...Case Study on Negligence - Stella v Christine Stella can take an action of Negligence against Christine for her careless conduct regarding the slippery floor as well as the heating urn and steamer. She will be the plaintiff, and Christine, the defendant. Stella bears the burden of proof that Christine owed her a duty of care, but omitted to perform it, which caused her personal injuries and economic loss. The elements, including duty of care, breach of duty of care, and damage, must be proven on the balance of probabilities. If proven, Stella will probably be able to claim monetary compensation for her medical costs, loss of earnings, and suffering and pain. At the meanwhile, however, Christine can defend herself by alleging Stella’s Contributory Negligence so that the amount of her compensation might be reduced. DUTY OF CARE The law states that the duty of care is established upon the reasonable foreseeability test, which means a defendant will owe a duty of care to a plaintiff where it is reasonably foreseeable that their act or omission of act might harm the plaintiff. Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] created the modern concept of negligence. Since then, the test of 'reasonable foreseeability' has been discussed in many cases. Take Wyong Shire Council v Shirt [1980] as an example, in that case the court held that it was a foreseeable risk that the ambiguity of the deep water sign might induce people to believe that the water was deep and therefore safe for water skiing;...
Words: 2159 - Pages: 9
...patients and their families. In the United States, about half of all deaths happen in a hospice program. When a patient is certified by their primary care physician and a hospice medical physician that they are terminally ill and has six months or less to live, they are then qualified to receive hospice benefits. Hospice care encompasses nursing, home health aide, social worker, and counseling services; most hospice care is provided in the home setting. As part of the health care industry, hospices are also subject to negligence cases. Negligent tort cases can arise when there is an “unintentional failure to live up to accepted standards of behaviors”. The four key elements to any negligence case are duty of care, breach of duty, harm, and causation. A legal study of various hospice negligence cases will be conducted to...
Words: 833 - Pages: 4
...The plaintiff, Logan, is obligated to prove her negligence claim against Defendant Rios with a preponderance of the evidence. As the supplemental commentary notes to the Franklin Supreme Court Approved Jury instructions note, it is necessary that Logan persuade a jury considering the evidence, that her proposition is more probable than not. A jury will evaluate the evidence, including witness testimony, and the weight to be given to it, and make a determination as to whether it is more probable than not that Rios’s negligence, through her employees at the store she owns, Trina’s Toys, was the direct and proximate cause of Logan’s injuries. Further, a jury will have to decide Rios’s affirmative defense of contributory negligence. There...
Words: 1806 - Pages: 8
...practiced and may vary on those involved. This did not stop Erin Brockovich, a former beauty queen from Kansas and not formally educated in the practice of law, from being able to see right from wrong. After reviewing a case for the sale of real-estate that contained medical records, she wondered why the records would ever be present in such a case. This lead to her begin asking more questions. After talking to the residents of Hinckley, researching public county water records, and discovering some of the actions taken by PG&E she and Masry believed they could prove negligence. Negligence can be defined as a breach of legal duty to act carefully, resulting in injury to another or damage to another’s property (Sigismond, 2014, p. 92). The research and testimony of Hinckley residents places PG&E negligent in their use of...
Words: 716 - Pages: 3
...Karen may have an action against ABBBW for her broken arm. The occupier-occupant relationship is an established duty case. The facts also clearly establish breach by stating that ABBBW had ‘carelessly forgotten to put up a sign’. Finally, causation is clear from the statement that Karen tripped ‘due to this instability’. The only issue which must be addressed is whether the legislative presumption of contributory negligence is applicable to Karen. Contributory negligence Section 95(1) of the Civil Law (Wrongs) Act (CLWA) states that contributory negligence will be presumed if the injured person was intoxicated at the time of the accident. It is noted that Karen enters the waterhole after consuming a litre of wine. Although other factors which influence the effects of alcohol are not mentioned, such as Karen’s body mass, the large quantity of wine consumed means that ABBBW would probably not have a problem establishing intoxication. However, Karen could rebut this presumption by referring to s 95(2)(a), which notes that contributory negligence will not be assumed if the plaintiff can prove on the balance of probabilities that his or her intoxication did not contribute to the accident. The facts simply state that Karen lost her balance ‘due to the instability’ of the waterhole and no indication is given that her intoxication made the accident more likely. Without evidence to the contrary, Karen would likely recover in full for her broken arm. Karen v ABBBW (2) ABBBW...
