautiful 1) The Golden age: - The first half of the movie is a whimsical, romantic, somewhat slapstick comedy set in the years before World War II. Guido Orefice, a young Italian Jew, arrives in Arezzo where he plans to set up a bookstore, taking a job as a waiter at his uncle’s hotel. He works in his uncle restaurant as a waiter. He fall in love with a wealthy girl and after few years they have a baby. There life was going perfect. Then the non-Jewish, Italian family started a war against Jewish community. Almost every Jewish people were captured and sent to the camp where only death, starvation and suffer was present. 2) The flood:- The war had made the life of the jewish people divesting. Many people were dead. Some of them were killed where as many of them died by starvation and disease. However, there were few survivors. Giosue manages to survive and thinks he has won the game when an American tank arrives to liberate the camp. He is reunited with his mother, not knowing that his father has been killed. Years later, he realizes the sacrifice his father made for him, and that it was because of that sacrifice that he is still alive today. 3) The Metamorphosis:- Giosue, son of Guido was living in a dream. Guido convinces Giosue that the camp guards are mean because they want the tank for themselves and that all the other children are hiding in order to win the game. Despite being surrounded by rampant misery, sickness and death...

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Journal Entry

...in Hawaii, the year is 1922. I came to Hawaii because my family enlisted a nakodo’s (go-between) on my behalf in my homeland of Korea, to find me a husband to take care of me. Many Korean men have been leaving our poor area outside of Okinawa to find more lucrative work. There have been quite a few who leave with the intent of working in Hawaii and building a beautiful home and having a family. There were many stories at the time of how well Korean mother's sons were doing in Hawaii, many pictures of homes, properties, beautiful beaches, gardens and animals. Additionally, a monthly check is sent from the sons to support their families back home in Korea. Many hundreds of young men have left Korea to work in the sugar cane fields in Hawaii. Families never know of the hardship their son's suffer, as the son's would never say; it would do no good to have their families worried or afraid for them. So they put on a happy face for all of the pictures, and sent as much money as they can without starving. Mothers of daughters saw these things and wanted their daughters to marry these successful men and live the beautiful life they saw in pictures. So they hired nakodo's to find suitable partners for their daughters, and would send our pictures to Hawaii, and so we were called "picture brides". My nakodo's name was Daka, and he never, ever smiled, even when my baby brother giggled and fell, Daka didn't even look at him. I wondered how such a sour man...

Words: 1283 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Lita E Bella Psychology

...Some people might conclude that the Award Winning film called “La Vita e Bella”, Life Is Beautiful, a film reviewed by Tom Dawson of the British Broadcasting Company doesn’t show the reality of the severeness for the Jews in the concentration camps and many find it offensive. Guido a Jewish and Italian waiter living in Italy moves in with his uncle who owns a restaurant in a fancy Hotel. On his way there he meets a lady named Dora who literally fell into his arms and since that day Guido fell deeply in love with her. Ever since that day Guido tried everything to win the heart of his princess as he called her. Eventually Dora falls for the charms of Guido she fell for that goofy and romantic way of his. Together they raise their son Giosue...

Words: 1412 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Beautiful Life

...Martin Luther born in 1483 in germany was a christian theologian and monk. his contributions to the christian religion were revolutionary and the impacts have shaped doctrines and structures present today in the religion. His interpretation of the bible resulted in controversial insights which challenged roman catholic traditions and the papal power which influenced europe in the middle ages. he initiated the protestant reformation which was hugely significant in the history of christianity. deep study of the scriptures gave way to many revelations for Luther. He believed and preached that salvation and subsequently eternity in heaven could not be simply earned through the doing of good deeds, but can only be received as a free gift of God's grace through faith in Jesus Christ as a redeemer from sin and subsequently eternity in Hell. At the time, the roman catholic church was selling 'indulgences' which were then believed to ensure acceptance to heaven and release from purgatory for those who bought them, regardless of sin, thus allowing people to think they could buy their way into heaven. The money was then used to construct cathedrals and monuments. Luther challenged the church on the corrupt nature of these promises they made to the public and endeavoured to expose the truths of the bible. As many germans were unable to read and understand the bible, they relied heavily on the word of the pope and the church, however Luther preached that ones faith and belief in Jesus...

Words: 975 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Life Is Beautiful By Elie Wiesel

...of those people was Eliezer Wiesel, author of the book Night (2006), and holocaust server. His story is not the only story out there. The move “Life is Beautiful” (2000) follows the story of a young man and his son though the holocaust. In the novel Night and in the movie “Life is Beautiful,” the holocaust is portrayed both similarly and differently through the fathers and the sons, developments of the fathers, and the faith development in the two boys. The most juxtapose aspect of the two stories was the relationship between the fathers and the sons. Both fathers care about their sons, but in Night (2006) they were not close at the beginning. “It’s dangerous to fall asleep in the snow. One falls asleep forever. Come, my son, come… get up” (Wiesel, 2006, p. 88). Eliezer and father grow in their relationship throughout the book, but at this moment shows how close they now are. After running for a long time, they can rest; Eliezer’s father won’t let him. Out of fear of losing his son, and...

Words: 651 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Night And Life Is Beautiful Analysis

...The Holocaust destroyed many lives; children and parents suffered equally. Parents either let their children see the hatred and discrimination or tried to shield them from it. In Life is Beautiful, during the Holocaust, Guido had an occupation of a book store owner who had a wife and little boy. On one day, the Nazi officers took him and his son from his home and put him on a crowded cattle car. His wife, not Jewish, demanded to go on one of the cattle cars. He went to the concentration camps with his wife and son but the Nazis separated Guido and his son from the wife. Guido realized how much discrimination and the magnitude of the hatred and mistreatment at the concentration camps and wanted to shield it from his young son. Guido told his...