Words: 2901 - Pages: 12
...Introduction: In this essay, the author’s aim is to examine the tort of negligence, the component parts of negligence in more detail, the landmark case law that acted as a catalyst for the change in the standard of care in Ireland. In the 20th century, the remarkable development of the modern tort of negligence originated on the neighbour principle in Donoghue v Stevenson in 1932. Thereby, a number of elements have been recognised in order to provide the tort of negligence. These include the duty of care, the breach of duty, damages and close casual connection between the parties. Eventually the question of whether a duty of care exists in any given relationship is related to the neighbour principle and is a question to be determined by the...
Words: 794 - Pages: 4
...Although this is a legal model used to evaluate hypothetical situations in law cases, it is by no means limited to the study of the law. Useful for case studies presented in varied mediums such as narratives, videos/films, or recordings, the IRAC method may be applied to other activities such as defining a term or demonstrating a concept, principle, relationship, analogy, or contrasting idea. Often the instructional focus is on the end result of case study discussion rather than on how to "walk through" a method or approach to be used by the students in the case analysis (Bittner, M.1990). Issue: A recent court ruling should motivate hospital risk managers to conduct a careful periodic review of their facility's procedures and legal obligations when it comes to treating intoxicated patients. The patient, Kevin Kowalski, later wandered onto a nearby highway and was struck by a car, leaving him paralyzed below the neck. Throughout the case, Mr. Kowalski contended that even though he decided on his own to leave the hospital, the hospital should have prevented him from doing so based on his level of inebriation. Analyze: In order to analyze the specific details of our risk management-drunken patient lawsuit, we need to state the facts. In June 2007, the New York State Court of Appeals dismissed the lawsuit accusing St. Francis medical hospital of Poughkeepsie, of medical malpractice and negligence for preventing an intoxicated patient, Kevin Kowalski, from leaving the hospital...
Words: 484 - Pages: 2
...2014 Assignment 1 – Case Studies Assessment Value: 20% Word Length 1500- 2000 words Date Due: Week 5 Friday by 5pm submitted via Level 6 Question 1. (10marks) Using your knowledge of statutory interpretation consider whether any of the following ‘sells or hires or offers for sale or hire or gives to any other person – any knife which has a blade which opens automatically by hand pressure applied to a button, spring or other device in or attached to the handle of the knife’ and therefore commits an offence under s1(1) of the Restriction of Offensive Weapons Act 1959: (i) Jane, a youth worker, confiscates a flick knife from a member of her youth club and gives it to her supervisor. (ii) Tony, an antique dealer, displays an old military knife with a spring opening device in his shop window with a price ticket attached to it. (iii) Fola buys an unopened box of kitchen utensils from a car boot sale. Without examining the contents closely she donates the box to a charity shop. The box is found to contain a flick knife. Question 2 (10 marks) Critically analyse the following case and say whether or not you think that the plaintiff will succeed under the tort of negligence: John was the batsman in a cricket match. He hit the ball so hard that it went over the brick wall that surrounded the cricket ground over the road outside and hit Mr Smith, who had just opened the front door of his house. Mr Smith sued the cricket club for negligence. Mr Smith had a nasty...
Words: 302 - Pages: 2
...Text: Miller/ Jentz, Business Law Today – The Essentials, softback -9th Ed., West,(2008). Bulletin Description: Introduction to the role of law and administrative agencies in business transactions; case studies in torts, property, contracts, sales, agency, business organizations, and employment law. Prerequisites: BIS 101, Tier I Continuing Admission to Professional Business Studies. . Methodology: Lecture, case study analysis, group in-class Assignments. . Course Objectives: This course is part of the BSBA degree program to provide students abilities to: • Demonstrate cognizant skills through case briefs and essays/reports. • Demonstrate successful, participatory team and peer performance. • Apply sound business processes to solve business problems and incorporate critical thinking skills to a series of integrated projects. • Demonstrate, through role playing and/or cases, ethical problem-solving in course content specific situations. The overall purpose of this course is to provide students with a basic understanding of the areas of law that primarily impact business transactions and organizations. Specifically, the course is designed to enable students to: • Demonstrate an understanding of the operations of the U.S. legal system. • Explain the role of administrative agencies in the regulation of business, e.g. Department of Commerce, Department of Labor, Equal Employment Opportunity...