Words: 1770 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Roberto Benigni's Life Is Beautiful

...Life is Beautiful is a film that portrays the life of a Jewish-Italian waiter who ends up in a concentration camp with his family, including his son and his wife. The story is considered a comedy-drama and uses comedy to convey its rather harsh story of the Holocaust. Many critics have shot down this movie for not portraying the actual events and the darkness of the Holocaust. Roberto Benigni, who co-wrote the film with Vincenzo Cerami, chose this storytelling tool to help develop a sense of deep underlying dramatic irony. They use the theories of survival that were originally developed by Viktor Frankl. His theory is founded on the belief that human nature is motivated by the search for life. Frankl defined his theory on the thought that humans can develop mental health issues and insanity without a sense of meaning in life. He developed this theory while he was in a concentration camp....

Words: 700 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

"Life Is Beautiful" vs. Maus Ii

...have been many re-tells of Holocaust survivor stories. For example, Maus II and “Life is Beautiful” are two excellent versions of Holocaust victims experiences. In these traumatic scenarios both stories shared a unified message of appreciation and never giving up hope. In “Life is Beautiful” Guido convinces his son Joshua that their time in the Concentration Camp was a game, assuring him they would be reunited with Dora (Joshua’s mother) and return back home, presenting hope. In Maus II Vladek was infected with Typhus and struggled to even stand on his two feet, but Vladek had hope throughout his sickness which eventually led to his freedom from the Concentration Camp and the reunion of him and his wife Anja. Another important unified message demonstrated was appreciation, in “Life is Beautiful” Guido lives every moment with his son as if it is his last, appreciating the time he spends with Joshua. In Maus II after Vladek survives the Holocaust he appreciates every piece of food and money. For instance, Vladek refuses to throw away even a crumb of food and did not allow his son to use his wooden matches in order to save them. There are many messages “Life is beautiful” and Maus II demonstrate but in my opinion I believe appreciating what one has and never giving up hope are the most valuable. The unified messages presented in both “Life is beautiful” and Maus II can be applied to not only my life, but everyones. In todays society most people forget how much food is cherished...

Words: 361 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Truth In Elie Wiesel's Life Is Beautiful

...and sustainable relationship, but to what extent does telling the truth become harmful in a relationship? In the memoir Night written by Elie Wiesel and in the movie Life is Beautiful directed by Roberto Benigni, both father and son Shlomo and Elie, and Guido and Joshua get sent off to a concentration camp due to the heinous matter of discrimination. The father-son relationship in Night differs from the father-son relationship in Life is Beautiful by how each of the fathers deal with the truth which ultimately distinguishes between a healthy...

Words: 1238 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Night In Elie Wiesel's Life Is Beautiful

...“Never shall I forget that night, the first night in camp, that turned my life into one long night seven times sealed.” (34) After reading Elie Wiesel’s account of the Holocaust in his book Night and watching the movie Life is Beautiful, directed by Roberto Benigni, I determined that, the book, Night has the greatest impact on the reader. Based on the mood and tone of the two stories, the amount of details, and the main characters of the stories, I believe that Wiesel’s account of the Holocaust leaves the reader more impacted than Benigni’s story of the same event. In Elie Wiesel’s literary memoir Night, which he wrote in the nineteen-fifties, after his ten years of vowed silence in respect for those who lost their lives in the Holocaust, Wiesel...

Words: 985 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Sarthak-Making My Life Beautiful

...Sarthak- Making My Life Meaningful No doubt, motherhood is altogether a different experience. People have different opinions to cite, writers have different words to explain, moms have different experiences to share… but the entry of the little sapling brings a lot of joy coupled with responsibilities. I felt these emotions when God blessed me with little angel, Sarthak on Jan 28, 2012. It was like a sea change in my body, mind, routine and life. Those initial days were full of irritation. I couldn’t sleep before the baby, couldn’t have meal as infants tend to disturb when moms eat, couldn’t surf net… means I had to keep all things that used to be important for me on the backburner. Now, the whole day was just for Sarthak; feeding him, cleaning his pants and all. I would feel so lazy, tired and depressed. Gradually time passed, my baby was growing and learning new things .My feelings started changing with activities of my little one. Now his smile helps me forget all of my worries. I feel love flowing while feeding him; enjoy moments while playing with him. Just two days back (on 14 june, 2012), my baby has started rolling over. I am having fun seeing him turning. He turns but doesn’t know to come back. So, we need to take care of him all the time. Even while sleeping also, he suddenly turns making us laugh like anything. My sweet baby… I love you a lot. You make my life...

Words: 252 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Gerda Weissmann Klein's All But My Life Is Beautiful

...that still haunts us today. A select few survivors of the Holocaust chose to find amazing ways to cope with the horrors of the Nazis’ concentration camps. Elements of Gerda Weissmann Klein’s All But My Life and Roberto Benigni’s Life is Beautiful explore the importance of finding ways to cope through performance. In All But My Life, Weissmann Klein describes her use of performance to endure the loss of her friends and family in Polish and Czechoslovakian camps. Similarly, Benigni creates the sad yet heartwarming Life is Beautiful, a story weaving together the love and imagination of a father to ensure his son’s survival. Both the novel and the movie prove...

Words: 1280 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Random Life

...Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random. Life is Beautiful. Random Life Life is Random...

Words: 416 - Pages: 2