Words: 1320 - Pages: 6
...*cell phone calls cannot be returned No electronic devices permitted in class Be respectful of others – do not arrive late or leave class early without good cause Text: Miller/ Jentz, Business Law Today – The Essentials, softback -9th Ed., West,(2008). Bulletin Description: Introduction to the role of law and administrative agencies in business transactions; case studies in torts, property, contracts, sales, agency, business organizations, and employment law. Prerequisites: BIS 101, Tier I Continuing Admission to Professional Business Studies. . Methodology: Lecture, case study analysis, group in-class Assignments. . Course Objectives: This course is part of the BSBA degree program to provide students abilities to: • Demonstrate cognizant skills through case briefs and essays/reports. • Demonstrate successful, participatory team and peer performance. • Apply sound business processes to solve business problems and incorporate critical thinking skills to a series of integrated projects. • Demonstrate, through role playing and/or cases, ethical problem-solving in course content specific situations. The overall purpose of this course is...
Words: 1434 - Pages: 6
...level of analysis required may be greater and more reliance on primary sources (e.g. precedent cases and legislation) and secondary sources (textbooks, articles) may be required. But the basic fundamentals are still the same: a well-structured piece of work that leads the reader through a discussion of a particular problem or issue. There should be an introduction, a body and a conclusion. Inevitably, either you will be required to put up arguments for hypothetical parties dealing with a hypothetical business problem or you may be asked for your view about a particular legal issue. It is essential that you base your arguments and views on legal principles and cases and thus reliance on what others have written is necessary. This guide attempts to provide you with some assistance in writing and referencing law academic papers. Some basic resource materials are also noted. [NB: This guide is a starting point only.] There are two types of Law Academic Papers Students who take the Business Law Major will inevitably be expected, at some stage, to answer at least two different styles of legal questions: legal case studies and essays. Legal case studies These are questions based on a set of hypothetical facts. The purpose of legal case study questions is both to engage you in problem solving and to consider the issues relevant to risk management. In particular, case studies test your ability to complete an IRAC analysis of the question. This analysis proceeds as follows: ...
Words: 1487 - Pages: 6
...Spring 2010 School of Engineering Maintenance impact on Production Profitability - A Case Study Växjö, 2010 Thesis no:TEK 028/2010 Obamwonyi Martyn Enofe Gregory Aimienrovbiye Department of Terotechnology (Total Quality Maintenance) Linnaeus University School of Engineering Department of Terotechnology (Total Quality Maintenance) 4SE31E Degree Project Master Thesis Författare/ Authors Obamwonyi Martyn Enofe Gregory Aimienrovbiye Linnaeus University Institutionen / Institution School of Engineering Department of Terotechnology (Systemekonomi) Dokumenttyp/Type of document Examensarbete (Degree Project) Handledare/Tutors Matias Taye Examinator/ Examiner Basim Al-Najjar Title och undertitel/ Title and subtitle Maintenance impact on Production Profitability - A Case Study Sammanfattning/Abstract Maintenance has had a tremendous impact on company’s proficiency to optimize its production system in order to meet its long term objectives. Generally, a production system in which maintenance is not given attention may easily lead to the system producing defective product as a result of machine defect. The purpose of this thesis is to utilized tools and methods to analyze the impact of maintenance implementation in a production system. The analytical Hierarchy process was utilized to filter the defining factors and sub-factors considered to be related to the life length and performance of production equipment in the research which was carried out at SCA...
Words: 17171 - Pages: 69
...ACS Code of Ethics Case Studies & Related Clauses to the Code of Conduct Australian Computer Society July 2012 Title ACS Code of Ethics Case Studies & Related Clauses to the Code of Conduct Authors Committee on Computer Ethics Mike Bowern Version History Date Document Version Revision History (reason for change) Author /Reviser July 2012 2.0 ACS Branding Sarah Li Approvals Date approved Version Approved By Date in force Date of Next Review To be confirmed 17 July 2012 2.0 Ruth Graham 17 July 2012 Custodian title & e-mail address: Responsible Business Group: Distribution: ruth.graham@acs.org.au Professional Standards, Learning & Development General (no restriction on distribution) Content Security: Unclassified Australian Computer Society | ACS Code of Ethics Case Studies & Related Clauses to the Code of Conduct | July 2012 Page 2 ACS CODE OF ETHICS CASE STUDIES & RELATED CLAUSES TO THE CODE OF CONDUCT This document provides a range of case studies with references to relevant clauses of the ACS Code of Ethics. These Codes consists of a series of clauses which gradually expand on aspects of ethical behaviour relevant to professional people in the ICT industry. Clause 2.0 describes the Code of Ethics, summarised as six values: The Primacy of the Public Interest; The Enhancement of the Quality of Life; Honesty; Competence; Professional Development; and Professionalism. Clauses 2.1 through to 2.7 cover the ACS Code...
Words: 13862 - Pages: 56
...SYSTEMS PART TWO: CASE EVIDENCE 3.3 SYSTEM TYPES - CASE STUDY FINDINGS 3.4 SUMMARY 4. ASSESSING HEALTH AND SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM EFFECTIVENESS PART ONE: LITERATURE AND FRAMEWORK FOR ASSESSMENT 4.1 INTRODUCTION 4.2 LITERATURE ON EFFECTIVENESS OF HEALTH AND SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS PART TWO: CASE EVIDENCE 4.3 THE TWENTY CASES: CONTENT AND LEVEL OF DEVELOPMENT OF HEALTH AND SAFETY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS 4.4 THE TWENTY CASES: OUTCOME DATA 4.5 SUMMARY 5. FACTORS SHAPING PERFORMANCE AND THE ROLE OF SYSTEM TYPE 5.1 INTRODUCTION 5.2 BASICS AND EXTRAS 5.3 SYSTEM-RELATED CHARACTERISTICS 5.4 THE ROLES OF THE KEY WORKPLACE PLAYERS 5.5 THE LINKAGES BETWEEN HEALTH AND SAFETY PERFORMANCE AND SYSTEM TYPE 5.6 SUMMARY 6. CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES APPENDIX ONE: CASE STUDY PROTOCOL APPENDIX TWO: ASSESSMENT CRITERIA APPENDIX THREE: CASE SUMMARIES AND SYSTEM TYPES Executive Summary This report examines planned approaches to health and safety management in the workplace. It is the result of a two-year study of enterprise-level health and safety management systems, funded by Worksafe Australia, and conducted from late 1994 to late 1996. The need for research on health and safety management systems arises from the intensive promotion of and apparent increasing interest at enterprise level in health and safety management systems. The need is underlined by limited research on the efficacy of health and safety management systems and alternative systems. In this study, a health and safety...
Words: 97784 - Pages: 392
...contemporary organizational issue you find intriguing. Use one field site or example for the entire paper. Also, be explicit about the level issue. For example, if you are using the concept of personality then it is an individual level issue. A list of concepts and their related levels is provided in a separate document. Focus of paper-related requirements: Outline: Submit a formal outline for your paper, complete with references. The purpose of the outline is to help you organize your content, which also results in increased clarity, improved logic, and better structure of the paper. There may be adjustments from this document to your final paper, but at this stage the paper should not require major revisions. Final Paper: Use a case study format for the structure of your paper. Identify and analyze issues using course concepts, and propose recommendations for the organization you are focusing on. Use of course concepts 1. Use a minimum of 8 concepts for the paper. Include a list of the concepts you used at the beginning of the paper. 2. Briefly define each concept you use within the text (a paragraph or two). 3. For each concept, write a diagnosis at one level (e.g., the person level). For example, you might write “The employee misses work frequently due to stress from conflict with her supervisor.” Note, stress and conflict would require definitions.) 4. For each concept, write a solution or solutions. Identify the level(s) you addressed in Step 2...
Words: 594 - Pages: 3